Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
How is what a revelation? The fact you continue to lie about the evidence?

Please tell me what lie I have told.

Are you trying to smear my post by conflating it with an unrelated post?

Or did you quote me by accident? :mad:

I don't understand the anger.

You mean the significance of emails being transmitted back and forth between Funding agencies and people within institutions that receive monies? Or do you mean the significance of multiple scientists, from 3 different continents, discussing this new outbreak of a virus on Sunday morning? Or do you mean the significance of 4 of the 5 co-authors of "Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2", who initially thought there were inconsistencies with the virus evolving in nature whereas in 9 days they did a 180 turnaround, were cc'ed on these emails?

Did you read the proposals? I have no idea what you mean by "how is this a revelation?"

I would rather that you stated your cases instead of pointing at something with that Ohmigodwillyoulookatthat tone.

What are we supposed to infer from all this?
 
I hope you are saying this with tongue-in-cheek.

Your "logic" will need to go both ways.

Using your reasoning: If the virus is not found in nature, then it was created by a different means. Your reasoning is more appropriate in disproving the naturally found hypothesis.

An easy way to determine if the Horseshoe Bat was the original culprit is to infect the bat with Covid-19. If viral antigens are found in the lung... then the hypothesis leans towards nature but if viral antigens are not found in the lungs, then Horseshoe bats move further down the list of suspects.

This bears no resemblance at all to the reasoning lomiller used in the comment you quoted. Read what he wrote again for comprehension. Specifically "Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab." Do you really disagree with this?
 
You seem satisfied the pandemic would still have happened if the lab had never been built?

Let's take a look at the numbers to date.

Pandemics and epidemics caused by transmission for animal reservoir to humans: (non-exhaustive list)

Ebola
SARS
Hiv
MERS
H1N1
Several other influenza pandemics

Pandemics and epidemics caused by lab leaks:
.
.
.
.
.
.


I'm not saying the lab wasn't involved, but until solid evidence presents that it was I'll stick to natural origin being more likely.
 
This bears no resemblance at all to the reasoning lomiller used in the comment you quoted. Read what he wrote again for comprehension. Specifically "Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab." Do you really disagree with this?

I do disagree. It is a myopic version of possible events.

A stored and sequenced sample is not required for the leak to have come from the actions of researchers at the lab. I can think of many scenarios. There are likely a LOT I have not even considered. There are likely a lot I have no ability to consider.
Can you not think of how it can happen?
 
Last edited:
Some things are easier to conceal than others.

We have virologists all over the world scrutinizing this virus.

1. A few of them have found apparent anomalies that on a closer look are probably not that anomalous after all.

2. Then there are some non-virologists who have apparently done some "Bayesian analysis" or discovered that the virus "defies the laws of physics" or had papers published in non-virology related journals or who have uncovered some vast conspiracy that apparently involves China, a non-profit organization ostensibly set up to prevent spillover events, and the US government.

Apparently some people prefer number 2 as the most likely explanation.

There seem to be suggestions, for example in that Vanity Fair piece, that Peter Daszak's big bags of money are hushing up the world's virologists.

Seriously, I am not saying it is impossible, but some versions of the lab leak hypothesis, particularly those that implicate Fauci, really are in total CT world.
 
Please tell me what lie I have told.
Oh for Pete's sake! See post #1128.


I would rather that you stated your cases instead of pointing at something with that Ohmigodwillyoulookatthat tone.

What are we supposed to infer from all this?
Don't conflate my post with anyone else's because you are very bad at it.

I said this:
SG said:
There is plenty of evidence of what the lab was working on as late as 2019. There's plenty of evidence of the staff and students excursions to the caves in Yunnan including some with pictures of less than ideal protective covering on. There are reports from those excursions that live bats were brought back to the WIV from the field and evidence live bats and live coronavirus cultures were in the WIV. And more...

That doesn't have **** to do with No Other's post. It doesn't have **** to do with Fauci.

It is evidence you lie claiming no evidence exists.
 
Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab. If the virus were already in a lab it would be documented and easy to find, but it has not been found. Thus the virus must never have been in a lab in which case we can't have a lab leak or the virus was in a lab and scientists have conspired to hide this.

Early on, weren't samples of viruses ordered to be destroyed (maybe for safety reasons or at least that was the reason they gave), and isn't the documentation under lock and key?

At the same time, other events occurred that looked like coverups, but maybe weren’t. As soon as it was clear that the threat was a dangerous new coronavirus, the local health commission and then the national one ordered diagnostic and genetics labs to destroy their samples or surrender them to high-level biosecurity labs. Most labs chose incineration — another crime scene wrecked.
That smacked of coverup, and was treated as such by the Trump administration, but it’s actually standard safety procedure to prevent outbreaks. Our C.D.C. gave the same order in 2014 when it realized that hospital labs had samples from Ebola patients being treated in Dallas and Omaha. “We told the labs in Texas and Nebraska to destroy them or send them to Fort Detrick,” Dr. Pierre E. Rollin, who recently retired from the C.D.C after 26 years of fighting global outbreaks, told me. “You can call that a cover-up, but it was a public health decision.”
And China’s lack of candor is disturbing. It denies access to the institute’s lab logs and whatever messages were swapped during its own investigations, took down 2018 statements critical of lab biosecurity protocols, retaliated against Australia for advocating an open investigation and sharply restricted the W.H.O. investigators.

It would be easy to find assuming that the samples hadn't been destroyed and that investigators had access to those logs. However, samples were destroyed even if for justifiable reasons.
 
Last edited:
Let's take a look at the numbers to date.

Pandemics and epidemics caused by transmission for animal reservoir to humans: (non-exhaustive list)

Ebola
SARS
Hiv
MERS
H1N1
Several other influenza pandemics

Pandemics and epidemics caused by lab leaks:

I'm not saying the lab wasn't involved, but until solid evidence presents that it was I'll stick to natural origin being more likely.

First, there are a dozen recent sources citing that the H1N1 reemergence in the 70s was from a lab leak. I have not looked into it. If you are talking about the 2009 H1N1v, it was traced to a pig farm in Mexico. Using the correct name would help.

But your cherry picked numbers pale in comparison to the hundreds of documented lab accidents in China including some at the WIV.

To review just a few: A Short History of China’s Biohazard Accidents — before COVID-19

In addition to those listed:
2010: “In a survey of 231 fourth-year medical students published in the Chinese journal Northwest Medical Education in 2010, 19 percent were unfamiliar with the term ‘laboratory biosafety.’ Seventy-nine percent had heard the term but weren’t completely sure what it meant.”
Which makes this accident unsurprising:

September 3, 2011: “On the heels of a damaging laboratory outbreak that sickened 27 students, leaders at China’s Northeast Agricultural University last week dismissed two administrators, apologized for insufficient safety practices, and offered thousands of dollars in compensation to the students, who contracted brucellosis while dissecting goats in an anatomy course last December.”


And there is this:
August 11, 2014: Two science researchers, Lynn Klotz and Edward Sylvester, published a paper suggesting that the odds are better than one in four that “one of these viruses will escape from a lab and seed the very pandemic the researchers claim they are trying to prevent.”
Klotz is senior science fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation, and Sylvester is director of the Walter Cronkite Science and Medical Journalism Program at Arizona State University. They wrote, “from the calculations in two in-depth pandemic risk analyses, there is a substantial probability that a pandemic with over a 100-million fatalities could be seeded from an undetected lab-acquired infection (LAI), if a single infected lab worker spreads infection as he moves about in the community. From the Klotz analysis, there is about a 1–30 percent probability, depending on assumptions, that, once infected, the lab worker will seed a pandemic.”
We aren't close to 100 million fatalities yet, but this isn't over.

Then there is corruption in China (like elsewhere).
October 12, 2014: Li Ning, a leading expert at transgenic technologies at China Agricultural University, was arrested on corruption charges; in early 2020, Chinese courts sentenced him to twelve years in prison for embezzling 37.56 million yuan. Shanghai-based publication The Paper later reported that he had earned 10.17 million yuan ($1.46 million) by “illegally selling off lab animals and experimental milk.”


And this:
May 2018: A profile of Luo Dongsheng, part of a team of researchers from the Wuhan Institute of Virology collecting samples from a cave in Hubei, central China, noted that, “Luo’s team has collected a full rack of swabs and bagged a dozen live bats for further testing back at the lab.” A picture illustrating the story showed the researchers with exposed skin on their wrists.

And this:
Sometime in 2018-2019: According to Voice of America, “About a year before the coronavirus outbreak, a security review conducted by a Chinese national team found the [Wuhan Institute of Virology] did not meet national standards in five categories.”


But let's not stop there.
In Dec 2019 I was initially believed that some sort of lab leak at the Lanzhou Veterinary Research Institute of the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Science caused 65 people to contract brucellosis, “which can lead to incapacitation and permanent damage of the central nervous system.” But subsequent investigation found that the cause was a leak at the Zhongmu Lanzhou biological pharmaceutical factory, “which occurred between late July to late August last year, according to the city’s Health Commission. While producing Brucella vaccines for animal use, the factory used expired disinfectants and sanitizers — meaning not all bacteria were eradicated in the waste gas. This contaminated waste gas formed aerosols that contained the bacteria — and leaked into the air, carried by wind down to the Lanzhou Veterinary Research Institute, where the outbreak first hit.”


Science Direct: Sept 2019: Current status and future challenges of high-level biosafety laboratories in China

What do you suppose they had to say? :rolleyes: Scroll down to Part 3 to find out.
 
Last edited:
Post 1128 is a post by the Atheist. Not me!

Retract your accusation!
Aha! Sorry. I have mixed your posts up but it was because you quoted my post that replied to TA's.

But you still tried to conflate my arguments with No Other's. How about apologizing for that? :)
 
Last edited:
Aha! Sorry. I have mixed your posts up but it was because you quoted my post that replied to TA's.

But you still tried to conflate my arguments with No Other's. How about apologizing for that? :)

I looked at the reason why I included your post.

It was because in the very reply, No Other was replying to you.

You are spot on!

People can also see it for themselves if they go to...

My question then was what is this revealing that we don't already know.
 
I would rather that you stated your cases instead of pointing at something with that Ohmigodwillyoulookatthat tone.

What are we supposed to infer from all this?
You re-characterized my question. You don't need to respond if the question doesn't meet your criteria for inclusion or if you don't know the answer.
 
This bears no resemblance at all to the reasoning lomiller used in the comment you quoted. Read what he wrote again for comprehension. Specifically "Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab." Do you really disagree with this?
First... it is the exact same reasoning (Boolean) juxtaposed.

Second... since we can't go back in time; I am assuming that "present" means today. That being said... "no". Expunging evidence is unfortunately performed all the time. People throw evidence off of bridges into rivers, people burn evidence into fireplaces, people eat evidence.
 
So that we do not mix lineages...

1. name the next relative that you are referring to, this way we are on the same page.
2. will this soon to be named next relative have the same polybasic insertion as SARS-CoV-2?

thx

RmYN02 which is Covid's second closest know relative and the newly discovered RacCS203 share parts of Covid-19 furin cleavage site.


https://www.virology.ws/2021/02/18/sars-like-bat-coronaviruses-are-not-only-in-china/


This paper has a number of useful Phylogenetic trees.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-21240-1

As you can see the closest know relative based on the receptor binding domain is the Pangolin virus SARSr-CoV GD/1/2019. This is the second closest relative in terms the spike protein but more slightly more distantly related when considering the whole genome.


picture.php


picture.php


picture.php
 
Your "logic" will need to go both ways.

Using your reasoning: If the virus is not found in nature, then it was created by a different means. Your reasoning is more appropriate in disproving the naturally found hypothesis.

You are not making sense. Labs catalog the viruses they are working on, they must have this data in order to work on them. This is vastly different from suggesting every virus that has ever exists out in nature has been catalogued.

An easy way to determine if the Horseshoe Bat was the original culprit is to infect the bat with Covid-19. If viral antigens are found in the lung... then the hypothesis leans towards nature but if viral antigens are not found in the lungs, then Horseshoe bats move further down the list of suspects.

Many people favor an intermediate host specifically because Covid-19 doesn't bind efficiently to bat ACE2. There are plausible scenarios for a jump directly from a bat. Eg both the CasCS203 virus does not use ACE2 at all, but has elements of the Covid-19 furin cleavage site and may be the virus responsible for covid reactive anti-bodies present in both bats an pangolins found in Thailand.
 
RmYN02 which is Covid's second closest know relative and the newly discovered RacCS203 share parts of Covid-19 furin cleavage site.

As you can see the closest know relative based on the receptor binding domain is the Pangolin virus SARSr-CoV GD/1/2019. This is the second closest relative in terms the spike protein but more slightly more distantly related when considering the whole genome.
Authors claim the RmYN02 polybasic furin site has a natural PAA amino acid insertion at the furin site, yet the SARS-CoV-2 has PRRA. Looking at the underlying
nucleotide sequence of RmYN02's closest ancestors bat-SL-CoVZC45 and bat-SL-CoVZXC21 no insertions are present just mutations of nucleotide.

That makes CoV-2 unique with it's beta Coronavirus relatives not only with the polybasic furin cleavage junction S1/S2 but also with the PRRA amino acid inserts.
 
Authors claim the RmYN02 polybasic furin site has a natural PAA amino acid insertion at the furin site, yet the SARS-CoV-2 has PRRA. Looking at the underlying
nucleotide sequence of RmYN02's closest ancestors bat-SL-CoVZC45 and bat-SL-CoVZXC21 no insertions are present just mutations of nucleotide.

That makes CoV-2 unique with it's beta Coronavirus relatives not only with the polybasic furin cleavage junction S1/S2 but also with the PRRA amino acid inserts.

The fact that the furin cleavage site exists on a spectrum of similar but not identical site suggests something that exists naturally and is evolving naturally. Since it is actively evolving whether or not something absolutely identical exists in a related virus is irrelevant.
 
The fact that the furin cleavage site exists on a spectrum of similar but not identical site suggests something that exists naturally and is evolving naturally. Since it is actively evolving whether or not something absolutely identical exists in a related virus is irrelevant.
It is not as much of a furin cleavage issue as it is the amino acids and location of furin cleavage. The insertion (PRRA) AND cleavage site (S1/S2) are completely unique to Covid-19... there is no other coronavirus with this combination. This is why the impact on humans is so much greater than it would be on any other creature, this combination of S1/S2 and PRRA was pretty much a "designer" attack on the human lungs and intestines. "

"Given the evolutionary gap, raTG13 is unlikely to be the direct ancestor virus of SARS-CoV-2, rather it branched out from the same ancestor (Xiaolu Tang, 2020; Zhou et al., 2020a)."

... until a creature is found, it is suspect that this evolved through nature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom