Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Posting extensive well sourced papers is not gish-galloping.*sigh* I already mentioned that Bloom’s paper is not evidence of lab leak or spillover.
I’m not “cherry-picking”; the problem is that when responding to your Gish Gallops,...
Bloom found evidence of things covered up that Capsid's review paper failed to mention. That was the context I brought his work up in. I didn't post it as proof of a lab origin.
The paper I just cited had much much more.
American Institute for Economic Research: The Origin of SARS-CoV-2
Denouncing the Lab Leak Theory
Covid-19 raises important considerations about truth and trust. While the genesis of Covid-19 is still shrouded in mystery, a lack of certainty didn’t stop prominent people and organizations from stating at an early date that any suggestion that SARS-CoV-2 was manipulated in a lab was not true,[8] misinformation,[9] a conjecture,[10] a conspiracy,[11] [12] false information,[13] implausible,[14] something out of a comic book,[15] extremely unlikely,[16] or already debunked,[17] and had been repeatedly disproven.[18]
Why were these people so dismissive of the lab leak theory? Were their statements based on a reasoned assessment of the data or the desire to steer public opinion toward a favored conclusion?
Some who made these claims, such as Anthony Fauci, have since backtracked and admitted that the lab leak theory has merit. Further, we now know that other prominent denouncers had privately presented evidence supporting the lab leak theory or had serious conflicts of interest due to their work with the Chinese lab in question.
Andersen was clear which side of the fence he was on yet when the Fauci emails came to light there was this:
Yet just a couple of months earlier, Andersen had emailed Fauci to report that the virus had “unusual features” that looked “potentially engineered.” He explained that he and his team “all find the genome inconsistent with expectations from evolutionary theory.”
And my POV is not isolated.
According to Xiao Qiang, a research scientist at Berkeley: “To understand exactly how this virus has originated is critical knowledge for preventing this from happening in the future.”[26] Based on what we know, the lab leak theory better fits the evidence.
One would think that all the information not being disclosed would be beneficial in supporting the zoonosis spillover. And yes there is clear evidence that a lot of the work at the WIV and elsewhere in China is there but unavailable to outsiders. I have posted extensive sources for that claim.