Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
And, I'll repeat my point then, that is a seriously screwed up analogy to make that point.

RY is right.

No, you are wrong to dismiss the point. In fact, I made this point way back on page 1...

By the way, an important thing to bear in mind, is that wherever a virus is first detected does not mean that that is where the virus originated.

I also sketched a scenario where something like this could happen...

I have a pet theory that maybe it existed on some small holding wildlife farm perhaps run by a small family who had developed antibodies against the virus that their animals had given to them, and that after the mass swine culling of 2018-2019, they got a chance to send some of their animals, for a good price, to one of the big cities.

It would be consistent with a scenario suggested by Garry, that the animals could have gone to Wuhan, and there be sent to two different markets, creating two different lineages and infecting people who went there.

If this were to happen around late-October to mid-November it would be consistent with other data we have about the evolution of the virus. Then, a small outbreak could have occurred around this time, mostly asymptomatic, until a few people began getting sick, masked by the flu epidemic of around the same time.

Subsequently, some of the sick people such as "First Case" who is actually not the first case in December 2019 could very easily be someone who himself did not have a connection to a market. But the majority of those who got sick did have a connection.

Is there evidence for this theory?

No. But it seems to match the available evidence.

Hence people such as Peter Daszak (obligatory acknoeldgement of Daszak's conflict of interest here: a reminder to everyone that Peter Daszak is a lying conniving evil person whose whole reason for being is to enrich himself while scattering viruses everywhere and lying for the Communist government in China) want to investigate the wildlife farm routes as this may end up giving clues to how it came about. I thnk he expects to find people and animals somewhere along the line to have evidence of the virus.

Interestingly, it was said on TWiV that RaTG13 and SARS-CoV2 probably share a common ancestor that they say is estimated (I didn't catch where or how they arrived at this conclusion, sorry) at around 60 years ago.
 
The problem with all of that is that one is no closer to finding the source of COVID-19 regardless of similar viruses being found in other parts of Asia.
How many decades did it take to track down the animal reservoir for AIDS, Ebola, the 1918 Flu, etc?


How did two related lineages of COVID 19, well adapted to humans, show up in Wuhan at about the same time?

Unless you are arguing for this being an engineered virus, the same "problems" exist for a lab leak. Problems is on quotes here, because it's very easy to explain both the distribution of cases and multiple early lineages with crossover in live animal markets. It's much harder to explain this pattern if it was a lab leak.

As for why it was highely infectious right from the start, Covid is a generalist virus, all it needs is a spike structure that is efficient at binding to ACE2 of a given species and it is immediately going to be highly infectious to that species. Eg humans spread it to minks and it was immediately even more infectious to them than it was to humans.

This favors it spreading from a host with more humanlike ACE2 receptors, but there are scenarios were it could come from a bat as well. That's not really all that significant given that bats are sold in these live animal markets.
 
Until you point out why the natural crossover has more compelling 'real' evidence I see no use in defending my list.

More compelling than what? The versionof the lab leak hypothesis you claim to support IS natural crossover, you are just arguing that natural crossover happened in a BSL4 lab for "#reasons" even though it just adds unnecessary complication.

Or, have you flip flopped and once again arguing the lab actually created the virus and didn't just spread and then cover up a naturally occurring virus?
 
How many decades did it take to track down the animal reservoir for AIDS, Ebola, the 1918 Flu, etc?
Humans are the reservoir for HIV. We didn't have the technology to track down the source of 1918 flu and we knew ebola was spilling over from animals because it was deadly when it turned up and it emerged repeatedly.

In none of those cases did researchers in a lab that was experimenting with those viruses exist, let alone were any in the vicinity or the outbreaks. That fact keeps being ignored in these little analogy games.


Unless you are arguing for this being an engineered virus, the same "problems" exist for a lab leak. Problems is on quotes here, because it's very easy to explain both the distribution of cases and multiple early lineages with crossover in live animal markets. It's much harder to explain this pattern if it was a lab leak.
It's convenient to keep alluding to the animal market spillover but it requires certain key details be ignored, mainly, not only do we not have an animal source, there is no connection between the first cases to any animal market.

So convenient to just fill in that blank to fit the animal source scenario.
 
His point, and it is not one that should be that difficult to grasp, is that just because we first discover something at a particular time and place, it does NOT mean that that is where and when it originated.

That is still something that needs to be discovered.

No, you are wrong to dismiss the point.
We're dismissing the misleading analogy.

OK. Since you won't drop this, spell out exactly how wrong you think the current science might be in actual quantities rather than "it could be anywhere/anytime" vagueness of your analogy. Drop the analogy, use real words to explain exactly how wrong you think the scientists might be.

Multiple teams arrived at a MRCA time within the final months of 2019. Could all of them be wrong by many decades as your analogy implies? How many decades? Should we completely ignore those results when planning what to do next as implied by your analogy?

Same question for location. Do we continue to plan our investigation around what current scientists think, or do we consider the entire occupied surface of the planet equally likely as implied by your analogy?
 
More compelling than what? The versionof the lab leak hypothesis you claim to support IS natural crossover, you are just arguing that natural crossover happened in a BSL4 lab for "#reasons" even though it just adds unnecessary complication.

Or, have you flip flopped and once again arguing the lab actually created the virus and didn't just spread and then cover up a naturally occurring virus?
I can't help you when you don't recognize the difference between GoF research vs "engineered".
 
Interestingly, it was said on TWiV that RaTG13 and SARS-CoV2 probably share a common ancestor that they say is estimated (I didn't catch where or how they arrived at this conclusion, sorry) at around 60 years ago.

I'm pretty sure I saw a paper on this recently. IIRC the range was 30-70 years with a 95% probability of them diverging prior to 1970. If I'm remembering this accurately that would imply a rather asymmetrical distribution but I didn't look into it.
 
Humans are the reservoir for HIV.
It took decades to narrow down how AIDS crossed over into humans. With these natural crossovers it's normal to take a long time to identify where a novel virus came from, the fact that this work is stull in progress for Covid tells us nothing.

We actually got really lucky with SARS in that the Civits that served as an intermediary were still in the market when investigators looked. With the low symptom nature of Covid-19, however it took 2-3 months to identify the outbreak and any infected animals would have been long gone.
 
It's convenient to keep alluding to the animal market spillover but it requires certain key details be ignored, mainly, not only do we not have an animal source, there is no connection between the first cases to any animal market.


A bold claim given the first case hasn't been identified and the first know case was infected 6-8 weeks after the virus crossed over to humans. That's up to 10 generations of human hosts removed from the first infection. It's completely unreasonable to expect pandemic to remain confined strictly to one of the markets this far into the pandemic.
 
It took decades to narrow down how AIDS crossed over into humans. With these natural crossovers it's normal to take a long time to identify where a novel virus came from, the fact that this work is stull in progress for Covid tells us nothing.

We actually got really lucky with SARS in that the Civits that served as an intermediary were still in the market when investigators looked. With the low symptom nature of Covid-19, however it took 2-3 months to identify the outbreak and any infected animals would have been long gone.
In 1978 I took care of my first AIDS patient in the hospital. It wasn't until 1983 that the HIV virus was isolated and identified.

SARS virus first infected a person in late 2002. It was identified in 2003. Notice the timeline difference. You cannot compare how long it took to identify a new virus in 1985 to how long it took in 2003.

CDC SARS timeline
2004
January 13: CDC issues “Notice of Embargo of Civets.” A SARS-like virus had been isolated from civets (captured in areas of China where the SARS outbreak originated). CDC banned the importation of civets. The civet is a mammal with a catlike body, long legs, a long tail, and a masked face resembling a raccoon or weasel. The ban is currently still in effect.

It was established that SARS first emerged from a wet market in Guangdong, China by Jan 2004. That's less than a year from when it was first identified.

By that timeline we should have found at least the likely animal that was the source of COVID well before now especially since almost 2 decades of advances have occurred.


And both you and AS continue to ignore the fact there was no major lab near the outbreak studying closely related viruses.
 
A bold claim given the first case hasn't been identified and the first know case was infected 6-8 weeks after the virus crossed over to humans. That's up to 10 generations of human hosts removed from the first infection. It's completely unreasonable to expect pandemic to remain confined strictly to one of the markets this far into the pandemic.
:rolleyes:

The earliest cases in Wuhan had no connection to any wet markets.

There are multiple scenarios with no direct evidence of which one it was. If you want to speculate it could have come from some unknown wet market exposure, then that should bear equal weight to speculating it could have come from the lab.
 
And both you and AS continue to ignore the fact there was no major lab near the outbreak studying closely related viruses.

I think that's the crux of it. That's the "too much of a coincidence for me" moment that got you wedded to the leak theory. Listen, no one's saying that it's not possible, or even probable, that the theory describes the start of this pandemic. However I think the main disagreement is your contention that it's a "no brainer" or the most likely scenario.
 
We're dismissing the misleading analogy.

OK. Since you won't drop this, spell out exactly how wrong you think the current science might be in actual quantities rather than "it could be anywhere/anytime" vagueness of your analogy. Drop the analogy, use real words to explain exactly how wrong you think the scientists might be.

Multiple teams arrived at a MRCA time within the final months of 2019. Could all of them be wrong by many decades as your analogy implies? How many decades? Should we completely ignore those results when planning what to do next as implied by your analogy?

Same question for location. Do we continue to plan our investigation around what current scientists think, or do we consider the entire occupied surface of the planet equally likely as implied by your analogy?

You clearly misunderstand.

That is the MRCA of the two lineages in Wuhan.

It doesn't mean it is the date of lab leak zoonotic spillover.

Remember that at least one of the lab leak theories is that it was caught in the wild, taken to the lab and then got out through bad security, right? Under that scenario, the virus did not originate in Wuhan, and it probably didn't spillover in the final months of 2019, right?

On the other hand, if you take the theory I sketched out, then the virus could have been circulating in some small isolated area of China for many years.

All I am saying, and I think the scientists do agree with me on that, is that we just don't know.
 
You clearly misunderstand.

That is the MRCA of the two lineages in Wuhan.
I asked you about the MRCA for crying out loud. I don't need to be told that the MRCA is the MRCA. I said MRCA.

It doesn't mean it is the date of lab leak zoonotic spillover.
I didn't ask this and I know the difference.

All I am saying, and I think the scientists do agree with me on that, is that we just don't know.
DON'T KNOW WHAT? Answer the questions I asked.
 
Humans are the reservoir for HIV. We didn't have the technology to track down the source of 1918 flu and we knew ebola was spilling over from animals because it was deadly when it turned up and it emerged repeatedly.

In none of those cases did researchers in a lab that was experimenting with those viruses exist, let alone were any in the vicinity or the outbreaks. That fact keeps being ignored in these little analogy games.

Actually, that is not true. I already told you about how Ebola outbreaks had been blamed on lab leaks. Robert Garry, who was on the TWiV podcast has been accused in the past of an Ebola lab leak when an outbreak occurred near his lab (which I seem to recall was studying Lassa fever).

And of course, all kinds of conspiracy theories developed around HIV/AIDS.

Every outbreak leads to conspiracy theories because someone must be to blame, someone must pay!
 
I asked you about the MRCA for crying out loud. I don't need to be told that the MRCA is the MRCA. I said MRCA.


I didn't ask this and I know the difference.


DON'T KNOW WHAT? Answer the questions I asked.

I honestly don't know your problem, and you definitely aren't going to get me to do any work for you when you are so rude.

If you want me to discuss things, you need to work on your civility level. I haven't been rude to you, but you seem to think you can browbeat me into aswering questions. How about....no! Do it yourself.
 
I'm supposed to tell you your opinion about scientists? OK. You've left me with the opinion that you are willing to misrepresent scientists as idiots in the same way that creationists do.
 
I'm supposed to tell you your opinion about scientists? OK. You've left me with the opinion that you are willing to misrepresent scientists as idiots in the same way that creationists do.

That's flat out false.

Why are you lying?

Oh forget it. Nobody is going to take these posts of yours seriously.

Have fun raging incoherently to yourself, because I'm about to make my reading of this thread much more pleasant. You have contributed nothing of substance to it anyway.

*Plonk*
 
It's because you keep saying scientists "don't know" but won't clarify what specifically they don't know. And presented an analogy that implies they could be completely wrong about two key facts. And I asked you two very specific questions that could have cleared this up and you ducked them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom