Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't disagree that the lab leak hypothesis is plausible enough to be seriously investigated. I just don't think the speed with which the source of SARS was identified supports it, for the reasons stated.
Fair enough*. What would be a reasonable amount of time to find the source?


*It is not fair enough however to compare it to the time it took to find the HIV and pin down the source to a geographical area.
 
Last edited:
I could take decades, depending on the specifics. It's just impossible to tell.
Should we wait those decades before pursuing other alternatives?

Keep in mind the rhetoric and positions of some people in this thread who are insisting that "we have our answers" and that all the other alternatives are necessarily conspiracy theories.
 
Should we wait those decades before pursuing other alternatives?

I don't think anyone here is arguing that we shouldn't look into alternatives. But what if it does take decades? So what? I mean, you can't argue that it would've been found by now. We just don't know yet. The main point of disagreement here is the contention that the leak hypothesis is _more_ likely.
 
I think the point being made is that we don't know where the first cases occurred, we only know where the first cases were identified. The first cases could have occurred at the market, and the disease then spread widely (thanks to its transmissibility and relatively low incidence of serious illness) before eventually being detected somewhere else. So we can't yet rule out an origin in the market, any more than we can yet rule out an origin in the Wuhan lab.

Serologies across China and the WHO analysis of ILI (influenza like illness) in China in 2019 showed Wuhan to be the clear location of the beginning of the virus.

It's fine to hypothesize there was a different market exposure. It's not fine to speak as if the Seafood Market super-spreader event is evidence for the origin being a market which is what the constant bringing up of the Seafood Market is trying to do.

And again, the super-spread event is worth noting but it should be kept in mind there were earlier recognized cases that had no connection to any wet market and only one other market in Wuhan had a trace of COVID 19 when it was looked for.
 
Last edited:
This isn't true at all. Multiple close Covid relatives have been identified and many examples of it previously unknown furin cleavage site in various stages of evolutionary development have been found. A clear evolutionary history of the key feature that makes this virus so infectious to humans has started to emerge. The fact that we can start to trace it's natural evolution means ANY variation of it being created in a lab is pseudoscientific nonsense.
None of those findings including the most closely related bat coronavirus are a clear ancestor otherwise it would be spoken of as just that.

The only version of the lab leak hypothesis that isn't complete pseudoscience is that it was a natural virus that for some reason was never catalogued, somehow escaped from a BSL4 lab. The infected person went shopping at multiple live animal markets spreading a different lineage of the virus in each on.
So full of erroneous facts I'm not wasting more time on this.
 
Looks like Fauci is on the hit list now. Maybe he has been for some time judging by my barge-pole distance observations of right-wing talking points.

This one starts with “Fauci lied, people died”.

That was enough for me, thanks, although he did refer to himself as a doctor. What is this guy a doctor of?
There is a clear effort from Dump supporters to make Fauci the fall guy so their cult leader isn't implicated.

I also didn't listen past “Fauci lied, people died” knowing that is a completely false premise.

Look at that, we have a point of agreement. :)
 
There's no evidence to support that kind of timeline.

What are you talking about? Determining the exact source of a virus takes TIME, and that time varies greatly depending on a number of factors. THERE IS NO WAY TO KNOW. You're asking me to provide evidence for the fact that there is no way to know in advance how much time it will take to track this thing down?

Are you for real?
 
... Keep in mind the rhetoric and positions of some people in this thread who are insisting that "we have our answers" and that all the other alternatives are necessarily conspiracy theories.
Which makes it quite ironic when people who have ruled the lab leak out accuse me of only considering the lab leak.

To repeat my position:
Most evidence: lab leak
Next, a Wuhan researcher was infected at a specimen collecting mission, bringing it back to Wuhan
Finally, with the least amount of evidence, a natural event that by miracle of miracles happened to begin in Wuhan near the lab.​


This is a good place to point something else out. I have years of experience in occupational infectious disease and that includes epidemiology. I see a clear pattern of the beginning of the pandemic in Wuhan.

Several members here have extensive experience in virology. I don't think either of us should ignore the evidence being used by the others to support or rule out the lab leak hypothesis. I'm certainly not ignoring the genome evidence. There remains an unexplained source for the two initial lineages turning up at the same time in Wuhan near the WIV.

There is a lot of unsupported speculation about how the virus spread from an unknown market and/or that low levels of undetected mild cases went on somewhere else.

Epidemiology does not support that speculation. In WA State where mild cases were found to be circulating by matching the genetic trail from the first case imported from Wuhan to a person with what was thought to be flu turned out to be COVID, and finally to an outbreak of fatal cases in a nursing home.

From that one can reasonably expect that one will not see 'only mild cases' somewhere as of yet undetected. It took a month for those mild cases to be ringed with serious cases in the Seattle area. In addition, within that month, hundreds of cases appeared.

In Wuhan, from the first documented case occurring on Nov 17, (not Dec, lomiller), there were ~266 documented cases by the end of Dec. Had there been a significant number of low-level infections occurring before the cases of severe COVID were detected in Wuhan, then the serology and ILI studies cited in this thread would not have found Wuhan as the only center of the pandemic.

And by that same evidence, the Nov 17 case which was severe enough to be detected wasn't the first case. I have no issue with that likelihood. There were 2 lineages by that time and they diverged somewhere.

If that occurred outside of Wuhan one would have expected to see one of more seeded outbreaks outside of Wuhan.

It that occurred in some wild animals that were shipped to 2 different wet markets in Wuhan, we are back to the same problem of the improbable likelihood no other seeding took place outside of Wuhan.

In addition, the species in which a perfectly-matched-to-human-airway-cells evolved (say a recombinant event) would have had to only evolve once, just before being shipped to Wuhan to 1 or 2 different wet markets (because the lineages diverged by then) soon to spark the pandemic on the first try. And nowhere else because again, the epidemiological evidence supports Wuhan as the only seeded part of the world.

266 or more cases in Wuhan within a month as well as the extensive spread in the Seattle area suggests rapid spread. One would see multiple seeded sites if the origin was anywhere except in Wuhan.
 
Last edited:
What are you talking about? Determining the exact source of a virus takes TIME, and that time varies greatly depending on a number of factors. THERE IS NO WAY TO KNOW. You're asking me to provide evidence for the fact that there is no way to know in advance how much time it will take to track this thing down?

Are you for real?
So you picked 10 years out a a hat then?

By supporting evidence I mean a logical evidence supported hypothesis as opposed to picking a number unrelated to the current state of the science.
 
So you picked 10 years out a a hat then?

I never said 10 years. I think you're still confusing posters together.

By supporting evidence I mean a logical evidence supported hypothesis as opposed to picking a number unrelated to the current state of the science.

You're just not listening: I'm not arguing for a particular number. I'm arguing that NONE OF US KNOWS how long it SHOULD take. That is self-evident.
 
Should we wait those decades before pursuing other alternatives?

Keep in mind the rhetoric and positions of some people in this thread who are insisting that "we have our answers" and that all the other alternatives are necessarily conspiracy theories.

Who is saying "We have our answer"? I suspect you mean me but if so you are taking the quote so far out of context I can only interpret this as deliberate dishonesty on your part.

My position has consistently been that there is no evidence for this hypothesis and that the chain of events where it could have occurred is not just too convoluted to be plausible given the simplicity of the alternative. The lack of evidence also seems to require scientists be involved in a conspiracy to hide "what really happened".


If I were to make a comparison I'd say my views on the lab leak hypothesis are much the same as my views on cold fusion. Sure "it's possible", research it all you want just don't go around presenting it as a real thing until you have evidence it can really be done.

You can just read my sig.
 
You're right, you said "decades". :rolleyes:

Can you be bothered to properly use the quote function so that the threading is done correctly?

And yeah, I said decades. So what? You're completely missing the point, even though I spelled it out for you. Do you really think there's a way to know how long it'll take?
 
None of those findings including the most closely related bat coronavirus are a clear ancestor otherwise it would be spoken of as just that.

So full of erroneous facts I'm not wasting more time on this.

And the most closely related spike, the part that allows Covid-19 to infect humans, still comes from a different Covid relative that infects Pangolins. Covid has many relatives that infect other species and thus far NONE of them are a clear ancestor.

Again though this is beside the point. The supposedly human created furin cleavage site has been found in many Covid relatives in various stages of evolution. Therefor, it is clearly a natural structure not something created by humans.
 
Can you be bothered to properly use the quote function so that the threading is done correctly?

And yeah, I said decades. So what? You're completely missing the point, even though I spelled it out for you. Do you really think there's a way to know how long it'll take?
Just walk it back to get to that comment. It's not hard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom