As the Fail spreads the unfounded lab leak theory, the notoriously far-left Forbes states quite plainly that the lab leak is CT:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/starts...onspiracy-theory-not-science/?sh=7f1dbc87dd8c
Sorry this is tl:dr but if you are really interested you will read all of my comments.
From your link:
... with the first major outbreak stemming from a wet market in Wuhan: the largest city by far in the Chinese province of Hubei.
Not where it started.
This is crap right here:
... despite the lack of any publicly available scientific evidence to the contrary ...
The author cites 9/11, the Moon landing, and climate warming faux hoaxes as analogies. They are not analogous but it's easy to go there to trash the lab leak hypothesis.
The other hallmark of conspiracies almost always involve some sort of guilt by association accusation.
Because you know, an outbreak in all of China that just coincidentally started next to the lab studying the very pathogen is mere guilt by association.
This is guilt by association:
claims that it was engineered as a bioweapon by the Chinese government, go back as far as January 26, 2020.
Given that is
not the leading hypothesis, it must mean all lab leak hypotheses must be the same. The author then spends three paragraphs discussing the bioweapon hypothesis.
He then makes this claim and honestly, where is the evidence supporting it?
... the obvious consensus opinion: that SARS-CoV-2 emerged naturally, likely through pangolins as an intermediary between bats and humans, infected its first humans in 2019, and found its way to the city of Wuhan, where it entered the greater human population and grew into the ongoing pandemic.
After presenting an unsupported hypothesis citing out of date information, the author then goes on to dismiss the following:
... there are some people for whom a few circumstantial facts stand out:
NAIAD funded EcoHealth Alliance, which in turn funded a study at the Wuhan Institute for Virology on research that could have added a spike protein, like the one found in SARS-CoV-2, into an ancestral bat virus,
the fact that leaks had occurred at labs before, and that the Wuhan Institute for Virology, the country’s only Level IV lab, was found to be following sub-standard protocols for a Level IV lab,
and the recent “bombshell” that three workers from the Wuhan Institute for Virology had the pneumonia-like symptoms of COVID-19 back in November of 2019, more than 4 weeks before the first official cases were announced and revealed.
Much further down in the article we come to this:
From the virus’s genome, we can robustly conclude that the mechanisms proposed for how this virus would have arisen in a lab are all wildly insufficient to explain its properties. From the case records of COVID-19 and the behavior of the disease, it’s likely that the first cases in Hubei province occurred as early as October of 2019, meaning that the alleged infections among Wuhan Institute of Virology workers could not explain the origin of the very first cases.
One, there is a pathway the virus could have evolved in the lab and there is no evidence of said pathway in the wild. Kind of biased opinion of the author.
Two, no one said the 3 scientists were the first infected and from the reports we don't know when their first symptoms started nor do we know how long the incubation period was.
Three, Oct is not the fixed date for the initial spillover. In fact the author of this piece himself claims it started elsewhere before arriving in Wuhan though there is no evidence of that either.
Then we have Dr Shi's denial anything like that existed in her lab.
The author claims the virus could have been circulating in mild cases before the outbreak. OK, then how is it the author claims it started in Oct? Cherry picking to support the paragraph du jour?
Indeed, in two-out-of-three simulations, the natural emergence of SARS-CoV-2 in humans would result in extinction of the virus before an epidemic ensued.

We know it emerged into a pandemic.
His most likely hypothesis has been discussed in this thread and among researchers cited: That of the virus jumping a number of times and dying out before becoming successful.
That still leaves a few problems. If that is the case, where is/are the closely related viruses? How did it not show up somewhere before Wuhan? And
how did it show up in Wuhan with 2 lineages both in Wuhan and both well adapted to human respiratory tract cells?
His next couple of paragraphs actually supports a lab virus though he claims it is evidence against a lab virus.
Finally the author asserts:
... there would have to be an enormous conspiracy. Dr. Shi must have been lying; other people in her group and at the Wuhan Institute for Virology must have been lying; people at EcoHealth Alliance must have been lying; affiliated researchers such as Peter Daszek must be lying;
For good measure he throws Dr Fauci in there which is ludicrous. He would have had no inside knowledge.
Could the people at the lab and Daszak all been lying? Absolutely. This is not the US or the UK. China controls very closely what its citizens are allowed to say and all of them, including Daszak have very good reasons to lie. They might be the ones held responsible. The authors believe that because these people were working to prevent such a pandemic they couldn't possibly have caused one.
The author says this about that:
It’s like imagining the world of Fahrenheit 451, where the “firefighters” are actually arsonists, except for virology: where the experts in pandemic prevention are actively trying to unleash pandemics upon the world.
Notice the blatant false narrative?

If it wasn't on purpose it must not have happened.
This doesn't support the natural spillover as the author claims either:
All of the studies support the same conclusion: that once the disease entered humans, it evolved from there, with a single entry point consistent with every one of the subsequent cases.
"It evolved from there" and "a single entry point" are contradictory.
Instead, the tactic we’re taking — accusing them of fraud without a shred of meaningful, direct evidence — showcases how thoroughly we’re letting fear and conspiratorial thinking cloud our judgment.
The Chinese have denied access to the information the investigators say they need. I don't know if I'd call it "fraud" (another false narrative in the piece), but there is a reason they aren't allowing anyone to see more than a small bit of information. You'd think they would want clear-cut exoneration of the WIV.
If you wanted to call for routine inspections, and the enforcement of sufficient safety criteria across the board, there are very few who would be opposed to that.
Few in the Western world, but that is not the same in China.
I'm sorry but this is pure crap:
But a call for a large-scale, outside investigation into Dr. Shi’s laboratory lacks the necessary evidence to motivate it. If any of the 18 scientists who signed the recent Science letter calling for such an investigation actually wanted to investigate the lab leak hypothesis in a scientific manner, they would simply write a research grant to do so. That’s how virology is routinely performed, and how scientific and professional misconduct in virology has been uncovered in the past.
We are supposed to think one can't ask for an investigation without evidence that one needs the investigation to get.
And more crap follows.
This is disappointing coming from a contributor to
Starts with a Bang. Note he's an astronomer, not a virologist or even a medical contributor to Science Blogs. I should see if I can still log on to Science Blogs to comment on this piece.