Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, it appears to be a clear cut case of spillover.

Why that is evidence of a lab accident now is because of what followed and what there should be evidence of but which there isn't.

You would think that given it was a spillover event the WIV researchers would have been all over it as supporting evidence the lab was not to blame.

A plausible reason why they were not all over it as a spillover event is that once they looked into it, they decided that it wasn't.

Given it was a spillover event (a second spillover of SARS not likely for multiple reasons) the WIV would have investigated the crap out of it, where is that work? It's what they were on a mission to do, investigate the ongoing risk of the next SARS CoV pathogen jumping to humans.

Why would Shi in 2020 have told SciAm interviewers that the men died of a fungal disease? Where is that evidence?

The only reasonable answer is they (including Daszak) did not want to reveal they were working with live cultures and doing GoF research.

See, I don't consider it a "reasonable" explanation that Daszak and Shi decided to "LOL! Let's cover up a spillover event just so that we can do some secret GoF research!" If this was a movie, there would be a massive plot hole in the villain's motives. Why not declare they have found a SARS spillover and use that fact to earn themselves the big investments to continue their work? Instead, they cover up the thread just to do secret stuff that they could have done anyway and to somehow profit from it? But where is the profit? What would be the point in it?

There's more: the scrubbing of certain data from online access in Sept 2019, Daszak's interview in Dec 2019 before he was aware the pandemic had begun (we know that because he didn't mention it and no one at the conference was apparently yet aware) where he talked freely of the GoF research, and more I have posted about.

The fact that nobody at the conference was aware there was a pandemic is not a problem for the spillover theory. It is a problem for the lab leak theory.

Remember it is the lab leak theorists who claim that the database was taken offline in response to an outbreak, and that therefore according to that theory the outbreak occurred two (ETA: Sorry, three months previously) months previously. And why was that a problem? Because whoever took the database down didn't want the supersecret databases to be discovered? Errrrmmm, what? Why were Daszak and Shi doing super secret stuff and nevertheless putting it up on public databses and apparently blabbing all about it in interviews?

Do you not see how these types of theories become incoherent and require all kinds of elaborate patches to make sense?
 
Last edited:
MILAN—In the quest to understand how the Covid-19 pandemic began, one persistent mystery is an Italian woman who researchers say they can no longer find.

Members of a World Health Organization-led team studying the origins of the virus want to investigate the case of a 25-year-old Milan resident who in November 2019 visited a hospital with a sore throat and skin lesions: symptoms of a disease that wouldn’t be discovered in the city of Wuhan in China for another month. She left behind a skin sample, smaller than a dime, that in two tests conducted more than six months later yielded traces of the Covid-19 virus, according to research published in January by the British Journal of Dermatology.

Additional studies of the woman’s case, scientists say, could help determine how long the virus was circulating in China and elsewhere before a cluster of cases erupted at Wuhan’s Huanan seafood market in December 2019. The Covid-19-positive skin sample, sitting in wax in a researcher’s office in Milan, is an example of the scattered clues about the pandemic’s early days that the WHO-led investigation is pursuing outside of China, where the pandemic began.

Link
 
A plausible reason why they were not all over it as a spillover event is that once they looked into it, they decided that it wasn't.
And don't you think there would be some evidence that is indeed what was found, you know, evidence before the pandemic?



See, I don't consider it a "reasonable" explanation that Daszak and Shi decided to "LOL! Let's cover up a spillover event just so that we can do some secret GoF research!" If this was a movie, there would be a massive plot hole in the villain's motives. Why not declare they have found a SARS spillover and use that fact to earn themselves the big investments to continue their work? Instead, they cover up the thread just to do secret stuff that they could have done anyway and to somehow profit from it? But where is the profit? What would be the point in it?
This is a distorted version of what I said.



The fact that nobody at the conference was aware there was a pandemic is not a problem for the spillover theory. It is a problem for the lab leak theory.
It's not a problem for either hypothesis. It's neutral. What it is a problem for is that Daszak was speaking freely about GoF research he was involved in before he decided to shut up about that.

Remember it is the lab leak theorists who claim that the database was taken offline in response to an outbreak, and that therefore according to that theory the outbreak occurred two (ETA: Sorry, three months previously) months previously. And why was that a problem? Because whoever took the database down didn't want the supersecret databases to be discovered? Errrrmmm, what? Why were Daszak and Shi doing super secret stuff and nevertheless putting it up on public databses and apparently blabbing all about it in interviews?

Do you not see how these types of theories become incoherent and require all kinds of elaborate patches to make sense?
I don't even understand this but I can see you stretched when the outbreak began from the month between the Sept actions of the Chinese government and when the first documented cases occurred in Oct to "three months". No one is claiming the first cases could only be traced back to Dec.

You're also framing it as a "super secret data base" when that is not what it was. And claiming Shi and Daszak were doing "super secret stuff" when they weren't.

It was only after the hypothesized lab accident that either of the 2 needed to cover their tracks. Why Shi was not publishing her research before then is something that needs to be looked at. We know at least the research data that Bloom recovered from the cloud was taken offline and the person who put the data up and then removed it would not answer Bloom's request for an explanation.

Just so you know, I'm not going to play chase all this nonsense around and around. I'll post again when I have more to say but not in response to these arguments you are making.

Address the evidence, not me or my reasoning. That is what you should be doing. You seem instead to be more interested in ... well I'm not sure what your point is actually.
 
And don't you think there would be some evidence that is indeed what was found, you know, evidence before the pandemic?



This is a distorted version of what I said.



It's not a problem for either hypothesis. It's neutral. What it is a problem for is that Daszak was speaking freely about GoF research he was involved in before he decided to shut up about that.

I don't even understand this but I can see you stretched when the outbreak began from the month between the Sept actions of the Chinese government and when the first documented cases occurred in Oct to "three months". No one is claiming the first cases could only be traced back to Dec.

You're also framing it as a "super secret data base" when that is not what it was. And claiming Shi and Daszak were doing "super secret stuff" when they weren't.

It was only after the hypothesized lab accident that either of the 2 needed to cover their tracks. Why Shi was not publishing her research before then is something that needs to be looked at. We know at least the research data that Bloom recovered from the cloud was taken offline and the person who put the data up and then removed it would not answer Bloom's request for an explanation.

Just so you know, I'm not going to play chase all this nonsense around and around. I'll post again when I have more to say but not in response to these arguments you are making.

Address the evidence, not me or my reasoning. That is what you should be doing. You seem instead to be more interested in ... well I'm not sure what your point is actually.

Yeah, I can understand why don’t want to discuss your reasoning because it is full of holes. You said the “only reasonable” explanation for covering up the Monjiang-SARS connection is because Daszak and Shi “did not want to reveal” they were doing GoF on SARS.

No, surely at least on reasonable explanation is that there was not a compelling enough reason for thinking there had been a SARS spillover, or that they had died of a fungus etc…

I think your explanation is an extraordinary one and it becomes even more extraordinary when you claim that “they did not want to reveal it” but apparently that is different from saying it is secret. Sorry what is the difference between secret and something they didn’t want people to know?

But also extraordinary is that they did not want people to know (i.e it was secret) and yet apparently Daszak was talking about it on interviews. It doesn’t make that much sense.

And no, the earliest “documented cases” are early December. It may be claimed there were earlier ones but those are not corroborated as far as I understand.

So, who was taking down the database in September and why would they do it? You claim it is because of lab escape of the secret stuff Daszak and Zhengli Shi were doing. If that’s the case why were they going round talking about their secret stuff if that was the stuff they were simultaneously trying to cover up?

And by the way, you also claimed that Wuhan was in lockdown in October despite no evidence from residents or the international consulates or international media etc… and yet apparently this also didn’t stop Daszak and Shi talking about their secret research.

Makes. No. Sense.
 
Here are the Nipah conference proceedings.

https://cepi.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/2019-Nipah-Conference-Proceedings.pdf

Zhengli Shi presents on the WIV BSL-4 lab (page 65) which she offers the lab for collaborative research. Hardly secretive.

The Wuhan BSL-4 facility has an annual call around April for external organisations wanting access to the facility to test their own samples or use samples from the in-house repositories. In addition, they offer an International BSL-4 biosafety training course in an annual call around September. The 9th International Symposium on Emerging Viral Diseases will be held in Wuhan, China, on October 18-20, 2020.
 
Last edited:
We know at least the research data that Bloom recovered from the cloud was taken offline and the person who put the data up and then removed it would not answer Bloom's request for an explanation.
False. Only the raw data was asked to be take down. The reason cited was lack of versioning capability in the database.

The processed data was and is fully available in the peer reviewed literature and there was nothing in Blooms subsequent analysis that could not have been done using this data. Blooms reprocessing the original raw data added nothing other than to serve as confirmation the original researcher got the correct results.
We know at least the research data that Bloom recovered from the cloud was taken offline and the person who put the data up and then removed it would not answer Bloom's request for an explanation.
Why would a research waste time responding to baseless allegations? Bombarding researchers with meaningless requests as a way to distract researchers from their work and to create a false public narrative they are “hiding” something is a longstanding practice in organized pseudoscience.
 
Maybe there's a secret lab there!

You may be on to something!


The obvious question being how did the secret Italian lab acquire a virus developed by the military lab Ft Detrick Maryland? Was the release of SARS-CoV-2 in China a NATO wide effort or was it simply a lab leak that was accidentally carried to China by US military personnel attending the military games in China? The military BSL-4 lab in Ft Detrick is know to be having issues with wastewater contamination and was even forced to shut down for a time so it could have been a lab leak there.

On the other hand a NATO wide plot it would shed some light on why scientists from Wuhan working at Canada’s national BSL-4 lab were arrested and escorted from the faculty under police guard in the summer of 2019. Neither Canada nor the US military have been willing to release information on the GoF research they were conducting a their respective labs and the WHO hasn’t been granted full access to them to conduct a search for the SARS-CoV-2 virus. This along with the complete lack of Corona Virus data from researchers at these facilities tells us there is a cover-up going on.

With this new information we can extend this cover-up to a third NATO country we need to seriously consider most or all of NATO was involved. As further evidence just look at Covid case counts in various NATO countries, the US, Canada, the UK, Germany, Italy Belgium all NATO countries and all among the highest number of cases per capital. This can only be explained if the virus was circulating in these countries much soon than they admit. It wasn’t until researchers in China clued into the pandemic that any of these counties was willing to admit the virus even existed!!!

/jk


Ok so I'm joking but it's at least as plausible as claiming some minors who died of something that was likely a fungal infection is somehow "proof" scientist are covering the "fact" Covid was produced in a lab.
 
Why would a research waste time responding to baseless allegations? Bombarding researchers with meaningless requests as a way to distract researchers from their work and to create a false public narrative they are “hiding” something is a longstanding practice in organized pseudoscience.


Yeah, how dare those meddling teenagers investigators take up scientists' valuable time asking annoying trivial questions like might this have something to do with the cause of the deaths of four million people?
 
Yeah, how dare those meddling teenagers investigators take up scientists' valuable time asking annoying trivial questions like might this have something to do with the cause of the deaths of four million people?

"might have something to do with"? More like doesn't have anything to do with. The final data was always available so finding an outdated version of the raw data changes nothing. It just a chance for political hacks to do some grandstanding and attack real scientists in the process. It's the same type of harassment climate scientists have been subjected to over the last couple decades.
 
I told you already that linking to the Daszak interview was before he knew about the pandemic and that it had nothing to do with the conference.
I was remarking on ShengLi Shi openly asking to collaborate with the global scientific community and to use the BSL-4 facilities. That to my mind isn't behaviour of someone trying to hide stuff.
 
"might have something to do with"? More like doesn't have anything to do with. The final data was always available so finding an outdated version of the raw data changes nothing. It just a chance for political hacks to do some grandstanding and attack real scientists in the process. It's the same type of harassment climate scientists have been subjected to over the last couple decades.


My point is, in this case, even if some of the questions being asked are barking up the wrong tree, anything less than total transparency and cooperation in answering them is intolerable. That's inconvenient for real scientists? Dying or being disabled or losing your business because of Covid-19 are all pretty inconvenient too, and those have happened to millions of people.

If there was ever a time in history for the advocates of science and rationality—you know, the good guys—to show a little concern and humility over the possible consequences of possibly grave mistakes, this is it. If scientists and pro-science politicians stick to "nyah nyah you don't have proof, the data is inconclusive, so stop bothering us important knowledgeable people about it," and then you don't come up with the evidence you expect to find for a natural crossover event, research could be over.
 
My point is, in this case, even if some of the questions being asked are barking up the wrong tree, anything less than total transparency and cooperation in answering them is intolerable. That's inconvenient for real scientists? Dying or being disabled or losing your business because of Covid-19 are all pretty inconvenient too, and those have happened to millions of people.
You completely ignored my point. In organized pseudoscience “asking questions” is a method for spreading misinformation and in some cases can even be an attempt to stop all research by swamping researchers with so many “questions” (usually done with FOI requests that the researcher has no choice but to respond to) they have no time for doing anything else.

If there was ever a time in history for the advocates of science and rationality—you know, the good guys—to show a little concern and humility over the possible consequences of possibly grave mistakes, this is it. If scientists and pro-science politicians stick to "nyah nyah you don't have proof, the data is inconclusive, so stop bothering us important knowledgeable people about it," and then you don't come up with the evidence you expect to find for a natural crossover event, research could be over.

There is a huge difference between responding to legitimate questions and veiled or outright but unsubstantiated accusations of scientific malfeasance, which is what’s going on here. In these cases it doesn’t even matter what the response is the CT’ers are trying to sell the controversy so even getting scientists to publically defend their actions is a win for the conspiracy theory.
 
Here are the Nipah conference proceedings.

https://cepi.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/2019-Nipah-Conference-Proceedings.pdf

Zhengli Shi presents on the WIV BSL-4 lab (page 65) which she offers the lab for collaborative research. Hardly secretive.

Zhengli Shi has been at the forefront of research into the dangers represented by coronaviruses carried by bats for nearly 2 decades. There probably isn’t anyone who has done as much to help the world prepare for and protect itself against diseases like Covid-19. Shi was also the scientist who tracked down the ultimate source of SARS, and ultimately debunked the claims of the Chinese government that it was a leak from a US lab. Yet, now she is being villainized simply because some people don’t trust certain scientists simply because they are Chinese.

The “infamous” gain of function research is key in determining which viruses have the potential for human pandemics, but now some people are insisting scientists shouldn’t even be looking to see what viruses are out there waiting.

The very people who have been raises the alarm about a potential pandemic like Covid-19 are ones being scapegoated on mass as “the culprits behind it”, and it’s depressing.

The lab in Wuhan is at the forefront of corona viruses specific research but there are people in this thread insisting that any scientist who’s been involved with it “can’t be trusted”
 
You completely ignored my point. In organized pseudoscience “asking questions” is a method for spreading misinformation and in some cases can even be an attempt to stop all research by swamping researchers with so many “questions” (usually done with FOI requests that the researcher has no choice but to respond to) they have no time for doing anything else.


That's not happening in this thread.

There is a huge difference between responding to legitimate questions and veiled or outright but unsubstantiated accusations of scientific malfeasance, which is what’s going on here. In these cases it doesn’t even matter what the response is the CT’ers are trying to sell the controversy so even getting scientists to publically defend their actions is a win for the conspiracy theory.


That's the way investigations work. If somebody disappears, there might be malfeasance involved or there might not. Regardless, the police tend to make veiled accusations of unsubstantiated malfeasance left and right until they explain the disappearance (or give up). If you're the last person known to have seen the missing person alive, you have the right to tell the police you're too busy and important to be bothered to answer their non-legitimate questions. Doing so doesn't guarantee they'll hang their heads in shame at being called pseudoscientists and leave you alone. And telling them, "of course I'll cooperate, you can search my house as much as you like, but only if you agree not to go in the garage or the back yard," won't help much either.
 
WTF?

It's a worldwide pandemic that has been raging for a year and a half and you think Shi didn't have time to search a computerized database?

She had time to say she searched said database and found no COVID-19 like genomes in there.

Go look at the 2017 PLOS pathogens article. Maybe you can find out why when the pandemic started Shi (and Daszak for that matter) denied they had been working on any live coronavirus cultures at the WIV.

I suspect that if you were the WIV in the middle of a pandemic, most of your resources would initially be redirected to supporting clinical services. Certainly that is what happened in the UK, academic departments of virology stopped doing much else but supporting testing, sequencing except some pretty direct applied research. The origin of the virus is pretty much at the bottom of anyone's priorities; it does not matter. What we have to deal with is the world as it is.

I guess the problem is what you define as a SARS-CoV-2 like genome (COVID-19 is the disease consequent on infection with SARS-CoV-2 there is no such thing as a COVID-19 genome). None of the genomes they had appeared to be a direct ancestor. You closest living species relative may be a chimpanzee, that does not mean an escaped chimpanzee was your father.
 
That's not happening in this thread.




That's the way investigations work. If somebody disappears, there might be malfeasance involved or there might not. Regardless, the police tend to make veiled accusations of unsubstantiated malfeasance left and right until they explain the disappearance (or give up). If you're the last person known to have seen the missing person alive, you have the right to tell the police you're too busy and important to be bothered to answer their non-legitimate questions. Doing so doesn't guarantee they'll hang their heads in shame at being called pseudoscientists and leave you alone. And telling them, "of course I'll cooperate, you can search my house as much as you like, but only if you agree not to go in the garage or the back yard," won't help much either.

I would say that in this thread there are some pretty outlandish theories and much of it relies on the “research” by organized anonymous Twitter users. In some cases there is a reliance on quote-mining and narratives drawn from incomplete knowledge with speculation filling the gaps.

There DOES need to be greater transparency, but to get that is going to require diplomacy. I don’t think the overheated rhetoric that has been coming from the US, for example, is that kind of diplomatic language, and many of the lab leakers have already made up their minds that the WHO and its team cannot be trusted either. It seems that any team that China permits would be seen as compromised.

In addition characterizing it as a police investigation already suggests that there has been a crime.
 
I suspect that if you were the WIV in the middle of a pandemic, most of your resources would initially be redirected to supporting clinical services. Certainly that is what happened in the UK, academic departments of virology stopped doing much else but supporting testing, sequencing except some pretty direct applied research. The origin of the virus is pretty much at the bottom of anyone's priorities; it does not matter. What we have to deal with is the world as it is.

I guess the problem is what you define as a SARS-CoV-2 like genome (COVID-19 is the disease consequent on infection with SARS-CoV-2 there is no such thing as a COVID-19 genome). None of the genomes they had appeared to be a direct ancestor. You closest living species relative may be a chimpanzee, that does not mean an escaped chimpanzee was your father.

This speculation does not fit the evidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom