Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not understand why there is all the talk about which markets are located next to which lab.

This is an infection that is largely asymptomatic in lots of people. No matter where it came from, it could have been going through several hosts until the first known symptomatic patient. It seems to me that it the virus could have come from any lab, or place in Wuhan.

Proximity to the lab was one of the main drivers for considering a lab leak in the first place, so the fact that none of the early cases has any connection to the lab or even any connection to someone who has a connection to it is significant.

You expect clusters of infections and increases in excess deaths near the area where the first transmission was occurring. This points to central Wuhan north of the Yangtze River. The wildlife trade is a known vector for introducing viruses in places exactly like that so it's a very good fit with the data.

It is less obvious that it could have been transported from another town, because then it would likely have spread there too.

A rural area may not have enough people concentrated in one place for the virus to spread as quickly. You also need a pretty big case count to find even 1 person who is seriously ill. A dozen workers on a wild animal farm or holding area won't generate enough cases to raise any alarms.

Nonetheless people delivering these animals would have more cause to make regular visits the places the first clusters occurred than would anyone from the lab. Again though, environmental samples from the market suggest infected animals were the early carriers.
 
Proximity to the lab was one of the main drivers for considering a lab leak in the first place, so the fact that none of the early cases has any connection to the lab or even any connection to someone who has a connection to it is significant.
This flies against the point that I tried to make: that the proximity to the lab has no bearing whatsoever. The fact that none of the early cases has any connection to the lab or even any connection to someone who has a connection to it does not favour one side over the other. That early lab leak proponents tried to use it as an argument, only shows that their argumentation was faulty because the disease is often asymptomatic; it does not show that the lab leak is wrong.

You expect clusters of infections and increases in excess deaths near the area where the first transmission was occurring. This points to central Wuhan north of the Yangtze River.
It does? I thought that the first clusters and excess deaths were in the city of Wuhan, not in "central Wuhan". In my eyes, this favours the lab leak theory.

The wildlife trade is a known vector for introducing viruses in places exactly like that so it's a very good fit with the data.
True, but the only animals that have been identified as possible vectors after a lot of research are living nowhere near the first clusters of infection.

A rural area may not have enough people concentrated in one place for the virus to spread as quickly. You also need a pretty big case count to find even 1 person who is seriously ill. A dozen workers on a wild animal farm or holding area won't generate enough cases to raise any alarms.
Neither would a number of people who never had symptoms of any kind, like, say, a young lab assistant.

Nonetheless people delivering these animals would have more cause to make regular visits the places the first clusters occurred than would anyone from the lab.
Yes, they would visit as dealer, but a market also has customers. Has it been determined that none of the lab workers or their families or friends ever made a visit to the market?

Again though, environmental samples from the market suggest infected animals were the early carriers.
I thought it had only suggested that the market was a good environment for the spreading of a viral disease - any viral disease. I am sure that if anything actually pointed to spreading of Covid-19, it would have been regarded as quite conclusive.
 
中国科学院武汉病毒研究所

The characters are fortunately quite similar to those of Japanese

My understanding is that Kanji literally means something to the effect of "Chinese writing".

With it's mix of Kanji, Hiragana and now even letters from the English alphabet being mixed together Japanese must be just about the most difficult language in the world to read.
 
It does? I thought that the first clusters and excess deaths were in the city of Wuhan, not in "central Wuhan". In my eyes, this favours the lab leak theory.

Could you explain your reasoning here? Wuhan is the name of the city in Hubei Province.

True, but the only animals that have been identified as possible vectors after a lot of research are living nowhere near the first clusters of infection.

If you mean bats, that is true. But that was also the case with SARS. It was also true with AIDS (cue: Skeptic Ginger yelling at me). In fact, there are many viruses which seem to be reservoirs of disease that end up being quite distantly located from the areas in which they cause illness. As I mentioned before, with asymptomatic spread, people popped up with the virus all over the world without having any obvious connection to China. It doesn't mean it didn't start there.


Neither would a number of people who never had symptoms of any kind, like, say, a young lab assistant.

Why a "young lab assistant"? Seems pretty specific.


Yes, they would visit as dealer, but a market also has customers. Has it been determined that none of the lab workers or their families or friends ever made a visit to the market?

Not sure, but it is said that Huanan Market also found SARS-CoV-2 in the drains perhaps where the animals were kept. So, unless the young lab assistants were not only visiting the market but also taking a dump in the wild animal enclosures it doesn't seem like a useful avenue of exploration.


I thought it had only suggested that the market was a good environment for the spreading of a viral disease - any viral disease. I am sure that if anything actually pointed to spreading of Covid-19, it would have been regarded as quite conclusive.

Sure, that could be true.

However, the main point here is that if it leaked from a lab we have two (or three) scenarios:

1.) It came from a wild virus transported to the lab and then it got out. (for a number of reasons this seems highly unlikely and at least on the most plausible end of the spectrum we are actually almost moving complelely away from lab leak and effectively arguing zoonotic spillover anyway. It makes no sense under these situations to question the type of so-called gain of function research or whatever else...)

2.) A manipulated virus using gain of function research. Now here, we have seen some of the weirdest elaborations, in my view. One of those is that a really, really deadly virus spilled over in the Monjiang Mine (it killed 3 out of six men shovelling bat ****) and was then engineered secretly in the lab by people whose main job was to find evidence of spillover. Why would they do this? Literally no one can make an argument for it that isn't bat **** insane.

3) It was a bioweapon that leaked out. Lab leakers say, "Don't smear us with that crazy theory" but many of them began with that one and have been working their way down the line since. The point seems to be that whatever happened, they just want the lab involved.
 
My understanding is that Kanji literally means something to the effect of "Chinese writing".

Yes, that's right!

With it's mix of Kanji, Hiragana and now even letters from the English alphabet being mixed together Japanese must be just about the most difficult language in the world to read.

Hiragana and Katakana are, I would say, pretty simple, as they are phonetic. In some ways they are very straightforward as they have very few irregular readings. That said, Kanji really takes years of dedicated study. (Apparently pre-romanized Vietnamese is really, really horrible to learn as it is a very idiosyncratic version of Chinese, according to a Vietnamese co-worker of mine).

Learning Japanese has come in useful for being able to read some Chinese, though, and I can often get an understanding of what something is about if not the details, when looking at something in Chinese. This is why I love it when people like Skeptic Ginger question "Do you ever get out of the country?" (she never answered my question about whether she had been to China, and didn't even acknowledge my answer when I told her how I knew the miners had not been treated for their illness for weeks and I pointed out that it was in the very quote she posted to me.)
 
Earlier, I said...

Also, I don't have an issue with Piplani or Bloom. Never said I did. All I am saying is that I don't think their papers prove a lab leak. I am sure if you asked them they would agree with me.

Anyway, now the aforementioned Bloom has a new pre-print out.

It basically says something that undermines much of the lab leak narrative. In fact, the title alone says it all...

ACE2 binding is an ancestral and evolvable trait of sarbecoviruses

In addition, ACE2 binding is highly evolvable: for many sarbecovirus RBDs there are single amino-acid mutations that enable binding to new ACE2 orthologs. However, the effects of individual mutations can differ markedly between viruses, as illustrated by the N501Y mutation which enhances human ACE2 binding affinity within several SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern12 but severely dampens it for SARS-CoV-1. Our results point to the deep ancestral origin and evolutionary plasticity of ACE2 binding, broadening consideration of the range of sarbecoviruses with spillover potential.

I think you can get the full PDF from here. I don't have the competence to understand it at all.

Maybe Capsid might be able to throw some light on what is being argued here...:o
 
This flies against the point that I tried to make: that the proximity to the lab has no bearing whatsoever. The fact that none of the early cases has any connection to the lab or even any connection to someone who has a connection to it does not favour one side over the other.

Not true. Cases are not randomly distributed, even when you have community transmission that makes it impossible to trace every single one. You still expect clusters of cases that can be traced back to a common point of origin. The fact that none of the early clusters point back to the lab strongly suggests the lab played no role in early transmission.


It does? I thought that the first clusters and excess deaths were in the city of Wuhan, not in "central Wuhan". In my eyes, this favours the lab leak theory.

You would not expect early cases to be randomly distributed around Wuhan. Even if you ignore this and just say "they are all in Wuhan" what, other than the lab being in Wuhan, would cause this to favor a lab leak? It seems like you are going from saying the lab location means nothing to the lab location being all important in the course of 2 paragraphs.

As I said above, the distribution of early cases in not random it's concentrated in Central Wuhan North of the Yangtze. Excess deaths are also concentrated in this area which strongly suggests that this is where the pandemic started.

picture.php




True, but the only animals that have been identified as possible vectors after a lot of research are living nowhere near the first clusters of infection.

Wild animals are transported widely in China for sale in places like the Wuhan Fish market. SARS was transported just as far from it's point of origin this way. It's a know vector that has concerned virologists for 2 decades.


Neither would a number of people who never had symptoms of any kind, like, say, a young lab assistant.

In that case you'd expect a cluster of cases with some connection back to the lab assistant. No such cluster occurs and serology on staff at the lab showed no one with SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.

Yes, they would visit as dealer, but a market also has customers. Has it been determined that none of the lab workers or their families or friends ever made a visit to the market?

There is no record of this occurring. It's also a somewhat unlikely that any particular customer would be making frequent visits to a wildlife market. This is really expensive food that would normally be reserved for special occasions.


I thought it had only suggested that the market was a good environment for the spreading of a viral disease - any viral disease. I am sure that if anything actually pointed to spreading of Covid-19, it would have been regarded as quite conclusive.

What makes it a risk is close exposure to wild animals, otherwise it's no more risky than any other type of market. Remember the risk of infection from short transient contact is quite low. An infected worker could spread Covid-19 to customers though shear volume of people they come into contact with but a single customer is relatively unlikely to spread it to a vender. It's much easier for a novel virus to spread out of a market this way than it is for the virus to get into a market this way
 
Maybe Capsid might be able to throw some light on what is being argued here...:o

I interpret that to mean the RBD is prone to mutations which will then have different binding affinities to ACE2 of other animals, meaning that spillover between animals can easily occur and is difficult to predict. It's gain of function in the wild!

Given the decades of evolution from RaTG13 to SARS-COV-2, then there has been plenty of time for the virus to jump between animals. The immediate animal reservoir hasn't been identified, however.
 
I interpret that to mean the RBD is prone to mutations which will then have different binding affinities to ACE2 of other animals, meaning that spillover between animals can easily occur and is difficult to predict. It's gain of function in the wild!

Given the decades of evolution from RaTG13 to SARS-COV-2, then there has been plenty of time for the virus to jump between animals. The immediate animal reservoir hasn't been identified, however.

Thanks for the input.

May I also ask one more thing?

What would you say to Rand Paul if he started talking about gain of function? :D
 
Thanks for the input.

May I also ask one more thing?

What would you say to Rand Paul if he started talking about gain of function? :D

I'd ask him to define gain of function. I think he believes it is simply adding a virus to a cell in vitro.
 
lomiller posted:

............................................

I have been looking to pre-pandemic scientific info sources to try to get to what could be true. There are some things China could not hide though in their rush to contain a dramatic outbreak.
But anyone can go on believing China "data" if they want. The timing looks pretty darn suspicious to me!!!

JAN 19, 2020: BBC - The new Chinese virus which has already spread abroad "is still preventable and controllable", China says.

Its National Health Commission warned, however, that close monitoring was needed given the source, transmission and mutation methods were unknown. Two people are known to have died from the respiratory illness which appeared in Wuhan city in December.



JAN 23, 2020: BEIJING (Reuters) - The Chinese city of Wuhan is rapidly building a new 1,000-bed hospital to treat victims of a new coronavirus, mobilizing machinery to get it ready by early next week, state media said.

The virus has killed 25 people in China and infected more than 800, the government said on Friday.

“The construction of this project is to solve the shortage of existing medical resources,” the report said.

China%20new%20hospital%20m.webp



eta: I dont think I need to mention the other 1500 bed hospital they started the next day, do I?
By this time internal China flights were cancelled. International flights were not.
 
Last edited:
I interpret that to mean the RBD is prone to mutations which will then have different binding affinities to ACE2 of other animals, meaning that spillover between animals can easily occur and is difficult to predict. It's gain of function in the wild!

Given the decades of evolution from RaTG13 to SARS-COV-2, then there has been plenty of time for the virus to jump between animals. The immediate animal reservoir hasn't been identified, however.

But we know this. That the virus could have jumped directly from bats to humans is evidenced both by SARS source research and the infection the miners got in 2012.

The labs (plural) in Wuhan were working with those SARS Co V-like cultures and live bats. In 2012 the virus did not pass easily from person to person. If the researchers were doing GoF research with related viruses, one may not see an obvious genetic marker. This has been posted about upthread though I know between all the links here, some more valid than others, it's hard to remember what has been posted.


steenkh said:
That early lab leak proponents tried to use it as an argument, only shows that their argumentation was faulty because the disease is often asymptomatic; it does not show that the lab leak is wrong.
Just to comment on this though I know you were saying it doesn't rule the lab leak out:

There is evidence the pandemic started in Wuhan that goes beyond where the first cases were detected. Within the WHO report is an extensive analysis on any pneumonia outbreaks elsewhere in China in all of 2019. Nothing was found. If asymptomatic carriers became infected somewhere besides Wuhan you would expect they spread it in other locations they had been.

The genetic trail begins in Wuhan though one of the researchers believed cases of the A variant lineage started elsewhere that the lineage was found. I keep trying to find that paper but without success.
 
Hiragana and Katakana are, I would say, pretty simple, as they are phonetic. In some ways they are very straightforward as they have very few irregular readings. That said, Kanji really takes years of dedicated study.

今ゆっくり漢字を学びています。難しいですよ! 
 
... I have been looking to pre-pandemic scientific info sources to try to get to what could be true. There are some things China could not hide though in their rush to contain a dramatic outbreak.
But anyone can go on believing China "data" if they want. The timing looks pretty darn suspicious to me!!!

JAN 19, 2020: BBC - The new Chinese virus which has already spread abroad "is still preventable and controllable", China says.

Its National Health Commission warned, however, that close monitoring was needed given the source, transmission and mutation methods were unknown. Two people are known to have died from the respiratory illness which appeared in Wuhan city in December.

JAN 23, 2020: BEIJING (Reuters) - The Chinese city of Wuhan is rapidly building a new 1,000-bed hospital to treat victims of a new coronavirus, mobilizing machinery to get it ready by early next week, state media said.

The virus has killed 25 people in China and infected more than 800, the government said on Friday.

“The construction of this project is to solve the shortage of existing medical resources,” the report said. [image snipped]

eta: I dont think I need to mention the other 1500 bed hospital they started the next day, do I?
By this time internal China flights were cancelled. International flights were not.

I was trying to do the math using the link below: where did it take us if one included incubation timing and numbers of people infected, but I needed more information to do it. The article was in an English language Japanese news source from back in Mar 2020 and it made me very curious given the headline said the virus was "throttled".

Now I realize they meant the information was throttled, not the outbreak

In Depth: How early coronavirus signs were spotted and throttled
The new coronavirus that has claimed nearly 3,000 lives and spread to almost 50 countries was sequenced in Chinese labs -- and found to be similar to SARS -- weeks before officials publicly identified it as the cause of a mysterious viral pneumonia cluster in Wuhan, a Caixin investigation has found.

Test results from multiple labs in December suggested there was an outbreak of a new virus. However, the results failed to trigger a response that could have prepared the public, despite being fed into an infectious disease control system that was designed to alert China's top health officials about outbreaks.
It goes on to describe hospitals sending patient specimens to more than one lab at about the same time.
Around that time, local doctors sent at least eight other patient samples from hospitals around Wuhan to multiple Chinese genomics companies, including industry heavyweight BGI, as they worked to determine what was behind a growing number of cases of unexplained respiratory disease. The results all pointed to a dangerous SARS-like virus.

That was days before China notified the World Health Organization on Dec. 31 about the emergence of an unidentified infectious disease, two weeks before it shared the virus' genome sequence with the world, and crucially, more than three weeks before Chinese authorities confirmed publicly that the virus was spreading.
Next it mentions Dr Li and his attempt to send out a warning but was told by the government to stop talking about it. (I found out more about him elsewhere BTW. Turns out he was an eye doctor working in the hospital that had these early cases.)

The government not only told Li to shut up, they also ordered all the labs that had received specimens to destroy them. That could be explained as a coverup or as an infection control measure. But the delay in telling the rest of the world doesn't fit with infection control.

Concerns about the new disease were initially kept within a small group of medical workers, researchers and officials. On Dec. 30, Dr. Li Wenliang was one of several in Wuhan who sounded the first alarms and released initial evidence online. Li, who was punished for the disclosure, would perish from the disease five weeks later, after contracting it from a patient.

On Jan. 1, after several batches of genome sequence results had been returned to hospitals and submitted to health authorities, an employee of one genomics company received a phone call from an official at the Hubei Provincial Health Commission, ordering the company to stop testing samples from Wuhan related and destroy all existing samples. The employee, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said they were told to immediately cease releasing test results and related information, and report any future results to authorities.

Then on Jan. 3, China's National Health Commission, the nation's top health authority, ordered institutions not to publish any information related to the unknown disease, and ordered labs to transfer any samples they had to designated testing institutions, or destroy them. The order, which Caixin has seen, did not specify any testing facilities.

We have mid Dec as the first hospitalized case that sent a specimen for genomic analysis:
The earliest results came from a 65-year-old deliveryman who worked at the Wuhan seafood market. These were returned on Dec. 27 by Vision Medicals, a genomics company based in the Huangpu district of Guangzhou in Guangdong Province.

The patient was admitted to the Central Hospital of Wuhan on Dec. 18 with pneumonia and his condition quickly deteriorated.

If he was admitted on Dec 18th we need to add the incubation period to that. And given the odds this was not the first patient (we have experience from Seattle and just the ratio of critical to mild cases) we need to calculate how many people were infected in Wuhan (a range) and how long before one shows up in the hospital after patient zero (also a range).

Suffice it to say the virus showed up much earlier than Dec, which is how we start with 2 lineages—A & B— in the earliest cases we know about. And we know from the WHO analysis about unexpected pneumonia cases elsewhere in China in 2019 that the virus did jump to people in Wuhan.

One other scenario would be an infected Wuhan lab worker who collected specimens from Yunnan, got infected there and brought the infection back. But for that scenario there would have needed to have been someone from Wuhan collecting specimens at the right time.

Later in the article we get to this:
In the following days, company executives visited Wuhan to discuss their findings with hospital officials and disease control authorities, the article said. "There was an intensive and confidential investigation underway, and officials from the hospital and disease control center had acknowledged many similar patients," it said....

And gathering more information later in the piece we get to this:
While researchers at Vision Medicals considered their findings, the Central Hospital of Wuhan sent swabs from another patient with the mysterious pneumonia to CapitalBio Medlab, a Beijing-based lab, for study.

The sample came from a 41-year-old man who had no history of contact with the seafood market and who was admitted to the hospital on Dec. 27.

Finally:
Also on Jan. 11, the Wuhan Municipal Health Commission resumed updating infection cases caused by the virus after suspending reports for several days. But the government repeated its claim that there had been no medical worker infections and that there was no evidence of human transmission.

Meanwhile, the commission reported that the number of confirmed cases had dropped to 41.


So 41 (admitted to) patients in the hospital or at least sick enough to have had a pneumonia diagnosis with laboratory proven COVID-19 on Jan 11. How many total does that represent in Wuhan and how far back was patient zero?
And yes, if something happened in one of the labs in mid-Sept, it could have triggered the government to take a slew of gene databases and other research off-line.

And if Shi was doing GoF research at the WIV it might have been a reason not to publish much from 2014 to 2017. In 2017 the US restored funding to GoF research. I have to go back and review what she published and look again at the genome data that was left out of the 2017 Nature publication which Shi later added as an addendum to the article after the pandemic was underway.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the input.

May I also ask one more thing?

What would you say to Rand Paul if he started talking about gain of function? :D

I'd ask him to define gain of function. I think he believes it is simply adding a virus to a cell in vitro.

Oooh, I thought you would say, "Senator Paul, you do not know what you are talking about, quite frankly, and I want to say that officially, You. DO. NOT. KNOW. What you are talking about!"
 
But we know this. That the virus could have jumped directly from bats to humans is evidenced both by SARS source research and the infection the miners got in 2012.

Please. You are smuggling very disputed claims iinto the narrative as though they were established fact.

You. DO. NOT. KNOW. They had a SARS virus.

The labs (plural) in Wuhan were working with those SARS Co V-like cultures and live bats. In 2012 the virus did not pass easily from person to person. If the researchers were doing GoF research with related viruses, one may not see an obvious genetic marker. This has been posted about upthread though I know between all the links here, some more valid than others, it's hard to remember what has been posted.

Very big ifs.

Again, this is almost exactly what is being disputed. You have no evidence that they were doing such GoF research on viruses from the Monjiang mine.

You. DO. NOT. KNOW. They were doing GoF research on Monjiang mine viruses.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom