Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Review referenced above points out.

So

Is not a good explanation as RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses are not the closest ancestor of SARS-CoV-2. Which this explanation would require. Secondly it requires this virus to have been sampled and sent in a viable state to WIV, and then escaped, and infected laboratory workers, then onward spread. When there is no evidence of 1)a similar virus causing infection in mineworkers 2) a similar virus being present at WIV, 3) WIV staff being infected early. Even if you wanted to go with the mineworker infection, it would be simpler to assume the worker, or someone infected by the worker, directly carried it to Wuhan without requiring the laboratory as an intermediate. We have seen this carriage with e.g. MERS. The Korean outbreak did not require MERS to have escaped from a laboratory in Korea.

The evidence does not favour this particular theory as the most likely (or indeed possible) explanation.
I take it you didn't read the actual article and/or didn't look at what was in the PhD thesis?

Because if you had, you would know the WIV had the whole genome the segment came from, that there were documented specimens collected by the WIV that they have not admitted to, that the segment is not supposed to be from a part of the COVID-19 but that other specimens the WIV has might be.

If you want to look at the issue honestly, don't be so quick to dismiss a paper that discusses work done pre-pandemic which is missing from the WIV now.
 
Review referenced above points out.

So

Is not a good explanation as RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses are not the closest ancestor of SARS-CoV-2. Which this explanation would require. Secondly it requires this virus to have been sampled and sent in a viable state to WIV, and then escaped, and infected laboratory workers, then onward spread. When there is no evidence of 1)a similar virus causing infection in mineworkers 2) a similar virus being present at WIV, 3) WIV staff being infected early. Even if you wanted to go with the mineworker infection, it would be simpler to assume the worker, or someone infected by the worker, directly carried it to Wuhan without requiring the laboratory as an intermediate. We have seen this carriage with e.g. MERS. The Korean outbreak did not require MERS to have escaped from a laboratory in Korea.

The evidence does not favour this particular theory as the most likely (or indeed possible) explanation.
The proposed hypothesis wasn't all that was in that paper.

You can cite all the natural zoonoses you want to. It doesn't negate the number and type of lab accidents, including the accidents at the WIV itself (documented in the thread), and it doesn't negate the fact there is more than just a little evidence for the lab accident and very little for a natural spillover incident.


From the CounterPunch source:
... Moreover, these early RaTG13 sequences went far beyond a short fragment, encompassing most of the genome (Rahalkar and Bahulikar, 2020a)...

Thus the RaTG13 genome sequence was mostly deciphered in 2018 and not in January 2020. Ergo, the viral genome most similar to SARS-CoV-2 was being studied at the WIV before the pandemic broke out.

But why hide this activity? ...

It turned out that RaTG13 was an exact genetic match to an already published partial virus sequence called BtCoV/4991. BtCoV/4991 had been obtained by Zheng-li Shi’s group in 2013 from a mine in Yunnan Province, China (Ge et al., 2016).

Furthermore, RaTG13 and BtCoV/4991 were from the same bat anal swab sample. In other words, from the data provided, the two were indistinguishable. Thus, RaTG13 did have a publishing history, but under the name BtCoV/4991 (Bengston, 2020).
Why pretend it was uncovered in the files in 2020 when it was discussed in a paper in 2018 and studied in 2013? How would this be forgotten given the patients sick in 2012 had a SARS-like coronavirus? See the information about the serologies tested showing the miners had antibodies to SARS. And given had that been a novel SARS outbreak it would have been well publicized. So the assumption is the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus. (There is other evidence about what the miners had.)

Why did Zheng-li Shi tell Scientific American in March 2020 that the miners died of a fungal infection? Why did her Zhou et al. 2020 publication rename BtCov/4991 as RaTG13 without explanation or even referencing the earlier work on BtCov/4991 or its mine origin? Especially, given that Zheng-li Shi and her corona-colleagues in China and elsewhere have constantly warned of coronavirus spillovers from bats (e.g. Zhou et al., 2018),


From the PhD thesis:
The author of this thesis is Canping Huang, who was a student of Gao Fu. Gao Fu is an important virologist known in the West as George Gao. In 2017 he was appointed head of China’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention, China’s CDC.

The direct relevance of the Canping Huang thesis, however, is that the author is one of relatively few researchers documented to have sampled the Mojiang mine for bat viruses.

Re the illness the miners had and that the WIV knew it:
The Canping Huang [PhD] thesis substantiates several aspects of the Mojiang Miners Passage theory. But perhaps the most significant of all its statements is that samples from four of the miners were tested at the WIV for IgG antibodies against the SARS virus. According to the PhD (see Fig. 3), all samples were positive. ...

It is highly unlikely, however, that the miners had SARS itself, since the SARS virus had not been observed since 2003. Moreover, the original SARS outbreak was in Guangdong province, far from the Mojiang mine. Thus, the miners presumably were infected with a virus similar, but not identical to, SARS, i.e. a novel coronavirus.
Confirmed also by the master's thesis.


To summarize that so far: there is documented evidence the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus, documented evidence the WIV researchers were studying it, and the WIV researchers denied they had been doing research on a SARS-like coronavirus to which they later partially admitted to when confronted.
 
Last edited:
...
So if anyone is wondering why virology as a field is not impressed by lab leak theories it is because it is a corrupt field and they just want cash....
This is a falsehood.

Currently more than a few top virologists (like Dr Redfield) at a minimum want the lab accident hypothesis explored further. They have been saying so publicly for a couple months now.

Newsweek: 18 Scientists, Including One Who Worked With Wuhan Lab, Say COVID Lab Leak Theory Needs Study
However, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, director-general of the WHO, said the possibility requires "further investigation" because the team didn't have access to enough raw data to adequately analyze the likelihood of any single hypothesis.

In a letter published Friday in the journal Science, 18 scientists wrote, "We must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data. Public health agencies and research laboratories alike need to open their records to the public." ...

The authors of the Science magazine letter criticized this assessment, saying it was made with "no findings in clear support" of any hypothesis. They also took issue with researchers not giving "balanced consideration" to both lab and zoonotic spillover theories....

Jamie Metzl, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and an adviser to the WHO who has long called for a full into all pandemic origin hypothesis, including a potential laboratory incident, told Newsweek in January that Trump's politicizing of the theory "frightened a lot of scientists." He said they didn't want to contribute to his perceived racism against the Chinese and his deflection of blame for the United States outbreak, so few people spoke up about a lab leak being a possibility.

"The chokehold on public consideration of an accidental lab incident as a possible pandemic origin has just been broken," Metzl told Newsweek. "Following publication of the Science letter, it will be irresponsible for any scientific journal or news outlet to not fully represent this viable hypothesis."


Harvard Scientist Says Trump Hatred Influenced Experts Who Denied Wuhan Lab Leak Theory


Atlantic OpEd: Don’t Fall for These Lab-Leak Traps
The No-Evidence Trap [Because there is evidence]

The Mad-Scientist Trap - The lab-leak theory isn’t singular; rather, it’s a catchall for a continuum of possible scenarios, ranging from the mundane to the diabolical. ...

The Culture-War Trap - Watch out for this distracting shift in tense, from the questions that remain unanswered to the questions that were never asked. ...

In this toxic framing, everyone can be a brave purveyor of dangerous truths. The virologist and lab-leak skeptic Angela Rasmussen has been threatened with violence and sexual assault; the former CDC director and lab-leak believer Robert Redfield has received death threats from fellow scientists.
Both sides are attacked in that last one.

Science News: The science around the lab leak theory hasn't changed. But here's why some scientists have.
Five virologists said few conclusions can be drawn based on the available scientific evidence, but they noted that the context and circumstances of the debate have changed. ...

Alina Chan isn't saying the coronavirus definitely leaked from a lab in China. What she is saying is what more scientists have grown comfortable discussing publicly: There's no clear evidence either way.

"I know a lot of people want to have a smoking gun," said Chan, a postdoctoral associate at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard University who specializes in genetic engineering and has been vocal about the need to investigate the possibility of a lab leak. "It's more like breadcrumbs everywhere, and they're not always leading in one direction. It's like the whole floor is covered in breadcrumbs."
Not the consensus you claim there is.
 
Last edited:
The proposed hypothesis wasn't all that was in that paper.

You can cite all the natural zoonoses you want to. It doesn't negate the number and type of lab accidents, including the accidents at the WIV itself (documented in the thread), and it doesn't negate the fact there is more than just a little evidence for the lab accident and very little for a natural spillover incident.


From the CounterPunch source:
Why pretend it was uncovered in the files in 2020 when it was discussed in a paper in 2018 and studied in 2013? How would this be forgotten given the patients sick in 2012 had a SARS-like coronavirus? See the information about the serologies tested showing the miners had antibodies to SARS. And given had that been a novel SARS outbreak it would have been well publicized. So the assumption is the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus. (There is other evidence about what the miners had.)




From the PhD thesis:

Re the illness the miners had and that the WIV knew it:Confirmed also by the master's thesis.


To summarize that so far: there is documented evidence the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus, documented evidence the WIV researchers were studying it, and the WIV researchers denied they had been doing research on a SARS-like coronavirus to which they later partially admitted to when confronted.


Did they get a sequence of the virus from the miners?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The proposed hypothesis wasn't all that was in that paper.

You can cite all the natural zoonoses you want to. It doesn't negate the number and type of lab accidents, including the accidents at the WIV itself (documented in the thread), and it doesn't negate the fact there is more than just a little evidence for the lab accident and very little for a natural spillover incident.


From the CounterPunch source:
Why pretend it was uncovered in the files in 2020 when it was discussed in a paper in 2018 and studied in 2013? How would this be forgotten given the patients sick in 2012 had a SARS-like coronavirus? See the information about the serologies tested showing the miners had antibodies to SARS. And given had that been a novel SARS outbreak it would have been well publicized. So the assumption is the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus. (There is other evidence about what the miners had.)




From the PhD thesis:

Re the illness the miners had and that the WIV knew it:Confirmed also by the master's thesis.


To summarize that so far: there is documented evidence the miners had a SARS-like coronavirus, documented evidence the WIV researchers were studying it, and the WIV researchers denied they had been doing research on a SARS-like coronavirus to which they later partially admitted to when confronted.

FWIW I had a look at the (translated) Master's thesis. It is about the level I would expect from a medical student. The differential is poor and poorly explored. The commonest cause of an outbreak like this from people exposed to bat guano is a fungal infection (Histoplasmosis). The story is pretty typical including the timing after exposure which would be long for a viral infection. None of the CXR or CT show appearances of COVID-19 infection. They did not diagnose a viral infection, but correctly considered a viral infection needed to be considered.Unfortunately there was no post mortem or biopsy done. The original SARS-CoV-2 was diagnosed because of the finding of a coronavirus on electron microscopy of lung tissue. This was followed up with DNA studies. SARS-CoV-2 was not found in the mine. The IgM will be pretty non specific, reacting to a range of coronaviruses. No one looked for legionella! The PhD thesis does not really address the diagnosis either. It is focussed on viruses from the wild and I cannot find any clear study of clinical samples.

The PhD thesis just references that IgG levels were done for SARS. We have no idea of the titre, specificity, timing etc. The author repeatedly says the cause of the pneumonia in the miners is unexplained. They certainly did not attribute it to SARS. It is quite possible that either the Master's or the PhD thesis made an error and there was only IgG or only IgM levels done. More likely the former.

The radiology of COVID-19 is very characteristic, none of the miners showed radiology typical of COVID-19. The nodular changes are more typical for histoplasmosis.

Maybe in the next ten years we will find the original animal virus. But what we can be pretty sure about is that it did not originate from a bat coronavirus that had been isolated from that mine and kept in WIV. None of the identified viruses could have evolved in to SARS-CoV-2. The problem is it will be impossible to ever prove to some peoples satisfaction that the virus did not come from WIV. Because you are trying to prove a negative.

Outbreaks of infections are common, most cases of pneumonia have no identified cause. Why you expect anyone to remember about a trivial bit of research from years before far away when they are dealing with an immediately present new virus is unclear.
 
Did they get a sequence of the virus from the miners?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No sequence. No EM. Too little information about the Immunology to interpret. indeed all the laboratory investigation is reported in a pretty shoddy way. for a clinical thesis on the investigation of an outbreak of an unknown pneumonia, one would expect a more thorough report on investigations. How was blood cultured? How was sputum cultured (sputum is uncommon in COVID-19 but reported in these cases). Was a legionella Ag done, what about cultures for fungi, immunology for fungi? Personally i would have sent this back with a large amount of red ink to be written with a more thorough review.
 
There seems to be a fairly contemporary report on the Mojiang mine and interestingly, just as the screenshot of the thesis said, no clear evidence of what caused the pneumonia was found. Apparently the miners died before the infectious disease scientists turned up and the scientists expedition into the mine where viruses were detected occurred long after the miners’ deaths, and the virus that the scientists were most concerned about was a virus similar to Nipah virus, related to Hendra. (By the way, the interview between Rachaniello and Daszak that is often brought up by lab leakers was at a conference about Nipah virus). Therefore the idea that the virus similar to SARS-CoV2 was the one that most raised their eyebrows is false and is a post-hoc interpretation.

Look at this!

In June 2012, three men removing slag from a derelict copper mine in southwestern China fell ill with severe pneumonia and died. Six months later, researchers went spelunking in the mine—an artificial cave hewn from a hillside—in search of pathogens. After taking anal swabs from bats, rats, and musk shrews living in the cave, the team has discovered what it says is a new virus that may have felled the workers.

The presumed pathogen resembles a genus of viruses known as henipaviruses, two of which are deadly: Hendra virus, discovered 20 years ago in Australia when it started killing horses—since then, four people who came in contact with infected horses have died—and Nipah virus, the cause of periodic outbreaks in people in Southeast Asia since 1998

Notice that the title is a question, and it goes on to say that the miners were dead before a virus could be isolated from them…

The three victims in Yunnan succumbed long before scientists arrived on the scene, so “we have not established a direct relationship between human infection and MojV,”

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2014/03/new-killer-virus-china
 
The nipah conference was early December 2019. I attended it and none of the delegates had even heard of COVID then.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
So that pretty much conclusively dispenses with that cynical Counterpunch article.

I wonder what new theory Skeptic Ginger will discover next?
 
FWIW I had a look at the (translated) Master's thesis. It is about the level I would expect from a medical student. The differential is poor and poorly explored. The commonest cause of an outbreak like this from people exposed to bat guano is a fungal infection (Histoplasmosis). The story is pretty typical including the timing after exposure which would be long for a viral infection. None of the CXR or CT show appearances of COVID-19 infection. They did not diagnose a viral infection, but correctly considered a viral infection needed to be considered.Unfortunately there was no post mortem or biopsy done. The original SARS-CoV-2 was diagnosed because of the finding of a coronavirus on electron microscopy of lung tissue. This was followed up with DNA studies. SARS-CoV-2 was not found in the mine. The IgM will be pretty non specific, reacting to a range of coronaviruses. No one looked for legionella! The PhD thesis does not really address the diagnosis either. It is focussed on viruses from the wild and I cannot find any clear study of clinical samples.

The PhD thesis just references that IgG levels were done for SARS. We have no idea of the titre, specificity, timing etc. The author repeatedly says the cause of the pneumonia in the miners is unexplained. They certainly did not attribute it to SARS. It is quite possible that either the Master's or the PhD thesis made an error and there was only IgG or only IgM levels done. More likely the former.

The radiology of COVID-19 is very characteristic, none of the miners showed radiology typical of COVID-19. The nodular changes are more typical for histoplasmosis.

Maybe in the next ten years we will find the original animal virus. But what we can be pretty sure about is that it did not originate from a bat coronavirus that had been isolated from that mine and kept in WIV. None of the identified viruses could have evolved in to SARS-CoV-2. The problem is it will be impossible to ever prove to some peoples satisfaction that the virus did not come from WIV. Because you are trying to prove a negative.

Outbreaks of infections are common, most cases of pneumonia have no identified cause. Why you expect anyone to remember about a trivial bit of research from years before far away when they are dealing with an immediately present new virus is unclear.
The master's thesis isn't new to this thread, I've posted links to it and discussions about it upthread.

You can dismiss the master's thesis like it is a term paper or something but here's one issue:
This began with the fact that the author of the thesis was the doctor who supervised the testing and treatment of the miners at the First Affiliated hospital of Kunming Medical University (Yunnan Province).

Re the rest of the genome, that has been known for a while once the WIV admitted to having it.

Full-genome evolutionary analysis of the novel corona virus (2019-nCoV) rejects the hypothesis of emergence as a result of a recent recombination event
The levels of genetic similarity between the 2019-nCoV and RaTG13 suggest that the latter does not provide the exact variant that caused the outbreak in humans, but the hypothesis that 2019-nCoV has originated from bats is very likely.

I do not believe the authors of the CounterPunch article said that was the direct ancestor of COVID 19. What they said was there are specimens from the miners that the WIV has not been forthcoming about.


Starting with the addendum that was submitted to Nature, what was admitted to when confronted with the evidence:
In November 2020 Nature published an addendum to Zhou et al. in which Zheng-li Shi and her co-authors conceded these points. They wrote:

“In 2018…..we performed further sequencing of these bat viruses and obtained almost the full-length genome sequence (without the 5′ and 3′ ends) of RaTG13.”

Thus the RaTG13 genome sequence was mostly deciphered in 2018 and not in January 2020. Ergo, the viral genome most similar to SARS-CoV-2 was being studied at the WIV before the pandemic broke out.

The Master’s thesis thus raised a host of questions. Why did the Ge et al. 2016 publication (from Zheng-li Shi’s lab), which sampled the mine on multiple occasions, make no mention of the outbreak that caused them to be sampling there in the first place? Why did Zheng-li Shi tell Scientific American in March 2020 that the miners died of a fungal infection? Why did her Zhou et al. 2020 publication rename BtCov/4991 as RaTG13 without explanation or even referencing the earlier work on BtCov/4991 or its mine origin? Especially, given that Zheng-li Shi and her corona-colleagues in China and elsewhere have constantly warned of coronavirus spillovers from bats (e.g. Zhou et al., 2018), why did no one seemingly prove or disprove the coronavirus theory in the Master’s thesis? Are we to presume that an apparent textbook case of a zoonotic spillover, significant enough at the time to be covered by Science magazine, was in the end simply ignored? ...

In their November addendum Zheng-li Shi and her colleagues at the WIV confirmed receiving thirteen serum samples–taken at approximately monthly intervals in 2012–from four of the hospitalised miners. But here there is a major discrepancy. Referring to the miner serum samples, the addendum states:

“To investigate the cause of the respiratory disease, we tested the samples using PCR methods developed in our laboratory targeting the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases of Ebola virus, Nipah virus and bat SARSr-CoVRp3, and all the samples tested negative for these viruses. We also tested the serum samples for the presence of antibodies against the nucleocapsid proteins of these three viruses, and none of the samples gave a positive result. Recently, we retested the samples with our validated enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) against the SARS coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) nucleocapsid protein–which has greater than 90% amino acid sequence identity with SARSr-CoVRp3–and confirmed that these patients were not infected by SARS-CoV-2.” (Zhou et al., 2020, addendum)

The implication is that, though various tests were performed at the WIV, SARS-CoV-2 was not found and no evidence for any other coronavirus was found either.

This obviously contradicts the Master’s thesis.



The PhD thesis is new.

The Canping Huang thesis substantiates several aspects of the Mojiang Miners Passage theory. But perhaps the most significant of all its statements is that samples from four of the miners were tested at the WIV for IgG antibodies against the SARS virus. According to the PhD (see Fig. 3), all samples were positive. (This test is distinct from the IgM test mentioned in the Master’s thesis). ...

The addendum asserts the results of three tests but their methods are not fully described, nor are the materials and reagents. The results, including controls, are also not shown. Importantly too, the eight similar viruses mentioned as being found along with RaTG13/4991 are neither referenced nor specified by name, even though their genomes may be crucial for tracing the pandemic’s origins. It is unscientific and ultimately somewhat ridiculous for Nature to publish an addendum making controversial, claims that are crucial to understanding the origin of a global pandemic costing millions of lives, but make meaningful independent scrutiny of those claims impossible.


The specimens are still there at the WIV:
We know too that the miners’ samples are apparently not depleted since the addendum claims to have ‘retested’ them ‘Recently’.
In the final analysis this situation is ultimately quite simple: three sources (the Master’s thesis, Canping Huang’s PhD and George Gao) clearly and credibly contradict the implication of the addendum on the key question of whether a coronavirus was detected in the miners’ serum samples.
 
Last edited:
No sequence. No EM. Too little information about the Immunology to interpret. indeed all the laboratory investigation is reported in a pretty shoddy way. for a clinical thesis on the investigation of an outbreak of an unknown pneumonia, one would expect a more thorough report on investigations. How was blood cultured? How was sputum cultured (sputum is uncommon in COVID-19 but reported in these cases). Was a legionella Ag done, what about cultures for fungi, immunology for fungi? Personally i would have sent this back with a large amount of red ink to be written with a more thorough review.
They have specimens from the miners. Any evidence these had sequenced viral genomes is absent from the record when it should be there. There should still be said specimens left, no mention of what happened to these specimens is mentioned.
 
The nipah conference was early December 2019. I attended it and none of the delegates had even heard of COVID then.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
No, and no one said they had. In the Daszak interview he discusses the work they were doing and it is clear he didn't yet know about the early pandemic cases. He discussed GoF research, IIRC, and later the WIV said they weren't doing any GoF research recently.
 
So that pretty much conclusively dispenses with that cynical Counterpunch article.

I wonder what new theory Skeptic Ginger will discover next?

That's absurd. Go back and look at what Daszak said in his interview at the conference and what was posted about that interview. If Daszak knew about the early cases he wouldn't have said the incriminating things about GoF research he said.
 
Last edited:
There seems to be a fairly contemporary report on the Mojiang mine and interestingly, just as the screenshot of the thesis said, no clear evidence of what caused the pneumonia was found. Apparently the miners died before the infectious disease scientists turned up and the scientists expedition into the mine where viruses were detected occurred long after the miners’ deaths, and the virus that the scientists were most concerned about was a virus similar to Nipah virus, related to Hendra. (By the way, the interview between Rachaniello and Daszak that is often brought up by lab leakers was at a conference about Nipah virus). Therefore the idea that the virus similar to SARS-CoV2 was the one that most raised their eyebrows is false and is a post-hoc interpretation.

Look at this!

Notice that the title is a question, and it goes on to say that the miners were dead before a virus could be isolated from them…

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2014/03/new-killer-virus-china
You are off base again. It gets tiring to keep up with your posts that don't address the evidence.


There were tissue specimens taken from the miners. There was serum collected from the miners. Collection of these specimens is described in the master's thesis. Lots of specimens were collected.

As for dying before they were seen, nonsense, the master's thesis was written by the physician who treated the miners.

The WIV researchers have tried to claim the miners had a fungal disease among other falsehoods.
 
You are off base again. It gets tiring to keep up with your posts that don't address the evidence.


There were tissue specimens taken from the miners. There was serum collected from the miners. Collection of these specimens is described in the master's thesis. Lots of specimens were collected.

As for dying before they were seen, nonsense, the master's thesis was written by the physician who treated the miners.

The WIV researchers have tried to claim the miners had a fungal disease among other falsehoods.

Why does that Science article from 2014 contradict your claims?

The viruses were collected later.
The virus that the scientists were most concerned about was a Nipah-like virus.
There was no connection found between the virus and the miners.

Did Zhengli Shi get in a time machine and dictate that article to throw people off the scent?
 
Link to the Daszak interview again.

This interview that was just days before the start of the coronavirus pandemic shows a current World Health Organization (WHO) inspector, who also runs EcoHealth Alliance, discuss the testing of modified coronaviruses on human cells and humanized mice in the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV), just weeks before the first cases of COVID-19 were announced in the city of Wuhan itself.

Originally taken on Dec. 9, 2019, three weeks before the Wuhan Municipal Health Commission announced an outbreak of a new form of pneumonia, virologist Vincent Racaniello interviewed British zoologist and president of EcoHealth Alliance Peter Daszak about his work at the nonprofit to protect the world from the emergence of new diseases and predict pandemics.

The second, more dangerous phase, which started in 2019, involved gain-of-function (GoF) research on coronaviruses and chimeras in humanized mice from the lab of Ralph S. Baric of the University of North Carolina. Funding for the program was withdrawn by the NIH under the Trump administration on April 27 amid the pandemic.


At the 28:10 mark of the podcast interview, Daszak states that researchers found that SARS likely originated from bats and then set out to find more SARS-related coronaviruses, eventually finding over 100. He observed that some coronaviruses can “get into human cells in the lab,” and others can cause SARS disease in “humanized mouse models.”

He ominously warned that such coronaviruses are “untreatable with therapeutic monoclonals [antibodies] and you can’t vaccinate against them with a vaccine.” Ironically, he claims that his team’s goal was trying to find the next “spillover event” that could cause the next pandemic, mere weeks before cases of COVID-19 were beginning to be reported in Wuhan.

When Racaniello asks what can be done to deal with coronavirus given that there is no vaccine or therapeutic for them, Daszak at the 29:54 mark appears to reveal that the goal of the GoF experiments was to develop a pan-coronavirus vaccine for many different types of coronaviruses.

The key takeaway:
Based on his response, it is evident that just before the start of the pandemic, the WIV was modifying coronaviruses in the lab. “You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily.” What he then mentioned has become the telltale trait of SARS-CoV-2, its spike protein: “Spike protein drives a lot of what happens with the coronavirus, zoonotic risk.”
 
He admitted they were currently doing GoF research. Later that was denied.

Please quote the relevant passages of the interview.

Besides in the interview he was talking about research being done in Baric’s lab. That is in the US. It was no secret what was being done in that lab and the research that he had been doing with Zhengli Shi was no secret either given that they had published papers on the research.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom