Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
On puhleese. :rolleyes:

Oh puhleese what? She was the only non Chinese person working in the most secure part of the lab. She was asked to and did (with another scientist) investigate claims that the virus leaked from the lab and did not find evidence that it did.

Your dismissal of her (and everyone else who doesn’t buy your lab origin story) is very telling.
 
Yes. But as I pointed out, people become violently ill with SARS and MERS so it is easier to pick up the trail, quicker than it is for Covid where we are still in the dark about who was even the first case, and whether the first case may have been months before the first known one. Your reasoning simultaneously relies on the idea it had been hanging since September spreading stealthily through Wuhan and also that we should have easily been able to trace the pathogen back to its source from the first known cases in December if it had been zoonotic.

I’m arguing that since we don’t know where the first cases actually were that we can’t make such definite claims about how there was no spillover in the markets or that no intermediate, amplifying host animals exist, etc…

We are well past this. We don't know who was patient zero but more than one researcher has concluded the pandemic started abruptly very near the time the first cases were found.

Multiple sources cited here found no epidemiological evidence for any outbreaks elsewhere in China prior to the initial case.

You should address those papers rather than ignoring them and repeating your hypotheses about what could have happened.
 
Oh puhleese what? She was the only non Chinese person working in the most secure part of the lab. She was asked to and did (with another scientist) investigate claims that the virus leaked from the lab and did not find evidence that it did.

Your dismissal of her (and everyone else who doesn’t buy your lab origin story) is very telling.
I did not dismiss the woman by ignoring her qualifications. Why do you feel the need to make up something I never said downplaying her credentials.

I did no such thing.

As for dismissing anyone who doesn't agree with the lab accident hypothesis, that's nonsense as well.

I have been posting in-depth research papers by qualified virologists among the scientists.

It would be nice if you'd actually read the science before trying to lump me in with non-evidence based claimants.
 
Last edited:
You think that has the weight of a queen on a chessboard? :rolleyes:

Compared to your illusory pawn, absolutely.

You continue to push (very hard) a conspiracy theory that still has no evidence whatsoever.

I am amused by the effort and time you're spending on it - so much time and effort that I'm in two minds as to whether you're trying (and failing) to convince others, or yourself.
 
To clarify why I don't find that particular 'testimony' to be very strong evidence:

It's one anecdote.

There's no way she was aware of who all associated with the WIV who might have been ill in Nov. I am not aware of a single person who claimed Shi herself had been ill.

There's no way she could possibly know biosafety protocols were meticulously followed at all the labs in at the university let alone all the labs in the Wuhan area let alone that all the students followed strict protocols. And upthread papers have been cited that noted the level 2 and 3 biosafety labs also worked with coronaviruses.

And in that last citation of the testimony, it's chock full of straw men arguments.

So one anecdote vs dozens of research papers cited in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Compared to your illusory pawn, absolutely.

You continue to push (very hard) a conspiracy theory that still has no evidence whatsoever.

I am amused by the effort and time you're spending on it - so much time and effort that I'm in two minds as to whether you're trying (and failing) to convince others, or yourself.
You are back to attacking me while not addressing any of the research cited.

Take that CT crap to the other ******* thread or post quotes of mine you are basing it on.


Thank you.
 
We are well past this. We don't know who was patient zero but more than one researcher has concluded the pandemic started abruptly very near the time the first cases were found.

Multiple sources cited here found no epidemiological evidence for any outbreaks elsewhere in China prior to the initial case.

You should address those papers rather than ignoring them and repeating your hypotheses about what could have happened.

“Near the time” could be late November or it could be …. according to YOUR hypothesis (despite no confirmatory or even supporting evidence) in early September. Obviously this is important because a major plank of your hypothesis rests on the pulling of the databases (which occurred in September) or your claimed lockdown of Wuhan in October (despite no evidence) or the sick workers from the WIV (apparently in November according to the sketchiest ever reports). If you are now saying that this happened before the outbreak then you have to toss them away as no longer something even you can believe.

And on the “no other outbreaks outside of Wuhan”, that misses the point of MY hypothesis. If it came from a wildlife farm in a rural area then maybe the only people exposed to the pathogen were already immune and thus they wouldn’t have sought medical help. That might also explain why the pathogen was so adapted to the human ACE receptor. The small holding farm may have simply sent their animals to Wuhan in the wake of increased demand due to the previous year’s mass culling of pigs (the policy brought in to stop swine flu) and then the animals and / or humans spread it in Wuhan.

Do I have evidence to support this? No! But no more than you have to support lab leak. But mine has a certain parsimony because you also need to explain how the WIV secretly had SARS CoV2 but never told anyone that they were working on it and never put it on any databases that could have been spotted by other researchers etc… you could argue that the Chinese government took down the databases and hushed everyone up but now you need to argue for clairvoyance on their behalf because you have just argued that the pathogen only got out just before the first known case, not months before. And the f course if they knew that why hadn’t they stopped the virus altogether?
 
To clarify why I don't find that particular 'testimony' to be very strong evidence:

It's one anecdote.

There's no way she was aware of who all associated with the WIV who might have been ill in Nov. I am not aware of a single person who claimed Shi herself had been ill.

There's no way she could possibly know biosafety protocols were meticulously followed at all the labs in at the university let alone all the labs in the Wuhan area let alone that all the students followed strict protocols. And upthread papers have been cited that noted the level 2 and 3 biosafety labs also worked with coronaviruses.

And in that last citation of the testimony, it's chock full of straw men arguments.

So one anecdote vs dozens of research papers cited in this thread.

Apparently the appropriate BSL for SARS CoV2 is BSL-3. Maybe Capsid could confirm or not. So it is. It unusual that the WIV used that level or even less for some of their work with bats particularly if there was no reason to suspect a deadly infection was within them.

I have also seen some pictures or WIV scientists doing work in bat caves with full body coverings.

I know that there are definitely reasons to be concerned about some of the researchers doing work in bat caves in China and I have read about it in Spillover as well.

That said, it is still only circumstancial evidence.
 
Angrysoba, I don't see you addressing the sources I cited. You still insist on repackaging my position(s) and arguing with those distortions.

Yes, "near the time" because that is what multiple sources I cited said.

And yes the timeframe is still late in 2019 be it Sept, Oct, or Nov because again those are from the source citations. I'm not aware any of them say the first detected case is patient zero.

I don't care whether the sources all say Sept because they don't don't say when patient zero was. As for the Chinese taking data offline in Sept, the Chinese have not had a good explanation for why that happened. Dr Bloom, the Fred Hutch researcher who found some of the deleted genome segments in the cloud, asked and has not received an answer as to why that genome data was removed from the NIH files by the Chinese researcher who put it there initially.

And you have to understand the evidence is accumulating here. More and more pieces are falling into place. So if you want to try some gotcha with the Sept data removal because whatever in your mind contradicts that, then you aren't looking at the total picture.
 
Angrysoba, I don't see you addressing the sources I cited. You still insist on repackaging my position(s) and arguing with those distortions.

Yes, "near the time" because that is what multiple sources I cited said.

And yes the timeframe is still late in 2019 be it Sept, Oct, or Nov because again those are from the source citations. I'm not aware any of them say the first detected case is patient zero.

I don't care whether the sources all say Sept because they don't don't say when patient zero was. As for the Chinese taking data offline in Sept, the Chinese have not had a good explanation for why that happened. Dr Bloom, the Fred Hutch researcher who found some of the deleted genome segments in the cloud, asked and has not received an answer as to why that genome data was removed from the NIH files by the Chinese researcher who put it there initially.

And you have to understand the evidence is accumulating here. More and more pieces are falling into place. So if you want to try some gotcha with the Sept data removal because whatever in your mind contradicts that, then you aren't looking at the total picture.

It depends on the sources. Are we talking about papers by Yuri Deigin etc? Are we talking about papers by DRASTIC? Are we talking about papers by Stephen Quay? Or the paper by Bloom?

Because I don’t feel any need to read and respond to papers that are not peer reviewed. I have no competence to check the workings of molecular biologists. I have no independent way of analyzing particular claims that are made in papers especially if they have not made it into reputable journals. If the authors cannot do that, then I have no reason to think that the papers are doing the science properly.

In addition, of those that have been published in reputable journals, many of them don’t, for me, push the needle closer to lab leak. At best they are often ambiguous (the Bloom paper, for example) or the one you are now claiming is another piece in the puzzle, seems to me to be ambiguous because it fits my hypothesis as well as yours.

I cannot claim any scientific expertise in this which is why I don’t engage in analyzing the papers. The only thing I can do is check the logic of the claims and to see which ones seem to fit the expectations of the majority of expert virologists etc…

Whenever we see a “new smoking gun” from one day to the next, we also get a furrowing of the collective brows of virologists who are usually pretty unimpressed.

Now, why is it that most virologists do not see the lab leak hypothesis as most likely (and that IS the view of most virologists as I have pointed out many times in the past)?

We could either argue that the virologists are just dummies who don’t know their field as well as Deigin, Quay and Weinstein.

Or we could argue that Peter Daszak has weaved some kind of spell of enchantment over the virologists (or maybe paid them off) or maybe threatened them with death - in which case we are definitely in CT territory.

Or is it because even though there are a number of virologists who see lab leak as “possible” they actually think it is, on balance, unlikely and not the best explanation for what we know?

It seems to me that the latter is the case and therefore it is the one I am going with.
 
This simply isn't true. The earliest documented cases are from December, some 6 weeks after the jump to humans occurred.

It’s not clear what “near the time” means when Skeptic Ginger uses it. I honestly have no idea.

But apparently “near the time” means September. Or later depending on whether or not it fits the other bits of evidence.
 
WA Post June 10, 2021: The media called the ‘lab leak’ story a ‘conspiracy theory.’ Now it’s prompted corrections — and serious new reporting.
The journalistic reconsideration of the lab story has been told not just in probing new stories — The Washington Post has published five stories about it on its front page in the past 2 1/2 weeks, some prompted by President Biden’s order of a 90-day review of the theory by intelligence agencies — but in corrected headlines and in editors’ notes affixed to last year’s stories. New information often casts out old, but it is unusual for news outlets to acknowledge so publicly that they have changed their understanding of events.
Takes a long time to clean the knee-jerk responses to the lab accident out. People just cling to that hand-waving dismissal: CT.


Many scientific experts were dismissive of the leak theory at first, thus validating the early skeptical reporting. As with any story that is new, complex and evolving, conventional wisdom undergoes a metamorphosis as new information arrives. ...

NPR reported in April 2020 that there was “virtually no chance” that the coronavirus was released from a laboratory in China “or anywhere else.” Such an accidental release, it said, “would have required a remarkable series of coincidences and deviations from well-established experimental protocols.”

Other articles and headlines characterized the theory as “false” or “debunked.”

But many of those news organizations have begun to amend their approach in light of a shifting consensus.
Dump's interference with the science is reported in the article.

We have to throw all that political crap out from the alt-right trying to demonize China to certain scientists who poisoned the investigating well back in early 2020.


A kind of tidal change began early last month, seemingly set in motion by two events.

The first was a lengthy review of the known scientific evidence about the lab theory by Nicholas Wade, a veteran science correspondent formerly with the New York Times. Writing in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, Wade deemed the theory plausible and worthy of further investigation. He also excoriated Chinese officials, Western scientists and the news media, accusing them of muddying or suppressing information or merely being uninterested in looking further.

In short order, Science magazine published a letter from 18 scientists who called for an independent investigation. “We must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data,” they wrote. “A proper investigation should be transparent, objective, data-driven, inclusive of broad expertise, subject to independent oversight, and responsibly managed to minimize the impact of conflicts of interest.”

Even now in this WA Po article and in a lot of the current news reports one will find today reporters can't quite bring themselves to take a hard look at the evidence. Better to go from crazy CT to neutral and claim the evidence is thin for either origin story, typical of a lot of news reports.

But the evidence is not "thin" on the lab side of the origin. What is thin on the natural spillover hypothesis is no trace of COVID 19 remnants can be found in any animal species. Nor has anyone found any trace of COVID 19 cases that preceded the Wuhan cases.

What is less "thin" on the lab origin side of the argument is a dozen papers cited here in this thread that go into great detail what specific evidence fits the lab accident hypothesis.

It's not just me saying so.
 
WA Post June 10, 2021: The media called the ‘lab leak’ story a ‘conspiracy theory.’ Now it’s prompted corrections — and serious new reporting.Takes a long time to clean the knee-jerk responses to the lab accident out. People just cling to that hand-waving dismissal: CT.


Dump's interference with the science is reported in the article.

We have to throw all that political crap out from the alt-right trying to demonize China to certain scientists who poisoned the investigating well back in early 2020.




Even now in this WA Po article and in a lot of the current news reports one will find today reporters can't quite bring themselves to take a hard look at the evidence. Better to go from crazy CT to neutral and claim the evidence is thin for either origin story, typical of a lot of news reports.

But the evidence is not "thin" on the lab side of the origin. What is thin on the natural spillover hypothesis is no trace of COVID 19 remnants can be found in any animal species. Nor has anyone found any trace of COVID 19 cases that preceded the Wuhan cases.

What is less "thin" on the lab origin side of the argument is a dozen papers cited here in this thread that go into great detail what specific evidence fits the lab accident hypothesis.

It's not just me saying so.

*yawn*

Nothing new. Just a rehash of what we have seen already and of course you talking about Dump.

I think your references to Dump tell us about YOUR epistemology not that of others. YOU rejected lab leak because of Dump, but just because you are now in favour of lab leak doesn’t mean that others cling to it because of Dump.
 
It wasn't supposed to be anything new, it's an op ed.

It is supposed to get you and others in the thread to stop calling the lab accident hypothesis a CT. It's supposed to get you to stop handwaving away the scientific evidence with various excuses that relieve you from any responsibility to actually look at the evidence. You dismissed the peer reviewed published paper I just posted along with the rest.

I would think you guys would want to know what the actual evidence is.

As far as I can tell the last piece of scientific evidence posted against the lab accident was the fact there were 2 lineages in the early cases. I'm interested. I asked multiple times where/when anyone thinks the lineages diverged. I don't recall seeing an answer.
 
Oh puhleese what? She was the only non Chinese person working in the most secure part of the lab. She was asked to and did (with another scientist) investigate claims that the virus leaked from the lab and did not find evidence that it did.


She never had control. That was the illusion. She was overwhelmed by the power of that place. But she made a mistake, too. She didn't have enough respect for that power and it's out now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom