angrysoba
Philosophile
Oh for pity's sake! Thinking this is a gotcha or something is absurd given the totality of the evidence. I obviously got it somewhere reading Andersen's papers.
From the WHO report, page 80, Table 8. Time to the most common ancestor (tMRCA) inferred in different studies.
Quote from the first entry in the table:
That was the model Andersen referred to:
Notice the first line in the table referring to a Sept date uses wait for it... BEAST.
Given the virus had to have begun circulating shortly before the Wuhan cases appeared, one needs to potentially add another couple of weeks which coincides directly with the Chinese moving WIV research data offline. I assume this is what you are getting at.
That date is consistent with a lab accident event.
Even if you use an Oct date for the first cases, the time from an accident to an outbreak consists of some period of time > a few weeks. Add in that there were two lineages detected in Wuhan early in the outbreak and there needed to be some amount of time for those 2 lineages to diverge and you have a match to the Chinese purging WIV data in September.
Thank you. I wasn't doing a gotcha; I wanted to know what the source was and was puzzled about it.
Anyway, thank you.