Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you look at the 'natural spillover is most likely' narrative you will find it comes from a PR campaign started by Daszak back in very early 2020. You know, that Lancet scandal and all that.

This is simply nonsense.

Yes, Daszak and others wrote that letter, but you make it sound like virologists can't possibly make up their own minds on these things and are being led by the nose by Daszak.

This is the type of reasoning which comes across as conspiratorial.
 
In late March, former Centers for Disease Control director Robert Redfield received death threats from fellow scientists after telling CNN that he believed COVID-19 had originated in a lab. “I was threatened and ostracized because I proposed another hypothesis,” Redfield told Vanity Fair.

Sorry, but what? "Death threats from fellow scientists"?

These are people he can verify as scientists? Therefore he must know who they are.

As far as I understand, death threats are not protected speech. If he is receiving them, then who are they and have they been prosecuted?
 
...
Remember that the SARS outbreak happened in Guangdong Province which is about 1000 kms from Yunnan, where Zhengli Shi and co found the bats that harboured the virus.

It's a similar distance from Yunnan to Wuhan.
Yeah and Wuhan and Guangdong are both in China. :rolleyes:

There's more than just distance involved here, it's called a trail, something for which there is no trail for an outbreak in Wuhan except via the WIV (and nearby labs).

NIH, 2004: Epidemiologic Clues to SARS Origin in China
Several observations support the hypothesis of a wild animal origin for SARS. Cases apparently occurred independently in at least five different municipalities; early case-patients were more likely than later patients to report living near a produce market (odds ratio undefined; lower 95% confidence interval 2.39) but not near a farm; and 9 (39%) of 23 early patients, including 6 who lived or worked in Foshan, were food handlers with probable animal contact.
There was no vague epidemiological pattern about it. And whether it was palm civets or horseshoe bats directly, the animals were sold in Guangdong wet markets and multiple cases could indeed be connected to those markets.

That is not the case in Wuhan where only one cluster and not the first cases are connected to a wet market.
 
There's more than just distance involved here, it's called a trail, something for which there is no trail for an outbreak in Wuhan except via the WIV (and nearby labs).

Yeah, and until there was a trail for SARS, there wasn't a trail.

If you look at how that happened, it took many years to fully establish that trail.
 
This is simply nonsense.

Yes, Daszak and others wrote that letter, but you make it sound like virologists can't possibly make up their own minds on these things and are being led by the nose by Daszak.

This is the type of reasoning which comes across as conspiratorial.
You are still ignoring what I posted about Daszak.

You did not address Daszak trying to steer people away from the lab accident and how yes indeed, when more virologists actually looked they are making up their own minds.

I repeat what you are ignoring:
To Gilles Demaneuf, following along from the sidelines, it was as if it had been “nailed to the church doors,” establishing the natural origin theory as orthodoxy. “Everyone had to follow it. Everyone was intimidated. That set the tone.” The statement struck Demaneuf as “totally nonscientific.” To him, it seemed to contain no evidence or information. And so he decided to begin his own inquiry in a “proper” way, with no idea of what he would find.
 
By the way, this whole, "We're the ones standing up for what we believe in despite the slings and arrows..." narrative is yet another tried and tested part of the conspiracy narrative.

But guess what...

The people arguing for spillover also get abuse on Twitter all the time.

Do you not think that Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, Angela Rassmussen, Vincent Racaniello, Amy Rosenfeld, Kristian Andersen, Robert Garry etc... get heaps of abuse both on Twitter and in other venues?

Maybe you think, "Ah, well they deserve it because they were responsible for the deaths of millions!" and indeed that seems to be the justification given when people spout that kind of stufff.

But it puts a massive lie to the idea that those who speak against the natural spillover and in favour of the lab leak somehow monopolize the bravery and courage and what have you that the maverick outsider narrative likes to wrap itself in.
 
Sorry, but what? "Death threats from fellow scientists"?

These are people he can verify as scientists? Therefore he must know who they are.

As far as I understand, death threats are not protected speech. If he is receiving them, then who are they and have they been prosecuted?

This is what Redfield said in the Vanity Fair interview:
After the interview aired, death threats flooded his inbox. The vitriol came not just from strangers who thought he was being racially insensitive but also from prominent scientists, some of whom used to be his friends. One said he should just “wither and die.”
You can choose not to believe him.

For what it's worth, apparently Daszak as well got death threats, in his case from QAnon believers.
 
You are still ignoring what I posted about Daszak.

You did not address Daszak trying to steer people away from the lab accident and how yes indeed, when more virologists actually looked they are making up their own minds.

I repeat what you are ignoring:

I'm not ignoring it. I have acknowledged it.

Your claim is that Peter Daszak has initimidated the virology world into silence.

My claim is that this narrative of yours is laughable.
 
This is what Redfield said in the Vanity Fair interview:You can choose not to believe him.

For what it's worth, apparently Daszak as well got death threats, in his case from QAnon believers.

So did Redfield get "death threats" from fellow scientists? No. He didn't. Even if someone who he chooses not to name said, "You should wither and die", that's not a death threat. It's not very nice, but it's not a death threat.

Daszak and Fauci, I would say get daily threats from very unhinged people all the time.

I would feel much more comfortable being in Redfield's position than Fauci or Daszak's.
 
Yeah, and until there was a trail for SARS, there wasn't a trail.

If you look at how that happened, it took many years to fully establish that trail.
Before I waste more time on this, go back and look at what I've already posted. SARS was directly connected to five different municipalities and the initial cases all had connections to handling or being near raw meat from the wet markets.

The fact the civet cat was initially suspected is because SARS was found in those animals. The connection to the horseshoe bats actually came from the researchers at the WIV who were collecting thousands of samples from the caves.

There was no evidence live or even killed bats were sold in any significant numbers in Wuhan. That was noted in a cite up thread. Where as finding SARS in the civet cats in the markets was found.

Nature: Animal sales from Wuhan wet markets immediately prior to the COVID-19 pandemic
Here we document 47,381 individuals from 38 species, including 31 protected species sold between May 2017 and November 2019 in Wuhan’s markets. We note that no pangolins (or bats) were traded, supporting reformed opinion that pangolins were not likely the spillover host at the source of the current coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. ...

Circumstantially, the absence of pangolins (and bats, not typically eaten in Central China; media footage generally depicts Indonesia) from our comprehensive survey data corroborates that pangolins are unlikely implicated as spill-over hosts in the COVID-19 outbreak. This is unsurprising because live pangolin trading has largely ceased in China13.

I know you think you have all these gotchas but you don't.
 
Before I waste more time on this, go back and look at what I've already posted. SARS was directly connected to five different municipalities and the initial cases all had connections to handling or being near raw meat from the wet markets.

The fact the civet cat was initially suspected is because SARS was found in those animals. The connection to the horseshoe bats actually came from the researchers at the WIV who were collecting thousands of samples from the caves.

There was no evidence live or even killed bats were sold in any significant numbers in Wuhan. That was noted in a cite up thread. Where as finding SARS in the civet cats in the markets was found.
Nature: Animal sales from Wuhan wet markets immediately prior to the COVID-19 pandemic

I know you think you have all these gotchas but you don't.

Huh? Nobody is arguing that bats were being sold and consumed in the markets!

You are the one attempted gotchas with these silly strawman arguments.
 
The identification of civet cats as a vector for SARS was more or less a lucky find from researchers at Hong Kong univeristy (IIRC) who went into a market in Shenzhen (not the one that was initially the source of the SARS outbreak) and it was from swabs of various animals there that they got closer to identifying SARS as coming from civet cats.

Until that had been done, nobody knew that civet cats were the source.

By the way, I will also note that some of the virologists who were involved with that research are now also being targeted by the internet sleuths of the Lab Leak Hypothesis.
 
Sorry, but what? "Death threats from fellow scientists"?

These are people he can verify as scientists? Therefore he must know who they are.

As far as I understand, death threats are not protected speech. If he is receiving them, then who are they and have they been prosecuted?

Sounds like a claim that needs supporting evidence.
 
By the way, let's go back to this...

You did not address Daszak trying to steer people away from the lab accident and how yes indeed, when more virologists actually looked they are making up their own minds.

I repeat what you are ignoring:

To Gilles Demaneuf, following along from the sidelines, it was as if it had been “nailed to the church doors,” establishing the natural origin theory as orthodoxy. “Everyone had to follow it. Everyone was intimidated. That set the tone.”

The statement struck Demaneuf as “totally nonscientific.” To him, it seemed to contain no evidence or information. And so he decided to begin his own inquiry in a “proper” way, with no idea of what he would find.

Gilles Demaneuf is the guy making a claim of intimidation, and Skeptic Ginger is using it as evidence there was intimidation.

Actually, look carefully at the quote again and you can see that it is an assertion without evidence.

He was following along from the sidelines.

He is not a virologist or an epidemiologist. Who is he?

Gilles Demaneuf is a data scientist with the Bank of New Zealand in Auckland.

So, huh? Why are we citing him as evidence of an intimidation campaign?

This all comes across as Scientists For Covid Truth type stuff.
 
Civet cats aren't cats and should instead be simply called civets.

Sorry, you are correct. Apparently palm civets to be precise.

The discovery was apparently announced at a press conference rather than in a peer-reviewed paper:

The search for an animal reservoir of the virus that causes severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) has turned to wild mammals after the isolation of a virus “almost identical” to SARS-associated coronavirus (SCV) from six masked palm civets (Paguma larvata) and one raccoon dog (Nyctereutes procyonoides) in a market in Shenzhen, southern China, in May. The research team, led by Guan Yi (University of Hong Kong), also detected antibody to SCV in a Chinese ferret badger (Melogale moschata) in the market. All three species are sold as delicacies for human consumption throughout southern China.

“The homology between SCV and the animal virus is extremely high at 99%”, says Guan. “The major difference is a 29 nucleotide deletion in SCV, which suggests transmission from animals to humans rather than a human virus that has jumped to animals. There are also consistent differences in the surface protein gene”.

“The study provides the first indication that the SARS virus exists outside a human host”, says team member Malik Peiris (Hong Kong University). All six civets in the market harboured the virus, which Peiris suggests points to recent infection. “It is possible that they got infected from the primary animal reservoir and are not themselves the true reservoir in nature.”

Link
 
Keep in mind when this paper was written the authors had this operating underlying premise:[I've taken out the reference numbers, 6,7,8 etc. but they can be found in the paper]

... virologic samples of wildlife in the Huanan market could not be linked to SARS-CoV-2, suggesting transmission at the market was downstream from the spillover event...

While the animals themselves may no longer have been there, environmental samples of the sewer where animal blood and waste were disposed of were positive for the virus shows there were infected animals there at some point.
 
While the animals themselves may no longer have been there, environmental samples of the sewer where animal blood and waste were disposed of were positive for the virus shows there were infected animals there at some point.


Does it? We know there were infected humans there at some point. Did the humans use different sewers?
 
While the animals themselves may no longer have been there, environmental samples of the sewer where animal blood and waste were disposed of were positive for the virus shows there were infected animals there at some point.

How many sewers draining wet markets in Wuhan that were positive for COVID 19 were there?


I'll wait for you to find that answer. Hint: it is in the thread and you can find it online.
 
Except the researcher who asked the material be retracted has refused to respond to Bloom's request for an explanation.


Bloom’s list of mutations is identical to those in the published paper, so going back to an outdated version of the raw data and re-generating the list of mutations didn’t buy him anything. If the Chinese researcher was trying to hide something why would they “hide” the information only to put all the data into their published paper?

And your evidence this scenario actually happened is?


1) This is exactly what happened with SARS. The virus spread between Civets that were housed together, the Civets were then distributed wildly to multiple markets where there were multiple crossover events.
2) Wildlife farming in China is not a farm to table operation, animals are collected in distribution centers and then to multiple markets. There is plenty of opportunity for it to sweep through the animal population then have infected animals are shipped to different markets. In fact given how infectious it is, it would be surprising if this did not happen.
3) Covid-19 is a generalist that can jump back and forth between species with ease. If you are widely distributing infected animals it would be surprising not to see multiple crossovers.
4) If there is a single “patient zero” the pandemic is ~75% likely to die out before it ever gets starts.
5) Multiple early lineages arising almost exactly when the virus jumped to humans is most easily explained by multiple crossover events.


COVID was found in the drain of one other market and again, there was no connection to any of the earliest cases.


This is false. More than half of the earliest known cases have direct exposure to wildlife markets. There are a few cases that do not have a clear chain of infection back to one of the markets, but this is hardly surprising for a virus that had been spreading asymptomatically for 6+ weeks already.

It also wasn’t found in “one” drain it was found in multiple drains underneath where the animals themselves were housed.
The Chinese government officials are the ones that came up with the idea the initial source could have been in a wildlife farm then shipped to various markets! I know my posts are tl:dr but you might want to actually read some of them.


The Chinese Government has denied that there were even live animals there at all. The Chinese Government was also responsible for shutting down the markets, distribution centers and farms without first collecting samples that would be needed to identify what animal the virus crossed over from. Contrary to your assertions, the evidence suggests China’s obfuscation is aimed at protecting wildlife markets not covering up a lab leak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom