Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
That doesn't answer my second question. ;)

It's probably a PITA to look up the correct spelling of his last name every time you want to reference him. I usually just stick to the name of the podcast, and having to spell the last name correctly is the main reason.
 
I remain convinced that there was no justification. The Chinese government engaged in a conspiracy at the beginning to try to hide the very existence of the pandemic. Is that a conspiracy theory?

A) that wouldn't actually be a conspiracy because there is only 1 entity involved.
B) it wasn't the Chinese government hiding things it was regional officials hiding things from the Chinese government. This doesn't appear to be a conspiracy either, more like a case of several people not wanting to be the ones to bring forward bad news.

I would not call it a "CT" in the "nutty CT" sense. That the coverup is larger and includes a lab leak does not seem that far-fetched IMO.

There is a huge difference between officials not reporting a suspicious disease cluster and accusing real scientists who made major contributions to their field of being involved in a conspiracy to cover-up the "real" origin of the pandemic.
 
Of course if you don't look, you can declare any damn thing you want.
:rolleyes:

People with different opinions here don't have them because they failed to read something you think would change their mind. They read it and still don't agree with you.

The only conspiracy in evidence is that of the Chinese government to cover things up.
 
Last edited:
Re the GoF dismissal in the Vincent podcast, no one is talking about all GoF research. We are talking very specifically of the danger of creating a very dangerous pathogen.

It's just like dismissing the lab leak argument by conflating it with the military creating a bioweapon. Conflating all GoF research with one specific case contradicts the claim one is all evidence directed.
 
People with different opinions here don't have them because they failed to read something you think would change their mind. They read it and still don't agree with you.

You can roll your eyes all you want, but the poster isn't disagreeing with the explanation; they are saying there is none, which is false.

How about you let us two resolved this one? Abooga doesn't need this sort of "help".
 
The Chinese government engaged in a conspiracy at the beginning to try to hide the very existence of the pandemic.

How did that go?

It took mere days for the Great Chinese Firewall to to be breached, yet here we are 18 months down the track, and all of the evidence for a lab leak consists of:

"What if?"
 
A) that wouldn't actually be a conspiracy because there is only 1 entity involved.
B) it wasn't the Chinese government hiding things it was regional officials hiding things from the Chinese government. This doesn't appear to be a conspiracy either, more like a case of several people not wanting to be the ones to bring forward bad news.



There is a huge difference between officials not reporting a suspicious disease cluster and accusing real scientists who made major contributions to their field of being involved in a conspiracy to cover-up the "real" origin of the pandemic.
As happened in parts of the USA when state authorities attempted to play down the effects of Covid.
 
How did that go?

It took mere days for the Great Chinese Firewall to to be breached, yet here we are 18 months down the track, and all of the evidence for a lab leak consists of:

"What if?"
You just keep passing that ******* lie around.

There is plenty of evidence of what the lab was working on as late as 2019. There's plenty of evidence of the staff and students excursions to the caves in Yunnan including some with pictures of less than ideal protective covering on. There are reports from those excursions that live bats were brought back to the WIV from the field and evidence live bats and live coronavirus cultures were in the WIV. And more...

You can pretend all you want that isn't evidence but obviously it is.
 
How did that go?

It took mere days for the Great Chinese Firewall to to be breached, yet here we are 18 months down the track, and all of the evidence for a lab leak consists of:

"What if?"
You seem satisfied the pandemic would still have happened if the lab had never been built?
 
You just keep passing that ******* lie around.

There is plenty of evidence of what the lab was working on as late as 2019. There's plenty of evidence of the staff and students excursions to the caves in Yunnan including some with pictures of less than ideal protective covering on. There are reports from those excursions that live bats were brought back to the WIV from the field and evidence live bats and live coronavirus cultures were in the WIV. And more...

You can pretend all you want that isn't evidence but obviously it is.

...and that isn't even the initial evidence that made it suspicious. Yet it is all "waved away". This stuff is all documented pre-covid.

Can anyone address this? And the lies about how it was not true? Why lie about it? I think that was a pretty short sighted mistake by Daszak. We all know the internet pops up with the record sooner or later. Was he duped? Did he not keep up with the Wuhan news?

To say all those past statements were misconstrued or misinterpreted would be ridiculous.
If the internet records of interviews and photos and links were altered after the fact....well that WOULD be a conspiracy, wouldnt it? :eye-poppi


It doesnt't prove where the virus originated but it is one of many pointers in a certain direction.
 
What do you mean by "closest relative"? RNA viruses undergo frequent recombination, and the spike has undergone at least one, and probably more than one. The evolutionary history of the spike itself may be significantly different than the rest of the virus.

The closest Covid relative does not have this furin cleavage site, but the next closest does. It's not even clear at this point whether recombination events removed the furin cleavage site from RaTG13 or added one to Covid's proximal ancestor.
So that we do not mix lineages...

1. name the next relative that you are referring to, this way we are on the same page.
2. will this soon to be named next relative have the same polybasic insertion as SARS-CoV-2?

thx
 
You just keep passing that ******* lie around.

There is plenty of evidence of what the lab was working on as late as 2019. There's plenty of evidence of the staff and students excursions to the caves in Yunnan including some with pictures of less than ideal protective covering on. There are reports from those excursions that live bats were brought back to the WIV from the field and evidence live bats and live coronavirus cultures were in the WIV. And more...

You can pretend all you want that isn't evidence but obviously it is.
You are spot on!

People can also see it for themselves if they go to...

https://reporter.nih.gov/search/nqZNwTbrOEy9gqAQDocvIQ/projects

type in: Daszak, Andersen

you will find the projects funded by Fauci's group and you will also note that GOF is being used prior to the lifting of the pause and after the pause was initiated.
 
B) it wasn't the Chinese government hiding things it was regional officials hiding things from the Chinese government. This doesn't appear to be a conspiracy either, more like a case of several people not wanting to be the ones to bring forward bad news.
Please provide a link for this claim. thx
 
Vincent Racaniello, the host of the podcast This Week in Virology (TWiV), he is a virologist who has been mentioned in this thread over and over again, sometimes by Lab Leakers such as with his interview with Peter Daszak, but also by people like myself because this is probably the best place for the lay public to learn about viruses.

His podcast has featured Peter Daszak and two other members of the WHO investigation, and Robert Garry.
Daszak and Garry are anything but objective. Garry was on the midnight emails with Jeremy Farrar and Fauci. Garry was also a co-author of the rapidly written and totally unproven theories in... "Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2". Daszak is part of EcoHealth who acts as a sub-agency for Fauci's Department granting hundreds of thousands of $ to many institutions.

By the way, can anybody provide an answer as to why Jeremy Farrar, who is the Director of Wellcome Foundation, heading up teleconferences with US government officials?
 
You just keep passing that ******* lie around.

There is plenty of evidence of what the lab was working on as late as 2019. There's plenty of evidence of the staff and students excursions to the caves in Yunnan including some with pictures of less than ideal protective covering on. There are reports from those excursions that live bats were brought back to the WIV from the field and evidence live bats and live coronavirus cultures were in the WIV. And more...

You can pretend all you want that isn't evidence but obviously it is.

You are spot on!

People can also see it for themselves if they go to...

https://reporter.nih.gov/search/nqZNwTbrOEy9gqAQDocvIQ/projects

type in: Daszak, Andersen

you will find the projects funded by Fauci's group and you will also note that GOF is being used prior to the lifting of the pause and after the pause was initiated.

Sorry, but how is this a revelation?
 
Daszak and Garry are anything but objective. Garry was on the midnight emails with Jeremy Farrar and Fauci. Garry was also a co-author of the rapidly written and totally unproven theories in... "Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2". Daszak is part of EcoHealth who acts as a sub-agency for Fauci's Department granting hundreds of thousands of $ to many institutions.

By the way, can anybody provide an answer as to why Jeremy Farrar, who is the Director of Wellcome Foundation, heading up teleconferences with US government officials?

Why not explain the significance of it first?
 
Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab. If the virus were already in a lab it would be documented and easy to find, but it has not been found. Thus the virus must never have been in a lab in which case we can't have a lab leak or the virus was in a lab and scientists have conspired to hide this.
I hope you are saying this with tongue-in-cheek.

Your "logic" will need to go both ways.

Using your reasoning: If the virus is not found in nature, then it was created by a different means. Your reasoning is more appropriate in disproving the naturally found hypothesis.

An easy way to determine if the Horseshoe Bat was the original culprit is to infect the bat with Covid-19. If viral antigens are found in the lung... then the hypothesis leans towards nature but if viral antigens are not found in the lungs, then Horseshoe bats move further down the list of suspects.
 
Sorry, but how is this a revelation?

How is what a revelation? The fact you continue to lie about the evidence? Are you trying to smear my post by conflating it with an unrelated post?

Or did you quote me by accident? :mad:
 
Last edited:
Why not explain the significance of it first?
You mean the significance of emails being transmitted back and forth between Funding agencies and people within institutions that receive monies? Or do you mean the significance of multiple scientists, from 3 different continents, discussing this new outbreak of a virus on Sunday morning? Or do you mean the significance of 4 of the 5 co-authors of "Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2", who initially thought there were inconsistencies with the virus evolving in nature whereas in 9 days they did a 180 turnaround, were cc'ed on these emails?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom