Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, that is not true. I already told you about how Ebola outbreaks had been blamed on lab leaks. Robert Garry, who was on the TWiV podcast has been accused in the past of an Ebola lab leak when an outbreak occurred near his lab (which I seem to recall was studying Lassa fever).
This is crap. None of this makes the analogies to other zoonotic epidemics and pandemics valid. Instead of trying to dismiss the lab accident hypothesis, why don't you concentrate on finding evidence for a natural event?

There is no evidence for a COVID 19 precursor percolating in China before the Wuhan cases.

The Wuhan cases have been described by multiple virologists as having started abruptly with a well-adapted strain of SARS CoV type virus. This is in contrast to the beginning of the SARS CoV 1 pandemic.

Lancet Feb 2021:
The low overall extent of infection and steep gradient of seropositivity from Wuhan to the outer provinces provide evidence supporting the success of containment of the first wave of COVID-19 in China. SARS-CoV-2 infection was largely asymptomatic, emphasizing the importance of active case finding and physical distancing. Virtually the entire population of China remains susceptible to SARS-CoV-2; vaccination will be needed for long-term protection.
Containment but also evidence the pandemic started in Wuhan and nowhere else.


And of course, all kinds of conspiracy theories developed around HIV/AIDS.

Every outbreak leads to conspiracy theories because someone must be to blame, someone must pay!

This is not the CT thread. Stop trying to drag your dismissal of the lab leak hypothesis into the area of CTs.
 
This is crap. None of this makes the analogies to other zoonotic epidemics and pandemics valid. Instead of trying to dismiss the lab accident hypothesis, why don't you concentrate on finding evidence for a natural event?

I'm countering this claim that you made....

In none of those cases did researchers in a lab that was experimenting with those viruses exist, let alone were any in the vicinity or the outbreaks. That fact keeps being ignored in these little analogy games.

You're making other analogies, such as here:


SARS virus first infected a person in late 2002. It was identified in 2003. Notice the timeline difference. You cannot compare how long it took to identify a new virus in 1985 to how long it took in 2003.

CDC SARS timeline

It was established that SARS first emerged from a wet market in Guangdong, China by Jan 2004. That's less than a year from when it was first identified.
By that timeline we should have found at least the likely animal that was the source of COVID well before now especially since almost 2 decades of advances have occurred.

And both you and AS continue to ignore the fact there was no major lab near the outbreak studying closely related viruses.

You are assuming that scientists would easily be able to track down the spillover event of Covid as "easily" as they did SARS.

However, you ignore some important points:

1) SARS did not have the kind of asymptomatic spread that Covid does, so it was easier to notice its emergence.

2) The priorities when a pandemic is in full swing is for management of the spread which necessarily involves decontamination of areas thought most likely to have caused the outbreaks. This amounts to a neccesary destruction of evidence.

When SARS's spillover vector was discovered, it was after the disease had ceased to be a problem.

So, if you want to complain that one analogy shouldn't be used because of cherry-picked disanalogous features, then the same goes for your reasoning.

Your argument is:

We found SARS went to humans through civet cats so we HAVE TO / MUST HAVE been able to get Covid by now or else lab leak!111!!!!

[/HILITE]Instead of trying to dismiss the lab accident hypothesis, why don't you concentrate on finding evidence for a natural event?

Why should I not do both? Sorry, but your views are as open to examination as anyone else's.
 
I'm countering this claim that you made....
So no interest in defending the natural spillover event then, just in attacking me?


You're making other analogies, such as here:

You are assuming that scientists would easily be able to track down the spillover event of Covid as "easily" as they did SARS.
Yes, more easily for that matter, researchers knew what to look for and where. And evidence for any wet market in Wuhan can't be found, nor is there any evidence in Yunnan bats nor pangolins. And there is evidence Wuhan was the central infection spreading site.

However, you ignore some important points:

1) SARS did not have the kind of asymptomatic spread that Covid does, so it was easier to notice its emergence.
What is missing that we don't have from other evidence?

2) The priorities when a pandemic is in full swing is for management of the spread which necessarily involves decontamination of areas thought most likely to have caused the outbreaks. This amounts to a neccesary destruction of evidence.

When SARS's spillover vector was discovered, it was after the disease had ceased to be a problem.
That's nonsense. If you are talking about they closed the super-spreader site the Seafood Market that did not stop the search for another wet market source. China covering it up OTOH...

So, if you want to complain that one analogy shouldn't be used because of cherry-picked disanalogous features, then the same goes for your reasoning.

Your argument is:

We found SARS went to humans through civet cats so we HAVE TO / MUST HAVE been able to get Covid by now or else lab leak!111!!!!
Yeah, pretty much, and I'm sticking to it.
 
So no interest in defending the natural spillover event then, just in attacking me?

Huh? I was mentioning an offhand comment about how just because one thing is first detected in one place and time, doesn't mean it originated there and then. You and Yuppy leapt all over that.

When I respond, you play the martyr! Poor Skeptic Ginger under incessant attack from me! How tragic.


Yes, more easily for that matter, researchers knew what to look for and where. And evidence for any wet market in Wuhan can't be found, nor is there any evidence in Yunnan bats nor pangolins. And there is evidence Wuhan was the central infection spreading site.

What is missing that we don't have from other evidence?

That's nonsense. If you are talking about they closed the super-spreader site the Seafood Market that did not stop the search for another wet market source. China covering it up OTOH...

Yeah, pretty much, and I'm sticking to it.

I have a feeling you may be overestimating how easy it is to track down these pathogens.

May I ask if you have any expert opinion on your side that agrees with your assertion that the spillover event MUST HAVE BEEN / HAS TO HAVE BEEN found by now...?
 
There are many places to look...

Chinese markets linked to some of the earliest COVID-19 cases were illegally selling a range of wildlife from which the coronavirus may have spread, according to a study published less than two weeks after U.S. President Joe Biden ordered a deeper probe into the pandemic’s genesis.

Mink, masked palm civets, raccoon dogs, Siberian weasels, hog badgers and Chinese bamboo rats were among 38 animal species sold live at markets in Wuhan from May 2017 to November 2019, researchers said Monday in a paper in the journal Scientific Reports originally submitted last October.
The hunt for COVID-19’s origins has become increasingly political amid criticism that the Chinese government hasn’t been open and transparent with key information, including activities in a Wuhan lab studying coronaviruses. The new findings support the conclusions of a World Health Organization-led research mission in early 2021 that concluded SARS-CoV-2 most likely spilled over to humans from animals — either directly from a bat or via another mammal, possibly one sold at the Huanan seafood and fresh produce market in central Wuhan.

“This report clearly places SARS-CoV-2 susceptible animals smack in the middle of Wuhan,” said Robert Garry, a professor of microbiology and immunology at Tulane University in New Orleans, who wasn’t involved in the research. It’s “a major revelation,” he said in an email.

Link
 
Surely lots of places to look makes it harder, not easier, than if there's just one place to look. Especially if (unlike SARS) asymptomatic spread meant the evidence would have been long gone before they even started looking.
 
Surely lots of places to look makes it harder, not easier, than if there's just one place to look. Especially if (unlike SARS) asymptomatic spread meant the evidence would have been long gone before they even started looking.

Indeed. Here is the paper about the animals that were in the markets...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-91470-2

Here we document 47,381 individuals from 38 species, including 31 protected species sold between May 2017 and November 2019 in Wuhan’s markets. We note that no pangolins (or bats) were traded, supporting reformed opinion that pangolins were not likely the spillover host at the source of the current coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. While we caution against the misattribution of COVID-19’s origins, the wild animals on sale in Wuhan suffered poor welfare and hygiene conditions and we detail a range of other zoonotic infections they can potentially vector. Nevertheless, in a precautionary response to COVID-19, China’s Ministries temporarily banned all wildlife trade on 26th Jan 2020 until the COVID-19 pandemic concludes, and permanently banned eating and trading terrestrial wild (non-livestock) animals for food on 24th Feb 2020. These interventions, intended to protect human health, redress previous trading and enforcement inconsistencies, and will have collateral benefits for global biodiversity conservation and animal welfare.
 
Last edited:
Surely lots of places to look makes it harder, not easier, than if there's just one place to look. Especially if (unlike SARS) asymptomatic spread meant the evidence would have been long gone before they even started looking.

It's been a year and a half and nothing close to COVID 19 has been found.

And for some reason the Chinese government refuses to cooperate.

If you look at the work being done at the WIV before the pandemic began, including Daszak's work he spoke freely about before he created a smokescreen dismissing any risk this was a lab accident you find they were doing GoF research with 'humanized mice' and with cultures using human cells to grow coronavirus cultures in.

Once the pandemic started Daszak and the lead investigator at the WIV denied they had any live bats or live viral cultures. Only a year before the first cases WIV researchers reported bringing live bats from Yunnan to the WIV. And there was a report about needing to take care of the bats when the usual caretaker was gone for a while.

Dr Shi (lead investigator at the WIV) claimed she looked at her database of what they were working on and nothing came close to COVID 19. But in Sept, a month before the first cases turned up, much of that database was taken offline by the Chinese government. The explanation it was to protect the researchers makes little sense given the timing. Why wasn't the protection needed a year ago? What changed?

All of this and more is documented in this thread.
 
Indeed. Here is the paper about the animals that were in the markets...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-91470-2

That was the market which turned out not to be where the first cases occurred. Yet it keeps being brought up again and again minus the evidence it wasn't where the first cases became infected.

The research I cite was being done at the WIV. One need not speculate such as needing to speculate there was a market exposure which is not documented.
 
Last edited:
I don't disagree that the lab leak hypothesis is plausible enough to be seriously investigated. I just don't think the speed with which the source of SARS was identified supports it, for the reasons stated.
 
That was the market which turned out not to be where the first cases occurred. Yet it keeps being brought up again and again minus the evidence it wasn't where the first cases became infected.
I think the point being made is that we don't know where the first cases occurred, we only know where the first cases were identified. The first cases could have occurred at the market, and the disease then spread widely (thanks to its transmissibility and relatively low incidence of serious illness) before eventually being detected somewhere else. So we can't yet rule out an origin in the market, any more than we can yet rule out an origin in the Wuhan lab.
 
That was the market which turned out not to be where the first cases occurred. Yet it keeps being brought up again and again minus the evidence it wasn't where the first cases became infected.
The research I cite was being done at the WIV. One need not speculate such as needing to speculate there was a market exposure which is not documented.

We don't know who the first infected people are!
 
A close look at Fauci's e-mails. It's amazing how much is in there that was redacted for what appears to be inappropriate reasons (a privilege is being claimed that doesn't seem to apply).



I'll say right up front that some of this seems to border on conspiracy-mongering, or has that feel to it. Still, I am curious about what they discussed in that conference call and what's behind the redacted parts of the e-mails.
 
With all those places to look, what's the hold up finding the source?

Ummm the fact that there are so many places to look? Your claim that "it should be easy" to examine dozens of species over a geographical area stretching from Japan to Africa make little sense.
 
It's been a year and a half and nothing close to COVID 19 has been found.

This isn't true at all. Multiple close Covid relatives have been identified and many examples of it previously unknown furin cleavage site in various stages of evolutionary development have been found. A clear evolutionary history of the key feature that makes this virus so infectious to humans has started to emerge. The fact that we can start to trace it's natural evolution means ANY variation of it being created in a lab is pseudoscientific nonsense.

The only version of the lab leak hypothesis that isn't complete pseudoscience is that it was a natural virus that for some reason was never catalogued, somehow escaped from a BSL4 lab. The infected person went shopping at multiple live animal markets spreading a different lineage of the virus in each on.

It may not be impossible, but it's hardly likely or credible when taken in the context that natural spillover from eating wild animals is a common vector for novel viruses and that it's been recognised for decades that live animal markets have been a high danger breeding ground for such events. Arguments that "my pet theory is still possible!!!" hold no weight when the standard accepted theory is so much more likely.
 
Dr Shi (lead investigator at the WIV) claimed she looked at her database of what they were working on and nothing came close to COVID 19. But in Sept, a month before the first cases turned up, much of that database was taken offline by the Chinese government. The explanation it was to protect the researchers makes little sense given the timing. Why wasn't the protection needed a year ago? What changed?

The first case identified case is from Dec, 3 months after the database was taken down. Crossover into humans is estimated to occur Oct, again after the database was take down. Scientists around the world had access to the database and knowledge of what it did and did not contain, presumably these were all part of the conspiracy as well?


Another thing I find weird about the relentless attacks on Dr Shi is that so much of the hypothesises hinges on her research into bat viruses. Her work on Corona viruses in horseshoe bats must be unassailably correct yet at the same time she must be completely untrustworthy agent of the Chinese government. (Even though her work debunked the Chinese government theory that the SARS was created in a US lab and released into China)

She isn't the only victim of these attacks on the scientific community, in fact nearly every researcher into the threat of pandemic Corona viruses is in some way vilified by these accusations. The lesson, apparently, is that virologists shouldn't research viruses with pandemic potential because they will be accused of causing the pandemic if it ever occurs.
 
A close look at Fauci's e-mails. It's amazing how much is in there that was redacted for what appears to be inappropriate reasons (a privilege is being claimed that doesn't seem to apply).



I'll say right up front that some of this seems to border on conspiracy-mongering, or has that feel to it. Still, I am curious about what they discussed in that conference call and what's behind the redacted parts of the e-mails.

Looks like Fauci is on the hit list now. Maybe he has been for some time judging by my barge-pole distance observations of right-wing talking points.

This one starts with “Fauci lied, people died”.

That was enough for me, thanks, although he did refer to himself as a doctor. What is this guy a doctor of?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom