lomiller
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2007
- Messages
- 13,208
That's not how it works. Researchers took the data of a hundred or so genomes from patients diagnosed with COVID 19 in the months around Dec, 2019. (The details are posted in the cites upthread, the exact number of genomes investigated isn't critical to the argument.)
You claimed that the earliest know case didn't come from either of the markets in question. The technique you are describing here does not allow for such an identification. So one of your two claims MUST be wrong.
This kind of contact tracing wasn't done.
Wasn’t done and can’t be done. The case you referred to is just one of dozens perhaps hundreds of cases in China in early Dec. It’s not reasonable to expect the virus to still be confined to it’s point of origin 4-8 weeks after it crossed over into humans, so whether an individual case was directly connected to the market is irrelevant.
What individual cases mean nothing, the greatest number of cases would still be expected to be found in the networks connected to that crossover. IOW the employees and\or suppliers to the suspect markets.
No, the genome evidence does not support this number of cases in Sept 2019.
The case you referenced was from Dec 2019.
This discussion has nothing to do with a genetic trail. You made false claims that the distribution of the virus in Dec doesn’t support the crossover point to humans not being connected to market\markets.The genetic trail is very clear and this did not happen.
What turned out to be the case and it was backed up by the WHO Report is that the initial market cluster was consistent with a super-spreader event, not the initial crossover from an animal to people. 40+% of the earliest cases (earlier than the market cluster) had no connection to any animal market.
I don't recall the WHO report calling it a super spreader event and such an event isn't required for an outbreak. Even if the crossover happened in the other market all it takes is one supplier carrying it to the fish market where it spreads from worker to worker.
