Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
It was in the master's thesis.How exactly did you determine what is most likely?
It was in the master's thesis.How exactly did you determine what is most likely?
We know a little more than that. We know their chest xrays showed a specific "ground glass" feature IIRC. I'll go look for it.To be honest, I think at this point it is fair to say that at the very least, the Masters thesis writer who apparently had some role in treating (some of?) the miners, believed that the pneumonia in the miners was caused by a SARS-related virus.
That said, I also think it seems difficult to really know much more than that at this point.
No doubt it would be useful to find out more about what happened to them, but I think too many gaps are being filled in with insufficient knowledge right now.
None of this is new to this thread including the reason for renaming the gene segment. I have also seen it suggested there was a different reason for renaming it which is possible. The suggestion came with a note to Shi that in her paper from 2018 she failed to note they had most of the whole genome and Shi went back and made an addendum to the paper. That's in this thread also.Snopes now has a new article on Lab Leak (or maybe an updated one?) which mentions the Mojiang mine incident:
Link
SG even says this herself asking why Shi and Daszak would try to cover up an exact case of exactly what their mission is there to discover.
Why indeed? Instead of answering in the most obvious way possible, that they decided it probably wasn't zoonotic spillover, instead some vast elaborate and apparently pointless plan emerges.
Maybe they wanted to cover up a spillover so that they could do naughty secret gain of function... so that they could put it on a database... even though it is totally secret... and then... right... then... they would have Ralph Baric in America also do gain of function to... err... cover up their gain of function.... and then they could... tell everyone about their gain of function at a conference in an interview... and ....what???!?? Why would this happen?
We know a little more than that. We know their chest xrays showed a specific "ground glass" feature IIRC. I'll go look for it.
And we know none of the health care workers taking care of them got sick which suggests the virus had not yet mutated to a form easily spread from person to person.
Now, would it help if there was a much more open approach to the investigation of this virus? Probably. But we have already seen that open interviews, papers, conference video and tweets are being seized on by “internet sleuths” who are very keen to incriminate a number of virologists and public health workers (from what I can see they now point fingers of blame at Shi, Daszak, Fauci, Eddie Holmes, Jeremy Farrar (sp,?), other members of the WHO investigation such as Koopmans, and now apparently Patrick Vallance, the editors of Nature, Amy Maxmen, Ian Lipkin, Ralph Baric, Kristian Anderson, Robert Garry, etc… etc… the list goes on and on and it only grows the more FOIA requests are made and suspicion seems to fall on anyone that the inner circle of suspects has emailed as redacted emails make their way onto the internet with questions about why this person said “could you look at this please, give me a call” (what could such a thing mean except for lab leak!?!?!!!).
I don't recall anything about an x-ray that looked like histo. It also doesn't grow in moist caves. It grows and spreads from chicken droppings. It's a risk for farmers and there was a mini epidemic of it after the Northridge earthquake in California which was hypothesized to be the result of dust being stirred up into the air.BUT. If you were asked in an exam for the likeliest infection that caused an outbreak of pneumonia in a group of cavers who had been in a bat infected cave the exam answer would be histoplasmosis, a fungus found in bat faeces that is well recognised as causing pneumonia. The exam answer is not an unknown corona virus.
Also to repeat the x-rays and CT scans look more like histoplasmosis than Covid-19. The mine workers may have had a virus infection but it was not covid-19 as we know it since the CT / CXR appearances of covid -19 are quite unusual.
The truly odd thing is that since a priori the likeliest diagnosis was histoplasmosis why was it not tested for and treated empirically?
Since there was no person to person transmission this would not have been an outbreak of high interest. You are putting a great deal of significance into it that was clearly no thought to be the case at the time. It appears it got no further than a poor quality Masters thesis and no case report in peer reviewed journals.
Also to repeat no novel virus was isolated from the mine workers. All novel viruses were from bats and other animals.
Yes. Level 2 and level 3 biosafety labs were used. I find that mind-boggling given the risk SARS poses....
One accusation that has been directed against the GoF research - and that increases the probability that lab leak is the source - is that the GoF research is being made under the lax BSL-2 instead of the high BSL-4 safety level. Is this really the case? Very few have commented this claim.
Actually I think that this is what it was. They were constantly having to discuss with specialists at other hospitals, their access to investigations was not very great. I think this was some type of rural health centre / acute hospital that was a bit overwhelmed by having several patients with a serious illness. That is why they had to send so many samples elsewhere for investigation.
The majority of patients admitted with a pneumonia to hospital do not ever get a definite diagnosis of a causative organism. Not isolating a causative organism for pneumonia is the norm.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4728150/
So what? Did they get better? No, they died.
They got a couple anti-virals too though not ones specifically for coronavirus. Usually they are used for herpes simplex. Of course maybe their cold sores erupted as they are known to do under stress.
And I don't remember without looking but they may have gotten an anti-viral we use for influenza.
Your logic is seriously flawed.
I don't think we have established if GoF was done at WIV. SG says it did but I'm not sure what the evidence is.
We know a little more than that. We know their chest xrays showed a specific "ground glass" feature IIRC. I'll go look for it.
And we know none of the health care workers taking care of them got sick which suggests the virus had not yet mutated to a form easily spread from person to person.
Or Bacteria, or fungus, or toxin. Legionella has no person to person transmission , but common source outbreaks are well recognised. they did not test for Legionella. I don't think it was Legionella, but it is possible.
GoF research may not alarm the people doing it, but it definitely alarms other people in the research communities.
GoF research may not alarm the people doing it, but it definitely alarms other people in the research communities.
2 decades of following climate change denial has taught me that giving the pseudo-skeptics the investigations and access they demand will just lead to more quote-mining for out of context snippets they can use to slander working scientists. There are ways in which data can be more open and disseminated more widely. The same is true with climate science where much progress has been made, and most scientific fields could benefit from this as well. This DOES NOT mean questioning the integrity of the scientists involved is justified.
I see the dismay being expressed by some virologists about lab origin CT's and vaccine about how science is being so badly misrepresented by so many mass media sources and wonder if they have been paying attention for the last 25 years because its nothing other scientists haven't experienced. The fact is though, that they probabaly haven't been paying attention and this really is the first time they have seen modern science defamation close up. Make no mistake though, "lab leak" is following the same blueprint as climate science denial, the promotion of Intelligent design, etc. Furthermore it's frequently coming from the same sources.
That's a huge jump from the evidence there but no, it does not point to a fungal pathogen. You guys really need to let go of this fungal etiology hypothesis....
If the survival rate seems to be connected to length of stay in the mine would that point more towards a fungal infection or a virus?
From the mine directly. Otherwise you'd see hospital workers getting infected. With SARS that is exactly what happened. And with H5N1 highly pathogenic influenza, it's exactly what hasn't happened yet. People in close contact with the animal source have gotten infected. Some family members have gotten infected. But it has yet to mutate to a form easily passed from person to person....Also, do we think that it is likely that whatever pathogen infected the miners came from the mine directly or that if one of them got the virus and then infected the others? If the latter then wouldn’t we also think it is likely they would infect their families as well?
Yes. Level 2 and level 3 biosafety labs were used. I find that mind-boggling given the risk SARS poses.
Also, the GoF research led to alarm as dangerous viruses were being made even more dangerous. So in 2014 the US put a moratorium on funding such research. The moratorium ended at some point, I think 2017.
GoF research may not alarm the people doing it, but it definitely alarms other people in the research communities.
The thing about the GoF research that is most disturbing to me is the claim by Shi that they had no live viral cultures at the WIV. That wasn't true and most recently one of the lab administrators admitted as much and said it was only for 3 specific cultures and nothing to do with SARS CoV.
People here in modern hospitals consult with specialists outside of the area if they are dealing with patients in critical condition and an unknown pneumonia. Add to that the fact SARS had been identified as coming from horseshoe bats in the area the miners were working and people were on the lookout for SARS making another jump into the population.
Your comparison fails. Sorry.
That's a huge jump from the evidence there but no, it does not point to a fungal pathogen. You guys really need to let go of this fungal etiology hypothesis.

Daszak said he was in the 2019 interview at the conference. As for it being done at the WIV, we don't know because China won't let anyone look.
That's a huge jump from the evidence there but no, it does not point to a fungal pathogen. You guys really need to let go of this fungal etiology hypothesis.
From the mine directly. Otherwise you'd see hospital workers getting infected. With SARS that is exactly what happened. And with H5N1 highly pathogenic influenza, it's exactly what hasn't happened yet. People in close contact with the animal source have gotten infected. Some family members have gotten infected. But it has yet to mutate to a form easily passed from person to person.