Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't recall anything about an x-ray that looked like histo. It also doesn't grow in moist caves. It grows and spreads from chicken droppings. It's a risk for farmers and there was a mini epidemic of it after the Northridge earthquake in California which was hypothesized to be the result of dust being stirred up into the air.

As for the xrays, with histo you either see nothing or you see lesions that look like old tuberculosis scarring. I am pretty sure TB is common in that part of the world.


And as for not of interest: nonsense, it was exactly what Shi et al were looking for. They were looking for the original source for SARS and the risk of another jump to humans.

Sorry, you are wrong. The classic Histoplasmosis outbreak is cavers in a bat infested cave.
Histoplasmosis is an infection caused by breathing in spores of a fungus often found in bird and bat droppings.
first google hit
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/histoplasmosis/symptoms-causes/syc-20373495
Can you give the evidence that Histoplasmosis does not grow in moist caves. Then provide data on the humidity of the cave in question?

I think you are getting confused with cocciomycosis.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9062329/
Should I take seriously the opinion of someone who cannot get their fungal infections correct?
 
By the way, the Snopes article is definitely an interesting read. It breaks down some of the claims that essentially come from Deigin, Baker, Wade and McNeil. Specifically it looks at the claims and relevance of RaTG-13 and the Mojiang mine and a few other points regarding the structure of the virus and how the theories have tried to inflate the significance of these issues.

I think they also reference the Counterpunch article claims and refer to it as “absurdly involved”.

https://www.snopes.com/news/2021/07/16/lab-leak-evidence/
 
I don't recall anything about an x-ray that looked like histo. It also doesn't grow in moist caves. It grows and spreads from chicken droppings. It's a risk for farmers and there was a mini epidemic of it after the Northridge earthquake in California which was hypothesized to be the result of dust being stirred up into the air.

As for the xrays, with histo you either see nothing or you see lesions that look like old tuberculosis scarring. I am pretty sure TB is common in that part of the world.


And as for not of interest: nonsense, it was exactly what Shi et al were looking for. They were looking for the original source for SARS and the risk of another jump to humans.

I am not a radiologist. But I think my opinion is better than anyone else I have seen quoted on the radiology.

You are talking about chronic histoplasmosis that looks like old miliary TB (not classic upper lobe fibrotic TB).

Acute symptomatic histoplasmosis looks like a diffuse atypical pneumonia, there may be a degree of lymphadenopathy, and in severe cases it progresses to an ARDS like picture. Those exposed to high doses as in cavers are more likely to get severe disease than those with a low infective load.

I know this is of very low evidence quality but the imaging is more like Histoplasmosis than Covid-19.
 
There were also similar "lab leak" hypothesis pushed as part of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, the AIDS pandemic in the 1980's the Zika virus epidemic in 2018, and the last Ebola outbreak. There were even "theories" back in 1918 that the flu pandemic was a wartime plot. In fact such theories pop up in essentially every pandemic or epidemic so why are some people trying to lower the bar on evidence this time around? Surely if "we need total transparency" is an argument this time it should have applied every time.
I thought the difference this time is the virus emerged ready to ravage the world efficiently.
 
People here in modern hospitals consult with specialists outside of the area if they are dealing with patients in critical condition and an unknown pneumonia. Add to that the fact SARS had been identified as coming from horseshoe bats in the area the miners were working and people were on the lookout for SARS making another jump into the population.

Your comparison fails. Sorry.


No we don't. Most pneumonias have no identifiable organism. We really don't phone a friend about every pneumonia with no identifiable cause.

Admittedly this was unusual as an 'outbreak'. But what was interesting is that they discussed with pulmonologists not infectious disease specialists.
 
Nice little bit of cherry picking there.

Legionaire's might have been on the differential, but again, the risk there comes from hot water.

We don't know anything about the ventilation system in the mine / cave. Also you heat water (> 40C) to prevent Legionella growth. Legionella does not grow in hot water. If you do not know what you are talking about do not post.

All I mean is that the clinical review was poor, the investigation was poor, the tests done were not thorough. Legionella was possible but not tested for. Histoplasmosis was likely but not tested for. To conclude that it was due to a novel corona virus in the absence of isolating a virus (or EM ing a virus), and failing to exclude more likely explanations is nonsense.

ETA Both Legionella and histoplasmosis cause point source outbreaks of severe pneumonia with no person to person transmission.

ETA 2 Both have evidence that severity of exposure is related to severity of disease.
 
Last edited:
What was the hospital in which these miners were treated? Bear in mind I am not asking for the university hospital where this masters was being done?

Do we actually know whether we are talking about six miners admitted to the same hospital at the same time? Do we know what role the writer of the masters was in during this time? I presume they were a student. Does this mean they had a relatively junior role?
Oh good grief! Are we sure they weren't infected as an alien experiment? :rolleyes:

Do you ever get out of the country? Every country doesn't look like what you'd see in a Nat Geo expedition. China is a modern country. Yes they have a large area that is rural. But there are several large cities in Yunnan including the city the miners were treated in.

I thought it best if I got more details myself on the hospital the miners died in. They actually do lung transplants at the main hospital in Kunming, Yunnan Province. The miners were treated in a large teaching hospital.

The workers, ages 30 to 63, were scrubbing a copper seam clean of bat faeces in April 2012. Weeks later, they were admitted to a hospital in the provincial capital of Kunming with persistent coughs, fevers, head and chest pains and breathing difficulties. Three eventually died.

I believe this is the hospital:
It conducted the first allogenic lung transplant in the province in 2005 and won a provincial science and technology progress award.

They've also done kidney transplants since 1983 (same source).

BTW, I'm pretty sure they know what histoplasmosis looks like. I think in one of the two theses it noted the miners may have gotten nosocomial aspergillosis AFTER THEY WERE ADMITTED.
 
Last edited:
I thought the difference this time is the virus emerged ready to ravage the world efficiently.

Any novel virus is "ready to ravage the world efficiently" because it's entering an environment where it doesn't need to contend with immunity.

SARS-CoV-2 itself is a generalist virus capable on infecting many different species. It binds to human ACE2 very efficiently, but this doesn't necessarily mean anything, it binds even better to mink ACE2 and no one has suggested the virus was "engineered to infect mink". Conversely there are also Pangolin viruses related to SARS-CoV-2 that bind more readily to human ACE2 than they do to the ACE2 of their natural host species.

There are quite a few animals that have ACE2 somewhat similar to humans and Covid can spread to most of them relatively easily.
 
I have asked you several times to pull up an actual quote but you won’t because Daszak says that the particular research you mentioned was in Ralph Baric’s lab in North Carolina. In America.

This is not surprising to anyone as it was published in papers that say exactly this.

Now there is also other work that was done in the WIV and this is also described in papers taking place in BSL-2 conditions. It was not, as far as I understand, GoF.

However, you and others keep insisting that Daszak has “admitted” to doing GoF in Wuhan and then you put it together to say it was also at BSL-2. This is you cobbling together various different claims and assertions.

Then when it is pointed out that this is not true you then jump to your next claim that maybe it was being done secretly

Then you go back to making the claim again that it was well known and admitted. This is utterly dishonest.
Dishonest? :id:

It's in the youtube video linked in this thread and the time it is discussed is noted.

I don't feel like looking for something that is in this thread that you, for whatever reason, have forgotten We discussed it at the time and YOU WERE IN THE DISCUSSION! I will not be goaded into finding it for you.
 
Last edited:
Do you ever get out of the country? Every country doesn't look like what you'd see in a Nat Geo expedition. China is a modern country. Yes they have a large area that is rural. But there are several large cities in Yunnan including the city the miners were treated in.

Do I get out of which country?

Japan, where I live? Or the UK, where I am from?

Oh no, you meant America, right? Because you are from America, so you think everyone you talk to is from America. So your attempt at looking urbane and cosmopolitan only makes you look the opposite.

Actually, I have been to China a few times. I have been to Guangdong, Beijiing and Dandong (the latter after returning from North Korea by train) as well as Shenzhen and Hong Kong. Of course, I am aware that much of China, particularly the big cities has modern infrastructure, but I also know that much of the countryside is not at the same level.



By the way, have you been to China?
 
Dishonest? :id:

It's in the youtube video linked in this thread and the time it is discussed is noted.
I don't feel like looking for something that is in this thread that you, for whatever reason, have forgotten We discussed it at the time and YOU WERE IN THE DISCUSSION! I will not be goaded into finding it for you.

For goodness sake! We've all seen the damn video!

My point is that you misquote it.

Look, let me help you:

Daszak says: "You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily...spike protein drives a lot of what happens with coronavirus zoonotic risk. So you can get the sequence you can build the protein and we work with Ralph Baric at UNC to do that, insert it into the backbone of another virus, and do some work in the lab, and you can get more predictive when you find a sequence..."

Notice, as I have been repeating endlessly to you whenever you wave your hand vaguely in the direction of this interview, that he is explicitly talking about Ralph Baric's lab.
 
The workers, ages 30 to 63, were scrubbing a copper seam clean of bat faeces in April 2012. Weeks later, they were admitted to a hospital in the provincial capital of Kunming with persistent coughs, fevers, head and chest pains and breathing difficulties. Three eventually died.

I thought it best if I got more details myself on the hospital the miners died in. They actually do lung transplants at the main hospital in Kunming, Yunnan Province. The miners were treated in a large teaching hospital.



I believe this is the hospital:

They've also done kidney transplants since 1983 (same source).

BTW, I'm pretty sure they know what histoplasmosis looks like. I think in one of the two theses it noted the miners may have gotten nosocomial aspergillosis AFTER THEY WERE ADMITTED.

Anyway, thank you for the quote.

Okay, so they went to Kunming which is indeed a modern city.

Aside from the Master's thesis, would there not also be hospital records? Wouldn't these be able to state what the doctors there thought the miners had?

For the record, histoplasmosis symptoms:

Symptoms of histoplasmosis include: 1

FeverCoughFatigue (extreme tiredness)
Chills
HeadacheChest painBody aches

and...

Severe histoplasmosis
In some people, usually those who have weakened immune systems, histoplasmosis can develop into a long-term lung infection, or it can spread from the lungs to other parts of the body, such as the central nervous system (the brain and spinal cord). 3

Link

So we know that the miners had not had adequate treatment for a matter of weeks before they finally ended up in a modern hospital in Kunming.

I would think that the clinic or hospital or wherever they had initially sought medical treatment absolutely was not an advanced institution given that Kunming is 250 kms from Mojiang Hani Autonomous Country with a population of 350,000 people.
 
Aaannd we have another full-of-holes report out today. I expect the story to turn up here if it hasn't already:

NPR: New Data Leads To Rethinking (Once More) Where The Pandemic Actually Began

I'm replying to the radio news report:

It's unfortunate how much the WHO report is relied on despite the problem the evidence it is supposed to support isn't in there: the evidence there was COVID at any other wet market besides the SeaFood market.

I'm still waiting for someone here to find that evidence in that report because I would like to update my arguments if it is in there. All I can find is markets exist in Wuhan.

Hole #1) ^ the above.

Hole #2) The seafood market was the site of a super-spreader event but it was not the source of the first cases. Note: said scientist uses hole #1 to explain his argument that all cases came from wet markets.

Hole #3) He made a little map of where cases were and they clustered around the seafood market (d'uh). But it hasn't dawned on him that market is in a residential area so no wonder cases clustered around the market (note: not the first cases) whereas I don't see any obvious housing around the WIV. It is in a complex of the university and other labs. Residences are across a bridge. People probably don't walk home to nearby residences.

Quay, on the other hand, much as you all like to dismiss him mapped the hospitals patients went to first and they followed the #2 subway line that leads straight out of the WIV.

Which brings up hole #4) Did this man not look at anything done by virologists looking at the genome patterns? It does not appear so.
 
Last edited:
Hole #2) The seafood market was the site of a super-spreader event but it was not the source of the first cases. Note: said scientist uses hole #1 to explain his argument that all cases came from wet markets.

We don't actually know where the first cases occurred.

This is one thing that we have been over a number of times.

The funny thing is that you use the first known infection to rule out the Huanan Market and doggedly stick to that narrative.

However, you also like to conjure up cases that we don't know about that took place in the Wuhan Military Games or wherever else and happily assert that the outbreak occurred in November, no October, no make that September and so the database got taken down.

If you can categorically rule out the Huanan Market the way you do, then to stay consistent you also have to rule out the WIV and many of your other theories that aren't backed by evidence.
 
Anyway, thank you for the quote.

Okay, so they went to Kunming which is indeed a modern city.

Aside from the Master's thesis, would there not also be hospital records? Wouldn't these be able to state what the doctors there thought the miners had?

For the record, histoplasmosis symptoms:

and...

Link
Please, don't try to think you can diagnose or even recognize a medical diagnosis based on a couple symptoms and an internet description you think it matches. I know you wouldn't like me to bring up Dunning Kruger, so don't keep giving me reasons to do so.

I do thank you however for the review because it is found in caves with bat droppings. I stand corrected on that. However, it suggests even more that the physicians who took care of the miners would have recognized it right away.


So we know that the miners had not had adequate treatment for a matter of weeks before they finally ended up in a modern hospital in Kunming.

I would think that the clinic or hospital or wherever they had initially sought medical treatment absolutely was not an advanced institution given that Kunming is 250 kms from Mojiang Hani Autonomous Country with a population of 350,000 people.
Where did you get the idea they weren't taken to the hospital for weeks or that they were not infected at the same time?
 
We don't actually know where the first cases occurred.

This is one thing that we have been over a number of times.

The funny thing is that you use the first known infection to rule out the Huanan Market and doggedly stick to that narrative.

However, you also like to conjure up cases that we don't know about that took place in the Wuhan Military Games or wherever else and happily assert that the outbreak occurred in November, no October, no make that September and so the database got taken down.

If you can categorically rule out the Huanan Market the way you do, then to stay consistent you also have to rule out the WIV and many of your other theories that aren't backed by evidence.

Round and round the same stuff.

None of the first cases going by date they developed the infection were connected to the seafood market or any other market.

You know how after false information is corrected, if you wait long enough people will forget the correction and go back to repeating the false information?
 
Please, don't try to think you can diagnose or even recognize a medical diagnosis based on a couple symptoms and an internet description you think it matches. I know you wouldn't like me to bring up Dunning Kruger, so don't keep giving me reasons to do so.

I do thank you however for the review because it is found in caves with bat droppings. I stand corrected on that. However, it suggests even more that the physicians who took care of the miners would have recognized it right away.

I am not claiming any expertise or competence in medical stuff. You can accuse me of Dunning Kruger if you like, but when someone claims no expertise but brings up some points anyway, then that is not Dunning Kruger.

Besides, I think Planigale brought up the corrections to you regarding bat caves, not me.

I don't mean to be rude, but you reply to a lot of people and mix them up very often. You have mistaken me for the Atheist, and now Planigale for me. My understanding is that Planigale is a front line doctor so she has a lot more understanding of these things than I do.

Where did you get the idea they weren't taken to the hospital for weeks or that they were not infected at the same time?


Where did I get the idea they weren't taken to the hospital for weeks? Well, it was something you quoted to me. I even highlighted it in red in the post you are quoting from now...

The workers, ages 30 to 63, were scrubbing a copper seam clean of bat faeces in April 2012. Weeks later, they were admitted to a hospital in the provincial capital of Kunming with persistent coughs, fevers, head and chest pains and breathing difficulties. Three eventually died.

So, they were presumably initially treated in a very small rural backwater (sorry, that's what Mojiang Hani appears to be) before they ended up in Kunming, so I assume it was only once it had become very serious that they were sent there. As I pointed out, it is about 250 kms away (maybe more for all I know because I don't exactly know the location of mine or where the miners lived).

Again, much of this just points to the fact that we are dealing with only partial knowledge here.
 
Round and round the same stuff.

None of the first cases going by date they developed the infection were connected to the seafood market or any other market.

You know how after false information is corrected, if you wait long enough people will forget the correction and go back to repeating the false information?

You do it all the time. I am setting my watch according to the next time you claim Peter Daszak announced in an interview that he did secret Gain of Function studies in Wuhan.

Besides, what I am saying is not that Huanan Market has been definitively shown to be the source of the outbreak. I don't believe I have ever said that so claiming I have is false. If you do it again, it will be a lie.

What I am saying, and all I am saying is that the market cannot be ruled out as the source of the outbreak. Really, nowhere can be including the WIV.

It is you, and only you making the case that Huanan must be ruled out as the source of the outbreak and suggesting that that makes the WIV the most likely source.
 
Last edited:
For goodness sake! We've all seen the damn video!

My point is that you misquote it.

Look, let me help you:

Daszak says: "You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily...spike protein drives a lot of what happens with coronavirus zoonotic risk. So you can get the sequence you can build the protein and we work with Ralph Baric at UNC to do that, insert it into the backbone of another virus, and do some work in the lab, and you can get more predictive when you find a sequence..."

Notice, as I have been repeating endlessly to you whenever you wave your hand vaguely in the direction of this interview, that he is explicitly talking about Ralph Baric's lab.
:bigclap:

You finally went back and looked for yourself. :thumbsup:

Now try looking for other sources where Daszak was working with GoF research for years and working closely with Shi and the WIV.

Baric was working on GoF in 2014 when the funding was paused. I just posted about that. They finished what they were working on (for almost a year more) then paused the work at UNC.

This is what the US State Dept says about the GoF research done at the WIV:
The WIV has a published record of conducting “gain-of-function” research to engineer chimeric viruses. But the WIV has not been transparent or consistent about its record of studying viruses most similar to the COVID-19 virus, including “RaTG13,” which it sampled from a cave in Yunnan Province in 2013 after several miners died of SARS-like illness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom