Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sorry for repeating myself but maybe someone here with a fresh eye for denying the lab leak hypothesis can help me find the evidence supporting this claim:

Garry: Early appearance of two distinct genomic lineages of SARS-CoV-2 in different Wuhan wildlife markets suggests SARS-CoV-2 has a natural origin. I can't find that supported in the citations he refers to.
The WHO report documented that early cases were not only linked to the Huanan market, but that other early cases were linked to different markets that sold wildlife or wildlife products....A dispassionate science-based discourse on the topic of the origin of SARS-CoV-2 must account for this new data revealed by the WHO study showing: 1. multiple markets were linked to the early cases, and 2. divergence of SARS-CoV-2into lineages A and B was an early occurrence. ...
That is not in the WHO report that I can see.

Nor can I find this in the WHO Report:
The WHO report documented that early cases were not only linked to the Huanan market, but that other early cases were linked to different markets that sold wildlife or wildlife products...
In a general sense one could say by default this is in the WHO Report. But definitively as asserted here, it is not there.

Previously, Rambaut et al, (2020) noted that at the root of the phylogeny of SARS-CoV-2 are two lineages designated lineage A and B. Early lineage A viruses include SARS-Cov-2 isolate EPI_ISL_529213 sampled on 30Dec19 from a person linked to a wildlife market different than the Huanan market
That may be there, after all it is very specific as to which specimen that is. But it is one specimen, not a cluster of the not-Seafood Market specimens.

Garry is using this claim as evidence the 2 COVID lineages are neatly packaged implicating two wildlife market(s) and asserting that explains the divergent lineages.

The WHO report made no mention of two clusters connected to 2 different markets. In that report 2 markets besides the Seafood Market were named but only one revealed any COVID 19 RNA. And there is nothing which supports a cluster of cases connected to a second market.


I will not be surprised if someone can find evidence for the 2 markets = 2 lineages assertion, sometimes I can't find my glasses when they are on my head. But I would sure like to see where this assertion is coming from.
 
Do you find this part credible: "small cluster of recently infected animals directly into either a single human individual or a small cluster of human individuals"?

You are asking if a particular hypothesis is credible. AFAIK the only hypothesis that seems dead in the water is that the virus was some sort of bio-weapon.

Are said hypotheses credible scenarios? Apparently. Are they definitive conclusions? Of course not.
 
Here we go again, denying there is any evidence supporting the lab leak when the thread is full of such evidence.

As for Capsid, yes I have been reading his posts. Seems to me they are non-committal because he doesn't find the evidence sufficient to declare anything.

A lot of people who initially discounted the lab leak scenario have begun to reconsider the hypothesis after all.

I do lean toward the lab accident hypothesis;

followed by the hypothesis some students and/or staff from the WIV became infected on a field trip to the bat caves in Yunnan Province shortly before the cases appeared in Wuhan.

I find the animal spillover the hypothesis with the least amount of evidence supporting it. There should have been a suspect species identified by now. It's been a year and a half of looking and not even a tentative source has been identified. Coronaviruses circulating in the bat colonies in Yunnan caves come the closest genetically to suggest an animal source.

Notice I don't claim any of those three hypotheses are confirmed. I do find it interesting that no matter how many times I state my position as "leaning", "favoring", or "not yet confirmed", at least 3 of you in this thread post as if I declared the lab was definitively the source.

Upon review of the thread I found one post of mine talking about the incredible tragedy from a lab leak. It was immediately followed by a clarification I was only pondering and didn't mean I thought the lab was definitively the source.

Why is this the case? I was looking through Spillover which gives an account of the way SARS was tracked down to civet cats. Apparently it was done by a researcher from Hong Kong University in a market in Shenzhen, when he swabbed a bunch of animals (it says it was unclear how he persuaded the market traders to do it, but suggests he just paid them with cash), and then it turned up in civet cats.

This is despite the fact that SARS did not begin in Shenzhen. Apparently it was in 2003 and the first concrete evidence it was zoonotic. So this was 3 years after the initial outbreak.

Tracing it from there all the way back to bats was only done even more recently and much of the work was done by Zhengli Shi's team (hence her name Batwoman) Peter Daszak, and Linfa Wang (Batman).

This paper is from 2005...

Bats Are Natural Reservoirs of SARS-Like Coronaviruses
Wendong Li1,2, Zhengli Shi2,*, Meng Yu3, Wuze Ren2, Craig Smith4, Jonathan H. Epstein5, Hanzhong Wang2, Gary Crameri3, Zhihong Hu2, Huajun Zhang2, Jianhong Zhang2, Jennifer McEachern3, Hume Field4, Peter Daszak5, Bryan T. Eaton3, Shuyi Zhang1,6,*, Lin-Fa Wang3,*

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/310/5748/676
 
Last edited:
Here we go again, denying there is any evidence supporting the lab leak when the thread is full of such evidence.

There isn't a shred of evidence it came from the lab, and you know it. All your bluster won't change the fact that the lab leak has zero evidence to support the idea.
_________________________

I just read a very good and balanced piece from Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/27/did-covid-come-from-a-wuhan-lab-what-we-know-so-far

The bit I like is the analogy of Saddam's WMD, They didn't exist, in spite of intelligence agencies demanding they did.
 
Why is this the case? I was looking through Spillover which gives an account of the way SARS was tracked down to civet cats. Apparently it was done by a researcher from Hong Kong University in a market in Shenzhen, when he swabbed a bunch of animals (it says it was unclear how he persuaded the market traders to do it, but suggests he just paid them with cash), and then it turned up in civet cats.

This is despite the fact that SARS did not begin in Shenzhen. Apparently it was in 2003 and the first concrete evidence it was zoonotic. So this was 3 years after the initial outbreak.

Tracing it from there all the way back to bats was only done even more recently and much of the work was done by Zhengli Shi's team (hence her name Batwoman) Peter Daszak, and Linfa Wang (Batman).

This paper is from 2005...

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/310/5748/676


SARS 1 and SARS 2 presented with completely different circumstances.

From my infectious disease news feed I first heard of SARS in Feb 2003: Published Date: 2003-02-10 23:50:00
Subject: PRO/EDR> Pneumonia - China (Guangdong): RFI


RFI means request for information from infectious disease or other healthcare workers on the ground.
This morning I received this e-mail and then searched your archives
and found nothing that pertained to it. Does anyone know anything
about this problem?
"Have you heard of an epidemic in Guangzhou? An acquaintance of mine
from a teacher's chat room lives there and reports that the
hospitals there have been closed and people are dying."

--

Published Date: 2003-02-11 23:50:00
Subject: PRO/EDR> Pneumonia - China (Guangdong) (02)
An unidentified pneumonia virus has killed 5 people and left hundreds
hospitalized in southern China, while rumors of a surging death toll
prompted frightened residents to stock up on antibiotics, officials
said Tuesday.
Health officials said the outbreak in a region of Guangdong province
near Hong Kong had been brought under control. They said Health
Ministry investigators sent from Beijing were trying to find the
source of the disease.
Some 300 people have been hospitalized, said an official of the provincial
Disease Prevention and Control Center. He said 59 of those people had
been treated and released. Officials wouldn't give any details about
who was killed by the disease or when. ...

So it began on the mainland in Guangdong (adjacent to Hong Kong). Infectious disease people tend to get very concerned when reports are that doctors and other healthcare workers are falling ill along with their patients combined with a high fatality rate. And that was reported initially.

China is at risk for outbreaks of new zoonosis. It is a well known hazard that these pathogens jump from domestic animals to people due to the frequent intermingling in rural China. Lots of ID experts are constantly looking for the next flu pandemic to emerge out of China in particular.

The first case of SARS was tracked back to late 2002. The ISID alert was in Feb of 2003. By June the civet cat was identified as the likely source.

SARS - WORLDWIDE (129): ORIGIN, SPECULATION
Source: OIE press release, 28 May 2003 [edited]
<http://www.oie.int/eng/press/en_last.htm>

SARS virus in civet cat
------------------------
On the basis of recent information of the World Health Organization
which traced the SARS virus to a civet cat and 2 other small mammals
in China, the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) states the
following:
- as mentioned in its previous information (see press release of 11
Apr 2003), the OIE still does not dispose of any scientific evidence
to suggest that SARS-related disease has occurred in animals.
- Therefore, the OIE continues the monitoring of the evolution of the
disease and undertakes a very close collaboration with the World
Health Organization as well as with the scientists of the OIE
Reference Laboratories on the subject.

Date: 31 May 2003
From: ProMED-mail <[email protected]>
Source: Nature 31 May 2003 [edited]
<http://www.nature.com/cgi-taf/Gateway.taf?g=5&file=/drugdisc/news/articles/423467a.html&filetype=&_UserReference=>

Virus detectives seek source of SARS in China's wild animals
-----------------------------
Researchers investigating the source of severe acute respiratory
syndrome (SARS) have turned their attention to the wild-animal
markets of southern China. The move follows reports that workers and
animals at the markets show high rates of infection with
coronaviruses, the family to which the virus believed to cause SARS
belongs.

The possible link to wild animals emerged on 23 May 2003, when a team
from the University of Hong Kong revealed that a coronavirus
resembling the SARS virus had been isolated from 6 masked palm civets
(_Paguma larvata_) and a raccoon dog (_Nyctereutes procyonoides_) in
a market in Shenzhen, in the southern Chinese province of Guangdong.
Antibodies against the virus were also found in a Chinese ferret
badger (_Melogale moschata_) from the same market.
Although the virus is not the same as that believed to cause SARS --
a member of the Hong Kong team describes it as "genetically very
close, but not identical" -- 5 out of the 10 civet handlers at the
market had antibodies against the SARS virus in their blood. A
Chinese government team has since released results showing that 66
out of 508 animal handlers tested at markets in Guangdong had
antibodies against the SARS virus.
Nothing like that has been found in Wuhan and all we know about the antibodies found in the staff and students at the WIV has been provided in a report from the Chinese government. The WHO inspection team said they were denied direct access to the bloodwork or blood specimens.

Further from ProMed:
Microbiologist Kwok-yung Yuen, who led the Hong Kong team, notes that
in the general population, the level of antibodies against the SARS
virus is much lower. "This suggests that the virus is jumping from
wild animals to humans," he says.
Because the animal virus is similar to the SARS virus, but different
from other coronaviruses, it is now a prime suspect in the hunt for
the origins of SARS. The likelihood that the virus is moving the
other way -- from humans to animals -- is diminished by ongoing work
on genetic sequences of the 2 viruses. These analyses suggest that
the animal version has an extra stretch of 29 nucleotide bases.
"Viruses tend not to gain stretches of nucleotides when they jump
across species," says Klaus Stoehr, a SARS expert at the World Health
Organization (WHO) in Geneva.
But uncertainties remain over the exact source of the virus. Only 6
civets were present in the market, and the fact that they all had the
virus suggests that they were infected recently. "They could have
gotten it from another animal during transport to the markets," says
Zhang-liang Chen, a molecular biologist and president of the China
Agricultural University in Beijing. Chen's group did not find the
SARS virus in samples from 8 civets taken from other markets and in
the wild in Guangdong.
The link to the Nature article is no longer working. At this point in the search for the source of SARS they were hot on the trail but it wasn't confirmed.
 
Last edited:
There isn't a shred of evidence it came from the lab, and you know it. All your bluster won't change the fact that the lab leak has zero evidence to support the idea.
_________________________

I just read a very good and balanced piece from Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/27/did-covid-come-from-a-wuhan-lab-what-we-know-so-far

The bit I like is the analogy of Saddam's WMD, They didn't exist, in spite of intelligence agencies demanding they did.
That highlighted bit is bizarre. Seriously.

I'm not impressed by a comparison to Saddam's WMD. There isn't anything remotely close in that analogy.

From your link:
While it is known that dromedaries were a major reservoir host for Mers, even now the role of the animals in transmitting the virus is poorly understood.

The same was true with the Sars outbreak. While civet cats were suspected as intermediate hosts, it took years to confirm. In neither case was there was a suggestion of a lab leak. Because of that, the model of transmission via an intermediate host has remained the predominant one under consideration.
Years to confirm or not, researchers were on the right track within months of identifying the agent causing SARS.

And we're pretty sure camel's milk is a source of MERS infection. I haven't kept up beyond that re MERS.

That bit I bolded is absurd. What lab would it have been in Guangdong China? Or in Saudi Arabia?
 
Last edited:
There isn't a shred of evidence it came from the lab, and you know it. All your bluster won't change the fact that the lab leak has zero evidence to support the idea.
_________________________

I just read a very good and balanced piece from Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/27/did-covid-come-from-a-wuhan-lab-what-we-know-so-far

The bit I like is the analogy of Saddam's WMD, They didn't exist, in spite of intelligence agencies demanding they did.

There's no proof but there is evidence, if only circumstantial - and more than there is for a natural cause.

It seems you feel that the level of proof you require for even considering a lab leak would be akin to the smoking gun (complete with fingerprints), the empty shell case, the bullet, the dead body , and a signed confession.
 
There's no proof but there is evidence, if only circumstantial - and more than there is for a natural cause.

Utter nonsense.

There are some coincidences, but no evidence.

Christ, I hope none of the people who have decided it came from the lab ever get on a jury.
 
Several posts moved to AAH for various reasons.

Please keep to the topic of the thread, and stop the bickering about the precise definition of words.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: zooterkin
 
There's no proof but there is evidence, if only circumstantial

This question was already asked a few days ago, and as yet no one supporting the lab leak hypothesis has provided an answer so I'll ask it again.

What is the single most compelling piece of positive evidence for a lab leak?
 
When you read what the researchers say about the research they conducted, get back to me.

You seem to think I'm making claims when I'm essentially posting what is in the citations.

The researchers in question are suggesting that there were 2 distinct crossover events, one on each market and that the "lineages" you are referring to already existed in the original animal hosts and didn't arise in humans. Writing it as "Human Corona Virus" and bolding the word human isn't an adequate rebuttal.


Here is part of the image from the paper you linked:
picture.php
 
This question was already asked a few days ago, and as yet no one supporting the lab leak hypothesis has provided an answer so I'll ask it again.

What is the single most compelling piece of positive evidence for a lab leak?
How about we just go for asking for a simple bullet point list of what the evidence is?
Your question doesn't seem fair for multiple reasons.

1. It would be fair to say that no origin hypothesis has compelling evidence because science as a whole considers the question unanswered.

2. Asking for a "single" piece of evidence doesn't work for questions that are supported by a range of small bit of circumstantial evidence. And, in fact, you are asking exactly the question creationists use to make it appear there is no good evidence for evolution.

3. I believe SG at least agrees the evidence is circumstantial?

Also let me clarify that it appears the (non CT) proponents of this are arguing for lab leak. The lab leak hypothesis is not at all contradictory to zoonotic origin, in fact, it is a kind of zoonotic origin hypothesis. Lab leak is where the virus arose naturally in an animal but the crossover event happened in the lab. Note that this means that quite a bit of potential evidence for natural origin does not contract the lab leak hypothesis.
 
He’s not going for a ‘gotcha.’ If you feel like it needs a bulleted list then make a bulleted list. I wouldn’t have a hard time making a short list of compelling points in support of evolution.
 
The researchers in question are suggesting that there were 2 distinct crossover events, one on each market and that the "lineages" you are referring to already existed in the original animal hosts and didn't arise in humans. Writing it as "Human Corona Virus" and bolding the word human isn't an adequate rebuttal.

Here is part of the image from the paper you linked:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1416&pictureid=12836[/qimg]
There are multiple hypotheses and some variation within those hypotheses. Two crossover events is one variation explaining the two lineages. It's not the only way to explain the two lineages that diverged early on.

There's nothing to rebut. You apparently still have a misunderstanding about the full genomes used to walk the clock back. They can't go back beyond speculating about the crossover event without a coronavirus from the species the crossover event emerged from.

The genomes used to estimate when the crossover event occurred came from people infected with COVID 19. They didn't come from coronaviruses in animals. They are human coronaviruses.
 
...

3. I believe SG at least agrees the evidence is circumstantial?

Also let me clarify that it appears the (non CT) proponents of this are arguing for lab leak. The lab leak hypothesis is not at all contradictory to zoonotic origin, in fact, it is a kind of zoonotic origin hypothesis. Lab leak is where the virus arose naturally in an animal but the crossover event happened in the lab. Note that this means that quite a bit of potential evidence for natural origin does not contract the lab leak hypothesis.
Yes.

There is a lot of evidence I think is very compelling about the lab accident. Dismissing it as "circumstantial" by some in this thread is quite the distortion of what that evidence is.

There is direct evidence the WIV was in the recent past engaged in research with live coronavirus cultures. Is that circumstantial?

There is direct evidence they lied about working with live coronavirus cultures. Is that circumstantial?
 
Also let me clarify that it appears the (non CT) proponents of this are arguing for lab leak. The lab leak hypothesis is not at all contradictory to zoonotic origin, in fact, it is a kind of zoonotic origin hypothesis.

A Lab leak still requires the virus to have been studied in a lab and for it's animal host to have been identified and brought to a lab. If this were the case we'd expect it to be relatively easy to find the animal host and for there to be data on the virus in existing research.

The explanation we are being given for why there is no data, no samples and no host identified is that there is a conspiracy to purge any related research from the record. At this point ANY lab-leak must have a conspiracy component to explain why there is no record of this virus ever being in a lab.
 
There are multiple hypotheses and some variation within those hypotheses. Two crossover events is one variation explaining the two lineages. It's not the only way to explain the two lineages that diverged early on.

That depends, as I said previously, on how different the lineages are which is a question you have never answered. The author of the paper you linked seemed to think the two linages are too far enough apart that they must have arisen in the original animal host.

Even if the lineages could have arisen in humans in an 4-8 week span, so what? How would this support your argument?
 
I didn't assume he was going for a gotcha and I can't make the list because I'm not one of the people making the argument.
 
There is direct evidence the WIV was in the recent past engaged in research with live coronavirus cultures. Is that circumstantial?

Lets play spot the moving goalposts. There is NO evidence for work with Covid-19 at WIV nor anyplace else in the world.

OF COURSE the WIV has done work with coronaviruses. China has 1 BSL-4 lab dealing with human diseases and China is a hotspot for potential Corona virus jumps to humans. The possibility of a coronavirus in China jumping from animal to humans and causing a pandemic has been recognised for at least 2 decades. This work is central to the very existence of the WIV.

China was going to be researching it and that research was going to be conducted un Wuhan. The fact that China was studying a known pandemic risk tells us nothing, nor does the fact that the risk turned out to be real.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom