Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're going to play this dozen-post round the mulberry bush game again when you could post the quote and the citation in a single sentence?

:rolleyes:

I've already quoted YOUR post:
1.) citing the Daily Mail
2.) claiming it is from a forthcoming paper
3.) in which one of the authors claims SARS CoV2 defies the laws of physics

Here you go, an article to be published in a couple of days has been previewed by the Daily Mail. You can get a head start dismissing their thesis. That it's in the Daily Mail with all the accompanying sensational language and that the thesis was rejected last year should give you all some ammo. :cool:

I was going to wait until the paper was published but the Daily Mail has quite a bit of it excerpted already. Scroll down to the actual paper excerpts. They are copy protected so I can't quote from the paper.

EXCLUSIVE: COVID-19 'has NO credible natural ancestor' and WAS created by Chinese scientists who then tried to cover their tracks with 'retro-engineering' to make it seem like it naturally arose from bats, explosive new study claims

I'm sure a number of people in this thread will see the bit about the claims being rejected earlier and dismiss the paper.

The 2 scientists have serious credentials and have authored or co-authored hundreds of papers published in scientific and medical journals.

PubMed: Dalgelish

Who are Angus Dalgleish and Birger Sørensen?


The lower level biosafety labs have been noted in citations in this thread.


I don't have any background in the paper's claim:

One tell-tale sign of alleged manipulation the two men highlighted was a row of four amino acids they found on the SARS-Cov-2 spike.

... Sørensen said the amino acids all have a positive charge, which cause the virus to tightly cling to the negatively charged parts of human cells like a magnet, and so become more infectious.

But because, like magnets, the positively charged amino acids repel each other, it is rare to find even three in a row in naturally occurring organisms, while four in a row is 'extremely unlikely,' the scientist said.

'The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' ...
I understand the positive and negative charges, just not that amino acids have these charges. I'll look for more relevant information on that and await critique by contributors to the thread.


QRB Discovery to save people time looking for the paper when it's published.

Why are you pretending you cannot read your own posts that are right in front of your eyes!?!?

Are you trying to get me carded for spamming by having to repeat myself whenever you tell me you didn't cite the Daily Mail, or you don't recall any discussion of the paper in this thread, or you have no idea what I am talking about when I say "break the laws of physics"?
 
OMG, finally. It took you forever to pull that **** out because???

Ignores 4 pages of clutter...
'The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' ...
There are a couple of citations about the unusual grouping of amino acids. I'll be sure to address that in my summary.

This is your typical cherry picking, BTW. It hardly negates dozens of research papers. You are trying waaaay too hard to lump any researcher with a lab origin hypothesis into the bag of outcasts and fringe researchers. They simply are not.
 
Last edited:
OMG, finally. It took you forever to pull that **** out because???

Holy crap! This is really, really painful.

It did not "take me forever".

It's the same bloody thing I posted to you in Post 1386 and 1389

This is in between you saying, "Are you mixing up the threads again? There is nothing like that in this thread." and "Article to be published in a couple days" is not citing Daily Mail as a source." and followed by "I still don't know what you are talking about breaking the laws of physics."

I repeated the specfic quote again, and you say: "You're going to play this dozen-post round the mulberry bush game again when you could post the quote and the citation in a single sentence?"

Now you say "OMG, finally."

Jesus ******* Christ! Are you being deliberately obtuse? Is this some kind of deliberate trolling or are you simply incapable of reading properly?
 
This is your typical cherry picking, BTW. It hardly negates dozens of research papers. You are trying waaaay too hard to lump any researcher with a lab origin hypothesis into the bag of outcasts and fringe researchers. They simply are not.

No what I said was that you are shovelling very obvious crap without even bothering to do the slightest sniff check.

If you are bothered by "outcasts" and "fringe researchers" etc... then maybe you wouldn't be championing them yourself.

First you insist I read and critique the papers you cite. Then, when I do you predictably complain about me being critical of them.

Tough crap. If you cite BS to support your position, then you have no excuse when your BS is called.
 
And the lab accident moves another pawn forward.

First the news report with some key points: Lab leak theory, once 'political dynamite,' gains credibility in new studyWe all know why, Daszak did his best to poison the well and there were blatant political reasons from Dump pushing the China is guilty crap to supposedly/apparently the US not wanting attention called to the role we played funding the GoF research and a bunch of stuff in between.

But you know that evidence has a way of not going away.
Here's the paper, published in Nature after a year delay: June 24, 2021: In silico comparison of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein-ACE2 binding affinities across species and implications for virus origin

[I learned a new word, in silico meaning in computer models as opposed to in vitro and in vivo.]

What these 4 Aussie researchers found goes with Quay's and other scientists' work, the molecular structure of COVID 19, while not having hallmarks of some military designer bioweapon, does have hallmarks of coming from a lab rather than a natural spillover event. And they lay out their case in meticulous detail in this paper.
As has been brought up by virologists like Dr Redfield, COVID 19 came ready to go right out of the gate:

So not only were none of the animal species a good fit for the COVID 19 spike protein, human cells were a perfect fit.

The actual findings are nothing new at this point, it basically says what I have been telling you for months which is that the SARS-COV-2 spike binds strongly to both human and Pangolin ACE2 but only binds weakly to bat ACE2.


Where they fall apart is in their interpretations of the results, which is no doubt why they had so much trouble getting published. For example they claim recombination events are rare, which couldn’t be farther from the truth. Recombination events that result in novel viruses are common, in fact it’s the primary source for novel RNA viruses. Not only that but there is direct evidence for such a recombination event in the SARS-COV-2 spike.

They also say RaTG13 is a close relative while the Pangolin viruses are not. This is misleading at best. The MRCA of RaTG13 occurred ~30-50 years ago while MRCA of the Pangolin viruses occurred ~100 years.

They say that if there was a recombination event that gave rise to Covid in Pangolins there should have been a Pangolin outbreak and the claim this didn’t happen. There are a bunch of problems with this one. First of all the event that gave rise to the furin cleavage site probably isn’t recent because there are elements of it in a number of close relatives. Second, SARS-COV-2 reactive antibodies have been found in Pangolins so a related virus has been circulating in them somewhat recently. Third, elements of the furin cleavage site are widespread in bat corona viruses indicating it’s an older feature not a recent change so any Pangolin or bat outbreak need not be recent. Forth, since similar spike structures are found in multiple pangolin viruses it’s not new to the species and therefor Covid-19 probably only results in mild illness in Pangolins and even if it is as bad as in humans a 1% death rate wouldn’t be noticed.

Finally they try to suggest the furin cleavage site may be an unintended by-product of gain of function research but again they ignore the evidence against this.
- There is no evidence such research was being conducted in Wuhan at the time
- There is no suitable proximal ancestor such work could have been performed on. (it’s been shown that RaTG13 cannot give rise to SARS-COV-2 from such research)
- Elements of the SARS-COV-2 furin cleavage site are widespread in it’s close relatives, this suggests it’s an ancestral feature.

I’ve mentioned this before but it’s worth saying again. People who claim a lab leak would “explain why we can’t find the proximal ancestor” are being seriously hypocritical because they themselves are advancing a hypothesis that has that problem on top of the numerous other issues.
 
But you are definitely not married to that conclusion. Nope. Nossir.

Where the evidence currently stands, the evidence for a lab accident outweighs a natural event. Show me some evidence of a natural spillover event and I'll change that position.

Reading a couple of recent op eds that note some news sources now have to retract their initial reports which said the lab accident was unlikely, I find them on their usual platform of equal positions regardless of the evidence.

I have the benefit of not being wedded to such a constraint. I can actually look at the available evidence and draw a conclusion. I will say (whether you all believe it or not) that earlier on I was more on the fence than not. But the evidence has been piling up on one side since.
 
The actual findings are nothing new at this point, it basically says what I have been telling you for months which is that the SARS-COV-2 spike binds strongly to both human and Pangolin ACE2 but only binds weakly to bat ACE2.
If you are stuck in this place, and your posts suggest you are, then you are simply not paying attention to any new evidence.

Like this comment, for example:
Where they fall apart is in their interpretations of the results, which is no doubt why they had so much trouble getting published. For example they claim recombination events are rare, which couldn’t be farther from the truth. Recombination events that result in novel viruses are common, in fact it’s the primary source for novel RNA viruses. Not only that but there is direct evidence for such a recombination event in the SARS-COV-2 spike.
The reason the research in question was not published was clearly spelled out: Journal editors were bamboozled by Daszak's efforts. They no longer consider the lab accident as unworthy of consideration. Thus with no changes in the paper (I think they might have updated a few references based on what has come to light since) the paper is now published IN A PEER REVIEWED JOURNAL.

If it was as you claim, unworthy of publication, what changed?

[snipped unsupported conclusions] ... Finally they try to suggest the furin cleavage site may be an unintended by-product of gain of function research but again they ignore the evidence against this.
It has not been suggested to be an unintended by-product

- There is no evidence such research was being conducted in Wuhan at the time
- There is no suitable proximal ancestor such work could have been performed on. (it’s been shown that RaTG13 cannot give rise to SARS-COV-2 from such research)
- Elements of the SARS-COV-2 furin cleavage site are widespread in it’s close relatives, this suggests it’s an ancestral feature.

I’ve mentioned this before but it’s worth saying again. People who claim a lab leak would “explain why we can’t find the proximal ancestor” are being seriously hypocritical because they themselves are advancing a hypothesis that has that problem on top of the numerous other issues.
None of this is factual. Your POV has not been updated in about a year by my estimate and you had it wrong then.
 
Where the evidence currently stands, the evidence for a lab accident outweighs a natural event. Show me some evidence of a natural spillover event and I'll change that position.

No you won't. You've been provided with such evidence, you've ignored it. You've presented very weak evidence, and ignored the criticisms. Don't pretend that you haven't heavily bet on that horse. It's not very credible.
 
No you won't. You've been provided with such evidence, you've ignored it. You've presented very weak evidence, and ignored the criticisms. Don't pretend that you haven't heavily bet on that horse. It's not very credible.
First: :id:


Second, the failure of the spillover evidence to persuade me has nothing to do with ignoring it.

Here's the spillover evidence: some early stuff about pangolins that has since turned out not to support the actual involvement of pangolins.

Incredulity it could be a lab accident.

The gene segment from a horseshoe bat coronavirus being constantly referred to as the closest match which turns out not to be all that close.

Two initial lineages found. That was supposed to be a big smoking gun but it turns out the evidence still supports the pandemic started in Wuhan.

Claims there were connections to other wet markets using the WHO citation which said no such thing.


I'm not sure if there is much more than that. Certainly not enough to explain how the pandemic started ready to go out of the box, that there was one incident (as opposed to SARS 1 which started with at least 5), that this occurred not just in Wuhan, but very close to the lab, and that no precursor viral strain or intermediary species between bat and people has been found, not even close.

Then there is the Chinese government's refusal to cooperate and removal of access to some genomic data of the research on CoV.

Strong circumstantial evidence in the way of past published findings that this very virus strain as well as GoF research was being done at WIV.

Lapses in infection control including pictures of lapses when collecting specimens in the bat caves.

A number of references to live cultures and live bats being studied at the WIV that have been denied. But the evidence is there were.

There's more but I'll stop here.
 
Last edited:
If you are stuck in this place, and your posts suggest you are, then you are simply not paying attention to any new evidence.
You were the one who linked this paper in spite of having argued against it’s underlying findings for almost a year. It seems that all it took for you to change your mind was a references in the popular press suggesting it supported your hypothesis.
The reason the research in question was not published was clearly spelled out: Journal editors were bamboozled by Daszak's efforts.
This is utterly stupid. There have been a number of papers with similar findings published in the last year, why didn’t the conspiracy “suppress “ as well? The difference is that these people were falsely asserting that these results somehow support a lab leak when in fact all they tell us is that tell us is that Covid probably didn’t come directly to humans from bats.
Thus with no changes in the paper (I think they might have updated a few references based on what has come to light since) the paper is now published IN A PEER REVIEWED JOURNAL.
All this paper does is show that SARS-COV-2 binds well to Human and Pangolin ACE2 but poorly to Bat ACE2. They also look at biding strength in some other animals, many of which have also been documented previously. In the past 9 months, I have seen at least 4 other papers in peer reviewed journals showing that show the same thing. It’s not new and not something, anyone has had trouble getting published.
 
Not sure what "this paper" you are referring to.

I have cited a number of sources that didn't support the lab accident. One in particular addressed the 2 lineages and had concluded one of the lineages (A) that was found in parts of China and Asia began there. I think that's what he said but I've had trouble finding it since then.

Anyway, stronger evidence has been published (yes some was in pre-prints) that supported the conclusion the A strain diverged within Wuhan and spread out.
 
The gene segment from a horseshoe bat coronavirus being constantly referred to as the closest match which turns out not to be all that close.

I have no idea what you are trying to say here, however when it comes to segments of the genome Corona viruses will have different phylogenetic trees for various parts of their genome because they undergo frequent recombination. It’s been know almost from the start that the closest relative for the full genome is NOT the closest relative for the binding domain.
picture.php
 
Not sure what "this paper" you are referring to.

If you are having trouble keeping up with what's being discussed I suggest clicking the link to the post being quoted and re-reading it. If you do that a couple times it will take you back to the post where *you* linked to the paper in question.
 
If you are having trouble keeping up with what's being discussed I suggest clicking the link to the post being quoted and re-reading it. If you do that a couple times it will take you back to the post where *you* linked to the paper in question.
What ******* link? I have linked to dozens of papers.

I'm not going to play 'what are you thinking'. Either post the link or the post # you are referring to or move on.

If you are having trouble keeping up with what's being discussed I suggest clicking the link to the post being quoted and re-reading it. If you do that a couple times it will take you back to the post where *you* linked to the paper in question.
Oh for pity's sake. I repeat, either post the link or the post number that contains the link you are referring to or move on.
 
Last edited:
First: :id:


Second, the failure of the spillover evidence to persuade me has nothing to do with ignoring it.

Here's the spillover evidence: some early stuff about pangolins that has since turned out not to support the actual involvement of pangolins.

Incredulity it could be a lab accident.

The gene segment from a horseshoe bat coronavirus being constantly referred to as the closest match which turns out not to be all that close.

Two initial lineages found. That was supposed to be a big smoking gun but it turns out the evidence still supports the pandemic started in Wuhan.

Claims there were connections to other wet markets using the WHO citation which said no such thing.


I'm not sure if there is much more than that. Certainly not enough to explain how the pandemic started ready to go out of the box, that there was one incident (as opposed to SARS 1 which started with at least 5), that this occurred not just in Wuhan, but very close to the lab, and that no precursor viral strain or intermediary species between bat and people has been found, not even close.

Then there is the Chinese government's refusal to cooperate and removal of access to some genomic data of the research on CoV.

Strong circumstantial evidence in the way of past published findings that this very virus strain as well as GoF research was being done at WIV.

Lapses in infection control including pictures of lapses when collecting specimens in the bat caves.

A number of references to live cultures and live bats being studied at the WIV that have been denied. But the evidence is there were.

There's more but I'll stop here.

My understanding is that the “evidence” (i.e published papers, interviews, on the record statements - i.e no coverup or conspiracy) is that the “riskier” GoF work was done in Dr Baric’s lab, whereas the research being done in WIV by Dr Shi was of chimerical viruses, and that it was this research being done in BSL-2 labs. It might sound dangerous but apparently there is no way to produce SARS-CoV2 this way.

In addition, about the bat strains that seem to be so distant from SARS-CoV 2 the point about those viruses is just that they show how common similar viruses are in nature. It is not the natural spillover theory that puts special emphasis on RaTG13, it is the lab leakers who do that. For example, from what I can see, Deigin and Segreto (whose work you have approvingly cited here) seem to suggest that this is the virus that was transformed by GoF or by chimerical manipulation- or both - into SARS CoV-2. (These days on Twitter they seem to be clutching at all kinds of straws such as the Daily Mail and Zero Hedge and assuming that if it goes against the spillover hypothesis - whether the sources are consistent or not - then it is good enough for them.) The only problem is that RaTG13 apparently has something like 1000 mutations scattered throughout that differ from SARS CoV2. It would make no sense to make SARS-CoV2 in a lab from this one instead of simply adding a spike protein on top (iiuc). Instead ir makes sense to think of RaTG13 as simply an ancestor of SARS CoV2 divergent by around 60 or 70 years.

Oh and the idea that Nature refused to publish a paper for a year because of Daszak is simply in a very particular type of conspiracy theory territory suggested by the Weinstein Brothers known as the Distributed Idea Suppression Complex (DISC). If you have evidence that Nature were influenced by him specifically then cite it otherwise you are pushing a CT.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom