lomiller
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2007
- Messages
- 13,208
I do not understand why there is all the talk about which markets are located next to which lab.
This is an infection that is largely asymptomatic in lots of people. No matter where it came from, it could have been going through several hosts until the first known symptomatic patient. It seems to me that it the virus could have come from any lab, or place in Wuhan.
Proximity to the lab was one of the main drivers for considering a lab leak in the first place, so the fact that none of the early cases has any connection to the lab or even any connection to someone who has a connection to it is significant.
You expect clusters of infections and increases in excess deaths near the area where the first transmission was occurring. This points to central Wuhan north of the Yangtze River. The wildlife trade is a known vector for introducing viruses in places exactly like that so it's a very good fit with the data.
It is less obvious that it could have been transported from another town, because then it would likely have spread there too.
A rural area may not have enough people concentrated in one place for the virus to spread as quickly. You also need a pretty big case count to find even 1 person who is seriously ill. A dozen workers on a wild animal farm or holding area won't generate enough cases to raise any alarms.
Nonetheless people delivering these animals would have more cause to make regular visits the places the first clusters occurred than would anyone from the lab. Again though, environmental samples from the market suggest infected animals were the early carriers.