Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I posted 2 cites from Quay early on. He did a statistical analysis that supported the lab accident and he mapped the first cases and found they closely followed the #2 subway line that connected the WIV to the airport.

I'm on my way out the door but I'll listen to it tonight. Thanks for the link.

Yep, that's why I thought you would be interested.

You're welcome.
 
Can lab accident deniers answer a few questions about just what is evidence please?

This isn't something I'd normally expect to have to explain on a forum dedicated to science and skepticism. Scientific evidence generally takes the form of confirmed predictions. You make prediction unique to the hypothesis being tested and then test that prediction.

There are a couple caveats.
a) Something is only evidence for one hypothesis over another if they result in different predictions.
b) Something is only evidence of there is a chance the prediction could turn out to be false.


Are papers published by the researchers at the WIV before the outbreak describing their GoF work with SARS CoV strains evidence


Not evidence. GoF is standard lab work. It happens in virology lab all over the world all the time. Something that is so ubiquitous can't be considered evidence for anything as it would be occurring regardless of the origin of Covid-19


Are records of students and researchers at the WIV going to the Yunnan bat caves to collect specimens of SARS CoV strains evidence?

Not evidence. The impetus for the Wuhan lab existing was the threat Corona viruses represent and the need to study them in greater detail. Getting samples from bats is an every day part of the work the lab was created for. It's something that would have been occurring regardless of how the first humans were infected and therefor cannot be used to distinguish between any hypothesis.

Is the fact the Chinese government quashed genome files just prior to the recognized cases evidence

This "fact" has been refuted. A reasonable explanation for taking the database offline has been given by the scientists involved, and as you already admitted the timeline doesn't work anyway.


Would the fact the Chinese government made purchases of massive amounts of PPE at the beginning of the pandemic evidence

Stocking up on supplies at the beginning of a potential pandemic should be something every government engages in. Again, this is true regardless of origin.

Is a long list of lab accidents at the WIV and a complaint there wasn't enough trained staff for the level 4 biosecurity just before the pandemic evidence?
Unsubstantiated claim. Lab accidents happen everywhere and no data on comparative frequency of abdicants has been presented. Even if true, it doesn't follow that this was a lab accident.

It's also worth noting that there are suspicious things about the claim itself. For example the BSL-4 lab didn't open until 2018 so how could there be a "long list" of accidents involving it?

Is the location of the pandemic's beginning in Wuhan near the WIV evidence whether or not you consider it is strong or weak evidence?

The basis of this claim is how close the Wuhan market is to the lab, but you insist the market has nothing to do with the origin of the outbreak.

As for the why they are in the same region, it's reason to question if there is a connection, BUT modeling 101 says you can't use the same data to from your hypothesis and to test your hypothesis, so this CAN'T be used as evidence.

Is evidence of other inadvertent lab releases and near misses of pathogens evidence

Lab accidents will regardless of Covid-19 origins so their existence doesn't favor any particular hypothesis and can't be called evidence for any particular hypothesis. It's also non-sequieter to assume that since lab accidents happen that this event is a lab accident.

Note that theories about a lab origin sprang up around Zika, H1N1 (2009), Ebola, SARS, AIDS and probabaly every single pandemic in the last 100 years. If "lab accidents happen" is evidence for a lab origin for Covid why is not considered evidence that all pandemics come from laboratories?
 
Last edited:
You weren't in the discussion in the first half. I stopped when I found that one.

What difference does it make how long ago it was? You said you never said it. You did.

I ASKED you for the evidence when I came into the discussion. I didn't say none existed. You do understand that one has to ask for the evidence for a claim at some point, right? That's not tantamount to saying there is no evidence.

Where is that post? I found nothing remotely like it.

Appropriately enough in post 666, your response to me mentioning circumstantial evidence (which I said didn't make much of a case) was a rolling eyes emoticon. You can follow the conversation from there.

It's in your last post, the one I was replying to!

Are you refering to post 1195? Look again.

If that wasn't it then which post was it?

Ginger, I have mentioned said evidence NUMEROUS times. You have NEVER addressed it and now you're asking me where it is? Are you for real?

More needless snark.

I've tried reason over and over and I can'T get through to you. So you'll excuse my vocal frustration with you.
 
Last edited:
And the evidence for the natural spillover where it was somehow in the wild in an unknown host but can't be found,

Just 2 days ago you posted a link to a "rebuttal" of a paper that shoed you couldn't get Covid-19 though laboratory manipulation of known Covid-19 relatives.

The central claim of that rebuttal turned out to be that it's wasn't known Covid-19 relatives "they" were working with, instead it was some other natural virus that has yet to be identified.

This about that for a min. A lab leak has exactly the same gap, IOW, the proposed wild ancestor "they" were supposedly working with hasn't been identified. In one case you (incorrectly) assert this means natural spillover is unlikely, but in the other you are claiming the exact same problem *supports* your hypothesis.


 
It occurs to me that the way evidence is dismissed for the lab leak theory is not used for the natural origin theory. I see no easy way of finding evidence for one that rules out the other theory.
 
It occurs to me that the way evidence is dismissed for the lab leak theory is not used for the natural origin theory. I see no easy way of finding evidence for one that rules out the other theory.

Sure. Most pandemics start in nature, however, so at least it's got those odds on its side.
 
It occurs to me that the way evidence is dismissed for the lab leak theory is not used for the natural origin theory. ....
This ^.


Moving on...

I listened to the podcast last night that angrysoba linked to. It was a debate with this title: "Be it resolved, the preponderance of evidence suggests COVID-19 leaked from a laboratory."

The reason wasn't because they intended it to be a one-sided debate but rather the idea was to debate if that was a true statement, a common debate format. So essentially it was Dr. Steven Quay who is convinced it most likely was a lab accident vs Dr. Daniel Griffin arguing that it was most likely a natural spillover event.

Griffin's main argument was that a natural event was common (he didn't address known lab accidents) and his concern was that it will happen again and we need to address the risk (also true for a lab accident but again, he didn't acknowledge that).

Quay, OTOH, had multiple reasons it was not a natural event. He started with ~10 things against a natural event and in his final argument he concentrated on 3.

He noted the market related cases were genetically downstream from other cases. That's a bit more than just saying which cases came first chronologically.

He mentioned the data base taken down and lamented why it was done and why won't China allow access to the material.

He noted it was dangerous that a lab like this was in a population center complete with an international airport. They both agreed on this but Griffin noted you won't have top-notch scientists if the WIV was in a rural area. Quay agreed and thought maybe some form of quarantine for the researchers could mitigate the risk.

Quay mentioned the thorough analysis in the WHO report which found no trace of COVID 19 outside of Wuhan (I posted about that upthread) before the cases were detected in Dec. 2019. He also said the Chinese tested thousands of animals and had yet to find any source of the spillover. I think the number was ~80,000 animals but that's based on my possibly faulty memory.

And Quay said the furin cleavage site was not seen in wild but has been seen in labs. From the genomes the WIV was looking at, serial passages will get you to covid 19.

I don't have the expertise to discuss the furin cleavage site but I do know from the epidemiology of highly pathogenic influenza that jumps from animals to humans that it doesn't happen in one fell swoop. We still have some very dangerous flu viruses that have infected people who were exposed to animals that carry it but as of yet have not seen the adaptation needed for those flu strains to spread easily from person to person.


In his final argument Quay listed three things one sees in a zoonosis spillover one did not see with COVID 19.

In a natural spillover event one finds an animal source with the virus mixing around and either recombining or mutating slowly (both usually) before getting to the spillover event. (You find this with influenza.)

Next there are usually multiple spillover events starting with a less than ideal match to the human pandemic strain. (Again you see this with influenza.)

And finally there should be at least some mutations within humans prior to the pandemic strain being perfected. (Also seen with pandemic influenza.)

Quay noted those 3 things were found with SARS CoV 1.

But with COVID 19 it was a single event, none of that precursor activity has been found. This observation has been confirmed by other virologists.

There was a single animal rather than a group of animals (of one species) sharing the virus as it became more and more adapted to human cells. They can't even find a single animal source but with 80,000 animals tested (I'll double check that number) they should have found something closer than the coronavirus bat virus.

And finally it was ready to go with that first case. There is no evidence of a lot of cases in humans where the virus became more and more adapted resulting in the pandemic strain. There was no evidence the virus percolated in humans anywhere. The genetic analysis showed the first case occurred somewhere in Wuhan (actually somewhere close to the WIV in Wuhan) and it was ready to go. That there were 2 lineages found early on is not evidence of numerous cases prior to the detection of the beginning of pandemic.


I'll see if I can find more published material from Quay for those who don't wish to listen to the 43 minute podcast debate. I wish there was a transcript.
 
Sure. Most pandemics start in nature, however, so at least it's got those odds on its side.
This is exactly what steenkh was referring to.

If you are going to argue odds then you need to consider the odds of the virus emerging near the WIV and a long distance from the Yunnan bats.

All the 'could have happened this way or that' can be made for both a natural and a lab accident scenario.
 
It occurs to me that the way evidence is dismissed for the lab leak theory is not used for the natural origin theory. I see no easy way of finding evidence for one that rules out the other theory.

In my view compelling evidence has not been provided for any hypothesis. The origin of COVID 19 is still unknown. And the thousands of posts on the topic here in this forum have done nothing to change that. There are some interesting ideas that may prove out, but nothing concrete.
 
I guess that means you'll continue to ignore the objections and points.

And you didn't even bother retracting what I showed you to be wrong about in my last post. Classy.
:id:

I have addressed every one of the natural event arguments.
 
In my view compelling evidence has not been provided for any hypothesis. The origin of COVID 19 is still unknown. And the thousands of posts on the topic here in this forum have done nothing to change that. There are some interesting ideas that may prove out, but nothing concrete.
It's true there is no conclusive evidence one way or the other yet. But at some point the evidence grows stronger for one scenario and weaker for the other. It's a false equivalence to say the evidence doesn't lean either way.

As for all the posting here, I've had many papers and points brought to my attention here that I might not have seen otherwise. I know a lot of our members are uncomfortable with forum conflict. That is what it is.
 
Last edited:
I have addressed every one of the natural event arguments.

Now that's a bald-faced lie, Ginger. I've been trying to get you to address mine for days now, and you have stadfastly avoided it. In fact you managed to look through the thread to find an inconsequent post of mine and managed to miss one that I found in a few seconds.
 
Now that's a bald-faced lie, Ginger. I've been trying to get you to address mine for days now, and you have stadfastly avoided it. In fact you managed to look through the thread to find an inconsequent post of mine and managed to miss one that I found in a few seconds.

Stop with the bitching about what you think I didn't address and just say what it is. I can't read your mind despite you thinking everything you've said is clear.

List what you think I haven't addressed.
And please stop calling me a liar. Good grief!
 
Last edited:
It's true there is no conclusive evidence one way or the other yet. But at some point the evidence grows stronger for one scenario and weaker for the other. It's a false equivalence to say the evidence doesn't lean either way.

As for all the posting here, I've had many papers and points brought to my attention here that I might not have seen otherwise. I know a lot of our members are uncomfortable with forum conflict. That is what it is.

Evidence can lean in a particular direction without being compelling. The “lean” of the arguments here has not convinced me that any particular idea will prove to be correct.
 
Evidence can lean in a particular direction without being compelling. The “lean” of the arguments here has not convinced me that any particular idea will prove to be correct.

I don't disagree with this. And obviously we in the thread don't agree on which batch of arguments carry more weight.
 
It occurs to me that the way evidence is dismissed for the lab leak theory is not used for the natural origin theory. I see no easy way of finding evidence for one that rules out the other theory.

That depends on which lab leak hypothesis you are referring to. There is considerable evidence against any human involvement with the creation of the virus.
- No one has seen a furin cleavage site likw the one in Covid-19 was examined, so there was no way to know what effect it would have until you'd studied the Covid-19 virus itself.
- no one had ever seen a furin cleavage site cleated in this way until they Covid-19 was studied
- If, for some reason, someone wanted to create furin cleavage site they would full cleavage site which would have been even better at binding to human cells. What Covid-19 has is only a partial site. Why would someone go to the trouble of creating a site and only do it part way?
- the site itself was created out of alignment, why would someone create the site out of alignment and then re-align it instead of creating it in alignment to begin with.



The version of the lab leak where scientist visited a bat cave got infected then took it back to Wuhan is just another version of natural spillover with some extra details added in for no particular reason. This isn't impossible but it's looking less and less likely as we learn more about Covid-19 relatives.

While the closest currently know relative comes from caves in Yunnan it's not a direct ancestor of Covid-19 (either natural or by lab manipulation). Other close relatives have been identified in bats and other hosts all the way from Japan to Africa.
 
I DID. But you keep ignoring it. Clearly you can't address it.

If you want people to stop pointing out your behaviour, stop that behaviour.

Seriously, you still insist on this game of guess what you are thinking when you could just repeat what it is you think I ignored?

I have no clue in the myriad of things you've posted what you are talking about.

Just say what the **** it is!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom