Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
*sigh* I already mentioned that Bloom’s paper is not evidence of lab leak or spillover.

I’m not “cherry-picking”; the problem is that when responding to your Gish Gallops,...
Posting extensive well sourced papers is not gish-galloping. :rolleyes:

Bloom found evidence of things covered up that Capsid's review paper failed to mention. That was the context I brought his work up in. I didn't post it as proof of a lab origin.

The paper I just cited had much much more.

American Institute for Economic Research: The Origin of SARS-CoV-2
Denouncing the Lab Leak Theory
Covid-19 raises important considerations about truth and trust. While the genesis of Covid-19 is still shrouded in mystery, a lack of certainty didn’t stop prominent people and organizations from stating at an early date that any suggestion that SARS-CoV-2 was manipulated in a lab was not true,[8] misinformation,[9] a conjecture,[10] a conspiracy,[11] [12] false information,[13] implausible,[14] something out of a comic book,[15] extremely unlikely,[16] or already debunked,[17] and had been repeatedly disproven.[18]

Why were these people so dismissive of the lab leak theory? Were their statements based on a reasoned assessment of the data or the desire to steer public opinion toward a favored conclusion?

Some who made these claims, such as Anthony Fauci, have since backtracked and admitted that the lab leak theory has merit. Further, we now know that other prominent denouncers had privately presented evidence supporting the lab leak theory or had serious conflicts of interest due to their work with the Chinese lab in question.

Andersen was clear which side of the fence he was on yet when the Fauci emails came to light there was this:
Yet just a couple of months earlier, Andersen had emailed Fauci to report that the virus had “unusual features” that looked “potentially engineered.” He explained that he and his team “all find the genome inconsistent with expectations from evolutionary theory.”


And my POV is not isolated.
According to Xiao Qiang, a research scientist at Berkeley: “To understand exactly how this virus has originated is critical knowledge for preventing this from happening in the future.”[26] Based on what we know, the lab leak theory better fits the evidence.

One would think that all the information not being disclosed would be beneficial in supporting the zoonosis spillover. And yes there is clear evidence that a lot of the work at the WIV and elsewhere in China is there but unavailable to outsiders. I have posted extensive sources for that claim.
 
Posting extensive well sourced papers is not gish-galloping. :rolleyes:

Bloom found evidence of things covered up that Capsid's review paper failed to mention. That was the context I brought his work up in. I didn't post it as proof of a lab origin.

The paper I just cited had much much more.

American Institute for Economic Research: The Origin of SARS-CoV-2

Andersen was clear which side of the fence he was on yet when the Fauci emails came to light there was this:


And my POV is not isolated.

One would think that all the information not being disclosed would be beneficial in supporting the zoonosis spillover. And yes there is clear evidence that a lot of the work at the WIV and elsewhere in China is there but unavailable to outsiders. I have posted extensive sources for that claim.

American Institute for Economic Research? Sounds legit. Written by a guy from the Hoover Institute because … of course. Looks like he is rehashing Quay, Deigin, and Segreto.

I think I’ll pass…
 
I'll see that crap TA and raise you one. There's a lot in this paper, it's quite thorough and well sourced, but I want to draw people's attention to a few things.

JUNE 4, 2021
A Chinese PhD Thesis Sheds Important New Light On The Origin of the COVID-19 Coronavirus
[Note a PhD thesis is peer reviewed.]The history of collecting and studying the viral genome is described. It was collected in the Yunnan mine where the 6 miners were infected back in 2013.



The Chinese master's thesis from that time period is reviewed. I posted a link to that earlier but there's another one in this paper.




One proposed hypothesis:


Deception:I'll let people read the addendum for themselves. Here is the implication:


There is another relevant Chinese thesis, this one for a doctorate:The Seeker is part of DRASTIC. A translation of the thesis is in this paper.

A discussion of the antibody testing of 4 of the miners found they had antibodies to SARS but since SARS had not been around since 2003, the antibodies represented a related virus infection had caused the pneumonia. Had those miners actually had SARS in 2012 it would have been a new outbreak and would have been in the headlines at the time.




Multiple visits to the mines and what and where specimens were collected and taken is discussed in detail including citations.

More deceit: Lots of missing data and the data taken offline are discussed in detail.

Congress has sent a letter to Daszak asking him to provide a lot of data he was clearly working on and asking him why he has tried to cover up anything related to a lab origin.




More to follow. :popcorn1

What’s the tl;dr on this?

Is it that they found a bunch of viruses in the mineshaft with RaTG13 and that one of the OTHER ones was SARS-CoV2?
 
What’s the tl;dr on this?

Is it that they found a bunch of viruses in the mineshaft with RaTG13 and that one of the OTHER ones was SARS-CoV2?
No, that is not what the paper says, not even close. It meticulously documents work that includes documenting specimens in the WIV files they were not forthcoming about including almost the full genome the RaTG13 'segment' is from. And when confronted with the evidence the WIV researcher only partially corrected the record.

The authors also point out the illness that the 6 miners were infected with was covered up claiming it was a fungal infection. The PhD thesis about the men's illness confirms they had a coronavirus and it includes the fact the WIV as well as multiple other labs in China have specimens from these patients which still has not been disclosed. The authors point out that it is ludicrous to think given the men had antibodies against something similar to SARS that that would not have set off extensive research about what they had.

The information was found in the published PhD thesis as well as in the earlier master's thesis that has been cited. You can try to erase the trail, but there are still leaks out there.



Re Quay's paper having no 'abstract', there is an Executive Summary. I've found more than a few researchers referring to his work. The ES addresses how he assigned probabilities:
The starting probability for origin of SARS-CoV-2 was set with the zoonotic or natural hypothesis at 98.8% likelihood with the laboratory origin hypothesis set at 1.2%. The initial state was biased as much as possible towards a zoonotic origin, with the starting point selected as the upper bounds of the 95% confidence interval for the mean and standard deviation of three independent estimates, including one by Daszak and colleagues. Each piece of new evidence for or against each hypothesis was then used to adjust the probabilities. If evidence favored a natural origin the math adjusts upward the probability of a natural origin, and so on.



It's interesting that despite the evidence of Daszak's conflict of interest and influence on the Lancet article, they've put out an update this month standing by their earlier piece because they stand by the researchers whose names are being besmirched. It's a real kumbaya moment. Given they are stressing the science I find it ironic.

Science, not speculation, is essential to determine how SARS-CoV-2 reached humans
Recently, many of us have individually received inquiries asking whether we still support what we said in early 2020.1 The answer is clear: we reaffirm our expression of solidarity with those in China who confronted the outbreak then, and the many health professionals around the world who have since worked to exhaustion, and at personal risk, in the relentless and continuing battle against this virus. Our respect and gratitude have only grown with time.



And I see the BBC has an article referring to the paper Capsid posted. I would love to send them my review of the review but instead I'll wait and see how others respond. They do note
They have published what is called a pre-print, meaning it has not yet been reviewed and edited by other experts.
Funny how that peer review doesn't matter when one is reporting on the natural spillover but it matters when a paper supports the lab accident.



So we have a fair amount of heel digging-in which includes ignoring Daszak's conflict of interest and influence slanting the WHO report, and, a fair bit of new information supporting the lab accident.
 
Last edited:
American Institute for Economic Research? Sounds legit. Written by a guy from the Hoover Institute because … of course. Looks like he is rehashing Quay, Deigin, and Segreto.

I think I’ll pass…
Suit yourself.

They also cite Andersen, Fauci, Daszak, the WHO report, and Bloom.

It's a typical think tank with an academic reputation. They are not new kids on the block.
 
Suit yourself.

They also cite Andersen, Fauci, Daszak, the WHO report, and Bloom.

It's a typical think tank with an academic reputation. They are not new kids on the block.

It’s a think tank that minimizes climate change and was behind the Great Barrington declaration that called for herd immunity and an end to social distancing and Covid mitigation strategies.
 
No, that is not what the paper says, not even close. It meticulously documents work that includes documenting specimens in the WIV files they were not forthcoming about including almost the full genome the RaTG13 'segment' is from. And when confronted with the evidence the WIV researcher only partially corrected the record.

The authors also point out the illness that the 6 miners were infected with was covered up claiming it was a fungal infection. The PhD thesis about the men's illness confirms they had a coronavirus and it includes the fact the WIV as well as multiple other labs in China have specimens from these patients which still has not been disclosed. The authors point out that it is ludicrous to think given the men had antibodies against something similar to SARS that that would not have set off extensive research about what they had.

The information was found in the published PhD thesis as well as in the earlier master's thesis that has been cited. You can try to erase the trail, but there are still leaks out there.



Re Quay's paper having no 'abstract', there is an Executive Summary. I've found more than a few researchers referring to his work. The ES addresses how he assigned probabilities:



It's interesting that despite the evidence of Daszak's conflict of interest and influence on the Lancet article, they've put out an update this month standing by their earlier piece because they stand by the researchers whose names are being besmirched. It's a real kumbaya moment. Given they are stressing the science I find it ironic.

Science, not speculation, is essential to determine how SARS-CoV-2 reached humans



And I see the BBC has an article referring to the paper Capsid posted. I would love to send them my review of the review but instead I'll wait and see how others respond. They do note Funny how that peer review doesn't matter when one is reporting on the natural spillover but it matters when a paper supports the lab accident.



So we have a fair amount of heel digging-in which includes ignoring Daszak's conflict of interest and influence slanting the WHO report, and, a fair bit of new information supporting the lab accident.

Okay, thanks. Well, I will look into it a bit more. My understanding regarding the death of the miners is that it is not exactly clear how they died and that it may have been through fungal infection. I haven’t really looked closely at that. I noticed that there was recently a big argument between a virologist called Steve Neil (I think) and Rosa Segreto on some very long Twitter thread. As with many of these discussions it is not always clear what the disputes are about and how they started.

That said, I take it that nobody is any longer making a claim that RaTG13 was manipulated to become SARS-CoV2.
 
What’s the tl;dr on this?

Is it that they found a bunch of viruses in the mineshaft with RaTG13 and that one of the OTHER ones was SARS-CoV2?

No, that is not what the paper says, not even close.

It is actually very close.

What we proposed, in short, is that the miners contracted one, or maybe multiple, RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses in the mine. The long hospitalization of the miners enabled the initial bat virus to evolve into a human coronavirus by providing conditions similar to extended viral passaging. The diagnostic samples sent to the WIV therefore contained a humanised virus and we proposed it was similar, or even identical, to SARS-CoV-2.
 
Review referenced above points out.

Although Rhinolophusbat virus RaTG13 collected in Yunnan has the highest average genetic similarity to SARS-CoV-2, a history of recombination means that three other bat viruses –RmYN02, RpYN06 and PrC31 –are closer in most of the virus genome (particularly ORF1ab) and thus share amore recent common ancestor with SARS-CoV-2

So
What we proposed, in short, is that the miners contracted one, or maybe multiple, RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses in the mine. The long hospitalization of the miners enabled the initial bat virus to evolve into a human coronavirus by providing conditions similar to extended viral passaging. The diagnostic samples sent to the WIV therefore contained a humanised virus and we proposed it was similar, or even identical, to SARS-CoV-2.

Is not a good explanation as RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses are not the closest ancestor of SARS-CoV-2. Which this explanation would require. Secondly it requires this virus to have been sampled and sent in a viable state to WIV, and then escaped, and infected laboratory workers, then onward spread. When there is no evidence of 1)a similar virus causing infection in mineworkers 2) a similar virus being present at WIV, 3) WIV staff being infected early. Even if you wanted to go with the mineworker infection, it would be simpler to assume the worker, or someone infected by the worker, directly carried it to Wuhan without requiring the laboratory as an intermediate. We have seen this carriage with e.g. MERS. The Korean outbreak did not require MERS to have escaped from a laboratory in Korea.

The evidence does not favour this particular theory as the most likely (or indeed possible) explanation.
 
Review referenced above points out.



So


Is not a good explanation as RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses are not the closest ancestor of SARS-CoV-2. Which this explanation would require. Secondly it requires this virus to have been sampled and sent in a viable state to WIV, and then escaped, and infected laboratory workers, then onward spread. When there is no evidence of 1)a similar virus causing infection in mineworkers 2) a similar virus being present at WIV, 3) WIV staff being infected early. Even if you wanted to go with the mineworker infection, it would be simpler to assume the worker, or someone infected by the worker, directly carried it to Wuhan without requiring the laboratory as an intermediate. We have seen this carriage with e.g. MERS. The Korean outbreak did not require MERS to have escaped from a laboratory in Korea.

The evidence does not favour this particular theory as the most likely (or indeed possible) explanation.

Thank you!

I was just looking at that very point. I think we have brought it up before.

The theory that RaTG13 is the key to the WIV's bad behaviour is one that many theorists were hanging their hat on.

It's their version of "Release the Zapruder footage!"

When the Zapruder footage is released...

"Who messed around with the Zapruder footage?"
 
Posting extensive well sourced papers is not gish-galloping. :rolleyes:

This is Gish Galloping...

What I see here is you trying to change the subject, using analogies that aren't analogous and I don't see the point.

There is a body of evidence, it is building. I am at a loss as to why you think pieces in the body of evidence have to somehow align perfectly. You want to criticize Quay, find an issue with his analysis or his conclusion, don't make specious claims he isn't qualified or doesn't understand statistics.
You have an issue with Pipliani, did his analysis contradict the previous analysis Capsid mentioned? I don't think it did.

You have an issue with Bloom, good luck with that, the man is an expert in cancer and viral genomics.


Capsid posted a review. I pointed out some very specific problems with the paper. Care to address those? Is there specific supporting evidence in the WHO report of more wet markets in Wuhan being connected to early cases? Because all I found were generalities, no market name, no specific patient. And most definitely not multiple wet markets.

Do you think it might have been important to comment on the reliability of some of the data they were using? Might it have been important to note the influence Daszak and his conflict of interest had on the WHO report, or that there have been multiple objections to the report's conclusion about the unlikelihood of a lab accident? Care to comment on how they left a critical incident (Reston, Virginia) out of their summary that lab accidents have never led to pandemics before?


Why you've gone off into attacking everything else but not addressing the actual criticisms of the review ... well I think you can see where I'm going here.

You make a flurry of claims and demands for answers, and most people are too busy to address them all. So, from time to time I might address one or two. Apparently you decide you have to keep bringing up Peter Daszak's conflict of interest. Despite the fact that I have accepted that numerous times, and have agreed with you endlessly on that, you keep bringing it up. It is almost as though you are trying to win an argument by making it too labour intensive to reply to you, which is exactly the purpose of a Gish Gallop.

Now, you wanted me to look at Dr Quay's BS paper, all 140 pages of it. I have made my judgment of it, and I think it is a steaming pile of crap. And I am not the only one. So I will not address it any more in the future. If you don't like it, I don't care. And literally nobody else who matters cares about it anyway. Of course, Dr Quay might be good at convincing the Wall Street Journal, its readers, some right-wing think-tanks, some right-wing Republicans, some far-left Counterpunch readers, whatever, but it is a crap paper by all reasonable accounts.
Also, I don't have an issue with Piplani or Bloom. Never said I did. All I am saying is that I don't think their papers prove a lab leak. I am sure if you asked them they would agree with me.

Now, to move onto the next item of the Gish Gallop, look at what is written in red.

Why didn't the paper mention Reston, Virginia?

Here is the claim in the Review...

There are precedents for laboratory incidents leading to isolated infections and transient transmission chains, including SARS-CoV. Aside from the 1977 A/H1N1 influenza pandemic that likely originated from a large-scale vaccine challenge trial, there are no documented examples of human epidemics or pandemics resulting from research activity. The emergence of SARS-CoV-2 differs markedly from documented laboratory escapes that, with the exception of Marburg virus, have been of readily identifiable viruses capable of human infection and associated with sustained work in high titer cultures. No previous epidemic has been caused by the escape of a novel virus and there is no data to suggest that the WIV—or any other laboratory—were working on SARS-CoV-2, or any virus close enough to be the progenitor, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Reston virus is actually doumented in the book Spillover, which made me suspicious of your claim that it was a human pandemic.

Wikipedia says:

While investigating an outbreak of Simian hemorrhagic fever (SHFV) in November 1989, an electron microscopist from USAMRIID named Thomas W. Geisbert discovered filoviruses similar in appearance to Ebola virus in tissue samples taken from a crab-eating macaque imported from the Philippines to Hazleton Laboratories in Reston, Virginia. The filovirus was further isolated by Dr. Peter Jahrling, and over the period of three months over a third of the monkeys died—at a rate of two or three a day.[14]

Blood samples were taken from 178 animal handlers during the incident.[15] Of them, six eventually seroconverted, testing positive using ELISA. They remained, however, asymptomatic. In January 1990, an animal handler at Hazelton cut himself while performing a necropsy on the liver of an infected Cynomolgus. Under the direction of the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the animal handler was placed under surveillance for the duration of the incubation period. When the animal handler failed to become ill, it was concluded that the virus had a low pathogenicity in humans.

So Reston virus did not even cause human illness, let alone an epidemic or a human pandemic. It doesn't even apparently make humans sick. So your attempted gotcha fails.

Let's say you just post the best evidence instead of shovelling a mountain of crappy evidence.
 
I'll see that crap TA and raise you one. There's a lot in this paper, it's quite thorough and well sourced, but I want to draw people's attention to a few things.

JUNE 4, 2021
A Chinese PhD Thesis Sheds Important New Light On The Origin of the COVID-19 Coronavirus
[Note a PhD thesis is peer reviewed.]The history of collecting and studying the viral genome is described. It was collected in the Yunnan mine where the 6 miners were infected back in 2013.



The Chinese master's thesis from that time period is reviewed. I posted a link to that earlier but there's another one in this paper.

I think the highlighted is unintentionally funny. When you say "I'll see that crap TA and raise you one." do you mean that what you then go on to post is even more crap than what The Atheist posted?

I mean, first off, you talk about it being a Master's thesis, and the Counterpunch people do as well. But it also says PhD thesis. In fact, is this a paper from a Masters or a PhD? There's quite a difference in expectations from the two levels of post-graduate research, but also... are we really using a postgraduate thesis as evidence now? I mean, when The Atheist posted an article talking about the WMD in Iraq (which was allegedly trumped up using someone's PhD thesis) that the next thing you would say when "raising" him would be to present a Master's thesis! I mean...LOL!

I mean, the article is essentially asserting that the WIV discovered a human spillover in 2012/2013, knew about it, and then tried to hush it up so that they could do some sneaky science...

And yet...

When I look through the thesis...

What do I find...?

Do I find a smoking gun?

No! What I find is this...

Read what it says...
 

Attachments

  • remains unclear.png
    remains unclear.png
    21.9 KB · Views: 12
In other words, we have a bunch of "internet sleuths" arguing that they believe the Wuhan Institute of Virology captured some SARS-like pathogens and made them more deadly in the lab, and they use as their evidence a PhD thesis (that they confusingly refer to as a Master's thesis) stating that nobody knows how the miners got pneumonia.

Not very convincing.
 
The latest theory from the lab leakers...

Alina Chan said:
This situation...

Virologists say that virologists are unlikely to have caused the pandemic.

Virologists say that more virology (and more funding for virologists) is needed to prevent a future pandemic.

So if anyone is wondering why virology as a field is not impressed by lab leak theories it is because it is a corrupt field and they just want cash.

Oh, by the way, Alina Chan has a book out soon on the lab leak. Please buy it!
 
Okay, thanks. Well, I will look into it a bit more. My understanding regarding the death of the miners is that it is not exactly clear how they died and that it may have been through fungal infection. I haven’t really looked closely at that. I noticed that there was recently a big argument between a virologist called Steve Neil (I think) and Rosa Segreto on some very long Twitter thread. As with many of these discussions it is not always clear what the disputes are about and how they started.

That said, I take it that nobody is any longer making a claim that RaTG13 was manipulated to become SARS-CoV2.
I'm not sure who made that assertion. It wasn't me.

Re what the miners had, the PhD thesis (peer reviewed as all doctorate theses are) revealed it was a coronavirus.
 
The latest theory from the lab leakers...

So if anyone is wondering why virology as a field is not impressed by lab leak theories it is because it is a corrupt field and they just want cash.

Oh, by the way, Alina Chan has a book out soon on the lab leak. Please buy it!
Give me a break. If one person is peddling a book that doesn't taint anyone else. Quay has a how to survive COVID booklet for sale too. BFD.

You have to show what said corruption resulted in like we can see how Daszak's conflict of interest resulted in quashing the lab accident hypothesis for a time.
 
I think the highlighted is unintentionally funny. When you say "I'll see that crap TA and raise you one." do you mean that what you then go on to post is even more crap than what The Atheist posted?

I mean, first off, you talk about it being a Master's thesis, and the Counterpunch people do as well. But it also says PhD thesis. In fact, is this a paper from a Masters or a PhD? There's quite a difference in expectations from the two levels of post-graduate research, but also... are we really using a postgraduate thesis as evidence now? I mean, when The Atheist posted an article talking about the WMD in Iraq (which was allegedly trumped up using someone's PhD thesis) that the next thing you would say when "raising" him would be to present a Master's thesis! I mean...LOL!
Oh my word, you really didn't look, did you? Those are 2 different theses. The translations are linked to in the piece.

I mean, the article is essentially asserting that the WIV discovered a human spillover in 2012/2013, knew about it, and then tried to hush it up so that they could do some sneaky science...
Yeah..no. It wasn't covered up in 2012. Look at the doctorate thesis. It was investigated, all sorts of specimens were collected and sent to multiple labs in China. I believe they refer to Shi herself discussing it in 2019 before the first cases showed up. Daszak did as well, that interview is cited upthread.

What happened next is all the references to the 2013 work were scrubbed from the WIV files. Supposedly only the fragment was found in the files. What the article described in detail was that the full genome should have been in the WIV files. They had the virus specimens, documented in the PhD thesis.

What the authors are saying is it is not credible the coronavirus the miners were found to have had would not have started a serious investigation. Where is that work? It's missing. Where are the specimens that where collected? They are missing.

Lots of trips to the mine (cave) in Yunnan were made to collect specimens that went to the WIV. The genome data base and/or whatever frozen specimens are at the WIV lack any record of these repeated specimen collections.

As for that thumbnail, yeah, that is one of the points and one of the problems. Where is that work? Where are those specimens that would be very useful now when looking for the origin of the pandemic.


The paper puts forth a new hypothesis for which I have no opinion as of yet. They suggested that at least one of the miners had a protracted case of whatever SARS-like coronavirus they were infected with. As we have seen now, people with protracted cases of COVID 19 are little crucibles for viral mutations. The hypothesis is that it could have been within that miner that the SARS-like coronavirus became better adapted to humans.

This is different than the hypothesis COVID-19 became better adapted through GoF research. Maybe it was a combination of the two. In either hypothesis the lab is implicated.



Not sure if I already mentioned this. Just because the COVID 19 got better such as with the deltoid variant doesn't mean it wasn't ready out of the box when the first person was infected in Wuhan.

And just a reminder: the first patients were not just in Wuhan, they were in Wuhan within a few miles of the WIV. And that seafood wet market may very well have been in the same vicinity, it has been shown both genetically and chronologically NOT to be the original source of the first human infection.
 
Last edited:
This is Gish Galloping...

You make a flurry of claims and demands for answers, and most people are too busy to address them all. So, from time to time I might address one or two. Apparently you decide you have to keep bringing up Peter Daszak's conflict of interest. Despite the fact that I have accepted that numerous times, and have agreed with you endlessly on that, you keep bringing it up. It is almost as though you are trying to win an argument by making it too labour intensive to reply to you, which is exactly the purpose of a Gish Gallop.

Now, you wanted me to look at Dr Quay's BS paper, all 140 pages of it. I have made my judgment of it, and I think it is a steaming pile of crap. And I am not the only one. So I will not address it any more in the future. If you don't like it, I don't care. And literally nobody else who matters cares about it anyway. Of course, Dr Quay might be good at convincing the Wall Street Journal, its readers, some right-wing think-tanks, some right-wing Republicans, some far-left Counterpunch readers, whatever, but it is a crap paper by all reasonable accounts.
Also, I don't have an issue with Piplani or Bloom. Never said I did. All I am saying is that I don't think their papers prove a lab leak. I am sure if you asked them they would agree with me.

Now, to move onto the next item of the Gish Gallop, look at what is written in red.

Why didn't the paper mention Reston, Virginia?

Here is the claim in the Review...

The Reston virus is actually doumented in the book Spillover, which made me suspicious of your claim that it was a human pandemic.

Wikipedia says:

So Reston virus did not even cause human illness, let alone an epidemic or a human pandemic. It doesn't even apparently make humans sick. So your attempted gotcha fails.

Let's say you just post the best evidence instead of shovelling a mountain of crappy evidence.
Of course the Reston, VI case didn't result in a pandemic. It's a well known incident where thank goodness the airborne virus that was unleashed wasn't a human pathogen. Had it been, by the time the lab errors were discovered it would have been too late.

It is a well known near-miss that one would leave out if one was trying to downplay the history of lab accidents.

As for the gish-gallop, I'm sorry you feel overwhelmed but you are confusing a single paper I post in detail about with some imaginary flood of information.


None of it has been crappy evidence. You cherry pick here and there and dismiss everything as a whole. Which is ironic given none of the spillover evidence has been very strong at all.

There are claims the genetics don't match a lab produced virus, usually along with the straw man anyone is talking about an "engineered" virus. And there's a whole lot of 'a spillover is historically more common'. Did I miss anything key?

Re what I've posted, some might be weaker, some stronger. But it is you that wants to hand wave it all away. It ain't going away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom