Angrysoba, I don't see you addressing the sources I cited. You still insist on repackaging my position(s) and arguing with those distortions.
Yes, "near the time" because that is what multiple sources I cited said.
And yes the timeframe is still late in 2019 be it Sept, Oct, or Nov because again those are from the source citations. I'm not aware any of them say the first detected case is patient zero.
I don't care whether the sources all say Sept because they don't don't say when patient zero was. As for the Chinese taking data offline in Sept, the Chinese have not had a good explanation for why that happened. Dr Bloom, the Fred Hutch researcher who found some of the deleted genome segments in the cloud, asked and has not received an answer as to why that genome data was removed from the NIH files by the Chinese researcher who put it there initially.
And you have to understand the evidence is accumulating here. More and more pieces are falling into place. So if you want to try some gotcha with the Sept data removal because whatever in your mind contradicts that, then you aren't looking at the total picture.
It depends on the sources. Are we talking about papers by Yuri Deigin etc? Are we talking about papers by DRASTIC? Are we talking about papers by Stephen Quay? Or the paper by Bloom?
Because I don’t feel any need to read and respond to papers that are not peer reviewed. I have no competence to check the workings of molecular biologists. I have no independent way of analyzing particular claims that are made in papers especially if they have not made it into reputable journals. If the authors cannot do that, then I have no reason to think that the papers are doing the science properly.
In addition, of those that have been published in reputable journals, many of them don’t, for me, push the needle closer to lab leak. At best they are often ambiguous (the Bloom paper, for example) or the one you are now claiming is another piece in the puzzle, seems to me to be ambiguous because it fits my hypothesis as well as yours.
I cannot claim any scientific expertise in this which is why I don’t engage in analyzing the papers. The only thing I can do is check the logic of the claims and to see which ones seem to fit the expectations of the majority of expert virologists etc…
Whenever we see a “new smoking gun” from one day to the next, we also get a furrowing of the collective brows of virologists who are usually pretty unimpressed.
Now, why is it that most virologists do not see the lab leak hypothesis as most likely (and that IS the view of most virologists as I have pointed out many times in the past)?
We could either argue that the virologists are just dummies who don’t know their field as well as Deigin, Quay and Weinstein.
Or we could argue that Peter Daszak has weaved some kind of spell of enchantment over the virologists (or maybe paid them off) or maybe threatened them with death - in which case we are definitely in CT territory.
Or is it because even though there are a number of virologists who see lab leak as “possible” they actually think it is, on balance, unlikely and not the best explanation for what we know?
It seems to me that the latter is the case and therefore it is the one I am going with.