Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
All right, you got any of these witnesses who aren't afraid of speaking up against the Chinese government... you know, the government that is pressuring Chinese students in Australia not to criticize the Chinese government? We already know what happened to one doc who tried to speak out that the pandemic was being covered up.

The question is one that you want answered so why not try doing some brainstorming and come up with some possibilities.

How about the consulates n Wuhan? Did nobody there notice the Chinese broadcasts and lockdown of the city that you claim only a few athletes visiting the city noticed?

How about the many international companies that are there?

And yes, I would expect in a city of millions of people there would be plenty of chatter that can be read, and there are millions of people around the world who are relatives of those who live in China.

You make it sound like China is on Pluto. It is nowhere near as completely closed off to the world as say North Korea. Sure, it is oppressive, and guess what we even know that as the examples you give show. So, where are the examples of the Chinese government telling students to keep quiet about the mysterious goings on in Wuhan?
 
The question is one that you want answered so why not try doing some brainstorming and come up with some possibilities.

How about the consulates n Wuhan? Did nobody there notice the Chinese broadcasts and lockdown of the city that you claim only a few athletes visiting the city noticed?

How about the many international companies that are there?

And yes, I would expect in a city of millions of people there would be plenty of chatter that can be read, and there are millions of people around the world who are relatives of those who live in China.

You make it sound like China is on Pluto. It is nowhere near as completely closed off to the world as say North Korea. Sure, it is oppressive, and guess what we even know that as the examples you give show. So, where are the examples of the Chinese government telling students to keep quiet about the mysterious goings on in Wuhan?
And you make it sound like the Chinese government is like any Western country where people are not afraid to speak out.

The comments about quashing student free speech was not about COVID but it was very recent.

Report: Chinese students in Australia threatened by Beijing
China’s government and its supporters have monitored, harassed and intimidated pro-democracy Chinese students living in Australia, and Australian universities have failed to protect the students' academic freedoms, Human Rights Watch said in a report published Wednesday. ...

n three cases, police in China visited or asked to meet with the families of students because of the students’ activities in Australia, according to the report, based on interviews with 24 pro-democracy students from mainland China and Hong Kong, and 22 academics at Australian universities. Chinese authorities threatened to jail one student who posted pro-democracy messages on Twitter in Australia, and confiscated the passport of another who expressed support for democracy in front of classmates in Australia, Human Rights Watch said.

Hong Kong dissidents are being equally oppressed at the moment:

‘They can’t speak freely’: Hong Kong a year after the national security law
Powerful chilling effect as dissenters are detained, often without charges, and face life in prison. ...

Is it N Korea? No, in NK the people are brainwashed to a significant degree, they see Dear Leader as a god. The Chinese might very well know what is going on in their country, but they also know not to speak up.

Then we have this:

Chinese Covid-19 Gene Data That Could Have Aided Pandemic Research Removed From NIH Database

You cannot ignore all that and claim the fact that an Australian researcher was at the WIV in Nov 2019 who didn't see anything amounts to any more than a weak anecdote.
 
Last edited:
No, do not ignore the rest of my post. There are ways of examining your question about whether Wuhan was shut down.
Right, ways of examining the question which are not available to us.


BTW, going back over some older evidence we dismissed for various reasons I can't recall at the moment, the issue of the full parking lot around one of the hospitals came up. I'm going to have to go back and look at that data.
 
Last edited:
Right, ways of examining the question which are not available to us.


BTW, going back over some older evidence we dismissed for various reasons I can't recall at the moment, the issue of the full parking lot around one of the hospitals came up. I'm going to have to go back and look at that data.

Why is it not available? I gave some suggestions about how you could examine it.

To be honest, it sounds like a massive long-shot. A single anecdote from a visitor saying it was like a ghost town and apparently no media or other residents felt like mentioning it.

Months into the pandemic people were alarmed at flights from Wuhan flying in to all kinds of destinations. There are a LOT of people in that city and a LOT of people flying in and out and a LOT of people who would be able to tell you if the city was shut down or if the government was warning about a pathogen etc….

I think it is ….weird that you think it is so difficult to examine.
 
It's a stupid suggestion angrysoba. As for one anecdote, there were almost 10K foreign military personnel at the games, not "a single anecdote".

How about you look for some of those military that are actually accessible and see if you can find any contradictions to the empty town reports.

I have a friend in Hong Kong I will be asking and hoping to hear back from in the next week or so. They are a distance from Wuhan but she might know if there were any shut downs. They jumped through some serious hoops when there was COVID in the city, wiping down anything they brought in from outside, stuff like that.
 
It's a stupid suggestion angrysoba. As for one anecdote, there were almost 10K foreign military personnel at the games, not "a single anecdote".

How about you look for some of those military that are actually accessible and see if you can find any contradictions to the empty town reports.

I have a friend in Hong Kong I will be asking and hoping to hear back from in the next week or so. They are a distance from Wuhan but she might know if there were any shut downs. They jumped through some serious hoops when there was COVID in the city, wiping down anything they brought in from outside, stuff like that.

It‘a not my job to find contradictory evidence. We don’t have 10,000 claims of a ghost town, do we? We don’t even have any claims by anyone except your surmising that 10 million people were locked down and only you have just now discovered it through the power of imagination whereas all the foreign consulates and media were oblivious to it, nobody in the city thought to or were brave enough to tell the outside world but you, yes YOU have uncovered Beijing’s dirty secret from a few lines in a couple of stories in the Daily Mail….

… is that your theory?
 
It‘a not my job to find contradictory evidence. We don’t have 10,000 claims of a ghost town, do we? We don’t even have any claims by anyone except your surmising that 10 million people were locked down and only you have just now discovered it through the power of imagination whereas all the foreign consulates and media were oblivious to it, nobody in the city thought to or were brave enough to tell the outside world but you, yes YOU have uncovered Beijing’s dirty secret from a few lines in a couple of stories in the Daily Mail….

… is that your theory?
Is it your hypothesis that 33 pages filled with supporting evidence is overridden because one researcher at the WIV reports seeing nothing in Nov? :rolleyes:

I remind you there already is genomic evidence the pandemic started earlier than Nov.
 
Is it your hypothesis that 33 pages filled with supporting evidence is overridden because one researcher at the WIV reports seeing nothing in Nov? :rolleyes:

I remind you there already is genomic evidence the pandemic started earlier than Nov.

Huh? Again, this is a weird conclusion. I am sure there is evidence that the virus was around in November. There is no evidence at all for your wild theory about a secret lockdown of Wuhan then. That bit is frankly crazy.
 
Huh? Again, this is a weird conclusion. I am sure there is evidence that the virus was around in November. There is no evidence at all for your wild theory about a secret lockdown of Wuhan then. That bit is frankly crazy.

Evidence there was some kind of lockdown in Wuhan in Oct when >9,000 military personnel from multiple countries were there for military games: One or more of said personnel said they witnessed it.

Evidence against any kind of lockdown in Wuhan in Nov: One researcher said she saw nothing amiss.

Once again you claim "no evidence at all" and claim I have "a wild theory" when you should know by now this is no longer a theory relegated to the CT circles where conflict-of-interest Daszak tried to bury it.

For whatever reason your posts seem to flip between different POVs.
 
Evidence there was some kind of lockdown in Wuhan in Oct when >9,000 military personnel from multiple countries were there for military games: One or more of said personnel said they witnessed it.

Evidence against any kind of lockdown in Wuhan in Nov: One researcher said she saw nothing amiss.

Once again you claim "no evidence at all" and claim I have "a wild theory" when you should know by now this is no longer a theory relegated to the CT circles where conflict-of-interest Daszak tried to bury it.

For whatever reason your posts seem to flip between different POVs.

Wrong, you are definitely pushing a conspiracy theory right now.

Seriously! Do you think there was a lockdown in Wuhan in October/November on the basis of ONE athlete saying "Gee! It looked like a ghost town"

The burden of proof is on YOU to give evidence for the lockdown.

There is NONE.

Get over it!
 
CT right, like all the evidence the Chinese government took off line was just a coincidence... That never happened.

Like the Chinese have refused to open the books so to speak for a proper COVID investigation.... That never happened.

Like the Chinese requiring one whistleblower doctor to keep his mouth shut ... That never happened.

How about the Chinese claiming 5 people at the military games who reported to the hospital in Oct really had malaria*, not COVID 19.... That never happened.

*Maybe these 5 people came from a malaria zone and just happened that all 5 got sick at the same time.

Coincidentally from the files of you can't have it both ways: China is officially malaria-free, says WHO
After having gone four years with no reported cases, China applied for malaria-free certification from WHO in 2020. Inspectors from WHO visited the country in May and verified that the “chain of indigenous malaria transmission by Anopheles mosquitoes has been interrupted nationwide” — even in southwestern Yunnan, which borders three malaria-endemic countries, Myanmar, Laos, and Vietnam.
Apparently there have been occasional imported cases during the 4 years.​

Nope, none of that happened, just some crazy CT.

I have asked before and I'm asking again, this is a thread for a serious discussion of the evidence. Please take your CT insults and other assorted nonsense to the thread in the CT forum where it belongs.
 
Last edited:
CT right, like all the evidence the Chinese government took off line was just a coincidence... That never happened.

Like the Chinese have refused to open the books so to speak for a proper COVID investigation.... That never happened.

Like the Chinese requiring one whistleblower doctor to keep his mouth shut ... That never happened.

How about the Chinese claiming 5 people at the military games who reported to the hospital in Oct really had malaria*, not COVID 19.... That never happened.

*Maybe these 5 people came from a malaria zone and just happened that all 5 got sick at the same time.

Coincidentally from the files of you can't have it both ways: China is officially malaria-free, says WHOApparently there have been occasional imported cases during the 4 years.​

Nope, none of that happened, just some crazy CT.

I have masked before and I'm asking again, this is a thread for a serious discussion of the evidence. Please take your CT insults and other assorted nonsense to the thread in the CT forum where it belongs.

You know full well what I am talking about is the specific claim by you that Wuhan was locked down in October. It is YOU, not me, who should take that particular theory to the CT forums.

Now, do you have evidence for your claim or do you think that reading one line in the Daily Mail has allowed you to notice something that all the consulates in Wuhan missed?

Answer me this:

Why did the world, including the diplomatic missions of the US, UK and France, for example, not notice the lockdown?

If you want to put forward this theory you need a lot more evidence than one person saying it looked like a ghost town.
 
I don't have to prove something that has already been addressed just because you are ignoring the evidence. And insisting I've made some new claim when in reality I posted what was said by the returning military personnel is absurd.

But that has nothing to do with you insulting people as CTers. I don't imagine you would like hearing that you are Daszak's patsy, would you?


Moving on, I wanted to go back over this data about the full parking lots around Wuhan hospitals in the Fall of 2019. This is one of several bits of evidence posted on much earlier in this thread that was dismissed at the time but which maybe upon review it actually does fall into place.

Harvard: Analysis of hospital traffic and search engine data in Wuhan China indicates early disease activity in the Fall of 2019
Abstract:
The global COVID-19 pandemic was originally linked to a zoonotic spillover event in Wuhan’s Huanan Seafood Market in November or December of 2019. However, recent evidence suggests that the virus may have already been circulating at the time of the outbreak. Here we use previously validated data streams - satellite imagery of hospital parking lots and Baidu search queries of disease related terms - to investigate this possibility. We observe an upward trend in hospital traffic and search volume beginning in late Summer and early Fall 2019. While queries of the respiratory symptom “cough” show seasonal fluctuations coinciding with yearly influenza seasons, “diarrhea” is a more COVID-19 specific symptom and only shows an association with the current epidemic. The increase of both signals precedes the documented start of the COVID-19 pandemic in December, highlighting the value of novel digital sources for surveillance of emerging pathogens.

Keep in mind when this paper was written the authors had this operating underlying premise:
... virologic samples of wildlife in the Huanan market could not be linked to SARS-CoV-2, suggesting transmission at the market was downstream from the spillover event...

This hypothesis is supported by emerging epidemiologic and phylogenetic evidence indicating that the virus emerged in southern China and may have already spread internationally, and adapted for efficient human transmission by the time it was detected in late December.
[I've taken out the reference numbers, 6,7,8 etc. but they can be found in the paper]

I believe the symptom search data was ridiculed if anyone wants to see what specifically was said dismissing this evidence.

The initial rise in GI symptoms may also hint at the missed early signals of COVID-19 in current surveillance systems for respiratory pathogens. The standard definition for influenza-like illness is a combination of fever along with cough and/or sore throat.
 
Last edited:
All right, you got any of these witnesses who aren't afraid of speaking up against the Chinese government... you know, the government that is pressuring Chinese students in Australia not to criticize the Chinese government? We already know what happened to one doc who tried to speak out that the pandemic was being covered up.
If no witnesses are speaking up then that's proof that the Chinese government silenced them. The less evidence we have of China deliberately creating Covid to infect the West a Wuhan lab-leak the more proof we have that it happened!
 
I don't have to prove something that has already been addressed just because you are ignoring the evidence. And insisting I've made some new claim when in reality I posted what was said by the returning military personnel is absurd.

But that has nothing to do with you insulting people as CTers. I don't imagine you would like hearing that you are Daszak's patsy, would you?


Moving on, I wanted to go back over this data about the full parking lots around Wuhan hospitals in the Fall of 2019. This is one of several bits of evidence posted on much earlier in this thread that was dismissed at the time but which maybe upon review it actually does fall into place.

Harvard: Analysis of hospital traffic and search engine data in Wuhan China indicates early disease activity in the Fall of 2019

Keep in mind when this paper was written the authors had this operating underlying premise:[I've taken out the reference numbers, 6,7,8 etc. but they can be found in the paper]

I believe the symptom search data was ridiculed if anyone wants to see what specifically was said dismissing this evidence.

Evidence Wuhan was locked down in October 2019, please!

Give me something or accept you have nothing.
 
Evidence there was some kind of lockdown in Wuhan in Oct when >9,000 military personnel from multiple countries were there for military games: One or more of said personnel said they witnessed it.
Maybe the population were indeed instructed to keep off the streets as much as possible whilst they were there. It sounds like something the Chinese government might do. You may be reading more into it than is warranted.
 
If no witnesses are speaking up then that's proof that the Chinese government silenced them. The less evidence we have of China deliberately creating Covid to infect the West a Wuhan lab-leak the more proof we have that it happened!

Are you suggesting there is only one single piece of evidence the Chinese are quashing dissident voices here? Because there are dozens of pieces of evidence.

As for the deliberate creation of a bioweapon or something related, no one I have seen is arguing that possibility.

Rather this involves hubris of some researchers, and the Chinese are not the only people doing this, that they can do gain-of-function research making pathogens more dangerous and nothing bad can ever result.

And one more comment about "proof", no one has claimed that either. What I and some others are claiming is when one looks at the evidence for a lab accident vs a natural spillover, there is more evidence on the lab leak side of the scale.
 
Last edited:
Are you suggesting there is only one single piece of evidence the Chinese are quashing dissident voices here?

Classic motte-and-bailey.

You are asked for evidence of a lock-down in October 2019, and you start asking if we believe that China is not authoritarian or silences dissent etc...

Yes, well all know that happens.

You have to spell out the actual evidence for the actual claim.

Was Wuhan locked down in October 2019?
 
Evidence Wuhan was locked down in October 2019, please!

Give me something or accept you have nothing.
Maybe the population were indeed instructed to keep off the streets as much as possible whilst they were there. It sounds like something the Chinese government might do. You may be reading more into it than is warranted.
Angrysoba is making up something about what I've posted, and you are following his lead.

To review before this discussion became distorted and full of nothing but cherry picked arguments, go back and look at post 1269 which I'll quote from here:
This anecdote was also interesting from the Daily Mail:
Gorges claims Wuhan’s streets were ‘nearly empty’ when he went for a cycle ride in the city. ‘It was a ghost town,’ he said. ‘There were rumours that the government warned the inhabitants not to go out.’
And from WA Po:
During the two-week event, however, many of the international athletes noticed that something was amiss in the city of Wuhan. Some later described it as a “ghost town.”

When a single Aussie scientist reported she did research in the WIV in Nov 2019 and didn't notice anything was amiss, suddenly this became a false assertion by angrysoba that I needed to prove "my claim" the streets in Wuhan were deserted in Oct 2019.



Maybe some of you not following the discussion would go back and actually review the evidence pro and con about the origin of COVID and join the discussion.

Post 1274 is a good place to save having to review the whole thread:
Incredibly detailed and thorough summary of all the evidence to the date of the paper (Bloom's work is not in there), complete with a 70+ page bibliography: 3. WUHAN LABORATORIES, BAT RESEARCH AND BIOSAFETY.

The paper goes over all the evidence of multiple possible scenarios. It includes much of which we've cited throughout this thread but in significantly greater detail. It's well organized. It includes work being done by other labs in Wuhan, issues before the BSL4 was built, images of students and workers collecting bat specimens without proper PPE, papers written by the scientists going back more than a decade including work by Daszak and Shi done in 2019.

Every aspect is included from waste disposal to live animals and in vivo cultures of SARS CoV specimens.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom