Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact that the furin cleavage site exists on a spectrum of similar but not identical site suggests something that exists naturally and is evolving naturally. Since it is actively evolving whether or not something absolutely identical exists in a related virus is irrelevant.

Maybe instead of spouting off your translation in what you don't really have any expertise in you could quote sources that do instead.

Like this one from 2 weeks ago: BioEssays: SARS-CoV-2′s claimed natural origin is undermined by issues with genome sequences of its relative strains - Coronavirus sequences RaTG13, MP789 and RmYN02 raise multiple questions to be critically addressed by the scientific community
Abstract
RaTG13, MP789, and RmYN02 are the strains closest to SARS-CoV-2, and their existence came to light only after the start of the pandemic. Their genomes have been used to support a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2 but after a close examination all of them exhibit several issues. We specifically address the presence in RmYN02 and closely related RacCSxxx strains of a claimed natural PAA/PVA amino acid insertion at the S1/S2 junction of their spike protein at the same position where the PRRA insertion in SARS-CoV-2 has created a polybasic furin cleavage site. We show that RmYN02/RacCSxxx instead of the claimed insertion carry a 6-nucleotide deletion in the region and that the 12-nucleotide insertion in SARS-CoV-2 remains unique among Sarbecoviruses. Also, our analysis of RaTG13 and RmYN02's metagenomic datasets found unexpected reads which could indicate possible contamination. Because of their importance to inferring SARS-CoV-2′s origin, we call for a careful reevaluation of RaTG13, MP789 and RmYN02 sequencing records and assembly methods. ...

After repeated requests for clarifications from several scientists and journalists and more than 9 months later, the Zhou et al.[1] paper has been amended with an Addendum,[1] which provides some missing information on RaTG13, most of it previously discovered and made public by an independent research group named “DRASTIC”[5] and published by Rahalkar and Bahulikar[6] and Segreto and Deigin.[7]

While the Addendum clarifies some crucial points, such as exact sampling location of RaTG13, and mentions the original paper describing it,[8] the information released is still incomplete and partially in conflict with data previously provided. ...

And like other missing data that might help resolve the origin debate:
In addition, new information revealed by the Addendum is that eight other beta-SARSr-CoVs distantly related to SARS-CoV were also isolated from the same Mojiang mine, and sequenced together with RaTG13, but neither their genomes, nor information about their sample names and eventual accession numbers is provided. ...

The Addendum also fails to release details about the number and kind of samples collected from the mine workers, their storage conditions, methods used for each test described and specification of the results obtained.

In addition, the Addendum fails to address and/or contradicts the statements in an MSc[10] and a PhD[11, 12] theses which have previously described in detail the miners’ pneumonia symptoms and stated that SARS Immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies were detected by the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in all four of the miners’ samples tested. ...

More questions:
However, several papers have already relied on MP789 for their analysis, namely the widely cited “The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2″ paper published in Nature Medicine by Andersen et al.[27] that concludes that SARS-CoV-2 most likely originated in nature. Recent analyses have questioned the possibility of pangolins as possible intermediate hosts for SARS-CoV-2,[28, 29] therefore Andersen et al.[27] and other authors relying on MP789 should carefully re-evaluate their conclusions. SARS-CoV-2′s RBD, which appears to be highly adapted to human ACE2[30]—even more than the one developed by severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS-CoV) in 2002/2003,[31] remains a very peculiar feature.


Finally:
In conclusion, we propose that the review process of all papers describing SARS-CoV-2′s closest relatives which could contribute to identify SARS-CoV-2′s origin should made public, allowing an open and critical evaluation by the entire scientific community.
 
Maybe instead of spouting off your translation in what you don't really have any expertise in you could quote sources that do instead.

Like this one from 2 weeks ago: BioEssays: SARS-CoV-2′s claimed natural origin is undermined by issues with genome sequences of its relative strains - Coronavirus sequences RaTG13, MP789 and RmYN02 raise multiple questions to be critically addressed by the scientific community

And like other missing data that might help resolve the origin debate:

More questions:


Finally:

What a terrible paper you've found!

Look something was fixed between preprint and publication, clearly suspicious! also people are conspiring to make fake entries in the genebank database!

They also try to make a big deal that only 2 of the 9 Pangolins sampled had the sequence shared for the receptor binding domain shared by Covid-19 and the Pangolin Sabercorona virus. Maybe, just maybe that's because the other 7 were not infected...

That was just stuff thrown in that has little to do with what the paper is actually saying. They are arguing (and I use that word VERY loosely) that Covid 19 could not be natural spillover from bats in any form. (Not scientists visiting the caves nor live animal trade) because they find evidence of deletions in the binding domain of related viruses.

Deletions have been discussed for a while now. We can't tell whether the furin cleavage site was inserted due to recombination with a Pangolin virus or whether it's an ancestral feature that has been lost or partially lost in covid relatives that infect bats.

The Phylogenetic trees I posted on the previous page that RmYN02 and RacCS203 both have elements of the RNA to form a furin cleavage site in spite of the fact they don't use ACE2 to enter cells. It would hardly be surprising for a virus to lose part of the RBD for something it doesn't connect to. If anything, though, loss of part of the RNA that codes for an unused receptor would further support natural evolutionary forces being involved.
 
It is not as much of a furin cleavage issue as it is the amino acids and location of furin cleavage. The insertion (PRRA) AND cleavage site (S1/S2) are completely unique to Covid-19...

Again, so what? Take enough different things "in combination" and every organism is unique.

is why the impact on humans is so much greater than it would be on any other creature, this combination of S1/S2 and PRRA was pretty much a "designer" attack on the human lungs and intestines. "

This part isn't true. There are MANY animals with ACE2 similar to humans where this structure is highly beneficial for the virus. This includes Pangolins but there are many others as well. Considering how quickly Covid spread though mink farms it may be even more infectious to them than it is to humans.

Also, while Covid is more infectious than the flu it's not even close to viruses like measles and it probabaly isn't even as infectious as the original SARS.
 
What a terrible paper you've found!

[snipped more unsupported drivel]

The Phylogenetic trees I posted on the previous page that RmYN02 and RacCS203 both have elements of the RNA to form a furin cleavage site in spite of the fact they don't use ACE2 to enter cells. It would hardly be surprising for a virus to lose part of the RBD for something it doesn't connect to. If anything, though, loss of part of the RNA that codes for an unused receptor would further support natural evolutionary forces being involved.
You continue to post demonstrating expertise you clearly do not have.


Moving on...

The authors' credentials:
Rossana Segreto
University of Innsbruck | UIBK · Institute of Microbiology
PhD

Yuri Deigin,MBA...
is a serial biotech entrepreneur, longevity research evangelist and activist, and a cryonics advocate. He is an expert in drug development and venture investments in biotechnology and pharmaceuticals. He is the CEO at Youthereum Genetics and the Vice President at Science for Life Extension Research Support Foundation.



There was a peer review reply to their paper
There is no evidence of SARS-CoV-2 laboratory origin: Response to Segreto and Deigin (DOI: 10.1002/bies.202000240)
Abstract
The origin of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) is the subject of many hypotheses. One of them, proposed by Segreto and Deigin, assumes artificial chimeric construction of SARS-CoV-2 from a backbone of RaTG13-like CoV and receptor binding domain (RBD) of a pangolin MP789-like CoV, followed by serial cell or animal passage. Here we show that this hypothesis relies on incorrect or weak assumptions, and does not agree with the results of comparative genomics analysis. The genetic divergence between SARS-CoV-2 and both its proposed ancestors is too high to have accumulated in a lab, given the timeframe of several years. Furthermore, comparative analysis of S-protein gene sequences suggests that the RBD of SARS-CoV-2 probably represents an ancestral non-recombinant variant. These and other arguments significantly weaken the hypothesis of a laboratory origin for SARS-CoV-2, while the hypothesis of a natural origin is consistent with all available genetic and experimental data.
The bolded is an argument by incredulity which I believe is not supported by the facts.


... to which the authors responded:There are no valid points of criticism in Tyshkovskiy and Panchin’s response (10.1002/bies.202000325) to our paper “The genetic structure of SARS-CoV-2 does not rule out a laboratory origin” (DOI: 10.1002/bies.202000240)
Abstract
Tyshkovskiy and Panchin have recently published a commentary on our paper in which they outline several “points of disagreement with the Segreto/Deigin hypothesis”. As our paper is titled “The genetic structure of SARS‐CoV‐2 does not rule out a laboratory origin”, points of disagreement should provide evidence that rules out a laboratory origin. However, Tyshkovskiy and Panchin provide no such evidence and instead attempt to criticize our arguments that highlight aspects of SARS‐CoV‐2 that could be consistent with the lab leak hypothesis. Strikingly, Tyshkovskiy and Panchin’s main point of criticism is based on a false premise that we have claimed RaTG13 to be a direct progenitor of SARS‐CoV‐2, and their other points of criticism are either incorrect or irrelevant to our hypotheses. Thus, the genetic structure of SARS‐CoV‐2 remains consistent with both natural or laboratory origin, which means that both the zoonotic and the lab leak hypothesis need to be investigated equally thoroughly.

Perhaps you can comment intelligently regarding the peer review and the rebuttal? :rolleyes:
 
Segreto's Twitter is intersting:
Rossana Segreto
@Rossana38510044
·
May 10/1
This all boils down to probability.

What are the odds of a virus new for humans but best adapted for human infection because of a sequence new for its group, the FCS, AND an high affinity RBD, that originated a pandemic after few months from its appearance..

Rossana Segreto
@Rossana38510044
·
3h
These lies make me feeling enraged because I was falsely accused to be a conspirator for more than a year but also ashamed and worried because of an unexpected behaviour of scientists and scientific journals with great reputation. THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE.

WhatsInWuchang
@InWuchang
· 3h
Replying to @stuartjdneil @lab_leak and 7 others
Andersen lied about addressing an "analysis". We know there was no analysis because Cotton said he didn't have evidence. Cotton just suggested the labs be investigated.

Andersen lied about multiple material facts, so no surprise he lied about this.
Interesting.

Rossana Segreto
@Rossana38510044
·
22m
This is a real shame. He forgot how many regretted to have signed the statement in The Lancet which condemned as conspiracy a possible lab leak of SARS2.
Quote Tweet
Vincent Racaniello
@profvrr
· 58m
One of the co-signers of the letter to Science asking for more investigation into the origins of #SARSCoV2 - Pamela Bjorkman - realized that the letter was a mistake. Read her letter to #TWiV at https://bit.ly/3zzX0AD - could not agree with her more.

Rossana Segreto
@Rossana38510044
·
3h
This is not a hypothesis, it's real. Some experts lied. It was not conspiracy to consider possible a lab origin for SARS2 and they knew it. Now they admit it. Shall we just accept that it happened? Why did it happen? Will this happen again in future?
Tweet
Yeyo
@RealYeyoZa
· 3h
The issue isn't whether there was a lab leak or not.

The issue is that a viable hypothesis got branded as a conspiracy theory by prominent scientists with huge conflicts of intetest and the media enthusiastically toed the line without questioning.
A common experience in this case, just look at some of the posts in this thread trying to drag a CT into the discussion.

It's important as skeptics that we consider sometimes what gets labeled a CT turns out not to be. You have to be able to let some beliefs go and consider alternative hypotheses.

Rossana Segreto Retweeted
Ian Birrell
@ianbirrell
·
15h
Another terrible piece in
@guardian
on this issue, still doggedly pushing the concept of conspiracy theories - this time by someone who is so ill-informed that he is unaware there is more than one relevant lab in Wuhan


Here is The Guardian piece, not sure if it has already been cited:
Opinion: Though it is newly respectable, the Wuhan lab theory remains fanciful
But there is an essential caveat that has been overlooked – that two different hypotheses are possible does not make them equally likely. Occam’s razor is a general rule of thumb, an injunction to “keep it simple”; when confronted with competing explanations for events, it is usually sensible to adopt the interpretation that pivots on the smallest number of supplementary assertions and assumptions.
IMO Occam's razor would find the lab accident more likely given the enormous coincidence one needs to explain a natural spillover event. See the first Twitter quote in this post.
 
You continue to post demonstrating expertise you clearly do not have.

Neither RmYN02 nor RacCS203 use ACE2 for entering their target cell. This is right out of the paper and even in the graphic I provided.


picture.php




The authors' credentials:
Rossana Segreto
University of Innsbruck | UIBK · Institute of Microbiology
PhD

Yuri Deigin,MBA...

Delgin has literally never published a peer reviewed paper on any other subject, at least not one that shows up in Google Scholar. Segreto is listed on the university website as a Technical assistant though that could just be a translation issue. She has previously published peer reviewed papers on fungus, nothing on virology.

This screams woo peddlers.


LOL

So they are saying "RaTG13 wasn't used to create chimera virus, they used some unidentified direct ancestor instead!"

This mean the "real" virus "they" experimented with still needs to be "found", so how exactly can they show how Covid needed a laboratory to hybridize it to turn it into Covid? This makes absolutely no sense.
 
Even your Google skills fail you, lomiller.

Here's one: Unexpected novel Merbecovirus discoveries in agricultural sequencing datasets from Wuhan, China
In this study we document the unexpected discovery of multiple coronaviruses and a BSL-3 pathogen in agricultural cotton and rice sequencing datasets. In particular, we have identified a novel HKU5-related Merbecovirus in a cotton dataset sequenced by the Huazhong Agricultural University in 2017. We have also found an infectious clone sequence containing a novel HKU4-related Merbecovirus related to MERS coronavirus in a rice dataset sequenced by the Huazhong Agricultural University in early 2020. Another HKU5-related Merbecovirus, as well as Japanese encephalitis virus, were identified in a cotton dataset sequenced by the Huazhong Agricultural University in 2018. An HKU3-related Betacoronavirus was found in a Mus musculus sequencing dataset from the Wuhan Institute of Virology in 2017. Finally, a SARS-WIV1-like Betacoronavirus was found in a rice dataset sequenced by the Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University in 2017. Using the contaminating reads we have extracted from the above datasets, we were able to assemble complete genomes of two novel coronaviruses which we disclose herein. In light of our findings, we raise concerns about biosafety protocol breaches, as indicated by our discovery of multiple dangerous human pathogens in agricultural sequencing laboratories in Wuhan and Fouzou City, China.

Here's an essay he wrote over a year ago: Lab-Made? SARS-CoV-2 Genealogy Through the Lens of Gain-of-Function Research

Maybe it will help people understand his current paper with Sergeto.


As for your backbone argument you are simply repeating Andersen without addressing additional papers:

The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2
However, the genetic data irrefutably show that SARS-CoV-2 is not derived from any previously used virus backbone20. Instead, we propose two scenarios that can plausibly explain the origin of SARS-CoV-2: (i) natural selection in an animal host before zoonotic transfer; and (ii) natural selection in humans following zoonotic transfer. We also discuss whether selection during passage could have given rise to SARS-CoV-2.
It's the same squirrel argument: discuss one lab accident possibility as if no others are possible.

Here's an earlier paper from Segreto and Deigin: The genetic structure of SARS-CoV-2 does not rule out a laboratory origin
In order to evaluate the emergence potential of novel CoVs, researchers have created a number of chimeric CoVs, consisting of bat CoV backbones, normally unable to infect human cells, whose spike proteins were replaced by those from CoVs compatible with human ACE2. These chimeras were meant to simulate recombination events that might occur in nature.[19, 20] Such gain-of-function experiments have raised a number of biosafety concerns and stirred controversy among researchers and the general public. One of the main arguments in favor of gain-of-function studies is the need to be prepared with an arsenal of drugs and vaccines for the next pandemic.[21] By contrast, one of the main arguments against them is that the next pandemic itself could be caused by those experiments, due to the risk of lab escape.[22, 23]...

Synthetically generating diverse panels of potential pre-emergent CoVs was declared a goal of active grants for the EcoHealth Alliance, which funded some of such research at WIV, in collaboration with laboratories in the USA and other international partners.viii...


The history of past research has been brought up already:
n 2008, the Baric group at the University of North Carolina (UNC) took the WIV research one step further: instead of using human immunodeficiency viruses (HIV) pseudo-viruses with bat CoV spike proteins, a live chimeric CoV was created. Following the experiments of their 2007 WIV colleagues, the Baric group used a bat SARS-like CoV as a backbone and replaced its RBD with the RBD from human SARS.[30]

In 2015, the Shi and Baric groups joined forces and published probably the most famous gain-of-function virology paper, which described the creation of another synthetic chimeric virus.[19] This time the RBD of a mouse-adapted SARS backbone (SARS-MA15) was replaced by the RBD of RsSHC014, a bat strain previously isolated from Yunnan bats in 2011 by the Shi group. In 2016, the Baric group repeated their 2015 experiment using the same SARS-MA15 backbone and the RBD from Rs3367,[31] a close relative of RsSHC014 also previously found in Yunnan by WIV and renamed “WIV1” after live culturing.[17]

Probably the largest reported number of novel chimeric viruses created was described in a 2017 paper from the Shi group at WIV,[15] in which the authors reported creating eight chimeric viruses using WIV1 as a backbone and transplanting into it various RBDs from bat SARS-like viruses. These viruses were collected over a span of 5 years from the same cave near Kunming, Yunnan Province, where the Shi group originally found Rs3367 and RsSHC014. Only two of the eight live chimeric viruses were successfully rescued, and those two strains were found to possess the ability to bind to the human ACE2 receptor, as confirmed by experiments in hACE2-expressing HeLa cells and RT-PCR quantification of viral RNA.
Lots of evidence of what they were working on at the WIV before a whole bunch of material was withdrawn from public view. You appear to be asking for evidence when we know the Chinese government isn't allowing researchers to look.

So claiming [look—squirrel] XYZ couldn't possibly be anything but natural is a failed argument.
 
Last edited:
Jon Stewart on the Colbert Show tonight weighs in on the side that it's too much of a coincidence to have not come from the lab. He might be a lay person but the man is smart ... and funny.




Colbert is not well informed. He put forth the idea that the WIV was there because the bats were there.


The second half:
 
Last edited:
Jon Stewart on the Colbert Show tonight weighs in on the side that it's too much of a coincidence to have not come from the lab. He might be a lay person but the man is smart ... and funny.




Colbert is not well informed. He put forth the idea that the WIV was there because the bats were there.


The second half:

So basically Stewart is smart because he "agrees" with you and Colbert is not because he doesn't.

But yeah, you're not wedded to this idea at all.
 
Last edited:
Jon Stewart on the Colbert Show tonight weighs in on the side that it's too much of a coincidence to have not come from the lab. He might be a lay person but the man is smart ... and funny.




Colbert is not well informed. He put forth the idea that the WIV was there because the bats were there.


The second half:

Ahhhh...comedy!

There's more where that came from...



It's comedy!
 
Hey! Comedian sees a coincidence, and riffs off it on tv! That's gotta be real evidence for.......something?
It's evidence the 'too much of a coincidence' hypothesis is being circulated in the public square as opposed to the attempt by Daszak and his ilk to snuff out that discussion.
 
It's evidence the 'too much of a coincidence' hypothesis is being circulated in the public square
So what if it is? Lots of ideas are "being circulated in the public square". Some of them are quite crazy. That an idea is being circulated in the public square just means it is being circulated in the public square, nothing else.
 
So what if it is? Lots of ideas are "being circulated in the public square". Some of them are quite crazy. That an idea is being circulated in the public square just means it is being circulated in the public square, nothing else.

Right, it's the equivalent of "many people say...".
Come on guys. Are you so detached from reality that you don't know that the "public square" includes Fauci, Tedros, and the leaders of the G7? Your hatred of this idea doesn't seem grounded in reality. This idea is not considered crazy by the most credible experts there are.
 
Come on guys. Are you so detached from reality that you don't know that the "public square" includes Fauci, Tedros, and the leaders of the G7? Your hatred of this idea doesn't seem grounded in reality. This idea is not considered crazy by the most credible experts there are.
Thank you for trying to bring this back to a relevant discussion. :thumbsup:
 
Come on guys. Are you so detached from reality that you don't know that the "public square" includes Fauci, Tedros, and the leaders of the G7? Your hatred of this idea doesn't seem grounded in reality. This idea is not considered crazy by the most credible experts there are.


But, you don't understand! If we can't convince people that one of the two equally plausible explanations for the origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus is totally outrageous and crazy, people might say nasty things about China and the U.S. and even... science itself! You can't expect people to have a balanced perspective on economic turmoil and three or four million casualties. They'll over-react in totally absurd ways like "maybe that kind of research should be restricted more." Can you imagine?
 
Are you so detached from reality that you don't know that the "public square" includes Fauci, Tedros, and the leaders of the G7?

What's "reality" got to do with this? "The public square" could be anyone, so sure it includes Fauci. That's trivial and worthless.

Your hatred of this idea doesn't seem grounded in reality.

What hatred? Why are you lying?
 
Come on guys. Are you so detached from reality that you don't know that the "public square" includes Fauci, Tedros, and the leaders of the G7? Your hatred of this idea doesn't seem grounded in reality. This idea is not considered crazy by the most credible experts there are.
What a strange response to what I said. Skeptic Ginger said that Jon Stewart's piece on the lab leak hypothesis was evidence that the idea was "circulating in the public square". I mistakenly assumed that that was somehow relevant to the discussion and just pointed out that something being in the public square means nothing, lots of ideas, good, bad and ugly, "circulate in the public square" and it doesn't mean anything in itself about the idea.

And now I'm being accused of having "hatred of the idea" of the lab leak hypothesis for pointing this out? I definitely don't hate the idea, I'm not sure how anything I've posted could lead to that conclusion, I just don't find it at all compelling. :confused:
 
Last edited:
Uh, Fauci is trivial and worthless? Did you not understand that I was citing people who think this is worth pursuing and not crazy? I didn't just cite him as a member of the public but a member of the public that agrees lab leak needs investigation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom