Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Possibly WIV have been busy and not had time to look through irrelevant historic samples?
WTF?

It's a worldwide pandemic that has been raging for a year and a half and you think Shi didn't have time to search a computerized database?

She had time to say she searched said database and found no COVID-19 like genomes in there.

Go look at the 2017 PLOS pathogens article. Maybe you can find out why when the pandemic started Shi (and Daszak for that matter) denied they had been working on any live coronavirus cultures at the WIV.
 
To repeat we have no idea of the sensitivity or specificity of the assay. We have no idea of the timing of the samples, we have no report of titres. IgG reports prior exposure not acute exposure. It cannot be used to say what the cause of the acute illness was in the absence of serial titres.

ETA we also have no idea about how many of the patients had serology samples taken.
Four of them had serologies drawn including serial serologies drawn monthly on the surviving miners.

And said serologies did test positive for IgM and later it was reported also for IgG.

But none of that matters. There is other evidence, and I said one could give Shi the benefit of the doubt on more recent retesting of the serum samples.

But none of that matters either.

Explain how Shi was studying SARS CoV from the bats in the cave in Yunnan for more than 5 years and doesn't have a wealth of information on that research that should at a minimum be available?


This is going to backfire on Shi and and the WIV because they cannot explain a whole lot of things about their coronavirus research.
 
Four of them had serologies drawn including serial serologies drawn monthly on the surviving miners.

And said serologies did test positive for IgM and later it was reported also for IgG.

But none of that matters. There is other evidence, and I said one could give Shi the benefit of the doubt on more recent retesting of the serum samples.

But none of that matters either.

Explain how Shi was studying SARS CoV from the bats in the cave in Yunnan for more than 5 years and doesn't have a wealth of information on that research that should at a minimum be available?


This is going to backfire on Shi and and the WIV because they cannot explain a whole lot of things about their coronavirus research.

First, wasn’t there a number of papers published on the Nipah-related virus?

Second, doesn’t Shi and others have a ton of papers?

I don’t think people can do all the work that you demand they do at all times.

Maybe Capsid might have some perspective on what the norm would be in this case.

I mean, maybe the accusation you are making is that Shi is lazy. Or maybe the implication here is that since 2013, she has been doing very dastardly things.

But you need evidence for this before people are going to draw those conclusions. It may be frustrating that there are gaps in the knowledge but filling in the blanks with whatever you want is hardly scientific.
 
Pubmed returns 135 publications from 2013 to date.That’s 16 per year, more than one a month. That’s impressive.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Pubmed returns 135 publications from 2013 to date.That’s 16 per year, more than one a month. That’s impressive.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I thought so. Shi is only human. It’s silly to be complaining that she hasn’t done enough work (although implying she might be doing a LOT of off-the-books work) while she is producing that number of publications and also going to conferences and apparently doing field work (which she is criticized for). Of course the logical thing is to hire people to do some of the other work, which of course they do and put adverts out for. But then this has also been seized on by DRASTIC as evidence of something nefarious.
 
Pubmed returns 135 publications from 2013 to date.That’s 16 per year, more than one a month. That’s impressive.

I don't recall saying Shi had no publications, only that there is a huge gap in what should be there on the WIV coronavirus data.

And yeah, looking through publications before Dec 2019 is where a lot of the work she denies having any records on can be found. It's where the discrepancies between what she is saying now and what she said in the past are being found.

For example, why did she tell Why did Shi tell SciAm this in June 2020?

Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut.

There is no evidence to back this up or to explain why the WIV collected so many specimens from the miners and the cave. Can you find this revelation and/or supporting evidence in any of those 135 publications?

Histoplasmosis (I've lost track of where this came up) is unlikely to have not been recognized, and it is unlikely to have been fatal in half the miners; and aspergillosis is almost never a primary pathogen, especially not in a 6 person cluster. It was mentioned as a secondary infection which is when you find it.

So what fungus killed the 3 miners and where is the supporting evidence? You find it in a pre-pandemic paper and I'm open to reading it.

And if the answer to the above is don't know and don't have, why did Shi tell SciAm that? Why did Shi not even name the fungus? It's not the least bit surprising there would be fungus among the bat guano cultures.

And the comment, only a matter of time... what, like they'd never been in those caves before? It's an odd comment.
 
Last edited:
I don't recall saying Shi had no publications, only that there is a huge gap in what should be there on the WIV coronavirus data.

And yeah, looking through publications before Dec 2019 is where a lot of the work she denies having any records on can be found. It's where the discrepancies between what she is saying now and what she said in the past are being found.

For example, why did she tell Why did Shi tell SciAm this in June 2020?



There is no evidence to back this up or to explain why the WIV collected so many specimens from the miners and the cave. Can you find this revelation and/or supporting evidence in any of those 135 publications?

Histoplasmosis (I've lost track of where this came up) is unlikely to have not been recognized, and it is unlikely to have been fatal in half the miners; and aspergillosis is almost never a primary pathogen, especially not in a 6 person cluster. It was mentioned as a secondary infection which is when you find it.

So what fungus killed the 3 miners and where is the supporting evidence? You find it in a pre-pandemic paper and I'm open to reading it.

And if the answer to the above is don't know and don't have, why did Shi tell SciAm that? Why did Shi not even name the fungus? It's not the least bit surprising there would be fungus among the bat guano cultures.

And the comment, only a matter of time... what, like they'd never been in those caves before? It's an odd comment.

I think you really need to make it much clearer what you think about the following things:

1.) What claims did she make and what evidence contradicts her claims?

It is too vague for you to say things like "there is a huge gap in what should be there on the WIV coronavirus data."

and

2.) what does she deny here "a lot of the work she denies having any records on can be found"?

3.) As I mentioned before with the fungus, we are only looking at a paraphrase of what she had said without explanation. It could be that she talked at length and the reporter or editors cut it down to "Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut." It simply isn't fair to look at the paraphrase and conclude that she is hiding something, and it makes for a very shaky foundation on which to build a hypothesis of deceit and secret dodgy doings.
 
What antivirals do you think were available in 2012?

Pegylated interferon and ribavirin were used. Somehow I doubt these were available in rural China in 2012 but maybe. A number of other antivirals were developed around that time, none that would be prescribed for a viral pneumonia of unknown etiology let alone be available in rural China.


But this is all moot anyway. You are back to cherry picking bits and pieces and claiming getting an anti-fungal was diagnostic which it is not.

By the way, I went down a rabbit hole of my own when discussing DRASTIC with some people on Twitter. I ended up looking up a paper by a pair of researchers here.

The treatment given to the pneumonia patients included antivirals (ganciclovir, acyclovir injections), steroids (methylprednisolone), antibiotics (meropenem, vancomycin, etc.), antifungals (caspofungin, fluconazole), and anti-thrombotic medicines (warfarin, low molecular weight heparin). The thesis concludes that severe pneumonia in miners was due to SARS-like CoV from horseshoe bats. Dr. Nanshan's conclusion that the Mojiang miners pneumonia appeared to be primarily viral and that it was most probably due to bat-related coronaviruses, is noteworthy.
 
I really don't see the significance of any of this Mojiang Mine story.
It would be informative to know the sequence of the coronavirus the miners got infected with as it will tell us what is needed to trigger a spillover event. The problem is it's possible/probable that the samples taken were not done in a way that would preserve the viral RNA of sufficient quality to get the sequence. RNA is very labile. WIV did take foecal samples from bats specifically to derive sequence in an effort to understand what viruses were in the cave. Did they do that because no sequence could be derived from the miners?

Edited to add: maybe that doesn't answer your question.
 
Last edited:
Summary of knowns

I've been reading through the thread, and though a summary of what is known at this time might be useful.

  • The progenitor virus(es) likely originate in bats from tropical South Asian region.
  • SARS-CoV2 breakout was centered on the Wuhan region of China late 2019.
  • Transportation of animals or samples to Wuhan is likely.
  • The Animal Market has been ruled out as the origin, more a super-spread location.
  • There is some evidence of silencing of scientists raising the alarm early in the outbreak.
  • There is some evidence of deleting research data.
  • The WHO was denied access to the WIV for around a year, until the terms of the investigation were negotiated.
  • A source reservoir of SARS-CoV2 virus has not (yet) been found in the wild.

Are there any corrections or additions needed to my list?
 
Last edited:
It would be informative to know the sequence of the coronavirus the miners got infected with as it will tell us what is needed to trigger a spillover event. The problem is it's possible/probable that the samples taken were not done in a way that would preserve the viral RNA of sufficient quality to get the sequence. RNA is very labile. WIV did take foecal samples from bats specifically to derive sequence in an effort to understand what viruses were in the cave. Did they do that because no sequence could be derived from the miners?

Edited to add: maybe that doesn't answer your question.

I agree with what you say about the potential value of the findings and you are right about that. I think perhaps my question was more to do with how it fits in with the lab leak narrative.

I found this new article that is something of a profile of Linfa Wang, who is sometimes dubbed the Bat Man to Zhengli Shi's Bat Woman. Capsid, no doubt you know his reputation, and maybe you have met him or seen his presentations.

I found that the profile in some way pulls back the camera lens and gives a broader perspective on the search for original SARS that he did with Zhengli Shi and others.

Linfa Wang essentially is portrayed as someone who thought that bats were the original reservoir of SARS rather than palm civets. It details some of the interesting points of this...

In a paper the researchers helped write in 2005, they shared data from tests of 408 bats representing nine separate species. They found evidence of SARS-like viruses in horseshoe bats and fruit bats. But they still hadn’t found a bat with a SARS-like virus with the ability to infect civets or humans.

A breakthrough came from a 12-month-long survey at the cave in Yunnan. By collecting fecal samples from the horseshoe bats year-round, the scientists increased their chances of finding bats with active coronavirus infections. They found a SARS-like virus in a bat that in subsequent lab tests did have the ability to infect human cells. In a 2013 paper, they called it “the clearest evidence yet” that SARS not only originated in bats, but could directly infect humans without having to first go through an intermediate animal such as civets. “The eureka moment is a slow process,” said Dr. Wang. “You put the pieces together like a jigsaw puzzle.”

For Dr. Wang, the critical piece of the puzzle came in a 2017 paper, over a decade after his trip to China on the WHO mission. Additional years of collecting bat samples from the same cave led to the discovery of a bat SARS-like virus even more closely related to the SARS outbreak one. They were finally ready to lay out the argument that the epidemic virus originated after a series of recombination events, when bats harboring various SARS-like viruses infected each other, with the viruses swapping genetic material to ultimately create the pandemic strain.

They also issued a warning that other SARS-like coronaviruses capable of infecting people were already circulating among bats in the region. The emergence of another SARS-like epidemic was a very real possibility, they wrote.

Over the years, Dr. Wang and Dr. Shi became friends. He said he was invited to the institute in Wuhan three to four times a year to attend meetings and serve as an expert adviser on projects. He supervised students, some of whom traveled to his lab. Dr. Wang, who grew up in Shanghai, said he and Dr. Shi liked to sing traditional Chinese ballads together at karaoke bars.

In early January, 2020, Dr. Wang was on one of his regular trips to Wuhan, attending meetings on bat coronavirus research. Covid-19 was already spreading in the city.

He used public transportation and took taxis. He went with Dr. Shi and other friends to restaurants. “The best restaurants were crowded,” he said. “In January it was already very dangerous, but I didn’t see it that way.”

He flew back to Singapore on Jan. 18, five days before China locked down the city. He hasn’t been back since.

I take a few things from this:

1.) Zhengli Shi and Linfa Wang seemed pretty unperturbed if they were going out to restaurants in the city. It doesn't sound like a city that was undergoing a lockdown.

2.) It doesn't seem that unusual that people were on alert for what they thought could be SARS in 2012, particularly those who had visited caves, and that doctors may have been ready to disagnose it with incomplete information.

3.) During the time that spanned the Mojiang Mine incident, it sounds like Zhengli Shi and Linfa Wang were very preoccupied with SARS coronavirus and so I think it is unlikely that they would have dismissed an incident of deaths if they had genuinely thought a coronavirus could have killed the miners.

But as I say, I don't know how this fits in with a theory.

Why indeed would they have not been ringing the alarm and being adamant amount this being a SARS-like spillover if they thought it was? I can't understand the lab leak claim that means they would deliberately cover-up a spillover.
 
The progenitor virus(es) likely originate in bats from tropical South Asian region.

This is where some clues seem to be leading but Covid related viruses infect bats that range from Japan to Africa. There is a heavy sampling bias for south east China due to the search for the origin of SARS. (the origin for SARS was tracked down by the same Shi Zhengli people are vilifying in this thread)


SARS-CoV2 breakout was centered on the Wuhan region of China late 2019.

Wuhan is the city Hubei is the region\province. The initial outbreak was near the center of Wuhan north of the Yangtze River. The virology lab is in the suburbs ~20Km south of the Yangtze. There were no early cases in the vicinity of the lab itself.



The Animal Market has been ruled out as the origin, more a super-spread location.

Probably both. Most of the early cases had direct contact with a wildlife market or contact with someone who did. The Wuhan Fish Market may have been a super spreader event as well, increasing it's representation in early cases. Environmental samples suggest the presence of infected animals there as well.

Keep in mind that the earliest confirmed cases comes from 4-6 weeks after the estimated time for the first human infection so there was plenty of time spread asymptomatically to people with no direct connection to a wildlife market, so it's expected that some early cases will have no known connection to wildlife.


There is some evidence of silencing of scientists raising the alarm early in the outbreak.

This mischaracterizes it I think. Regional officials dragged their feet on reporting the cluster of pneumonia cases\deaths that couldn't be attributed to a known cause. This delayed efforts to identify the virus and gave time for vendors to get their animals out of the Whuan Fish Market.

A doctor treating many of the early cases tried to convince local government officials that this was a potential new virus outbreak but was ignored. He eventually died from Covid himself which some people say was foul play. He was however in his 60's and was treating serious Covid cases before it was know just how infectious the virus is. He was unlikely to be taking the precautions ICU's are currently using with Covid so it's more likely he contracted the disease as part of his work.


There is some evidence of deleting research data.

Not really. A database of virus samples and genetic sequencing was taken offline in early Oct, but the estimated time for the fist human case was late Oct or early Nov so it likely predates human infection.

The database remains available to researchers who request access, it's only internet access to the master copy that was removed. Even though the data was public no one has identified any data that was there in Oct 2019 but is missing now.

There were also some partial sequences removed from a US database on request, but these were from samples taken around Jan 2020 as part of efforts to develop diagnostics. These were recovered from cloud backups but there is nothing in them that didn't show up in the original peer reviewed paper based on them.

No reason has been given for the removal request, but anecdotally virologists have said lack of versioning is an issue for the database in question. IOW you can't update the data once it's there so if you have a new version of the data all you can do is request the old version be removed.


The WHO was denied access to the WIV for around a year, until the terms of the investigation were negotiated.
[*]A source reservoir of SARS-CoV2 virus has not (yet) been found in the wild.

"Full access" the BSL-4 lab has never been granted, but this wasn't going to happen regardless of the origin of Covid-19. China has just 1 BSL-4 lab working with human viruses so it's completely unsurprising that there are parts of it that are off limits.

The US and other nations have entire BSL-4 labs that the WHO would never be granted access to either because they are doing work for the military. This doesn't imply weapons, most military work would involve countermeasure against biological attacks. This is still Top Secret because you don't want potential adversaries to find potential holes in defences.



A source reservoir of SARS-CoV2 virus has not (yet) been found in the wild.

It's not just a reservoir that is missing, a direct recent ancestor hasn't been found. This is a problem for the lab leak hypothesis because it's much more likely for an unknown undocumented virus to exist out in the wild than it is for an unknown and undocumented virus to be the subject of genetic experiments in a lab.
 
By the way, I went down a rabbit hole of my own when discussing DRASTIC with some people on Twitter. I ended up looking up a paper by a pair of researchers here.
I'm not sure what your issue is? I also linked to those authors.

The drugs one receives, especially when one has an unknown pathogen that has put one in the ICU, are not diagnostic for anything. So what do you think it means?

Both those antivirals are not broad spectrum, they are to treat HSV. It appears they are throwing everything including the kitchen sink at the patient.

That the patient needs an anticoagulant is specific, OTOH. It means the patient is having or is at risk of having a clotting disorder. It doesn't speak to the cause and it is possible they use it for people who cannot get up out of bed to prevent thromboembolism.

Can you explain what your issue is with this source?
 
It would be informative to know the sequence of the coronavirus the miners got infected with as it will tell us what is needed to trigger a spillover event. The problem is it's possible/probable that the samples taken were not done in a way that would preserve the viral RNA of sufficient quality to get the sequence. RNA is very labile. WIV did take foecal samples from bats specifically to derive sequence in an effort to understand what viruses were in the cave. Did they do that because no sequence could be derived from the miners?

Edited to add: maybe that doesn't answer your question.

They collected multiple samples from the bats (an some rats) in that cave at regular intervals specifically to look for coronaviruses. They had been searching for the precursor virus to SARS and the miner's illness was suspected to be a new spillover incident.

I assume you know this so I'm unclear about this question: "Did they do that because no sequence could be derived from the miners?"

The initial specimens from the patients were collected by the hospital staff. I think if we had the coronavirus genome from those patients it would have been reported at the time. A documented new spillover event would have been a huge deal.

And in fact the significance of the miners' illness is one reason some researchers looking at this whole thing question missing data that should be in the WIV files and/or specimens in their freezers.


And given that, per my post above, did you find any earlier research describing how the WIV researchers found the miners' illness was fungal ergo a false alarm? And what fungus they were infected with?
 
I've been reading through the thread, and though a summary of what is known at this time might be useful.

  • The progenitor virus(es) likely originate in bats from tropical South Asian region.
  • SARS-CoV2 breakout was centered on the Wuhan region of China late 2019.
  • Transportation of animals or samples to Wuhan is likely.
  • The Animal Market has been ruled out as the origin, more a super-spread location.
  • There is some evidence of silencing of scientists raising the alarm early in the outbreak.
  • There is some evidence of deleting research data.
  • The WHO was denied access to the WIV for around a year, until the terms of the investigation were negotiated.
  • A source reservoir of SARS-CoV2 virus has not (yet) been found in the wild.

Are there any corrections or additions needed to my list?
That's about right.

The specific cave and bat species the likely SARS CoV came from has been pinned down to the cave in Yunnan. And while there are other sources of coronaviruses in a broad area of SE Asia, this specific cave has the mother load so to speak. It includes all the parts of the SARS virus and is believed to be (per Shi's own work) the origin of SARS that found its way to civets in the markets in Guangdong in 2002.
 
I agree with what you say about the potential value of the findings and you are right about that. I think perhaps my question was more to do with how it fits in with the lab leak narrative.

I found this new article that is something of a profile of Linfa Wang, who is sometimes dubbed the Bat Man to Zhengli Shi's Bat Woman. Capsid, no doubt you know his reputation, and maybe you have met him or seen his presentations.

I found that the profile in some way pulls back the camera lens and gives a broader perspective on the search for original SARS that he did with Zhengli Shi and others.

Linfa Wang essentially is portrayed as someone who thought that bats were the original reservoir of SARS rather than palm civets. It details some of the interesting points of this...

I take a few things from this:

1.) Zhengli Shi and Linfa Wang seemed pretty unperturbed if they were going out to restaurants in the city. It doesn't sound like a city that was undergoing a lockdown.
There are many reasons this would have been true. The story is behind a paywall for me.

as said:
2.) It doesn't seem that unusual that people were on alert for what they thought could be SARS in 2012, particularly those who had visited caves, and that doctors may have been ready to disagnose it with incomplete information.

3.) During the time that spanned the Mojiang Mine incident, it sounds like Zhengli Shi and Linfa Wang were very preoccupied with SARS coronavirus and so I think it is unlikely that they would have dismissed an incident of deaths if they had genuinely thought a coronavirus could have killed the miners.
Re #2 there was tons of information. And the attention paid to collecting specimens from the patients and from the caves is evidence they took it very seriously. And dismissing it now as a "fungal" infection is belied by both the master's and the doctorate theses and the specimen collecting done from that cave.

Re #3 Yes, absolutely they were. That was the mission they were on as well as they were looking for new coronavirus hazards the world was at risk for.


as said:
Why indeed would they have not been ringing the alarm and being adamant amount this being a SARS-like spillover if they thought it was? I can't understand the lab leak claim that means they would deliberately cover-up a spillover.
It remains one of the important unanswered questions.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I am not being clear about what confuses me here.

You seem to be saying that the Mojiang mine incident is evidence of a clear cut case of spillover. If that is the case, why do you think it is evidence of lab leak?
Yes, it appears to be a clear cut case of spillover.

Why that is evidence of a lab accident now is because of what followed and what there should be evidence of but which there isn't.

You would think that given it was a spillover event the WIV researchers would have been all over it as supporting evidence the lab was not to blame.

Given it was a spillover event (a second spillover of SARS not likely for multiple reasons) the WIV would have investigated the crap out of it, where is that work? It's what they were on a mission to do, investigate the ongoing risk of the next SARS CoV pathogen jumping to humans.

Why would Shi in 2020 have told SciAm interviewers that the men died of a fungal disease? Where is that evidence?

The only reasonable answer is they (including Daszak) did not want to reveal they were working with live cultures and doing GoF research.

There's more: the scrubbing of certain data from online access in Sept 2019, Daszak's interview in Dec 2019 before he was aware the pandemic had begun (we know that because he didn't mention it and no one at the conference was apparently yet aware) where he talked freely of the GoF research, and more I have posted about.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom