Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I believe you should say your leading hypothesis. It's not the leading hypothesis in the field. It's also not strictly a ruled out conspiracy theory as multiple people in the thread are trying to make it out to be. Unless you're part of the Chinese government the mainstream opinion seems clear: Lab leak is not the most likely explanation but it is not ruled out, still on the table, and still needs investigation.

It IS a conspiracy theory by any definition. The lab leak hypothesis is only possible of numerous scientists have conspired to hid the "real" source of the pandemic. Not just scientists mind you but nearly every scientist who specialized in the pandemic possibilities of corona viruses would need to be part of the conspiracy. It may not be impossible that the conspiracy actually exists but there is no evidence for it.

You are also underselling how unlikely scientists in the field think the lab leak hypothesis is. The WHO investigation team ranked it as on par with the hypothesis that Covid came to China from another country on frozen food. That is also "possible" in the same sense, it's really unlikely and doesn't fit the data but is "not impossible" and indeed carries the same recommendations for further investigation in the interest of leaving no stone unturned.
 
Your cause is a noble one but ... I'm not sure my statement requires a consensus.

I said, "it is a no brainer that the lab leak hypothesis is the most likely scenario."

No one has to agree, and obviously only one or two other people in this thread might. But your attempt to water down what I said is just that, an attempt to water down what I said and meant.

:)

So not only is it your opinion but anyone who doesn't agree is an idiot.

Very nice.

Seems to me you're not reading what I'm posting.

If I said that, post the quote.

SG - in your world "no brainer" means what, exactly? In mine it seems that you are saying that persons who do not agree with your position do not have brains. A reasonable inference is that you think they are idiots. stupid, fools, etc. Is it really so difficult to discuss the issue without insulting those that disagree with you?

In my layman's view there have been good, logical arguments provided here for both sides of the "lab" question, and I do not think the issue is anywhere near as settled as you are claiming. Your arguments have not yet convinced this "no brainer". And insults and anger do nothing to advance your position.
 
It IS a conspiracy theory by any definition. The lab leak hypothesis is only possible of numerous scientists have conspired to hid the "real" source of the pandemic.
No. Not all conspiracies are conspiracy theories. That's a pretty stupid mistake on this forum.

And how could you possibly know how many people it would take when we have no idea what, if anything, was covered up?

For crying out loud, lab leaks are possible with no one at all knowing it even happened. If they mishandled a sample somewhere along the way it could have leaked without anyone knowing they even found it.

I have no idea what's behind the rush to judgement on this board that isn't shared by the experts.
 
No. Not all conspiracies are conspiracy theories. That's a pretty stupid mistake on this forum.

And how could you possibly know how many people it would take when we have no idea what, if anything, was covered up?

For crying out loud, lab leaks are possible with no one at all knowing it even happened. If they mishandled a sample somewhere along the way it could have leaked without anyone knowing they even found it.

I have no idea what's behind the rush to judgement on this board that isn't shared by the experts.

Many people find it extremely difficult to back away from a prematurely stated position.
 
None of those are actually evidence of the lab leak theory, so if they're the "key pieces of evidence" then the case looks pretty weak in my opinion.

The first one is a question about the likelihood of a spillover event vs a lab leak, not evidence of the lab leak.

Also worth noting that the there was a recent paper in Nature that says this "key piece of evidence" strongly favors natural crossover and makes a lab leak improbably. To cite it as evidence for a lab leak when high profile peer reviewed papers say it's evidence against a lab leak borders on absurd.

The third is a question about the evidence of another theory, not evidence of the theory being proposed.

The pangolin as an amplifier host may be in question, but the pangolin CoV virus is much more closely related to SARS-CoV-2 than the SARS-CoV virus you say the lab was working on, which puts into question the relevancy of the lab working on SARS-CoV.

The most important thing about the Pangolin virus is that it's spike structure is genetically the closes yet found to the spike in Covid-19. There is also considerable evidence for at least one recombination event in that area of Covid-19's genetic code.

Originally it was thought that this spike structure was unique to Pangolins but subsequent studies have found similar spikes in close Covid relatives infecting a variety of hosts ranging from Japan to Africa. This extends the range of potential intermediate hosts dramatically to say the least. The paper I linked above, however makes a compelling case that host needs to have ACE2 receptors more like what's found in humans\pangolins that the ACE2 receptor found in bats.
 
I'm not arguing for either case, I'm impartial as to the source of the pandemic, just pointing out that a lot of the "key evidence" you're using in favour of the lab leak theory isn't evidence at all.

So it's not evidence in favour of either theory.

I quoted what I was referring to in my post, the thing I was referring to was the fact that lab leaks of infectious agents sometimes happen. Here's the quote in question:


How is this a "key piece of evidence" in favour of the lab spillover hypothesis? A "key piece of evidence" for the lab leak hypothesis is just you questioning that the fact that spillover events happen isn't good evidence in favour of a spillover event. If it's key evidence, then it's pretty weak sauce.

At best it's evidence that, absent anything else, the lab leak hypothesis is a possibility, it's definitely not evidence in favour of the hypothesis, anymore than the fact that sometimes people wear hats is evidence in favour of the hypothesis that I am wearing a hat.

I never said that there was evidence in favour of the pangolin as an amplifier, I even pointed out that it's been called into question, I was just pointing out that it's a stronger hypothesis than one hypothesis that you have offered in favour of the lab leak, that the WIV was studying SARS-CoV and there's no evidence that gain of function research might not have turned SARS-CoV into SARS-CoV-2. The pangolin CoV virus that sparked the hypothesis is much more closely related to SARS-CoV-2 than SARS-CoV is, it's pretty much a non-starter of an hypothesis that SARS-CoV might have been altered via gain of function research into a virus that is genetically much closer to several known wild bat coronaviruses (there are bat coronaviruses which are 90-95% genetically identical to SARS-CoV-2, whereas SARS-CoV is 79% genetically identical to SARS-CoV-2) than the original SARS-CoV virus. Virologists have construct a family tree of related coronaviruses and there's simply no way to have altered SARS-CoV via gain of function research so that looks like it belongs on another branch of the coronavirus family tree alongside several natural bat (and indeed, pangolin) coronaviruses.

I'm not arguing in favour of a natural spillover event, just pointing out that a lot of the "key pieces of evidence" you're arguing in favour of the lab leak hypothesis aren't actually evidence in favour of it at all, and some don't even qualify as pieces of evidence of anything, they're just vague questions about the possibilities of one hypothesis vs another.
To claim there is no evidence of anything is an odd position.
 
Originally it was thought that this spike structure was unique to Pangolins but subsequent studies have found similar spikes in close Covid relatives infecting a variety of hosts ranging from Japan to Africa. This extends the range of potential intermediate hosts dramatically to say the least. The paper I linked above, however makes a compelling case that host needs to have ACE2 receptors more like what's found in humans\pangolins that the ACE2 receptor found in bats.

The previous studies about the relations of SARS viruses that could emerge all focus on a single area of China as most dangerous- Yunnan- one specific cave. One rural area. This is where spillover WAS FOUND. People died. People were sick. Antibodies were detected.
Smaller events are all around China but this place was THE PLACE related to the original SARS outbreak and had all the ingredients for human infections with the ACE-2 receptor. They went there often, took lots of samples, bats, other mammals, humans. Took it all back to Wuhan.

No other animals tested came closer than the Chinese Horseshoe bat, but it was concluded that maybe there was one- because that does happen and it was not thought that bats viruses could "make" it direct or that the risk of those occurrences was very rare.
But they can. In this one place.
And I think the measured response of the paper is because the study was funded by aims trying to close the wildlife market trade and reduce risk (not a bad goal!). If you say the most documented human spillover danger of a new SARS outbreak is all in this one rural batcave, then it doesnt support the mission as effectively. If you read the papers, you will notice a bit of bias between the aim of the research (ie wildlife trade policy) and what they found (noting the high recombinations in a single cave) --which are not mutually exclusive since a single cave can certainly spread to other caves and local wildlife and humans and move from there- and there could be other unknown remote caves. All the human expansion and increased interactions with wildlife is, of course, a risk to look at.

There were a few scientific papers outlining surveys and serological results in this area. 10 years of it. At the end of the papers it is always a statement such as "this is concerning...more surveillance and research needed".

Here are two of them....but there are more.
2017:
Discovery of a rich gene pool of bat SARS-related coronaviruses provides new insights into the origin of SARS coronavirus

As a whole, our findings from a 5-year longitudinal study conclusively demonstrate that all building blocks of the pandemic SARS-CoV genome are present in bat SARSr-CoVs from a single location in Yunnan. The data show that frequent recombination events have happened among those SARSr-CoVs in the same cave. While we cannot rule out the possibility that similar gene pools of SARSr-CoVs exist elsewhere, we have provided sufficient evidence to conclude that SARS-CoV most likely originated from horseshoe bats via recombination events among existing SARSr-CoVs. In addition, we have also revealed that various SARSr-CoVs capable of using human ACE2 are still circulating among bats in this region. Thus, the risk of spillover into people and emergence of a disease similar to SARS is possible. This is particularly important given that the nearest village to the bat cave we surveyed is only 1.1 km away, which indicates a potential risk of exposure to bats for the local residents. Thus, we propose that monitoring of SARSr-CoV evolution at this and other sites should continue, as well as examination of human behavioral risk for infection and serological surveys of people, to determine if spillover is already occurring at these sites and to design intervention strategies to avoid future disease emergence.

2019:
Human-animal interactions and bat coronavirus spillover potential among rural residents in Southern China

This study found serological evidence for bat-borne coronavirus transmission to people. Direct contact with bats was not identified as a risk factor. However, self-reported severe acute respiratory infection (SARI) and/or influenza-like illness (ILI) was linked to human interaction with other wildlife and livestock, suggesting that there may be other zoonotic exposures leading to clinical illness in these populations.

The low levels of sero-positivity found in the study could reflect a number of factors: 1) the rarity of spillover and bat-to-human transmission, as has been reported for other virus-host systems [[50], [51], [52], [53], [54]]; 2) the use of a snowball technique for sample selection that could have biased the population sampled; 3) the limited diversity of CoVs that this study tested for; 4) the possibility that these infections cause high mortality rates and therefore the number of survivors and number of seropositive people is low, although this seems unlikely because the mortality rate from SARS was >10% during an outbreak that included hospital exposure and therefore likely high infectious doses [55,56]; and 5) that antibodies to these viruses wane rapidly in humans. The latter hypothesis is supported by findings that antibodies to SARS decline rapidly (2–3 years) after illness [57]. Expanding this approach to a larger population, using a longitudinal (repeated sampling) approach, and targeting people who are in the higher-risk categories identified here may provide a larger number of sero-positives and more critical information on the driving factors of viral spillover. However, despite the small sample sizes, this study suggests that there are a substantial number of people in rural Southern China who are exposed to bat-borne viruses, and that exposure likely occurs through the daily or normal practices of rural communities, rather than specific high-risk behaviours (e.g. wild animal hunting). Considering the proven potential of some SARSr-CoVs currently circulating in bats in southern China, to infect human cells, cause clinical signs in humanized mouse models, and lead to infections that cannot be treated with monoclonal therapies effective against SARS-CoV [[58], [59], [60]], this represents a clear and present danger to our biosafety and public health. Further studies to determine the relationship between SARSr-CoV and HKU10-CoV exposure and illness in people may help elucidate this risk and provide critical mitigation strategies.
 
Last edited:
It IS a conspiracy theory by any definition. The lab leak hypothesis is only possible of numerous scientists have conspired to hid the "real" source of the pandemic. Not just scientists mind you but nearly every scientist who specialized in the pandemic possibilities of corona viruses would need to be part of the conspiracy. It may not be impossible that the conspiracy actually exists but there is no evidence for it.

You are also underselling how unlikely scientists in the field think the lab leak hypothesis is. The WHO investigation team ranked it as on par with the hypothesis that Covid came to China from another country on frozen food. That is also "possible" in the same sense, it's really unlikely and doesn't fit the data but is "not impossible" and indeed carries the same recommendations for further investigation in the interest of leaving no stone unturned.

The position of said scientists was heavily influenced by Daszak and his company early in the pandemic. A few of said scientists signed a letter that ruling out the lab accident was premature. Over time more and more said scientists have questioned the early declaration the lab accident was unlikely. The news organizations and Facebook have withdrawn their early positions and now say the lab accident needs to be considered.

As for the conspiracy, only the Chinese government, the scientists at the WIV who are controlled by the Chinese government, and Daszak would need to be in on the coverup.

I know some people think the scientists in China must be just like scientists here and would speak truth to power as the saying goes. But that is not true. Today is the 31st anniversary of Tiananmen Square massacre of students by the Chinese army. Any protestors face 5 years in prison.

Hong Kong had been the last place on Chinese soil where the June 4, 1989, event was publicly commemorated, and tens of thousands of people gathered in Victoria Park in past years to honor the victims who died when China's military put down student-led pro-democracy protests.

In the Beijing square on Friday morning, security was increased and police checked identities of pedestrians while tour buses shuttled Chinese tourists onto the square as on any other day. ...

Law also told reporters police had arrested a 36-year-old woman from the Hong Kong Alliance, as well as a 20-year-old food delivery man for advertising and publicizing an unauthorized assembly on their social media accounts even after the vigil was banned.

The alliance confirmed the arrest of its vice chair, Chow Hang Tung, on Friday morning.
Does that sound like a country where scientists could freely go against the government's position on something like a lab accident at the WIV?

That there is a conspiracy to cover up a lab accident of such magnitude is certainly well within the realm of possibilities.
 
No. Not all conspiracies are conspiracy theories. That's a pretty stupid mistake on this forum.

And how could you possibly know how many people it would take when we have no idea what, if anything, was covered up?

All theories that involve a conspiracy to cover something up are conspiracy theories. This is true whether the conspiracy is real or not. In this case there is no evidence the conspiracy is real.
And how could you possibly know how many people it would take when we have no idea what, if anything, was covered up?

If it is real it would need to involve nearly every scientist in the world looking to identify Corona viruses with Pandemic potential. For a Covid-19 proximal ancestor to be in the lab in the first place it would need to be sampled and catalogued, and this catalogue is widely available to many researchers around the world.

As it stands now, however, scientists Peter Daszek are being deemed "not trustworthy" simply by virtue of having a relationship with the lab and\or the WiV. Keep in mind that his lab is the global center for pandemic Coronavirus research, there are no true experts on Pandemic coronaviruses who don't have some connection to it. The whole field is effectively under attack just when their expertise is needed most.

For crying out loud, lab leaks are possible with no one at all knowing it even happened. If they mishandled a sample somewhere along the way it could have leaked without anyone knowing they even found it.

There has never been a novel virus pandemic created by a lab leak. natural crossovers on the other hand are common not just in humans but all across nature.

I have no idea what's behind the rush to judgement on this board that isn't shared by the experts.

I'm not sure what experts you are referring to but the peer reviewed literature makes it clear what virologists think happened. Being willing to see low probability alternative theories like cold food or a lab leak investigated does not mean they are supported by credible evidence.
 
The previous studies about the relations of SARS viruses that could emerge all focus on a single area of China as most dangerous- Yunnan- one specific cave. One rural area. This is where spillover WAS FOUND. People died. People were sick. Antibodies were detected.

Not quite. A cave was identified with viruses that contains all the elements of SARS but the complete virus itself wasn’t found. The direct ancestor, the one that passed it to humans, was found in Civet cats in a live animal market. The Civets probably got it from bats with a connection to the suspect cave. Unfortunately the "stealth" nature of Covid-19 means that by the time scientists started looking at live animal markets any infected animals would have been long gone.

Also worth noting that the Chinese scientist who tracked down the cave is one of the people who would need to be helping cover up the hypnotized lab leak. Real scientists are being harmed, and real science is being harmed by these unsubstantiated claims of a lab leak and subsequent cover-up.

Antibodies were detected.

Covid reactive antibodies have been found in wild bats and wild pangolins in Thailand. Give the wide range of close Covid relatives this may not mean the antibodies were generated in response to Covid's proximal ancestor though.
 
SG - in your world "no brainer" means what, exactly? In mine it seems that you are saying that persons who do not agree with your position do not have brains. A reasonable inference is that you think they are idiots. stupid, fools, etc. Is it really so difficult to discuss the issue without insulting those that disagree with you?

In my layman's view there have been good, logical arguments provided here for both sides of the "lab" question, and I do not think the issue is anywhere near as settled as you are claiming. Your arguments have not yet convinced this "no brainer". And insults and anger do nothing to advance your position.
It means there is a preponderance of evidence. That doesn't mean anyone not recognizing it is an idiot anymore than people who don't know how to cook are idiots.

Now people who can't see that Dump is mentally ill after all this time I might call idiots.

Because it offended so many people I shall refrain from speaking those particular thoughts for the moment.
 
Many people find it extremely difficult to back away from a prematurely stated position.
IMO that is a huge part of what is going on. And when you have an editorial by an It Starts with a Bang blogger claiming there is no evidence, it's easy for people to confirm their initial POV.

I feel the need to define evidence here. I keep pointing out what the evidence is only to be denied that is evidence. Oddly enough JesseCuster agreed there is no evidence for either hypothesis using the definition that none of the evidence for a lab accident is actually evidence.
 
Also worth noting that the there was a recent paper in Nature that says this "key piece of evidence" strongly favors natural crossover and makes a lab leak improbably. To cite it as evidence for a lab leak when high profile peer reviewed papers say it's evidence against a lab leak borders on absurd.
I'm sorry, which "key piece of evidence" is that?


The most important thing about the Pangolin virus is that it's spike structure is genetically the closes yet found to the spike in Covid-19. There is also considerable evidence for at least one recombination event in that area of Covid-19's genetic code.

Originally it was thought that this spike structure was unique to Pangolins but subsequent studies have found similar spikes in close Covid relatives infecting a variety of hosts ranging from Japan to Africa. This extends the range of potential intermediate hosts dramatically to say the least. The paper I linked above, however makes a compelling case that host needs to have ACE2 receptors more like what's found in humans\pangolins that the ACE2 receptor found in bats.
the pangolin crossover is an early hypothesis which has been moved to the bottom of possible scenarios for a number of reasons. The most important reason being the bat SARS-CoV group of viruses circulating in horseshoe bats in the caves in Yunnan is more closely related to COVID-19 and there are all the elements needed for a bat to human crossover without an intermediary species including the event a few years ago where 6 people working in the caves developed a coronavirus pneumonia.

But there is still the problem that no closely related virus in bats, or pangolins for that matter, have been found.
 
Last edited:
The most important reason being the bat SARS-CoV group of viruses circulating in horseshoe bats in the caves in Yunnan is more closely related to COVID-19

Eh? No it hasn't. The number of potential intermediate hosts has increased beyond pangolins, but pangolins themselves remain a leading candidate.

The most important reason being the bat SARS-CoV group of viruses circulating in horseshoe bats in the caves in Yunnan is more closely related to COVID-19

You have it completely backwards. The search for the proximal ancestor has increased to a vast area, it has NOT been narrowed down to these caves. In fact the inability to find anything more closely related to RaTG13 despite extensive sampling seems to be ruling out these caves.

Close Covid relatives have been identified ranging from Japan to Africa. The closest genetic match for the spike that allows Covid to enter human cells still comes from a Pangolin virus in Thailand.
 
... For a Covid-19 proximal ancestor to be in the lab in the first place it would need to be sampled and catalogued, and this catalogue is widely available to many researchers around the world.
Do you have evidence for this? Because early on the Chinese government removed access to much of the WIV research.


... As it stands now, however, scientists Peter Daszek are being deemed "not trustworthy" simply by virtue of having a relationship with the lab and\or the WiV. Keep in mind that his lab is the global center for pandemic Coronavirus research, there are no true experts on Pandemic coronaviruses who don't have some connection to it. The whole field is effectively under attack just when their expertise is needed most.
This misrepresents why Daszak's conclusions are suspect. He steered the investigation away from the WIV early on and it was very successful. Now it is coming out just how much the early hypotheses were distorted by Daszak's actions. There is now a recognition of this matter and people who initially accepted Daszak's view have retracted their early positions.


... There has never been a novel virus pandemic created by a lab leak. natural crossovers on the other hand are common not just in humans but all across nature.
COVID-19 is not as novel as you seem to think.


... I'm not sure what experts you are referring to but the peer reviewed literature makes it clear what virologists think happened. Being willing to see low probability alternative theories like cold food or a lab leak investigated does not mean they are supported by credible evidence.
You are out of date here. Maybe you should look at the recent changed POVs.
 
Not quite. A cave was identified with viruses that contains all the elements of SARS but the complete virus itself wasn’t found. The direct ancestor, the one that passed it to humans, was found in Civet cats in a live animal market. The Civets probably got it from bats with a connection to the suspect cave. Unfortunately the "stealth" nature of Covid-19 means that by the time scientists started looking at live animal markets any infected animals would have been long gone.
Fascinating how you've built this story up by adding some elements that make it work for you.

Also worth noting that the Chinese scientist who tracked down the cave is one of the people who would need to be helping cover up the hypnotized lab leak. Real scientists are being harmed, and real science is being harmed by these unsubstantiated claims of a lab leak and subsequent cover-up.
Did you mean hypothesized? But as to the paragraph, yeah, China's authoritarian government is like that.

Who would be harmed if the truth turned out to be a lab accident? China, Dr Shi and her colleagues, Daszak... Think about it.


Covid reactive antibodies have been found in wild bats and wild pangolins in Thailand. Give the wide range of close Covid relatives this may not mean the antibodies were generated in response to Covid's proximal ancestor though.
I already addressed this.
 
Eh? No it hasn't. The number of potential intermediate hosts has increased beyond pangolins, but pangolins themselves remain a leading candidate.

You have it completely backwards. The search for the proximal ancestor has increased to a vast area, it has NOT been narrowed down to these caves. In fact the inability to find anything more closely related to RaTG13 despite extensive sampling seems to be ruling out these caves.

Close Covid relatives have been identified ranging from Japan to Africa. The closest genetic match for the spike that allows Covid to enter human cells still comes from a Pangolin virus in Thailand.

You aren't keeping up with current discoveries.
 
If never claimed that, did I? If I did, please link the post where I said there was no evidence of anything.

You didn't actually address anything I said.
This was the exchange:
Skeptic Ginger said:
And there is no evidence of a natural spillover using these definitions.
Jesse said:
I'm not arguing for either case, I'm impartial as to the source of the pandemic, just pointing out that a lot of the "key evidence" you're using in favour of the lab leak theory isn't evidence at all.

Please tell me which hypothesis has any evidence at all and what that evidence is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom