Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are off base again. It gets tiring to keep up with your posts that don't address the evidence.


There were tissue specimens taken from the miners. There was serum collected from the miners. Collection of these specimens is described in the master's thesis. Lots of specimens were collected.
As for dying before they were seen, nonsense, the master's thesis was written by the physician who treated the miners.

Before they were seen by the WIV scientists, definitely. I mean, think about it, how much of an expert is the writer going to be on viruses if they are only writing their Master's thesis on this after the fact?

The WIV researchers have tried to claim the miners had a fungal disease among other falsehoods.

Everything you write about this is dripping with cynicism as though the WIV are always up to some devious tricks.

I looked through that Master's thesis, and even though I don't know anything about medicine, there are some notable things.

Two of the three miners who recovered received something called Fluconazole which is an anti-fungal medicine. It seems that the other cases were suspected of being a fungal infection as well. Only Case Six doesn't seem to match that, but he apparently didn't seem to be as sick as the others and had presumably had less exposure than the others.

The writer of the thesis does not say that they could make any conclusive finding that it was a virus, only that it could have been.

Here is the thing, Case Five did not have any anti-viral treatment, so honestly it looks ambiguous at best.

This is hardly a massive siren alert that proves Zhengli Shi and her band of deviants are up to no good.
 
We discussed that Daszak video at length early on in the thread. Feel free to review what was discussed and get back to us.


Moving on, here's another report on the "addendum" to the research published in Nature. It was linked to earlier I believe. Perhaps different wording might make the issues more clear for some.

I know some of you have decided any and everything Yuri Deigin and Rossana Segreto have to say about the lab origin is worth dismissing out of hand. I can't recall what the ginned up sin is about them. But this paper is supported by citing the sources so regardless of who wrote the piece, the discussion should be about what is written and cited. I am not including the research done for this paper, guessing that's what people have an issue with. Rather I'm quoting what refers to the CounterPunch article to provide a different description of the issues with the Zhou et al paper.

SARS-CoV-2′s claimed natural origin is undermined by issues with genome sequences of its relative strains
Shortly after the beginning of the pandemic, Zhou et al.[1] have published a key paper first describing RaTG13, which is SARS-CoV-2′s closest relative found so far (96.2% identity). Very little information on sampling site and sequencing methods was released by the authors at the time. ...

After repeated requests for clarifications from several scientists and journalists and more than 9 months later, the Zhou et al.[1] paper has been amended with an Addendum,[1] which provides some missing information on RaTG13, most of it previously discovered and made public by an independent research group named “DRASTIC”[5] and published by Rahalkar and Bahulikar[6] and Segreto and Deigin.[7]


Re specimens from the miners which a couple of posts up there is a claim weren't available:
While the Addendum clarifies some crucial points, such as exact sampling location of RaTG13, and mentions the original paper describing it,[8] the information released is still incomplete and partially in conflict with data previously provided. In this regard, the Addendum clarifies that RaTG13 has been fully sequenced in 2018[5] and not after the beginning of the pandemic, as seemingly implied by Zhou et al.[1] as a result of them having matched SARS-CoV-2 to that short RdRp region. It is important to notice that if the full genome of RaTG13 was present in their database since 2018, it would have immediately come up as the best match to SARS-CoV-2 when queried in 2020, with no need to mention the match to its short RdRp region.
So it was in the database since at least 2018 yet not disclosed until the omission was uncovered by other researchers.


Moreover, the Addendum confirms our suggestion[7] that RaTG13's partial RdRp mentioned by Zhou et al.[1] could have been previously named RaBtCoV/4991,[8] which is a sample collected in 2013 in a mine where six workers—three of whom died—contracted pneumonia with very similar symptoms as SARS-CoV-2, and later four of whom were confirmed by WIV to carry antibodies against SARS.[6, 7]
The two theses include discussions of all the specimens that were collected in 2013 and later including specimens that went directly to the WIV.


In addition, new information revealed by the Addendum is that eight other beta-SARSr-CoVs distantly related to SARS-CoV were also isolated from the same Mojiang mine, and sequenced together with RaTG13, but neither their genomes, nor information about their sample names and eventual accession numbers is provided. It is not known how these sequences relate to RaTG13. The Addendum also fails to release details about the number and kind of samples collected from the mine workers, their storage conditions, methods used for each test described and specification of the results obtained.


In addition, the Addendum fails to address and/or contradicts the statements in an MSc[10] and a PhD[11, 12] theses which have previously described in detail the miners’ pneumonia symptoms and stated that SARS Immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies were detected by the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in all four of the miners’ samples tested.
It's been discussed why these antibodies are to a SARS-like coronavirus and not to SARS 1.


A discussion of the contaminants in the initial bat fecal swabs, what should be there that isn't and what is there that shouldn't be is discussed in the next few paragraphs.


A discussion of all the issues from pangolins to codons follows that. It's not relevant to why I'm reposting this link and it also has been discussed ad nauseum upthread.


The conclusion describes what data is missing and what needs to be looked at before claiming either the lab or natural origin of COVID-19:
These sequences have been widely used to support a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2 but after a close examination, all of them exhibit issues which should be specifically addressed and clarified. It should be also noted that amplicon and raw data connected to these sequences have been made available only after request from scientists willing to verify the assembled published genomes. Lack of accuracy and missing or conflicting information in the papers describing these key sequences should have been resolved during a thorough peer review process.
So much for the infallibility of peer reviews.


Why has this not already been done?
we propose that the review process of all papers describing SARS-CoV-2′s closest relatives which could contribute to identify SARS-CoV-2′s origin should made public, allowing an open and critical evaluation by the entire scientific community.
 
Last edited:
Please quote the relevant passages of the interview. Besides in the interview he was talking about research being done in Baric’s lab. That is in the US. It was no secret what was being done in that lab and the research that he had been doing with Zhengli Shi was no secret either given that they had published papers on the research.

So he doesn’t say they did the GoF in Wuhan but in Baric’s lab. So your claim that he incriminated himself fails.

We discussed that Daszak video at length early on in the thread. Feel free to review what was discussed and get back to us.

So you are ignoring the request to quote the relevant part where he "incriminates himself" because you know that you don't have such a quote from him.

As I suspected. It's just more smearing.
 
Before they were seen by the WIV scientists, definitely. I mean, think about it, how much of an expert is the writer going to be on viruses if they are only writing their Master's thesis on this after the fact?
This is another falsehood.

Everything you write about this is dripping with cynicism as though the WIV are always up to some devious tricks.
Facts: much of the database re coronaviruses has been taken offline by the Chinese.

Fact: some of the research done at the WIV has been covered up.

Fact: What was in the freezer and/or database at the WIV has been covered up.

Make of that what you will.



I looked through that Master's thesis, and even though I don't know anything about medicine, there are some notable things.

Two of the three miners who recovered received something called Fluconazole which is an anti-fungal medicine. It seems that the other cases were suspected of being a fungal infection as well. Only Case Six doesn't seem to match that, but he apparently didn't seem to be as sick as the others and had presumably had less exposure than the others.
Allow me to fill you in on that. When you don't know what a patient has you sometimes use the shotgun approach. They probably got antibiotics as well. And sometimes antibiotics result in fungal overgrowth like thrush (oral candida). And sometimes people have fungal infections along with their other infections. Look at all the Mucormycosis people in India are experiencing.

Bottom line, getting fluconozole is not diagnostic.


The writer of the thesis does not say that they could make any conclusive finding that it was a virus, only that it could have been.

Here is the thing, Case Five did not have any anti-viral treatment, so honestly it looks ambiguous at best.
What anti-viral treatment were they supposed to get for said unidentified viral pneumonia? In addition, we don't know what viruses were collected and identified from the miners because that would have happened later at the WIV and that information isn't available.


You need to quit cherry picking little bits here and there and look at the actual evidence.
 
So much for the infallibility of peer reviews.

No one has ever made a claim of infallability of peer reviews. If anything, I have said the opposite, that they often involve all kinds of problems.

But what you are doing is just another motte-and-bailly.

Given that you cannot defend a nonsense paper like Steven Quay's, you decide to substitute it with a different claim - that peer-review is "infallible".

Of course, it isn't. But if you want your thesis to be taken seriously, you might want to at least try to get your peers to scrutinize it first.
 
What anti-viral treatment were they supposed to get for said unidentified viral pneumonia? In addition, we don't know what viruses were collected and identified from the miners because that would have happened later at the WIV and that information isn't available.

Actually, we do.

No viruses were collected from the miners!
 
Allow me to fill you in on that. When you don't know what a patient has you sometimes use the shotgun approach. They probably got antibiotics as well. And sometimes antibiotics result in fungal overgrowth like thrush (oral candida). And sometimes people have fungal infections along with their other infections. Look at all the Mucormycosis people in India are experiencing.

Bottom line, getting fluconozole is not diagnostic.

Not my point. My point is that we don't really know what killed the miners.

You said:

The WIV researchers have tried to claim the miners had a fungal disease among other falsehoods.

They tried to claim!
Among other falsehoods!

First of all, it is not a crazy assumption. Second, we don't know it is false.

Let's look at where the claim comes from...

Three years earlier Shi’s team had been called in to investigate the virus profile of a mine shaft in Yunnan’s mountainous Mojiang County—famous for its fermented Pu’er tea—where six miners suffered from pneumonialike diseases and two died. After sampling the cave for a year, the researchers discovered a diverse group of coronaviruses in six bat species. In many cases, multiple viral strains had infected a single animal, turning it into a flying factory for new viruses.

“The mine shaft stunk like hell,” says Shi, who, like her colleagues, went in wearing a protective mask and clothing. “Bat guano, covered in fungus, littered the cave.” Although the fungus turned out to be the pathogen that had sickened the miners, she says it would have been only a matter of time before they caught the coronaviruses if the mine had not been promptly shut.

Link

Much of this seems like a paraphrasing by the writer. Do we know Zhengli Shi's actual words? Surely we should know by now that nuance can be lost when a reporter paraphrases people's words.

Do you have any more definitive statements than this?
 
So you are ignoring the request to quote the relevant part where he "incriminates himself" because you know that you don't have such a quote from him.

As I suspected. It's just more smearing.
:sdl: :rolleyes:

What part of we already discussed this did you miss? At least I provided the bloody link again which is more than you do telling me to chase some obscure reference back to a previous post.
 
Debunking the false claim the miners had a fungal infection was just debunked in more than one source. You go and read the original lie and ask for evidence it was a lie? :confused: Seriously?

Here we go again:
Independent Science News: Virologist Dr. Jonathan Latham and geneticist Dr. Allison Wilson: A Proposed Origin for SARS-CoV-2 and the COVID-19 Pandemic
In a March 2020 interview with Scientific American Zeng-li Shi dismissed the significance of these deaths, claiming the miners died of fungal infections. Indeed, no miners or deaths are mentioned in the paper published by the Shi lab documenting the collection of RaTG13 (Ge et al., 2016).

But Shi’s assessment does not tally with any other contemporaneous accounts of the miners and their illness (Rahalkar and Bahulikar, 2020).

Looks like the reason for the fluconazole was to treat potential histoplasmosis which they did not have.

Histoplasmosis is a known pathogen in the US. It looks like and can be mistaken for tuberculosis on a chest x-ray. If these miners had histoplasmosis there would be no mystery about what they had and it would not likely have killed 3 of the 6 miners, especially in such a short time.

Fifth, the sampling by the Shi lab found that bat coronaviruses were unusually abundant in the mine (Ge at al., 2016). Among their findings were two betacoronaviruses, one of which was RaTG13 (then known as BtCoV/4991). In the coronavirus world betacoronaviruses are special in that both SARS and MERS, the most deadly of all coronaviruses, are both betacoronaviruses. Thus they are considered to have special pandemic potential, as the concluding sentence of the Shi lab publication which found RaTG13 implied: “special attention should particularly be paid to these lineages of coronaviruses” (Ge at al., 2016).
And where might we find that "special attention"? Oh that's right, it's missing from the WIV and other Chinese databases.
 
Debunking the false claim the miners had a fungal infection was just debunked in more than one source. You go and read the original lie and ask for evidence it was a lie? :confused: Seriously?

Here we go again:
Independent Science News: Virologist Dr. Jonathan Latham and geneticist Dr. Allison Wilson: A Proposed Origin for SARS-CoV-2 and the COVID-19 Pandemic

In a March 2020 interview with Scientific American Zeng-li Shi dismissed the significance of these deaths, claiming the miners died of fungal infections. Indeed, no miners or deaths are mentioned in the paper published by the Shi lab documenting the collection of RaTG13 (Ge et al., 2016).

Yes, evidence it was a lie, please. What you are doing is quote-mining. You have a paraphrasing of Zhengli Shi's words, and you are using it to do a lot of heavy lifting.

First of all, we don't know it was a lie. We don't know why the miners got pneumonia.

We don't have Zhengli Shi's exact words. By claiming she lied to Scientific American, you are suggesting she is being deliberately deceptive. Why would she do it?
 
Suit yourself.

They also cite Andersen, Fauci, Daszak, the WHO report, and Bloom.

It's a typical think tank with an academic reputation. They are not new kids on the block.

They are Koch funded climate change deniers

https://www.desmog.com/american-institute-economic-research/

and primary sponsors of the Great Barrington Declaration which proposed just letting everyone get as a way to achieve herd immunity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Barrington_Declaration

They are paid promoters of right wing pseudoscience, nothing more.
 
It's been discussed why these antibodies are to a SARS-like coronavirus and not to SARS 1.

Can you remind me what that was? Coronavirus antibodies are cross reactive so how was the assay discriminatory?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Can you remind me what that was? Coronavirus antibodies are cross reactive so how was the assay discriminatory?
Four of the miners had antibodies to SARS. But there had been no cases of SARS since 2003 and the outbreak was in Guangdong, not near the Yunnan mine the miners had been working in. It is unlikely all four would have been infected with SARS in the past.

So one can draw 2 conclusions. Either they actually had SARS in which case alarms would have gone off everywhere: SARS 1 has jumped into humans again!

Or they had a SARS-like coronavirus and the immune globulin was cross reacting.

Separate from how we know the miners had antibodies to a SARS-like coronavirus is one thing. But if that was the case then the WIV and maybe the Chinese CDC would have invested a lot of resources into investigating the coronavirus.

And the 2 theses are evidence they did. But in Dec 2019 the story changed, the specimens documented that were collected disappeared from the files and the WIV researchers claimed the miners had a fungal infection, no mention of the serologies. In addition they claimed they only had the genome fragment that was the closest match.

When confronted they admitted they had most of the whole genome since 2018 and submitted an addendum to the original research.


You can look at my other posts and the sources to see that did not answer a whole lot of questions. Starting with the specimens collected that were documented in the master's thesis that were taken to the WIV. And other specimens with a number of coronaviruses were also collected by the WIV. I'll go find the quote on that and edit it in.
OK, I think it's all there now.

From the CounterPunch document:

In their November addendum Zheng-li Shi and her colleagues at the WIV confirmed receiving thirteen serum samples–taken at approximately monthly intervals in 2012–from four of the hospitalised miners. But here there is a major discrepancy. Referring to the miner serum samples, the addendum states:
According to the master's thesis:
“In order to analyze the pathology and the cause of the disease, the Chinese Yunnan Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, other medical centers and other research labs collected samples from the patients, bats, rats and the environment. The blood samples of four cases showed that: four patients’ throat swabs and whole blood samples were negative for SARS coronavirus*, epidemic hemorrhagic fever, Dengue fever (type 1-4), epidemic encephalitis type B, flavivirus and alphavirus pathogen nucleic acid tests (Chengdu Military Region for Disease and Control). The blood samples of four of the cases, and from four other people who had been to the cave yet had no symptoms, all showed no abnormal results (Guangdong, lab of Nan Shan Zhong); The bats in the mine were dissected, and bat feces were tested, and no abnormality was found (Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences)……Half a year later, the Jin Qi lab went to the same cave to collect samples from bats and wild rats and tested for pathogens.”
The negative serum tests were for IgM. Later tests for IgG were positive. IgM is first to develop (we use it to determine if an infection is acute) and IgG develops shortly thereafter (we use that to see past or ongoing infection).

... the first SARS outbreak in 2002. Hence, top virology labs in China, such as those of George Gao, Zhong Nanshan, Zheng-li Shi and Qi Jin became involved in investigating the outbreak.

We are nevertheless left with a mystery, which the Canping Huang thesis deepens considerably. Why, given this strong interest, were only two quite minor scientific papers ever published that mentioned the mine, of which only one mentioned the outbreak (Wu et al., 2014; Ge et al., 2016)? Especially since no alternative cause for the outbreak was found. ...

There are strong signs that plenty of this emerging infectious coronavirus research remains unpublished, even those parts that are highly connected to the origins of the pandemic. For example, Chapter 3. of Canping Huang’s thesis was never published or otherwise made available. Though he identified two Alphacoronaviruses in the Mojiang mine and obtained partial genome sequences, he did not show them. They are not in the thesis itself nor does he seem to have deposited them in any public database.

A key example is that Zheng-li Shi also possesses unpublished coronavirus genomes from the mine. These include at least eight other very closely related Betacoronaviruses that she has featured in several recent oral presentations and for which she has at least partial genome sequences.
See the specifics in the link: A Chinese PhD Thesis Sheds Important New Light On The Origin of the COVID-19 Coronavirus

These genomes, if published, would approximately double the number of published genomes in the SARS-CoV-2 phylogenetic clade, which is the phylogenetic group containing all the closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2. The information contained in these genomes would doubtless be extremely valuable for understanding the ancestry of SARS-CoV-2. It is therefore remarkable that they remain unpublished over a year after the Wuhan outbreak.

Among other questions:
By the same token, if a coronavirus was found in the 2012 miners’ samples it would surely also mean that subsequent research, presumably at the WIV, has been concealed.


Now we get to the doctorate thesis:
Its English title is “Novel Virus Discovery in Bat and the Exploration of Receptor of Bat Coronavirus HKU9”.
The author of this thesis is Canping Huang, who was a student of Gao Fu. Gao Fu is an important virologist known in the West as George Gao. In 2017 he was appointed head of China’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention, China’s CDC.

The direct relevance of the Canping Huang thesis, however, is that the author is one of relatively few researchers documented to have sampled the Mojiang mine for bat viruses.
Chapter 3 titled: Initial investigation of the causes of unexplained severe pneumonia incidents related to an abandoned mining cave found in Mojiang Hani Autonomous County, Yunnan Province.

The Canping Huang thesis substantiates several aspects of the Mojiang Miners Passage theory. But perhaps the most significant of all its statements is that samples from four of the miners were tested at the WIV for IgG antibodies against the SARS virus. According to the PhD (see Fig. 3), all samples were positive. (This test is distinct from the IgM test mentioned in the Master’s thesis).
 
Last edited:
Thanks for taking the time to reply. So the miners are antibody positive for a coronavirus which they could have caught before they went to the mine. The IgM negative result shows that they weren’t infected within a month or so and why there was no focus on a coronavirus infection.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom