angrysoba
Philosophile
Yes, it appears to be a clear cut case of spillover.
Why that is evidence of a lab accident now is because of what followed and what there should be evidence of but which there isn't.
You would think that given it was a spillover event the WIV researchers would have been all over it as supporting evidence the lab was not to blame.
A plausible reason why they were not all over it as a spillover event is that once they looked into it, they decided that it wasn't.
Given it was a spillover event (a second spillover of SARS not likely for multiple reasons) the WIV would have investigated the crap out of it, where is that work? It's what they were on a mission to do, investigate the ongoing risk of the next SARS CoV pathogen jumping to humans.
Why would Shi in 2020 have told SciAm interviewers that the men died of a fungal disease? Where is that evidence?
The only reasonable answer is they (including Daszak) did not want to reveal they were working with live cultures and doing GoF research.
See, I don't consider it a "reasonable" explanation that Daszak and Shi decided to "LOL! Let's cover up a spillover event just so that we can do some secret GoF research!" If this was a movie, there would be a massive plot hole in the villain's motives. Why not declare they have found a SARS spillover and use that fact to earn themselves the big investments to continue their work? Instead, they cover up the thread just to do secret stuff that they could have done anyway and to somehow profit from it? But where is the profit? What would be the point in it?
There's more: the scrubbing of certain data from online access in Sept 2019, Daszak's interview in Dec 2019 before he was aware the pandemic had begun (we know that because he didn't mention it and no one at the conference was apparently yet aware) where he talked freely of the GoF research, and more I have posted about.
The fact that nobody at the conference was aware there was a pandemic is not a problem for the spillover theory. It is a problem for the lab leak theory.
Remember it is the lab leak theorists who claim that the database was taken offline in response to an outbreak, and that therefore according to that theory the outbreak occurred two (ETA: Sorry, three months previously) months previously. And why was that a problem? Because whoever took the database down didn't want the supersecret databases to be discovered? Errrrmmm, what? Why were Daszak and Shi doing super secret stuff and nevertheless putting it up on public databses and apparently blabbing all about it in interviews?
Do you not see how these types of theories become incoherent and require all kinds of elaborate patches to make sense?
Last edited: