Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's not how it works. Researchers took the data of a hundred or so genomes from patients diagnosed with COVID 19 in the months around Dec, 2019. (The details are posted in the cites upthread, the exact number of genomes investigated isn't critical to the argument.)

You claimed that the earliest know case didn't come from either of the markets in question. The technique you are describing here does not allow for such an identification. So one of your two claims MUST be wrong.
This kind of contact tracing wasn't done.

Wasn’t done and can’t be done. The case you referred to is just one of dozens perhaps hundreds of cases in China in early Dec. It’s not reasonable to expect the virus to still be confined to it’s point of origin 4-8 weeks after it crossed over into humans, so whether an individual case was directly connected to the market is irrelevant.

What individual cases mean nothing, the greatest number of cases would still be expected to be found in the networks connected to that crossover. IOW the employees and\or suppliers to the suspect markets.

No, the genome evidence does not support this number of cases in Sept 2019.

The case you referenced was from Dec 2019.

The genetic trail is very clear and this did not happen.
This discussion has nothing to do with a genetic trail. You made false claims that the distribution of the virus in Dec doesn’t support the crossover point to humans not being connected to market\markets.


What turned out to be the case and it was backed up by the WHO Report is that the initial market cluster was consistent with a super-spreader event, not the initial crossover from an animal to people. 40+% of the earliest cases (earlier than the market cluster) had no connection to any animal market.

I don't recall the WHO report calling it a super spreader event and such an event isn't required for an outbreak. Even if the crossover happened in the other market all it takes is one supplier carrying it to the fish market where it spreads from worker to worker.
 
How many cities with wet markets do you think are in China?

A lot, since a wet market is any market that has perishable items like meat, fruit or vegetables. Don't use the term interchangeably with live animal market. There is some overlap but they are not the same thing.
 
Skeptic Ginger claimed that Andersen had said two lineages had been found in Wuhan in Sept 2019. When I asked for this to be supported, she assumed bad motives on my part.

wrt multiple lineages, unless we quantify how much difference there is between them we can't infer anything. The earliest samples of the virus are still 4-8 weeks removed from the jump to humans. This could be plenty of time for the "lineages" to manifest.
 
This might be an interesting part:

On the question of evidence of transmission before Dec 2019:

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=1338

They agree that there probably had been transmission prior to Dec 2019.

The interesting thing is that some lab leakers are trying to have it both ways. They argue

Premise 1: that there was probably transmission going as far back as Sept 2019 (after all, that's when the WIV took down the database, right?).
There had to be transmission somewhere in order to have 2 lineages in the first known cases.

But then they also

Premise 2: try to rule out the market as the centre of the outbreak - "No, the first case in early Dec 2019 had no contact with the market. And 40% had no contact with the market!"
This came directly from the WHO report. It did not come from any "leakers" whoever they are.

Therefore, it started in the WIV.

But of course, if we accept premise 1, then we negate premise 2.
No, no and no, in that order.

The mere fact that the first known case had no contact with the market merely means that it wasn't the first case.
We know the first known case wasn't the first case.

The non-lab leakers clearly have no problem with that part because they agree about multiple lineages predating the "first case". Therefore the markets are back in play.
Two lineages and I'm not sure who you think has a problem with this.

However, let's be clear here: The paper by Garry cited the WHO report except some of his claims were not supported by the WHO report.
In particular the claim that all the cases were tied to at least one wet market in Wuhan.

Early appearance of two distinct genomic lineages of SARS-CoV-2 in different Wuhan wildlife markets suggests SARS-CoV-2 has a natural origin; Garry
The WHO report documented that early cases were not only linked to the Huanan market, but that other early cases were linked to different markets that sold wildlife or wildlife products. Among the first 168 diagnosed cases of COVID-19 in Wuhan with onset date prior to December 31, 2019 and a known history of exposure to wildlife markets 55.4% (93/168) reported such exposures. Of the 168 cases, 28% (47/168) had only been to the Huanan market, 22% (38/168) had exposure to another wildlife market and 4.7% (8/168) had exposure to the Huanan market and another market (Annex E2, Table 1 of WHO, 2021).
Maybe he didn't mean to imply that divvying up into various market exposures included all the known cases.

WHO Report
For those cases where the information was available, 55.4% had a history of recent exposure to a market:28.0% to the Huanan market only, 22.6% to other markets only, and 4.8% to both. 44.6% had no history of market exposure (see Fig. 24 and Annex E4). Cases with market exposure were more evident among the early cases but exposure to other markets occurred in the earliest cases as much as exposure to the Huanan market. The case reported with the earliest onset date (8 December) had no history of exposure to the Huanan market.
Page 95 has a chart of samples from the various locations:
Other markets in Wuhan* ... *The other markets were Dongxihu Market and Huanggang Center Market.
Only one sample collected was positive by RT-PCR so I don't see how that translates to all these other market-tied cases.



++++++
There could have been direct spillover from a bat without an intermediary.

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=2413
Yep.
++++++

Cold-chain theory:

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=2683

I get the impression that none of them think it is a good idea, and even if not true then not explanatory from where it comes from initially.

They give some explanation about why it is not crazy, but they think it is unlikely.
There was also concern of spread via frozen fish in NZ but I don't think that panned out as the most viable hypothesis.

+++++++

The elephant in the room: Fourth scenario: lab leak

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=3000


Marion says she asked why they took the database offline and says she was satisfied with the answer. Hmmmm...I didn't hear what the reason she said was.

Daszak also says he asks why they took down the database. Though he doesn't say what they answered.

+++++

Daszak says that if there is solid leads on people being sick then they should share it.

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=3657

Apparently there is nothing but vague hearsay right now.
There are other discussions of these issues in this thread.
 
To clear up more misconceptions about what I've said:

You claimed that the earliest know case didn't come from either of the markets in question. The technique you are describing here does not allow for such an identification. So one of your two claims MUST be wrong.
[sidenote] For the record I corrected the number of genomes in the initial analysis which involved 27 full genomes and one partial genome, not 100 or so. [/sidenote]

Of the initially identified cases, many had an onset that preceded the first recognized cluster that occurred at the Wuhan Seafood Market. That is one data point.

The genome analysis which was used to walk the time clock back to the estimated true first cases is not something that identified the first known patients. The collected virus, later identified by the viral genome of the cases in the first patients was the starting place, not the endpoint. That is a second data point.

No one has of yet identified where the first crossover occurred. It could have been in a bat in Yunnan, a wild animal in some wet market somewhere in China, the WIV, or even another lab in Wuhan (I believe there are 2 other labs).

The virus had to have circulated to some extent prior to the walked back clock which found 2 lineages.

The WHO found no evidence of any outbreak prior to the one in Dec in Wuhan. I don't believe they had conclusively ruled the possibility out.


Wasn’t done and can’t be done. The case you referred to is just one of dozens perhaps hundreds of cases in China in early Dec. It’s not reasonable to expect the virus to still be confined to it’s point of origin 4-8 weeks after it crossed over into humans, so whether an individual case was directly connected to the market is irrelevant.

What individual cases mean nothing, the greatest number of cases would still be expected to be found in the networks connected to that crossover. IOW the employees and\or suppliers to the suspect markets.
These cases were identified from virus RNA collected from the nasopharynx or some other relevant site in the initial COVID 19 positive patients.

They weren't identified via contact tracing.

The case you referenced was from Dec 2019.

This discussion has nothing to do with a genetic trail. You made false claims that the distribution of the virus in Dec doesn’t support the crossover point to humans not being connected to market\markets.
:boggled:

What I said was that in the WHO report not all of the initially identified cases had a wet market connection. That is what the report said, it didn't originate from me. See the quote from the WHO Report in my above post.


I don't recall the WHO report calling it a super spreader event and such an event isn't required for an outbreak. Even if the crossover happened in the other market all it takes is one supplier carrying it to the fish market where it spreads from worker to worker.
The initial cluster of cases in the Wuhan Seafood Market was initially though to be the beginning of the pandemic. However when more cases came to light that occurred earlier than the market cluster, it was clear the market was not where the initial animal to human event occurred. Or at least the initial cluster was not the true initial cases.

Multiple sources have since hypothesized that rather than the initial event, a super-spreader event occurred at the Wuhan market.
 
Watch the TWiV video up thread. They talk about this being perfectly normal reasonable research.
Well yeah, that was the belief.

If it turns out they caused the thing they were trying to prevent, that belief needs to be seriously reevaluated.

And for the record, researchers doing this kind of work have been cautioned time and time again that they were playing with fire.
 
A lot, since a wet market is any market that has perishable items like meat, fruit or vegetables. Don't use the term interchangeably with live animal market. There is some overlap but they are not the same thing.
It's pretty common for live animals to be for sale at all of these markets. Often the customer buys the live animal and it is slaughtered on the spot for the customer.

We know this not just from SARS but also because the markets have been the source of more than one influenza outbreak. Also risky is anywhere people come in close contact with domestic animals. In 2009 the flu variant arose and crossed over to people from a pig farm in Mexico. Wild birds spread highly pathogenic flu strains to domestic birds (ducks and poultry) along their migration routes. That can result in the wide scale culling of those stocks.
 
wrt multiple lineages, unless we quantify how much difference there is between them we can't infer anything. The earliest samples of the virus are still 4-8 weeks removed from the jump to humans. This could be plenty of time for the "lineages" to manifest.
Where do you think these samples were from?

Those lineages (2) are both human coronaviruses. If we could trace the lineages back to the source, we would have the answer.

We have the virus samples and they were collected from patients in Wuhan in Dec 2019. Genetic clocks are then used to work backward to the theoretical most common ancestor in the human pandemic.

There's lots of discussion in the cited papers that there was an abrupt introduction into the human population.
 
Last edited:
Where do you think these samples were from?

Those lineages (2) are both human coronaviruses. If we could trace the lineages back to the source, we would have the answer.

Again, without quantifying how different these "lineages" are it's impossible to say if there is anything relevant or even remotely interesting in this factoid.


The distinction of human coronavirus is nonsense wrt this discussion. We don't have the immediate animal ancestor so we don't know what genetic differences characterise "human" from it's immediate animal predecessor.
 
We have the virus samples and they were collected from patients in Wuhan in Dec 2019. Genetic clocks are then used to work backward to the theoretical most common ancestor in the human pandemic.
Didn't you just agree a day or two ago that this MRCA wouldn't have to be in the human pandemic??
 
Last edited:
Again, without quantifying how different these "lineages" are it's impossible to say if there is anything relevant or even remotely interesting in this factoid.

The distinction of human coronavirus is nonsense wrt this discussion. We don't have the immediate animal ancestor so we don't know what genetic differences characterise "human" from it's immediate animal predecessor.
When you read what the researchers say about the research they conducted, get back to me.

You seem to think I'm making claims when I'm essentially posting what is in the citations.
 
Didn't you just agree a day or two ago that this MRCA wouldn't have to be in the human pandemic??
No, not me. Or you are misinterpreting something I posted.

Researchers, plural, used the rate of mutation (nucleotide substitution) and calculated when the COVID genomes we have probably first appeared.

It was recent, 2 separate lineages diverged early in the process. Summarized in one of the papers: either the human adaptation had some early adjusting to get a good match or the adjusting took place in the source of the crossover. We have not found the source from which the virus jumped. If we did we'd know if it was ready-adapted to human cells or sputtered about for a short time in people before becoming adapted.

It does seem to be the evidence-supported case that the cross-over was abrupt, near to the time the cases appeared, and well adapted or quickly adapted to human cells.

There is as of yet no evidence of any outbreaks anywhere except in Wuhan with the exception 6 miners were infected directly from bats a few years ago in Yunnan where they worked in caves there. There is good evidence the virus might have crossed over from bats to humans directly without need of an intermediary species. That doesn't rule an intermediary species out.

None of the bat viruses collected in Yunnan are a direct match to COVID 19. No intermediary species has been found.

I won't repeat the evidence for a lab cultured virus because people misunderstand me when I do.
 
So you think the human adaptation happened in humans or what?

I was repeating what was in the citations.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7095063/
Instead, we propose two scenarios that can plausibly explain the origin of SARS-CoV-2: (i) natural selection in an animal host before zoonotic transfer; and (ii) natural selection in humans following zoonotic transfer. We also discuss whether selection during passage could have given rise to SARS-CoV-2.

https://virological.org/t/clock-and-tmrca-based-on-27-genomes/347
We are starting to see more structure in the tree and overall the genetic data is highly suggestive of a single-point introduction into the human population followed by sustained human-to-human transmission. This introduction was likely via either a single infected animal or a small cluster of recently infected animals directly into either a single human individual or a small cluster of human individuals. All subsequent cases are the result of human-to-human transmission with no further evidence of zoonotic transmissions.

The adaptation to humans was established right out of the gate.

Contrast this with highly pathogenic avian flu H5N1 which has been sputtering along for a couple decades now without becoming an efficient human pathogen.
 
...none exists.

There is speculation, no evidence. If there were evidence, the case would be closed already.

Have you read Capsid's responses?
Here we go again, denying there is any evidence supporting the lab leak when the thread is full of such evidence.

As for Capsid, yes I have been reading his posts. Seems to me they are non-committal because he doesn't find the evidence sufficient to declare anything.

A lot of people who initially discounted the lab leak scenario have begun to reconsider the hypothesis after all.

I do lean toward the lab accident hypothesis;

followed by the hypothesis some students and/or staff from the WIV became infected on a field trip to the bat caves in Yunnan Province shortly before the cases appeared in Wuhan.

I find the animal spillover the hypothesis with the least amount of evidence supporting it. There should have been a suspect species identified by now. It's been a year and a half of looking and not even a tentative source has been identified. Coronaviruses circulating in the bat colonies in Yunnan caves come the closest genetically to suggest an animal source.

Notice I don't claim any of those three hypotheses are confirmed. I do find it interesting that no matter how many times I state my position as "leaning", "favoring", or "not yet confirmed", at least 3 of you in this thread post as if I declared the lab was definitively the source.

Upon review of the thread I found one post of mine talking about the incredible tragedy from a lab leak. It was immediately followed by a clarification I was only pondering and didn't mean I thought the lab was definitively the source.
 
:boggled:

What is to agree with? These are expert opinions not shared by everyone.

Do I find them credible? Yes, certainly.
Do you find this part credible: "small cluster of recently infected animals directly into either a single human individual or a small cluster of human individuals"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom