Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
It wasn't supposed to be anything new, it's an op ed.

Two journalists think we should take the lab leak hypothesis seriously?

Well, okay then. That's their opinion, I guess.


It is supposed to get you and others in the thread to stop calling the lab accident hypothesis a CT. It's supposed to get you to stop handwaving away the scientific evidence with various excuses that relieve you from any responsibility to actually look at the evidence. You dismissed the peer reviewed published paper I just posted along with the rest.

It's not a CT per se to think the virus leaked from a lab. A CT will depend on the reasoning.

If it becomes the idea that alll the virologists in the world are being cowed by Peter Daszak, then yes, it is a CT.

I would think you guys would want to know what the actual evidence is.

As far as I can tell the last piece of scientific evidence posted against the lab accident was the fact there were 2 lineages in the early cases. I'm interested. I asked multiple times where/when anyone thinks the lineages diverged. I don't recall seeing an answer.

I don't know how we can know that.
 
Apparently the appropriate BSL for SARS CoV2 is BSL-3. Maybe Capsid could confirm or not. So it is. It unusual that the WIV used that level or even less for some of their work with bats particularly if there was no reason to suspect a deadly infection was within them.

I have also seen some pictures or WIV scientists doing work in bat caves with full body coverings.

I know that there are definitely reasons to be concerned about some of the researchers doing work in bat caves in China and I have read about it in Spillover as well.

That said, it is still only circumstancial evidence.


Yes SARS-COVV-2 is BSL-3. There are many bat viruses that would warrant BSL-4.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
There is a good video definitely worth watching here (it is only 16 minutes) that rips apart some of the utter crap that has been uncritically parrotted here (such as the Sorensen and Dalglish "paper" that the Daily Mail reported was going to be published in the QRB - remember with the claims that the WIV had broken the laws of physics - ROFLMAO!)

It also mentions the Piplani et al. paper and how it doesn't get us any closer to a lab leak (given that what you would actually have to be arguing for is an engineered virus).

 
There is a good video definitely worth watching here (it is only 16 minutes) that rips apart some of the utter crap that has been uncritically parrotted here (such as the Sorensen and Dalglish "paper" that the Daily Mail reported was going to be published in the QRB - remember with the claims that the WIV had broken the laws of physics - ROFLMAO!)
Are you mixing up the threads again? There is nothing like that in this thread.

It also mentions the Piplani et al. paper and how it doesn't get us any closer to a lab leak (given that what you would actually have to be arguing for is an engineered virus).

So let's see, a couple references to an argument not made in this thread about a broken refrigerator seal. This is the first time I've even heard of this. There is a reference to the ill lab workers in Nov, something which while noted has not been relied upon here. Pretty sure no one has relied on the Daily Mail over a research paper.

I can't take anymore of it. List his points and I'll address them but otherwise the video is yet another piece that belongs in the CT thread.
 
Are you mixing up the threads again? There is nothing like that in this thread.

It was this thread. You found that BS very exciting: I've highlighted it for you

Here you go, an article to be published in a couple of days has been previewed by the Daily Mail. You can get a head start dismissing their thesis. That it's in the Daily Mail with all the accompanying sensational language and that the thesis was rejected last year should give you all some ammo. :cool:

I was going to wait until the paper was published but the Daily Mail has quite a bit of it excerpted already. Scroll down to the actual paper excerpts. They are copy protected so I can't quote from the paper.

EXCLUSIVE: COVID-19 'has NO credible natural ancestor' and WAS created by Chinese scientists who then tried to cover their tracks with 'retro-engineering' to make it seem like it naturally arose from bats, explosive new study claims

I'm sure a number of people in this thread will see the bit about the claims being rejected earlier and dismiss the paper.

The 2 scientists have serious credentials and have authored or co-authored hundreds of papers published in scientific and medical journals.

PubMed: Dalgelish

Who are Angus Dalgleish and Birger Sørensen?


The lower level biosafety labs have been noted in citations in this thread.


I don't have any background in the paper's claim:

One tell-tale sign of alleged manipulation the two men highlighted was a row of four amino acids they found on the SARS-Cov-2 spike.

... Sørensen said the amino acids all have a positive charge, which cause the virus to tightly cling to the negatively charged parts of human cells like a magnet, and so become more infectious.

But because, like magnets, the positively charged amino acids repel each other, it is rare to find even three in a row in naturally occurring organisms, while four in a row is 'extremely unlikely,' the scientist said.

'The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' ...
I understand the positive and negative charges, just not that amino acids have these charges. I'll look for more relevant information on that and await critique by contributors to the thread.


QRB Discovery to save people time looking for the paper when it's published.


Hilarious!

The funny bit is of course that the journal never published the paper.

Oh, and apparently his most famous legacy involved discovering something that by his claim broke the laws of physics.
 
So let's see, a couple references to an argument not made in this thread about a broken refrigerator seal. This is the first time I've even heard of this. There is a reference to the ill lab workers in Nov, something which while noted has not been relied upon here. Pretty sure no one has relied on the Daily Mail over a research paper.

I can't take anymore of it. List his points and I'll address them but otherwise the video is yet another piece that belongs in the CT thread.

There is the papers by Segreto and Deigin, which you have posted here before, that claim a GoF of RaTG13 that turned it into SARS-CoV2.

Apparently no scientists take this seriously.

Bye bye Deigin and Segreto.

Then the Sorensen and Dalgliesh paper that you trumpeted which is BS.

Then the Piplani paper which you claim shows must prove GoF.

Well, no, because you are still left without knowing what the original virus that was worked on was.

Then, we are left with nothing more than speculation.

Now, for zoonotic spillover theory that is pretty much where we were. The progress is slow but possibly making headway.

For lab-leak / GoF, the claims are wild and ridiculous and often end up being contradicted quickly. Fine, if you are happy to grasp at straws.
 
"Article to be published in a couple days" is not citing Daily Mail as a source.

I'll get to the rest later.
 
"Article to be published in a couple days" is not citing Daily Mail as a source.

:dl:

Nice try. Let's rewind the tape shall we...

There is a good video definitely worth watching here (it is only 16 minutes) that rips apart some of the utter crap that has been uncritically parrotted here (such as the Sorensen and Dalglish "paper" that the Daily Mail reported was going to be published in the QRB - remember with the claims that the WIV had broken the laws of physics - ROFLMAO!)

Are you mixing up the threads again? There is nothing like that in this thread.

"nothing like that in this thread"? Only exactly like it in this thread...

Here you go, an article to be published in a couple of days has been previewed by the Daily Mail. You can get a head start dismissing their thesis.

....

Whoops!

I don't have any background in the paper's claim:

One tell-tale sign of alleged manipulation the two men highlighted was a row of four amino acids they found on the SARS-Cov-2 spike.

... Sørensen said the amino acids all have a positive charge, which cause the virus to tightly cling to the negatively charged parts of human cells like a magnet, and so become more infectious.

But because, like magnets, the positively charged amino acids repel each other, it is rare to find even three in a row in naturally occurring organisms, while four in a row is 'extremely unlikely,' the scientist said.

'The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' ...
I understand the positive and negative charges, just not that amino acids have these charges. I'll look for more relevant information on that and await critique by contributors to the thread.

In other words, it turned out to be exactly what was posted in this thread - total nonsense.

You posted it, and now you claim you didn't, despite it being right there "Dalgliesh", "QRB", "Daily Mail", "breaking the laws of physics".

QRB Discovery to save people time looking for the paper when it's published.

"QRB to save people time looking for the paper when it's published"?

So where is this paper? Has it actually been published?
 
Even your Google skills fail you, lomiller.

Here's one: Unexpected novel Merbecovirus discoveries in agricultural sequencing datasets from Wuhan, China

Here's an essay he wrote over a year ago: Lab-Made? SARS-CoV-2 Genealogy Through the Lens of Gain-of-Function Research

Maybe it will help people understand his current paper with Sergeto.


As for your backbone argument you are simply repeating Andersen without addressing additional papers:

The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2It's the same squirrel argument: discuss one lab accident possibility as if no others are possible.

Here's an earlier paper from Segreto and Deigin: The genetic structure of SARS-CoV-2 does not rule out a laboratory origin


The history of past research has been brought up already:
Lots of evidence of what they were working on at the WIV before a whole bunch of material was withdrawn from public view. You appear to be asking for evidence when we know the Chinese government isn't allowing researchers to look.

So claiming [look—squirrel] XYZ couldn't possibly be anything but natural is a failed argument.

Anyway, Skeptic Ginger, all the stuff above is stuff about Yuri Deigin and Rosanna Segreto. They believe the SARS-CoV2 was a "chimera" created in a lab.

Here's what an, admittedly non-peer-reviewed paper says:

"CONCLUSIONS
In summary, the hypothesis of artificial creation of SARS-CoV-2 proposed by Segreto and Deigin is not supported by evidence. Additionally, it does not agree with a number of findings based on genetic analysis of SARS-CoV-2 and its relatives. The scenario of chimeric virus combined from RaTG13 and MP789 strains seems incompatible with the high genetic divergence between these coronaviruses and SARS-CoV-2. The scenario of SARS-CoV-2 synthesis from two still unpublished viruses is not amenable to a test of falsification, as a formal hypothesis should be; furthermore, it does not seem to be likely, given the much higher prevalence of unknown coronaviruses and recombination events in the wild. Moreover, Segreto's and Deigin's hypothesis is significantly weakened by a recent analysis of S-protein gene divergence suggesting that the most likely explanation for SARS-CoV-2 origin doesn't require recombination at all, neither in nature, nor in the lab.[3]"

Link


Of course, it is hard to know which argument you are making from one post to the next.

1.) a wild virus that escaped "right off the bat" so to speak.

2.) an engineered virus (apparently the belief of Deigin and Segreto; and also of Sorenson and Dalgliesh).

3.) Something else, I aint sayin' just innuendoin'!

Let's see what Deigin is up to now....

Link

Whoa, is this legit?? A confirmed Wuhan Covid case from NOVEMBER 2019.

Looks like this truth-seeking scientist has found an article from the Daily Mail from March 2020 talking about a British teacher in Wuhan being ill...

Okay, first of all, if it is true that he got Covid-19 in November 2019, then why is this not better known? It is reported in one of the most widely read tabloids in the world. It is probably not going to be some secret knowledge known only to dedicated researchers. But even if true, why the "Whoa"?

Connor Reed, a 25-year-old expat from Llandudno in North Wales, has worked in a school in Wuhan, China, for almost a year. In November he became the first British man to catch the coronavirus. From coughs and aches to burning up and spending the night in hospital, here’s how he beat the illness that is sweeping the globe.

Day 1 — Monday November 25: I have a cold. I’m sneezing and my eyes are a bit bleary. It isn’t bad enough to keep me off work. I arrived in this country to teach English as a foreign language — but now I’m a manager at a school in Wuhan, the city in central China where I have lived for the past seven months.

I speak Mandarin well, and the job is interesting. My cold shouldn’t be very contagious, so I have no qualms about going to work. And I live alone, so I’m not likely to give it to anyone. There hasn’t been anything in the news here about viruses. I have no cause for concern. It’s just a sniffle.

I will say it is interesting that "if this is legit" his testimony torpedoes the idea that Wuhan was in lockdown in October.
 
I'm not sure if I should waste my time on all that angrysoba. Especially since it's only a matter of time before the lab accident becomes the more likely than not consensus.

You claim I cited the Daily Mail as a source when the story is about a research paper. That's dishonest at best.

Sometime today I'll try to post a summary of all the actual evidence.

:popcorn1
 
I'm not sure if I should waste my time on all that angrysoba. Especially since it's only a matter of time before the lab accident becomes the more likely than not consensus.

Quite a few people, including multiple members and former members of this forum, have assured me it is only a matter of time before Einstein's theory of relativity will be exposed as one of the greatest frauds in the history of so-called science.

My personal opinion is that saying "it's only a matter of time" is not always a compelling argument, but that's not to say similar proclamations never come true. While waiting for time to pass, we can amuse ourselves by considering evidence as it becomes available.
 
I'm not sure if I should waste my time on all that angrysoba. Especially since it's only a matter of time before the lab accident becomes the more likely than not consensus.

Sounds familiar. This type of claim has been made many times about many subjects that we’re still waiting on.

You claim I cited the Daily Mail as a source when the story is about a research paper. That's dishonest at best.

This is hilarious. You linked to the Daily Mail story about a paper, did you not?

In addition you linked to the claim by one of the authors that it broke the laws of physics (that also sounds familiar - LOL!)

Now fine, if you are embarrassed about the link to the Daily Mail why not link to the actual paper instead of the interview with the author which you absolutely did use as a source (calling me a liar is itself a lie, SG!).

You won’t because this imminent publication never seems to have been published in the journal it was supposed to have been.

Instead the only publication where it saw the light of day was in… you guessed it… the Daily Mail…as an embargoed copy.

Sometime today I'll try to post a summary of all the actual evidence.

:popcorn1

I’d like to see the summary, set to the soundtrack of Loose Change, no doubt.

;)
 
Quite a few people, including multiple members and former members of this forum, have assured me it is only a matter of time before Einstein's theory of relativity will be exposed as one of the greatest frauds in the history of so-called science.

My personal opinion is that saying "it's only a matter of time" is not always a compelling argument, but that's not to say similar proclamations never come true. While waiting for time to pass, we can amuse ourselves by considering evidence as it becomes available.
It is a relevant statement (not argument) given the tide of evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis continues to flow and given despite a year and a half of intense effort has failed to find a related species/event suggesting a path to get to the pandemic. All suggested spillover scenarios amount to no more than conjecture.

You might look at the WAPo link I cited a few posts up for an op ed discussing how we got here:

"The media called the ‘lab leak’ story a ‘conspiracy theory.’ Now it’s prompted corrections — and serious new reporting."
 
It is a relevant statement (not argument) given the tide of evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis continues to flow and given despite a year and a half of intense effort has failed to find a related species/event suggesting a path to get to the pandemic. All suggested spillover scenarios amount to no more than conjecture.

You might look at the WAPo link I cited a few posts up for an op ed discussing how we got here:

"The media called the ‘lab leak’ story a ‘conspiracy theory.’ Now it’s prompted corrections — and serious new reporting."

All good. Now you cannot claim that the lab leak theory is being suppressed any more so presumably this scientific consensus will coalesce any time now. Any …. time …. now…. Any…. …. time …. …. now …. Zzzzzz
 
I'm not embarrassed angrysoba, that's silly. If you don't understand what the difference is between linking to news information and citing research, I can't help you.

I still don't know what you are talking about breaking the laws of physics. If you are trying to discredit the authors of any papers or news stories, get in line. Lot's of hardcore natural origin folks love to discredit authors and researchers rather than address anything in their papers.
 
Oh and as for taking a long time to post a list of citations, it's a damn long list within 35 pages needed to review. You might just want to cool your heels.
 
I'm not embarrassed angrysoba, that's silly. If you don't understand what the difference is between linking to news information and citing research, I can't help you.

Oh my word! I am talking about the actual research you claim to be citing.

I'm still don't know what you are talking about breaking the laws of physics. If you are trying to discredit the authors of any papers or news stories, get in line. Lot's of hardcore natural origin folks love to discredit authors and researchers rather than address anything in their papers.

The author himself said (in the quoted “research”you cited)
The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row.
 
Oh and as for taking a long time to post a list of citations, it's a damn long list within 35 pages needed to review. You might just want to cool your heels.

I’m not saying anything about the time it takes for you to summarize the information but mocking the idea that very soon all the scientists will agree with lab leak.
 
Oh my word! I am talking about the actual research you claim to be citing.

The author himself said (in the quoted “research”you cited)
You're going to play this dozen-post round the mulberry bush game again when you could post the quote and the citation in a single sentence?

:rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom