Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh for pity's sake! Thinking this is a gotcha or something is absurd given the totality of the evidence. I obviously got it somewhere reading Andersen's papers.

From the WHO report, page 80, Table 8. Time to the most common ancestor (tMRCA) inferred in different studies.
Quote from the first entry in the table:
That was the model Andersen referred to:
Notice the first line in the table referring to a Sept date uses wait for it... BEAST.


Given the virus had to have begun circulating shortly before the Wuhan cases appeared, one needs to potentially add another couple of weeks which coincides directly with the Chinese moving WIV research data offline. I assume this is what you are getting at.

That date is consistent with a lab accident event.

Even if you use an Oct date for the first cases, the time from an accident to an outbreak consists of some period of time > a few weeks. Add in that there were two lineages detected in Wuhan early in the outbreak and there needed to be some amount of time for those 2 lineages to diverge and you have a match to the Chinese purging WIV data in September.

Thank you. I wasn't doing a gotcha; I wanted to know what the source was and was puzzled about it.

Anyway, thank you.
 
I liked that Garry paper (pub just 10 days ago) because it seems to go through many of the possibilities that I did outside the "created or natural" false dichotomy so many have....but then it discounts some things we know are possible, like direct infection bat-human.

And why would 2 trips to two different markets be more likely? If the 'wild' animals infect each other and then, then so can the animals caged in the lab. And if there can be two wild mammals, then why not two humans? I guess he supposes they did not have live bats there and only cultures?
Because a segment was close to two pangolins from 2 years prior? If that was unique to that species, then we'd know pangolins carried it at some point....but we do not. Why can't it just be another bat a few inches away in confined cages?

ugh...I read it a few times and am more confused each time trying to figure his logic..... but I'll read it again. :eye-poppi

A lot of these papers we've cited make assertions: ergo the lab is unlikely/ruled out. When you look closely however, the authors filled in blanks with unsupported conclusions. For example claiming all the initial cases in Wuhan had connections to animal markets, they cite the WHO report and then lo and behold I look at the WHO reference and it clearly notes ~40+% of the early cases were not tied to animal markets.
 
Could it have developed in a wild animal that was then shipped to Wuhan markets? That leads back to the unavoidable, improbable coincidence it not only started where the WIV studying coronaviruses is located, but somehow 2 divergent lineages just happened to wind up there and nowhere else.

The suggestion by Garry is that two different animals carrying SARS-CoV2 coming from the same farm could have been shipped to two different markets in Wuhan, and that led to the divergent lineages.
 
I'm such a meanie!

Am I to assume that you have made up your mind that the Chinese government knew the virus was out and so scrubbed the databases in response?
It is one hypothesis and it was put out there by DRASTIC who also noted what specific data was taken down. The Sept date in no way discredits the hypothesis. So in that sense I am against discrediting viable evidence.

What's annoying is we've been through all this.
 
It is one hypothesis and it was put out there by DRASTIC who also noted what specific data was taken down. The Sept date in no way discredits the hypothesis. So in that sense I am against discrediting viable evidence.

What's annoying is we've been through all this.


Huh? I'm trying to ascertain how certain we are about a September 2019 start time.

If we can determine for sure that a September start time is a widely accepted plausiable start time.

And the databases were taken down then.

Then I agree it looks suspicious.

I want to be completely sure about that first so obviously I am going to test the solidity of the evidence.

There is nothing wrong with that at all.

You are so quick to roll your eyes, and to for Pity's sake, and to make "You are trying to do this because you are a horrible mean and nasty person" attacks yet what I asked was....

1) I asked about the Andersen claim before (and you also specified that the Sept 2019 date referred to Wuhan). From my memory, you couldn't find the source, so I had looked through the papers for the date and had been unable to find it.

2) You then made the claim again, so I just asked you, politiely, ["Could you link to the paper in which Andersen says this [September 2019 origin]?

His paper most frequently cited is this one. I have scanned through it but don't see the September 2019 date. I may have missed it."] to see if you could locate it this time.

Then you got angry. But when you explained it to me I said thank you.

And after I said thank you, you were still angry and accused me of having malign intent.

What gives?
 
I liked that Garry paper (pub just 10 days ago) because it seems to go through many of the possibilities that I did outside the "created or natural" false dichotomy so many have....but then it discounts some things we know are possible, like direct infection bat-human.

Are you going to respond to my request any time soon?
 
Two other points on the Garry paper

The paper says:
Hybrids of natural and Lab Leak scenarios have been suggested (Relman, 2020; Baker, 2020). Some variations on a hybrid scenario suggest that SARS-CoV-2 is a natural virus that infected a scientist while doing field work resulting in mildly symptomatic or asymptomatic spread or that after being brought back to a laboratory SARS-CoV-2 was released unknowingly, but not successfully cultured or otherwise manipulated. Compared to the millions of worldwide encounters of humans with wildlife, including the trapping of bats for food, the number of high-risk exposures of scientists doing field or laboratory work with samples from wildlife is miniscule.

First, the team is selective. They know where some 'danger of spillover' ones are located- because it already happened. I would think those Yunnan caves would be on the topsuperurgent priority list for consistent study every year. The locals had antibodies to bat viruses and then they had those 4 miners die of a SARS-like disease.

Also, while I cannot confirm their source right now, the DRASTIC team SG mentioned claimed that, after those deaths, the Chinese gov't moved inhabitants of the village near the old mine to a safer distance claiming "water contamination."

Second, the paper claims that
There are no documented cases of laboratory infections with previously unknown, but pathogenic, viruses. Thus, hybrid scenarios are of very low probability.

Shi herself documented such a case in 2010 saying:
the full-length genome sequence revealed that this was a new Hantaan virus isolate, designated strain KY. Sequence analysis of the three genome segments indicated that this new isolate is a reassortant derived from human and rat Hantaan viruses. Further sequence analysis of the medium (M) genome segment revealed that it originated from a recombination event between two rat Hantaan virus lineages.

It may not count since one species of those rats might have already carried a human-enabled virus and the other infected rat species kept the ability. She doesnt say. But it was new, a hybrid, infected 15 people, and came from the lab!
 
Second, the paper claims that


Shi herself documented such a case in 2010 saying:


It may not count since one species of those rats might have already carried a human-enabled virus and the other infected rat species kept the ability. She doesnt say. But it was new, a hybrid, infected 15 people, and came from the lab!

"new Hantaan virus isolate"

A new isolate, but not a new virus.

The claim is that a brand new virus previously unknown escaped from a lab.
 
Huh? I'm trying to ascertain how certain we are about a September 2019 start time.
You want a fixed date when we have ranges of possible times.

If we can determine for sure that a September start time is a widely accepted plausiable start time.
It is definitely plausible. That's based on the evidence posted in this thread. If you are looking for some kind of consensus you won't find it yet.

And the databases were taken down then.
Then I agree it looks suspicious.
Of course it is suspicious, you don't need to agree. Got any alternative explanations for why else it was done?

I want to be completely sure about that first so obviously I am going to test the solidity of the evidence.

There is nothing wrong with that at all.
That's up to you. I don't care.

You are so quick to roll your eyes, and to for Pity's sake, and to make "You are trying to do this because you are a horrible mean and nasty person" attacks yet what I asked was....
Like I said, you are bringing up stuff that was discussed and pretending you never got your answers. But you did, you didn't look at the citations.

1) I asked about the Andersen claim before (and you also specified that the Sept 2019 date referred to Wuhan). From my memory, you couldn't find the source, so I had looked through the papers for the date and had been unable to find it.
No, not buying it. You looked for some expected spoonful and as far as I can tell you are skipping half or more of what's been posted.

2) You then made the claim again, so I just asked you, politiely, ["Could you link to the paper in which Andersen says this [September 2019 origin]?

His paper most frequently cited is this one. I have scanned through it but don't see the September 2019 date. I may have missed it."] to see if you could locate it this time.

Then you got angry. But when you explained it to me I said thank you.

And after I said thank you, you were still angry and accused me of having malign intent.

What gives?
Is it or is it not true that Sept has been within the range of possible dates of the first cases? So did I imagine it earlier on or did you simply fail to get the spoon fed answer you were looking for?
 
"new Hantaan virus isolate"

A new isolate, but not a new virus.

The claim is that a brand new virus previously unknown escaped from a lab.

NIH: Hantavirus outbreak associated with laboratory rats in Yunnan, China
Abstract
An outbreak of hemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome occurred among students in a college (College A) in Kunming, Yunnan province, China in 2003. Subsequent investigations revealed the presence of hantavirus antibodies and antigens in laboratory rats at College A and two other institutions. Hantavirus antibodies were detected in 15 additional individuals other than the index case in these three locations. Epidemiologic data indicated that the human infections were a result of zoonotic transmission of the virus from laboratory rats. A virus was isolated from rats in College A and the full-length genome sequence revealed that this was a new Hantaan virus isolate, designated strain KY. Sequence analysis of the three genome segments indicated that this new isolate is a reassortant derived from human and rat Hantaan viruses. Further sequence analysis of the medium (M) genome segment revealed that it originated from a recombination event between two rat Hantaan virus lineages.
It's pretty simple.

And no, we aren't talking about something drastically different here.
 
Last edited:
You want a fixed date when we have ranges of possible times.

It is definitely plausible. That's based on the evidence posted in this thread. If you are looking for some kind of consensus you won't find it yet.

Of course it is suspicious, you don't need to agree. Got any alternative explanations for why else it was done?

That's up to you. I don't care.

Like I said, you are bringing up stuff that was discussed and pretending you never got your answers. But you did, you didn't look at the citations.

No, not buying it. You looked for some expected spoonful and as far as I can tell you are skipping half or more of what's been posted.

Is it or is it not true that Sept has been within the range of possible dates of the first cases? So did I imagine it earlier on or did you simply fail to get the spoon fed answer you were looking for?

Have it your way then. Stay angry if you like.
 
Have it your way then. Stay angry if you like.
I'm not angry. Answer the highlighted questions:

Is it or is it not true that Sept has been within the range of possible dates of the first cases?

So did I imagine it earlier on or did you simply fail to get the spoon fed answer you were looking for?
 
Last edited:
Are you going to respond to my request any time soon?

Oh yeah! I think SG gave you a pretty good overview. (though your lazy-reading self didnt deserve it! :p)

It starts with simply noticing some incredible coincidences of location. "Bat coronavirus pandemic starts next to the world premiere lab studying bat coronaviruses."

Then the wet market story turns out not to be true. The first (confirmed) patient was a month before and not connected to the market. The claims of massive testing at the markets with lots of positive tests turned out not to involve a single infected animal.

Just look to the areas you think would be most convincing to you and see if you can make sense of it. The science is interesting to learn about and most of the main papers are linked in the thread somewhere if you search for them.
 
...
It starts with simply noticing some incredible coincidences of location. "Bat coronavirus pandemic starts next to the world premiere lab studying bat coronaviruses."

Then the wet market story turns out not to be true. The first (confirmed) patient was a month before and not connected to the market. The claims of massive testing at the markets with lots of positive tests turned out not to involve a single infected animal. ...
Adding to that, something I said in the beginning of this discussion: "Most (all?) of the coronaviruses they were studying did not naturally occur in the Wuhan area."


We have gone through the evidence there was gain of function research with live coronaviruses occurring at the WIV. Despite the fact it was denied later that any live viral cultures were studied in the WIV, earlier papers by the researchers there reported on research with live viral cultures. And that's not even including the evidence there were cages at the WIV for bats.


We are left to explain the divergence early on into 2 distinct lineages. Capsid and Chris Halkides are convinced that is evidence it didn't start at the lab.
If correct and the WHO report found no evidence of any outbreak prior to the Wuhan cases, and no animal source has been found...

So where did those lineages diverge and where is the evidence for that?
The only support for the hypothesis the virus emerged in a wild animal that was then sold at the Wuhan markets has some very big holes. 40+% of the early cases in Wuhan had no connection to any wet market, and, no infected animal has been found.
 
The important thing is that if the virus escaped from a Chinese lab then they are to blame for the 3.5 million deaths and global economic damage, which justifies demonizing the Chinese government while excusing our own incompetent response.

There's just one problem with that - until March 2020 the US government was funding coronavirus research in Wuhan. Trump ended funding after learning that $3.7 million had gone to the Wuhan lab, which is an admission of our own government's part in it and an attempt to distance himself from it (if the virus really did escape from the Wuhan lab - or even if it didn't!).


Sherkeu said:
It may not count since one species of those rats might have already carried a human-enabled virus and the other infected rat species kept the ability. She doesnt say. But it was new, a hybrid, infected 15 people, and came from the lab!
The conclusion is obvious - we must immediately stop all coronavirus research, particularly in countries which are likely to harbor strains that could jump to humans. This is the only way to prevent future outbreaks! :rolleyes:

We can just stick to the science and let it lead us where the evidence goes, but when the source of this outbreak is exposed it will be used for political ends. We can only hope that those ends are more constructive than destructive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom