Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Please tell me which hypothesis has any evidence at all and what that evidence is.
You're one arguing in favour of the lab leak hypothesis. I'm just pointing out that your "key pieces of evidence" aren't actually evidence in favour of the hypothesis aren't remotely impressive.

For example, pointing out that lab leaks sometimes happen is not actually evidence that a lab leak actually happened in this instance. If a car crash happens and I argue that I think it was likely caused by a mechanical fault, it's not a valid argument for me to claim that a "key piece of evidence" that it was a mechanical fault is that sometimes mechanical faults are known to cause car crashes. I've just pointed out that, absent any other evidence of might have caused the crash, the mechanical fault hypothesis is merely possible.

Another example, you've argued that the lab leak might have happened because someone merely Dr. Shi "simply claimed she looked through her data and didn't find anything" regarding the hypothesis that the SARS-CoV-2 virus was created via gain of function research on the SARS-CoV virus. This is an especially odd argument given that you seem very dismissive of the idea that it might have been a spillover event involving one of several other much more closely related coronaviruses that are known to exist, or it might have an as of yet unidentified virus that SARS-CoV-2 spilled over to humans. The fact that there are many known coronaviruses that are much closer related to SARS-CoV-2 than SARS-CoV would seem to rule that possibility out.

What do you think is the most compelling evidence in favour of the hypothesis that the virus leaked from WIV?
 
Last edited:
You aren't keeping up with current discoveries.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-21240-1

Among the many questions unanswered for the COVID-19 pandemic are the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and the potential role of intermediate animal host(s) in the early animal-to-human transmission. The discovery of RaTG13 bat coronavirus in China suggested a high probability of a bat origin. Here we report molecular and serological evidence of SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses (SC2r-CoVs) actively circulating in bats in Southeast Asia. Whole genome sequences were obtained from five independent bats (Rhinolophus acuminatus) in a Thai cave yielding a single isolate (named RacCS203) which is most related to the RmYN02 isolate found in Rhinolophus malayanus in Yunnan, China. SARS-CoV-2 neutralizing antibodies were also detected in bats of the same colony and in a pangolin at a wildlife checkpoint in Southern Thailand. Antisera raised against the receptor binding domain (RBD) of RmYN02 was able to cross-neutralize SARS-CoV-2 despite the fact that the RBD of RacCS203 or RmYN02 failed to bind ACE2. Although the origin of the virus remains unresolved, our study extended the geographic distribution of genetically diverse SC2r-CoVs from Japan and China to Thailand over a 4800-km range. Cross-border surveillance is urgently needed to find the immediate progenitor virus of SARS-CoV-2.
 
Not quite. A cave was identified with viruses that contains all the elements of SARS but the complete virus itself wasn’t found. The direct ancestor, the one that passed it to humans, was found in Civet cats in a live animal market. The Civets probably got it from bats with a connection to the suspect cave. Unfortunately the "stealth" nature of Covid-19 means that by the time scientists started looking at live animal markets any infected animals would have been long gone.

This is not different from my post. We agree.
The elements of SARS were there. SARS-like viruses were there. "The" specific SARS-Cov (number 1) that killed nearly 900 persons was not found but recombination among hundreds of thousands of bats huddled together means it's like a needle in a haystack until it gets out of the cave into another mammal that is not so adapted. Only then, and only if it gets widely spread or is particularly deadly, would anyone notice it. That is why Professor Shi and her team went to that cave in the first place. The dead miners were a red flag to investigate. I provided the medical report at least a month ago.
I feel like perhaps you havent read the relevant information on the history of spillover already so maybe you do not know.

What you do likely already know is that bats are pretty unique mammals in having the ability to carry "more than average" dangerous viruses, in multiple forms, at the same time, without getting ill. (and there are good theories on that as to their high metabolism due to flight affecting immune responses...etc...but that is a different discussion).

Also worth noting that the Chinese scientist who tracked down the cave is one of the people who would need to be helping cover up the hypnotized lab leak. Real scientists are being harmed, and real science is being harmed by these unsubstantiated claims of a lab leak and subsequent cover-up.

I do not know what you are talking about with the phrase "hypnotized lab leak". I am honestly confused by this choice of words.

Ralph S. Baric runs the other premiere lab working on bat-derived coronaviruses- at Univ N.Carolina. He knows Shi, has collaborated and co-authored with the Wuhan team since 2015. He taught her his patented GoF and RNA manipulation techniques- which he patented as "seamless" or "no-see-um" in the early 2000's to where anyone looking at the genome would not see any manipulation. He developed the theory of Remdesivir as a potential therapeutic....BEFORE this one was out.
He thinks it is likely a natural infection, from bats, to humans, then mutating- but doesnt rule out that it is related to the lab's research. Why does he consider it a possibility? It certainly doesnt help him. He says the research is still more valuable than the risks.
He signed his name to the letter calling for more data and investigation which stated that a leak related to the lab was not given balanced consideration.
Is he wrong to consider it?
letter:
https://science.sciencemag.org/content/372/6543/694.1

Covid reactive antibodies have been found in wild bats and wild pangolins in Thailand. Give the wide range of close Covid relatives this may not mean the antibodies were generated in response to Covid's proximal ancestor though.

These anti-bodies were found in humans- over 10 years after the first SARS outbreak and were people who had not been infected in the first round.
I'm sure most of these infections are rather benign...as we'd have pandemics all the time if not. Oddly, they only asked people about recent illness, and not deaths or some past period where there were unusual SARS-like illnesses. The positive rate was so low that they reserved it for some further study. I'd like to see a study on that now.

I tend to also consider that these remote rural areas may have been exposed to various forms of this virus for as long as humans have lived near there. And it stayed there. And it mutated there...in humans.

It was interesting enough to study seriously...and they did study it. And they did spend time in those villages and that cave. And they did go back and forth with their susceptible human bodies and all of the samples to Wuhan. Both human and bat and 'other'.
Then the pandemic starts in Wuhan.

The pieces fit for several possibilities but no one can summarily discount a relation to the research in Wuhan. Saying it's a choice between manufactured lab leaked virus and a natural spillover is a false dichotomy. Transmission can happen any time a human gets exposed, from bat, other mammal (including humans), no matter if they work in a lab or not.
Can also be lab contamination. Go take a look at WIV's patent applications in the last 3 years for preventing contamination of potentially dangerous pathogens (disinfectants and containment methods allowing for transport of a virus). I dont know why they'd try to solve an issue they never had. The patents explain WHY they want the new method. Most of their applications prior to this perios are not related to this at all.

Do you want the official links?
I will give them if I thought anyone would actually go read it.

*sorry if there are typos/errors, but my daughter is here and complaining that I need to come play Battleship.
 
Last edited:
This was the exchange:


Please tell me which hypothesis has any evidence at all and what that evidence is.
1. You didn't quote me saying I said there was no evidence, which is what you're claiming I said. You even said I "agreed" to it. I did no such thing.

2. You quoted me specifically saying I wasn't arguing for either hypothesis, merely pointing out what I think are major flaws in your "key pieces of evidence"

If I'm not arguing either case, why would I be expected to offer evidence in favour of either case, you're the one arguing in favour of the lab leak hypothesis, it's incumbent on you to make the case in its favour, like I said, I'm just pointing out that the "key pieces of evidence" you're using in its favour aren't actually helping your case (like I said, some of them aren't even evidence, they're merely rather vague questions about the likelihood of either scenario).
 
Last edited:
I dont know why they'd try to solve an issue they never had.
I imagine that methods of disinfection and containing deadly pathogens are high on the priority of laboratories (or should be) are high on the priorities of labs studying them.

Is an institution patenting such methods they come up with evidence that they have had an accident? :confused:
 
I imagine that methods of disinfection and containing deadly pathogens are high on the priority of laboratories (or should be) are high on the priorities of labs studying them.

Is an institution patenting such methods they come up with evidence that they have had an accident? :confused:

Improvement is always great. But what drives the need to spend money on it? Go read them...then come back and give an opinion.

If you want me to find them for you (if you cannot), I will. Just let me know!

Now I am really late for Battleship! :p
 
You're one arguing in favour of the lab leak hypothesis. I'm just pointing out that your "key pieces of evidence" aren't actually evidence in favour of the hypothesis aren't remotely impressive.

For example, pointing out that lab leaks sometimes happen is not actually evidence that a lab leak actually happened in this instance. If a car crash happens and I argue that I think it was likely caused by a mechanical fault, it's not a valid argument for me to claim that a "key piece of evidence" that it was a mechanical fault is that sometimes mechanical faults are known to cause car crashes. I've just pointed out that, absent any other evidence of might have caused the crash, the mechanical fault hypothesis is merely possible.

Another example, you've argued that the lab leak might have happened because someone merely Dr. Shi "simply claimed she looked through her data and didn't find anything" regarding the hypothesis that the SARS-CoV-2 virus was created via gain of function research on the SARS-CoV virus. This is an especially odd argument given that you seem very dismissive of the idea that it might have been a spillover event involving one of several other much more closely related coronaviruses that are known to exist, or it might have an as of yet unidentified virus that SARS-CoV-2 spilled over to humans. The fact that there are many known coronaviruses that are much closer related to SARS-CoV-2 than SARS-CoV would seem to rule that possibility out.

What do you think is the most compelling evidence in favour of the hypothesis that the virus leaked from WIV?

You're dodging my question and the key issue here. If all the evidence I've posted isn't really evidence then what is the evidence for the natural spillover?

And I know why you don't want to answer that. It's because if you define the evidence I have posted as not really evidence, then none of the 'evidence' for a natural spillover event is actually evidence either.
 

The problem with all of that is that one is no closer to finding the source of COVID-19 regardless of similar viruses being found in other parts of Asia. How did two related lineages of COVID 19, well adapted to humans, show up in Wuhan at about the same time?

Flu is all over the planet in different species as well. That doesn't mean an identified strain could have come from anywhere. Identified strains, even new recombinant strains can pretty much be narrowed down to one or a couple potential sources.
 
Last edited:
1. You didn't quote me saying I said there was no evidence, which is what you're claiming I said. You even said I "agreed" to it. I did no such thing.

2. You quoted me specifically saying I wasn't arguing for either hypothesis, merely pointing out what I think are major flaws in your "key pieces of evidence"

If I'm not arguing either case, why would I be expected to offer evidence in favour of either case, you're the one arguing in favour of the lab leak hypothesis, it's incumbent on you to make the case in its favour, like I said, I'm just pointing out that the "key pieces of evidence" you're using in its favour aren't actually helping your case (like I said, some of them aren't even evidence, they're merely rather vague questions about the likelihood of either scenario).
Yes I quoted you and you are still dodging the question. What constitutes 'real' evidence?
 
It's all posted in the ******* thread, Belz. :rolleyes:

Moving on, it has become hopeless to find the truth for at least anytime in the near future.

China has published a non-peer reviewed paper saying they have evidence it was a bat to pangolin to human sequence somewhere well away from the WIV and they pushed it in their propaganda website: GlobalTimes. Of course a couple weeks ago the story was it started in the US and we're covering it up. They claim the sick WIV researchers in Nov is a complete fabrication (and given that was on Dump's watch, it may indeed be a bogus story). And the Chinese are very pissed off at Biden calling for an investigation.

In the meantime the right wing idiots on this side of the Pacific are going full bore with the lab leak hypothesis which for me anyway, muddies the water so badly one cannot see past one's nose.

It's going to take a long time for all the crap to get sorted out, probably more than a year.

I'll edit in a couple links, I switched computers and I have to look them up again.

Bizarre, I'm not getting the link I just read on my other laptop. I'll have to post the links later tonight.

Here's a Global Times link to a related study. There are lots of sources calling it a China propaganda site but then we have plenty of those ourselves. US only brings harms by making COVID-19 origin sourcing a thing of CIA

PZ has weighed in on there is no evidence side. Here it is: The “lab-leak” stuff is as imaginary as the Iraqi aluminum tubes
 
Last edited:
To late to edit but here are the links:

Global Times: New research from Wuhan Institute of Virology further refutes novel coronavirus laboratory leakage

They report on this published in Biorxiv Identification of a novel lineage bat SARS-related coronaviruses that use bat 2 ACE2 receptor

The comments in PZ's blog I wanted to post:
mistershelden
24 May 2021 at 11:51 am

Since we have not (yet??) found the zoonotic origins and we know:
1. The Wuhan lab had a very large collection of bat coronaviruses including the closest known to SARS Cov2, RaTG13
2. The Wuhan lab was infecting humanised mice and human cell cultures with these bat coronaviruses, including serial passage, to select for viruses which might be virulent in humans
3. The Wuhan lab was doing controversial gain-of-function experiments on viruses
4. There is no significant population of wild bats in Wuhan
5. The outbreak appears to have started almost next door to the lab
6. Accidental escapes of lab cultures are common
…it doesn’t seem a stretch to think that a lab escape is a pretty strong possibility.

I realise that Nicholas Wade is persona non grata around here, and for good reason, however his survey of the evidence around an accidental lab escape is thorough and measured:
https://thebulletin.org/2021/05/the-origin-of-covid-did-people-or-nature-open-pandoras-box-at-wuhan/
And the following article is a very good accompaniment:
https://www.currentaffairs.org/2021/05/the-stakes-of-finding-covid-19s-origins

And 2 posts down is the rebuttal:
raven
24 May 2021 at 12:12 pm

6. Accidental escapes of lab cultures are common

That isn’t the least bit true.
In fact, accidental escapes of lab cultures are very, very rare.

3. The Wuhan lab was doing controversial gain-of-function experiments on viruses

This isn’t true either.

https://www.factcheck.org/2021/05/the-wuhan-lab-and-the-gain-of-function-disagreement
Claimed by such notable kooks as Rand Paul and Tucker Carlson on Fox NoNews. Not credible sources at all.
This factcheck article is very long and I’m not going to post something no one will read.
“Perlman told us that he thought Fauci’s response in the May 11 exchange was correct — that no money was given for gain-of-function research.”

Stringing together false assertions without proof doesn’t make this claim proved or even probable.
What it does is make it yet again, another B grade conspiracy theory by crackpots.

I also ran across something else that was relevant and which I had seen before, when some of these papers say the pangolin coronavirus has a 99% match, they are really only talking about a match in a single segment of the virus.

ScienceAlert: Coronavirus Could Be a 'Chimera' of Two Different Viruses, Genome Analysis Suggests
On 7 February, 2020, we learned that a virus even closer to SARS-CoV-2 had been discovered in pangolin. With 99 percent of genomic concordance reported, this suggested a more likely reservoir than bats.

However, a recent study under review shows that the genome of the coronavirus isolated from the Malaysian pangolin (Manis javanica) is less similar to SARS-Cov-2, with only 90 percent of genomic concordance. This would indicate that the virus isolated in the pangolin is not responsible for the COVID-19 epidemic currently raging.

However, the coronavirus isolated from pangolin is similar at 99 percent in a specific region of the S protein, which corresponds to the 74 amino acids involved in the ACE (Angiotensin Converting Enzyme 2) receptor binding domain, the one that allows the virus to enter human cells to infect them.

I read that much earlier and then saw references to the pangolin coronavirus being a 99% match and I wondered why this discovery wasn't splashed across the headlines that the source animal had been found. It turns out it had not and the claim of a 99% match without saying what exactly a match meant in this context.

And earlier link posted here: Coronavirus Likely Did Not Jump To Humans From Pangolins, Genetic Analysis Reveals
Researchers at the Guangdong Institute of Applied Biological Resources examined whether pangolins could have served as that intermediate host by assembling the whole genome of a coronavirus that has been identified in three sick Malayan pangolins from two groups, which were likely to be smuggled for black market trade. The results indicate that the pangolin coronavirus is genetically similar to SARS-CoV-2 as well as a group of bat coronaviruses, but not likely its precursor.


I'm sure this was posted before but given the new wave of 'information' coming from both China and the right-wing politicians here, I think relevant papers written before the pandemic are going to be the most reliable.

2018: How China’s Bat Caves Hold the Secret to Preventing Epidemics
“Samples like these are of great value,” Luo later says from the comparative comfort of the WIV’s laboratories, where freezers store thousands of virus samples at minus 80 degrees Celsius. “When there is a new outbreak [of disease], we can search the database, trace where the virus originated, and find out why it occurred in that location.”

So far so good, just a databank of frozen specimens. Until you get to this part:
Zhou also studies the pathogenicity of emerging viruses — the rates at which they infect humans and other animals. “We test the virus on [isolated] human cells or genetically modified mice to see if they become infected,” he says....

By 8:30 p.m., Luo’s team has collected a full rack of swabs and bagged a dozen live bats for further testing back at the lab. Luo hopes that this time, the results will come out differently. His colleague points out a firefly bobbing up and down in the pitch-black cave. “It might be a good omen,” Luo says with a smile.
That is the WIV where Dr Bat-Woman said they had no live bats or virus cultures.
 
Yes I quoted you and you are still dodging the question.

What constitutes 'real' evidence?
I'm pretty sure this is the first time you've asked me "what constitutes real evidence" so I'm confused as to how I've been avoiding that question? :confused:

As I've already said, I'm not arguing any particular hypothesis for the origins of COVID-19, I've just yet to see anything that makes the lab leak hypothesis compelling.

What do you find compelling in terms of evidence regarding the lab leak hypothesis? I've pointed out what I think are major flaws in your "key pieces of evidence" regarding that hypothesis and you haven't actually addressed them.

Here they are again (I've numbered them for ease of discussion)

1. Is it really more likely when two, not one, ready to go lineages turned up in Wuhan at the same time?

2. Also there have been plenty of lab accidents so just saying a natural spillover is more likely really isn't much evidence at all.

3. What direct evidence of a spillover is there?

4. People keep repeating the pangolin as an intermediary source when there is less and less evidence for that hypothesis the closer it is looked at.

1. is not a piece of evidence that favours the lab leak hypothesis, it's a question about how likely the spillover event is

2. merely makes the lab leak hypothesis possible in light of any evidence of where COVID-19 came from

3. isn't evidence of the lab leak hypothesis, it's a question about the evidence regarding another hypothesis about the origin of COVID-19. Granting for the sake of argument that there is no evidence for a spillover event, does that give credence to any alternative hypotheses? No, especially if the competing hypotheses also lack evidence.

4. isn't evidence of lab leak hypothesis, it's a supposed flaw with one possible scenario of how COVID jumped from bats to humans.

Can you at least see why I don't the lab leak case compelling at all, if that's what constitutes "key pieces of evidence"? Where's the beef?
 
Improvement is always great. But what drives the need to spend money on it? Go read them...then come back and give an opinion.

If you want me to find them for you (if you cannot), I will. Just let me know!
If you know why the lab was improving their protocols, then why not just say so? If answer supports the lab leak hypothesis, then you could just come out with it.

Why so coy? :confused:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom