Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're hilarious.


Moving on... If this is tl;dr for anyone read it in parts, skim it or just read the source material. I think some of you will find there is indeed new material here.

Here's more from Dr Quay discussing the furin site issue: March 1, 2021: Jorge Casesmeiro Roger (El Imparcial- a Spanish language news source), conducts an interview with Dr. Steven Carl Quay, MD, PhD on his statistical analysis of pandemic origin, a study that concludes “beyond a reasonable doubt” that SARS-CoV-2 is a lab derived virus at 99,8% chance versus a 0,2% probability of being a natural zoonosis.

At least as of March it was 62,000 animals tested, not 80,000:
A random study in all of China for a year in over 62,000 animals found zero virus”.
It's too late to edit my other post.

Now, why is 0 out of over 62,000 important? Let’s go back to 2003, with SARS-CoV-1. Once they knew within four months that it came from civet cats in a market, 90% of every cat that they tested from that point forward had SARS-CoV-1. And in 2015, when a similar coronavirus broke out in the Middle East, ten months after the first human patient they knew it was from camels and, again, 92% of every camel had the virus. So now we’ve done a random study in all of China for a year in over 62,000 animals and we found zero virus. The probability of that being similar to prior zoonosis its just abnormally low. ...

... One of the criticisms, for example, was that if there is an infinite number of species of coronaviruses and I don’t find a “furin site” in six hundred, is that really meaningful? So it turns out that one member of both Commissions, Dr. Peter Daszak, has actually estimated how many different species of coronaviruses there are in the world: 3.204. So instead of having an infinite number, I can drop 3.204 into my analysis. Which modifies the number by only about 0.5.


[Jorge Casesmeiro Roger] ... By the way, a very well known GoF coronavirus researcher, the aforementioned Peter Daszak, president of Ecohealth Alliance, is specially active in spreading that lab origin of the pandemic its just a conspiracy theory. He even tried to discredit lab hypothesis orchestrating at The Lancet an apparent editorial statement against it, in a way that was later revealed as something very similar to a conspiracy. Paradoxically, the starting probabilities of your analysis are based on Daszak’s work, among others.

[Quay] Look, I want to get to the truth, but I also want to do it in the most aggressive way I can. So wherever I could, I either used data from Dr. Daszak, who’s widely published, Dr. Shi at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) or Dr. Baric from North Carolina and leading coronavirus US expert.

And from the WHO themselves.

Yes Jorge, that’s right. They were the ones that studied 540 people for what’s called seroconversion. In SARS-CoV-1 and MERS there were blood samples in a refrigerator from people who had an early infection that wasn’t strong enough to become an epidemic. But they showed evidence of having antibodies. That’s called seroconversión. And it was about 1 to 3% in SARS-CoV-1 and MERS that you could find it in stored, refrigerated samples. But with CoV-2, in March 2020 the WHO examined 540 samples from Wuhan and found zero seroconversions. The probability of this is less than one on twenty that it was running around in Wuhan before the epidemic broke out.


Re the right out of the gate evidence:
For example, in SARS-CoV-1, the first human case had only 17% of the mutations it needed to become an epidemic, the first time around. But with SARS-CoV-2 it has 99.5% of the best mutations from the very first patient.

Which is what happened with SARS-CoV-1 and MERS.
Yes, in the first six months of the epidemic about every other patient got it from an animal. The intermediate host, either civet cats or the camels, developed those really good mutations to get into humans as well among themselves. So when you look at the virus in humans where the epidemic happens, you can trace the virus back through the mutations. If it traces back a year earlier or two years earlier that’s called posterior diversity. That means that the virus was really jumping into humans from cousins of the virus as opposed to a single primary parent virus.

But in SARS-CoV-2 we don’t see this.

In CoV-2 we have over a hundred million cases and they all trace through one patient: a patient the end of December at the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) hospital in Wuhan, about three kilometers from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV). That patient had what was called Lineage A. Every CoV-2 in the entire world is a descendant of that one. Even the one President Trump got. They all can trace back to that single individual patient. In SARS-CoV-1 you had multiple jumps from animals into humans. In MERS you had multiple jumps from camels into humans. CoV-2 is a one to one. You have one jump into one human from one animal. An animal in a laboratory I believe.


Back to the furin site:
... there are at least eleven different laboratories around the world, including the WIV, that have purposely put a furin cleavage site in a Spike protein. ...

... SARS-CoV-2 comes from a subgroup of coronaviruses called the sarvecovirus. But it’s the only one of this subgroup, this subgenera that has a furin site. ...

... If we look at between six and nine hundred other Sarbecoviruses, it depends on the numbers you use: zero have a furin cleavage site. All the furin cleavage sites are in distant relatives of this subgenera and the virologists tell me, and they agree, that recombination can’t occur that far apart.
That's interesting.


Dr Quay addresses the issue with the unusual codon that makes that business about the unlikely combo posted upthread a bit more clear.


... the additional steps needed to créate SARS-CoV-2 from RaTG13 are not clearly identified in the genome and so there are likely additional laboratory viruses involved in the process...


Re Dr Shi not finding any related viruses in her data:
So one of the statments that I put in the analysis at the end was that Dr. Shi was very carefully when she said that none of the viruses that she collected in the wild matched SARS-CoV-2. Which I believe its a true statement. But one that is a little bit tricky. Because what you just said its not what she actually said. You said that none of the viruses in the lab matched SARS-CoV-2. But Dr. Shi did not say that. What she said is: None of the viruses collected in the wild matched SARS-CoV-2. But if she collected a virus in the wold and then manipulated it in the laboratory, her careful statement would be true.
[typos in the original]

That's also very interesting. Dr Quay reached out to Dr Shi but received no reply.


Dr Quay talks about the dangerous GoF research in 2014 that resulted in temporary halt to that research.
... the 2017 lift reactivated US public fund on high risk coronavirus Gain-of-Function experiments with the Wuhan lab.
Hard to say they weren't doing that at the WIV when some of the funding came directly from the NIH.

There was a discussion about US scientists coordinating with the WIV but I had no idea of the scope of it until that all happened.


Just looking at the odds again, natural vs lab accident:
I was a little surprised by one of the WHO individuals who said that lab accidents are rare and so I sent him an email. In my Bayesian análisis there is a reference that showed that in Asia there was 0.8 laboratory leaks every year over a 30 year period.


Dr Quay notes he had a lot of experience with the furin site as a bee venom expert in his earlier days teaching at Stanford. It caught his attention as well as the Lancet opinion piece that made the unscientific CT statement did.

He discusses his company's work with the interviewer. Quay is the guy working on nasal delivery of drugs. When I posted his stuff before it was dismissed by some here as nothing more that self promoting his company's products. His credentials and experience as well as the fact he had published hundreds of papers were ignored.

Quay is not impressed by the evidence masks decrease transmission. I have to disagree with him on that one. I don't think everyone looks at the person with the infection wearing the mask, they mostly look at how it protects the person wearing it. Quay is not the only one making that mistake which I think he did.
 
Last edited:
Man, I've seen some circular discussions in my time, but this one takes the biscuit.

How about a truly independent, and highly informed opinion?

Helen Clark - who is nobody's person but her own - co-chaired an international investigation into every aspect of the pandemic over the past year.

As well as rightly smacking the WHO upside the head, the panel has states "the jury is out" on the origin of the virus. Jeez, I'm sure that's been said once or twice in this very thread.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/he...posing-china-travel-bans-jury-out-on-lab-leak

As you were, the pointless and inane bickering may resume now.
 
....

As you were, the pointless and inane bickering may resume now.
:p

Trying to move on. :)

A lot of the articles I went through this morning simply rehashed the same summary again and again. I can't easily see who was on that "expert panel" but it looks like it was a panel on the response and the delays etc as to what let the virus get so far out of hand. Seems like a worthwhile discussion but they need to say what kind of "experts" they included.
 
Last edited:
Just to poke in here because I saw an article of some relevance to the thread topic -

In hunt for Covid’s origin, new studies point away from lab leak theory

To poke at one part -

In parts of rural China where bat guano is collected from caves and used as fertiliser, people had been found to be carrying antibodies to those viruses, indicating previous infection. In other words, a spillover event could have happened without the involvement of any lab.

Still, it remains possible that the virus escaped from a lab. Some lab leak theorists consider it suspicious that the initial outbreak of Covid-19 happened in Wuhan, home to several high-security labs that study coronaviruses.

But Robertson says the fact that Wuhan is a city is explanation enough. Unlike the rural areas where the virus might have infected people previously, Wuhan has the population density – 11 million people – to sustain an outbreak.

Of all the known bat coronaviruses, the most similar to Sars-CoV-2, sharing 96% of its genome, is RaTG13, a virus that researchers at the WIV were studying prior to the pandemic.

But since RaTG13 was identified, others have been isolated from bats in China and south-east Asia that are also highly similar to Sars-CoV-2. A cluster of them, from the Chinese province of Yunnan, was described last week in the journal Cell. “The connection between RaTG13, the Wuhan Institute of Virology and Sars-CoV-2 isn’t required any more,” says Robertson.

The article goes into more depth on the subject in general, of course, and repeatedly makes clear that there really isn't a definitive answer currently.
 
Just to poke in here because I saw an article of some relevance to the thread topic -

In hunt for Covid’s origin, new studies point away from lab leak theory

To poke at one part -



The article goes into more depth on the subject in general, of course, and repeatedly makes clear that there really isn't a definitive answer currently.


Yes, This has been discussed several times here.
The reason Wuhan knew about antibodies and spillover in those caves is because a few people died of a SARS like virus in Yunnan and they were sent from Wuhan to investigate it. They have been visiting this area since. It is not open to the public or anyone else except the researchers since. Even the nearby village was relocated due to concerns.
They took samples from there every year.... back to Wuhan.
Then an outbreak happens in Wuhan.

So Im not sure how that points away from it being related to the work the lab was doing at some point in their travels or research. It's possible! (but I tend to think things happen closer to home)
 
Last edited:
Yes, This has been discussed several times here.

Thank you and I'm not surprised. I thought that I'd link to it, though, just in case anyone would find it to be potentially useful.

With that said, I may as well state my position on the subject as simply "I don't know and I have yet to see reason to care much about the origins beyond any potential usefulness in helping to lower the chances of future problems."
 
Last edited:
Thank you and I'm not surprised. I thought that I'd link to it, though, just in case anyone would find it to be potentially useful.

With that said, I may as well state my position on the subject as simply "I don't know and I have yet to see reason to care much about the origins beyond any potential usefulness in helping to lower the chances of future problems."

The thing that is true about what you posted is that spillover DID happen without the involvement of the lab. It was natural and SARS-like.

How this related 2019 novel virus traveled the long distance to Wuhan is the puzzle to solve in this thread!.

We do know that virus samples were taken to Wuhan that can infect human lung cells, naturally, without alteration.
Other ways of it getting to Wuhan are possible. Wildlife trade has been the top alternative way of bridging all those miles, but no animal in the trade has been found to carry it.
 
Last edited:
Not sure if this fresh

Writing in the Wall Street Journal this month, Quay and Muller explained that the "genetic fingerprint" of SARS-CoV-2 was the most damning indication it had been created in a lab.

They pointed to a specific amino acid sequence known as CGG-CGG, or double CGG, that is commonly spliced into viruses by researchers in order to increase their lethality.

"In fact, in the entire class of coronaviruses that includes CoV-2, the CGG-CGG combination has never been found naturally," they wrote.

"Now the damning fact. It was this exact sequence that appears in CoV-2. Proponents of zoonotic origin must explain why the novel coronavirus, when it mutated or recombined, happened to pick its least favourite combination, the double CGG. Why did it replicate the choice the lab's gain-of-function researchers would have made?"


https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/co...ng-scientists-say/6OCKGKKHQ6IF3VW5RU5QSLMIZI/
 
argh, more about arginine

"Now the damning fact. It was this exact sequence that appears in CoV-2. Proponents of zoonotic origin must explain why the novel coronavirus, when it mutated or recombined, happened to pick its least favourite combination, the double CGG. Why did it replicate the choice the lab's gain-of-function researchers would have made?" New Zealand Herald, as linked above.

The codon CGG specifies the amino acid arginine, and there are six codons in all that do so in the standard table of the genetic code. I cannot say very much on the question of how rare or common this codon is. This depends on which organism is being discussed. What is not immediately clear is why this has an effect on lethality. I did a bit more looking into the general question of CGG-CGG and found this:

"Andersen says that Baltimore was incorrect about that detail, however. In SARS-CoV-2, about 3% of the nucleotides encoding arginine are CGG, he says. And he points out that around 5% of those encoding arginine in the virus that caused the original SARS epidemic are CGG, too. In an e-mail to Nature, Baltimore says [virologist Kristian] Andersen could be correct that evolution produced SARS-CoV-2, but adds that “there are other possibilities and they need careful consideration, which is all I meant to be saying”. Nature
 
Last edited:
And agreeing with Dr Quay is Dr Redfield, a virologist, in an interview with Dr Gupta from CNN. You hear Redfield in his own words, it's not all written reporting. Notice how the piece calls it a CT several times and puts up the WHO report and Fauci's opinion to rebut Redfield's. No mention is made that the WHO report was considered inconclusive by the head of the WHO.

It's an uphill battle to get any neutrality on this subject despite things like Redfield's and Quay's arguments that it was too well adapted to humans in its single jump to humans to have occurred naturally, (single jump not in much dispute).

No precursor history as of yet discovered.

 
Last edited:
PRRA site

After making previous comment (#1233) about CGG-CGG, I did a little bit more reading an found an article from last February that put the question into context by discussing a preprint (I realize that I am behind). These two codons are part of the four codons for the sequence PRRA, which is the furin cleavage site. I also found an article at the Andersen website, but I have not read it in detail yet. It has links to other articles, one of which is from Bill Gallagher.
 
Last edited:
After making previous comment (#1233) about CGG-CGG, I did a little bit more reading an found an article from last February that put the question into context by discussing a preprint (I realize that I am behind). These two codons are part of the four codons for the sequence PRRA, which is the furin cleavage site. I also found an article at the Andersen website, but I have not read it in detail yet. It has links to other articles, one of which is from Bill Gallagher.

What's your understanding of the CGG repeat increasing lethality? I've not heard of this and fairly certain that I would have.
 
Thank you and I'm not surprised. I thought that I'd link to it, though, just in case anyone would find it to be potentially useful.

With that said, I may as well state my position on the subject as simply "I don't know and I have yet to see reason to care much about the origins beyond any potential usefulness in helping to lower the chances of future problems."

The link was new as were the viruses identified in the paper. They fit and expand the existing phylogenetic tree for Covid-19 which we've previously discussed.
 
my best guess

What's your understanding of the CGG repeat increasing lethality? I've not heard of this and fairly certain that I would have.
Disclaimer: I know just enough to be dangerous. I don't think that it is the CGG-CGG itself; instead, I think that it is the middle six bases of the twelve bases that code for PRRA, which is a Furin cleavage site, if I am not mistaken. I think that this is why the word "lethality" came up. There is disagreement about how this cleavage site came into existence.
 
Last edited:
Disclaimer: I know just enough to be dangerous. I don't think that it is the CGG-CGG itself; instead, I think that it is the middle part of the twelve bases that code for PRRA, which is a Furin cleavage site, if I am not mistaken. There is disagreement about how this cleavage site came into existence.


The CGG repeat is what was quoted but even so how do two arginines make a virus lethal? Or do they mean more infectious? They also confuse nucleosides with amino acids.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
What's your understanding of the CGG repeat increasing lethality? I've not heard of this and fairly certain that I would have.

I believe it was discussed on the TWiV podcast a few weeks back. Vincent Racaniello said that there was nothing particularly interesting about the repeated sequence and that double or triple copies of it happen all the time in nature even in other corona viruses.

The claims of "increased lethality" seem unlikely to matter because Covid is considerably less lethal than SARS or MERS both of which are 10X-20X more likely to kill you if you contract them. What makes Covid so dangerous is it's ability to spread rapidly with minimal symptoms then turn much more serious in ~5% of cases.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom