Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
A Lab leak still requires the virus to have been studied in a lab and for it's animal host to have been identified and brought to a lab. If this were the case we'd expect it to be relatively easy to find the animal host and for there to be data on the virus in existing research.

The explanation we are being given for why there is no data, no samples and no host identified is that there is a conspiracy to purge any related research from the record. At this point ANY lab-leak must have a conspiracy component to explain why there is no record of this virus ever being in a lab.

The WIV employees and students have made trips to the bat caves in Yunnan Province to collect specimens. This is well documented and pics have been posted of them collecting the specimens.

They claim they didn't collect any live bats but evidence has been posted in this thread that they indeed did.

Regardless of the live bats, research has been reported on (again there are links in this thread) where coronavirus was cultured in cells at the WIV.

At what point do you supposed the cultured coronavirus no longer resembles the direct samples initially collected?
 
The fact that China was studying a known pandemic risk tells us nothing, nor does the fact that the risk turned out to be real.
I'm not making sense of your point or you argument, can you clarify?

You seem to be saying that since we know WIV is a potential source of coronaviruses that it can't be the source of Covid and that doesn't make sense. I'm not getting what you think you're arguing against or arguing for here.

At this point it seems perfectly reasonable to be looking at WIV as the source of the virus. Do you agree with that?
 
Lets play spot the moving goalposts. There is NO evidence for work with Covid-19 at WIV nor anyplace else in the world.

OF COURSE the WIV has done work with coronaviruses. China has 1 BSL-4 lab dealing with human diseases and China is a hotspot for potential Corona virus jumps to humans. The possibility of a coronavirus in China jumping from animal to humans and causing a pandemic has been recognised for at least 2 decades. This work is central to the very existence of the WIV.

China was going to be researching it and that research was going to be conducted un Wuhan. The fact that China was studying a known pandemic risk tells us nothing, nor does the fact that the risk turned out to be real.
No one is moving any goal posts. :rolleyes:

You want to dismiss an awful lot of evidence with the wave of your hand claiming, 'yes but they weren't looking at COVID 19'. Well d'uh.

Once again it is claimed in this thread that the source of the pandemic has not been specifically tied to the lab. But it hasn't been specifically tied to a natural (ie not in the lab) crossover either! It's not yet determined where it first emerged. Neither hypothesis has been confirmed. Why are you dismissing one of the 2 hypotheses when neither has been confirmed?

Not quite 2 decades. SARS emerged in 2003. It was after that interest was sparked to look at the coronaviruses circulating in bats in the Yunnan caves.

Why do you believe that the fact the WIV was studying the very thing that became a pandemic in 2019 tells you nothing. The problem is not that the research was being done (that they were studying live virus notwithstanding), the problem is of all the potential places in China, the pandemic began, not where the bats were, but 1,200 kilometers away where the WIV was.
 
I'm not making sense of your point or you argument, can you clarify?

You seem to be saying that since we know WIV is a potential source of coronaviruses that it can't be the source of Covid and that doesn't make sense. I'm not getting what you think you're arguing against or arguing for here.

The fact that coronaviruses are studied there does not help narrow down the source of the virus. It was 100% guaranteed to be studying corona viruses so the fact that it was tells us nothing new

At this point it seems perfectly reasonable to be looking at WIV as the source of the virus. Do you agree with that?


It was suggested that the fact they study Coronaviruses WIV is evidence for a leak, but this isn't the case. The mere fact that something is possible doesn't mean the evidence will back it up nor does it mean we don't discard the hypothesis when evidence fails to come forward.

Eg 300 years ago it was "possible" that there was a large unknown hominid wandering around western North America. At least it was possible enough to justify some investigation. As evidence failed to come forward supporting the hypothesis it was discarded by most reasonable people.

"It's possible" isn't evidence and should not be treated as such.
 
Once again it is claimed in this thread that the source of the pandemic has not been specifically tied to the lab. But it hasn't been specifically tied to a natural (ie not in the lab) crossover either! It's not yet determined where it first emerged. Neither hypothesis has been confirmed. Why are you dismissing one of the 2 hypotheses when neither has been confirmed?

2 theories are not equal just on the basis of "not being confirmed".

One hypothesis is simple, common in nature and consistent will all the know facts. The other is more complex incredibly rare in comparison to the number of zoonotic crossovers that occurred and requires a cover-up in order to explain why there is no data in the lab about either the host r the virus.


Not quite 2 decades. SARS emerged in 2003. It was after that interest was sparked to look at the coronaviruses circulating in bats in the Yunnan caves.

Why do you believe that the fact the WIV was studying the very thing that became a pandemic in 2019 tells you nothing. The problem is not that the research was being done (that they were studying live virus notwithstanding), the problem is of all the potential places in China, the pandemic began, not where the bats were, but 1,200 kilometers away where the WIV was.

A direct ancestor to Covid 19 has not been found in the Yunnan caves, nor has it been found in any samples or data studied at the WIV. The longer and harder you look for something and don't find it the more likely it becomes it's not there at all. A direct Covid ancestor probabaly will not be found there. Wild animal farms in SE China and other countries in SE Asia look more promising at this point and have received far less investigation.
 
Last edited:
The fact that coronaviruses are studied there does not help narrow down the source of the virus. It was 100% guaranteed to be studying corona viruses so the fact that it was tells us nothing new.
It's a potential source. The fact that we've known it was a potential source even before the pandemic doesn't mean it's not a potential source, correct??

WIV is potential source for the virus. Do you agree with that??
 
The fact that coronaviruses are studied there does not help narrow down the source of the virus.
This is oddly accurate.

No, by itself it does not help "narrow things down". In fact, it adds one more place to look at (assuming you're weren't dense enough to not be looking there in the first place).
 
2 theories are not equal just on the basis of "not being confirmed".
You're right, the lab leak theory is supported by more evidence. :p

One hypothesis is simple, common in nature and consistent will all the know facts. The other is more complex incredibly rare in comparison to the number of zoonotic crossovers that occurred and requires a cover-up in order to explain why there is no data in the lab about either the host r the virus.

A direct ancestor to Covid 19 has not been found in the Yunnan caves, nor has it been found in any samples or data studied at the WIV. The longer and harder you look for something and don't find it the more likely it becomes it's not there at all. A direct Covid ancestor probabaly will not be found there. Wild animal farms in SE China and other countries in SE Asia look more promising at this point and have received far less investigation.



The Telegraph: Why the Covid Wuhan lab escape theory, dead and buried months ago, has risen again
One of the major problems with the zoonosis – bat jumping – theory was that coronavirus turned up oddly well adapted to infect the human upper respiratory tract. But if a virus had been altered to specifically infect humans it would make more sense, some argue.

A new unpublished research paper, seen by The Telegraph, shows that scientists were doing just that as early as 2008. The tests, known as "gain of function" experiments, were designed to get ahead of an emerging deadly virus.

In 2008, Dr Shi's group in Wuhan first demonstrated the ability to switch the receptor binding domains for bat and human Sars viruses, and by 2010 the Institute of Virology had embarked on "gain of function" experiments to increase the infectiousness of Sars coronavirus in humans.
By 2015, Wuhan scientists had created a highly infectious chimeric virus which targeted the human upper respiratory tract.

In 2018 and 2019, grants from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) in the US show that Dr Shi had applied to work on "virus infection experiments in humanised mice" using Sars coronaviruses to find out what changes could lead to a spillover event into humans.
Shortly before the first cases of coronavirus were reported, Dr Daszak gave an interview, saying the work had been going on for six or seven years, and warning that they had created "untreatable" Sars viruses which could infect humanised mice. ...
The Daszak interview is linked to in this thread.


BBC: Covid origin: Why the Wuhan lab-leak theory is being taken seriously
A team of WHO-appointed scientists flew to Wuhan earlier this year on a mission to investigate the source of the pandemic. After spending 12 days there, which included a visit to the laboratory, the team concluded the lab-leak theory was "extremely unlikely"....

A prominent group of scientists criticised the WHO report for not taking the lab-leak theory seriously enough - it was dismissed in a few pages of a several-hundred-page report.

"We must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data," the scientists wrote in Science Magazine.

And there is growing consensus among experts that the laboratory leak should be looked at more closely.

Even the WHO's own director-general, Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, has called for a new investigation, saying: "All hypotheses remain open and require further study."

And Dr Fauci now says he's "not convinced" the virus originated naturally.
That's a shift from a year ago, when he thought it most likely Covid had spread from animals to humans....
 
It's a potential source. The fact that we've known it was a potential source even before the pandemic doesn't mean it's not a potential source, correct??

WIV is potential source for the virus. Do you agree with that??

"It's a potential source of the virus therefor it's the source of the virus" isn't a sound logical argument. If you are going to call it a potential source then you need other independent evidence supporting it. That's the stage we're at in the discussion and thus far the supporting evidence is not just lacking, it's completely absent.


WIV is potential source for the virus. Do you agree with that??

At this point no I don't agree. It could have been considered one at first but the lack of supporting evidence has removed it from consideration IMO. I'd be open to new evidence, but with the evidence available this seems like an unlikely source at best.
 
"It's a potential source of the virus therefor it's the source of the virus" isn't a sound logical argument. If you are going to call it a potential source then you need other independent evidence supporting it. That's the stage we're at in the discussion and thus far the supporting evidence is not just lacking, it's completely absent. ...
:rolleyes:

Talk about confirmation bias. You just can't let go of this, can you.

From my previous post, how is this not the presence of evidence?
In 2008, Dr Shi's group in Wuhan first demonstrated the ability to switch the receptor binding domains for bat and human Sars viruses, and by 2010 the Institute of Virology had embarked on "gain of function" experiments to increase the infectiousness of Sars coronavirus in humans.

By 2015, Wuhan scientists had created a highly infectious chimeric virus which targeted the human upper respiratory tract.
In 2018 and 2019, grants from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) in the US show that Dr Shi had applied to work on "virus infection experiments in humanised mice" using Sars coronaviruses to find out what changes could lead to a spillover event into humans.
Shortly before the first cases of coronavirus were reported, Dr Daszak gave an interview, saying the work had been going on for six or seven years, and warning that they had created "untreatable" Sars viruses which could infect humanised mice. ...

Can you justify your assertion there is no evidence whatsoever given the above?
 
"It's a potential source of the virus therefor it's the source of the virus" isn't a sound logical argument.
Which I didn't make.

If you are going to call it a potential source then you need other independent evidence supporting it.
No I don't. Identifying as a potential is all you have to do identify it as a potential source. WTF is the matter with you?
 
Utter nonsense.

There are some coincidences, but no evidence.

Christ, I hope none of the people who have decided it came from the lab ever get on a jury.
I have decided it came from a lab, indeed weeks ago this thread was awash with sufficient proof.
Great thread you started thank you.
 
I am not sure what more evidence is needed to show that a lab manufactured virus escaped....
Your source doesn't show that. It's being looked in to is what your source says. Lie much? As if this thread needs more confusion.
 
Your source doesn't show that. It's being looked in to is what your source says. Lie much? As if this thread needs more confusion.
I don't view a source, but a deep body of evidence where a lab was designing a virus that escaped then spread.
A terrible accident and a criminal cover up that precluded timely steps to containment and international border precautions. This is an evil empire in stark view.
In my opinion.
 
Last edited:
I am not sure what more evidence is needed to show that a lab manufactured virus escaped with full knowledge of the Chinese and a desperate failed cover up by locking down Wuhan.
A malign superpower has finally been exposed.

Based on what? You've not linked to any evidence.

I have decided it came from a lab

I have decide it's a plague sent by Nyarlathotep.
 
Based on what? You've not linked to any evidence.



I have decide it's a plague sent by Nyarlathotep.
Fair point but I was responding to TA ridiculing those who had decided.
The correct term is concluded.
 
No, you had the right term to begin with. If you had actual evidence, then you could conclude.
Fair point again, but I went to a dissertation

https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/312209/conclude-vs-decide-in-ameng

I now think decide is wrong usage in any context in the debate.
It is also true to say that I can only conclude it was an escape from the lab if I am factually correct.
I believe that proof of one or other will be available when the Chinese cooperate fully.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom