Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why not? You believe that Piplani and Bloom both support a lab-leak theory. According to Quay it is a cast-iron certainty that it escpaed from a lab. If you believe Quay, Piplani and Bloom's work would be superfluous.

It seems to me you are keeping two sets of books. On the one hand you argue that Quay's paper is a good one, but that would end all doubt on the matter. And yet, absolutely nobody reputable takes it seriously.
What the **** are you even talking about? Every paper must be a review now because I found very specific things to criticize the last review for?

Your post has gone a tad off the rails.
 
What the **** are you even talking about? Every paper must be a review now because I found very specific things to criticize the last review for?

Your post has gone a tad off the rails.

Sorry, I didn't complete the thought.

The two sets of books are:

1. Quay is correct = 100% chance of lab origins

2. Evidence is slowly mounting up (Pipliani et. al, Bloom etc...)

If Quay is correct, all else is superfluous. Do you not quite think he is right?
 
Sorry, I didn't complete the thought.

The two sets of books are:

1. Quay is correct = 100% chance of lab origins

2. Evidence is slowly mounting up (Pipliani et. al, Bloom etc...)

If Quay is correct, all else is superfluous. Do you not quite think he is right?

What I see here is you trying to change the subject, using analogies that aren't analogous and I don't see the point.

There is a body of evidence, it is building. I am at a loss as to why you think pieces in the body of evidence have to somehow align perfectly. You want to criticize Quay, find an issue with his analysis or his conclusion, don't make specious claims he isn't qualified or doesn't understand statistics.

You have an issue with Pipliani, did his analysis contradict the previous analysis Capsid mentioned? I don't think it did.

You have an issue with Bloom, good luck with that, the man is an expert in cancer and viral genomics.

Capsid posted a review. I pointed out some very specific problems with the paper. Care to address those? Is there specific supporting evidence in the WHO report of more wet markets in Wuhan being connected to early cases? Because all I found were generalities, no market name, no specific patient. And most definitely not multiple wet markets.

Do you think it might have been important to comment on the reliability of some of the data they were using? Might it have been important to note the influence Daszak and his conflict of interest had on the WHO report, or that there have been multiple objections to the report's conclusion about the unlikelihood of a lab accident? Care to comment on how they left a critical incident (Reston, Virginia) out of their summary that lab accidents have never led to pandemics before?


Why you've gone off into attacking everything else but not addressing the actual criticisms of the review ... well I think you can see where I'm going here.
 
Last edited:
You have an issue with Pipliani, did his analysis contradict the previous analysis Capsid mentioned? I don't think it did.

You have an issue with Bloom, good luck with that, the man is an expert in cancer and viral genomics.

I don't have an issue with either of them. Why do you think I do?

I have an issue with your insistence that Quay's paper is worth anything.

From what I can see, it is not considered that by the field otherwise it would have reputable backing.

It does not.
 
So your evidence and/or reasoning why you are critical of Quay is what exactly?

I've already stated the reasoning various times, haven't I?

I have explained that when someone is proposing a scientific explanation that I have no competence to judge, then I rely on the competence of those who are in the field.

It seems pretty clear that Dr Quay's paper is not of any interest to virologists otherwise his claimed mathematical proof that SARS-CoV2 is 99.8% from a lab would be BIG BIG news!

And yet, aside from being entertained by some right-wing GOP crazies, and getting an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal his paper has not been taken up as the last word on this.

In fact, if we do a quick look, we can find that virologists who have actually looked at what he says, dispute his claims.

Here, for example is an article by a molecular biologist and a virologist from the University of Leeds (that's in the UK, by the way):

An important way scientists can determine the origin of a virus is by looking at its genome. In the WSJ article, the authors, Prof Richard Muller, an astrophysicist, and Dr Steven Quay, physician and chief executive of Atossa Therapeutics, claim Sars-CoV-2 has “genetic fingerprints” of a lab-origin virus. They say that the presence of a particular genetic sequence (CGG-CGG) is a sign that the virus originated in a lab.

...

The authors of the WSJ article argue that Sars-CoV-2 originated in a lab based on the presence of a “CGG-CGG” sequence. They claim this is a “readily available and convenient” codon pair that scientists prefer to use to produce the amino acid arginine. But to anyone with an understanding of the techniques required for genetic modification, this double-CGG is usually no more difficult or easy to produce than any other pair of codons that encode arginines.

No reason CGG-CGG had to be made in lab
The authors claim that the CGG codon appears less frequently than the other five possible codons in betacoronaviruses (the family of coronaviruses to which Sars-CoV-2 belongs). If we look at related coronaviruses, the CGG codon encodes about 5% of all arginines in Sars-CoV compared with about 3% of all arginines in Sars-CoV-2. Though CGG is less common than other codons, the authors’ argument fails to provide a reason that the double-CGG sequence could not exist naturally.
The authors argue that recombination (when viruses that infect the same host share genetic material) was the most likely way in which Sars-CoV-2 was able to obtain the double-CGG sequence. They note that the double-CGG codon pair is not found in other members of this “class” of coronavirus, so natural recombination could not possibly generate a double-CGG. However, viruses do not just depend on preassembled segments of genetic material to evolve and expand their host range.

The authors also claim that mutation (random copying errors) is unlikely to generate the double-CGG sequence. But viruses evolve at a rapid rate, so much so that the accumulation of mutations is a common inconvenience of virological studies. Recombination is one way in which viruses evolve, but the authors’ dismissal of mutation as a source of viral change is an inaccurate description of reality.

The final claim that the first sequenced Sars-CoV-2 virus was ideally suited to the human host neglects evidence of viral circulation in local animal populations, animal-to-animal transmission, and the rapid evolution that is driving the increasing transmissibility of the newer variants. If the virus was ideally adapted to humans, why is so much further evolution evident?
 
I've already stated the reasoning various times, haven't I?

I have explained that when someone is proposing a scientific explanation that I have no competence to judge, then I rely on the competence of those who are in the field.

It seems pretty clear that Dr Quay's paper is not of any interest to virologists otherwise his claimed mathematical proof that SARS-CoV2 is 99.8% from a lab would be BIG BIG news!
Oh for pity's sake.
1) Quay's papers have gotten a lot of attention, not just in the WSJ.
2) Two of his papers came out when the media was quashing the notion of a lab origin. And don't pretend that didn't happen.
3) You cite 2 virologists' rebuttal. You have a habit of calling a couple of virologists a consensus.

And yet, aside from being entertained by some right-wing GOP crazies, and getting an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal his paper has not been taken up as the last word on this.
Why should it be the last word as opposed to a piece of data? This is a straw man of yours, if Quay's work wasn't the nail in the coffin it must be useless.

And I certainly have not relied solely on Quay's work. There is a wealth of evidence here in this thread and very little if any of it points to a natural spillover event.

But, back to Quay:
In fact, if we do a quick look, we can find that [2] virologists who have actually looked at what he says, dispute his claims.
ftfy

Here, for example is an article by a molecular biologist and a virologist from the University of Leeds (that's in the UK, by the way):
Yep, 2. Count them, 2.

Why are you pointing out where Leeds is? :confused:

I've seen this genetic sequence argument from both sides as well as the furin cleavage argument. I would say those two arguments remain unresolved with pro and con on each. There is no virologists' consensus. And despite your attempt to drag the lab origin down to the CT level with the comment on the physics involved, Quay doesn't even make that particular argument.

Here's what Quay said about the furin cleavage site in one interview I posted near the beginning of the thread:
Yes, and there are at least eleven different laboratories around the world, including the WIV, that have purposely put a furin cleavage site in a Spike protein. They put a particular set of amino acids and the furin enzyme clipper says: Oh, I like that spot. Then they clip it and the virus goes into the cell. And every time that’s been done since 1992 it always increases the infectivity, the transmissibility and the lethality of the virus. So when you see a furin cleavage site in a coronavirus you know it has a great significance. Now, SARS-CoV-2 comes from a subgroup of coronaviruses called the sarvecovirus. But it’s the only one of this subgroup, this subgenera that has a furin site.

And directly from Quay's paper, notice he says "rare" not physically impossible:
But it gets worse still for the zoonosis theory. The gene sequence for the amino acids in the furin site in CoV-2 uses a very rare set of two codons, three letter words so six letters in a row, that are rarely used individually and have never been seen together in tandem in any coronaviruses in nature. But these same ‘rare in nature’ codons turn out to be the very ones that are always used by scientists in the laboratory when researchers want to add the amino acid arginine, the ones that are found in the furin site. When scientists add a dimer of arginine codons to a coronavirus, they invariably use the word, CGG-CGG, but coronaviruses in nature rarely (<1%) use this codon pair. For example, in the 580,000 codons of 58 Sarbecoviruses the only CGG pair is CoV2; none of the other 57 sarbecoviruses have such a pair. 8

You should really read Quay's paper. You don't have to be an expert to understand it.

From your posts I gather you have not.
 
Here's a thread on reddit in the r/virology subreddit.

Someone brings up Steven Quay and Robert Muller's claims...

They and other virologists on the thread find the claims about the codons to be ludicrous.
Didn't you gripe upthread that I cited a news source which as I noted merely pointed to a study I cited. And you want me to look at a discussion on Reddit? :rolleyes:
 
Oh for pity's sake.
1) Quay's papers have gotten a lot of attention, not just in the WSJ.

"A lot of attention" from whom? Reputable scientists in the field? Spoiler warning: NO!

2) Two of his papers came out when the media was quashing the notion of a lab origin. And don't pretend that didn't happen.

Wake me up when it gets into a peer-reviewed, non-pay-for-play journal. This is going to happen, right? Right?

Spoiler warning: NO!

Honestly, this is like a re-run of Steven Jones and 9/11.

3) You cite 2 virologists' rebuttal. You have a habit of calling a couple of virologists a consensus.

You wanted an argument, I gave you one. What is your response to their claim that the structure is not an obvious sign of lab tampering?

Why should it be the last word as opposed to a piece of data? This is a straw man of yours, if Quay's work wasn't the nail in the coffin it must be useless.

If he proved it was 100% impossible to have come from nature, then it would indeed be the nail in the coffin, would it not? Are you not as confident of his findings as that? I guess nobody else is so it is understandable.


And I certainly have not relied solely on Quay's work. There is a wealth of evidence here in this thread and very little if any of it points to a natural spillover event.

But, back to Quay:
ftfy


Yep, 2. Count them, 2.

Which is 2 more than support Quay. Of course, these two need to be added to the, what, 17 virologists who worked on the paper that Capsid linked to.

There seem to be quite a few. What is your explanation for them not siding with Dr Quay? Paid off? Threatened? Ignorant? Stupid? Sheeple?

Why are you pointing out where Leeds is? :confused:

It aint in China! It's not in the US, so they aren't being suppressed by Fauci or CNN or the CDC or whichever other bogeyman the lab leakers are blaming this week for why their theories are not being taken seriously in the field.

I've seen this genetic sequence argument from both sides as well as the furin cleavage argument. I would say those two arguments remain unresolved with pro and con on each. There is no virologists' consensus. And despite your attempt to drag the lab origin down to the CT level with the comment on the physics involved, Quay doesn't even make that particular argument.

Here's what Quay said about the furin cleavage site in one interview I posted near the beginning of the thread:

And directly from Quay's paper, notice he says "rare" not physically impossible:

You should really read Quay's paper. You don't have to be an expert to understand it.

From your posts I gather you have not.

Yeah, he says "rare", and then assigns a probablility that when added together means he all but rules out any possible

I've read a bit of the paper, but I have no way to trust that he is doing the Bayesian analysis correctly. I just cannot know how he is making these probabilties.

Besides, it is not that "lab leak" per se is a conspiracy theory, it is the means by which it is argued.

As I have said, the vast number of virologists seem to be unpersuaded of the lab leak, and see nothing in the data to support that. So, if that is the case, there needs to be an explanation for why they haven't gone there yet. The explanations usually given are when the conspiracy comes in... Peter Daszak and China have paid off/threatened etc...
 
Of course we've already talked about it! Nothing in Capsid's cite was new either.

I take this as a refusal to discuss the actual evidence. I can see why you prefer to ignore it, brush it off under false pretenses, claim Quay isn't the right kind of expert when he clearly is, cherry pick something from one of Quay's papers because I cited that one rather than just tell people to go find it in the thread, that's all you and others on the the natural spillover side in this thread do.

But that's OK. The evidence isn't going away.

:popcorn1

The new bit that we haven't discussed is the culture of bat coronaviruses in Vero E6 cells which deletes the furin cleavage site. This has only recently been known and may not have been realised at the time. The purpose at WIV was mainly to try and recover live viruses from foecal samples (or was this for nefarious reasons?). Whatever, the cultured virus would not lead to a SARS-COV-2 progenitor. Of course, there is the possibility that the lab cultured virus on other cell lines.
 
You should really read Quay's paper. You don't have to be an expert to understand it.

From your posts I gather you have not.
Well, it's 140 pages long, and poorly written. Using a method employed by the paper (pulling an estimate out of thin air), I'd estimate that less than 2% of those who have contributed to this thread have taken the time to read that paper with great care.

I've read a bit of the paper, but I have no way to trust that he is doing the Bayesian analysis correctly. I just cannot know how he is making these probabilties.

Besides, it is not that "lab leak" per se is a conspiracy theory, it is the means by which it is argued.
I was curious about the nature of Quay's argument, and whether he was doing the Bayesian analysis correctly, so I wasted some time this morning trying to read the paper.

First of all, the paper is poorly written. To start with, it's hard to perceive the paper's overall structure. The paper is 140 pages long, with no outline or table of contents, no numbering of sections or subsections, and indeed no clear indication of where sections/subsections begin other than a line or phrase of boldface text such as "Executive Summary." or "Zoonosis Hypothesis". For example, it is unclear where the "Executive Summary" is intended to end, although I assume it ends at the end of page 11. (It is also possible that Quay's "Executive Summary" is 140 pages, and that the 140 pages I see merely summarize another paper I haven't seen. I hope that's not true, but I can't tell for certain). For another example, page 15 says "The details of the evidence used to arrive at this conclusion is contained in Appendix 1." There is no "Appendix 1" in the paper, although I might guess we're expected to assume that appendix was to begin somewhere between page 12 and the green-highlighted "Evidence." on page 21. Perhaps the most likely start of the missing "Appendix 1" is the following line on page 18 (with bold face and highlighting as in the original, except the original highlighting is green rather than yellow):
Quay said:
1. General approach of this analysis22
Six lines later, Quay writes:
Quay said:
This brief description of the Bayes Theorem was taken from the work of Jon Seymour:24
"Taken" is an understatement, as Quay's brief description of the Bayes Theorem was essentially copied and pasted from Jon Seymour's blog, including Seymour's crappy notations for multiplication (e.g. "P(E|H).P(H)") and hatted H (e.g. "P(E|^H)"), which might well be necessary to work around the limitations of software used by Seymour's blog but are inexcusable in a document we're supposed to take seriously as a scientific paper.

On page 19, Quay writes (with bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights the first "independent" in green instead of yellow; I have no idea why he used different colors to highlighted two occurrences of the same word on the same line):
Quay said:
Independence. An important qualitative assessment that must be made is whether or not two pieces of evidence are independent of each other. If they are independent, they can each be used in determining a new likelihood calculation. If they are dependent on each other then they must be combined and only a single new likelihood analysis can be made. Where ever possible, evidence statements that could be considered as dependent are called out and this rule is followed on their contribution to the analysis.
That's an important point. It took me a little time to confirm that all of Quay's adjustments to his prior probabilities were multiplications and divisions that are valid only if the associated bits of evidence are statistically independent. Before commenting on what appear to me to be examples of adjustments based on evidence that is probably not statistically independent, let's look at the paragraph immediately following the paragraph I quoted above.
Quay said:
Subjective Discount Factor. The impact of each piece of evidence was adjusted further by a subjective discount factor. This is a qualitative assessment of the overall veracity of a particular piece of evidence when all factors, samples, methods, data sources, etc. are taken into context. It varies from 60% to 100% and is used as a fraction to reduce the impact of a single piece of evidence even further.
Some of you might have thought I was exaggerating when I spoke of Quay "pulling an estimate out of thin air", but no. Quay acknowledges the subjectivity of his discount factors.

To illustrate Quay's use of Bayes's Theorem, here is the conclusion of Quay's first adjustment (bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights "Starting likehood..." and "Adjusted likelihood..." in green instead of yellow):
Quay said:
Conclusion. For purposes of this analysis and to be as conservative as possible, the assumptions will be that there is at least a 1% prior belief in a laboratory outbreak (because that was our starting probabilities), but there is no more than a 51% chance that an uncontrolled release of a highly contagious disease would lead to a local outbreak, and that there was at least a 10% chance that a natural outbreak of a virus native to Yunnan would have occurred in Wuhan before any place else. Using these assumptions, the initial likelihood of a 1% laboratory origin changes to 4.9%.

Starting likelihood from initial state: Zoonotic origin (98.8%) and laboratory origin (1.2%)
Adjusted likelihood: Zoonotic origin (95.1%) and laboratory origin (4.9%)
As you can see, the adjustment going from "1% laboratory origin" to "4.9%" is explicitly based on assumptions pulled out of the air, although the air used as source here may be more substantial than the air from which some of the paper's other assumptions were extracted.

Here are the three biggest adjustment to Quay's estimated probability of a laboratory origin:
  • Lack of evidence of seroconversion in Wuhan and Shanghai (going from 4.9% to 19.1%)
  • Lack of posterior diversity (from 19.1% to 69.2%)
  • Lack of furin cleavage sites in any other sarbecovirus (from 69.2% to 95.3%)
The explicitly subjective discount factors Quay pulled out of thin air to come up with those adjustments are:
Quay said:
Subjective Discount Factor: 90% (a one in 10 chance this is wrong). This is a subjective value.
Quay said:
Subjective Discount Factor: 95% (a one in 20 chance this is wrong)
Quay said:
Subjective Discount Factor. 95% confidence (only a one in 20 chance this is wrong).
I have absolutely no competence in virology or any other biological science, but my remarks above explain why I am not at all impressed by Quay's paper.
 
Last edited:
Well, it's 140 pages long, and poorly written. Using a method employed by the paper (pulling an estimate out of thin air), I'd estimate that less than 2% of those who have contributed to this thread have taken the time to read that paper with great care.


I was curious about the nature of Quay's argument, and whether he was doing the Bayesian analysis correctly, so I wasted some time this morning trying to read the paper.

First of all, the paper is poorly written. To start with, it's hard to perceive the paper's overall structure. The paper is 140 pages long, with no outline or table of contents, no numbering of sections or subsections, and indeed no clear indication of where sections/subsections begin other than a line or phrase of boldface text such as "Executive Summary." or "Zoonosis Hypothesis". For example, it is unclear where the "Executive Summary" is intended to end, although I assume it ends at the end of page 11. (It is also possible that Quay's "Executive Summary" is 140 pages, and that the 140 pages I see merely summarize another paper I haven't seen. I hope that's not true, but I can't tell for certain). For another example, page 15 says "The details of the evidence used to arrive at this conclusion is contained in Appendix 1." There is no "Appendix 1" in the paper, although I might guess we're expected to assume that appendix was to begin somewhere between page 12 and the green-highlighted "Evidence." on page 21. Perhaps the most likely start of the missing "Appendix 1" is the following line on page 18 (with bold face and highlighting as in the original, except the original highlighting is green rather than yellow):

Six lines later, Quay writes:

"Taken" is an understatement, as Quay's brief description of the Bayes Theorem was essentially copied and pasted from Jon Seymour's blog, including Seymour's crappy notations for multiplication (e.g. "P(E|H).P(H)") and hatted H (e.g. "P(E|^H)"), which might well be necessary to work around the limitations of software used by Seymour's blog but are inexcusable in a document we're supposed to take seriously as a scientific paper.

On page 19, Quay writes (with bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights the first "independent" in green instead of yellow; I have no idea why he used different colors to highlighted two occurrences of the same word on the same line):

That's an important point. It took me a little time to confirm that all of Quay's adjustments to his prior probabilities were multiplications and divisions that are valid only if the associated bits of evidence are statistically independent. Before commenting on what appear to me to be examples of adjustments based on evidence that is probably not statistically independent, let's look at the paragraph immediately following the paragraph I quoted above.

Some of you might have thought I was exaggerating when I spoke of Quay "pulling an estimate out of thin air", but no. Quay acknowledges the subjectivity of his discount factors.

To illustrate Quay's use of Bayes's Theorem, here is the conclusion of Quay's first adjustment (bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights "Starting likehood..." and "Adjusted likelihood..." in green instead of yellow):

As you can see, the adjustment going from "1% laboratory origin" to "4.9%" is explicitly based on assumptions pulled out of the air, although the air used as source here may be more substantial than the air from which some of the paper's other assumptions were extracted.

Here are the three biggest adjustment to Quay's estimated probability of a laboratory origin:
  • Lack of evidence of seroconversion in Wuhan and Shanghai (going from 4.9% to 19.1%)
  • Lack of posterior diversity (from 19.1% to 69.2%)
  • Lack of furin cleavage sites in any other sarbecovirus (from 69.2% to 95.3%)
The explicitly subjective discount factors Quay pulled out of thin air to come up with those adjustments are:



I have absolutely no competence in virology or any other biological science, but my remarks above explain why I am not at all impressed by Quay's paper.

I don't have any expertise either but it's still clear from the literature that most of Quay's assumptions are fundamentally flawed. Eg:

He claims SARS-CoV-2 has been "optimized" for humans when it clearly has not. (the furin cleave site is sub-optimal and out of frame things no human researcher would do)

He claims there are few related viruses with a furin cleavage site but the sampling method used for most of the catalog he's looking at actually tends to destroy furin cleavage sites.

He suggests that the fact few people in Wuhan have antibodies ("Lack of evidence of seroconversion") is evidence for a lab leak, but it's a Novel virus you'd expect almost no one to have antibodies regardless of origin.

Quay says location favors a lab leak but there are no early cases near the lab, they are all 20+ Km away on the other side of the Yangtze river. In fact the progress of the early epidemic shows the virus moving towards the lab instead of radiating outwards away from it as you'd expect if the cause were a lab leak.


Quay suggests that lack of a suitable proximal ancestor favors a lab leak, but the lab leak hypothesis has almost the exact same problem, there is no viable candidate for scientists to have been experimenting on. Furthermore, while there are certainly many undiscovered relative in the wild the chances of experimenting on an unknown Covid relative in a lab is almost zero.

I could point out more examples but the paper is just a Gish Gallop that is shamelessly committing so many errors that no one is likely to go though the effort of documenting them all
 
The new bit that we haven't discussed is the culture of bat coronaviruses in Vero E6 cells which deletes the furin cleavage site. This has only recently been known and may not have been realised at the time. The purpose at WIV was mainly to try and recover live viruses from foecal samples (or was this for nefarious reasons?). Whatever, the cultured virus would not lead to a SARS-COV-2 progenitor. Of course, there is the possibility that the lab cultured virus on other cell lines.

Thanks, I'll look at that again and the past citations that noted the vero cell cultures.

I'm also curious when I see mice used and humanized mice used (meaning they have been bred to have human-like cells in the respiratory tract). Not sure why the research reports aren't more clear about which they are talking about.
 
Well, it's 140 pages long, and poorly written. Using a method employed by the paper (pulling an estimate out of thin air), I'd estimate that less than 2% of those who have contributed to this thread have taken the time to read that paper with great care.

I was curious about the nature of Quay's argument, and whether he was doing the Bayesian analysis correctly, so I wasted some time this morning trying to read the paper.

First of all, the paper is poorly written. To start with, it's hard to perceive the paper's overall structure. The paper is 140 pages long, with no outline or table of contents, no numbering of sections or subsections, and indeed no clear indication of where sections/subsections begin other than a line or phrase of boldface text such as "Executive Summary." or "Zoonosis Hypothesis". For example, it is unclear where the "Executive Summary" is intended to end, although I assume it ends at the end of page 11. (It is also possible that Quay's "Executive Summary" is 140 pages, and that the 140 pages I see merely summarize another paper I haven't seen. I hope that's not true, but I can't tell for certain). For another example, page 15 says "The details of the evidence used to arrive at this conclusion is contained in Appendix 1." There is no "Appendix 1" in the paper, although I might guess we're expected to assume that appendix was to begin somewhere between page 12 and the green-highlighted "Evidence." on page 21. Perhaps the most likely start of the missing "Appendix 1" is the following line on page 18 (with bold face and highlighting as in the original, except the original highlighting is green rather than yellow):

Six lines later, Quay writes:

"Taken" is an understatement, as Quay's brief description of the Bayes Theorem was essentially copied and pasted from Jon Seymour's blog, including Seymour's crappy notations for multiplication (e.g. "P(E|H).P(H)") and hatted H (e.g. "P(E|^H)"), which might well be necessary to work around the limitations of software used by Seymour's blog but are inexcusable in a document we're supposed to take seriously as a scientific paper.

On page 19, Quay writes (with bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights the first "independent" in green instead of yellow; I have no idea why he used different colors to highlighted two occurrences of the same word on the same line):

That's an important point. It took me a little time to confirm that all of Quay's adjustments to his prior probabilities were multiplications and divisions that are valid only if the associated bits of evidence are statistically independent. Before commenting on what appear to me to be examples of adjustments based on evidence that is probably not statistically independent, let's look at the paragraph immediately following the paragraph I quoted above.

Some of you might have thought I was exaggerating when I spoke of Quay "pulling an estimate out of thin air", but no. Quay acknowledges the subjectivity of his discount factors.

To illustrate Quay's use of Bayes's Theorem, here is the conclusion of Quay's first adjustment (bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights "Starting likehood..." and "Adjusted likelihood..." in green instead of yellow):

As you can see, the adjustment going from "1% laboratory origin" to "4.9%" is explicitly based on assumptions pulled out of the air, although the air used as source here may be more substantial than the air from which some of the paper's other assumptions were extracted.

Here are the three biggest adjustment to Quay's estimated probability of a laboratory origin:
  • Lack of evidence of seroconversion in Wuhan and Shanghai (going from 4.9% to 19.1%)
  • Lack of posterior diversity (from 19.1% to 69.2%)
  • Lack of furin cleavage sites in any other sarbecovirus (from 69.2% to 95.3%)
The explicitly subjective discount factors Quay pulled out of thin air to come up with those adjustments are:

I have absolutely no competence in virology or any other biological science, but my remarks above explain why I am not at all impressed by Quay's paper.
Thanks. I'll take another look at the paper using your analysis information.

As for reading all 140 pages, one can skim parts of it as in all these long research papers. Quay has commented on feedback he's gotten, I'll look at that again as well.
 
Well, it's 140 pages long, and poorly written. Using a method employed by the paper (pulling an estimate out of thin air), I'd estimate that less than 2% of those who have contributed to this thread have taken the time to read that paper with great care.


I was curious about the nature of Quay's argument, and whether he was doing the Bayesian analysis correctly, so I wasted some time this morning trying to read the paper.

First of all, the paper is poorly written. To start with, it's hard to perceive the paper's overall structure. The paper is 140 pages long, with no outline or table of contents, no numbering of sections or subsections, and indeed no clear indication of where sections/subsections begin other than a line or phrase of boldface text such as "Executive Summary." or "Zoonosis Hypothesis". For example, it is unclear where the "Executive Summary" is intended to end, although I assume it ends at the end of page 11. (It is also possible that Quay's "Executive Summary" is 140 pages, and that the 140 pages I see merely summarize another paper I haven't seen. I hope that's not true, but I can't tell for certain). For another example, page 15 says "The details of the evidence used to arrive at this conclusion is contained in Appendix 1." There is no "Appendix 1" in the paper, although I might guess we're expected to assume that appendix was to begin somewhere between page 12 and the green-highlighted "Evidence." on page 21. Perhaps the most likely start of the missing "Appendix 1" is the following line on page 18 (with bold face and highlighting as in the original, except the original highlighting is green rather than yellow):

Six lines later, Quay writes:

"Taken" is an understatement, as Quay's brief description of the Bayes Theorem was essentially copied and pasted from Jon Seymour's blog, including Seymour's crappy notations for multiplication (e.g. "P(E|H).P(H)") and hatted H (e.g. "P(E|^H)"), which might well be necessary to work around the limitations of software used by Seymour's blog but are inexcusable in a document we're supposed to take seriously as a scientific paper.

On page 19, Quay writes (with bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights the first "independent" in green instead of yellow; I have no idea why he used different colors to highlighted two occurrences of the same word on the same line):

That's an important point. It took me a little time to confirm that all of Quay's adjustments to his prior probabilities were multiplications and divisions that are valid only if the associated bits of evidence are statistically independent. Before commenting on what appear to me to be examples of adjustments based on evidence that is probably not statistically independent, let's look at the paragraph immediately following the paragraph I quoted above.

Some of you might have thought I was exaggerating when I spoke of Quay "pulling an estimate out of thin air", but no. Quay acknowledges the subjectivity of his discount factors.

To illustrate Quay's use of Bayes's Theorem, here is the conclusion of Quay's first adjustment (bolding and highlighting as in the original, except Quay highlights "Starting likehood..." and "Adjusted likelihood..." in green instead of yellow):

As you can see, the adjustment going from "1% laboratory origin" to "4.9%" is explicitly based on assumptions pulled out of the air, although the air used as source here may be more substantial than the air from which some of the paper's other assumptions were extracted.

Here are the three biggest adjustment to Quay's estimated probability of a laboratory origin:
  • Lack of evidence of seroconversion in Wuhan and Shanghai (going from 4.9% to 19.1%)
  • Lack of posterior diversity (from 19.1% to 69.2%)
  • Lack of furin cleavage sites in any other sarbecovirus (from 69.2% to 95.3%)
The explicitly subjective discount factors Quay pulled out of thin air to come up with those adjustments are:



I have absolutely no competence in virology or any other biological science, but my remarks above explain why I am not at all impressed by Quay's paper.

Thanks very much! Your evaluation of his paper definitely seems to match my impression of it.

I also wondered where the numbers were coming from so I guess the answer is just out of thin air.

In addition, for a paper that is presumably submitted to journals for peer review, it seems odd that there were none of the usual features of a research paper such as an abstract, methodology, results, discussion and conclusion. The tables are not numbered and labeled (e.g: Table 1: Sunmary of Bayesian Analysis), and, as you pointed out, he uses unconventional headings, so it is not clear where one starts and ends. There is absolutely no hope for this paper getting into a respectable, non-pay-for-play, journal, so it doesn’t give me any confidence that the parts I have no expertise in will be handled any better.

It also seems odd that you would have a sole author outside of his field of expertise writing his own paper when he could have teamed up with the relevant experts - say, a virologist, a molecular biologist and an expert in Bayesian analysis (or at least someone competent). My understanding is that you would need to use a tried and tested method and then apply it evenly to case you are investigating so that if anyone wanted to check Quay’s work they could apply the same methodology. Looking at what he has done, I can’t see any way the results of this piece of research could hope to be replicated because, as you say, he seems to be just assigning arbitrary values.

So, now he has finally teamed up with someone, and that is a physicist called Richard Muller, and they have written an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal. However, it is not clear what expertise he brings. In their op-ed piece they concentrate a lot on the particular structure of the furin cleavage site. They point out that no other coronaviruses in their class share a particular structure which is something often used to modify viruses. I think that is what the actual virologist, David Baltimore, was quoted as saying was a “smoking gun” of lab origins. However, he has since walked it back and many other virologists have since pointed out that it is not a smoking gun at all. For Quay and Muller’s part they say something like “Yes, it could have evolved naturally, but do you believe that?” Or something to that effect. This is simply an argument from incredulity. Again, I cannot work out by myself how likely it is that the virus is likely to be natural or not and I very much doubt that anyone without expertise in the field can do that, which is why Quay’s paper has to be treated with suspicion at the very least. Besides, given that it has no hope of being published in a reputable journal, and given that no virologists take it seriously, I don’t see any reason to waste more time on it.

Oh, and again, this answers Skeptic Ginger’s question of why that review paper ignored Quay’s paper; it is pretty obviously rubbish.
 
... Oh, and again, this answers Skeptic Ginger’s question of why that review paper ignored Quay’s paper; it is pretty obviously rubbish.
And Bloom's?

Quay and Bloom were examples of papers not addressed. It was the very last 2 lines in my critique of Capsid's cite.
SG said:
While relying on the WHO report, a number of research findings are left out. Quay and Bloom are not mentioned. If this is supposed to be a thorough unbiased assessment, it simply isn't.

Are you going to use the cherry picked reference to Quay and skip right over the rest of my critique?
 
And Bloom's?

Quay and Bloom were examples of papers not addressed. It was the very last 2 lines in my critique of Capsid's cite.


Are you going to use the cherry picked reference to Quay and skip right over the rest of my critique?

*sigh* I already mentioned that Bloom’s paper is not evidence of lab leak or spillover.

I’m not “cherry-picking”; the problem is that when responding to your Gish Gallops, I don’t have time to address every single issue you raise which is a mixture of speculation, appeal to crappy papers, assertions without evidence, insinuations of corruption, and demands to read hundreds of pages or technical reports that I have already stated that I am not qualified to assess.

You hate it when people say the lab leak is a conspiracy theory, and that’s fine. But your reasoning and style very much borrows from the playbook of conspiracy theorists: non-experts, cynicism, low quality evidence, grand narratives, claims that “they” are in the pay of larger forces, or threatened etc, heavily politicized commentary.
 
I'll see that crap TA and raise you one. There's a lot in this paper, it's quite thorough and well sourced, but I want to draw people's attention to a few things.

JUNE 4, 2021
A Chinese PhD Thesis Sheds Important New Light On The Origin of the COVID-19 Coronavirus
[Note a PhD thesis is peer reviewed.]
However, the two sentences in Zhou et al., (2020) describing RaTG13 allayed any fears:

“We then found that a short region of RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) from a bat coronavirus (BatCoV RaTG13)*–which was previously detected in Rhinolophus affinis from Yunnan province–showed high sequence identity to 2019-nCoV. We carried out full-length sequencing on this RNA sample (GISAID accession number EPI_ISL_402131).”

This statement clearly implied that, prior to the pandemic, WIV researchers had only ever studied a ‘short’ fragment of RaTG13, that the fragment was unpublished (since no prior description was cited), and that no recent research had been carried out on RaTG13 or its sample. Consequently, a lab leak involving RaTG13 was implausible.

But all these inferences turned out to be untrue. Zhou et al. was one of the pandemic’s key misinformation superspreaders. ...

Moreover, these early RaTG13 sequences went far beyond a short fragment, encompassing most of the genome (Rahalkar and Bahulikar, 2020a).

In November 2020 Nature published an addendum to Zhou et al. in which Zheng-li Shi and her co-authors conceded these points. They wrote:

“In 2018…..we performed further sequencing of these bat viruses and obtained almost the full-length genome sequence (without the 5′ and 3′ ends) of RaTG13.”

Thus the RaTG13 genome sequence was mostly deciphered in 2018 and not in January 2020. Ergo, the viral genome most similar to SARS-CoV-2 was being studied at the WIV before the pandemic broke out.

But why hide this activity?...
The history of collecting and studying the viral genome is described. It was collected in the Yunnan mine where the 6 miners were infected back in 2013.

According to their own words, it would therefore be surprising had Zheng-li Shi’s group not gone on to study BtCoV/4991 aka RaTG13.

The Chinese master's thesis from that time period is reviewed. I posted a link to that earlier but there's another one in this paper.

The Master’s thesis thus raised a host of questions. Why did the Ge et al. 2016 publication (from Zheng-li Shi’s lab), which sampled the mine on multiple occasions, make no mention of the outbreak that caused them to be sampling there in the first place? Why did Zheng-li Shi tell Scientific American in March 2020 that the miners died of a fungal infection? Why did her Zhou et al. 2020 publication rename BtCov/4991 as RaTG13 without explanation or even referencing the earlier work on BtCov/4991 or its mine origin? ...

Are we to presume that an apparent textbook case of a zoonotic spillover, significant enough at the time to be covered by Science magazine, was in the end simply ignored?


One proposed hypothesis:
The theory was stimulated chiefly by two observations. The first was that some of the miners with the mystery disease were ill for about five months (April to September, 2012). The second key observation was the assertion in the Master’s thesis that diagnostic samples taken from four of the miners were sent to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

What we proposed, in short, is that the miners contracted one, or maybe multiple, RaTG13-like bat coronaviruses in the mine. The long hospitalization of the miners enabled the initial bat virus to evolve into a human coronavirus by providing conditions similar to extended viral passaging. The diagnostic samples sent to the WIV therefore contained a humanised virus and we proposed it was similar, or even identical, to SARS-CoV-2.


Deception:
n their November addendum Zheng-li Shi and her colleagues at the WIV confirmed receiving thirteen serum samples–taken at approximately monthly intervals in 2012–from four of the hospitalised miners. But here there is a major discrepancy. Referring to the miner serum samples, the addendum states:
I'll let people read the addendum for themselves. Here is the implication:
The implication is that, though various tests were performed at the WIV, SARS-CoV-2 was not found and no evidence for any other coronavirus was found either.

This obviously contradicts the Master’s thesis.

The difference between these two positions is crucial. If a coronavirus of any kind was found in the miners’ samples it would likely alter our whole understanding of the pandemic origin.

This is because every possible effort would surely have been made to identify it, grow it in cultured human cells, sequence its genome, characterise its infectivity, and much more. There are two primary reasons for this.

First, discovering a coronavirus infection in the miners would triumphantly vindicate the basic research premise of Zheng-li Shi and the WIV. Their pitch is that bat coronaviruses are dangerous pathogens that may at any moment jump to humans and other animals.

Second, a novel coronavirus in the miners would represent a veritable research bonanza: a highly lethal zoonotic disease outbreak caught in the act.

By the same token, if a coronavirus was found in the 2012 miners’ samples it would surely also mean that subsequent research, presumably at the WIV, has been concealed.


There is another relevant Chinese thesis, this one for a doctorate:
For many months, a scientific document has been shared on the internet that appears to shed much light on the fate of samples taken from the mine and the miners, as well as the broader context. It is a translation of a Chinese PhD thesis originally written in 2016. Like the Master’s thesis it also was found on the Chinese thesis database by @TheSeeker268. Its English title is “Novel Virus Discovery in Bat and the Exploration of Receptor of Bat Coronavirus HKU9”. (Download the Chinese PhD thesis here)
The Seeker is part of DRASTIC. A translation of the thesis is in this paper.

A discussion of the antibody testing of 4 of the miners found they had antibodies to SARS but since SARS had not been around since 2003, the antibodies represented a related virus infection had caused the pneumonia. Had those miners actually had SARS in 2012 it would have been a new outbreak and would have been in the headlines at the time.

Since it is not easy to dismiss, this assertion of multiple positive tests is a fact of great significance. As we and others have suggested, it seems likely that the miners had COVID-like symptoms because they were infected with a SARS-like coronavirus.

If so, researchers at the WIV have attempted to hide that diagnosis.


Multiple visits to the mines and what and where specimens were collected and taken is discussed in detail including citations.

More deceit:
Nevertheless, the March 2021 WHO report, like the earlier Scientific American interview, attributes the miners’ illnesses to a fungal infection (WHO Annex, p131). However, it should be emphasized that, once again, this mention of a fungal origin by the WHO is not supported by anydata or cited evidence. Nor is there any suggestion that fungal biologists investigated the outbreak. The case for a fungal outbreak is therefore very weak....

This quite lengthy list of interested laboratories goes beyond those listed in the Master’s thesis, but is not surprising. A lethal disease outbreak originating from bats with a probable viral aetiology is not an everyday occurrence. The previous one in China was declared a pandemic: the first SARS outbreak in 2002. Hence, top virology labs in China, such as those of George Gao, Zhong Nanshan, Zheng-li Shi and Qi Jin became involved in investigating the outbreak....

There are strong signs that plenty of this emerging infectious coronavirus research remains unpublished, even those parts that are highly connected to the origins of the pandemic.
Lots of missing data and the data taken offline are discussed in detail.

Congress has sent a letter to Daszak asking him to provide a lot of data he was clearly working on and asking him why he has tried to cover up anything related to a lab origin.

The Congressional letter raises many questions pertinent to any investigation of the virus’ origin. What is altered by the revelations of the PhD is to render much more compelling the probability, first asserted in the Master’s thesis, that there was a coronavirus in medical samples taken from the miners. This in turn serves to underline the obvious inconsistencies and omissions of Zhou et al. 2020 and especially its addendum. These flaws make the likelihood that the Mojiang mine played a key role in the COVID-19 outbreak seem ever more plausible and the need to obtain samples and sequences still more urgent.


More to follow. :popcorn1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom