Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
How so? How do you calculate it to be improbable (and no, I'm not asking for math here)?
Of all the gin joints in China, the virus walked into this one.

How many cities with wet markets do you think are in China?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_in_China
There are a gazillion cities. And Wuhan has more than 9 million people.

What kind of odds would you give the pandemic starting not only in a city of 9+ million, but turning up in 2 lineages both near the WIV where they were studying pathogenic coronaviruses?


That's odd; I was told there was no hard evidence. Can you confer and come back with a consistent answer?
You were told????


There's nothing absurd about it, and you can't dismiss me that easily. You've not shown that it came from a lab, full stop.
No one has claimed we have definitively shown that. No one has shown it came from an animal spillover event either. After more than a year of searching, no animal reservoir has been found.

I'm not sure how to address your seemingly different expectation from this thread than is actually in the thread.


We are trying to look at all the evidence for all the viable hypotheses. Despite efforts by many to dismiss it, moving higher and higher on the differential is the lab accident hypothesis.

Has it been ruled in? No, of course not. Who gave you the impression this thread was completed and conclusively shown it was a lab spillover?

IMO: Next down the list is a direct bat to human spillover event outside of the lab. That one is hard to reconcile with the location of the outbreak. However, it is very possible researchers from the WIV went to the bat caves and returned to Wuhan with the infection. That might explain the 2 lineages if 2 researchers returned infected from 2 different bats from the same colony. And a team of university students traveling to Yunann might not have been officially recognized.

The argument against this is there has been no outbreak in Yunnan since the three cave workers were infected, and, the collected coronaviruses from the cave don't match perfectly with COVID 19. The virus was changed somewhere and gain of function research with live cultures in the WIV would explain how and where that happened.

Third up is some sort of intermediary animal spillover from the markets. It would involve a location outside of Wuhan where the animals were shipped from. I really don't find this very plausible given no intermediary animal has been identified in well over a year of looking. And given 40+% of the first detected cases had no exposure to any wet market.
 
What kind of odds would you give the pandemic starting not only in a city of 9+ million, but turning up in 2 lineages both near the WIV where they were studying pathogenic coronaviruses?

I don't know, you tell me.

You were told????

Yes. I must admit that I shouldn't trust your claims as far as I could throw you, but there you have it.

No one has claimed we have definitively shown that.

You're the one who said we had hard evidence, but then your main argument above is entirely circumstantial. So it seems like your objection to me calling it circumstantial was, at best, misguided.
 
I don't know, you tell me.
I did already, it's incredibly low odds.

Yes. I must admit that I shouldn't trust your claims as far as I could throw you, but there you have it.
So you can quote me where I said we definitely know the lab is the source? I don't think so.

You're the one who said we had hard evidence, but then your main argument above is entirely circumstantial. So it seems like your objection to me calling it circumstantial was, at best, misguided.
We do have hard evidence, lots of it.

You seem to be conflating hard evidence with proof. :boggled:

The patient genome work is hard evidence.

The genomes of coronaviruses compared to the genome and lineages of the COVID 19 are hard evidence.

Much of the work going on at the WIV has been documented with hard evidence such as papers written by the researchers before the pandemic. That includes hard evidence of which cultures they were working with, we have lots of that evidence.


And so on.
 
None of this belongs in this thread. First it is unsupportable and second it belongs in the CT forum.

Interesting opinion but not right if we prefer to seek full facts .

Let's look at the Maryland to Chapel Hill to Wuhan life chain and relate that to the topic title and the likelihood that enhanced values translates to deliberate and engineered weaponisation .
This habit of relegating matters that you cannot or will not address to CT is cowardly.
 
I did already, it's incredibly low odds.

Sorry, you claiming that the odds are low means nothing.

So you can quote me where I said we definitely know the lab is the source? I don't think so.

Sorry, I blame the English language. You, plural.

We do have hard evidence, lots of it.

Then why did you start with circumstantial evidence and kept on that until this post?

You seem to be conflating hard evidence with proof.

In all your years on this forum you still haven't learned what "proof" means?

The genomes of coronaviruses compared to the genome and lineages of the COVID 19 are hard evidence.

That is still circumstantial. You need to link one with the other.
 
Sorry, you claiming that the odds are low means nothing.
Because you can't do the math yourself? :confused:


Then why did you start with circumstantial evidence and kept on that until this post?
:rolleyes:


In all your years on this forum you still haven't learned what "proof" means?
:rolleyes:


That is still circumstantial. You need to link one with the other.

This reply is too far out there. When you get back to reality maybe try again.
 
Because you can't do the math yourself?

What math? Do you expect me to believe that you did any math on this? It's your opinion that it's unlikely. And I may agree, but that doesn't mean much. Thousands of unlikely things happen every day. All this means is that your suggestion is possible, even perhaps probable.


What? It's a perfectly cromulent question. If you have hard evidence, why did you start with the weaker circumstancial evidence in response to my request? Have you no answer to that? Is it because you have no clue what constitutes hard evidence and what constitutes circumstantial evidence?


"Proof" is either used in mathematics, or colloquially in everyday conversation as a synonym for "evidence". So if you're making a distinction between "evidence" and "proof", then you should be using the mathematical definition, which means nothing in this context. Since you probably are also not using this definition, it means that you're using a personal definition i.e. you don't understand what the word means. Which is surprising, given how often we've discussed this here with various woo-woos.

This reply is too far out there. When you get back to reality maybe try again.

You really don't understand what any of those terms mean, do you? In fact, you are not aggressively ignorant, using smileys and "talk to the hand" antics to avoid admitting it.
 
What math? Do you expect me to believe that you did any math on this? It's your opinion that it's unlikely. And I may agree, but that doesn't mean much. Thousands of unlikely things happen every day. All this means is that your suggestion is possible, even perhaps probable.
:boggled:I can't help you if you don't see how extremely unlikely it is that the pandemic started near where the WIV was studying coronaviruses. Maybe someone else can explain it.


What? It's a perfectly cromulent question. If you have hard evidence, why did you start with the weaker circumstancial evidence in response to my request? Have you no answer to that? Is it because you have no clue what constitutes hard evidence and what constitutes circumstantial evidence?
Start when? :confused: I started at the beginning of this thread when it was moved out of the general COVID science discussion. I don't even know what circumstantial evidence you are talking about. I truly cannot understand your train of thought but it is waaay out there from the discussion in the thread.

You are ignoring a wealth of evidence. Again, maybe someone else can explain it to you.


"Proof" is either used in mathematics, or colloquially in everyday conversation as a synonym for "evidence". So if you're making a distinction between "evidence" and "proof", then you should be using the mathematical definition, which means nothing in this context. Since you probably are also not using this definition, it means that you're using a personal definition i.e. you don't understand what the word means. Which is surprising, given how often we've discussed this here with various woo-woos.
:boggled:

You don't seem to think 'hard' scientific evidence exists in this discussion unless it is conclusive that the lab is the source. :boggled::boggled::boggled::boggled::boggled:


You really don't understand what any of those terms mean, do you? In fact, you are not aggressively ignorant, using smileys and "talk to the hand" antics to avoid admitting it.
:rolleyes:


When you stop and rethink your posts here, let me know. In the meantime I honestly don't know what your problem is except to attack me.

I've summarized the evidence, I spelled the evidence out, I cited multiple sources of the evidence as have other people having a normal conversation here. I noted the limitation of the evidence for any hypothesis.


You are not making any sense. Seriously!
 
See previous .
Look at emerging hard evidence and don't simply adopt a Compliant Gullible stance , probably being hypnotised by MSM led fake news .

On a priori grounds a virus mutates every time its programming hits a difficulty . In that context a vaccine is the equivalent of a nuclear explosion .

That's still ********. (And you should probably learn what 'a priori' means.)

Mutations don't occur because a genome "hits a difficulty". That's not how evolution works. Vaccines don't even kill the virus - they mimic the virus so that the immune system can make antibodies against things with those protein structures, without all the respiratory issues, organ failure and whatnot that can come from an infection when the immune system has no previous exposure to a virus. Then the immune system has a record of the antibodies that will kill the virus should it later be exposed to it, so it can kill it before it overwhelms the host.

You're either making stuff up, or more likely parroting it from somewhere else. But trying to pad your sentences out with Latin phrases used in the wrong context isn't going to fool many people here.
 
Moving on: Covid: Biden orders intelligence report on virus origin
Authorities linked early Covid cases to a seafood market in Wuhan, and scientists believed the virus first passed to humans from animals.

But recent US media reports suggest growing evidence the virus could instead have emerged from a laboratory in China.

Beijing has condemned the reports and suggested it could have come from a US laboratory instead.
Nothing new there.

the Biden administration has conceded the American intelligence community is split on Covid-19's origins - it could be the lab or animal-to-human contact - and no-one is near certain about it.

That marks a big shift from the derision heaped on the lab theory by many in the media and politics last year, when Donald Trump, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, Senator Tom Cotton and others floated the idea.
IOW Dump made it impossible to trust any version of events.

"Here is their current position: 'While two elements in the IC leans toward the former scenario and one leans more toward the latter - each with low or moderate confidence - the majority of elements do not believe there is sufficient information to assess one to be more likely than the other.'"

The tide has shifted:
Anthony Fauci, President Biden's chief medical adviser, has maintained he believes the virus was passed from animals to humans, though he conceded this month he was no longer confident Covid-19 had developed naturally. ...

The laboratory leak allegations were widely dismissed last year as a fringe conspiracy theory, after then-President Donald Trump said Covid-19 had originated from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Many US media outlets described such claims as debunked or false.


And of course Dump wants credit regardless:
On Tuesday, Mr Trump sought to take credit in an emailed statement to the New York Post. "To me it was obvious from the beginning but I was badly criticised, as usual," he said. "Now they are all saying: 'He was right.'"
I wish we could shut Dump up. If he keeps it up half the planet's population won't believe whatever the actual evidence shows.


This is not helpful: Politico: Facebook lifts ban on posts claiming Covid-19 was man-made as Wuhan theories surge
hifting definitions on social media: Facebook announced in February it had expanded the list of misleading health claims that it would remove from its platforms to include those asserting that "COVID-19 is man-made or manufactured." The tech giant has updated its policies against false and misleading coronavirus information, including its running list of debunked claims, over the course of the pandemic in consultation with global health officials.

But a Facebook spokesperson said Wednesday that the origin language had been stricken from that list due to the renewed debate about the virus’ roots.
They must not have any knowledgeable scientists in their decision making group because this says they don't understand how most of us are defining "manmade".
 
Did you ever get an answer to that?

I cited the studied that came up with that number yesterday. A summary of various estimates including the Septemeber estimate and otehrs can be found in a WHO report I'll name below. The September estimate is the earliest estimate in the report, so it's accepted but an outlier IMO.

I don't have a good link to share since the link I got this from was dynamic but this is the report that summarizes various estimates of the tMRCA. Table is on page 80. This is the WHO report mentioned several times over the past couple days.

WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2: China PartJoint WHO-China Study14January-10 February 2021Joint Report

Thanks, yes, I am now aware of the study that looked at this. It was by Bai et. al. I take it this is quite an early paper in the pandemic.

Skeptic Ginger claimed that Andersen had said two lineages had been found in Wuhan in Sept 2019. When I asked for this to be supported, she assumed bad motives on my part.

Yes, there are several papers on the topic and SG is choosing the one that best fits her narrative.

That's fine, because I can understand why someone might say, "Look, the Chinese took down a database in September - suspiciously close to the outbreak. Could it be that that was the time a pathogen was known to have escaped so they took it down in anticipation of the pandemic?"

But.... it also seems to make the Chinese actions incoherent. Why would they simultaneously take down a database and then apparently make NO EFFORT whatsoever to contain a leaked virus INSTEAD of going into emergency measures?

We now know what happened with the pathogen, but they couldn't have known that at the time.

Also, something like a public database seems like the type of thing that virologists or infectious disease experts around the world would have copies of. Are these copies not availablle?

It has been claimed that GeneBank (?) has also got almost all of this information as well.

The claim, though, is that there were some viruses which were not yet on the Genebank records, but were on the database. But again, I would come back to the question of why the Chinese government thought:

1) A pathogen has escaped.
2) It will be a pandemic
3) Scrub the public records! (Hope no one has a copy...fingers crossed)
4) Just deny all knowledge
5) Hope it all blows over

Maybe this database will show that they had the virus and they knew full well they did.

OR

Maybe the database is like the Area 51 (bound to contain the secret) OR like Wilikleaks (when these cables come out we'll see the whole 9/11 plot!) OR like the Zapruder film (when we see the video it will defo show the shot came from the front...oops! It doesn't so it must have been altered...etc...)

Anyway, I have no idea. I tend to think some of the lab leak "evidence" is a bit forced. The database stuff, for example. But I am definitely open to the possibility that it could have come from the lab somehow.
 
I can't help you if you don't see how extremely unlikely it is that the pandemic started near where the WIV was studying coronaviruses. Maybe someone else can explain it.

Did you even read what you responded to? I agreed that it's unlikely. The problem is that you are incapable of going beyond that.

You are ignoring a wealth of evidence.

I don't think you and I agree on what "wealth" means.

You don't seem to think 'hard' scientific evidence exists in this discussion unless it is conclusive that the lab is the source.

Excluded middle fallacy.

When you stop and rethink your posts here, let me know.

Likewise.
 
Thanks, yes, I am now aware of the study that looked at this. It was by Bai et. al. I take it this is quite an early paper in the pandemic.

Skeptic Ginger claimed that Andersen had said two lineages had been found in Wuhan in Sept 2019. When I asked for this to be supported, she assumed bad motives on my part.

Yes, there are several papers on the topic and SG is choosing the one that best fits her narrative.
I didn't "choose" anything. The information on the Sept actions of the Chinese government came up after I had read the Andersen work. It was challenged that the Sept actions couldn't have been in response to a lab accident because the pandemic started later.

I remembered reading the estimate about the Sept date for the earliest cases. And it was Andersen.

Note to thread readers, myself and others have been asked repeatedly to go back and spoon feed something we already cited/posted to someone who didn't read it at the time. Maybe some of us don't feel we are obligated to do this every time it is asked. It doesn't mean we have not backed up our claims with citations!

I read it. There were 2 lineages initially (confirmed) and the range of the initial cases does include Sept. (confirmed). So unless you think I made it up to "fit my narrative" and just magically knew ahead of time that my "narrative" would be corroborated, you really need to stop making false claims about what I've read and what I've posted.


Time to move on. If you don't think it is possible the actions of the government taking WIV data offline is related then you need to make that case.


That's fine, because I can understand why someone might say, "Look, the Chinese took down a database in September - suspiciously close to the outbreak. Could it be that that was the time a pathogen was known to have escaped so they took it down in anticipation of the pandemic?"
Yes, it is absolutely within the range of possibilities.

But.... it also seems to make the Chinese actions incoherent. Why would they simultaneously take down a database and then apparently make NO EFFORT whatsoever to contain a leaked virus INSTEAD of going into emergency measures?
How do you know they made no effort to contain the outbreak? Maybe they thought they had. They did not have tests available at the time to find mild cases. They might have had no idea there were mild cases or to what extent they existed.


We now know what happened with the pathogen, but they couldn't have known that at the time.
Which is not relevant because all that is needed was an alert the accident had happened and that there might be a problem.

Why would that not be enough to act on?

Also, something like a public database seems like the type of thing that virologists or infectious disease experts around the world would have copies of. Are these copies not availablle?

It has been claimed that GeneBank (?) has also got almost all of this information as well.
We have that information thanks to the DRASTIC team. I've posted it twice now. I'll post it again.

If you guys are really interested in this topic, how about taking an interest in the posted evidence?

The claim, though, is that there were some viruses which were not yet on the Genebank records, but were on the database.
That is not the claim. Again, look at the facts because we do have them. They took down data related to research being done at the WIV.


But again, I would come back to the question of why the Chinese government thought:

1) A pathogen has escaped.
2) It will be a pandemic
3) Scrub the public records! (Hope no one has a copy...fingers crossed)
4) Just deny all knowledge
5) Hope it all blows over

Maybe this database will show that they had the virus and they knew full well they did.

OR

Maybe the database is like the Area 51 (bound to contain the secret) OR like Wilikleaks (when these cables come out we'll see the whole 9/11 plot!) OR like the Zapruder film (when we see the video it will defo show the shot came from the front...oops! It doesn't so it must have been altered...etc...)

Anyway, I have no idea. I tend to think some of the lab leak "evidence" is a bit forced. The database stuff, for example. But I am definitely open to the possibility that it could have come from the lab somehow.
There's no reason for this Area 51 crap except to point out that you have not read the posted citations so you are drawing conclusions with a large missing data set.


On to the DRASTIC citation for the 3rd (at least) time: An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline
Abstract
On the 12th Sep 2019, the main database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline. Eventually every single of the 16 virus databases managed by the WIV was taken offline. Here we show how these databases may provide essential clues at to the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and review the circumstances in which they were taken offline....

Objectives:
- List all the DBs that were taken offline
- Explain their significance
- Back it up with screenshots and proofs of deletion
The doc is 26 pages and very carefully laid out so please take the time to look at this citation before you continue on with your false conclusions about this data.
On page 20 the data is entered in a chart format so you can see it at a glance. The columns are: # (1 to 15); name; description; URI /URL; Status (all are offline); Issuing agency; Contact

From the last page:
2.d Zoom: Access Interruption:
The portals and all the databases are inaccessible. The machine is there but not serving any web-page at any of the relevant addresses.
 
But you would need to do some investigations on those very same lifts that are killing people to work out why.


Well, we certainly know more about coronaviruses than we did in late 2019. So, um, research mission accomplished? Good job everyone? Let's do more gain-of-function studies in insufficiently bio-safe facilities so we'll learn even more?

Nope. IF (remember this is all hypothetical as there's insufficient evidence at present to conclude any specific source for Covid-19) this was an accidental lab release, there damn well better be some big changes going forward.
 
Correction...

My correction is that you are certain the virus escaped from the lab.

You've made 28 of the past 100 posts in the thread trying to convince everyone the virus came from the Wuhan lab. You pay lip service to the fact that there is still both insufficient evidence to be certain of anything, and that we have evidence from an actual virologist that it's unlikely to have been created in a lab.

You're obsessed with the idea that it's a Chinese conspiracy, and the silliest part of that is, so what where it came from?

What are going to do, sue China? Get them to reanimate the 10 million dead? Pay compensation to long Covid sufferers?

Try waiting for actual evidence before trying to convince everyone your "theory" is right. Then it might be worth a few posts.
 
I recently started watching this podcast again. Just started on this one, but since it is relevant to the topic here, I thought I'd share it for anyone interested.

I may or may not have comments on it after I get through it all:

 
I recently started watching this podcast again. Just started on this one, but since it is relevant to the topic here, I thought I'd share it for anyone interested.

I may or may not have comments on it after I get through it all:


Wow! I was waiting for this one.

I guess this has only gone up a few hours ago.

TWiV with Peter Daszak and Marion Koopmans...

I know what I am doing for the next 90 minutes.

Thanks for this!
 
But it hasn't escaped my notice that you haven't attempted to defend your claim that a genome mutates because it "hits a difficulty". You seem ignorant of the basic fact that vaccines don't attack a virus. They stimulate the host's immune system to produce antibodies capable of attacking the virus.

You also haven't provided a source for the quote in your recent post. Where are you acquiring this information? Did you find it yourself, or merely copy and paste it from someone else?

I feel sorry for all those bats that get infected with SARS-related viruses from vaccinated bats.

Reading that back, it may not make sense. It's in response to the claim that vaccines cause mutations. Mutations occur in the absence of vaccines all the time and continuously as we can see with the evolution of beta coronaviruses in bats.
 
Last edited:
This might be an interesting part:

On the question of evidence of transmission before Dec 2019:

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=1338

They agree that there probably had been transmission prior to Dec 2019.

The interesting thing is that some lab leakers are trying to have it both ways. They argue

Premise 1: that there was probably transmission going as far back as Sept 2019 (after all, that's when the WIV took down the database, right?).

But then they also

Premise 2: try to rule out the market as the centre of the outbreak - "No, the first case in early Dec 2019 had no contact with the market. And 40% had no contact with the market!"

Therefore, it started in the WIV.

But of course, if we accept premise 1, then we negate premise 2.

The mere fact that the first known case had no contact with the market merely means that it wasn't the first case.

The non-lab leakers clearly have no problem with that part because they agree about multiple lineages predating the "first case". Therefore the markets are back in play.

++++++
There could have been direct spillover from a bat without an intermediary.

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=2413
++++++

Cold-chain theory:

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=2683

I get the impression that none of them think it is a good idea, and even if not true then not explanatory from where it comes from initially.

They give some explanation about why it is not crazy, but they think it is unlikely.

+++++++

The elephant in the room: Fourth scenario: lab leak

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=3000


Marion says she asked why they took the database offline and says she was satisfied with the answer. Hmmmm...I didn't hear what the reason she said was.

Daszak also says he asks why they took down the database. Though he doesn't say what they answered.

+++++

Daszak says that if there is solid leads on people being sick then they should share it.

https://youtu.be/d7kRxmEgzbQ?t=3657

Apparently there is nothing but vague hearsay right now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom