Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I take it you didn't read the actual article and/or didn't look at what was in the PhD thesis?Review referenced above points out.
So
Is not a good explanation as RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses are not the closest ancestor of SARS-CoV-2. Which this explanation would require. Secondly it requires this virus to have been sampled and sent in a viable state to WIV, and then escaped, and infected laboratory workers, then onward spread. When there is no evidence of 1)a similar virus causing infection in mineworkers 2) a similar virus being present at WIV, 3) WIV staff being infected early. Even if you wanted to go with the mineworker infection, it would be simpler to assume the worker, or someone infected by the worker, directly carried it to Wuhan without requiring the laboratory as an intermediate. We have seen this carriage with e.g. MERS. The Korean outbreak did not require MERS to have escaped from a laboratory in Korea.
The evidence does not favour this particular theory as the most likely (or indeed possible) explanation.
Because if you had, you would know the WIV had the whole genome the segment came from, that there were documented specimens collected by the WIV that they have not admitted to, that the segment is not supposed to be from a part of the COVID-19 but that other specimens the WIV has might be.
If you want to look at the issue honestly, don't be so quick to dismiss a paper that discusses work done pre-pandemic which is missing from the WIV now.