Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm confused. How is the fact that COVID-19 is easily transmissible between humans evidence in favour of the lab leak hypothesis? :confused:

Because the virus first appeared ready to go, well adapted to human cells. Usually a zoonotic virus (from animals to people) enters the first humans without being a perfect match. It then has to get passed around a bit between humans before a well adapted version emerges. If that adaptation happened no evidence of it has been found.

SARS-CoV-2 is well adapted for humans. What does this mean for re-emergence?
Abstract
In a side-by-side comparison of evolutionary dynamics between the 2019/2020 SARS-CoV-2 and the 2003 SARS-CoV, we were surprised to find that SARS-CoV-2 resembles SARS-CoV in the late phase of the 2003 epidemic after SARS-CoV had developed several advantageous adaptations for human transmission. Our observations suggest that by the time SARS-CoV-2 was first detected in late 2019, it was already pre-adapted to human transmission to an extent similar to late epidemic SARS-CoV. However, no precursors or branches of evolution stemming from a less human-adapted SARS-CoV-2-like virus have been detected. The sudden appearance of a highly infectious SARS-CoV-2 presents a major cause for concern that should motivate stronger international efforts to identify the source and prevent near future re-emergence.


There is another relevant hypothesis, that said adaptions occurred within the bat population. It's been described as a 'generalist version' coronavirus and that's been posted about upthread.
 
It's not.

That which is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

I'm sticking with that plan until there's some...

Evidence!
So you didn't read the citation then. Why am I not surprised. :rolleyes:

Pro lab leak:
Ben Embarek said he and his fellow investigators didn't do a full audit of the WIV. The WHO team spent just hours at the institute — which isn't enough time to pore over files, databases, or freezer inventories. The institute's staff also did not share all of its records or safety logs.

That's why Tedros, Fauci, and many others are still calling for a full investigation of the lab.

Con
However, Jonna Mazet, an epidemiologist at the University of California at Davis, has worked directly with WIV researchers, including one of its prominent virologists, Shi Zhengli. Mazet told Insider the lab's records were above reproach.

"She is absolutely positive that she had never identified this virus prior to the outbreak happening," Mazet told Insider, referring to Shi's work.

Bottom line the WHO investigation was far from thorough yet came up with an assertion which would have taken a thorough investigation to come up with.
 
It's in the freaking link that I just read for the other poster who can't be bothered.

Dude, what IS your problem? I'm asking you for information because I find what you posted interesting and, if I'm going to use that in the future in discussions on this topic I'd like to verify that information. I'm not your opponent, here.

There's no link in the post where you said that, and I haven't read every post in the thread because it's a week-end and I have other things to do. So instead of acting like a jackass how about you answer my ******* request?
 
What do you mean "first appeared"? You mean "first analysed"? There might've been several generations of adaptation before that happened.
Can you provide the window for those "several generations"? Hint: the person you are quoting has provided that information several times.
 
Can you provide the window for those "several generations"?

What? I said there might have been. My point is that there's no reason to assume that the first victim was the first infected. How do we know how many persons exist in the chain until that point?

Did I beat up someone in your family in the past? What the hell did I do to earn your ire, here?
 
Oh, I don't know, look at the evidence??

Oh, you mean the fact that the virus transmits among humans? Or the fact that investigators couldn't perform a full audit?

Again, I have no idea why you're so aggressive. I've not insulted you or even argued against you in this thread. I asked you ONE SIMPLE QUESTION. If there are issues in your life right now, please refrain from taking it out on people here.
 
No. I don't mean that. Get a clue by reading the thread. You're asking questions that have been answered, asking for links that were just presented. Get up to speed on your own.

So you in fact have no evidence to support your claim. I'll treat it as such then. A shame. It was an interesting tidbit, and had you just posted the evidence you claim exists it would've actually been less of an effort than the tirade you went on.
 
So you in fact have no evidence to support your claim. I'll treat it as such then. A shame. It was an interesting tidbit, and had you just posted the evidence you claim exists it would've actually been less of an effort than the tirade you went on.
Whenever said evidence is posted, you ignore it and repeat your false assertion that no evidence has been provided.

You have yet to address this:
Could you describe short of finding the actual answer (animal jump or lab accident) just what it is you would consider as evidence?

And maybe address post #730 while you are at it.
 
Whenever said evidence is posted, you ignore it and repeat your false assertion that no evidence has been provided.

Critiquing something is not ignoring it. Remember you said that the investigators' inability to complete their audit is evidence for a lab leak?

EDIT: Also "said" evidence has not been posted since I made my request, so you're talking nonsense here.

You have yet to address this:

Actually I have addressed it, but you failed to respond.
 
Last edited:
Bottom line the WHO investigation was far from thorough yet came up with an assertion which would have taken a thorough investigation to come up with.

You really do need to grip on the "evidence" concept.

See my point made several times about Saddam and WMD.

I shall continue to await actual evidence.
 
I don't think asserting there is no evidence is "critiquing" it.

Nor is claiming there's some analogy here to GW Bush et al fabricating evidence there were WMDs in Iraq a critique.

There is simply no point in trying to have a discussion with either of you.
 
Last edited:
Bottom line the WHO investigation was far from thorough yet came up with an assertion which would have taken a thorough investigation to come up with.

Here's the thing, I think that you are beginning from an assumption that is not shared by the WHO scientists.

This is not a criminal investigation, but you are arguing as though you think it should be and one where the scientists at the WIV, and also at EcoHealth ought to be considered suspects who better have very good alibis.

On the other hand, the WHO scientists are approaching this from the point of view that exactly the things they have been warning is likely to happen, has happened.

There was an interesting point made by one of the people on the Garry podcast who said that back in 2018-2019, there had been a massive outbreak of swine flu that had led to a mass culling of pigs in China (and in Vietnam), and that this in turn had been a big boost for the wildlife farm trade.

With pork supplies dwindling as leading producer China and hard-hit Vietnam destroy huge numbers of hogs and tighten controls on shipments, prices have soared by up to 40 percent globally and caused shortages in other markets.

“This is the largest animal disease outbreak in history,” said Dirk Pfeiffer, a veterinary epidemiologist at the City University of Hong Kong. “We’ve never had anything like it.”

This would, then, have increased the possibility of a zoonotic virus emerging through the very mechanisms that people like EcoHealth have warned about.
 
I see lots of in-your-endo in both articles, zip-all in terms of facts. Let us make one thing clear to Islamists, Van Gelicals, GOP zombies and loose thinkers the world over: "Reason" is not, has never been, and will never constitute factual evidence, no matter the sophistry, "clear pointers", or "must be so's". Also, if someone hits a tree while drunk driving 10x and then hits a tree again, there is no evidence drunk driving was involved in the last incident until there is.

Could the virus have been designed? Possible. Fine, the notion may be entertained and examined. So far, no evidence.

There is no direct evidence of the person being drunk. But in examining the statistical probability of the person being drunk or not, the odds are higher if the person has previously done it 10 times as opposed to never. So it *is* evidence. The question is what weight to give that evidence.

The problem in this case is that the party most equipped to provide the factual evidence is the one least likely to willingly provide it.
 
Here's the thing, I think that you are beginning from an assumption that is not shared by the WHO scientists.
There are experts on both sides and in the middle as to where COVID originated.

Ex-CDC Director Robert Redfield believes COVID-19 came from Wuhan lab
“I’m of the point of view that I still think the most likely etiology of this pathology in Wuhan was from a laboratory — escaped,” said Redfield, who led the CDC during the height of the pandemic. “Other people don’t believe that. That’s fine. Science will eventually figure it out.”



This is not a criminal investigation, but you are arguing as though you think it should be and one where the scientists at the WIV, and also at EcoHealth ought to be considered suspects who better have very good alibis.
I never said anything like this.

I have said Daszak has a conflict of interest and his attempt to steer conclusions away from a lab accident is evident.

And while I'm at it, Garry has used the same biased language claiming the virus doesn't look designed.

"The adaptations that the virus has made to affect humans are actually very different than what you would expect if you were designing it using computational models in biological engineering.”

Virologist Robert Garry

To repeat, there are three hypotheses within the lab accident scenario.

1) The virus was constructed or designed. That's a non starter yet in Garry's language he repeats this hypothesis as if it is the only lab accident scenario.

#2) is the virus is a hybrid that developed in the lab and #3) is that the virus came to the WIV in specimens collected in Yunnan.



On the other hand, the WHO scientists are approaching this from the point of view that exactly the things they have been warning is likely to happen, has happened.
You are back to ignoring Daszak's conflict of interest.



There was an interesting point made by one of the people on the Garry podcast who said that back in 2018-2019, there had been a massive outbreak of swine flu that had led to a mass culling of pigs in China (and in Vietnam), and that this in turn had been a big boost for the wildlife farm trade.

This would, then, have increased the possibility of a zoonotic virus emerging through the very mechanisms that people like EcoHealth have warned about.
And yet the species responsible for the initial jump to humans still cannot be found.
 
And while I'm at it, Garry has used the same biased language claiming the virus doesn't look designed.



To repeat, there are three hypotheses within the lab accident scenario.

1) The virus was constructed or designed. That's a non starter yet in Garry's language he repeats this hypothesis as if it is the only lab accident scenario.

#2) is the virus is a hybrid that developed in the lab and #3) is that the virus came to the WIV in specimens collected in Yunnan.

All three of these are addressed in the podcast:

1) Garry points out the unlikelihood of that.

2) Garry points out there is no evidence of the virus being there, and the GoF assumption partly falls under 1 anyway. Garry talks about the unlikelihood of getting from, say, RaTG13 to SARS-CoV2. Some lab leakers are indeed making claims that Garry says are highly implausible. In fact, hypothesis #2 seems a convenient way of having your cake and eating it.

"They made the virus more transmissable in the lab"
"There is no good evidence for saying that the viruses we know of can be altered in the way proposed"
"I never said it was manufactured!"

3) Depending on how you argue it, it pretty much ceases to be lab leak. Are we saying they had the virus, and knew about it? Or are we saying that when the scientists went to Yunnan Province they came back with it on their clothes or caught it from a bat???

Because, as mentioned, that is hardly lab leak. It has nothing to do with the taking down of the database. It has nothing to do with the transmissability. In fact, it really has nothing to do with a lab leak, because all you are saying in this case is that a virus from the wild infected people...

This is theory that "William Shakespeare didn't write the plays - a different man also called William Shakespeare wrote the plays."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom