Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
:bigclap:

You finally went back and looked for yourself. :thumbsup:

I didn't finally go back for JFC sakes! I have been telling you that you have got it wrong every time you bring up that interview.

Now try looking for other sources where Daszak was working with GoF research for years and working closely with Shi and the WIV.

Baric was working on GoF in 2014 when the funding was paused. I just posted about that. They finished what they were working on (for almost a year more) then paused the work at UNC.

This is what the US State Dept says about the GoF research done at the WIV:

Huh! That garbage "fact" sheet again put out by Mike Pompeo?

So, basically you have no evidence whatsoever?

And no it wasn't my job to quote Daszak in that interview, it was your job because you are the one making BS claims.

Anyway, now that I have, I expect to hear no more about "That interview".

I actually thought I had heard the last of Pompeo and Quay, but here you are resurrecting the zombie memes.
 
Last edited:
:bigclap:

You finally went back and looked for yourself. :thumbsup:

Now try looking for other sources where Daszak was working with GoF research for years and working closely with Shi and the WIV.

Baric was working on GoF in 2014 when the funding was paused. I just posted about that. They finished what they were working on (for almost a year more) then paused the work at UNC.

This is what the US State Dept says about the GoF research done at the WIV:

Why on earth would the US embassy in Tbilisi be releasing US state departments official information on China?

There is also content in the blurb that we explicitly know is false. No original source for rumors that researchers at the lab were sick has been identified and the claim itself is utterly implausible. To get 3 seriously ill people you'd expect hundreds of cases and that simply didn't happen. This seems more like a mid level staffer who has no direct involvement with anything and watches a little too much Fox News than Official State department information.
 
Why on earth would the US embassy in Tbilisi be releasing US state departments official information on China?

There is also content in the blurb that we explicitly know is false. No original source for rumors that researchers at the lab were sick has been identified and the claim itself is utterly implausible. To get 3 seriously ill people you'd expect hundreds of cases and that simply didn't happen. This seems more like a mid level staffer who has no direct involvement with anything and watches a little too much Fox News than Official State department information.

It was put out by Mike Pompeo.

Just right-wing nuttery.
 
An assertion without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
And yet you assert a natural spillover is the only valid hypothesis.


This leads to what I was thinking about recently. There's a pretty broad consensus among involved scientists that the lab accident hypothesis is valid. Neither hypothesis, be it the lab or a natural spillover event, has been proven. Some scientists have taken sides as to which hypothesis they dismiss and which they think the evidence supports but more than a few think either hypothesis is possible.

But some people in this thread are dismissing the lab accident hypothesis as if the natural spillover has been proven. It hasn't.

I have spent pages discussing the evidence for the lab origin, but I have not spent pages attacking the spillover origin except to say there is no evidence, only speculation that it is more likely.

If we were to compare speculation on either hypothesis one could easily note that the spillover origin is supported by the fact it is common and could have occurred.

But one can just as easily note that the location of the earliest cases being right next to the WIV supports the hypothesis it could have come from the lab.

How does speculation on either of those points alone result in anything other than they are equivalent reasons for each hypothesis? IOW one cannot dismiss either origin which is the position many in the scientific community are currently taking.
 
And yet you assert a natural spillover is the only valid hypothesis.


This leads to what I was thinking about recently. There's a pretty broad consensus among involved scientists that the lab accident hypothesis is valid. Neither hypothesis, be it the lab or a natural spillover event, has been proven. Some scientists have taken sides as to which hypothesis they dismiss and which they think the evidence supports but more than a few think either hypothesis is possible.

But some people in this thread are dismissing the lab accident hypothesis as if the natural spillover has been proven. It hasn't.

I have spent pages discussing the evidence for the lab origin, but I have not spent pages attacking the spillover origin except to say there is no evidence, only speculation that it is more likely.

If we were to compare speculation on either hypothesis one could easily note that the spillover origin is supported by the fact it is common and could have occurred.

But one can just as easily note that the location of the earliest cases being right next to the WIV supports the hypothesis it could have come from the lab.

How does speculation on either of those points alone result in anything other than they are equivalent reasons for each hypothesis? IOW one cannot dismiss either origin which is the position many in the scientific community are currently taking.
I agree, we just don't know either way.
Can I remark on the earliest cases being right next to the WIV. I thought we had established that the BSL-4 lab, the Wuhan National Biosafety Laboratory, was not near the earliest cases at the Huanan seafood market (I couldn't find it listed on google maps) and the WIV itself is 11 miles away on the other side of the Yangtze river.
 
Last edited:
I agree, we just don't know either way.
Can I remark on the earliest cases being right next to the WIV. I thought we had established that the BSL-4 lab, the Wuhan National Biosafety Laboratory, was not near the earliest cases at the Huanan seafood market (I couldn't find it listed on google maps) and the WIV itself is 11 miles away on the other side of the Yangtze river.


You are more or less correct. The lab itself is much farther south, in the suburbs. The Wuhan market is in the central districts North of the Yangtze river. Two other markets are also in the central district south of the Yangtze river. The WiV may also have offices in the central district a little south of the Qiyimen market, but I'm not 100% sure if they are still located there. I seem to recall seeing that they moved into the National BSL-4 lab in early or mid 2019. There are also 2 other markets located in the same block as the Wuhan Fish Market that are also not on the map.

In any case there are no early cases anywhere near the lab itself, and nearly all the earliest cases, including the two earliest know cases, are north of the Yangtze river near the Wuhan fish Market.

picture.php
 
Last edited:
I agree, we just don't know either way.
Can I remark on the earliest cases being right next to the WIV. I thought we had established that the BSL-4 lab, the Wuhan National Biosafety Laboratory, was not near the earliest cases at the Huanan seafood market (I couldn't find it listed on google maps) and the WIV itself is 11 miles away on the other side of the Yangtze river.
Thank you.

I think the thought is moving to include the BSL 2 or 3 labs, and don't forget there is also the Chinese CDC lab in Wuhan.

From Wiki on the Chinese CDC:
The CCDC administers a number of laboratories across China, including the biosafety level 2 facility at the Wuhan Center for Disease Control (sometimes confused with the nearby Wuhan Institute of Virology),[5] which received global media coverage during the COVID-19 pandemic for its research into SARS-like coronaviruses of bat origin.[6][7][8] On January 10, 2020, the CCDC uploaded the genetic sequence of SARS-CoV-2 to GISAID for global dissemination.[9]

The center is 280 yards from the wet-market that was considered a source of the COVID-19 coronavirus.[10]

It published the journal China CDC Weekly.
Note they have not updated the erroneous statement the wet market was the known origin.

Business Insider has a good summary of what is known about the Wuhan CDC lab. The article is neutral as in it presents both origin POVs.


Back to the WIV: yes, 11 miles or whatever across the river and which is not in a residential area as far as I can see. You would not expect to find residences near the WIV which was my point about the latest "I know, I know" revelation.

The paper that this describes is cited somewhere upthread: COVID-19 Origin and Spread Linked to PLA Hospital and Wuhan Metro System Line 2 by Physician-Scientist Dr. Steven Quay. Line #2 connects to the WIV directly.

So there is that.


Of course there is a cluster around the market, it was the site of a known super-spreader event. And, there are residential areas around the market. The fact the CCDC lab is practically next to the wet market means maybe there is missed evidence with everyone looking at the WIV. And China also saw to it data from the CCDC was unavailable as well.
 
Last edited:
Thank you.

I think the thought is moving to include the BSL 2 or 3 labs, and don't forget there is also the Chinese CDC lab in Wuhan.

From Wiki on the Chinese CDC:Note they have not updated the erroneous statement the wet market was the known origin.

Business Insider has a good summary of what is known about the Wuhan CDC lab. The article is neutral as in it presents both origin POVs.


Back to the WIV: yes, 11 miles or whatever across the river and which is not in a residential area as far as I can see. You would not expect to find residences near the WIV which was my point about the latest "I know, I know" revelation.

The paper that this describes is cited somewhere upthread: COVID-19 Origin and Spread Linked to PLA Hospital and Wuhan Metro System Line 2 by Physician-Scientist Dr. Steven Quay. Line #2 connects to the WIV directly.

So there is that.


Of course there is a cluster around the market, it was the site of a known super-spreader event. And, there are residential areas around the market. The fact the CCDC lab is practically next to the wet market means maybe there is missed evidence with everyone looking at the WIV. And China also saw to it data from the CCDC was unavailable as well.


I thought the CCDC was next to the WIV?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You are more or less correct. The lab itself is much farther south, in the suburbs. The Wuhan market is in the central districts North of the Yangtze river. Two other markets are also in the central district south of the Yangtze river. The WiV may also have offices in the central district a little south of the Qiyimen market, but I'm not 100% sure if they are still located there. I seem to recall seeing that they moved into the National BSL-4 lab in early or mid 2019. There are also 2 other markets located in the same block as the Wuhan Fish Market that are also not on the map.

In any case there are no early cases anywhere near the lab itself, and nearly all the earliest cases, including the two earliest know cases, are north of the Yangtze river near the Wuhan fish Market.
I do not understand why there is all the talk about which markets are located next to which lab.

This is an infection that is largely asymptomatic in lots of people. No matter where it came from, it could have been going through several hosts until the first known symptomatic patient. It seems to me that it the virus could have come from any lab, or place in Wuhan. It is less obvious that it could have been transported from another town, because then it would likely have spread there too.
 
I do not understand why there is all the talk about which markets are located next to which lab.

This is an infection that is largely asymptomatic in lots of people. No matter where it came from, it could have been going through several hosts until the first known symptomatic patient. It seems to me that it the virus could have come from any lab, or place in Wuhan. It is less obvious that it could have been transported from another town, because then it would likely have spread there too.

Indeed. This is one of the big problems with tracing where it came from.

This is actually true of many viruses. For example, it took many years for scientists to realize where AIDS came from and how long ago. Where a virus is first found is quite often not its origin.

In my humble opinion, the lab leakers seem to be making location do most of the work, and they are also very happy to rule out the Huanan Market based on the fact that the first known case had no relationship to the market.

However, as you say, this forgets about asymptomatic spread. (Weren't the first cases of Covid 19 in the US and other places often found with no discernable route to China? If so, the absurd reasoning might go, maybe it doesm't come from China!!)

Some evidence exists that Huanan had a particularly high level of concentration of the virus given that it was detectd in the drains there, apparently near where wild life farmed animals were kept.

It could be (and yes, this is speculation), that it came into Wuhan on the wildlife farm route. Certain handlers of the wildlife may have built up immunity to severe forms of the virus as it gradually became adapated to humans through an intermediate host.
 
I do not understand why there is all the talk about which markets are located next to which lab.

This is an infection that is largely asymptomatic in lots of people. No matter where it came from, it could have been going through several hosts until the first known symptomatic patient. It seems to me that it the virus could have come from any lab, or place in Wuhan. It is less obvious that it could have been transported from another town, because then it would likely have spread there too.
There was a new report out by someone who was sure they'd solved the origin question by mapping out where the earliest cases started. I posted on it above.
The logic had several holes in it.


Quay's piece on the proximity to metro line 2 had more validity if someone from the WIV with the infection rode on that subway route.
 
Indeed. This is one of the big problems with tracing where it came from.

This is actually true of many viruses. For example, it took many years for scientists to realize where AIDS came from and how long ago. Where a virus is first found is quite often not its origin.....
This is so not analogous at all. I'm not even sure who you mean was looking at "where it was first found".

There were health care providers hypothesizing a number of things that were non-infectious as the cause. Once the virus was identified, no one was looking for the origin in the US or even Haiti. By that time we knew it originated somewhere in Africa.
 
I agree, we just don't know either way.
Can I remark on the earliest cases being right next to the WIV. I thought we had established that the BSL-4 lab, the Wuhan National Biosafety Laboratory, was not near the earliest cases at the Huanan seafood market (I couldn't find it listed on google maps) and the WIV itself is 11 miles away on the other side of the Yangtze river.

Apparently Google Maps are wildly inaccurate when it comes to places in China.

This apparently is what shows up for the Wuhan Insitute of Virology on Google Maps, but the satellite images don't seem to match photographs of it.

It seems that the WIV refers to a number of different buildings auch as an HQ, for example, and the labs themselves in different areas.

Apparently Baidu Maps might be more accurate, but then you will have to search using Chinese.

中国科学院武汉病毒研究所

The characters are fortunately quite similar to those of Japanese, so I can easily see that it begins with China 中国, Science Insitute/Academy 科学院, apparently this 武汉 is Wuhan (although it is different in Japanese), this is virus 病毒 in Chinese apparently, although to my eye it looks like "sick poison", and then 研究所 is research institute.

If you look it up on Baidu Maps there seem to be a number of locations associated with the Wuhan Institute of Virology, but I haven't found the one that looks most like the pictures we usually see of the WIV yet.
 
What annoys me about some of this is how much blatant quote-mining and editorial top-spin some people like to indulge in when they talk to scientific authorities.

Take this Fox News coverage with a heavily edited interview. It is pretty clear that Francis Collins's words are pretty consistent from what he said before to what he says now.

He says there is no evidence of engineering of the virus and that he believes the virus is natural.

Fox News try to twist his words to saying that he first dismissed a lab leak and is now changing his mind.

So what changed his mind? Dun...dun...dun....

Then they play a clip of him saying he thinks it is natural, and not engineered but it cannot be completely ruled out that someone got infected etc...

Then they say he rules out the wet market. Again, this is NOT exactly what he says, only that there are cases that don't appear to be from the wet market.

What he actually says is pretty much where most scientists and virologists are, that a lab leak cannot be completely ruled out, but there is no evidence of a manipulated or engineered virus being the cause of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Link
 
Is this new?

Anyway, regarding the claims of gain-of-function research at WIV, it looks like Rand Paul was accusing Fauci and the NIH of funding gain-of-function research at the WIV.

This refers to a paper from 2017 (maybe this relates to the same claims that Mike Pompeo and the Trump administration were accusing the WIV of doing GoF that Skeptic Ginger brought up before).

Rand Paul basically accuses Fauci of lying and Fauci himself points out that Rand Paul doesn't know what he is talking about and that if anyone was lying it was Rand Paul.

Hmmmm....who to trust? Well respected scientists like Fauci and other virologists and evolultionary biologists or a sad sack bunch of right-wing climate change deniers, alternative medicine advocates, and libertarians from the GOP?

Here's Rand Paul:

"Dr. Fauci, as you're aware, it is a crime to lie to Congress," Paul said. "On May 11, you stated that the NIH has not ever, and does not now fund gain-of-function research and the Wuhan Institute of Virology. And yet, gain-of-function research was done entirely in the Wuhan Institute ... and was funded by NIH."

Paul cited a research paper published in 2017 that states it was funded by the NIH that discovered new strains of SARS that would provide "new insights into the origin and evolution of SARS-CoV and highlights the necessity of preparedness for future emergence of SARS-like diseases."

After Paul asked Fauci if he wanted to retract his previous statement, Fauci said he had never lied to Congress.

"This paper that you're referring to was judged by qualified staff, up and down the chain as not being gain of function," Fauci said. After Paul interrupted, Fauci continued: "Sen. Paul, you do not know what you are talking about, quite frankly, and I want to say that officially. You do not know what you are talking about."

The two then began to talk over each other, before Paul said that Fauci was "dancing around" the idea the scientists took animal viruses and increased their transmissibility to humans.

"You're trying to obscure responsibility for 4 million people dying around the world from a pandemic," Paul said.

Fauci responded: "You are implying that what we did was responsible for the deaths of individuals. I totally resent that, and If anyone is lying here senator, it is you.”

Link
 
A UK virologist has weighed in on what he saw in the Fauci vs Rand debate.

He thinks that Rand Paul is being deliberately disinformative and thinks that Rand knows full well that he is not as ignorant as he sounds.

Link

Personally, I have no idea what Rand Paul knows and think it is just as likely that as with Donald Trump, he simply doesn't care whether it is true or false. Paul is a Bull **********.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom