Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Something that should be of interest...

TWiV is talking to both Robert Garry and Kristian Andersen:



Let's hope that Vincent doesn't waste the opportunity to ask, "When did you become an evil shill for Peter Daszak and the Chinese Communist Party? Why won't you tell us the Truth about the Covid being manufactured by Zheng-li Shi?" etc...
 
The TWiV episode is mostly spent talking about the Jesse Bloom pre-print.

Essentially, they argue that there is nothing really nefarious on display, and apparently Jesse Bloom has now altered his pre-print which takes out some of the earlier points made.

Andersen explains that these types of retraction requests are fairly common and sometimes they relate to contamination (IIUC).

Next, they turn to the idea that multiple zoonosis could have occured in a number of markets.

The way this would happen is if animals were sent to Wuhan, to a central distributor and then sent to the various markets around Wuhan.

It is possible, and even likely, that there had been a number of spillover events from whatever wild animals had been sold in various markets. Many of these spillovers could even have fizzled out, but there may end up being no single Patient Zero. There could have been a few different people who were infected directly from animals there (an earlier discussion of mink illustrates this where apparently the virus is well-adapted to mink as well as other animals and can then hop back to humans).

Garry points to the fact that SARS-CoV2 samples seem to have been taken from drains in the markets themselves and it is suggestive that animals slaughtered there in the markets give a clue to the fact that they are important to the spillover events.

Also of interest here is that the Chinese government is actually extremely sensitive about the problem of wildlife farms. It doesn't look good if such farms are implicated in the spread of a deadly virus and apparently they have declared that wildlife such as that which may have spread the virus is NOT sold in the markets.

In other words, the spillover from wildlife hypothesis (i.e. the most likely hypothesis) also upsets the Chinese government.

I have to wonder now if blaming the scientists in a lab could end up some type of convenient scapegoat for the Chinese government.
 
...

Let's hope that Vincent doesn't waste the opportunity to ask, "When did you become an evil shill for Peter Daszak and the Chinese Communist Party? Why won't you tell us the Truth about the Covid being manufactured by Zheng-li Shi?" etc...
Have you forgotten that Daszak was responsible for steering people away from the potential lab accident origin with a dishonest representation of the facts?

The rest of that **** about COVID being manufactured is a narrative that belongs in the CT thread, not here.
 
The TWiV episode is mostly spent talking about the Jesse Bloom pre-print.

Essentially, they argue that there is nothing really nefarious on display, and apparently Jesse Bloom has now altered his pre-print which takes out some of the earlier points made.

Andersen explains that these types of retraction requests are fairly common and sometimes they relate to contamination (IIUC).
Except the researcher who asked the material be retracted has refused to respond to Bloom's request for an explanation. And as far as Bloom altering his preprint, I need the details to assess that but Bloom went out of his way to say there were other possibilities besides anything nefarious.


Next, they turn to the idea that multiple zoonosis could have occured in a number of markets.

The way this would happen is if animals were sent to Wuhan, to a central distributor and then sent to the various markets around Wuhan.
This is not new and I addressed it upthread. The problem here is that some of these anti-lab accident guys talked as if the WHO had found connections in cases that preceded the seafood market cluster to these other markets then cited the WHO report which said no such thing.

We all know one can speculate this or that possibility. Got any evidence besides "it could have happened"? Did you find anything in the WHO report which actually tied any cases to any other markets beyond speculation?


It is possible, and even likely, that there had been a number of spillover events from whatever wild animals had been sold in various markets. Many of these spillovers could even have fizzled out, but there may end up being no single Patient Zero. There could have been a few different people who were infected directly from animals there (an earlier discussion of mink illustrates this where apparently the virus is well-adapted to mink as well as other animals and can then hop back to humans).
And your evidence this scenario actually happened is?


Garry points to the fact that SARS-CoV2 samples seem to have been taken from drains in the markets themselves and it is suggestive that animals slaughtered there in the markets give a clue to the fact that they are important to the spillover events.
I'll have to go look upthread but IIRC besides the seafood market, COVID was found in the drain of one other market and again, there was no connection to any of the earliest cases. In one case the son had been to a different market but the son had no evidence of past infection. IOW there was only a near miss there, not an actual connection to the case.


Also of interest here is that the Chinese government is actually extremely sensitive about the problem of wildlife farms. It doesn't look good if such farms are implicated in the spread of a deadly virus and apparently they have declared that wildlife such as that which may have spread the virus is NOT sold in the markets.
The Chinese government officials are the ones that came up with the idea the initial source could have been in a wildlife farm then shipped to various markets! I know my posts are tl:dr but you might want to actually read some of them.


In other words, the spillover from wildlife hypothesis (i.e. the most likely hypothesis) also upsets the Chinese government.
Facts supporting the bolded part are not in evidence. Got any evidence supporting any of this paragraph?


I have to wonder now if blaming the scientists in a lab could end up some type of convenient scapegoat for the Chinese government.
Riight, the Chinese government would rather it look like a lab accident in their brand new state of the art biosafety lab than due to continuing the wildlife trade. :rolleyes:

The whole point of implicating the wildlife farms was because that was, you know, farming and not the actual wildlife trade!
 
Classic motte-and-bailey.

You are asked for evidence of a lock-down in October 2019, and you start asking if we believe that China is not authoritarian or silences dissent etc...

Reminds me of the CT forum, where a CTer's reaction to being asked for solid evidence was to ask "do you think the government always tells the truth?".
 
Re natural origin hypothesis rather than going back over the 30+ pages here, I just searched for new sources all from 2021 which shoot big fat holes through the speculation from your podcast:

PBS: WHO report says COVID originated in bats, but critics claim the study was biased

Tech Review: No one can find the animal that gave people covid-19

MSN news: Humans, Not Animals, Likely Took the COVID Virus to Wuhan, Contrary to China's Claims
There is broad agreement that the coronavirus is part of a lineage of viruses founds in horseshoe bats in South China. The mystery centers on how the virus came to cause an outbreak in Wuhan, a thousand miles away, without leaving any trace of its journey.

That is essentially the question Peter Daszak, an expert on disease zoology and a member of the WHO team, attempted to address in the press conference.
Good ol' Daszak.

Continuing:
For the virus to have jumped from a South China horseshoe bat to another animal, and then to have followed a chain of transmission through an unknown series of hosts, possibly as part of the wildlife trade, until it reached Wuhan, where it then exploded into the population and got noticed at last, requires a series of low-probability events. ...

We could concoct a theoretical game of hopscotch in which the virus randomly transmits from host to host, accumulating mutations along the way, threading the needle of cities and villages and South China wet markets, and landing in downtown Wuhan ready for its coming-out party. It's not impossible. It's just getting-struck-by-lightning-while-being-eaten-by-a-shark unlikely.

And if it did happen, it should have been part of a noticeable pattern. In a long, meandering chain of transmissions, each node branching into new infections, Wuhan would have been just one twig of a full-fledged tree—the kind of tree epidemiologists use to trace viral evolution. Even if most other branches eventually died out, the entire tree could not have disappeared without leaving a trace. And yet it doesn't exist.


And herein lies the problem:
Most of the scientific evidence points toward COVID-19 beginning in Wuhan in October or November 2019. Despite a year of intense searching, not a single close ancestor of the virus has been found. As a group of 26 scientists stated in a recent letter calling for a new, objective investigation into the origins of SARS-CoV-2, "There is as yet no evidence demonstrating a fully natural origin of this virus." It's as if it just teleported from South China to Wuhan. ...

Daszak is hoping frozen food can explain this teleportation. The theory is that wild animals being farmed in South China picked up the virus from bats, were killed, frozen, and shipped to Wuhan, and somehow managed to spread the virus through the environs of the market. ... Unfortunately, it's both bad science and bad math.
Starting to see the picture yet?

Read on. The article describes how China closely controlled the WHO report. It describes the glaring hole in the frozen meat hypothesis. It notes that had the wildlife farms been the source one would have expected to find infected farm workers and they weren't found.

Your podcast seems to have left out details like:
In any case, the WHO team's Chinese investigators pretty much scuttled Daszak's theory by announcing that they had tested tens of thousands of wild and farmed animals across China without finding a single trace of SARS-CoV-2.

The article goes on to describe the thousands of specimens the WIV researchers brought back from the Yunnan caves and how many were stored at the WIV. It notes the genetic information on more than a few of those sequences were taken offline and when Daszak was asked about them he said he recalled none of the genomes were relevant despite the Chinese refusing to allow the WHO team access to the data.

The documented lapses in PPE collecting the specimens, the past lapses in safety at the WIV are noted.

Here's the best speculation and it's time for the naysayers in this thread to stop acting like the lab accident is a CT:
In other words, you could not build a better conduit for channeling viruses straight from rural South China to downtown Wuhan. Whether or not the virus made it into the lab and later escaped, this was its best transport option. This viral monorail ran between a number of caves in South China and the WIV multiple times every year, with a different mix of students and scientists.

And it wasn't limited to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The Wuhan CDC also extensively collected bat samples and has been accused of inadequate precautions. One Wuhan University post about a sampling trip to Yunnan in the summer of 2019 (a few months before the pandemic started) shows researchers entering bat caves in street clothes and handling bats with their bare hands, a shocking violation of safety protocols. The bats collected included horseshoe bats, the kind most likely to carry SARS-like diseases. If you're looking for potential carriers, there's no need for hypothetical frozen ferret badgers. Start with the motherlode of cases right in the scientific record.
The article goes on to note that really 2 hypotheses remain: the spillover happened during specimen collection and was brought back to Wuhan, or it occurred after the specimens were in the lab. Either way, research into the dangerous pathogens is going on all over the world with no international regulations.


As much as Daszak and the Chinese government want there to be another answer, in the end one cannot hide the evidence.
 
Reminds me of the CT forum, where a CTer's reaction to being asked for solid evidence was to ask "do you think the government always tells the truth?".
If you think the lab accident is a CT compare my post above to angrysoba's report from the podcast he listened to.
 
Re natural origin hypothesis rather than going back over the 30+ pages here, I just searched for new sources all from 2021 which shoot big fat holes through the speculation from your podcast:

PBS: WHO report says COVID originated in bats, but critics claim the study was biased

Tech Review: No one can find the animal that gave people covid-19

MSN news: Humans, Not Animals, Likely Took the COVID Virus to Wuhan, Contrary to China's ClaimsGood ol' Daszak.

Continuing:


And herein lies the problem:Starting to see the picture yet?

Read on. The article describes how China closely controlled the WHO report. It describes the glaring hole in the frozen meat hypothesis. It notes that had the wildlife farms been the source one would have expected to find infected farm workers and they weren't found.

Your podcast seems to have left out details like:

The article goes on to describe the thousands of specimens the WIV researchers brought back from the Yunnan caves and how many were stored at the WIV. It notes the genetic information on more than a few of those sequences were taken offline and when Daszak was asked about them he said he recalled none of the genomes were relevant despite the Chinese refusing to allow the WHO team access to the data.

The documented lapses in PPE collecting the specimens, the past lapses in safety at the WIV are noted.

Here's the best speculation and it's time for the naysayers in this thread to stop acting like the lab accident is a CT:The article goes on to note that really 2 hypotheses remain: the spillover happened during specimen collection and was brought back to Wuhan, or it occurred after the specimens were in the lab. Either way, research into the dangerous pathogens is going on all over the world with no international regulations.


As much as Daszak and the Chinese government want there to be another answer, in the end one cannot hide the evidence.

The podcast did not talk about frozen food at all so why you think that a bunch of articles claiming lab leak is all that remains I don’t k now.

It has nothing to do with what they were talking about.

But at least you have come clean that you are full a throated lab leak theorist.
 
It's not going to help you guys continuing to ignore the evidence that is piling up.

Angrysoba, I know you don't read my tl;dr posts but you'd be better off just not answering than picking a bit of sarcasm you think lets you dodge the facts.

Your podcast was wrong on a dozen levels. Frozen food was mentioned in the citation and if you look it was a bit of sarcasm. What was glaringly evident in the source I cited was how absolutely unrealistic a spillover event was as the COVID origin and how the evidence connecting the origin to a Wuhan lab is more than realistic.

Taking out the highlights doesn't change this problem you have with the spillover theory:
We could concoct a theoretical game of hopscotch in which the virus randomly transmits from host to host, accumulating mutations along the way, threading the needle of cities and villages and South China wet markets, and landing in downtown Wuhan ready for its coming-out party. It's not impossible. It's just getting-struck-by-lightning-while-being-eaten-by-a-shark unlikely.



And Belz, I read your post. A CT is all you talked about:
Belz said:
Reminds me of the CT forum, where a CTer's reaction to being asked for solid evidence was to ask "do you think the government always tells the truth?".
If you were not referring the the people in this thread being CTers because they think the lab accident is more likely, it wasn't clear from that post.
 
Last edited:
The whole point of implicating the wildlife farms was because that was, you know, farming and not the actual wildlife trade!

I think you misunderstand.

Wildlife farms refers to farming of non-domesticated animals, but the bit that the Chinese goverment finds embarrassing is that there are live animals at the markets.
 
:popcorn1

It's only a matter of time before the consensus shifts sides.

When virologists start to believe that it came from a lab, then so will I. Until then, the consensus is that it came from natural spillover.

When I look at the lab leak side and I see some of the people pushing it (Weinstein, etc...), I find myself stepping away.
 
Taking out the highlights doesn't change this problem you have with the spillover theory:

And Belz, I read your post. A CT is all you talked about:If you were not referring the the people in this thread being CTers because they think the lab accident is more likely, it wasn't clear from that post.

I said the argument is like that of a CTer. For ****'s sake, learn to read!
 
I think you misunderstand.

Wildlife farms refers to farming of non-domesticated animals, but the bit that the Chinese goverment finds embarrassing is that there are live animals at the markets.

D'uh. But did you miss the part where it was the Chinese government pushing the wildlife farm origin?
 
D'uh. But did you miss the part where it was the Chinese government pushing the wildlife farm origin?

No, the Chinese government were arguing for the frozen food (cold chain) hypothesis. This is one that most virologists don't find credible. (And they also have some bat-crap conspiracy theories of their own such as that the US military introduced it during the Wuhan Games - yep, crazy, but not any crazier than the idea there was a secret lockdown of the city in October 2019).

It's a no-brainer to look at the wildlife farms given that the transmission of humans to wildlife through markets is how we ended up with SARS. In the book, Spillover, David Quanmen has a chapter called "Lunch at the Rat Farm" where he visits a farm for this kind of meat and warns about how the next human pandemic could emerge from this type of area.

Remember that the SARS outbreak happened in Guangdong Province which is about 1000 kms from Yunnan, where Zhengli Shi and co found the bats that harboured the virus.

It's a similar distance from Yunnan to Wuhan.

The point is that wildlife is shipped to big cities to central distribution points (live animals, not frozen food!), and from there sent to various markets in the cities.

It is a very plausible theory and certainly not one to artificially exclude (as you seem to want to do) on the basis that the Chinese government supports the theory (again, even if they do, they hardly are the only ones to come up with the idea).
 
When virologists start to believe that it came from a lab, then so will I. Until then, the consensus is that it came from natural spillover.

When I look at the lab leak side and I see some of the people pushing it (Weinstein, etc...), I find myself stepping away.
Some of those virologists already do think the lab accident is more probable. Those would be all the ones who presented evidence you have ignored.

And most of the virologists are PC enough to say neither theory is off the table. That is hardly a consensus for the natural spillover event.

If you look at the 'natural spillover is most likely' narrative you will find it comes from a PR campaign started by Daszak back in very early 2020. You know, that Lancet scandal and all that.

Need a review?

The Lab-Leak Theory: Inside the Fight to Uncover COVID-19’s Origins
On February 19, 2020, The Lancet, among the most respected and influential medical journals in the world, published a statement that roundly rejected the lab-leak hypothesis, effectively casting it as a xenophobic cousin to climate change denialism and anti-vaxxism. Signed by 27 scientists, the statement expressed “solidarity with all scientists and health professionals in China” and asserted: “We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin.”
That was one of the pushes to dismiss the lab accident as a CT, Daszak and his efforts including leading the WHO investigative team was one of the others.

But questions about this narrative started to trickle in as scientists looked at the actual evidence and didn't blindly follow the prescribed narrative.
To Gilles Demaneuf, following along from the sidelines, it was as if it had been “nailed to the church doors,” establishing the natural origin theory as orthodoxy. “Everyone had to follow it. Everyone was intimidated. That set the tone.”

The statement struck Demaneuf as “totally nonscientific.”
To him, it seemed to contain no evidence or information. And so he decided to begin his own inquiry in a “proper” way, with no idea of what he would find.

That researcher started with the history of lab accidents in China and he was joined by another researcher who listed all the other virology labs in Wuhan and the snowball started rolling:
Having connected online, Demaneuf and de Maistre began assembling a comprehensive list of research laboratories in China. As they posted their findings on Twitter, they were soon joined by others around the world. Some were cutting-edge scientists at prestigious research institutes. Others were science enthusiasts. Together, they formed a group called DRASTIC, short for Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19. Their stated objective was to solve the riddle of COVID-19’s origin.


This is where we (aka me and others) have to stand up for what we observed despite the resistance:
With disreputable wing nuts on one side of them and scornful experts on the other, the DRASTIC researchers often felt as if they were on their own in the wilderness, working on the world’s most urgent mystery. They weren’t alone.


Talk about a taboo narrative:
But for most of the past year, the lab-leak scenario was treated not simply as unlikely or even inaccurate but as morally out-of-bounds. In late March, former Centers for Disease Control director Robert Redfield received death threats from fellow scientists after telling CNN that he believed COVID-19 had originated in a lab. “I was threatened and ostracized because I proposed another hypothesis,” Redfield told Vanity Fair. “I expected it from politicians. I didn’t expect it from science.”


And here's the clincher, what I've been saying about the narrative Daszak tried to control but with which the evidence will not be quashed:
Then came the revelation that the Lancet statement was not only signed but organized by a zoologist named Peter Daszak, who has repackaged U.S. government grants and allocated them to facilities conducting gain-of-function research—among them the WIV itself.


The reality and what a couple of us have been pointing out since the beginning of this thread:
To one former federal health official, the situation boiled down to this: An institute “funded by American dollars is trying to teach a bat virus to infect human cells, then there is a virus” in the same city as that lab. It is “not being intellectually honest not to consider the hypothesis” of a lab escape.

And given how aggressively China blocked efforts at a transparent investigation, and in light of its government’s own history of lying, obfuscating, and crushing dissent, it’s fair to ask if Shi Zhengli, the Wuhan Institute’s lead coronavirus researcher, would be at liberty to report a leak from her lab even if she’d wanted to.


Need more?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom