Not quite. A cave was identified with viruses that contains all the elements of SARS but the complete virus itself wasn’t found. The direct ancestor, the one that passed it to humans, was found in Civet cats in a live animal market. The Civets probably got it from bats with a connection to the suspect cave. Unfortunately the "stealth" nature of Covid-19 means that by the time scientists started looking at live animal markets any infected animals would have been long gone.
This is not different from my post. We agree.
The elements of SARS were there. SARS-like viruses were there. "The" specific SARS-Cov (number 1) that killed nearly 900 persons was not found but recombination among hundreds of thousands of bats huddled together means it's like a needle in a haystack until it gets out of the cave into another mammal that is not so adapted. Only then, and only if it gets widely spread or is particularly deadly, would anyone notice it. That is why Professor Shi and her team went to that cave in the first place. The dead miners were a red flag to investigate. I provided the medical report at least a month ago.
I feel like perhaps you havent read the relevant information on the history of spillover already so maybe you do not know.
What you do likely already know is that bats are pretty unique mammals in having the ability to carry "more than average" dangerous viruses, in multiple forms, at the same time, without getting ill. (and there are good theories on that as to their high metabolism due to flight affecting immune responses...etc...but that is a different discussion).
Also worth noting that the Chinese scientist who tracked down the cave is one of the people who would need to be helping cover up the hypnotized lab leak. Real scientists are being harmed, and real science is being harmed by these unsubstantiated claims of a lab leak and subsequent cover-up.
I do not know what you are talking about with the phrase "hypnotized lab leak". I am honestly confused by this choice of words.
Ralph S. Baric runs the other premiere lab working on bat-derived coronaviruses- at Univ N.Carolina. He knows Shi, has collaborated and co-authored with the Wuhan team since 2015. He taught her his patented GoF and RNA manipulation techniques- which he patented as "seamless" or "no-see-um" in the early 2000's to where anyone looking at the genome would not see any manipulation. He developed the theory of Remdesivir as a potential therapeutic....BEFORE this one was out.
He thinks it is likely a natural infection, from bats, to humans, then mutating- but doesnt rule out that it is related to the lab's research. Why does he consider it a possibility? It certainly doesnt help
him. He says the research is still more valuable than the risks.
He signed his name to the letter calling for more data and investigation which stated that a leak related to the lab was not given balanced consideration.
Is he wrong to consider it?
letter:
https://science.sciencemag.org/content/372/6543/694.1
Covid reactive antibodies have been found in wild bats and wild pangolins in Thailand. Give the wide range of close Covid relatives this may not mean the antibodies were generated in response to Covid's proximal ancestor though.
These
anti-bodies were found in humans- over 10 years after the first SARS outbreak and were people who had not been infected in the first round.
I'm sure most of these infections are rather benign...as we'd have pandemics all the time if not. Oddly, they only asked people about recent illness, and not deaths or some past period where there were unusual SARS-like illnesses. The positive rate was so low that they reserved it for some further study. I'd like to see a study on that now.
I tend to also consider that these remote rural areas may have been exposed to various forms of this virus for as long as humans have lived near there. And it stayed there. And it mutated there...in humans.
It was interesting enough to study seriously...and they did study it. And they did spend time in those villages and that cave. And they did go back and forth with their susceptible human bodies and all of the samples to Wuhan. Both human and bat and 'other'.
Then the pandemic starts in Wuhan.
The pieces fit for several possibilities but no one can summarily discount a relation to the research in Wuhan. Saying it's a choice between manufactured lab leaked virus and a natural spillover is a false dichotomy. Transmission can happen any time a human gets exposed, from bat, other mammal (including humans), no matter if they work in a lab or not.
Can also be lab contamination. Go take a look at WIV's patent applications in the last 3 years for preventing contamination of potentially dangerous pathogens (disinfectants and containment methods allowing for transport of a virus). I dont know why they'd try to solve an issue they never had. The patents explain WHY they want the new method. Most of their applications prior to this perios are not related to this at all.
Do you want the official links?
I will give them if I thought anyone would actually go read it.
*sorry if there are typos/errors, but my daughter is here and complaining that I need to come play Battleship.