Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Does it? We know there were infected humans there at some point. Did the humans use different sewers?

While some humans may be urinating\defecating in the middle of a public market I doubt it's a common enough occurrence to account for the virus showing up in multiple drains and you would still need to explain why it only happened in the part of the market where there were live animals.
 
Does it? We know there were infected humans there at some point. Did the humans use different sewers?

Lomiller's post is full of falsehoods. Notice he has no citations supporting his claims. The initial COVID cases in Wuhan have not been tied to any wet market. A super-spreader cluster was tied to the early cases but they were not the first cases.

People like Daszak who have a financial interest in the origin not being the lab continue to refer to the wet market and multiple markets in Wuhan as the source of the spillover event but cite the WHO investigation when there is no evidence supporting that claim in the WHO report.

This is what the WHO final report says:
Since the COVID-19 virus has a genome identity of 96% to a bat SARS-like coronavirus and 86%-92% to a pangolin SARS-like coronavirus, an animal source for COVID-19 is highly likely. This was corroborated by the high number of RT-PCR positive environmental samples taken from the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan
There is not a single mention of any tie to or positive culture from any other wet market in Wuhan that I could find searching for the word "market" in the document.


IIRC there was one other market with a positive COVID sample found in a drain but it was not connected to any early cases. I'll have to search the thread to find the source.
 
Last edited:
As for SARS 1 the differences are stark and only fit COVID 19's origin if one cherry picks from them.

I posted these differences a few posts up.
 
And the lab accident moves another pawn forward.

First the news report with some key points: Lab leak theory, once 'political dynamite,' gains credibility in new study
The rejections kept coming. The coronavirus was a topic of intense scientific fascination, yet the four Australian researchers challenging conventional wisdom about how the pandemic originated couldn’t find a publisher for their study.

“We were quite stunned,” recalls one of that study’s authors, Dr. Nikolai Petrovsky, an endocrinologist at Flinders University in Australia who is also developing a coronavirus vaccine. The work he and his group had done only received what he called “blanket rejections.”

That finally changed late last month, when Nature Scientific Reports published their paper, “In silico comparison of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein-ACE2 binding affinities across species and implications for virus origin.” ...

“It’s definitely concerning that the paper took over one year to be accepted for publication,” says Pat Fidopiastis, a microbiologist at California Polytechnic State University. “It’s important to continue asking questions and demand honest answers.”...
We all know why, Daszak did his best to poison the well and there were blatant political reasons from Dump pushing the China is guilty crap to supposedly/apparently the US not wanting attention called to the role we played funding the GoF research and a bunch of stuff in between.

But you know that evidence has a way of not going away.
Here's the paper, published in Nature after a year delay: June 24, 2021: In silico comparison of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein-ACE2 binding affinities across species and implications for virus origin

[I learned a new word, in silico meaning in computer models as opposed to in vitro and in vivo.]

What these 4 Aussie researchers found goes with Quay's and other scientists' work, the molecular structure of COVID 19, while not having hallmarks of some military designer bioweapon, does have hallmarks of coming from a lab rather than a natural spillover event. And they lay out their case in meticulous detail in this paper.
... Spike protein exhibited the highest binding to human (h)ACE2 of all the species tested, forming the highest number of hydrogen bonds with hACE2. Interestingly, pangolin ACE2 showed the next highest binding affinity despite having a relatively low sequence homology, whereas the affinity of monkey ACE2 was much lower despite its high sequence similarity to hACE2. ... These findings show that the earliest known SARS-CoV-2 isolates were surprisingly well adapted to bind strongly to human ACE2, helping explain its efficient human to human respiratory transmission. ...

The closest known relative to SARS-CoV-2 identified so far is the bat RaTG13 virus. However, RaTG13 has a different S protein to SARS-CoV-2 as it lacks a polybasic furin cleavage site and has major amino acid differences in its RBD that, at the sequence level, is most similar to the RBD of pangolin CoV (sequence data in Fig. 1). ...

Conspicuously, we found that the binding of the SARS-CoV-2 S protein was higher for human ACE2 than any other species we tested, with the ACE2 binding energy order, from highest to lowest, being human > pangolin > dog > monkey > hamster > ferret > cat > tiger > bat > civet > horse > cow > snake > mouse. At its extremes, this ranking accords with experimental observations that humans are highly permissive to SARS-CoV-2 infection whereas mice on the other hand are not susceptible. ...

As has been brought up by virologists like Dr Redfield, COVID 19 came ready to go right out of the gate:
This minimal S protein RBD mutation during the early pandemic supports the view that the SARS-CoV-2 S protein was already optimally adapted for human ACE2 binding. This finding was surprising as a zoonotic virus typically exhibits the highest affinity initially for its original host species, with lower initial affinity to receptors of new host species until it adapts. As the virus adapts to its new host, mutations are acquired that increase the binding affinity for the new host receptor. ...

As the simulations are very lengthy, we only ran multiple simulations for the species proposed as intermediate hosts and potential sources of the original virus, human, pangolin, bat and snake to estimate the uncertainty in the binding energies. As the ACE2 proteins for all species were extremely similar in sequence, we expected that these simulation error estimates would be of the same order for all other species. The predicted binding energies for these other species were significantly lower than those of human ACE2.

So not only were none of the animal species a good fit for the COVID 19 spike protein, human cells were a perfect fit.
 
And the lab accident moves another pawn forward.

First the news report with some key points: Lab leak theory, once 'political dynamite,' gains credibility in new studyWe all know why, Daszak did his best to poison the well and there were blatant political reasons from Dump pushing the China is guilty crap to supposedly/apparently the US not wanting attention called to the role we played funding the GoF research and a bunch of stuff in between.

But you know that evidence has a way of not going away.
Here's the paper, published in Nature after a year delay: June 24, 2021: In silico comparison of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein-ACE2 binding affinities across species and implications for virus origin

[I learned a new word, in silico meaning in computer models as opposed to in vitro and in vivo.]

What these 4 Aussie researchers found goes with Quay's and other scientists' work, the molecular structure of COVID 19, while not having hallmarks of some military designer bioweapon, does have hallmarks of coming from a lab rather than a natural spillover event. And they lay out their case in meticulous detail in this paper.
As has been brought up by virologists like Dr Redfield, COVID 19 came ready to go right out of the gate:

So not only were none of the animal species a good fit for the COVID 19 spike protein, human cells were a perfect fit.

Interesting, but what are the implications for virus origins? Do they say in the paper (given that is in the title)?

ETA: because it would also be consistent with my hypothesis about a small-scale wildlife farm in which humans running it had built up antibodies to the virus.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, but what are the implications for virus origins? Do they say in the paper (given that is in the title)?

ETA: because it would also be consistent with my hypothesis about a small-scale wildlife farm in which humans running it had built up antibodies to the virus.
Oh look, another incredibly in-depth scientific discussion published in a peer reviewed journal that's no one (apparently) is bothering to read. Wouldn't want to find out you're wrong now, would you. :rolleyes:

Answers to your first two questions: Yes and yes. They conclude it would not have the key pieces of the viral genome it has had it been a natural zoonotic spillover.

As for your second paragraph, are you joking? There are a dozen citations in this thread already that rule your hypothesis out. There is no trail where there should be one. There is no animal species that has a direct remnant of COVID that you would expect to find.

The main analysis these researchers carried out was to look at how well the spike fit in multiple different species. And remember, the work they did was done more than a year ago using early versions of COVID 19 before it had mutated much.

... Spike protein exhibited the highest binding to human (h)ACE2 of all the species tested, forming the highest number of hydrogen bonds with hACE2. Interestingly, pangolin ACE2 showed the next highest binding affinity despite having a relatively low sequence homology
Pangolin discussed further down in the paper.

There are other citations in this thread documenting that after an extensive search, no pangolins or bats were sold in the Wuhan markets. And pangolins do not reproduce well in captivity and are not found in all that many Chinese wet markets.

These findings show that the earliest known SARS-CoV-2 isolates were surprisingly well adapted to bind strongly to human ACE2, helping explain its efficient human to human respiratory transmission....

This minimal S protein RBD mutation during the early pandemic supports the view that the SARS-CoV-2 S protein was already optimally adapted for human ACE2 binding. This finding was surprising as a zoonotic virus typically exhibits the highest affinity initially for its original host species, with lower initial affinity to receptors of new host species until it adapts.

And herein lies more evidence this was not a natural spillover event:
Since our binding calculations were based on SARS-CoV-2 samples isolated in China from December 2019, at the very onset of the outbreak, the extremely high affinity of S protein for human ACE2 was unexpected.


Coming close was the pangolin:
... the possibility of pangolins being an intermediary vector for SARS-CoV-2 cannot be excluded (see also discussion below).

But they go on later in the paper to say:
Although it has high spike RBD sequence similarity to SARS-CoV-2, pangolin-CoVs are not closely related to SARS-CoV-2, with ~ 90% sequence similarity across their whole genome23. ...

However, such events are rare as they require coinfection of the one host with two viruses at exactly the same time and the SARS-CoV-2 genome was reported to exhibit no evidence of recent recombination, arguing against this possibility57. Most importantly, if such a recombination event had occurred in pangolins it would be expected to have triggered an epidemic spread of the new highly permissive SARS-CoV-2-like virus among pangolin populations. Currently there is no evidence of a pangolin SARS-CoV-2 outbreak, making this scenario unlikely. ...
Notably, all pangolin coronaviruses identified to date lack the furin-like cleavage site between S1/S2 in the SARS-CoV-2 S protein that facilitates its rapid spread through human populations. The fact pangolin CoV S protein does not have the furin cleavage site that is a prominent feature of the SARS-CoV-2 S protein45, argues against pangolins being the intermediate vector for transmission of SARS-CoV-2 to humans.
And further down in the paper:
Nevertheless, no SARS-CoV-2-like virus has been found in pangolins, suggesting they were not the original source.


How about bats:
As highlighted by our data, the binding affinity of SARS-CoV-2 S protein for bat ACE2 is considerably lower than for human ACE2 and other species. Notably, RaTG13 S protein was shown not to bind to human ACE255. Hence even if SARS-CoV-2 did originally arise from a bat precursor virus, which remains unproven, it must have spent considerable time in an intermediate animal host to allow it to adapt its S protein sufficiently to then be able to bind human ACE2. There are currently no explanations for how or where such a transition could have occurred to generate a SARS-CoV-2 spike protein optimised for human ACE2.

More on bats:
To date, a virus directly related to SARS-CoV-2 has not been identified in bats or any other non-human species, leaving its origins unclear.


They looked at a number of species:
Binding affinities for all other modelled species were all substantially lower than for human ACE2 at the > 99.99% confidence level.


Here's the money ball:
Does high human ACE2 binding affinity represent a recent gain-of-function mutation? ...

Phylodynamic analyses of the COVID-19 genomes estimated the date for the most recent common ancestor as late 2019, consistent with the earliest reported date in 2019 for the initial cluster of pneumonia cases in Wuhan58. Based on available genome sequence data, this study concluded that the current pandemic has been driven entirely by human-to-human transmission since at least December. ... These data suggest that SARS-CoV-2 spike RBD evolved by selection on a human-like ACE2.


Of course it's not conclusive beyond all doubt. But they were quite clear about what they found with their computer models, the evidence fits the lab origin better than a natural zoonotic spillover event:
In summary, our study suggests that from the beginning of this pandemic the SARS-CoV-2 S protein already had very high, optimal binding to hACE2. There is minimal early evidence of selection pressure to further optimise binding, in contrast to what has been seen with other zoonotic viruses at the time of their entry into the human population.
 
Oh look, another incredibly in-depth scientific discussion published in a peer reviewed journal that's no one (apparently) is bothering to read. Wouldn't want to find out you're wrong now, would you. :rolleyes:

Answers to your first two questions: Yes and yes. They conclude it would not have the key pieces of the viral genome it has had it been a natural zoonotic spillover.

As for your second paragraph, are you joking? There are a dozen citations in this thread already that rule your hypothesis out. There is no trail where there should be one. There is no animal species that has a direct remnant of COVID that you would expect to find.

The main analysis these researchers carried out was to look at how well the spike fit in multiple different species. And remember, the work they did was done more than a year ago using early versions of COVID 19 before it had mutated much.

Pangolin discussed further down in the paper.

There are other citations in this thread documenting that after an extensive search, no pangolins or bats were sold in the Wuhan markets. And pangolins do not reproduce well in captivity and are not found in all that many Chinese wet markets.



And herein lies more evidence this was not a natural spillover event:


Coming close was the pangolin:

But they go on later in the paper to say:And further down in the paper:


How about bats:


More on bats:


They looked at a number of species:


Here's the money ball:


Of course it's not conclusive beyond all doubt. But they were quite clear about what they found with their computer models, the evidence fits the lab origin better than a natural zoonotic spillover event:

Thanks. I don’t have time to read it all right now.
 
While an expert with close knowledge of the lab and personnel deploys a queen to take out the lonely pawn.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/he...le-threats-against-wuhan-lab-conspiracybuster

I think SG referred to her as a “single Aussie” without mentioned her senior status and reputation.

Also, as I have been pointing out, it is not the lab leak theorists who tend to get the most in the way of personal threats and abuse on social media, but virologists and other scientists, particularly those who stand up for the professionalism of their colleagues:

Dr Anderson was last in Wuhan in November 2019 when, it is now believed, the virus was beginning to spread. She has known the director of the lab’s emerging infectious diseases section, Shi Zhengli, since meeting her at the CSIRO in Geelong and 2003. She refuted claims that scientists in the Wuhan lab became ill, saying had this been true she would have known.

Facebook’s decision to remove large amounts of misinformation about Covid-19 and replace it with fact-checked material, including Dr Anderson’s, infuriated extremist conspiracy websites so much that one published her email address.

The man dubbed America’s “most prolific” conspiracy theorist, Texan Alex Jones, named Dr Anderson as “the woman running projects with weaponised COVID” and claimed she “ran all the censorship for Facebook ... and silences the president”.

Geelong-born Dr Anderson had no idea she was being targeted until a friend from New York asked: “Why am I seeing your face?”

The first email to hit her inbox read simply: “Eat a bat and die, bitch.” When the onslaught became intense enough for her to call Singapore police, they took it seriously.

“They said to be aware of my surroundings, and that freaked me out a bit,” Dr Anderson said from Melbourne, where she returned to work last month. “I’m a runner and on one of the apps I use, Strava, it shows where your running route [is], so you can watch someone and figure out where they live, so I had to lock down my Strava.”
 
This is an interesting point regarding claims that have been made about how "we know that they had bats there":

She is particularly concerned about the Australian book What Really Happened in Wuhan by journalist Sharri Markson, which is being marketed in part on the strength of an “unearthed” video showing scientists with bats at the Wuhan lab.

“To my knowledge, that was a video made several years ago to promote the lab,” Dr Anderson said.

“I didn’t know who [the author of the book] was until I saw the headline about the bat video, a ‘secret’ bat colony. There are many labs working with bats and have bat colonies in multiple countries.

“There are scientific meetings dedicated specifically to bat virus research and the last such meeting that I attended was in Colorado, USA.”

When she saw the “secret video” claim, “I thought, ‘This is just rubbish’ ... It’s crazy and it gives the public a terrible impression of scientists.
 
This made me think of another in silico analysis that looked at the similarities of the ACEs across a large number of species with that of the human sequence and therefore the propensity to be infected with SARS-COV-2. The ACE-2 sequence does not vary much. The hamster is used as an experimental model of infection and disease for SARS-COV-2, it has a medium score. There are plenty of animals in that medium list that can be found in China where the virus could have evolved on a human-like ACE-2.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32826334/
 
As for your second paragraph, are you joking? There are a dozen citations in this thread already that rule your hypothesis out. There is no trail where there should be one. There is no animal species that has a direct remnant of COVID that you would expect to find.

We have been over this before and from what I remember, you claimed "there is no animal link" and I corrected you to "we have found no animal link".

At that point, I thought you agreed that you had overstated your case. But here you are back to claiming categorically that there is no animal link.

It is too early in the game to know this. Whereas you might be able to point to how SARS and MERS were found to have animal links fairly quickly, you forget the important point that there was less asymptomatic spread with those viruses.

Besides, we don't really know enough about the animal trail with Ebola yet. It is posited that bats are the likely the reservoir but even that is still not clear.

[/QUOTE]
 
This made me think of another in silico analysis that looked at the similarities of the ACEs across a large number of species with that of the human sequence and therefore the propensity to be infected with SARS-COV-2. The ACE-2 sequence does not vary much. The hamster is used as an experimental model of infection and disease for SARS-COV-2, it has a medium score. There are plenty of animals in that medium list that can be found in China where the virus could have evolved on a human-like ACE-2.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32826334/

I see that the paper is mentioned in the one SG linked to...

Other relevant modelling papers were also published while our paper was under review. Damas et al. published an analysis of ACE2 sequences from 410 vertebrate species, including 252 mammals, generating a probability that they could be used as a receptor by SARS-CoV-216. They classed the species into five risk groups. Man, apes, monkeys, Chinese hamsters, whales and porpoises were included in the high-binding group. Golden hamsters, cattle and cats were members of the medium binding group while dogs, horses and bats were in the low binding group. Notably, pangolins, ferrets, mice, and minks were all assigned to the very low binding group in their analyses, susceptibility predictions that do not correlate well with either our data predictions or with actual experimental observations.
 
While an expert with close knowledge of the lab and personnel deploys a queen to take out the lonely pawn.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/he...le-threats-against-wuhan-lab-conspiracybuster

What makes you think that person was aware of everything going on in Wuhan?

And this classic definition of a straw man again despite it not being discussed in scientific circles looking at the lab accident hypothesis:
... part of Chinese bioweapons research
No one in this thread has said this had anything to do with the origin of COVID 19.


And this is what you put up against a number of well researched analysis of the virus:
“I have worked in this exact laboratory at various times for the past two years. I can personally attest to the strict control and containment measures implemented while working there. The staff at [Wuhan Institute of Virology] are incredibly competent, hard-working, and are excellent scientists with superb track records.”
One, we don't know which lab in Wuhan that was the source and two, we know this claim isn't true because there is photographic evidence of breaches of that "strict control and containment"

She refuted another straw man:
She refuted claims that scientists in the Wuhan lab became ill, saying had this been true she would have known.
It was claimed three people were ill. She thinks she would have known that not a single person—student or researcher—was ill in Nov 2019.

She whines about what material FB took down as false. Meh, I don't go to FB for scientific research, do you? Whooptido Alex Jones and a bunch of Dump cultists were upset with FB. It makes for a more dramatic 'news' story.

I don't know anything about any "secret video":
“To my knowledge, that was a video made several years ago to promote the lab,” Dr Anderson said.
This is supposedly (I guess) the only video evidence of lapses in infection control collecting bats and bat guano in Yunnan. Perhaps you should visit this paper I posted a couple pages back: 3. WUHAN LABORATORIES, BAT RESEARCH AND BIOSAFETY
“There is a lot of debris in the laboratory, The laboratory stores a lot of cartons, which is crowded & chaotic, Experiment & living area not separated, Students are not wearing lab coats, Safety facilities No eyewash, Chemical waste & household waste mixed, temporary storage cabinets have simple disposal of biochemical waste & too much temporary storage” (Lab Report Wuhan University, 2019). ...

The authors state that “there is a shortage of personnel for facility and equipment maintenance in ABSL-3 facilities” and that “we need to take comprehensive measures to address the AUP review, laboratory animal management, laboratory safety management, facility and equipment management, and personnel training (Guo et al., 2019).
...

As for the only images of breaches in infection control protocol being in some old video:
Graduates of the Wuhan University’s Department of Ecology carried out yearly sampling of bats in the summer months (WEMP, 2020), for example, during a field survey expedition from June 18 to July 16, 2019, in Yunnan and Shenzhen (WEMP, 2019) ...

It is clear from the photographs on the following page, that the research students failed to wear proper PPE when catching and sampling bats from areas (Yunnan) where Bat SARS- like Coronaviruses were prevalent, including the key bat species known to harbour such viruses, Chinese rufous horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus sinicus) and Rhinolophus Affinis. See Figure set 4.
I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest you didn't look at that tl:dr paper.

You think that has the weight of a queen on a chessboard? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
This made me think of another in silico analysis that looked at the similarities of the ACEs across a large number of species with that of the human sequence and therefore the propensity to be infected with SARS-COV-2. The ACE-2 sequence does not vary much. The hamster is used as an experimental model of infection and disease for SARS-COV-2, it has a medium score. There are plenty of animals in that medium list that can be found in China where the virus could have evolved on a human-like ACE-2.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32826334/
The paper I cited addresses hamsters among other commonly used lab animals. It also carefully analyses the weight of each species to be infected by the COVID 19 spike protein. It's not all or none. There is a continuum.

They cited your link and commented:
Other relevant modelling papers were also published while our paper was under review. Damas et al. published an analysis of ACE2 sequences from 410 vertebrate species, including 252 mammals, generating a probability that they could be used as a receptor by SARS-CoV-216. ...

Notably, pangolins, ferrets, mice, and minks were all assigned to the very low binding group in their analyses, susceptibility predictions that do not correlate well with either our data predictions or with actual experimental observations.
I'm not quite sure why the Damas et al paper would have found bats and pangolins in the low susceptibility group.

More from the paper I posted:
Conspicuously, we found that the binding of the SARS-CoV-2 S protein was higher for human ACE2 than any other species we tested, with the ACE2 binding energy order, from highest to lowest, being human > pangolin > dog > monkey > hamster > ferret > cat > tiger > bat > civet > horse > cow > snake > mouse. At its extremes, this ranking accords with experimental observations that humans are highly permissive to SARS-CoV-2 infection whereas mice on the other hand are not susceptible.
 
We have been over this before and from what I remember, you claimed "there is no animal link" and I corrected you to "we have found no animal link"....
I have not overstated my case. Maybe you decided I had. :confused:

You are conflating not finding the exact animal match with not finding anything at all. In the case of SARS 1, the connection to civet cats and multiple wet markets was found shortly after the coronavirus was identified.

In the case of COVID 19, not a single trace has been found in a year and a half.
 
Last edited:
I have not overstated my case. Maybe you decided I had. :confused:

You are conflating not finding the exact animal match with not finding anything at all. In the case of SARS 1, the connection to civet cats and multiple wet markets was found shortly after the coronavirus was identified.

In the case of COVID 19, not a single trace has been found in a year and a half.

Yes. But as I pointed out, people become violently ill with SARS and MERS so it is easier to pick up the trail, quicker than it is for Covid where we are still in the dark about who was even the first case, and whether the first case may have been months before the first known one. Your reasoning simultaneously relies on the idea it had been hanging since September spreading stealthily through Wuhan and also that we should have easily been able to trace the pathogen back to its source from the first known cases in December if it had been zoonotic.

I’m arguing that since we don’t know where the first cases actually were that we can’t make such definite claims about how there was no spillover in the markets or that no intermediate, amplifying host animals exist, etc…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom