It would be informative to know the sequence of the coronavirus the miners got infected with as it will tell us what is needed to trigger a spillover event. The problem is it's possible/probable that the samples taken were not done in a way that would preserve the viral RNA of sufficient quality to get the sequence. RNA is very labile. WIV did take foecal samples from bats specifically to derive sequence in an effort to understand what viruses were in the cave. Did they do that because no sequence could be derived from the miners? ...
Not only would it be useful having these questions answered about the miners' infection, this would also be very useful:
one) there were specimens from those men collected and described in the master's thesis that should still be available to recover the RNA from. Those specimens haven't been mentioned anywhere at any time since they were recorded as collected in the master's thesis that I am aware of.
And
two), there is still no explanation for Shi claiming they had a fungal infection.
Both of those questions would go a long way toward supporting the claim the RaTG13 bat virus (which took a while before Shi went back to correct the record that they had most of the full genome) was indeed the closest match to COVID 19.
Correction to the Nature article that addresses the full genome
Can we revisit the cells? This is key to understanding the gain of function aspect. The virus taken from bat poo was cultured in Vero E6 cells, these are monkey cells and have the ACE-2 receptor. HeLa cells were also used (this is a cell line derived from humans) but was transfected with the ACE-2 receptor (I assume HeLa cells don't usually have ACE-2?) and compared to untransfected HeLa cells. Only the transfected cells got infected. I don't regard that as a gain of function study but rather to just confirm that the viruses they collected can use the ACE-2 receptor which would be needed for a zoonotic virus to cause a spillover event. The studies are not designed to be producing a more virulent strain (in my opinion). Is there evidence that the virus was deliberately manipulated/passaged to derive a more virulent strain?
Assuming you are addressing me, are you talking about this paper from 2015 (because there are others)?
NatureMedicine: A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence
Wild-type SARS-CoV (Urbani), mouse-adapted SARS-CoV (MA15) and chimeric SARS-like CoVs were cultured on Vero E6 cells ...
... Human lungs for HAE cultures were procured under University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Institutional Review Board–approved protocols. HAE cultures represent highly differentiated human airway epithelium containing ciliated and non-ciliated epithelial cells as well as goblet cells. ...
... Both wild-type and chimeric viruses were derived from either SARS-CoV Urbani or the corresponding mouse-adapted (SARS-CoV MA15) infectious clone (ic) as previously described27. Plasmids containing spike sequences for SHC014 were extracted by restriction digest and ligated into the E and F plasmid of the MA15 infectious clone. ...
... Thereafter, plasmids containing wild-type, chimeric SARS-CoV and SHC014-CoV genome fragments were amplified, excised, ligated and purified. In vitro transcription reactions were then preformed to synthesize full-length genomic RNA, which was transfected into Vero E6 cells as previously described2. The medium from transfected cells was harvested and served as seed stocks for subsequent experiments....
Re GoF studies and funding:
These studies were initiated before the US Government Deliberative Process Research Funding Pause on Selected Gain-of-Function Research Involving Influenza, MERS and SARS Viruses (
http://www.phe.gov/s3/dualuse/Documents/gain-of-function.pdf). This paper has been reviewed by the funding agency, the NIH. Continuation of these studies was requested, and this has been approved by the NIH.
And re Daszak, this correction was added:
20 November 2015In the version of this article initially published online, the authors omitted to acknowledge a funding source, USAID-EPT-PREDICT funding from EcoHealth Alliance, to Z.-L.S. The error has been corrected for the print, PDF and HTML versions of this article.
Here's a layperson's account of that particular research describing how reverse genetics plays a part.
Inside the risky bat-virus engineering that links America to Wuhan - If you study a hundred different bat viruses, your luck may run out.
Baric asked Shi if he could have the genetic data for SHC014. “She was gracious enough to send us those sequences almost immediately,” he says. His team introduced the virus modified with that code into mice and into a petri dish of human airway cells. Sure enough, the chimera exhibited “robust replication” in the human cells—evidence that nature was full of coronaviruses ready to leap directly to people.
While Baric’s study was in progress, the National Institutes of Health announced that it would temporarily halt funding for “gain of function” research—experiments that make already dangerous viruses more virulent or transmissible—on SARS, MERS (which is also caused by a coronavirus), and influenza until the safety of such research could be assessed. The announcement brought Baric’s work to a standstill.
But US funding of GoF research was reinstated.
The NIH decided the risk was worth it. In a potentially fateful decision, it funded work similar to Baric’s at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which soon used its own reverse-genetics technology to make numerous coronavirus chimeras.
Unnoticed by most, however, was a key difference that significantly shifted the risk calculation. The Chinese work was carried out at biosafety level 2 (BSL-2), a much lower tier than Baric’s BSL-3+.
Fauci described the risk this way:
“Consider this hypothetical scenario,” Fauci wrote. “An important gain-of-function experiment involving a virus with serious pandemic potential is performed in a well-regulated, world-class laboratory by experienced investigators, but the information from the experiment is then used by another scientist who does not have the same training and facilities and is not subject to the same regulations. In an unlikely but conceivable turn of events, what if that scientist becomes infected with the virus, which leads to an outbreak and ultimately triggers a pandemic?”
Back to Baric and Shi:
They did share resources—for example, Baric sent the transgenic mice with human lung receptors to Wuhan. But after their initial collaboration, the two centers were more like competitors.
Why Daszak cannot afford for this to be a lab accident:
By then, examples of such dangers were already being discovered by Shi’s team, which had spent years sampling bats in southern China to locate the origin of SARS. The project was part of a global viral surveillance effort spearheaded by the US nonprofit EcoHealth Alliance. The nonprofit—which has an annual income of over $16 million, more than 90% from government grants—has its office in New York but partners with local research groups in other countries to do field and lab work. The WIV was its crown jewel, and Peter Daszak, president of EcoHealth Alliance, has been a coauthor with Shi on most of her key papers.
But here's the key and I'll stop citing sources here but I will drudge up other links in this thread that address the Vero E6 cells and the HeLa cells. The point is Shi and Daszak were working with live cultures which both later denied. This paragraph is about culturing viruses genetically close to the SARS virus:
In a cave in Yunnan Province in 2011 or 2012, they discovered the two closest, which they named WIV1 and SHC014.
Shi managed to culture WIV1 in her lab from a fecal sample and show that it could directly infect human cells, proving that SARS-like viruses ready to leap straight from bats to humans already lurked in the natural world.
You would think they would be using this work to support the natural spillover. But they are not. Why not?
Honest question, have we seen that the W1V1 genome is indeed not a close relative to COVID 19? I haven't looked for that information yet.
OTOH, there is other GoF research Daszak talked about in that Dec 2019 interview. And there are other citations in this thread about GoF research and live cultures at the WIV. I'll track it down later.
And what data was taken offline in Sept 2019?
Bloom already showed some of that data was very relevant when he recovered it from the cloud. And there was another paper cited here somewhere about a couple early cases in Guangdong being in sequence, Bloom showed those cases were infected in Wuhan and diagnosed in Guangdong. I'll put those citations together in a follow up post.