Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
lomiller just agreed he said it and that I've taken it out of context.



The context in question, btw, was you suggested that investigating the lab would answer the question about a lab leak and I was pointing out that it had already been investigated as part o the WHO mission. "we have our answer" was specific to the subject of an investigation. You chose to take it out of context to mean something else after the fact.

Of course in cases like these investigations never matter, the results of any and every investigation will be rejected if they don't give the answer the CTers are looking for. The failure to find any results get blamed on "the cover-up" and some new excuse for demanding yet another investigation will be found.

In fact there is\was a follow up planned for everything the WHO mission looked into, this includes unlikely scenarios like the virus coming to China from another country in frozen food or a lab leak. When this follow-up shows nothing some other scientists will get slandered as an excuse to demand even more investigations.
 
Do you really think that not trusting the "investigation" of the WHO is similar to being a flat earther or something like that? Seriously?
 
The context in question, btw, was you suggested that investigating the lab would answer the question about a lab leak and I was pointing out that it had already been investigated as part o the WHO mission. "we have our answer" was specific to the subject of an investigation. You chose to take it out of context to mean something else after the fact.
Huh? I think you said that to mean that you find the current lab investigation to have settled the question of whether there was a leak at the lab. Is that not what you think? Do you now agree with me (and my opinion is what I think the experts like Fauci and Tedros think) that the lab investigation we have was not definitive?
 
Here's your own words on what you said that phrase meant:
lomiller said:
My position has consistently been that there is no evidence for this hypothesis and that the chain of events where it could have occurred is not just too convoluted to be plausible given the simplicity of the alternative. The lack of evidence also seems to require scientists be involved in a conspiracy to hide "what really happened".


I've been arguing with you pointing out that the experts themselves do not find the lack of evidence convincing because the investigation was incomplete. I've cited Tedros mostly for that but he's obviously not the only one. And I've also been arguing that not all conspiracies are conspiracy theories. I've also pointed out that it is impossible to know how convoluted the coverup might have been without knowing that even was a coverup and some details about it. I've also pointed out that not all lab leak scenarios involve a coverup, some scenarios could include total accident that no one has yet become aware of.
 
Well, it probably could be anything.
...
I'm not surprised you would say this. OTOH...

I mean is the claim here that Yossarian, bored of redacting all the definite artcles, suddenly discovers that the US had funded the China Virus and was really shocked and thought, "Better cover that up!"
This does make sense as the most likely reason for the redaction.
 
I've been arguing with you pointing out that the experts themselves do not find the lack of evidence convincing because the investigation was incomplete. I've cited Tedros mostly for that but he's obviously not the only one.

Is Tedros a virologist? Does he even doubt the scientific consensus that this was natural spillover from wildlife?

Also. why would an "incomplete investigation" favor a lab leak over the virus being imported from another country on frozen food? The WHO investigation put this on similar footing as the lab leak hypothesis, so why is it only the lab leak you think is "still possible" and needs further investigation?

And I've also been arguing that not all conspiracies are conspiracy theories.

All theories involving a conspiracy to cover something up are conspiracy theories.

What I think you mean to say is that in some cases the conspiracy and coverup are real. The way we distinguish between these cases is to find evidence showing the conspiracy and coverup are real. Feel free to start providing this evidence any time you like.

I've also pointed out that it is impossible to know how convoluted the coverup might have been without knowing that even was a coverup and some details about it.

This makes no sense. It's equivalent to saying we can't say QAnon CT are to convoluted to be plausible because we have yet to uncover the details of the conspiracy so we don't know how convoluted the cover-up really is.

I've also pointed out that not all lab leak scenarios involve a coverup, some scenarios could include total accident that no one has yet become aware of.

Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab. If the virus were already in a lab it would be documented and easy to find, but it has not been found. Thus the virus must never have been in a lab in which case we can't have a lab leak or the virus was in a lab and scientists have conspired to hide this.
 
Is Tedros a virologist? Does he even doubt the scientific consensus that this was natural spillover from wildlife?
What difference do either of those things make? He's the director general of the WHO and he thinks his organization report was inconclusive and the lab needs further investigation.
Also. why would an "incomplete investigation" favor a lab leak over the virus being imported from another country on frozen food?
It doesn't FFS. It supports the idea that investigation was incomplete.
The WHO investigation put this on similar footing as the lab leak hypothesis, so why is it only the lab leak you think is "still possible" and needs further investigation?
Huh? It needs further investigation because the WHO says it was inconclusive and needs further investigation. Others such as Fauci agree. That's good enough for me.

I don't know what "so why is it only the lab leak you think is "still possible"" is supposed to mean unless trying to claim I think the lab leak is already proven which I obviously don't.

All theories involving a conspiracy to cover something up are conspiracy theories.

What I think you mean to say is that in some cases the conspiracy and coverup are real.
And you think I'm being disingenuous. You know damn well that the phrase "conspiracy theory" means something beyond just a theory about a conspiracy.
The way we distinguish between these cases is to find evidence showing the conspiracy and coverup are real. Feel free to start providing this evidence any time you like.
Which will come after the investigation. We have to look for the evidence to find it. DUH. Fortunately for the planet you aren't in control of that and aren't likely to stop further investigations. And for that reason I'll think I'll be giving up on this thread shortly.
This makes no sense. It's equivalent to saying we can't say QAnon CT are to convoluted to be plausible because we have yet to uncover the details of the conspiracy so we don't know how convoluted the cover-up really is.
That is incredibly stupid. There is no comparison to QAnon CT's here. We know for an god damn fact that a pandemic occurred. Tons of QAnon CT's are about things that didn't even happen.

Any lab leak requires samples of that virus to be in a lab. If the virus were already in a lab it would be documented and easy to find, but it has not been found.
This is just plain wrong. This can be wrong multiple ways ranging from didn't know they had it at all to had it and covered it up. This has been explained and should be obvious on top of that.
 
Last edited:
Fortunately for the planet you aren't in control of that and aren't likely to stop another investigation.
This pretty much sums up my opinion about this thread. Since the PTB in the real world are continuing the investigations and giving proper to weight to all alternatives this conversation seems pointless.
 
Just to review because it's important and it's been semi-buried here, and while Daszak isn't cited as an expert so much as his conflict of interest is downplayed, Andersen is cited as an expert:

Yes it's from Nicolas Wade


Daszak and the Lancet editorial:
From early on, public and media perceptions were shaped in favor of the natural emergence scenario by strong statements from two scientific groups. These statements were not at first examined as critically as they should have been.

“We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin,” a group of virologists and others wrote in the Lancet on February 19, 2020, when it was really far too soon for anyone to be sure what had happened. Scientists “overwhelmingly conclude that this coronavirus originated in wildlife,” they said, with a stirring rallying call for readers to stand with Chinese colleagues on the frontline of fighting the disease.

Contrary to the letter writers’ assertion, the idea that the virus might have escaped from a lab invoked accident, not conspiracy. It surely needed to be explored, not rejected out of hand. ... the signatories of the Lancet letter were behaving as poor scientists: They were assuring the public of facts they could not know for sure were true.

It later turned out that the Lancet letter had been organized and drafted by Peter Daszak, president of the EcoHealth Alliance of New York. Daszak’s organization funded coronavirus research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. If the SARS2 virus had indeed escaped from research he funded, Daszak would be potentially culpable. This acute conflict of interest was not declared to the Lancet’s readers. To the contrary, the letter concluded, “We declare no competing interests.”


Andersen:
A second statement that had enormous influence in shaping public attitudes was a letter (in other words an opinion piece, not a scientific article) published on 17 March 2020 in the journal Nature Medicine. Its authors were a group of virologists led by Kristian G. Andersen of the Scripps Research Institute. “Our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus,” the five virologists declared in the second paragraph of their letter.

Unfortunately, this was another case of poor science, in the sense defined above. ...

If a virus has been manipulated, whether with a seamless method or by serial passage, there is no way of knowing that this is the case. Andersen and his colleagues were assuring their readers of something they could not know.
And Andersen continues to push this hypothesis.

The discussion part of their letter begins, “It is improbable that SARS-CoV-2 emerged through laboratory manipulation of a related SARS-CoV-like coronavirus.”...

The Andersen paper’s speculation about designing a viral spike protein through calculation has no bearing on whether or not the virus was manipulated by one of the other two methods....


This is something done in this very thread:
The Daszak and Andersen letters were really political, not scientific, statements, yet were amazingly effective. Articles in the mainstream press repeatedly stated that a consensus of experts had ruled lab escape out of the question or extremely unlikely. Their authors relied for the most part on the Daszak and Andersen letters, failing to understand the yawning gaps in their arguments.


I do lean toward the lab leak hypothesis. But one reason it seems that's the only position I put forth is because from the beginning of this thread I've had to counter the initial bias that "most experts agree" it wasn't a lab leak. And the claim the lab leak is a CT still permeates some people's posts here.
 
Last edited:
This pretty much sums up my opinion about this thread. Since the PTB in the real world are continuing the investigations and giving proper to weight to all alternatives this conversation seems pointless.
I see a benefit from the discussion here and it's a benefit I attribute to many threads on this board: It's helps my critical thinking to be challenged and to read other POVs, and, it helps me refine arguments I myself might put forth.
 
I'm not getting that in this thread. Too detached from reality and I can find a broader range of unbiased information elsewhere. You've provided good and broad links though, which is a separate issue from me disagreeing about your assessment of what's most likely.
 
I'm not surprised you would say this. OTOH...

This does make sense as the most likely reason for the redaction.

That's strange. Earlier you were in agreement with me that "Fauci lied, people died" was not worth pursuing, but now you are saying is the most likely explanation.

Hmmm....
 
That's strange. Earlier you were in agreement with me that "Fauci lied, people died" was not worth pursuing, but now you are saying is the most likely explanation.

Hmmm....
Talk about distorting what I said to mean something completely different. :rolleyes:


For the record I said:
I also didn't listen past “Fauci lied, people died” knowing that is a completely false premise.
The video was not worth watching. Any more than that has been pulled from the nether regions of wishful thinking.
 
Last edited:
This is not really that relevant but does anyone really take the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists seriously? I mean, I get that they are worried that the world might destroy itself through nuclear war (news flash: everyone is against that outcome), but is it a “scholarly” publication with rigorous standards? Has anyone found that the X minutes to midnight model has any real world correlation? Does it even make sense for the nuclear scientists to be saying “the end of the world is getting nigher- unless you heed our warnings in which case it might refer a bit…”

Originally quoted in an article in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists in May, and widely requoted since, Baltimore had appeared to suggest that a specific feature in Covid-19’s genome, known as the furin cleavage site, was the “smoking gun” to the theory the virus had been contained inside a laboratory and then escaped via a leak.
 
Talk about distorting what I said to mean something completely different. :rolleyes:


For the record I said:The video was not worth watching. Any more than that has been pulled from the nether regions of wishful thinking.

Are you saying that the lab leak is known about by Fauci and that he was emailing his colleagues about it but that US agencies are now covering it up with redacted emails?

I think that’s highly unlikely.
 
Again though this is beside the point. The supposedly human created furin cleavage site has been found in many Covid relatives in various stages of evolution. Therefor, it is clearly a natural structure not something created by humans.
Nothing is "clearly". Describe how this furin cleavage is similar to it's closest relative in the phylogenetic tree.
 
Are you saying that the lab leak is known about by Fauci and that he was emailing his colleagues about it but that US agencies are now covering it up with redacted emails?

I think that’s highly unlikely.

I'm saying none of that has jack to do with why the video didn't interest me. You are reading things into my post that aren't there.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom