Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
And the most closely related spike, the part that allows Covid-19 to infect humans, still comes from a different Covid relative that infects Pangolins. Covid has many relatives that infect other species and thus far NONE of them are a clear ancestor.

Again though this is beside the point. The supposedly human created furin cleavage site has been found in many Covid relatives in various stages of evolution. Therefor, it is clearly a natural structure not something created by humans.

There is no point in this. Your errors need constant correcting and you just keep repeating the errors anyway.
 
It doesn't.

Two lineages is evidence there were earlier cases.

It's not evidence those cases were outside of Wuhan.
If it doesn't support the lab leak hypothesis that you're defending, then why mention it, for example, here, in a previous post of yours:

Two lineages, well adapted to humans suddenly appeared next to the WIV which just happened to be researching SARS CoVs and related viruses. There is a no brainer here that the lab accident is the leading* hypothesis. That it refused to go away within the scientific community despite all the times it was declared a non-starter is testimony to the fact the evidence will win out in the end.
It seems that you think the fact that 2 lineages appeared next to the WIV, is evidence of a leak from the WIV. If not, what did you mean by the above reference to it?
 
It doesn't.

Two lineages is evidence there were earlier cases.


The separation in lineage occurs so early that these "earlier cases" may have happened before it spread to humans. It could have happened in one of the very first few human cases, but then you still need to explain why the outbreaks in 2 different markets each had a distinct lineage. The animal host would also explain why the early outbreaks were in live animal markets, something that isn't quite so easy to explain with a lab leak.

This is why the recent paper in Nature said the early separation of linages strongly favored natural crossover due to infected animals in live markets.
 
There is no point in this. Your errors need constant correcting and you just keep repeating the errors anyway.

Repeating yourself won't change the facts. I've provided links to high impact scientific journals to support my position, you've answered that with hand waving.
 
If it doesn't support the lab leak hypothesis that you're defending, then why mention it, for example, here, in a previous post of yours:

It seems that you think the fact that 2 lineages appeared next to the WIV, is evidence of a leak from the WIV. If not, what did you mean by the above reference to it?
Like I said. It is evidence there were earlier cases. It is not evidence those earlier cases were outside of Wuhan.

Yes, two lineages appearing near the WIV makes the coincidence of the location of the start of the pandemic even more improbable. If there were 2 lineages both in Wuhan it's more improbable the pandemic started elsewhere. Otherwise one would expect to see 2 different parts of China or elsewhere to have also been seeded.
It started in the Wuhan area, we have epidemiological evidence of that. If there are no other seeded locations the lab is implicated.
 
The separation in lineage occurs so early that these "earlier cases" may have happened before it spread to humans. It could have happened in one of the very first few human cases, but then you still need to explain why the outbreaks in 2 different markets each had a distinct lineage. The animal host would also explain why the early outbreaks were in live animal markets, something that isn't quite so easy to explain with a lab leak.

This is why the recent paper in Nature said the early separation of linages strongly favored natural crossover due to infected animals in live markets.
More false things in your posts stated as facts. The highlighted is a false underlying premise.

As to the Nature article, there are a number of scientific opinions claiming something favors a natural crossover. Without a source it doesn't favor natural or lab spillover.

It is evidence of timing.

There is separate evidence the pandemic began in Wuhan.
 
Keep in mind the rhetoric and positions of some people in this thread who are insisting that "we have our answers"...

I see you've [predictably] failed to answer lomiller asking for evidence of that.

Please note which posts make that claim, because I can't find any.
 
The U.S. and the European Union are set to back a renewed push into investigating the origins of Covid-19 after conflicting assessments about where the outbreak started, according to a document seen by Bloomberg News.

In a draft statement the countries hope to adopt at a summit later this month, they “call for progress on a transparent, evidence-based, and expert-led WHO-convened phase 2 study on the origins of COVID-19, that is free from interference.”

The U.S. is among several countries that have called on China to be more transparent with its data and allow greater access, amid ongoing questions over whether the outbreak was caused by a laboratory accident, was transmitted from wildlife or caused by something else. A new investigation risks fueling tensions with China, which has rejected suggestions of a lab leak and rebuffed international efforts to further probe the virus’s origins.

Link
 
Looks like Fauci is on the hit list now. Maybe he has been for some time judging by my barge-pole distance observations of right-wing talking points.

This one starts with “Fauci lied, people died”.

That was enough for me, thanks, although he did refer to himself as a doctor. What is this guy a doctor of?
There is a clear effort from Dump supporters to make Fauci the fall guy so their cult leader isn't implicated.

I also didn't listen past “Fauci lied, people died” knowing that is a completely false premise.

Look at that, we have a point of agreement. :)

It is a flippant remark, true. I understand why you find it off-putting. You would have to push through that to get to the more substantive part of what he has to say.

What he does do, is discuss several e-mails to and from Fauci and within a sort of crisis committee including outside experts (outside of the government) that was convened over this to discuss the origins of the virus and gain of function research. Most of the substance of that discussion has been completely redacted. The e-mails were released with those parts completely blanked out. Why? What were they saying that needs to be hidden from the public?
 
It is a flippant remark, true. I understand why you find it off-putting. You would have to push through that to get to the more substantive part of what he has to say.

What he does do, is discuss several e-mails to and from Fauci and within a sort of crisis committee including outside experts (outside of the government) that was convened over this to discuss the origins of the virus and gain of function research. Most of the substance of that discussion has been completely redacted. The e-mails were released with those parts completely blanked out. Why? What were they saying that needs to be hidden from the public?

Well, it probably could be anything.

I am pretty sure I have seen all kinds of examples of these FOIA requests that have been made by various people who have received letters with all kinds of stuff redacted, then other groups get the same letters with completely different stuff redacted.

It is often thought, "Ah! That must be where the conspiracy lies!", but quite often when those parts become unredacted, it turns out to be nothing particularly interesting.

It could yet again be a kind of Area 51-type thing, or the UFOs/UAPs type thing.

Do we assume that someone is saying, "uh oh, we had better black out the bits where Peter Daszak is telling Anthony Fauci that Zhengli-Shi made Covid-19 in the WIV with Barack Obama's funds...etc...?" in one of these letters?

If so, who is doing the redacting? I have no idea which agencies are responsible for this, but there must be some assumption here that whoever it is, knows they are concealing a big conspiracy and are going through the emails to erase the clues.

Maybe Dr Peak Prosperity explains the redacting process... Does he?
 
I mean is the claim here that Yossarian, bored of redacting all the definite artcles, suddenly discovers that the US had funded the China Virus and was really shocked and thought, "Better cover that up!"
 
Do we assume that someone is saying, "uh oh, we had better black out the bits where Peter Daszak is telling Anthony Fauci that Zhengli-Shi made Covid-19 in the WIV with Barack Obama's funds...etc...?" in one of these letters?

No, but the interesting thing is actually that there was a moratorium placed on funding of gain-of-function research in 2014 when Obama was president, and the moratorium was lifted in 2017 under Trump. There were, however, exceptions to the moratorium, and it appears that this research was conducted under the exceptions.

The meeting the had seemed to be regarding this situation, in which funding of the gain-of-function research (which was subcontracted to the WIV) was approved despite the moratorium. The research was published in Nature in 2015.

If so, who is doing the redacting? I have no idea which agencies are responsible for this, but there must be some assumption here that whoever it is, knows they are concealing a big conspiracy and are going through the emails to erase the clues.

Maybe Dr Peak Prosperity explains the redacting process... Does he?

And that's a good question. He does sort of go into it. I think someone (probably a lawyer) at the NIH or NIAID (the government agency that Fauci heads). But I'm not entirely sure about that.
 

Just wanted to add a quote from that article:

Biosafety and biosecurity.

Reported studies were initiated after the University of North Carolina Institutional Biosafety Committee approved the experimental protocol (Project Title: Generating infectious clones of bat SARS-like CoVs; Lab Safety Plan ID: 20145741; Schedule G ID: 12279). These studies were initiated before the US Government Deliberative Process Research Funding Pause on Selected Gain-of-Function Research Involving Influenza, MERS and SARS Viruses (http://www.phe.gov/s3/dualuse/Documents/gain-of-function.pdf). This paper has been reviewed by the funding agency, the NIH. Continuation of these studies was requested, and this has been approved by the NIH.

Of course, that research could not have been the source, but the research continued in subsequent years. It's not clear if it ever ended.

IOW, the research involved "Generating infectious clones of bat SARS-like CoVs". So maybe it's not so crazy that people people might raise questions after a bat SARS-like CoV emerged in the very city where this research was being conducted.
 
Last edited:
No, but the interesting thing is actually that there was a moratorium placed on funding of gain-of-function research in 2014 when Obama was president, and the moratorium was lifted in 2017 under Trump. There were, however, exceptions to the moratorium, and it appears that this research was conducted under the exceptions.

The meeting the had seemed to be regarding this situation, in which funding of the gain-of-function research (which was subcontracted to the WIV) was approved despite the moratorium. The research was published in Nature in 2015.

I could be wrong about this but wasn't the moratorium only no research conducted in the US?

But scanning through that paper, I notice something that was explicitly pointed out by Peter Daszak in that so-called "smoking gun" interview that he had with Vincent Racaniello:

All mouse studies were performed at the University of North Carolina (Animal Welfare Assurance #A3410-01) using protocols approved by the UNC Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC).

He was talking about Ralph Baric's lab. And furthermore:

Biosafety and biosecurity.
Reported studies were initiated after the University of North Carolina Institutional Biosafety Committee approved the experimental protocol (Project Title: Generating infectious clones of bat SARS-like CoVs; Lab Safety Plan ID: 20145741; Schedule G ID: 12279). These studies were initiated before the US Government Deliberative Process Research Funding Pause on Selected Gain-of-Function Research Involving Influenza, MERS and SARS Viruses (http://www.phe.gov/s3/dualuse/Documents/gain-of-function.pdf). This paper has been reviewed by the funding agency, the NIH. Continuation of these studies was requested, and this has been approved by the NIH.
SARS-CoV is a select agent. All work for these studies was performed with approved standard operating procedures (SOPs) and safety conditions for SARS-CoV, MERs-CoV and other related CoVs. Our institutional CoV BSL3 facilities have been designed to conform to the safety requirements that are recommended in the Biosafety in Microbiological and Biomedical Laboratories (BMBL), the US Department of Health and Human Services, the Public Health Service, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and the NIH. Laboratory safety plans were submitted to, and the facility has been approved for use by, the UNC Department of Environmental Health and Safety (EHS) and the CDC. Electronic card access is required for entry into the facility. All workers have been trained by EHS to safely use powered air purifying respirators (PAPRs), and appropriate work habits in a BSL3 facility and active medical surveillance plans are in place. Our CoV BSL3 facilities contain redundant fans, emergency power to fans and biological safety cabinets and freezers, and our facilities can accommodate SealSafe mouse racks. Materials classified as BSL3 agents consist of SARS-CoV, bat CoV precursor strains, MERS-CoV and mutants derived from these pathogens. Within the BSL3 facilities, experimentation with infectious virus is performed in a certified Class II Biosafety Cabinet (BSC). All members of the staff wear scrubs, Tyvek suits and aprons, PAPRs and shoe covers, and their hands are double-gloved. BSL3 users are subject to a medical surveillance plan monitored by the University Employee Occupational Health Clinic (UEOHC), which includes a yearly physical, annual influenza vaccination and mandatory reporting of any symptoms associated with CoV infection during periods when working in the BSL3. All BSL3 users are trained in exposure management and reporting protocols, are prepared to self-quarantine and have been trained for safe delivery to a local infectious disease management department in an emergency situation. All potential exposure events are reported and investigated by EHS and UEOHC, with reports filed to both the CDC and the NIH.

This is mentioned:
Key Laboratory of Special Pathogens and Biosafety, Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan, China

Xing-Yi Ge & Zhengli-Li Shi

But only under affiliations.

This is not to say there were no gain-of-function studies being done at the WIV, or the use or live animals, live cultures, live bats, etc... It doesn't rule anything out, but this paper doesn't seem to be much of a lead.

Is this something that Dr Peak Prosperity puts forth as evidence?

And that's a good question. He does sort of go into it. I think someone (probably a lawyer) at the NIH or NIAID (the government agency that Fauci heads). But I'm not entirely sure about that.

Because again, this is how the conspiracy becomes untenable. Is Fauci now ordering redactions? Are there now lawyers who are privy to some inner conspiracy?

What if Joe Biden fired Fauci (like Rand Paul wants) and brought someone else in? Is Fauci going to have to burn down the building and blame Islamic terrorists to cover up his role in the pandemic?
 
I could be wrong about this but wasn't the moratorium only no research conducted in the US?
It was on US government funding of the research, I believe (regardless of where it was actually conducted). But I could be wrong too.
But scanning through that paper, I notice something that was explicitly pointed out by Peter Daszak in that so-called "smoking gun" interview that he had with Vincent Racaniello:

He was talking about Ralph Baric's lab.
In 2015 when that paper was published, maybe that was true, but the research continued in subsequent years, so it's possible that some of the mice models developed by Baric were supplied to Wuhan so that they could do the same research there.

This is not to say there were no gain-of-function studies being done at the WIV, or the use or live animals, live cultures, live bats, etc... It doesn't rule anything out, but this paper doesn't seem to be much of a lead.

Is this something that Dr Peak Prosperity puts forth as evidence?

He mentions this paper to note that the research continued despite the moratorium, and it continued after this paper was published. It was approved by the NIH, so essentially they deemed it important enough to make an exception to the moratorium for this project.



Because again, this is how the conspiracy becomes untenable. Is Fauci now ordering redactions? Are there now lawyers who are privy to some inner conspiracy?

What if Joe Biden fired Fauci (like Rand Paul wants) and brought someone else in? Is Fauci going to have to burn down the building and blame Islamic terrorists to cover up his role in the pandemic?

I don't know who did the redacting, and I'm not suggesting that the redacted bits would show some kind of malevolent conspiracy if revealed. They might, however, prove embarrassing or controversial. Maybe they were second-guessing the wisdom of this research, since it didn't in the end prevent the very pandemic that it was supposed to. (The rationale for this research being that it might help scientists to prevent a future pandemic.)
 
I don't know who did the redacting, and I'm not suggesting that the redacted bits would show some kind of malevolent conspiracy if revealed. They might, however, prove embarrassing or controversial. Maybe they were second-guessing the wisdom of this research, since it didn't in the end prevent the very pandemic that it was supposed to. (The rationale for this research being that it might help scientists to prevent a future pandemic.)

I have read this a couple of times from posters here and from other voices on the Internet.

"So your research didn't prevent a pandemic! Then it must have been worthless!"

No, literally nobody thinks that if you just do some GoF studies there will be no pandemics. This is like saying we need to improve forest conservation to prevent forest fires. If a forest fire happens, you don't then say, "Ah, well that was useless then..."

People like the EcoHealth Alliance are talking about emerging viruses all over the world due to the enroachment of humans on natural habitats.

This is happening with SARS-like viruses, Ebola, Nipah, Hendra etc... and non-virus illnesses like Lyme Disease.

There are all manner of methods to attempt to prevent or to anticipate viruses, and Gain of Function is just a small part of that.

We don't KNOW how this virus came about so pointing to one thing and calling it useless is like pointing to the fireproofing on the WTC buildings and saying, "Well I guess that didn't stop the buildings falling down."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom