Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The nipah conference was early December 2019. I attended it and none of the delegates had even heard of COVID then.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

By the way, this is interesting. Did you get to speak to any of the major players? (Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, etc...?) Did you ever stumble upon them while they were laughing maniacally about their sinister cover-ups? ;)
 
Thanks for taking the time to reply. So the miners are antibody positive for a coronavirus which they could have caught before they went to the mine. The IgM negative result shows that they weren’t infected within a month or so and why there was no focus on a coronavirus infection.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Also interesting. Do you mean that there was nothing in the antibody response to suggest that the miners had contracted a SARS-like virus?
 
Skeptic Ginger,

I must say that I am a bit confused by the claims of the Counterpunch article and where we are supposed to be going with the Monjiang story.

In some ways it seems to be hinting at something dark and deceptive, but I can't figure out what the narrative is supposed to be.

If, as the Counterpunch article suggests, and you seem to agree with, that back in 2012 or 2013 that a re-emergenc of SARS or perhaps even bigger, a SARS-like virus was potentially big news, then I don't understand what it would mean for the WIV to conceal this...

After all, it wasn't "no news" as I have already posted a story about it where it was wondered whether or not a Nipah-like virus had been responsible.

So, you are making an argument that at the time a doctor who wrote a masters thesis and was one of those who treated the miners, thought it was a SARS-like coronavirus, but back in 2012, 2013 etc... what would have been the purpose of covering that up?

I mean, I get that you now think Zhengli Shi has lied about it since then and said it was a fungus.

But the theoretical narrative suggests the lies began way almost a six or seven years before Covid-19. This doesn't make sense to me at all.
 
So, I have found a pre-print that essentially agrees with a theory that I find quite plausible. Yes, I admit that its squaring with my biases makes me more receptive to it.

Obviousy it is merely a pre-print and not peer-reviewed, and clearly all it is is a possible mechanism for spillover:

One massive disruption to human-animal contact in 2019 is linked to the on-going African swine fever virus (ASFV) pandemic. This began in Georgia in 2007 and was introduced to China in 2018. Pork is the major meat source in the Chinese diet. Severe fluctuations in the pork market prior to December 2019, may have increased the transmission of zoonotic pathogens, including severe acute respiratory syndrome–related coronaviruses, from wildlife to humans, wildlife to livestock and non-local animals to local animals. The major production and consumption regions for pork are geographically separated in China. The dramatic shortage of pork following restrictions of pig movement and culling resulted in price increases, leading to alternative sources of meat and unusual animal and meat movements nationwide often involving wildlife and thus greatly increased opportunities for human-Sarbecovirus contacts.

Link
 
Facts: much of the database re coronaviruses has been taken offline by the Chinese.

Fact: some of the research done at the WIV has been covered up.

Fact: What was in the freezer and/or database at the WIV has been covered up.

Make of that what you will.

It would be great if we could just "make of that what you will".

Look, no one is allowed into Area 51... make of that what you will!

The US government has not been forthcoming with its UFO pictures. Make of that what you will!

You shouldn't simply make of things what you will. That is basically the lab leak of the gaps.

Wherever you find an anomaly or something missing, you simply fill it in yourself with innuendo. We don't know why the miners died. We don't know what the samples from the miners said.

Shall we just make of it what we will?

Yeah! I know let's just assume that there was a SARS-like coronavirus in the miners and the Chinese used the lungs of the miners to make the virus more transmissable (this by the way, is basically the Counterpunch article).

Then we can imply all sorts of things about RaTG-13. Did you know it has changed its name? That there are inconsistencies etc... Shall we make of it what we will? Yeah, okay then, let's assume RaTG-13 is just another name for SARS-CoV2 and insinuate it was manipulated in the lab.

If it is pointed out that RaTG13 cannot be made into SARS-CoV2 then just say that SARS-CoV2 was probably one of the other ones. We don't know what the other viruses are so let's just make of that what we will...
 
Also interesting. Do you mean that there was nothing in the antibody response to suggest that the miners had contracted a SARS-like virus?


I’m assuming the IgM test was done to look for a recent infection because the throat swab PCRs might have missed catching any transient appearance of virus (and they were negative so the IgM test is for confirmation). The conclusion would be that they had not been infected with a SARS like virus recent to the test. That’s not surprising in that the miners could have been infected with a coronavirus years earlier.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
The master's thesis isn't new to this thread, I've posted links to it and discussions about it upthread.

You can dismiss the master's thesis like it is a term paper or something but here's one issue:

Re the rest of the genome, that has been known for a while once the WIV admitted to having it.

Full-genome evolutionary analysis of the novel corona virus (2019-nCoV) rejects the hypothesis of emergence as a result of a recent recombination event

I do not believe the authors of the CounterPunch article said that was the direct ancestor of COVID 19. What they said was there are specimens from the miners that the WIV has not been forthcoming about.


Starting with the addendum that was submitted to Nature, what was admitted to when confronted with the evidence:





The PhD thesis is new.




The specimens are still there at the WIV:

It would be helpful if you could be clearer about the claims you make. Discrepancies in different reports written at different times by different people happen. My guess is that a Masters would be written by an intern or equivalent. It is of very poor quality, it is not an expert opinion. The disease that these miners had was not Covid-19. It is unlikely that the virologists would know about the Master's, virology scientist would not know about a clinical Master's and one would not normally reference such. The Master's makes no claim that a definitive diagnosis was arrived at. There is no conflict with subsequent negative studies from WIV.

Thus the RaTG13 genome sequence was mostly deciphered in 2018 and not in January 2020. Ergo, the viral genome most similar to SARS-CoV-2 was being studied at the WIV before the pandemic broke out.

As referenced above RaTG13 is not the closest relation to SARS-CoV-2 even amongst known betacoronaviruses. It is somewhat distantly related and can not have been the origin of SARS-CoV-2. That it was known to WIV is irrelevant since it cannot have caused COVID-19.

To be clear no coronavirus was isolated from samples from any of the miners.
 
They have specimens from the miners. Any evidence these had sequenced viral genomes is absent from the record when it should be there. There should still be said specimens left, no mention of what happened to these specimens is mentioned.


No lung biopsies were taken. At most you would have some serology specimens, these are not good samples to look for viraemia. Sputum samples etc. are not routinely kept. My guess is that they have no samples likely to be useful for sequencing. It would not be normal to keep samples, clinical medicine is very real time. There are not the resources to keep large amounts of clinical material on the off chance there might be a pandemic in a few years time.

ETA reviewing there may have been whole blood sent on patients 2 and 4 together with respiratory samples.
 
Last edited:
No, that is not what the paper says, not even close. It meticulously documents work that includes documenting specimens in the WIV files they were not forthcoming about including almost the full genome the RaTG13 'segment' is from. And when confronted with the evidence the WIV researcher only partially corrected the record.

The authors also point out the illness that the 6 miners were infected with was covered up claiming it was a fungal infection. The PhD thesis about the men's illness confirms they had a coronavirus and it includes the fact the WIV as well as multiple other labs in China have specimens from these patients which still has not been disclosed. The authors point out that it is ludicrous to think given the men had antibodies against something similar to SARS that that would not have set off extensive research about what they had.

The information was found in the published PhD thesis as well as in the earlier master's thesis that has been cited. You can try to erase the trail, but there are still leaks out there.



Re Quay's paper having no 'abstract', there is an Executive Summary. I've found more than a few researchers referring to his work. The ES addresses how he assigned probabilities:



It's interesting that despite the evidence of Daszak's conflict of interest and influence on the Lancet article, they've put out an update this month standing by their earlier piece because they stand by the researchers whose names are being besmirched. It's a real kumbaya moment. Given they are stressing the science I find it ironic.

Science, not speculation, is essential to determine how SARS-CoV-2 reached humans



And I see the BBC has an article referring to the paper Capsid posted. I would love to send them my review of the review but instead I'll wait and see how others respond. They do note Funny how that peer review doesn't matter when one is reporting on the natural spillover but it matters when a paper supports the lab accident.



So we have a fair amount of heel digging-in which includes ignoring Daszak's conflict of interest and influence slanting the WHO report, and, a fair bit of new information supporting the lab accident.


No it does not. It explicitly says the cause is unknown. I agree with WHO the x-rays look more like a fungal infection and definitely are NOT COVID-19.

Remember IgG does not represent current but previous infection. One can never rely on a single IgG for diagnosis. Usually one looks for rising titres on acute and convalescent sera.

The reality is sera samples if they still exist are likely stuck at the bottom of a freezer somewhere. I have certainly sent samples off to reference labs on unusual pneumonias only to get embroiled in discussions about who will pay for the processing, then saying no one can find the samples sent. People are looking for a whole level of functionality that would not happen in a small self limiting outbreak with no evidence of person to person transmission in the back of beyond. With no evidence of person to person transmission no one would really care.
 
Oh my word, you really didn't look, did you? Those are 2 different theses. The translations are linked to in the piece.

Yeah..no. It wasn't covered up in 2012. Look at the doctorate thesis. It was investigated, all sorts of specimens were collected and sent to multiple labs in China. I believe they refer to Shi herself discussing it in 2019 before the first cases showed up. Daszak did as well, that interview is cited upthread.

What happened next is all the references to the 2013 work were scrubbed from the WIV files. Supposedly only the fragment was found in the files. What the article described in detail was that the full genome should have been in the WIV files. They had the virus specimens, documented in the PhD thesis.

What the authors are saying is it is not credible the coronavirus the miners were found to have had would not have started a serious investigation. Where is that work? It's missing. Where are the specimens that where collected? They are missing.

Lots of trips to the mine (cave) in Yunnan were made to collect specimens that went to the WIV. The genome data base and/or whatever frozen specimens are at the WIV lack any record of these repeated specimen collections.

As for that thumbnail, yeah, that is one of the points and one of the problems. Where is that work? Where are those specimens that would be very useful now when looking for the origin of the pandemic.


The paper puts forth a new hypothesis for which I have no opinion as of yet. They suggested that at least one of the miners had a protracted case of whatever SARS-like coronavirus they were infected with. As we have seen now, people with protracted cases of COVID 19 are little crucibles for viral mutations. The hypothesis is that it could have been within that miner that the SARS-like coronavirus became better adapted to humans.

This is different than the hypothesis COVID-19 became better adapted through GoF research. Maybe it was a combination of the two. In either hypothesis the lab is implicated.



Not sure if I already mentioned this. Just because the COVID 19 got better such as with the deltoid variant doesn't mean it wasn't ready out of the box when the first person was infected in Wuhan.

And just a reminder: the first patients were not just in Wuhan, they were in Wuhan within a few miles of the WIV. And that seafood wet market may very well have been in the same vicinity, it has been shown both genetically and chronologically NOT to be the original source of the first human infection.

Can I repeat. There was no evidence of person to person transmission for the miners outbreak so no one cared. Promed (an outbreak alert news site) is full of small outbreaks. No one cares if there is no evidence of person to person transmission.

https://promedmail.org
 
I take it you didn't read the actual article and/or didn't look at what was in the PhD thesis?

Because if you had, you would know the WIV had the whole genome the segment came from, that there were documented specimens collected by the WIV that they have not admitted to, that the segment is not supposed to be from a part of the COVID-19 but that other specimens the WIV has might be.

If you want to look at the issue honestly, don't be so quick to dismiss a paper that discusses work done pre-pandemic which is missing from the WIV now.

The PhD reports no clinical samples other than sera for IgG.
 
The proposed hypothesis wasn't all that was in that paper.

You can cite all the natural zoonoses you want to. It doesn't negate the number and type of lab accidents, including the accidents at the WIV itself (documented in the thread), and it doesn't negate the fact there is more than just a little evidence for the lab accident and very little for a natural spillover incident.


From the CounterPunch source:
Why pretend it was uncovered in the files in 2020 when it was discussed in a paper in 2018 and studied in 2013? How would this be forgotten given the patients sick in 2012 had a SARS-like coronavirus? See the information about the serologies tested showing the miners had antibodies to SARS. And given had that been a novel SARS outbreak it would have been well publicized. So the assumption is the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus. (There is other evidence about what the miners had.)




From the PhD thesis:

Re the illness the miners had and that the WIV knew it:Confirmed also by the master's thesis.


To summarize that so far: there is documented evidence the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus, documented evidence the WIV researchers were studying it, and the WIV researchers denied they had been doing research on a SARS-like coronavirus to which they later partially admitted to when confronted.

To repeat we have no idea of the sensitivity or specificity of the assay. We have no idea of the timing of the samples, we have no report of titres. IgG reports prior exposure not acute exposure. It cannot be used to say what the cause of the acute illness was in the absence of serial titres.

ETA we also have no idea about how many of the patients had serology samples taken.
 
Last edited:
We discussed that Daszak video at length early on in the thread. Feel free to review what was discussed and get back to us.


Moving on, here's another report on the "addendum" to the research published in Nature. It was linked to earlier I believe. Perhaps different wording might make the issues more clear for some.

I know some of you have decided any and everything Yuri Deigin and Rossana Segreto have to say about the lab origin is worth dismissing out of hand. I can't recall what the ginned up sin is about them. But this paper is supported by citing the sources so regardless of who wrote the piece, the discussion should be about what is written and cited. I am not including the research done for this paper, guessing that's what people have an issue with. Rather I'm quoting what refers to the CounterPunch article to provide a different description of the issues with the Zhou et al paper.

SARS-CoV-2′s claimed natural origin is undermined by issues with genome sequences of its relative strains



Re specimens from the miners which a couple of posts up there is a claim weren't available:So it was in the database since at least 2018 yet not disclosed until the omission was uncovered by other researchers.


The two theses include discussions of all the specimens that were collected in 2013 and later including specimens that went directly to the WIV.


It's been discussed why these antibodies are to a SARS-like coronavirus and not to SARS 1.


A discussion of the contaminants in the initial bat fecal swabs, what should be there that isn't and what is there that shouldn't be is discussed in the next few paragraphs.


A discussion of all the issues from pangolins to codons follows that. It's not relevant to why I'm reposting this link and it also has been discussed ad nauseum upthread.


The conclusion describes what data is missing and what needs to be looked at before claiming either the lab or natural origin of COVID-19:So much for the infallibility of peer reviews.


Why has this not already been done?

Possibly WIV have been busy and not had time to look through irrelevant historic samples?

The horrible truth is scientists collect samples on field trips, archive them and sometimes are horribly bad about processing them, writing them up and submitting them for publication and to databases. A PhD student a few years down the line will be given them to play with. This does not represent some sort of cover up. field trips are a bit of fun. Then you get back to the real work.
 
This is another falsehood.

Facts: much of the database re coronaviruses has been taken offline by the Chinese.

Fact: some of the research done at the WIV has been covered up.

Fact: What was in the freezer and/or database at the WIV has been covered up.

Make of that what you will.



Allow me to fill you in on that. When you don't know what a patient has you sometimes use the shotgun approach. They probably got antibiotics as well. And sometimes antibiotics result in fungal overgrowth like thrush (oral candida). And sometimes people have fungal infections along with their other infections. Look at all the Mucormycosis people in India are experiencing.

Bottom line, getting fluconozole is not diagnostic.


What anti-viral treatment were they supposed to get for said unidentified viral pneumonia? In addition, we don't know what viruses were collected and identified from the miners because that would have happened later at the WIV and that information isn't available.


You need to quit cherry picking little bits here and there and look at the actual evidence.

Yet they gave anti-fungal treatment for an unidentified fungus and antibiotics for an unidentified bacteria. So why not give antivirals for an unidentified virus? In most parts of the world one would not use systemic fluconazole for oral candida. Even assuming they had that (not reported).

The report is clear. No tissue samples were taken. There were no samples reported as sent to reference labs other than sera which are not likely to yield virus. It is unlikely they would even bother to try looking.

ETA

looking more carefully probably whole blood +/- respiratory secretions were sent for PCR on patients 2 and 4.
 
Last edited:
I’m assuming the IgM test was done to look for a recent infection because the throat swab PCRs might have missed catching any transient appearance of virus (and they were negative so the IgM test is for confirmation). The conclusion would be that they had not been infected with a SARS like virus recent to the test. That’s not surprising in that the miners could have been infected with a coronavirus years earlier.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Going through the Master's thesis again. Only patients 2 and 4 had samples sent for PCR. It is unclear what samples were sent. My guess from the virology reported is blood and sputum. samples are only reported as sent to one laboratory for an 'aetiology' test. I cannot see that a throat swab was taken (though it may have been, but that would not be routine to investigate a pneumonia with a productive cough).

We are really stretching things when only 1/3 patients had PCR done. It is also unclear exactly how many had serology done, it may have been the same two.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for taking the time to reply. So the miners are antibody positive for a coronavirus which they could have caught before they went to the mine. The IgM negative result shows that they weren’t infected within a month or so and why there was no focus on a coronavirus infection.
First, I missed this: going back to the CounterPunch article the master's thesis documents they did find positive IgM from the miners.
According to the Master’s thesis, Prof. Nanshan Zhong advised SARS testing and samples from four miners were therefore sent to the WIV. These tested positive for coronavirus in an IgM antibody test (See Fig. 1 [a screen grab from the thesis]).
It was in the PhD thesis the IgG was noted:
... We also got clues from a PhD thesis by Huang, C. published in 2016, that the patients’ samples were sent to WIV and the IgG antibody tests for SARS were positive, indicating that SARS-like coronavirus could be involved in the infections.

It was Shi who said in 2020 the serum was tested earlier and retested recently and no Covid-19 antibodies were found.
In their November addendum Zheng-li Shi and her colleagues at the WIV confirmed receiving thirteen serum samples–taken at approximately monthly intervals in 2012–from four of the hospitalised miners. But here there is a major discrepancy. Referring to the miner serum samples, the addendum states: ...

... We also tested the serum samples for the presence of antibodies against the nucleocapsid proteins of these three viruses, and none of the samples gave a positive result. Recently, we retested the samples with our validated enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) against the SARS coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) nucleocapsid protein–which has greater than 90% amino acid sequence identity with SARSr-CoVRp3–and confirmed that these patients were not infected by SARS-CoV-2.” (Zhou et al., 2020, addendum)
It is possible, giving Shi the benefit of the doubt, that a more specific antibody test was negative. It's also possible in 2020 the serum was tested specifically for COVID 19 and other coronaviruses would not have cross-reacted. Shi still did not provide the earlier test records when the WHO team investigated the origin of COVID-19.

With those discrepancies however, is there any other evidence the miners had an acute coronavirus? Yes.
Rahalkar and Bahulikar Is there any correlation between lethal pneumonia cases in miners in 2012– TongGuan mine, Mojiang, China, RaTG13, and present Covid-19?
This Master’s thesis is in Chinese and was translated for understanding the details. It clearly mentions various radiological and clinical findings such as interstitial pneumonia, ground-glass opacities in the lungs, and some pulmonary thromboembolism....

According to him, the patients had interstitial pneumonia (primarily of viral origin) and invasive aspergillosis (secondary).
Back to the Oct 2020 article by Rahalkar and Bahulikar https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2020.581569/full#B4
This study started with two important questions: first, were there any similar atypical pneumonia outbreaks, even on a smaller level, reported between SARS in 2004 and COVID-19 in 2019/20 in China. Second, examining the beta-coronavirus most closely related to date with SARS-CoV-2 at the genome sequence level, strain RaTG13 (CoV4991), which was sampled from a horseshoe bat in Yunnan province, we asked where exactly did it come from. It was found that RaTG13/CoV4991 was collected from Tongguan mineshaft in Mojiang, Yunnan, China, in 2013. Surprisingly, the same mineshaft was also associated with a severe pneumonia-like illness in miners in 2012 killing three of the six miners. ... The Master's thesis concluded that a SARS-like CoV originating from Chinese horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus) was the predicted causative agent.
So now we have chest x-rays that look like COVID 19 does, thromboembolisms, a master's thesis that concludes the patients had a coronavirus and the unclear antibody tests.


But even if the miners didn't have an acute coronavirus infection, and the antibodies represented past coronavirus exposure, there are still the same questions about missing research.
The best information can be found in what past research has been reported starting with this: To confirm the original source of SARS 1:2017 Scientific American: Bat Cave Solves Mystery of Deadly SARS Virus
To clinch the case, a team led by Shi Zheng-Li and Cui Jie of the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China sampled thousands of horseshoe bats in locations across the country. ... After finding a particular cave in Yunnan, southwestern China, in which the strains of coronavirus looked similar to human versions, the researchers spent five years monitoring the bats that lived there, collecting fresh guano and taking anal swabs.
So from 2013 to 2017 Shi was collecting specimens from bats in the specific Yunnan cave the miners had been infected in.
They sequenced the genomes of 15 viral strains from the bats and found that, taken together, the strains contain all the genetic pieces that make up the human version. Although no single bat had the exact strain of SARS coronavirus that is found in humans, the analysis showed that the strains mix often.

Here is the study with the 15 genomes:PLOS Pathogens, 2017: Discovery of a rich gene pool of bat SARS-related coronaviruses provides new insights into the origin of SARS coronavirus
Based on the analysis of full-length genome sequences of the newly identified bat SARSr-CoVs, we speculate that the direct ancestor of SARS-CoV may have arisen from sequential recombination events between the precursors of these bat SARSr-CoVs prior to spillover to an intermediate host. In addition, we found bat SARSr-CoV strains with different S proteins that can all use the receptor of SARS-CoV in humans (ACE2) for cell entry, suggesting diverse SARSr-CoVs capable of direct transmission to humans are circulating in bats in this cave.
One would think that with this data the WIV would be using it to support the natural spillover event.
Maybe it is because of this:
In the current study, we successfully cultured an additional novel SARSr-CoV Rs4874 from a single fecal sample using an optimized protocol and Vero E6 cells [17]. Its S protein shared 99.9% aa sequence identity with that of previously isolated WIV16 and it was identical to WIV16 in RBD. Using the reverse genetics technique we previously developed for WIV1 [23], we constructed a group of infectious bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clones with the backbone of WIV1 and variants of S genes from 8 different bat SARSr-CoVs. Only the infectious clones for Rs4231 and Rs7327 led to cytopathic effects in Vero E6 cells after transfection
Note they did indeed use Vero E6 cells.
In contrast, when Vero E6 cells were respectively infected with the two successfully rescued chimeric SARSr-CoVs, WIV1-Rs4231S and WIV1-Rs7327S, and the newly isolated Rs4874, efficient virus replication was detected in all infections. To assess whether the three novel SARSr-CoVs can use human ACE2 as a cellular entry receptor, we conducted virus infectivity studies using HeLa cells with or without the expression of human ACE2. All viruses replicated efficiently in the human ACE2-expressing cells. The results were further confirmed by quantification of viral RNA using real-time RT-PCR
I posted about this way back at the beginning of this thread.


I have more but I'll save it for later.
 
Last edited:
Going through the Master's thesis again. Only patients 2 and 4 had samples sent for PCR. It is unclear what samples were sent. My guess from the virology reported is blood and sputum. samples are only reported as sent to one laboratory for an 'aetiology' test. I cannot see that a throat swab was taken (though it may have been, but that would not be routine to investigate a pneumonia with a productive cough).

We are really stretching things when only 1/3 patients had PCR done. It is also unclear exactly how many had serology done, it may have been the same two.
Not sure what you are looking at but there is a screen grab from the thesis that noted all 4 serologies were positive for IgM.

See my post above.

Also, the WIV was experimenting with live SARS CoV cultures which Shi has repeatedly denied.


Chip chip chip, chipping away at that natural spillover event.
 
Yet they gave anti-fungal treatment for an unidentified fungus and antibiotics for an unidentified bacteria. So why not give antivirals for an unidentified virus? In most parts of the world one would not use systemic fluconazole for oral candida. Even assuming they had that (not reported).

The report is clear. No tissue samples were taken. There were no samples reported as sent to reference labs other than sera which are not likely to yield virus. It is unlikely they would even bother to try looking.

ETA

looking more carefully probably whole blood +/- respiratory secretions were sent for PCR on patients 2 and 4.

What antivirals do you think were available in 2012?

Pegylated interferon and ribavirin were used. Somehow I doubt these were available in rural China in 2012 but maybe. A number of other antivirals were developed around that time, none that would be prescribed for a viral pneumonia of unknown etiology let alone be available in rural China.


But this is all moot anyway. You are back to cherry picking bits and pieces and claiming getting an anti-fungal was diagnostic which it is not.
 
Yet they gave anti-fungal treatment for an unidentified fungus and antibiotics for an unidentified bacteria. So why not give antivirals for an unidentified virus? In most parts of the world one would not use systemic fluconazole for oral candida. Even assuming they had that (not reported).

The report is clear. No tissue samples were taken. There were no samples reported as sent to reference labs other than sera which are not likely to yield virus. It is unlikely they would even bother to try looking.

ETA

looking more carefully probably whole blood +/- respiratory secretions were sent for PCR on patients 2 and 4.
If you look more carefully the miners may have had secondary aspergillosis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom