Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I'm sorry for repeating myself but maybe someone here with a fresh eye for denying the lab leak hypothesis can help me find the evidence supporting this claim:
Garry: Early appearance of two distinct genomic lineages of SARS-CoV-2 in different Wuhan wildlife markets suggests SARS-CoV-2 has a natural origin. I can't find that supported in the citations he refers to.
Nor can I find this in the WHO Report:
Garry is using this claim as evidence the 2 COVID lineages are neatly packaged implicating two wildlife market(s) and asserting that explains the divergent lineages.
The WHO report made no mention of two clusters connected to 2 different markets. In that report 2 markets besides the Seafood Market were named but only one revealed any COVID 19 RNA. And there is nothing which supports a cluster of cases connected to a second market.
I will not be surprised if someone can find evidence for the 2 markets = 2 lineages assertion, sometimes I can't find my glasses when they are on my head. But I would sure like to see where this assertion is coming from.
Garry: Early appearance of two distinct genomic lineages of SARS-CoV-2 in different Wuhan wildlife markets suggests SARS-CoV-2 has a natural origin. I can't find that supported in the citations he refers to.
That is not in the WHO report that I can see.The WHO report documented that early cases were not only linked to the Huanan market, but that other early cases were linked to different markets that sold wildlife or wildlife products....A dispassionate science-based discourse on the topic of the origin of SARS-CoV-2 must account for this new data revealed by the WHO study showing: 1. multiple markets were linked to the early cases, and 2. divergence of SARS-CoV-2into lineages A and B was an early occurrence. ...
Nor can I find this in the WHO Report:
In a general sense one could say by default this is in the WHO Report. But definitively as asserted here, it is not there.The WHO report documented that early cases were not only linked to the Huanan market, but that other early cases were linked to different markets that sold wildlife or wildlife products...
That may be there, after all it is very specific as to which specimen that is. But it is one specimen, not a cluster of the not-Seafood Market specimens.Previously, Rambaut et al, (2020) noted that at the root of the phylogeny of SARS-CoV-2 are two lineages designated lineage A and B. Early lineage A viruses include SARS-Cov-2 isolate EPI_ISL_529213 sampled on 30Dec19 from a person linked to a wildlife market different than the Huanan market
Garry is using this claim as evidence the 2 COVID lineages are neatly packaged implicating two wildlife market(s) and asserting that explains the divergent lineages.
The WHO report made no mention of two clusters connected to 2 different markets. In that report 2 markets besides the Seafood Market were named but only one revealed any COVID 19 RNA. And there is nothing which supports a cluster of cases connected to a second market.
I will not be surprised if someone can find evidence for the 2 markets = 2 lineages assertion, sometimes I can't find my glasses when they are on my head. But I would sure like to see where this assertion is coming from.