Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Vincent is annoyed that many people didn't like the Garry interview episode on TWiV.

Amy says that Vincent will be going over the Eddie Holmes paper on Friday.

https://youtu.be/xDnBXHmYQIM?t=387

Looks like this might be the paper:

https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/...vr.it&utm_medium=twitter#.YMDAIw7jq44.twitter

Despite the discovery of animal coronaviruses related to SARS-CoV-2, the evolutionary origins of this virus are elusive. We describe a meta-transcriptomic study of 411 bat samples collected from a small geographical region in Yunnan province, China, between May 2019 and November 2020. We identified 24 full-length coronavirus genomes, including four novel SARS-CoV-2 related and three SARS-CoV related viruses. Rhinolophus pusillus virus RpYN06 was the closest relative of SARS-CoV-2 in most of the genome, although it possessed a more divergent spike gene. The other three SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses carried a genetically distinct spike gene that could weakly bind to the hACE2 receptor in vitro. Ecological modeling predicted the co-existence of up to 23 Rhinolophus bat species, with the largest contiguous hotspots extending from South Laos and Vietnam to southern China. Our study highlights the remarkable diversity of bat coronaviruses at the local scale, including close relatives of both SARS-CoV-2 and SARS-CoV.
 
Vincent and Amy are asked their thoughts on gain of function.

They say they do it every day, and if you don't do it you effectively end all microbiology research.

https://youtu.be/xDnBXHmYQIM?t=1329


Interesting...

ETA: They think most people do not understand Gain of Function and assume it is always bad and furthermore they blame Ebright and "That idiot at Harvard" Mark Lipsitch, that is behind the negativity towards Gain of Function.
 
Last edited:
Vincent addresses the question "Is there reason to believe some virologists might be biased against lab leak investigation because it is negative for the profession?"

https://youtu.be/xDnBXHmYQIM?t=2928

He says, "You mean me? No. I am driven by data. There is no data supporting lab leak. If there was, I would be interested. There is not. End of story."
 
Who's "Vincent", and why are we on a first-name basis with him?

Vincent Racaniello, the host of the podcast This Week in Virology (TWiV), he is a virologist who has been mentioned in this thread over and over again, sometimes by Lab Leakers such as with his interview with Peter Daszak, but also by people like myself because this is probably the best place for the lay public to learn about viruses.

His podcast has featured Peter Daszak and two other members of the WHO investigation, and Robert Garry.
 
This conflation of Conspiracy Theory with simply talking about possible conspiracies is a constant annoying habit of this forum (and society in general, you can see how governments often appeal to it as soon as someone starts to criticise some shady deal). I think we need to stop appealing to Occam´s razor so casually in these cases. Occam´s razor is a good tool to try to evaluate theories about the physical world, chemistry, zoology etc., when you don´t have entities that are actively trying to hide things from view, mislead etc. It reminds me of the old stories about Randi and how scientists were often misled by scam artists, and how a magician was required for the job... because the tools of science were inadecuately naive in those cases. Evaluating a possible conspiracy to hide a lab leak requires looking for more subtle kinds of data, clues. Of course "proof" would require some harder evidence, but for the purpose of assessing whether there is reason to suspect a coverup, we can look at the evidence that has been posted in this thread, and to me at least, it does seem to point in the direction of a possible cover up of a lab leak or similar ◊◊◊◊◊◊ in China. I wish some harder evidence comes up, if not I´m quite happy with regarding it as "probably happened" until then. One does not always have to know one way or the other all the time.
 
Last edited:
This conflation of Conspiracy Theory with simply talking about possible conspiracies is a constant annoying habit of this forum (and society in general, you can see how governments often appeal to it as soon as someone starts to criticise some shady deal). I think we need to stop appealing to Occam´s razor so casually in these cases. Occam´s razor is a good tool to try to evaluate theories about the physical world, chemistry, zoology etc., when you don´t have entities that are actively trying to hide things from view, mislead etc. It reminds me of the old stories about Randi and how scientists were often misled by scam artists, and how a magician was required for the job... because the tools of science were inadecuately naive in those cases. Evaluating a possible conspiracy to hide a lab leak requires looking for more subtle kinds of data, clues. Of course "proof" would require some harder evidence, but for the purpose of assessing whether there is reason to suspect a coverup, we can look at the evidence that has been posted in this thread, and to me at least, it does seem to point in the direction of a possible cover up of a lab leak or similar ◊◊◊◊◊◊ in China. I wish some harder evidence comes up, if not I´m quite happy with regarding it as "probably happened" until then. One does not always have to know one way or the other all the time.

The highlighted is the summary.
 
This conflation of Conspiracy Theory with simply talking about possible conspiracies is a constant annoying habit of this forum (and society in general, you can see how governments often appeal to it as soon as someone starts to criticise some shady deal). I think we need to stop appealing to Occam´s razor so casually in these cases. Occam´s razor is a good tool to try to evaluate theories about the physical world, chemistry, zoology etc., when you don´t have entities that are actively trying to hide things from view, mislead etc. It reminds me of the old stories about Randi and how scientists were often misled by scam artists, and how a magician was required for the job... because the tools of science were inadecuately naive in those cases. Evaluating a possible conspiracy to hide a lab leak requires looking for more subtle kinds of data, clues. Of course "proof" would require some harder evidence, but for the purpose of assessing whether there is reason to suspect a coverup, we can look at the evidence that has been posted in this thread, and to me at least, it does seem to point in the direction of a possible cover up of a lab leak or similar ◊◊◊◊◊◊ in China. I wish some harder evidence comes up, if not I´m quite happy with regarding it as "probably happened" until then. One does not always have to know one way or the other all the time.

Did you not read the justification for calling it a CT before writing this?
 
Did you not read the justification for calling it a CT before writing this?
I did not see any justification for such thing, I even asked why it was compared to things like flat earth (post 1082), but received no response.
 
Look harder.
I remain convinced that there was no justification. The Chinese government engaged in a conspiracy at the beginning to try to hide the very existence of the pandemic. Is that a conspiracy theory? technically yes, but I would not call it a "CT" in the "nutty CT" sense. That the coverup is larger and includes a lab leak does not seem that far-fetched IMO.
 
Last edited:
Nothing is "clearly". Describe how this furin cleavage is similar to it's closest relative in the phylogenetic tree.

What do you mean by "closest relative"? RNA viruses undergo frequent recombination, and the spike has undergone at least one, and probably more than one. The evolutionary history of the spike itself may be significantly different than the rest of the virus.

The closest Covid relative does not have this furin cleavage site, but the next closest does. It's not even clear at this point whether recombination events removed the furin cleavage site from RaTG13 or added one to Covid's proximal ancestor.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom