Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because a couple people here seem to have forgotten:

WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE SIX MINE WORKERS?
Though the full biographical details of the six workers have not been released, their surnames, ages and medical records were published in a 2013 thesis written by a Kunming Medical University postgraduate student named Li Xu.

Li's study, still available on China's scientific paper archive at cnki.net, examines each patient's symptoms and concludes they were victims of a "SARS-like" coronavirus contracted from horseshoe bats.
 
Really? Just what evidence is that? :rolleyes:

Capsid an Planigale give it a pretty through analysis starting at about post 1546

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13533143&postcount=1546

There is no good evidence for an active viral infection. The the WHO and the doctors treating them leaned towards it being a fungal infection. This was yet another of your arguments where you claim it *could* have happened this way therefor that is what happened.
 
Sorry, not buying it. Planigale claimed the master's thesis was of poor (or some similar adjective) quality without knowing that a physician who was treating the patient was involved in writing it.

And I don't recall Capsid claiming the miners had a fungal infection not a virus. What he said was RNA viruses are less stable and it did not surprise him there were no specimens specifically collected from the miners still available.

If you want to quote something in particular that contradicts my recollection, please do. But don't expect me to sort through a bunch of posts I already read to try to figure out where you got the false idea there was evidence these miners died of a fungal and not a viral illness.
 
Last edited:
So, I have to wonder what "backbone" and "insert" in this email is supposed to mean.

Link

I would assume that the term "insert" is being used in a particular technical sense, but that it would sound like it might be confused with some kind of laboratory jiggery pokery.

Of course, if it turns out that this really is a conspiracy then it also seems that the Wellcome Trust, Patrick Vallance in the UK, and other members of the WHO investigation are all in on it.

Not a tall order for some of the lab leakers, but I am guessing that even Yuri Deigin thinks that this is not as much of a smoking gun as some of his fans believe. I think Yuri Deigin is smarter than that.
 
So, I have to wonder what "backbone" and "insert" in this email is supposed to mean.

Link

I would assume that the term "insert" is being used in a particular technical sense, but that it would sound like it might be confused with some kind of laboratory jiggery pokery.

Of course, if it turns out that this really is a conspiracy then it also seems that the Wellcome Trust, Patrick Vallance in the UK, and other members of the WHO investigation are all in on it.

Not a tall order for some of the lab leakers, but I am guessing that even Yuri Deigin thinks that this is not as much of a smoking gun as some of his fans believe. I think Yuri Deigin is smarter than that.

Aren't they talking about the vaccines that could be developed? Jenner Institute had already made a MERS vaccine and could easily be adapted with a new insert. The backbone being the chimp adenovirus.
 
Aren't they talking about the vaccines that could be developed? Jenner Institute had already made a MERS vaccine and could easily be adapted with a new insert. The backbone being the chimp adenovirus.

To be honest, I have no idea and I think it is really difficult to know what is being discussed since most of it is redacted.

I have noticed a lot of Twitter chatter is based around emails that have been obtained through FOIA requests. The assumption seems to be that the secret truths are hidden in there somewhere.

So they get back some emails which have a lot of redactions (I assume in cases like this the request was for emails between, say, Koopmans and Vallance, and then the others were redacted). I assume the theory goes that on the one hand, whoever is redacting the information is in on it because they redact the important bits, but the redacters like to leave a few breadcrumbs anyway because...well... I suppose they like to tease, or something.

Anyway, I have been seeing a lot these types of emails up and there are a number of ways they can be interpreted. If, for example, you are already inclined to believe in lab leak, then these definitely look fishy. On the other hand, it could well be that the correspondence is for reasons other than hiding their complicity in a massive international conspiracy.

I tend to think it would be odd, indeed, if the Netherlands, the UK (Patrick Vallance is Chief Scientific Adviser to the UK government - essentially Anthony Fauci in the UK) and all the other world's virologists are in on it.
 
Sorry, not buying it. Planigale claimed the master's thesis was of poor (or some similar adjective) quality without knowing that a physician who was treating the patient was involved in writing it.

And yet they were treated for a fungal infection. At best the physicians treating them didn't know what it was and from that you drew the conclusion not only that it was a virus but only related SARS-CoV-2.

If you want to quote something in particular that contradicts my recollection, please do.

I can't help with your recollection other than to suggest you go back and actually read it this time.
 
And yet they were treated for a fungal infection. At best the physicians treating them didn't know what it was and from that you drew the conclusion not only that it was a virus but only related SARS-CoV-2.



I can't help with your recollection other than to suggest you go back and actually read it this time.

How exactly did you determine what is most likely?

To be honest, I think at this point it is fair to say that at the very least, the Masters thesis writer who apparently had some role in treating (some of?) the miners, believed that the pneumonia in the miners was caused by a SARS-related virus.

That said, I also think it seems difficult to really know much more than that at this point.

No doubt it would be useful to find out more about what happened to them, but I think too many gaps are being filled in with insufficient knowledge right now.
 
Snopes now has a new article on Lab Leak (or maybe an updated one?) which mentions the Mojiang mine incident:

The 2012 Mojiang Mine Incident’s Scientific Significance Has Been Distorted
In reading virtually anything written about the lab leak hypothesis, what proponents identify as the “most startling” finding is that the RaTG13 virus was originally named Ra4991. This renaming, lab leak advocates allege, was done to obscure the sample’s connection to a mineshaft in southern China where workers shoveling bat guano in 2012 became ill with SARS-like symptoms and died. As Shi has explained, the new name reflects the species of bat from which the virus was collected (Rhinolophus affinis), the location where it was collected (Tongguan) and the year of the sample’s collection (2013).

In an addendum to her SARS-CoV-2 genome paper published months later, Shi stated that these samples were collected after local authorities were concerned that the miners’ cases could represent a novel animal-born virus. Shi’s team (which was not the only group working at this site) sampled bat fecal samples once or twice a year from 2013 to 2015, collecting a total of 1,322 samples. Within those samples, Shi said in an interview with Science, nine were identified as containing betacoronaviruses, the family to which SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 belong. One of those betacoronavirus-containing samples was Ra4991.

The name change has been used to project suspicion onto Shi’s work in the absence of clearly defined theories about its relevance. “Rather than ‘finding’ RaTG13 in her freezers in February, Dr. Shi had worked with it since at least 2016, but under a different name, RaBtCoV/4991,” McNeil wrote. “This virus,” he argued, using a strawman argument never presented by Shi, “had not been gathered at random but from a mineshaft in which miners digging bat guano got pneumonia, some fatally.”

Deigin, in his piece, made the same argument. “It is odd that in her 2020 paper on RaTG13 Shi Zhengli fails to mention RaBtCoV/4991 or cite her 2016 paper about its discovery,” he wrote. “It is not like RaBtCoV/4991 was forgotten by her group, as it is mentioned in their 2019 paper, where it is included in a phylogenetic tree of other coronaviruses.” Finding things “odd” is not evidence; it is innuendo.

Innuendo is all lab leak advocates have offered on this point. Most lab leak articles cite a translated Chinese master’s thesis about the miners’ illness as evidence of deception. This thesis argued that a SARS-like coronavirus may have been responsible for the deaths of the miners, but it found no definitive evidence in favor of that conclusion. In perhaps the least controversial statement of the lab leak debate, the authors who brought this translated thesis into the limelight concluded “that the Mojiang mineshaft miners’ illness could provide important clues to the origin of SARS-CoV-2.”

Indeed it could, but that has nothing to do with the plausibility of a lab leak. While the conclusion is disputed, let’s say for sake of argument that these miners died of a bat-borne coronavirus contracted in the mine as alleged (the presence of multiple viruses and other pathogens make any such a conclusion challenging and another team of researchers proposed a different kind of virus they identified in the same mine as the miners’ cause of death in 2014). Such an occurrence would be evidence of a bat-borne virus similar to SARS-CoV-2 evolving to infect humans without any laboratory intervention.

Link

SG even says this herself asking why Shi and Daszak would try to cover up an exact case of exactly what their mission is there to discover.

Why indeed? Instead of answering in the most obvious way possible, that they decided it probably wasn't zoonotic spillover, instead some vast elaborate and apparently pointless plan emerges.

Maybe they wanted to cover up a spillover so that they could do naughty secret gain of function... so that they could put it on a database... even though it is totally secret... and then... right... then... they would have Ralph Baric in America also do gain of function to... err... cover up their gain of function.... and then they could... tell everyone about their gain of function at a conference in an interview... and ....what???!?? Why would this happen?
 
It moved to the WIV, it didn't stop.

There are more articles on the GoF research, including a publication in 2017 I believe. I've not had time yet to put another tl:dr post on the GoF and live viral cultures at the WIV together but I'm working on it. Those sources have been posted here. I keep getting sidetracked finding things at the beginning of the thread that make more sense now. That and I actually have work to do though that may be hard to tell given how interested I am in the origin of COVID.


It does! Which makes it more puzzling that Shi et al would not be all over the miner's infections and the research that followed at the WIV. An unsupported claim the miners died of a fungal infection** makes no sense at all.

There is one important aspect of the miner's infections: it did not spread to their families or the medical staff taking care of them. That is typical of an initial spillover event. Patients are infected initially from an animal but the virus is not tuned to human cells. That comes later after the virus has developed more variants which are adapted to humans.

We've seen that happen with influenza where a number of highly pathogenic strains have crossed into people but not yet adapted to person to person spread. The H5N1 strain infections in people in Hong Kong resulted in statewide planning here for the next great flu pandemic. That big one hasn't happened yet. We know from the virus and from history it still will. And H5N1 is still smoldering, not gone away.



**Which BTW rarely occurs as an outbreak, histoplasmosis being one exception. Fungal infections almost always are either single patient events or nosocomial outbreaks in hospital patients who are medically compromised. And as I mentioned earlier, a histoplasmosis diagnosis would not have been missed. At a minimum it wouldn't have been confused with a novel virus spillover.

BUT. If you were asked in an exam for the likeliest infection that caused an outbreak of pneumonia in a group of cavers who had been in a bat infected cave the exam answer would be histoplasmosis, a fungus found in bat faeces that is well recognised as causing pneumonia. The exam answer is not an unknown corona virus.

Also to repeat the x-rays and CT scans look more like histoplasmosis than Covid-19. The mine workers may have had a virus infection but it was not covid-19 as we know it since the CT / CXR appearances of covid -19 are quite unusual.

The truly odd thing is that since a priori the likeliest diagnosis was histoplasmosis why was it not tested for and treated empirically?

Since there was no person to person transmission this would not have been an outbreak of high interest. You are putting a great deal of significance into it that was clearly no thought to be the case at the time. It appears it got no further than a poor quality Masters thesis and no case report in peer reviewed journals.

Also to repeat no novel virus was isolated from the mine workers. All novel viruses were from bats and other animals.
 
Maybe they wanted to cover up a spillover so that they could do naughty secret gain of function... so that they could put it on a database... even though it is totally secret... and then... right... then... they would have Ralph Baric in America also do gain of function to... err... cover up their gain of function.... and then they could... tell everyone about their gain of function at a conference in an interview... and ....what???!?? Why would this happen?
I know you meant it ironically, but in general it seems to me that there is too much talk of cover up. I think that the GoF community probably did not regard this research as controversial, and did nothing to hide it, and they probably really do not believe in the lab leak theory themselves, but there must have been a nagging suspicion after SARS-COV-02 made the headlines, that just possibly somebody may connect this virus with their research, and reacted in a protective way to redirect suspicion in other directions. This could be construed as a cover up.

I can easily imagine that the Chinese government that is normally secretive would react quickly to make a cover up and close access to databases, not because there is controversial stuff in the databases, but just in case.

It is all natural reactions from researchers believing in what they have done, and a totalitarian government doing what it always does.

Nothing I have seen here constitutes evidence one way or the other, but I must say that the lab leak theory certainly look valid to me.

One accusation that has been directed against the GoF research - and that increases the probability that lab leak is the source - is that the GoF research is being made under the lax BSL-2 instead of the high BSL-4 safety level. Is this really the case? Very few have commented this claim.
 
Without it her assertion is unsupported. AKA Shi is lying.

We know it wasn't a ******* fungus (though one report says a fungal infection developed when the men were medically compromised: aspergillus is a fungus that is a nosocomial infection patients are infected with in a hospital, not one that is the primary infection in 6 people at once). And most likely it wasn't a bacteria. Both of those would have been diagnosed by their doctors. That leaves a virus.

You seem to think they went to a backwater hospital where the doctors were stupid. :rolleyes:

If you deny evidence what's the point of a discussion?

If you don't understand this stuff, stop making things up you imagine they could be.

Actually I think that this is what it was. They were constantly having to discuss with specialists at other hospitals, their access to investigations was not very great. I think this was some type of rural health centre / acute hospital that was a bit overwhelmed by having several patients with a serious illness. That is why they had to send so many samples elsewhere for investigation.

The majority of patients admitted with a pneumonia to hospital do not ever get a definite diagnosis of a causative organism. Not isolating a causative organism for pneumonia is the norm.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4728150/
 
One accusation that has been directed against the GoF research - and that increases the probability that lab leak is the source - is that the GoF research is being made under the lax BSL-2 instead of the high BSL-4 safety level. Is this really the case? Very few have commented this claim.

I don't think we have established if GoF was done at WIV. SG says it did but I'm not sure what the evidence is.
 
I know you meant it ironically, but in general it seems to me that there is too much talk of cover up. I think that the GoF community probably did not regard this research as controversial, and did nothing to hide it, and they probably really do not believe in the lab leak theory themselves, but there must have been a nagging suspicion after SARS-COV-02 made the headlines, that just possibly somebody may connect this virus with their research, and reacted in a protective way to redirect suspicion in other directions. This could be construed as a cover up.

I can easily imagine that the Chinese government that is normally secretive would react quickly to make a cover up and close access to databases, not because there is controversial stuff in the databases, but just in case.

It is all natural reactions from researchers believing in what they have done, and a totalitarian government doing what it always does.

Nothing I have seen here constitutes evidence one way or the other, but I must say that the lab leak theory certainly look valid to me.

One accusation that has been directed against the GoF research - and that increases the probability that lab leak is the source - is that the GoF research is being made under the lax BSL-2 instead of the high BSL-4 safety level. Is this really the case? Very few have commented this claim.

GoF research is critical to understanding what viruses and classes of viruses represent a risk of crossing over into humans and creating a pandemic. Most virologists understand that it there needs to be strict controls over where\how it's done. All the confirmed GoF research mentioned in this thread so far actually took place in the US not China.

No matter how fast the Chinese government responded they could not travel back in time to withdraw public access to "the database". The removal of public access too place before the estimated date of the SARS-CoV-2 virus crossing over into humans.

So far as I know it's only public access that has been removed and researchers can still get the database on request and that it was an important tool in identifying several of the close SARS-CoV-2 relatives we now know about. It's also worth remembering that in spite of researches all over the world having downloaded the public access version no close relatives have been found that don't show un in the current versions.

A final point, one that I have made before, is that Dr Shi herself played a big role in debunking the theory that China was promoting, that the original SARS was a product of a US laboratory. In spite of this Shi is being pained as a pawn of the Chinese government for taking a similar stance on a similar theory this time around. The only difference is that the hypothesis says it was a Chinese lab not a US lab being blamed.
 
There were also similar "lab leak" hypothesis pushed as part of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, the AIDS pandemic in the 1980's the Zika virus epidemic in 2018, and the last Ebola outbreak. There were even "theories" back in 1918 that the flu pandemic was a wartime plot. In fact such theories pop up in essentially every pandemic or epidemic so why are some people trying to lower the bar on evidence this time around? Surely if "we need total transparency" is an argument this time it should have applied every time.
 
I know you meant it ironically, but in general it seems to me that there is too much talk of cover up. I think that the GoF community probably did not regard this research as controversial, and did nothing to hide it, and they probably really do not believe in the lab leak theory themselves, but there must have been a nagging suspicion after SARS-COV-02 made the headlines, that just possibly somebody may connect this virus with their research, and reacted in a protective way to redirect suspicion in other directions. This could be construed as a cover up.

I can easily imagine that the Chinese government that is normally secretive would react quickly to make a cover up and close access to databases, not because there is controversial stuff in the databases, but just in case.

It is all natural reactions from researchers believing in what they have done, and a totalitarian government doing what it always does.

Nothing I have seen here constitutes evidence one way or the other, but I must say that the lab leak theory certainly look valid to me.

One accusation that has been directed against the GoF research - and that increases the probability that lab leak is the source - is that the GoF research is being made under the lax BSL-2 instead of the high BSL-4 safety level. Is this really the case? Very few have commented this claim.

The type of research that was conducted at BSL-2 was not - from what I understand- GoF research. The GoF research, from what I understand, was done in Ralph Baric’s lab in North Carolina. The research done in Wuhan, according to the published papers, was not of the same type.

The theory seems to be that not only were the types of research done according to what was in the published papers exactly the type described but ALSO there was other research being done off the books. That seems to be the claim.

In addition, the database, apparently was accessed by a public facing webpage until September 2019 as well as the staff’s email accounts, and this webpage was removed, according to Shi, because there had been multiple hacking attempts of both the database and emails. However, September 2019 would still be three months before the first official cases of Covid 19 and even a month or two before the estimated time by most researchers for its prevalence in Wuhan. For many lab leakers, this seems too coincidental and I think they argue that the WIV probably knew the virus got out in September and so reacted by closing the database. Some people have also speculated that cases of illness to athletes in the Wuhan Military Games in October and some intelligence reports of sick WIV employees in November point to evidence of the virus. However a more parsimonious answer regarding any such illnesses is that it was flu season and/or simple cases of post-hoc narrative building. After all, if it was so widespread by October why don’t we have evidence of the virus spreading to family members of the Military Games from when they arrived back in their respective countries? Regarding the sick WIV lab workers we have no details at all. Shi and others have asked to hear the names of these supposed sick workers but guess what… US intelligence does not share such information - of course - and apparently nobody has a problem with such information being kept secret by the US government but they somehow don’t expect the same level of secrecy from the Communist government of China.

As for the database, as lomiller points out, the WIV has said it shares its database with researchers who ask to see it, but it isn’t open-access to the public.

Now, would it help if there was a much more open approach to the investigation of this virus? Probably. But we have already seen that open interviews, papers, conference video and tweets are being seized on by “internet sleuths” who are very keen to incriminate a number of virologists and public health workers (from what I can see they now point fingers of blame at Shi, Daszak, Fauci, Eddie Holmes, Jeremy Farrar (sp,?), other members of the WHO investigation such as Koopmans, and now apparently Patrick Vallance, the editors of Nature, Amy Maxmen, Ian Lipkin, Ralph Baric, Kristian Anderson, Robert Garry, etc… etc… the list goes on and on and it only grows the more FOIA requests are made and suspicion seems to fall on anyone that the inner circle of suspects has emailed as redacted emails make their way onto the internet with questions about why this person said “could you look at this please, give me a call” (what could such a thing mean except for lab leak!?!?!!!).

Is a lab leak possible? Maybe, and the fact it broke out in Wuhan is certainly eye-brow raising (although even here it was partly so because it was a BSL-4 lab but some of the “damning” details is that research was done at BSL-2). But honestly what is put forward as evidence seems to rely on very wild theories of extraordinary international cover-up and as we know extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The evidence we tend to see is ambiguous at best and often can only be explained as lab leak if we also grant other unlikely assumptions as well.
 
And yet they were treated for a fungal infection. ....
So what? Did they get better? No, they died.

They got a couple anti-virals too though not ones specifically for coronavirus. Usually they are used for herpes simplex. Of course maybe their cold sores erupted as they are known to do under stress.

And I don't remember without looking but they may have gotten an anti-viral we use for influenza.

Your logic is seriously flawed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom