Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
@JesseCuster If you know that non-crazy people support the idea under discussion what is the point of mentioning that the public includes people with crazy ideas? BTW you didn't mention "good" in your original post. You focused on crazy.
 
@JesseCuster If you know that non-crazy people support the idea under discussion what is the point of mentioning that the public includes people with crazy ideas? BTW you didn't mention "good" in your original post. You focused on crazy.

NO ONE is saying that the idea is crazy, Yuppy. Maybe if you guys stopped attacking strawmen we'd be having a discussion.
 
@Belz Do you agree that Fauci, Tedros, the leaders of the G7 and many other credible authorities consider the lab leak to be plausible?
 
@Belz Do you agree that Fauci, Tedros, the leaders of the G7 and many other credible authorities consider the lab leak to be plausible?

Do you agree that I find it plausible as well, or did you miss that while assembling your earlier strawman?


Oops, I guess we've moved on from the "public square" argument, now that it's been blown apart!
 
@JesseCuster If you know that non-crazy people support the idea under discussion what is the point of mentioning that the public includes people with crazy ideas?
What's the point of mentioning that the idea is "circulating in the public square", it tells you nothing about the idea in question, other than it's "circulating in the public square"? That's all I was asking about, it's an entirely irrelevant point that adds nothing to the discussion. When I asked that, Ginger Skeptic posted this:

So what if I posted it? What is the problem? Did I say it was more than that? I said Stewart was smart. He is. I said Colbert had facts wrong. He did. I added later Stewart also had facts wrong. He did.

Is this intended to open a discussion about it or to complain that I posted it? I want to get it straight before I continue.

The negative reaction to my posting it seems well over the top.
So it wasn't intended to add anything to the discussion. It wasn't intended to point out that relevant public figures like Anthony Fauci are discussing the idea, it was just an offhand comment that wasn't meant to add to the discussion. I got my answer to my question.

You've entirely misunderstood her comment if you think pointing out that people like Fauci are part of the "public square" is some sort of defense of what she said.
 
@JesseCuster If you know that non-crazy people support the idea under discussion what is the point of mentioning that the public includes people with crazy ideas? BTW you didn't mention "good" in your original post. You focused on crazy.
Now you're just being obtuse.

I merely pointed out that something an idea "being circulated in the public square" is entirely irrelevant to the worthiness of an idea.

I said that some ideas being discussed in the public square includes crazy ideas to point out that that it doesn't add anything to the debate about the idea itself, because discussions in the public square includes things that are crazy, so it's not meaningful to point out that something happens to be a public discussion.

For example, if the discussion was about anti-vaxxers, (I feel compelled to say that I'm not comparing the idea of the lab leak with anti-vaxxers before someone gets bent out of shape) and someone said that anti-vaccination ideas were "circulating in the public square" it would be reasonable to think that the person who said that was making a relevant point and it would be reasonable to point out that it's an irrelevant point because an idea "circulating in the public square" doesn't lend any weight to it. It turns out that I misunderstood Ginger Skeptic's comment, and she wasn't trying to add to the discussion, it was just an offhand comment that meant nothing at all.

I don't know why what I said was so contentious. :confused: Some people seem to be just looking for a bone to pick.
 
Last edited:
What's the point of mentioning that the idea is "circulating in the public square", it tells you nothing about the idea in question, other than it's "circulating in the public square"? That's all I was asking about, it's an entirely irrelevant point that adds nothing to the discussion. When I asked that, Ginger Skeptic posted this:

So it wasn't intended to add anything to the discussion. It wasn't intended to point out that relevant public figures like Anthony Fauci are discussing the idea, it was just an offhand comment that wasn't meant to add to the discussion. I got my answer to my question.

You've entirely misunderstood her comment if you think pointing out that people like Fauci are part of the "public square" is some sort of defense of what she said.
In this case for more than a year the lab accident hypothesis was purposefully sold to the public as a conspiracy theory and the public bought it hook line and sinker.
While there were a few knowledgeable scientists objecting to that position, only in the last few months has the idea that there really was a valid lab accident hypothesis begun to interest a wider public including being accepted in broader scientific circles.

Rarely is a scientific matter subject to purposeful dismissal like this one was.

That Jon Stewart spent most of his interview on the Colbert show says a lot that this is now making up for the initial coverup.

If you think that adds nothing to the discussion then I suggest you reconsider in the bigger picture.

You might also want to consider the definition of 'public square' as a literary term. It is broader than the square in ancient Venice where the term arose.

https://thepublicsquare.com/
The Public Square is a place where ideas flow and people connect through radio, video, podcasts, publications, music creation and publishing and live events.
 
Come on guys. Are you so detached from reality that you don't know that the "public square" includes Fauci, Tedros, and the leaders of the G7? Your hatred of this idea doesn't seem grounded in reality. This idea is not considered crazy by the most credible experts there are.

I guess that depends on how you define "crazy". It's considered on par with the hypothesis that the virus came into China on frozen food. IOW it's possible if you squint really hard but no credible expert sees any evidence it actually happened.

And that is just the "plausible" hypothesis that "it was somehow in the lab in some unknown host, but no one knows how it got there, no one cataloged, someone got infected but no-one knows who then that person went to 2 different markets and spread a different lineage of the virus in each one".

The versions where the virus was actually created by Chinese scientist has been debunked in the peer reviewed literature and it openly laughed at by virologists who actually study the virus.

If "it's not impossible" is the most you can say about a hypothesis you need to be very careful of giving it any credibility. There are natural well understood mechanisms for a novel virus to jump species. It's normal it happens all the time and it requires no special explanation. Meanwhile every time there is a pandemic we see conspiracy theories that "it came from a lab". When someone claims makes the extraordinary claim a disease outbreak came from a lab the first reaction from anyone with basic critical thinking skills should be "show me the evidence" and thus far no one has shown any evidence
 
I guess that depends on how you define "crazy". It's considered on par with the hypothesis that the virus came into China on frozen food. IOW it's possible if you squint really hard but no credible expert sees any evidence it actually happened.
You've convinced me you've cherry picked yourself in to a complete misunderstanding of the situation. Do some open minded googling would be my advice.
 
...
And that is just the "plausible" hypothesis that "it was somehow in the lab in some unknown host, but no one knows how it got there, no one cataloged, someone got infected but no-one knows who then that person went to 2 different markets and spread a different lineage of the virus in each one".
And the evidence for the natural spillover where it was somehow in the wild in an unknown host but can't be found, no one knows where it crossed over into humans, no one knows who the patient zero was...

You have some falsehoods there as well, there is no evidence how it got to one market and as for the second, no one knows that there was a second market.

...The versions where the virus was actually created by Chinese scientist has been debunked in the peer reviewed literature and it openly laughed at by virologists who actually study the virus.
"Openly laughed at"? Debunked in peer reviewed literature? I don't think very much of the literature is as of yet peer reviewed. Care to post a few links? Let's see what the criticisms of the paper were.


...If "it's not impossible" is the most you can say about a hypothesis you need to be very careful of giving it any credibility.
:id:


...There are natural well understood mechanisms for a novel virus to jump species. It's normal it happens all the time and it requires no special explanation. Meanwhile every time there is a pandemic we see conspiracy theories that "it came from a lab". When someone claims makes the extraordinary claim a disease outbreak came from a lab the first reaction from anyone with basic critical thinking skills should be "show me the evidence" and thus far no one has shown any evidence
No, just no.
 
Can lab accident deniers answer a few questions about just what is evidence please? This is not a question of arguing what the evidence supports, just what exactly is being dismissed here as "not evidence".

Are papers published by the researchers at the WIV before the outbreak describing their GoF work with SARS CoV strains evidence one way or the other?

Are records of students and researchers at the WIV going to the Yunnan bat caves to collect specimens of SARS CoV strains evidence?
Is the fact the Chinese government quashed genome files just prior to the recognized cases evidence, whether or not one believes the timing puts the evidence's value in doubt?

Would the fact the Chinese government made purchases of massive amounts of PPE at the beginning of the pandemic evidence if it can be shown the orders were first made before any recognized cases? The orders are well documented including the US supplying PPE and ventilators at a time we needed them here, but I'm still looking for the initial order dates.

Is a long list of lab accidents at the WIV and a complaint there wasn't enough trained staff for the level 4 biosecurity just before the pandemic evidence?
Is the location of the pandemic's beginning in Wuhan near the WIV evidence whether or not you consider it is strong or weak evidence?

Is evidence of other inadvertent lab releases and near misses of pathogens evidence regardless of the number of these incidents?


If you find yourself arguing about the conclusions one can or can't draw from this evidence it is a sign you can't answer the question about what is or is not evidence. It would mean you are answering 'it is only evidence if you think it supports a particular conclusion'.

That should be a separate answer, yes it is evidence but here is why it doesn't support the lab accident hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
I'm no denier, so I'll abstain.
:rolleyes:

You've spent the last half of this thread (I didn't go back further than that) refusing to define what you consider evidence and dismissing evidence posted/cited claiming it isn't evidence.

Is it really that hard to admit there is indeed evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis, even it not enough to convince you?

Why are you claiming you want a discussion then dismissing any effort others make to have one?
 
Last edited:
You've spent the last half of this thread (I didn't go back further than that) refusing to define what you consider evidence and dismissing evidence posted/cited claiming it isn't evidence.

Why are you lying? What possible benefit could that have for you?

Not only have I admitted that the leak hypothesis is possible and indeed plausible, perhaps even probable, but I didn't even once refuse to define what I consider to be evidence. How can you say that this is "spending the last half of this thread" doing so? And the only evidence I've dismissed from you is the evidence I've mentioned, and which you have completely avoided addressing.

Aren't you tired of using hyperbole and strawmen to handwave other people's objections? Don't you think it'd be time for you to honestly address these objections?

Is it really that hard to admit there is indeed evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis, even it not enough to convince you?

I never said that there isn't any evidence. Remember when I told you that you have circumstantial evidence? Wasn't that yesterday? How can you, with a straight face, now claim, for anyone here able to go back and read the thread, that I haven't done so?

Aren't you getting embarrassed at any point by your own antics?
 
... Not only have I admitted that the leak hypothesis is possible and indeed plausible, perhaps even probable, but I didn't even once refuse to define what I consider to be evidence. How can you say that this is "spending the last half of this thread" doing so? And the only evidence I've dismissed from you is the evidence I've mentioned, and which you have completely avoided addressing.

... I never said that there isn't any evidence. Remember when I told you that you have circumstantial evidence? Wasn't that yesterday? How can you, with a straight face, now claim, for anyone here able to go back and read the thread, that I haven't done so?
OK, let's see.

... Excuse me, where is there evidence that it came from a lab?
Does that say anything about "other than circumstantial"? I can find no post where you defined what you consider evidence. Perhaps you could direct me to it. Nor do I see any post where you addressed the evidence you call circumstantial other than to dismiss it out of hand. Can you find one where you addressed the circumstantial evidence?



You asked me to prove the negative. Is that the question you claim I didn't address?
Nobody said anything about a final word except you. The tentative conclusion is that it came, as diseases often do, from an animal source. Do you or do you not have evidence that it didn't?
...
Now please quote where I said anything about there being a "final word".



Depends if there's any evidence either way. Oh, look! There's evidence that it jumped from bats to us. Gee, who'd have thought, eh?
Is this circumstantial or direct? Please post why you consider this direct evidence if you do and why it is more direct evidence than research papers the scientists working at the WIV and the record of what they collected from the Yunnan caves.



Why are you lying? What possible benefit could that have for you?...

Aren't you getting embarrassed at any point by your own antics?
More unnecessary snark. No, I am not lying and no I am not the least bit embarrassed about my posts here.
 
Last edited:
OK, let's see.

Does that say anything about "other than circumstantial"?

Are you joking? That was almost a month ago! Is that all you found? You're a far cry from "spending half the thread" doing so. It's still a lie by you.

Also, that a post doesn't address the circumstantial evidence doesn't negate another post that does. Sheesh.

I can find no post where you defined what you consider evidence.

You also found no point where I talked about the virtues of eating daily bananas, but why bring it up? Why would you expect me to do something like that out of the blue?

Nor do I see any post where you addressed the evidence you call circumstantial other than to dismiss it out of hand.

Another lie. I didn't dismiss the circumstantial evidence. I said it wasn't strong enough to draw a conclusion from.

Is that the question you claim I didn't address?

What are you even talking about? Where did I mention questions you didn't address?

No, I am not lying

It's either lying, or you are incapable of understanding English.
 
Last edited:
so there is apparently a debate about the lab leak here.

Stephen Quay vs Daniel Griffin.

Vincent Racaniello says he was asked to participate but declined because he thought it was pointless to have a debate with people who don't know anything about viruses and said to Daniel Griffin that he shouldn't have participated either.

https://munkdebates.com/podcast/covid-19-origins

I haven't listened, but those for and against might be interested in it.
 
Are you joking? That was almost a month ago! Is that all you found? You're a far cry from "spending half the thread" doing so. It's still a lie by you.
You weren't in the discussion in the first half. I stopped when I found that one.

What difference does it make how long ago it was? You said you never said it. You did.

B said:
Another lie. I didn't dismiss the circumstantial evidence. I said it wasn't strong enough to draw a conclusion from.
Where is that post? I found nothing remotely like it.

B said:
What are you even talking about? Where did I mention questions you didn't address?
It's in your last post, the one I was replying to!
B said:
... the only evidence I've dismissed from you is the evidence I've mentioned, and which you have completely avoided addressing.
If that wasn't it then which post was it?

B said:
It's either lying, or you are incapable of understanding English.
More needless snark.


If you would just address the issues you could save yourself pages of posts complaining:
the dismissal of evidence out of hand sans any discussion
and, giving more weight to the circumstantial evidence for a natural event than for the evidence for a lab accident
​
 
so there is apparently a debate about the lab leak here.

Stephen Quay vs Daniel Griffin.

Vincent Racaniello says he was asked to participate but declined because he thought it was pointless to have a debate with people who don't know anything about viruses and said to Daniel Griffin that he shouldn't have participated either.

https://munkdebates.com/podcast/covid-19-origins

I haven't listened, but those for and against might be interested in it.
I posted 2 cites from Quay early on. He did a statistical analysis that supported the lab accident and he mapped the first cases and found they closely followed the #2 subway line that connected the WIV to the airport.

I'm on my way out the door but I'll listen to it tonight. Thanks for the link.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom