Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just to poke in here because I saw an article of some relevance to the thread topic -

In hunt for Covid’s origin, new studies point away from lab leak theory

The paper referenced in this article was discussed extensively on the most recent episode of TWiV a couple days ago. Discussion starts at about the 30 min mark, but the non-covid paper they discuss before that is interesting as well.

They seem to agree that southeast China is getting closer but the search for the proximal ancestor needs to move farther south with a lot more sampling in Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, etc.

https://www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(21)00709-1.pdf

 
The paper referenced in this article was discussed extensively on the most recent episode of TWiV a couple days ago. Discussion starts at about the 30 min mark, but the non-covid paper they discuss before that is interesting as well.

They seem to agree that southeast China is getting closer but the search for the proximal ancestor needs to move farther south with a lot more sampling in Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, etc.

https://www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(21)00709-1.pdf

You can't play that back on the forum. Do you have the link to the video on Youtube?
 
The paper referenced in this article was discussed extensively on the most recent episode of TWiV a couple days ago. Discussion starts at about the 30 min mark, but the non-covid paper they discuss before that is interesting as well.

They seem to agree that southeast China is getting closer but the search for the proximal ancestor needs to move farther south with a lot more sampling in Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, etc.

https://www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(21)00709-1.pdf
video link was missing a character, it should work now

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaQecONCxew

 
An article proving China deleted files to prevent research on the origins

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/co...-researcher-finds/KIJOU6FUVHDSQAIOX5IDASVX5M/

Hmmm...interesting. It is from work by Jesse Bloom, who from what I have seen seems to be agnostic on the issue of whether or not it is a lab leak or natural spillover.

However, the deleted data has not been lost. By searching in the Google and Amazon clouds used for storage by the SRA, the professor found some of the removed genomic sequences.

The deleted data could now help fill in a missing link for scientists puzzled by the evolution of Sars-CoV-2 in people.

Regardless of how it ultimately reached humans, experts agree that Sars-CoV-2 originated in bats. But until now, the earliest known samples from Wuhan - including those taken from the Huanan Seafood Market, originally suspected as the potential source of the outbreak - were further away from these viruses, genetically, than other Sars-CoV-2 samples obtained in other parts of China and even other parts of the world.

The deleted sequences fill in that gap, as they are closer to the bat coronaviruses, and so could represent an earlier step in the evolution of the virus. They add further evidence that the virus was already circulating in humans in Wuhan as early as autumn 2019.

Experts said this was a major development.

Professor Rasmus Neilsen, a genomics expert at the University of California, Berkeley, tweeted: "These are the most important data that we have received regarding the origins of Covid-19 for more than a year."

However, there are also other important implications, as Professor Bloom explained in a lengthy Twitter thread.

"First, [the] fact this dataset was deleted should make us sceptical that all other relevant early Wuhan sequences have been shared," he said, pointing out that China ordered many labs to destroy early samples.

Chinese scientists were also under orders to get their publications on coronavirus checked and centrally approved - an order that came one day before the publication of the pre-print linked to the deleted samples.

Here is the long Twitter thread about this.

Link
 
video link was missing a character, it should work now

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaQecONCxew


A 2 hour podcast with no transcript. Seriously?

I looked at the link you posted but I don't think "we need to look further afield" is very meaningful for two reasons: one, it's obvious and what has been done still hasn't turned up any more likely suspects, and two, a thorough assessment by the WHO team could find no evidence of anything suggesting COVID 19 circulated anywhere else in China before the Wuhan outbreak.
 
Last edited:
OTOH, a new line of inquiry has been opened up regarding cases in Wuhan before the recognized outbreak and it would explain both the 2 lineages and the early cases that turned up in other countries. Early cases newly found in the US are of particular interest.

From the COVID science thread:
SG said:
Some suspect that athletes may have contracted covid at military games in Wuhan in October, 2019.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/06/23/congress-wuhan-military-games-2019-covid/

Well that would explain a number of puzzle pieces that hadn't yet fit into place, namely the Chinese government took access away to a lot of genome lab records in mid-Sept. In addition there were two lineages circulating (A & B) among the initial recognized cases in late Nov.

I found this interesting (NY Post link if WAPo is paywalled for people):
The State Department’s only consideration of the Military World Games happened in March 2020, when the Chinese Communist Party, in an attempt to sow disinformation, claimed that US Army personnel from a bioresearch lab in Fort Detrick in Frederick, Md., carried the disease to Wuhan.
"Attempt to sow disinformation" is typical US POV narrative, however I tend to think the narrative is correct for a couple reasons. One, it only came up as a reaction to Dump's ignorant politicization of the origin of the virus. Dump set the investigation on the origin of COVID back so far he may have destroyed any chance we ever had of determining the origin.

And two, the WIV was working with coronaviruses and the viruses are endemic in bats in Yunnan Province. There is no connection like that to a lab at Fort Detrick that I am aware of. But if there is, the US needs to come clean.


As for the suspect cases, I wonder if there were any fatalities from pneumonia among those attendees. If there were and even if some were hospitalized, there might be some preserved lab specimens or lab results that would be useful to look for.
 
Hmmm...interesting. It is from work by Jesse Bloom, who from what I have seen seems to be agnostic on the issue of whether or not it is a lab leak or natural spillover.



Here is the long Twitter thread about this.

Link

The twitter thread says it was US data (not Chinese) data from the NIH that was missing and needed to be recovered.

It seems fairly mundane overall. It says samples from the Wuhan market had already diverged from the proximal ancestor. We already knew that lineage A and B separated in Oct or early Nov a full month before the earliest samples so it's not a surprising result.
 
A 2 hour podcast with no transcript. Seriously?

I looked at the link you posted but I don't think "we need to look further afield" is very meaningful for two reasons: one, it's obvious and what has been done still hasn't turned up any more likely suspects, and two, a thorough assessment by the WHO team could find no evidence of anything suggesting COVID 19 circulated anywhere else in China before the Wuhan outbreak.

In the TWiV podcast they discuss how this is proceeding more or less like the SARS search, where they found more and more elements of the final virus until they found a cave with all the elements in one place. The paper provides further evidence that that the key genetic elements are present in several bat species and Pangolins ranging across SE Asia, but does not yet put everything in once place.

The part of China where these samples were taken is on the northern end of these overlapping ranges so it looks like the search needs to move south.
 
The twitter thread says it was US data (not Chinese) data from the NIH that was missing and needed to be recovered.

It seems fairly mundane overall. It says samples from the Wuhan market had already diverged from the proximal ancestor. We already knew that lineage A and B separated in Oct or early Nov a full month before the earliest samples so it's not a surprising result.

Yeah, I have to say that it doesn't really do much more than suggest something nefarious.

What that is, I don't exactly know. The only bit that could potentially be interesting is if it pushes back the start time to at or before September 2019. A lot of the lab leak theory (or at least one of them) hinges on the idea that the Chinese government (or someone in authority) discovered a particular virus had escaped and therefore decided to pull down the online databases (although that again, I am not sure how signiificant it would be given that surely the same data would have been saved by other researchers).

V&A didn't seem much impressed by the paper...
 
Yeah, I have to say that it doesn't really do much more than suggest something nefarious.

What that is, I don't exactly know. The only bit that could potentially be interesting is if it pushes back the start time to at or before September 2019. A lot of the lab leak theory (or at least one of them) hinges on the idea that the Chinese government (or someone in authority) discovered a particular virus had escaped and therefore decided to pull down the online databases (although that again, I am not sure how signiificant it would be given that surely the same data would have been saved by other researchers).

V&A didn't seem much impressed by the paper...
Given the 2 earliest lineages I think that corroborates the evidence for a few months earlier starting point.
 
The twitter thread says it was US data (not Chinese) data from the NIH that was missing and needed to be recovered.

It seems fairly mundane overall. It says samples from the Wuhan market had already diverged from the proximal ancestor. We already knew that lineage A and B separated in Oct or early Nov a full month before the earliest samples so it's not a surprising result.

The Twitter link doesn't work.

As for the data that is "missing" it was data the Chinese took off line in mid-Sept. That is clearly documented by D.R.A.S.T.I.C. including a list of what's missing and why it matters.

I'm not sure what you are talking about with the missing NIH data because I can't see the Twitter link.
 
Never mind I found another article on the US database.

A scientist says he's found 13 Wuhan coronavirus sequences that were deleted from a US database - and claims they're a 'goldmine' for research into the virus' origins
Dr. Jesse Bloom, a researcher at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center in Seattle, said Tuesday that he had recovered the deleted files from Google Cloud, and had reconstructed partial sequences of 13 viruses. He said they came from samples taken at the early stages of pandemic in Wuhan, where scientists first discovered SARS-CoV-2, the novel coronavirus that causes COVID-19.

The data initially came from a study by Wuhan University scientists, he said.

Bloom said his findings suggested the coronavirus was already circulating in Wuhan before being linked to COVID-19 outbreaks at the Huanan Seafood Market. They also suggested the sequences used in most studies into the virus' origins, including the joint WHO-China report, "are not fully representative of the viruses actually present in Wuhan at that time," he said.

This is excellent news, can't wait to read more about what the earlier genomes reveal.
 
The Twitter link doesn't work.

As for the data that is "missing" it was data the Chinese took off line in mid-Sept. That is clearly documented by D.R.A.S.T.I.C. including a list of what's missing and why it matters.

I'm not sure what you are talking about with the missing NIH data because I can't see the Twitter link.

I tried the link again and it seems fine to me.

It’s a thread by Jesse Bloom himself explaining his investigation. He is talking about data stored by NIH that was deleted.
 
I tried the link again and it seems fine to me.

It’s a thread by Jesse Bloom himself explaining his investigation. He is talking about data stored by NIH that was deleted.

I still get this message: "Something went wrong. Try reloading." :confused:

But no worries, I'll look for the Tweets around using the link.

The article I linked to explained how the data was deleted by whoever entered it, apparently, and Bloom got it back via the Cloud.

Bloom Twitter feed
Third, preprint provides modestly more evidence for progenitor being in clade A (not market clade), & substantially more evidence it might have T at site 29095. However, current inferences are likely based on incomplete data.
@sergeilkp
says it best: https://twitter.com/sergeilkp/status/1407505140718972928 (5/n)
Quote Tweet
Sergei Pond
@sergeilkp
· Jun 22
We should be prepared however, to revise these ideas and hypotheses further if and when more early sequence data emerge. I would not be surprised if these revisions are very significant (e.g. the timing of introduction).

Earlier Tweets than above
In a new study, I identify and recover a deleted set of #SARSCoV2 sequences that provide additional information about viruses from the early Wuhan outbreak: https://biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.18.449051v1 (1/n)

Here's the preprint: Recovery of deleted deep sequencing data sheds more light on the early Wuhan SARS-CoV-2 epidemic

https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.18.449051v1.full.pdf
 
Last edited:
Well let's start here from Bloom's article:
The second explanation, which was proposed in a blog post by Garry
(2021) and amplified by a popular podcast (Racaniello et al. 2021),

is that there were multiple zoonoses from distinct markets, with
the Huanan Seafood Market being the source of viruses in clade
B, and some other market being the source of viruses that lack
the T8782C and C28144T mutations. However, inspection of Figure 4 shows that clade B is connected to viruses lacking T8782C and C28144T by single mutational steps via other human isolates, so this explanation requires not only positing two markets with two progenitors differing by just two mutations, but also the exceedingly improbable evolution of one of these progenitors
towards the other after it had jumped to humans.

So the two market explanation gets another nail in the coffin. (The first nail being there was not an identified 'other market'.)

Re the data deleted by China:
The fact that such an informative data set was deleted has implications beyond those gleaned directly from the recovered
sequences. Samples from early outpatients in Wuhan are a
gold mine for anyone seeking to understand spread of the virus.
Even my analysis of the partial sequences is revealing, and it
clearly would have been more scientifically informative to fully
sequence the samples rather than surreptitiously delete the partial sequences. There is no plausible scientific reason for the
deletion: the sequences are perfectly concordant with the samples described in Wang et al. (2020a,b), there are no corrections
to the paper, the paper states human subjects approval was obtained, and the sequencing shows no evidence of plasmid or
sample-to-sample contamination. It therefore seems likely the sequences were deleted to obscure their existence. Particularly
in light of the directive that labs destroy early samples (Pingui
2020) and multiple orders requiring approval of publications
on COVID-19 (China CDC 2020; Kang et al. 2020a), this suggests a less than wholehearted effort to trace early spread of the
epidemic.



The problem with using the wrong anecdotal information on the location and source of samples being used:
Future studies should devote equal effort to going beyond the
annotations in GISAID to carefully trace the location of patient infection and sample sequencing.
Bloom found, for example, that samples collected in Guangdong were actually from patients infected in Wuhan and who later traveled to Guangdong where they developed symptoms.
Future studies should devote equal effort to going beyond the
annotations in GISAID to carefully trace the location of patient infection and sample sequencing. The potential importance
of such work is revealed by the observation that many of the
sequences closest to SARS-CoV-2’s bat coronavirus relatives
are from early patients who were infected in Wuhan, but then
sequenced in and attributed to Guangdong.



Again, why were the databases deleted?
Minimally,
it should be immediately possible for the NIH to determine the
date and purported reason for deletion of the data set analyzed
here, since the only way sequences can be deleted from the SRA
is by an e-mail request to SRA staff (SRA 2021). In addition, I
suggest it could be worthwhile to review e-mail records to identify other SRA deletions, which are already known to include
SRR11119760 and SRR11119761 (USRTK 2020).
Importantly, SRA
deletions do not imply any malfeasance: there are legitimate
reasons for removing sequencing runs, and the SRA houses
>13-million runs making it infeasible for its staff to validate the
rationale for all requests. However, the current study suggests that at least in one case, the trusting structures of science have been abused to obscure sequences relevant to the early spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Wuhan.
 
Last edited:
I am curious> what could the legitimate reasons be for removing sequencing runs?

Do such deletion requests to the SRA staff come with a justification for the request?

I'm not even sure they were deleted. From the error message posted in the twitter thread, it looks like the project name they were collected under no longer exists. It could be as simple as them being moved or collected under another once the existence of a novel virus was confirmed.
 
I am curious> what could the legitimate reasons be for removing sequencing runs?

Do such deletion requests to the SRA staff come with a justification for the request?
He stated why in the piece, because the volume of data is so massive it's not all kept.

And I do not believe any reason need be given based on the fact this particular request was not accompanied by a reason.
 
I'm not even sure they were deleted. From the error message posted in the twitter thread, it looks like the project name they were collected under no longer exists. It could be as simple as them being moved or collected under another once the existence of a novel virus was confirmed.
Did you not read the piece by Bloom? Did you only read the Twitter feed?

You probably should read the piece. You will be much better informed about this if you do.

Here's the link again: Recovery of deleted deep sequencing data sheds more light on the early Wuhan SARS-CoV-2 epidemic

It might be confusing because I posted the link in post 1255 and quoted from it in 1256.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom