Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The important thing is that if the virus escaped from a Chinese lab then they are to blame for the 3.5 million deaths and global economic damage, which justifies demonizing the Chinese government while excusing our own incompetent response.

There's just one problem with that - until March 2020 the US government was funding coronavirus research in Wuhan. Trump ended funding after learning that $3.7 million had gone to the Wuhan lab, which is an admission of our own government's part in it and an attempt to distance himself from it (if the virus really did escape from the Wuhan lab - or even if it didn't!).


The conclusion is obvious - we must immediately stop all coronavirus research, particularly in countries which are likely to harbor strains that could jump to humans. This is the only way to prevent future outbreaks! :rolleyes:

We can just stick to the science and let it lead us where the evidence goes, but when the source of this outbreak is exposed it will be used for political ends. We can only hope that those ends are more constructive than destructive.

It's not the escape....it's the delay and coverup that puts the world at risk. A bit like trying to hide Chernobyl while you try and fix it yourself all while watching a radiation cloud on the move.
When the BS-4 was announced there, (for other viruses, not even corona ones...more like Ebola level though Ebola wasnt an outbreak at the time) there were concerns about the Chinese system which had intermittent funding and inconsistent staffing, was more lax on inspections, and has a culture that is less collaborative and open and so prone to more safety concerns as any alarm moves slower up the hierarchy. That may be why there were often western universities and teams that would partner (and pay). France was first to pay for Wuhan. Later the US also paid, and not just the NIH...so did Singapore (with Duke I believe). Probably others too. If they are building it and it's a risk, what else can you do but try to be involved?

That's not something I have looked too much into so details could be wrong. Maybe our China posters can weigh in if they know a bit more. I do know the Gain of Function was stopped under Obama so some of it moved to other foreign labs. Perhaps a risk aversion with unintended consequences (though no evidence yet in this case)
 
Last edited:
How does the detection of early (September) sars-cov2 antibodies in Italy fit into all of this?

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0300891620974755
We looked at that and the problem is it was serum antibody testing, not an actual culture of the virus from a person. The antibody tests commonly have false positives.

SARS-CoV-2 RBD-specific antibodies were detected in 111 of 959 (11.6%) individuals, starting from September 2019 (14%), with a cluster of positive cases (>30%) in the second week of February 2020 ...

What needs to happen is to test another batch of stored serum to see if the same antibodies were detectible.

Keep in mind they are talking about potentially asymptomatic infections. That is inconsistent with the COVID 19 that began in Wuhan and has spread around the world. While there are clearly asymptomatic cases, where are the severe cases in Italy in late 2019? Cases do appear after the cases in Wuhan and an individual or individuals did connect to Italy early on in the pandemic. So severe cases of COVID 19 did show up, but not as early as Sept 2019.
 
We looked at that and the problem is it was serum antibody testing, not an actual culture of the virus from a person. The antibody tests commonly have false positives.



What needs to happen is to test another batch of stored serum to see if the same antibodies were detectible.

Keep in mind they are talking about potentially asymptomatic infections. That is inconsistent with the COVID 19 that began in Wuhan and has spread around the world. While there are clearly asymptomatic cases, where are the severe cases in Italy in late 2019? Cases do appear after the cases in Wuhan and an individual or individuals did connect to Italy early on in the pandemic. So severe cases of COVID 19 did show up, but not as early as Sept 2019.

I had posted a while back about all of the flu samples China had on hand to test from their flu season- 300k samples across provinces? Maybe more.
Earlier reports said they did not retest any before December. There is no access to those samples to anyone. This should be one of the first areas looked at for the WHO team to gert good data related to origin. Did they say anything in the report about it? I have not read the whole thing (and didnt expect much from it but I could be surprised!).
 
I don't know if it is on-topic here, but it seems related to the issues here: What is the purpose of Gain of Function research? The ViW seems to have been doing this research (among many others all over the world), and the object seems to try to enable virus to be more efficient in infecting humans, which makes the lab leak theory so scary. But what exactly is the researchers trying to gain from being better able to infect humans - when we are not talking about miliary research?
 
AIUI the aim was to discover the kind of mutations that might occur so we could prepare (design vaccines etc) in case they did.
 
Oh yeah! I think SG gave you a pretty good overview.

Circumstantial stuff. That doesn't make much of a case.

It starts with simply noticing some incredible coincidences of location. "Bat coronavirus pandemic starts next to the world premiere lab studying bat coronaviruses."

In an area known for bat viruses and wet markets.

Then the wet market story turns out not to be true.

Woah, back up. Might not be true or turned out to not be true?

Just look to the areas you think would be most convincing to you and see if you can make sense of it.

So basically you're asking me to think my way to a conclusion rather than follow hard evidence. Skepticism!
 
Circumstantial stuff. That doesn't make much of a case.

In an area known for bat viruses and wet markets.

Woah, back up. Might not be true or turned out to not be true?



So basically you're asking me to think my way to a conclusion rather than follow hard evidence. Skepticism!

The area is not known for bat viruses...unless you are speaking of the lab. It isnt known for eating bats either.

Wet market as hub of first of infections was NOT true, even by China's own admission- and by earlier reports, and by the WHO report. The first (confirmed) case was a month before with no relation to a wet market. He was an office worker in his 40's.

Follow the evidence, of course. My point was that there is quite a bit of circumstantial evidence that if you are interested in the science, the misdirections, the motives, lies, etc.... you can start where you like. Like the OJ trial...a lot of naysayers at the time, but a lot of different evidence to poke at. Can't eat the whole bat in one bite!

I thought you were going to read Belz instead of these sophomoric gotcha statements. Very disappointed. I await some improvement in your thread participation.
 
Last edited:
Wet market as hub of first of infections was NOT true, even by China's own admission- and by earlier reports, and by the WHO report. The first (confirmed) case was a month before with no relation to a wet market. He was an office worker in his 40's.

I don't understand what you mean by "a month before" in relation to the market.

My point was that there is quite a bit of circumstantial evidence that if you are interested in the science, the misdirections, the motives, lies, etc.... you can start where you like.

It's your claim, not mine.

Can't eat the whole bat in one bite!

I'd rather not, you're right.

I thought you were going to read Belz instead of these sophomoric gotcha statements.

I'm trying to pin down exactly what the claim is and what the evidence is to begin with. Instead I get a bunch of allusions to circumstantial stuff and calls to think for myself, the latter of which I always treat with extreme suspicion.
 
I'm trying to pin down exactly what the claim is and what the evidence is to begin with.
Well there are not many definitive claims in here. Likelihoods and possibilities- maybe a pet theory- but those can change. If you need math-like proof, it does not exist, and never will. And not just for this question.

Instead I get a bunch of allusions to circumstantial stuff and calls to think for myself, the latter of which I always treat with extreme suspicion.
:D
I too share this suspicion.

You need to lower expectations. I am listening to a documentary on the late bronze age right now. Can I prove it? No. Even your own eyes and ears could deceive you.

You want me to prove something about a pandemic virus in China? If I could I certainly would not be in here. I'd be negotiating deals for my superior skills.

Viruses dont walk around on microscope projections at the local disco. (but that's not a bad idea)
It's mostly inference. So yeah.... Think for yourself! Be bold!
 
False positives.

Whatever test they are using is junk.

Likely. It was also said upthread by SG (I think....she points out most of my mistakes and I made this one about super early infections)

But China doesnt miss a good propaganda opportunity!

Reuters (11/20)
Chinese state media have cited the presence of the coronavirus on imported frozen food packaging, as well as scientific papers claiming that the coronavirus was circulating in Europe earlier than previously believed, as evidence that China may not have been its origin.

“#COVID19 did not start in central China’s Wuhan but may come through imported frozen food and packaging: experts,” said a Wednesday Facebook post by the ruling Communist Party’s official People’s Daily.

The WHO team actually went along with this- for a while.
I think it was more internal messaging - to blame foreigners for the original AND new outbreaks in China though. The world just happens to also overhear it.
 
Last edited:
The conclusion is obvious - we must immediately stop all coronavirus research, particularly in countries which are likely to harbor strains that could jump to humans. This is the only way to prevent future outbreaks! :rolleyes:


IF it turns out conclusively that Covid-19 occurred because of unsafe coronavirus research, then yes, that is exactly what we must do. Obviously. At least, until measures are put into place that reduce the future risk by at least several orders of magnitude compared to previous practices.

When three and a half million people die and the world's economy is thrown into turmoil for more than a year, "how dare you stand in the way of SCIENCE!" isn't a very convincing case for continuing with business as usual.

If 3,500,000 people were killed (and millions more had permanent or lasting injuries) in elevator accidents in a year, would you tag a suggestion that "maybe we should use the stairs for a while" with the same :rolleyes: eye-rolling smilie?
 
IF it turns out conclusively that Covid-19 occurred because of unsafe coronavirus research, then yes, that is exactly what we must do. Obviously. At least, until measures are put into place that reduce the future risk by at least several orders of magnitude compared to previous practices.

When three and a half million people die and the world's economy is thrown into turmoil for more than a year, "how dare you stand in the way of SCIENCE!" isn't a very convincing case for continuing with business as usual.

If 3,500,000 people were killed (and millions more had permanent or lasting injuries) in elevator accidents in a year, would you tag a suggestion that "maybe we should use the stairs for a while" with the same :rolleyes: eye-rolling smilie?
But you would need to do some investigations on those very same lifts that are killing people to work out why.
 
Well there are not many definitive claims in here. Likelihoods and possibilities- maybe a pet theory- but those can change. If you need math-like proof, it does not exist, and never will. And not just for this question.

Not quite that much, but something more than conjecture and circumstance would be nice.
 
Epidemiology of the first cases:I should point out here that there is no evidence of an outbreak preceding the Wuhan outbreak that can explain the evolution of the 2 lineages.

As I noted earlier and in contradiction to the paper claiming all/most of the case could be connected to an animal market... yeah...no.


Summary:


And the recommendations are for further study.


“The earliest know case” is a sample size of one. As such it doesn’t tell us as much as you seem to think it does. For crossover in early Nov that case is the last in a line of infected hosts some 5 people long and there are several dozen other cases that were never identified. If half the infections were occurring elsewhere by this time there is a 50% chance that a one person sample is not going to have any particular connection to the epicenter of the pandemic.

Since cases are going to more common within networks of co-workers and families we’d still expect to see a large fraction of the cases within the network the first infection occurred in. IOW workers at the market\markets are still going to be the most commonly infected people this early, even if several dozen carriers have already been walking around spreading the virus to people with no direct connection to either market.


For an early Sept crossover that chain is up to 20 people and there are potentially tens of thousands of infected people walking around. I don’t find this credible since there would be hundreds of deaths by mid Dec.

What I found interesting was the evidence there was probably some spread of the virus before the identified cases in Wuhan. The same thing happened here in the Seattle area. Three cases were identified and researchers at Fred Hutch determined they were closely related meaning there was already a simmering epidemic here before it came to anyone's attention.
I'm not sure why that's interesting or surprising. 50% of all cases are asymptomatic, and only about 10% of cases are really serious. This means most early cases are going to be effectively untraceable even while they are spreading the virus. This is one of the major reasons why Covid-19 spread worldwide while SARS was easy to contain in comparison.
 
Huh? I'm trying to ascertain how certain we are about a September 2019 start time.
Did you ever get an answer to that?

I cited the studied that came up with that number yesterday. A summary of various estimates including the Septemeber estimate and otehrs can be found in a WHO report I'll name below. The September estimate is the earliest estimate in the report, so it's accepted but an outlier IMO.

I don't have a good link to share since the link I got this from was dynamic but this is the report that summarizes various estimates of the tMRCA. Table is on page 80. This is the WHO report mentioned several times over the past couple days.

WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2: China PartJoint WHO-China Study14January-10 February 2021Joint Report
 
I don't know if it is on-topic here, but it seems related to the issues here: What is the purpose of Gain of Function research? The ViW seems to have been doing this research (among many others all over the world), and the object seems to try to enable virus to be more efficient in infecting humans, which makes the lab leak theory so scary. But what exactly is the researchers trying to gain from being better able to infect humans - when we are not talking about miliary research?

Unless I'm mistaking the research you are referring to, the object is to identify viruses which have the potential to jump to humans before they actually do so in order to be ready for it when it occurs.
 
OK, allow me to address these issues.

Sherkeu said:
I had posted a while back about all of the flu samples China had on hand to test from their flu season- 300k samples across provinces? Maybe more.
Earlier reports said they did not retest any before December. There is no access to those samples to anyone. This should be one of the first areas looked at for the WHO team to gert good data related to origin. Did they say anything in the report about it? I have not read the whole thing (and didnt expect much from it but I could be surprised!).
The WHO Report does an extensive review of all the sentinel data collected in China in the months before the outbreak. There wasn't so much as a hint of any unusual respiratory infection activity anywhere in China until the Wuhan outbreak. There was the usual influenza and pneumonia activity as one would expect. And much of that was detected by sentinel culture sampling.



lomiller said:
“The earliest know case” is a sample size of one. As such it doesn’t tell us as much as you seem to think it does. For crossover in early Nov that case is the last in a line of infected hosts some 5 people long and there are several dozen other cases that were never identified. If half the infections were occurring elsewhere by this time there is a 50% chance that a one person sample is not going to have any particular connection to the epicenter of the pandemic.
That's not how it works. Researchers took the data of a hundred or so genomes from patients diagnosed with COVID 19 in the months around Dec, 2019. (The details are posted in the cites upthread, the exact number of genomes investigated isn't critical to the argument.)

From those genomes multiple researchers followed the trail backward in time to the earliest cases.

The conclusion of when the first cases occurred wasn't determined from finding the earliest patient though it turns out those first cases correlate with the timeline calculated from the genetic trail.


lomiller said:
Since cases are going to more common within networks of co-workers and families we’d still expect to see a large fraction of the cases within the network the first infection occurred in. IOW workers at the market\markets are still going to be the most commonly infected people this early, even if several dozen carriers have already been walking around spreading the virus to people with no direct connection to either market.
This kind of contact tracing wasn't done. You need to look at the evidence we have. However there was a paper by Dr Quay that noted the earliest cases clustered around the #2 mass transit line that leads from the WIV into the city. It's posted upthread.


lomiller said:
For an early Sept crossover that chain is up to 20 people and there are potentially tens of thousands of infected people walking around. I don’t find this credible since there would be hundreds of deaths by mid Dec.
No, the genome evidence does not support this number of cases in Sept 2019.


lomiller said:
I'm not sure why that's interesting or surprising. 50% of all cases are asymptomatic, and only about 10% of cases are really serious. This means most early cases are going to be effectively untraceable even while they are spreading the virus. This is one of the major reasons why Covid-19 spread worldwide while SARS was easy to contain in
The genetic trail is very clear and this did not happen.

Yes, mild cases are missed. But that doesn't mean we have no idea how many of these cases there were.

We know there is a consensus that two lineages turned up in Wuhan at the very beginning of the pandemic. There were clearly cases that led to these 2 lineages but there is no evidence said cases were extensive, and there is no evidence the initial cases occurred outside of Wuhan.

We do have an unanswered question: how did those 2 lineages diverge and where did they originate? It remains an unanswered question but that doesn't mean there were large numbers of cases outside of Wuhan that were all mild or asymptomatic. The genome map and all the usual surveillance of respiratory infection indicators in China show no hint of evolution outside of Wuhan.

Just like in the US, China monitors multiple indicators of the level of respiratory infection in the population. There were no spikes in mild URIs in China until the cases in Wuhan in late 2019.


Belz said:
Circumstantial stuff. That doesn't make much of a case.
Are you talking about the Hanta virus lab accident or something else?


Belz said:
In an area known for bat viruses and wet markets.
No, the area around Wuhan is not known for the species of bats within which coronaviruses circulate. Those occur hundreds of kilometers away in Southern China where the climate is different.

As for the wet markets, those occur all over China so cases of COVID turning up in Wuhan is still an improbable coincidence.


Belz said:
Woah, back up. Might not be true or turned out to not be true?
What turned out to be the case and it was backed up by the WHO Report is that the initial market cluster was consistent with a super-spreader event, not the initial crossover from an animal to people. 40+% of the earliest cases (earlier than the market cluster) had no connection to any animal market.


Belz said:
So basically you're asking me to think my way to a conclusion rather than follow hard evidence. Skepticism!
We are following the hard evidence. You don't seem to be reading any of the citations.


Belz said:
Not quite that much, but something more than conjecture and circumstance would be nice.
It's absurd to discount the pages and pages of evidence cited in this thread as "conjecture and circumstance". It's pretty clear you aren't interested in the evidence, preferring instead to dismiss the lab accident hypothesis out of hand.



RY said:
I cited the studied that came up with that number yesterday. A summary of various estimates including the Septemeber estimate and otehrs can be found in a WHO report I'll name below. The September estimate is the earliest estimate in the report, so it's accepted but an outlier IMO.
The range is from Sept to early Dec. That Sept is the earliest date in the range still leaves us with enough time for an accident to occur before the government took the WIV data offline. That is the important piece in the timeline.

Even if the earliest known cases were in Nov, there are still the two lineages to resolve. That adds enough time to the estimate of the first case to have occurred around the same time as the government took the data offline.
 
Unless I'm mistaking the research you are referring to, the object is to identify viruses which have the potential to jump to humans before they actually do so in order to be ready for it when it occurs.
How did that work out then? Did they accomplish their goal?

:mad:
 
Are you talking about the Hanta virus lab accident or something else?

I've not specified, have I? I'm talking about the responses to my challenge.

No, the area around Wuhan is not known for the species of bats within which coronaviruses circulate. Those occur hundreds of kilometers away in Southern China where the climate is different.

Noted.

As for the wet markets, those occur all over China so cases of COVID turning up in Wuhan is still an improbable coincidence.

How so? How do you calculate it to be improbable (and no, I'm not asking for math here)?

We are following the hard evidence.

That's odd; I was told there was no hard evidence. Can you confer and come back with a consistent answer?

It's absurd to discount the pages and pages of evidence cited in this thread as "conjecture and circumstance". It's pretty clear you aren't interested in the evidence, preferring instead to dismiss the lab accident hypothesis out of hand.

There's nothing absurd about it, and you can't dismiss me that easily. You've not shown that it came from a lab, full stop.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom