Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
....

Can you at least see why I don't the lab leak case compelling at all, if that's what constitutes "key pieces of evidence"? Where's the beef?
Until you point out why the natural crossover has more compelling 'real' evidence I see no use in defending my list.

We need a shared definition of 'real' evidence to communicate. You think it is one thing, I think it is another thing.

Just claiming you are only talking about one half of the debate isn't cutting it. We are weighing the most likely of 2 options.

This is the 4th or 5th time you've dodged the key issue, that of there being no evidence whatsoever supporting either option if you define evidence as not evidence.
 
If you know why the lab was improving their protocols, then why not just say so? If answer supports the lab leak hypothesis, then you could just come out with it.

Why so coy? :confused:
Maybe you could review the evidence already posted for the lab errors before accusing someone of not meeting your needs.

Chinese Lab with Checkered Safety Record D

Of course this is from the VOA so maybe not better that the Global Times. Both are propaganda sites. But there are other sources posted here about the specific biosafety issues with the WIV.
 
Last edited:
Which makes it a bit difficult to reach conclusions about what's more likely, wouldn't you say?

Yeah, that was the point of my recent post: "it has become hopeless to find the truth at least for anytime in the near future."
 
Last edited:
On TWiV, they are talking about this paper, which is on RaTG13.

I can't really say I understand the discussion, but they explain that when SARS-CoV-2 came about, the WIV BLASTed (which means to search it on a database, according to Brianne) it to find the closest sequence and it was then that they looked into RaTG-13.

It may be interesting for some people here:

https://youtu.be/NGo958fkFz8?t=3899
 
Huh. I guess that was too cryptic for you. Wanna try again?

These one-liners that offer no substance to further info or insight into the origins of Covid are tiresome. I could put most of your posts in several threads on many topics and they would fit. Lazy.

Have you read the thread yet? Have you read any of the scientific papers yet?
I'd guess "no" by the fact that you offer no specifics in any rebuttal, but I could be wrong.
 
These one-liners that offer no substance to further info or insight into the origins of Covid are tiresome.

I've given up trying to reason with Ginger, so I'm trying a different tactic.

I'd guess "no" by the fact that you offer no specifics in any rebuttal

What rebuttal? Ginger is attached to this one theory and has nothing to offer to support it. There's nothing to refute. Remember the "pros" of the theory that were rightly ridiculed?

I could put most of your posts in several threads on many topics and they would fit. Lazy.

Well you know what you need to do, then.
 
Last edited:
Until you point out why the natural crossover has more compelling 'real' evidence I see no use in defending my list.
That's a frankly bizarre defense to criticism of your "key pieces of evidence". Unless I can defend a position that I'm not trying to defend, you won't defend your position against criticism?

I am criticising your stance, which I will quote:
There is a no brainer here that the lab accident is the leading hypothesis.

And these are the "key pieces of evidence" you have stated for the lab leak hypothesis:

Is it really more likely when two, not one, ready to go lineages turned up in Wuhan at the same time?

Also there have been plenty of lab accidents so just saying a natural spillover is more likely really isn't much evidence at all.

What direct evidence of a spillover is there?

People keep repeating the pangolin as an intermediary source when there is less and less evidence for that hypothesis the closer it is looked at.
I've explained the reason why I think those "key pieces of evidence" just don't cut the mustard for the lab leak hypothesis.

For reasons I simply can't understand, you simply refuse to explain why my objections don't hold and why that evidence would lead you to conclude that it's a "no brainer" that the lab leak hypothesis is the most likely explanation for the origins of COVID-19.

I'm criticising your defense of the lab leak hypothesis because I simply don't see why it's remotely compelling, and you're not explaining why you've come to the conclusion that it's a "no brainer" that it's the most likely hypothesis.

Can you explain why my objections to your "key piece of evidence" aren't valid and why they lead you to believe that the lab leak hypothesis is such a no-brainer? Because I'm just not getting it.
 
Last edited:
I see you cut off the part where I remind you of the ridiculous points you presented in suport of that theory.
I answered the excerpt I quoted.

That includes "nuff said". Sorry if that's not satisfying for you.


That's a frankly bizarre defense to criticism of your "key pieces of evidence". Unless I can defend a position that I'm not trying to defend, you won't defend your position against criticism?
...
That you won't answer the question defining what is real evidence says it all.

If you can't define it, I can't defend my statements.
 
In that last video I posted, Vincent makes an interesting point.


Someone: "Did you know that there is a Wuhan Institute of Virology right there where the virus was first found?"
Vincent: "Did you know that AIDS was first discovered in San Franciso in the 1980s, but that it had emerged in Africa in the 1920s?"
Someone: "Why are you defending China?"
 
In that last video I posted, Vincent makes an interesting point.


Someone: "Did you know that there is a Wuhan Institute of Virology right there where the virus was first found?"
Vincent: "Did you know that AIDS was first discovered in San Franciso in the 1980s, but that it had emerged in Africa in the 1920s?"
Someone: "Why are you defending China?"
I don't know who this Vincent is but is that kind of stupidity typical of him and are you defending it?
 
That you won't answer the question defining what is real evidence says it all.

If you can't define it, I can't defend my statements.
I don't need to define "evidence" in order to point out what's wrong with your evidence.

I'll explain again my objections to your "key pieces of evidence" for the lab leak hypothesis.

1. Is it really more likely when two, not one, ready to go lineages turned up in Wuhan at the same time?

2. Also there have been plenty of lab accidents so just saying a natural spillover is more likely really isn't much evidence at all.

3. What direct evidence of a spillover is there?

4. People keep repeating the pangolin as an intermediary source when there is less and less evidence for that hypothesis the closer it is looked at.
1. This is a question about the likelihood of a spillover event being the cause of the pandemic, not a piece of evidence in favour of the lab leak hypothesis. I don't need to define "real evidence" for that point to make sense.

2. This is phrased as an objection to the idea that "a natural spillover is more likely" as evidence of the spillover hypothesis, thus is not presented as evidence in favour of the lab leak hypothesis, but an objection to a vague assertion about the likelihood of the spillover hypothesis. Even if you take the fact that lab leaks happen as evidence for the lab leak hypothesis, it's merely evidence that such a thing is possible, it's not evidence that it actually happened in this instance. I don't need to define "real evidence" for this to be understood.

3. This isn't evidence for the lab leak hypothesis, it's another question about the evidence for the spillover hypothesis. I don't need to qualify what I mean by the "evidence" for this to be self-evident.

4. If one proposed hypothesis for how the spillover might have happened (i.e. via a pangolin as an amplifier host) isn't panning out, then that is not evidence in favour of the lab leak hypothesis, it just means that if it was a spillover event, then it didn't happen with a pangolin as an intermediate host between bats and humans.

I can't make it any clearer than that. We don't need to debate what either of us means by "real evidence" to understand me.

You've stated that it's a "no brainer" that the lab leak hypothesis is the most likely explanation and these are your "key pieces of evidence" for that hypothesis and I've explained my objections to those as evidence that supposedly supports the lab leak hypothesis. I don't understand why you're so wedded to the lab leak hypothesis if that's what you think are the "key pieces of evidence" going for it.

If you disagree with me, then explain what's wrong with my objections.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why you're so wedded to the lab leak hypothesis if that's what you think are the "key pieces of evidence" going for it.

Oh, I've been assured that she's not wedded to it at all. I've even been put on ignore by another poster when I refused to play Ginger's game any longer and tried a different method of pushing my point through.

This is becoming ideological.
 
In that last video I posted, Vincent makes an interesting point.
Someone: "Did you know that there is a Wuhan Institute of Virology right there where the virus was first found?"
Vincent: "Did you know that AIDS was first discovered in San Franciso in the 1980s, but that it had emerged in Africa in the 1920s?"
Someone: "Why are you defending China?"

Once again, another analogy fail.

And for the record, it did not emerge in the 20s.

Researchers trace first HIV case to 1959 in the Belgian Congo

It may have begun 10-20 years earlier still putting it in the very late 1930s.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom