Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
In that last video I posted, Vincent makes an interesting point.


Someone: "Did you know that there is a Wuhan Institute of Virology right there where the virus was first found?"
Vincent: "Did you know that AIDS was first discovered in San Franciso in the 1980s, but that it had emerged in Africa in the 1920s?"
Someone: "Why are you defending China?"

As an analogy no more relevant than the WMD analogy.

Aids emerged and prevailed in San Francisco due to behaviour of the locals.
 
I don't know who this Vincent is but is that kind of stupidity typical of him and are you defending it?

His point, and it is not one that should be that difficult to grasp, is that just because we first discover something at a particular time and place, it does NOT mean that that is where and when it originated.

That is still something that needs to be discovered.
 
That's a seriously stupid way to communicate that point unless you're trying to claim some crackpot idea that everything we actually do know is wrong. Are you trying to claim that we should ignore what we do know about the origin of SARS_CoV2? Should we be considering that it's more than a century old? Are you trying to push the "it's just flu" agenda?
 
Last edited:
That's a seriously stupid way to communicate that point unless you're trying to claim some crackpot idea that everything we actually do know is wrong. Are you trying to claim that we should ignore what we do know about the origin of SARS_CoV2? Should we be considering that it's more than a century old? Are you trying to push the "it's just flu" agenda?

No, Yuppy. You need to stop trying to come up with the worst interpretation of what people say and then assuming that is what they are saying.
 
Interpretation? 1920 is a century ago. Although since your source says 1920s it may be a bit short of a century.
 
Last edited:
Interpretation? 1920 is a century ago. Although since your source says 1920s it may be a bit short of a century.

I will repeat the point again...

His point, and it is not one that should be that difficult to grasp, is that just because we first discover something at a particular time and place, it does NOT mean that that is where and when it originated.
That is still something that needs to be discovered.
 
No particular bone in this fight, but as someone who lives in Hong Kong, and is extremely aware of the capabilities of control that China has, there is literally nothing they would not do to cover it up in the still less than likely occurrence that a lab leak was indeed the source.

They are fully aware how it would turn the world against them, even more than it currently is.

In order to control that cover up, well meaning and professional scientists would be threatened or disappeared, their families would be threatened or disappeared.

This is not a western country or even Russia we are talking about. The state's control of the media and population within China's borders is absolute.

This doesn't make the leak theory any more or less likely, it just means that it would be way more easy to cover up than it would be elsewhere.

Edited to add: The Chinese state's control of personal communications is no less absolute. Websites, phone and email messages via all China's native services and also messages using non-Chinese apps such as WhatsApp are routinely removed and or censored, even in what would seem to us trivial cases. For example, messages from HK to Chinese WhatsApp users discussing the HK Local Election results, where the pro-government parties were thoroughly trounced, were simply not received by the Chinese recipients. If they go to all that trouble for something that was just mildly embarrassing, just imagine the lengths they would go to to protect something genuinely dangerous. Again, this is not supporting the lab leak theory, just pointing out that covering it up would be *easily* within the state's capability.
 
Last edited:
No particular bone in this fight, but as someone who lives in Hong Kong, and is extremely aware of the capabilities of control that China has, there is literally nothing they would not do to cover it up in the still less than likely occurrence that a lab leak was indeed the source.

They are fully aware how it would turn the world against them, even more than it currently is.

In order to control that cover up, well meaning and professional scientists would be threatened or disappeared, their families would be threatened or disappeared.

This is not a western country or even Russia we are talking about. The states control of the media and population within China's borders is absolute.

This doesn't make the leak theory any more or less likely, it just means that it would be way more easy to cover up than it would be elsewhere.
Thank you. That is what I thought.

Sorry Hong Kong has been taken over by China. Hope you're OK.
 
Thank you. That is what I thought.

Sorry Hong Kong has been taken over by China. Hope you're OK.

Yes, I am fine thank you. And as long as one does not rock the boat politically, or basically promote any form of democracy, day to day life is perfectly fine. Apart from some vaccine hesitation, HK has done incredibly well with the pandemic.

However, there is no getting away from the fact that HK is no longer Asia's World City and run under 1 Country 2 Systems, its becoming more like any other Chinese city as each month goes by. I would give it another maybe 5 years before the firewall and censorship will apply here too.
 
:confused:

By current discoveries I mean the stuff that makes a pangolin involvement highly unlikely.

Care to link these "discoveries". By this I mean I mean actual papers in real, high impact, peer reviews journals. Also note that evidence for a different intermediate host in no way rules out pangolins.
 
SGU talk about the lab leak hypothesis on their latest episode.

They point out that there is no new evidence despite all the recent media sensationalism about it.

Link

They also mention a blogpost by David Gorski in which he looks at the latest resurgence.

He is not impressed by the lab leak hypothesis.

Bad logic and math aside, I’ve noticed that the lab leak hypothesis has definitely—shall we say?—evolved during the last year. Given the utter lack of evidence in the nucleotide sequences of SARS-CoV-2 for an “engineered” origin, the “respectable” people now claiming that the coronavirus came from a lab hasten to deny that they think it was “engineered” or a “bioweapon.” Basically, there are now two main versions of the “lab leak” hypothesis:

1.An engineered SARS coronavirus created at the Wuhan Institute of Virology through “gain of function” experiments somehow escaped and caused the pandemic.
2. A natural SARS coronavirus stored and studied at the Wuhan Institute of Virology somehow escaped and caused the pandemic.​

I can say with a high degree of confidence based on existing evidence that the first version is so implausible as to have drifted well into conspiracy theory territory. The second is the version that “reasonable” people consider plausible, but there is no good evidence for either version. In any event, given how much these hypotheses have been discussed in the news as though there were some new evidence that now makes the “lab leak” hypothesis more likely (spoiler alert: there isn’t) and assaulted me on social media, coming from conspiracy theorists and non-conspiracy theorists, I just had to look into this issue again.

In particular he calls the claims by Dalgleish and Sorenson (that have been trumpeted by the Leakies here) Bull ******

He makes the same point I made earlier...

If it truly “violates the laws of physics” to have four positively charged amino acids all in a line next to each other in a protein, then it would be utterly impossible to engineer a nucleotide sequence that could encode such a protein, because translation would fail! Seriously, how could any journal allow a review article to make such a nonsensical argument? It turns out that four positively charged amino acids in a row is quite common, a motif found in thousands of different proteins.

And...

The key claim made by Dalgleish and Sørensen is this:

Dalgleish and Sørensen claim that scientists working on Gain of Function projects took a natural coronavirus ‘backbone’ found in Chinese cave bats and spliced onto it a new ‘spike’, turning it into the deadly and highly transmissible SARS-Cov-2.​

They base their argument on, in essence, an argument from ignorance, with a bit of conspiracy theory added. Yes, it is possible to create genetic sequences without, for instance, typical restriction enzyme sites of the sort that were frequently used to insert sequences into genomes. However, it isn’t nearly as easy as Dalgleish and Sørensen make it sound. Basically, to them these nefarious Chinese scientists were supposedly so clever that they not only did something that’s not at all trivial but did it without leaving behind any telltale signs in the sequence of genetic manipulation, other than the ones that only Dalgleish and Sørenson “discovered,” such as the six areas on the protein that basically every other scientist didn’t find suspicious.

He also discusses Nicholas Wade's article that Leakies got excited by....

Basically, Wade’s argument seems to be that because a furin cleavage site of this sort hasn’t been seen in SARS-related beta coronaviruses before it must have been engineered. The problem is that such furin cleavage sites are common in a wide variety of viruses, including coronaviruses, and that scientists already had identified plausible mechanisms by which it could have ended up where it did in SARS-CoV2 last year:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom