Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you are looking at the WIV headquarters building. The BSL-4 lab itself is reported as being in the Zhengdian Scientific Park in the Jiangxia District which about right.

https://lssf.cas.cn/en/facilities-view.jsp?id=ff8080814ff56599014ff59e677e003d

How much of what the Chinese media reports as the location of important things is an accurate reflection of the actual location of important things?

I propose that if you don't know the answer to this question, you have no business appealing to the Chinese media in any serious debate.
 
How much of what the Chinese media reports as the location of important things is an accurate reflection of the actual location of important things?

I propose that if you don't know the answer to this question, you have no business appealing to the Chinese media in any serious debate.

It’s pretty simple. You can see photographs of the WIV and then you can match it with satellite images as well.
 
How much of what the Chinese media reports as the location of important things is an accurate reflection of the actual location of important things?

I propose that if you don't know the answer to this question, you have no business appealing to the Chinese media in any serious debate.

There is mistrust of China then there is stupidity. You've crossed the line to the latter. It's impossible to hide the location of the lab from western virologists who visit it, nor is there any need to hide it's location in the first place.
 
There is mistrust of China then there is stupidity. You've crossed the line to the latter. It's impossible to hide the location of the lab from western virologists who visit it, nor is there any need to hide it's location in the first place.

Yes, it is indeed very silly to assume that China would be able to hide the location of a well-known Virology lab.

That said, it can be confusing when looking on Google Maps. It appears everything is wrong on Google Maps when looking at China.

The best thing to do is to go to Baidu Maps and copy and paste Chinese name for things. Several locations appeared when I did that and one of them seemed to match the place that appears on the paper.

I am assuming that it is accurate, as it really would make no sense for respected scientists to attempt to get through peer review by making up the location of a well-known site.
 
An in depth critique.

https://zenodo.org/record/5075888

Most of the points raised here are discussed.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

One of the things I did find interesting in a quick skim of the beginning of the paper is this:

Animal traders working in 2003, without a SARS diagnosis, were documented to have high levels of IgG to SARS-CoV (13% overall and >50% for traders specializing in civets7). Subsequent serological surveys found ~3% positivity rates to SARS-CoV related (SARSr-CoV) viruses in residents of Yunnan province living close to bat caves 8, demonstrating regular exposure in rural locations.

I have to wonder then if it would support my personal hypothesis that there may be some people who may have been exposed to SARS-CoV-2 for some time, maybe even on a generational level, in small rural farms rearing certain wildlife.

Maybe this is already a working hypothesis among many virologists and other scientists....
 
One of the things I did find interesting in a quick skim of the beginning of the paper is this:



I have to wonder then if it would support my personal hypothesis that there may be some people who may have been exposed to SARS-CoV-2 for some time, maybe even on a generational level, in small rural farms rearing certain wildlife.

Maybe this is already a working hypothesis among many virologists and other scientists....

Possibly, but you'd only expect it in the region the virus originated and this isn't known yet. While the closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 have been identified in the Yunnan the paper makes the point that there is a major sampling bias and that the viruses identified there are decades removed from that area are still decades removed from the MRCA with SARS-CoV-2.

The presence of Covid-19 reactive antibodies in bats and pangolins in Thailand suggests you'd need to look further to the South East to find rural areas where people were exposed as well.
 
Possibly, but you'd only expect it in the region the virus originated and this isn't known yet. While the closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 have been identified in the Yunnan the paper makes the point that there is a major sampling bias and that the viruses identified there are decades removed from that area are still decades removed from the MRCA with SARS-CoV-2.

The presence of Covid-19 reactive antibodies in bats and pangolins in Thailand suggests you'd need to look further to the South East to find rural areas where people were exposed as well.

Yes, indeed. And the paper also says that while some of those viruses don't have as much of the genetic similarity to SARS-CoV-2 they seem to share a more recent common ancestor (is this correct?).

What I take away from this is that finding the trail of the virus is going to be like looking for a needle in a haystack, but that there clearly needs to be more international involvement and China needs to cooperate more on this.

Sure there may be areas of sensitivity, but this affects everyone across the globe.
 
Yes, indeed. And the paper also says that while some of those viruses don't have as much of the genetic similarity to SARS-CoV-2 they seem to share a more recent common ancestor (is this correct?).

What I take away from this is that finding the trail of the virus is going to be like looking for a needle in a haystack, but that there clearly needs to be more international involvement and China needs to cooperate more on this.

Sure there may be areas of sensitivity, but this affects everyone across the globe.

This paper says so. I saw the references in the source paper they are citing as well but it wasn't quite as clear to me what this meant in terms of MRCA. Recombination really complicates this since different parts of the virus genome may have different MRCA.

The source paper they are citing said something to the effect that these other viruses were more similar to SARS-CoV-2 if you exclude the spike itself. The RaTG13 spike is more closely related than these other viruses, but if you look at the Receptor Binding Domain it's closer to different viruses again. There is at least one recombination event in play, possibly more and there is a lot of bat specific evolution in RaTG13.


picture.php


picture.php


picture.php
 
This paper says so. I saw the references in the source paper they are citing as well but it wasn't quite as clear to me what this meant in terms of MRCA. Recombination really complicates this since different parts of the virus genome may have different MRCA.

The source paper they are citing said something to the effect that these other viruses were more similar to SARS-CoV-2 if you exclude the spike itself. The RaTG13 spike is more closely related than these other viruses, but if you look at the Receptor Binding Domain it's closer to different viruses again. There is at least one recombination event in play, possibly more and there is a lot of bat specific evolution in RaTG13.


[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1416&pictureid=12844[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1416&pictureid=12845[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1416&pictureid=12846[/qimg]

Ah! I see. So the recombination is ultimately what makes it very different even if it had a more recent common ancestor.

But I guess an important point here is that the Yunnan caves cannot be assumed to be the only source of SARS-CoV2 as something like it has left the caves after diverging from RaTG-13
 
To be fair, some of what you cite is probably not even considered evidence. Bloom’s paper is evidence of…what? Some data was deleted? But what does that prove?

As for Quay, I don’t even know if anyone takes his work seriously. Have any of his papers been published?

Come on, get real. The paper cites the WHO report that doesn't support the claim other markets were the source of the earliest cases in Wuhan.

The fact the Chinese removed access to material and won't cooperate with the investigation is cited by multiple sources and no one has denied it happened.

Bloom is a top notch scientist at one of the most important research facilities in this country: Fred Hutch. His finding of deleted genomic data in the cloud was an important element in the search for the origin of COVID 19.

Quay has more than 300 published papers. And oh look, one of his papers on the origin of COVID was "preprinted" in the same publication as Capsid's paper: A Bayesian analysis concludes beyond a reasonable doubt that SARS-CoV-2 is not a natural zoonosis but instead is laboratory derived and they are both "preprints" not yet peer reviewed. Quay's is original work and Capsid's is a "review". Despite all those scientists that signed on to the review, it is still a preprint.


But you guys go ahead and discuss your denial and hypotheses. The evidence will resolve this issue and that paper was not it.
 
Come on, get real. The paper cites the WHO report that doesn't support the claim other markets were the source of the earliest cases in Wuhan.

The fact the Chinese removed access to material and won't cooperate with the investigation is cited by multiple sources and no one has denied it happened.

Bloom is a top notch scientist at one of the most important research facilities in this country: Fred Hutch. His finding of deleted genomic data in the cloud was an important element in the search for the origin of COVID 19.

Quay has more than 300 published papers. And oh look, one of his papers on the origin of COVID was "preprinted" in the same publication as Capsid's paper: A Bayesian analysis concludes beyond a reasonable doubt that SARS-CoV-2 is not a natural zoonosis but instead is laboratory derived and they are both "preprints" not yet peer reviewed. Quay's is original work and Capsid's is a "review". Despite all those scientists that signed on to the review, it is still a preprint.


But you guys go ahead and discuss your denial and hypotheses. The evidence will resolve this issue and that paper was not it.

Of course Bloom is a well-qualified scientist, as are they, but I was asking what the relevance of his paper is. It is NOT evidence of a lab leak as it requires a number of steps and assumptions and accusations to get to lab leak.

As for Quay, he may be in the same stage of the peer review process but remember that it is still a pre-print. The fact that it hasn’t yet been through peer-review might be one reason why they don’t want to cite the research. I actually don’t understand why you find that unusual. If I uploaded a paper to a pre-print server would it suddenly make my paper just as likely to be good research as all the other papers there or would it make a difference if I was writing outside my field? The answer is obvious. From what I can see, nobody really seems to be taking Quay’s research seriously (apart from some motivated politicians in Congress).
 
Of course Bloom is a well-qualified scientist, as are they, but I was asking what the relevance of his paper is. It is NOT evidence of a lab leak as it requires a number of steps and assumptions and accusations to get to lab leak.
It is evidence they don't have information the Chinese are hiding. It wasn't even mentioned in the paper.

In addition if you read Bloom's paper, he found that some cases diagnosed in Guangdong actually were infected in Wuhan and he cautions researchers to get more information before plugging a case into a time and place on the timeline. Again, not even mentioned despite the Capsid link attributing cases to exposure outside of Wuhan. (But I'd have to go look at those details.)

As for Quay, he may be in the same stage of the peer review process but remember that it is still a pre-print. The fact that it hasn’t yet been through peer-review might be one reason why they don’t want to cite the research. I actually don’t understand why you find that unusual. If I uploaded a paper to a pre-print server would it suddenly make my paper just as likely to be good research as all the other papers there or would it make a difference if I was writing outside my field? The answer is obvious. From what I can see, nobody really seems to be taking Quay’s research seriously (apart from some motivated politicians in Congress).
Their own paper had not been through peer review and you are imagining they didn't want to cite work from 6 months ago because it hadn't been through peer review? :rolleyes:


It could have easily been handled in the review by saying it wasn't considered while acknowledging it existed.

That 'review' was written with a clear bias, I cited reasons for that conclusion and you are making up stuff to rationalize that bias valid.

Show me where in the WHO paper it supports other markets in Wuhan being the documented source of early cases.

Show me where in the paper they acknowledge the lack of cooperation by the Chinese or that some information in the WHO report was based on being supplied conclusions by the Chinese and not the work that got them there. (For example, the claim none of the researchers tested positive for past COVID infection was unverified.)

Show me where in the paper they acknowledged work they had not considered.

Show me that they recognized cases from Guangdong had been infected in Wuhan.

Show me where in that paper they discussed or described the limitations of the WHO final report.​

And IMO they should have at least mentioned the whole Lancet/Daszak conflict of interest issue especially given Daszak remained on the WHO team.
 
Last edited:
It is evidence they don't have information the Chinese are hiding. It wasn't even mentioned in the paper.

In addition if you read Bloom's paper, he found that some cases diagnosed in Guangdong actually were infected in Wuhan and he cautions researchers to get more information before plugging a case into a time and place on the timeline. Again, not even mentioned despite the Capsid link attributing cases to exposure outside of Wuhan. (But I'd have to go look at those details.)

Their own paper had not been through peer review and you are imagining they didn't want to cite work from 6 months ago because it hadn't been through peer review? :rolleyes:


It could have easily been handled in the review by saying it wasn't considered while acknowledging it existed.

That 'review' was written with a clear bias, I cited reasons for that conclusion and you are making up stuff to rationalize that bias valid.

Show me where in the WHO paper it supports other markets in Wuhan being the documented source of early cases.

Show me where in the paper they acknowledge the lack of cooperation by the Chinese or that some information in the WHO report was based on being supplied conclusions by the Chinese and not the work that got them there. (For example, the claim none of the researchers tested positive for past COVID infection was unverified.)

Show me where in the paper they acknowledged work they had not considered.

Show me that they recognized cases from Guangdong had been infected in Wuhan.

Show me where in that paper they discussed or described the limitations of the WHO final report.​

And IMO they should have at least mentioned the whole Lancet/Daszak conflict of interest issue especially given Daszak remained on the WHO team.

This is just repeating stuff that we have already talked about.

I get it, you find the pre-print insufficiently cynical and accusatory, but that is not the type of thing that you are likely to find in a scientific paper. They are not going to start writing about how Peter Daszak and the Chinese can't be trusted.

Steven Quay's "Bayesian analysis" claims that there is a 99.8% chance that the virus has a lab origin. Why has this not received far more attention if it truly is a game-changer?

But from what I can see, he is not an expert in virology nor in stats or Bayesian analysis.

If you have a single author of a paper way outside the field of their expertise making ground-breaking claims then, well, I wonder if a Bayesian analysis of that would show how likely it is that the paper is a good one...

This is part of his table which shows the main steps he takes to go from near certainty of zoonosis to near-certainty of lab origin...
 

Attachments

  • Summary of evidence Quay.jpg
    Summary of evidence Quay.jpg
    44.6 KB · Views: 11
This is just repeating stuff that we have already talked about.
Of course we've already talked about it! Nothing in Capsid's cite was new either.

I take this as a refusal to discuss the actual evidence. I can see why you prefer to ignore it, brush it off under false pretenses, claim Quay isn't the right kind of expert when he clearly is, cherry pick something from one of Quay's papers because I cited that one rather than just tell people to go find it in the thread, that's all you and others on the the natural spillover side in this thread do.

But that's OK. The evidence isn't going away.

:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
Besides, I have a question for you, SG.

Why do you think it is that neither the Piplani et. al paper nor the Bloom paper have cited Quay either?

Wouldn't their papers be good supports for the Quay claim?

In fact, I would be interested to see if any reputable researchers have cited Quay.
 
Of course we've already talked about it! Nothing in Capsid's cite was new either.

I take this as a refusal to discuss the actual evidence. I can see why you prefer to ignore it, brush it off under false pretenses, claim Quay isn't the right kind of expert when he clearly is, cherry pick something from one of Quay's papers because I cited that one rather than just tell people to go find it in the thread, that's all you and others on the the natural spillover side in this thread do.

But that's OK. The evidence isn't going away.

:popcorn1

He really isn't.
 
Besides, I have a question for you, SG.

Why do you think it is that neither the Piplani et. al paper nor the Bloom paper have cited Quay either?

Wouldn't their papers be good supports for the Quay claim?

In fact, I would be interested to see if any reputable researchers have cited Quay.
Neither Piplani nor Bloom wrote a review compiling the evidence then posting a position. D'uh!
 
Neither Piplani nor Bloom wrote a review compiling the evidence then posting a position. D'uh!

Why not? You believe that Piplani and Bloom both support a lab-leak theory. According to Quay it is a cast-iron certainty that it escpaed from a lab. If you believe Quay, Piplani and Bloom's work would be superfluous.

It seems to me you are keeping two sets of books. On the one hand you argue that Quay's paper is a good one, but that would end all doubt on the matter. And yet, absolutely nobody reputable takes it seriously.

:rolleyes:

Attack the arguer when you can't address the argument, yep.

That's why peer review is not done by randomly chosen people but people with the necessary credentials.

I cannot check Andrew Wiles's sums to find out whether or not he solved Fermat's last theorem, that has to be done by qualified mathematicians.

I cannot claim any expertise on what values I should assign seroprevalaence in Wuhan and Shanghai etc.. or what values I should assigne to "opportunity" or to lack of posterior diversity or the rarity of particular structures within wild viruses over lab viruses etc...

All I can do is note the dog that didn't bark evidence that nobody with such credentials seems to have found his work persuasive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom