Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Of all the gin joints in China, the virus walked into this one.How so? How do you calculate it to be improbable (and no, I'm not asking for math here)?
How many cities with wet markets do you think are in China?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_in_China
There are a gazillion cities. And Wuhan has more than 9 million people.
What kind of odds would you give the pandemic starting not only in a city of 9+ million, but turning up in 2 lineages both near the WIV where they were studying pathogenic coronaviruses?
You were told????That's odd; I was told there was no hard evidence. Can you confer and come back with a consistent answer?
No one has claimed we have definitively shown that. No one has shown it came from an animal spillover event either. After more than a year of searching, no animal reservoir has been found.There's nothing absurd about it, and you can't dismiss me that easily. You've not shown that it came from a lab, full stop.
I'm not sure how to address your seemingly different expectation from this thread than is actually in the thread.
We are trying to look at all the evidence for all the viable hypotheses. Despite efforts by many to dismiss it, moving higher and higher on the differential is the lab accident hypothesis.
Has it been ruled in? No, of course not. Who gave you the impression this thread was completed and conclusively shown it was a lab spillover?
IMO: Next down the list is a direct bat to human spillover event outside of the lab. That one is hard to reconcile with the location of the outbreak. However, it is very possible researchers from the WIV went to the bat caves and returned to Wuhan with the infection. That might explain the 2 lineages if 2 researchers returned infected from 2 different bats from the same colony. And a team of university students traveling to Yunann might not have been officially recognized.
The argument against this is there has been no outbreak in Yunnan since the three cave workers were infected, and, the collected coronaviruses from the cave don't match perfectly with COVID 19. The virus was changed somewhere and gain of function research with live cultures in the WIV would explain how and where that happened.
Third up is some sort of intermediary animal spillover from the markets. It would involve a location outside of Wuhan where the animals were shipped from. I really don't find this very plausible given no intermediary animal has been identified in well over a year of looking. And given 40+% of the first detected cases had no exposure to any wet market.
