Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, some interesting emails have turned up in Fauci correspondence.
(was this a hack of some kind or a FOI request? - sorry, not paid attention to that side of things)

There are some emails between Kristian Andersen, Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins.

It looks like Andersen was asked whether or not he thought the virus looked engineered in some way.

Andersen says that mostly it looks natural but there are some areas which he finds odd and that his team would look into it.

I presume that they did this then came to the conclusion it was natural.

Link

...
This is an interesting reply in that exchange: And it only took three days to go from "we all find the genome inconsistent with evolution" to "crackpot theories of this virus somehow engineered", "fringe theories", "conspiracy theorists".

What an epiphany! Then overnight became evangelists for zoonosis, slayers of heretics.
 
Ran across this group called "D.R.A.S.T.I.C."

https://drasticresearch.org/

A motley group that seemed to have come together organically looking for evidence of a lab leak. Featured in the Vanity Fair article.

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/202...inside-the-fight-to-uncover-covid-19s-origins

I haven't dived into the lab leak hypothesis but it's always seemed possible due to the proximity to Wuhan and my father's experiences as a bacteriologist in a state DOH lab. But I'm not anywhere near informed enough to have a strong opinion.
 

What Andersen says in that email is this:

"...I do wonder if we need to be more firm on the question of engineering. The main crackpot theories going around at the moment relate to this virus being somehow engineered with intent and that is demonstrably not the case. Engineering can mean many things and could be done for either basic research or nefarious reasons, but the data conclusively show that neither was done..."

In other words he is making the distinction that you yourself have called for:

1.) The bioweapon idea of it being deliberately made is the crackpot idea.

2.) The idea that it had been altered through, say gain of function, is NOT a crackpot idea.

But he also says that neither the crackpot idea, nor the non-crackpot idea are true. It is a natural virus.
 
Can you clarify what you are reading in to these statements I'll quote. I'll provide some information I think I have, please dispute me if you think I've got misinformation.
1.) The bioweapon idea of it being deliberately made is the crackpot idea.
I don't know of anyone suggesting bioweapon, so OK. But why do you point this out?

2.) The idea that it had been altered through, say gain of function, is NOT a crackpot idea.
Right. And I believe Fauci recently said that he is not convinced that the virus is natural so I believe this is still on the table but is currently considered less likely.

But he also says that neither the crackpot idea, nor the non-crackpot idea are true. It is a natural virus.
Right, But I'd like to point out two things. One is that this is his opinion and I don't know what the consensus is. I believe the consensus is that this is considered most likely but there is no agreement that it rules out other possibilities.

The second point is that natural origin doesn't preclude lab leak. If the initial infection was at the WIV then both natural origin and lab leak could be true. There is the possible, for example, that there specimen collection protocols aren't strict enough.
 
Last edited:
Can you clarify what you are reading in to these statements I'll quote. I'll provide some information I think I have, please dispute me if you think I've got misinformation.

I don't know of anyone suggesting bioweapon, so OK. But why do you point this out?


Right. And I believe Fauci recently said that he is not convinced that the virus is natural so I believe this is still on the table but is currently considered less likely.


Right, But I'd like to point out two things. One is that this is his opinion and I don't know what the consensus is. I believe the consensus is that this is considered most likely but there is no agreement that it rules out other possibilities.

The second point is that natural origin doesn't preclude lab leak. If the initial infection was at the WIV then both natural origin and lab leak could be true. There is the possible, for example, that there specimen collection protocols aren't strict enough.

I'll post a copy of the email, so that it might make more sense in context...

The idea that they collected the virus and it escaped without having been altered is of course possible. Many things are possible. But there isn't any evidence of that yet.
 

Attachments

  • Email Andersen.jpg
    Email Andersen.jpg
    61.4 KB · Views: 8
I'm afraid I don't understand, are you claiming to be Kristian Andersen?

No.

Sorry, I don't understand your confusion or what you want me to clarify. I posted the email that he sent which I quoted from and also which attracted the comment that Skeptic Ginger posted.

Why are you asking me if I am him?
 
Because I asked you for your thoughts on those opinions and then you simply cited his opinions as if they were necessarily yours.

My question was: "Can you clarify what you are reading in to these statements I'll quote."
 
Last edited:
RealClearPolitics: How Fact-Checkers Mishandled the COVID-19 Origin Debate
While the precise origin of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, remains unknown, several fact-checkers and media outlets found themselves in an embarrassing position when a theory they had previously dismissed as "baseless" gained new attention from scientists. That theory holds that the novel coronavirus did not originate from human contact with an infected animal, but instead was leaked - intentionally or otherwise - from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. ...

For months before elite opinion on the subject began to turn, fact-checkers, media figures, and social-media platforms dismissed the lab-leak theory out of hand while relying on questionable evidence.


As an example:
On Sept. 16, PolitiFact's Daniel Funke penned a polemical fact check of Yan's claim. He described the idea that COVID-19 originated in a laboratory as a "debunked conspiracy theory" whose exponents dissented from the "consensus of the scientific community and international public health organizations" on the natural origin of COVID-19. He argued that the virus's genetic structure precluded "the possibility that it was manipulated in a lab." Funke called Yan's claim "inaccurate and ridiculous" and awarded it the "Pants on Fire!" verdict. ...

Both PolitiFact and FactCheck.org added editor's notes to their pieces in May acknowledging that, contrary to their previous statements, the lab-leak theory could not be ruled out. PolitiFact went a step further and "archived" the original fact check, thus removing it from the site's database. "When this fact-check was first published in September 2020, PolitiFact's sources included researchers who asserted the SARS-CoV-2 virus could not have been manipulated. That assertion is now more widely disputed," the editor's note reads.


More reversals:
Many other outlets followed a similar pattern. As journalist Drew Holden has documented, Politico, Reuters, NPR, The Hill, BBC News, Business Insider, and Fortune magazine, among others, all minimized the idea that the virus leaked from a Wuhan lab as a baseless conspiracy theory, but all have now reversed course.
WA Po, CNN and the NYT can also be added to the list.


Nicolas Wade has been dismissed in this thread.
The lab-leak theory's newfound credibility is due in part to reporting by Nicholas Wade, a former science reporter at the New York Times. Wade, who was cited in PolitiFact's May explainer on the virus's origins, wrote a lengthy piece in Medium on May 2 arguing that media claims of a "scientific consensus" on the natural origin of the virus relied on questionable sources.

The lab-leak theory's newfound credibility is due in part to reporting by Nicholas Wade, a former science reporter at the New York Times. Wade, who was cited in PolitiFact's May explainer on the virus's origins, wrote a lengthy piece in Medium on May 2 arguing that media claims of a "scientific consensus" on the natural origin of the virus relied on questionable sources. He contended that two scientific groups' statements - one in The Lancet and another in Nature spearheaded by Dr. Kristian Andersen - were taken as evidence of a scientific "consensus" but were "not at first examined as critically as they should have been."


And this applies to the most recent posts in this thread in addition to others:
"The [Peter] Daszak and Andersen letters were really political, not scientific statements, yet were amazingly effective," Wade wrote. "Articles in the mainstream press repeatedly stated that a consensus of experts had ruled lab escape out of the question or extremely unlikely. Their authors relied for the most part on the Daszak and Andersen letters, failing to understand the yawning gaps in their arguments."


And look at this:
According to internal emails obtained by the public-health-transparency group U.S. Right to Know, the Lancet statement was organized and drafted by EcoHealth Alliance CEO Peter Daszak. ... USRTK also discovered that four of the Lancet letter's signatories had undisclosed affiliations with EcoHealth Alliance.

One relies on another who relies on another: it's turtles all the way down:
Both PolitiFact and FactCheck.org cited the Lancet statement as evidence of a supposed scientific consensus about COVID-19's natural origin, but neither mentioned Daszak's connection to the Wuhan institute.


Finally:
Fact-checkers should avoid the temptation to treat claims around scientific theories, which are by their nature opinions, as matters of plain and objective fact. Scientific questions are settled not through derision but through open debate and an honest examination of the evidence.
The evidence will provide the answers if people will honestly leave politics and dug in position biases out of the mix.

No matter how many times I say I think a particular hypothesis has more evidence than the others, I hear back in posts here that I have my mind made up. Yes, I am posting evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis and yes I did say it's a no-brainer that is the most evidence based hypothesis.

But the question is still open. At a minimum, no one should be asserting the now discredited claim (which is still being reported in opinions on the Net) that there is no evidence supporting the lab accident hypothesis. If you think that is a valid assertion, look at the link I've cited here.
 
Last edited:
Because I asked you for your thoughts on those opinions and then you simply cited his opinions as if they were necessarily yours.

My question was: "Can you clarify what you are reading in to these statements I'll quote."

I don't think I am "reading into" his comments. I am just stating them.

I honestly don't know what else to add.
 
What are the key pieces of evidence for a lab accident?
Is it really more likely when two, not one, ready to go lineages turned up in Wuhan at the same time?

Also there have been plenty of lab accidents so just saying a natural spillover is more likely really isn't much evidence at all.

What direct evidence of a spillover is there?

People keep repeating the pangolin as an intermediary source when there is less and less evidence for that hypothesis the closer it is looked at.​
None of those are actually evidence of the lab leak theory, so if they're the "key pieces of evidence" then the case looks pretty weak in my opinion.

The first one is a question about the likelihood of a spillover event vs a lab leak, not evidence of the lab leak.

The second one isn't evidence at all. The fact the a particular thing sometimes happens isn't evidence that it happened in any given circumstance.

The third is a question about the evidence of another theory, not evidence of the theory being proposed.

The pangolin as an amplifier host may be in question, but the pangolin CoV virus is much more closely related to SARS-CoV-2 than the SARS-CoV virus you say the lab was working on, which puts into question the relevancy of the lab working on SARS-CoV.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to believe at all that some laboratories are developing viruses as a potential weapon. We don't live in Resident Evil, after all. Any weapon must be controllable, otherwise, it will bring damage to its creators. I believe more that the virus mutated under the influence of permafrost thawing. We do not know what diseases were thousands of years ago. By and large, we do not know the thousands of viruses that animals and birds carry. It is not surprising that viruses mutate in order to survive in new carriers.
 
None of those are actually evidence of the lab leak theory, so if they're the "key pieces of evidence" then the case looks pretty weak in my opinion.

The first one is a question about the likelihood of a spillover event vs a lab leak, not evidence of the lab leak.
And there is no evidence of a natural spillover using these definitions.

The second one isn't evidence at all. The fact the a particular thing sometimes happens isn't evidence that it happened in any given circumstance.
How does this differ from claiming a natural spillover event is likely? It doesn't.

The third is a question about the evidence of another theory, not evidence of the theory being proposed.
I'm not sure which thing you are referring to.

The pangolin as an amplifier host may be in question, but the pangolin CoV virus is much more closely related to SARS-CoV-2 than the SARS-CoV virus you say the lab was working on, which puts into question the relevancy of the lab working on SARS-CoV.
An amplifier? Where's the evidence of that? If you have been reading the thread the pangolin as an intermediator has been discredited for a number of reasons.
Not enough of them around.

None have been found with anything close to a COVID 19 virus.

They're not farmed because it's hard to do so, they don't reproduce easily.

And no, there is no better fit to a pangolin coronavirus.​

Tell me which bit of evidence there is for the natural spillover event?
 
Last edited:
I don't want to believe at all that some laboratories are developing viruses as a potential weapon. We don't live in Resident Evil, after all. Any weapon must be controllable, otherwise, it will bring damage to its creators. I believe more that the virus mutated under the influence of permafrost thawing. We do not know what diseases were thousands of years ago. By and large, we do not know the thousands of viruses that animals and birds carry. It is not surprising that viruses mutate in order to survive in new carriers.
No one is arguing the bioweapn hypothesis. I'm not sure how your comments fit into the discussion we are having.
 
I don't want to believe at all that some laboratories are developing viruses as a potential weapon. We don't live in Resident Evil, after all. Any weapon must be controllable, otherwise, it will bring damage to its creators. I believe more that the virus mutated under the influence of permafrost thawing. We do not know what diseases were thousands of years ago. By and large, we do not know the thousands of viruses that animals and birds carry. It is not surprising that viruses mutate in order to survive in new carriers.
It is the issue that this virus occurred where it was being studied.

I wont track it right now, but poster Rolfe is a notable researcher and clinician.
When foot and mouth broke out she said to her mother how lucky it was it broke near a lab that could analyse and track.

Woops.
It came from the lab.

Rolfe has better recall of the facts....
 
And there is no evidence of a natural spillover using these definitions.
I'm not arguing for either case, I'm impartial as to the source of the pandemic, just pointing out that a lot of the "key evidence" you're using in favour of the lab leak theory isn't evidence at all.

How does this differ from claiming a natural spillover event is likely? It doesn't.
So it's not evidence in favour of either theory.

I'm not sure which thing you are referring to.
I quoted what I was referring to in my post, the thing I was referring to was the fact that lab leaks of infectious agents sometimes happen. Here's the quote in question:

Also there have been plenty of lab accidents so just saying a natural spillover is more likely really isn't much evidence at all.
How is this a "key piece of evidence" in favour of the lab spillover hypothesis? A "key piece of evidence" for the lab leak hypothesis is just you questioning that the fact that spillover events happen isn't good evidence in favour of a spillover event. If it's key evidence, then it's pretty weak sauce.

At best it's evidence that, absent anything else, the lab leak hypothesis is a possibility, it's definitely not evidence in favour of the hypothesis, anymore than the fact that sometimes people wear hats is evidence in favour of the hypothesis that I am wearing a hat.

An amplifier? Where's the evidence of that? If you have been reading the thread the pangolin as an intermediator has been discredited for a number of reasons.
I never said that there was evidence in favour of the pangolin as an amplifier, I even pointed out that it's been called into question, I was just pointing out that it's a stronger hypothesis than one hypothesis that you have offered in favour of the lab leak, that the WIV was studying SARS-CoV and there's no evidence that gain of function research might not have turned SARS-CoV into SARS-CoV-2. The pangolin CoV virus that sparked the hypothesis is much more closely related to SARS-CoV-2 than SARS-CoV is, it's pretty much a non-starter of an hypothesis that SARS-CoV might have been altered via gain of function research into a virus that is genetically much closer to several known wild bat coronaviruses (there are bat coronaviruses which are 90-95% genetically identical to SARS-CoV-2, whereas SARS-CoV is 79% genetically identical to SARS-CoV-2) than the original SARS-CoV virus. Virologists have construct a family tree of related coronaviruses and there's simply no way to have altered SARS-CoV via gain of function research so that looks like it belongs on another branch of the coronavirus family tree alongside several natural bat (and indeed, pangolin) coronaviruses.

Tell me which bit of evidence there is for the natural spillover event?
I'm not arguing in favour of a natural spillover event, just pointing out that a lot of the "key pieces of evidence" you're arguing in favour of the lab leak hypothesis aren't actually evidence in favour of it at all, and some don't even qualify as pieces of evidence of anything, they're just vague questions about the possibilities of one hypothesis vs another.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom