Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
One researcher, Andersen, did calculate, using a biological clock, back to Sept. 2019. At that point he found two distinct lineages. And that is where it's being argued that is evidence it didn't start in Wuhan.

I think I asked you this before but where does Andersen claim it began in September 2019?
 
Epidemiology of the first cases:
The earliest cases were mostly
resident in the central districts of Wuhan, but cases began to appear in all districts of Wuhan in mid- to
late December 2019 (Fig. 23).
I should point out here that there is no evidence of an outbreak preceding the Wuhan outbreak that can explain the evolution of the 2 lineages.

As I noted earlier and in contradiction to the paper claiming all/most of the case could be connected to an animal market... yeah...no.
For those cases where the information was available, 55.4% had a history of recent exposure to a
market:28.0% to the Huanan market only, 22.6% to other markets only, and 4.8% to both. 44.6% had no history of market exposure (see Fig. 24 and Annex E4). Cases with market exposure were more
evident among the early cases but exposure to other markets occurred in the earliest cases as much as
exposure to the Huanan market. The case reported with the earliest onset date (8 December) had no
history of exposure to the Huanan market.


Summary:
The joint international team concluded that:
1. Linking genomic data with epidemiological data is essential for molecular analysis in support
of origin-tracing studies.
2. Quality control of genome sequencing is important to provide reliable results.
3. Viruses from some Huanan market cases were identical, suggesting a spreading event.
4. Analysis of early case genomes also showed some diversity, suggesting additional sources and
unrecognized circulation.

5. Estimates of the time to most recent common ancestor (from literature and re-analysis) suggest
that virus transmission or circulation date might be recent, in late 2019.
6. Up to now, the most closely related genomic sequences have been found in bats.
7. Reports of detection of SARS-CoV-2 in cases and environmental samples before January 2020
in different parts of the world require follow-up.


And the recommendations are for further study.


What I found interesting was the evidence there was probably some spread of the virus before the identified cases in Wuhan. The same thing happened here in the Seattle area. Three cases were identified and researchers at Fred Hutch determined they were closely related meaning there was already a simmering epidemic here before it came to anyone's attention.
 
I think I asked you this before but where does Andersen claim it began in September 2019?

That was his biological clock model looking for the earliest common ancestors. The WHO report also notes the same thing but they found the most common consensus was late Nov.

But put together with a bit of simmering before cases were detected and you get a few weeks to months before the Dec cases.

From the WHO report, page 80 is: Table 8. Time to the most common ancestor (tMRCA) inferred in different studies.
2019, late September ... strict clock model

We still have to explain the 2 lineages and to do that you need a few earlier cases. With no evidence those cases began outside Wuhan one has to consider these dates do agree with the government taking a lot of research offline in Sept.
 
Sorry, don't follow your reasoning there.
One need not assume anything, just read the papers.

Clock and TMRCA based on 27 genomes - January 25, 2020
Kristian Andersen, Scripps Research
Following up on the analyses provided by Andrew Rambaut this is a brief report estimating the evolutionary rate and timing of the epidemic (date of the most recent ancestor (MRCA)) based on 27 publicly shared n2019-nCoV genome sequences. Compared to earlier analyses where several parameters had to be fixed, there is now enough information content in the sequences to obtain reasonable estimates of the clock and TMRCA without fixing parameters. This work is for information purposes only and is not intended for publication. All the data used here is provided by the laboratories listed below through NCBI Genbank or GISAID....

A phylogenetic tree was created using PhyML and in agreement with previous analyses, still shows limited genetic variation in the sampled viruses, which is consistent with a recent common ancestor. Two distinct clusters can also be seen from the tree, consistent with reported human clusters of cases 224 (shown in orange and red)....

Back to the 2 lineages diverging:
We are starting to see more structure in the tree and overall the genetic data is highly suggestive of a single-point introduction into the human population followed by sustained human-to-human transmission. This introduction was likely via either a single infected animal or a small cluster of recently infected animals directly into either a single human individual or a small cluster of human individuals. All subsequent cases are the result of human-to-human transmission with no further evidence of zoonotic transmissions. ...

The ranges are more appropriate for interpretation of the dates, as opposed to any one of point media values mentioned above. They are all likely to change - possibly significantly - as more patients are sampled and genomes produced.


This update from March 2020 has been cited more than once here. Nature: The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2
 
I'm not sure where you are going with this but really, man, keeping up on what's been posted is your best bet.
I think I am up to speed.


Since the stuff you just quoted includes the possibility that the introduction began with a small cluster of humans and, further, from a small cluster of animals, there is the possibility that the last common ancestor does not correspond with the beginning of the pandemic but precedes it. The last common ancestor would be in that cluster of animals not in humans in that case.
 
I think I am up to speed.


Since the stuff you just quoted includes the possibility that the introduction began with a small cluster of humans and, further, from a small cluster of animals, there is the possibility that the last common ancestor does not correspond with the beginning of the pandemic but precedes it. The last common ancestor would be in that cluster of animals not in humans in that case.
That bolded part is a given.

You can't make up imaginary genomes to uncover the animal origin. You have COVID 19 and it jumped to humans some time before the pandemic started.

There are closely related coronaviruses in bats. There's a genetic gap between those and the human pandemic coronavirus.

One thing I did get from the WHO report is they did a very thorough job showing the pandemic began in Wuhan. There's a lot of discussion in the report about hints of potentially earlier cases but nothing that is conclusive. What is conclusive, however, is there was no evidence of anything close to an outbreak in China before the Wuhan cases.

China uses a lot of the same kinds of surveillance we do here in the US looking at ILIs (influenza like illnesses), pneumonia deaths, excess mortality, surveillance cultures, and so on. Nothing ticked up on the radar until Dec in Wuhan.

By the time it did show up in Wuhan there were 2 lineages. And there were disconnected cases meaning the virus was circulating before it was detected and we don't have all the in between cases. But unless it simmered and simmered before taking off, then all the evidence points to it beginning in Wuhan.

Is there any evidence it jumped to humans elsewhere? Not really.

Is there evidence the two divergent lineages were introduced to humans elsewhere? Not really.

Could it have developed in a wild animal that was then shipped to Wuhan markets? That leads back to the unavoidable, improbable coincidence it not only started where the WIV studying coronaviruses is located, but somehow 2 divergent lineages just happened to wind up there and nowhere else.
 
Last edited:
Could you link to the paper in which Andersen says this [September 2019 origin]?

His paper most frequently cited is this one. I have scanned through it but don't see the September 2019 date. I may have missed it.

Oh for pity's sake! Thinking this is a gotcha or something is absurd given the totality of the evidence. I obviously got it somewhere reading Andersen's papers.

From the WHO report, page 80, Table 8. Time to the most common ancestor (tMRCA) inferred in different studies.
Quote from the first entry in the table:
2019, late September ... strict clock model
That was the model Andersen referred to:
To estimate the substitution rate of nCoV-2019, I used BEAST 116 with a simple model consisting of HKYγ, strict clock with a CTMC rate prior, and a constant tree prior.
Notice the first line in the table referring to a Sept date uses wait for it... BEAST.


Given the virus had to have begun circulating shortly before the Wuhan cases appeared, one needs to potentially add another couple of weeks which coincides directly with the Chinese moving WIV research data offline. I assume this is what you are getting at.

That date is consistent with a lab accident event.

Even if you use an Oct date for the first cases, the time from an accident to an outbreak consists of some period of time > a few weeks. Add in that there were two lineages detected in Wuhan early in the outbreak and there needed to be some amount of time for those 2 lineages to diverge and you have a match to the Chinese purging WIV data in September.
 
Are you looking for this (different author than you are asking about though):

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1201971220306950
Thank you. :)

I did see that paper:
The tMRCA was inferred in late September 2019 (95% CI 08 August–26 October 2019, Table 2, Figure S2B), which was about two months before the early cases of SARS-CoV-2 (Huang et al., 2020).

Andersen was cited in the above paper. I was on one of my rabbit hole dives when I looked at a lot of that stuff. I didn't cite all the papers I read.
 
Just to be clear, I'm pretty sure that is the paper behind the first line of the page 80 WHO report you've quoted recently. Do you agree?
 
Is there evidence the two divergent lineages were introduced to humans elsewhere? Not really.

Could it have developed in a wild animal that was then shipped to Wuhan markets? That leads back to the unavoidable, improbable coincidence it not only started where the WIV studying coronaviruses is located, but somehow 2 divergent lineages just happened to wind up there and nowhere else.

I liked that Garry paper (pub just 10 days ago) because it seems to go through many of the possibilities that I did outside the "created or natural" false dichotomy so many have....but then it discounts some things we know are possible, like direct infection bat-human.

And why would 2 trips to two different markets be more likely? If the 'wild' animals infect each other, then so can the animals caged in the lab. And if there can be two wild mammals, then why not two humans? I guess he supposes they did not have live bats there and only cultures?
Because a segment was close to two pangolins from 2 years prior? If that was unique to that species, then we'd know pangolins carried it at some point....but we do not. Why can't it just be another bat a few inches away in confined cages?

ugh...I read it a few times and am more confused each time trying to figure his logic..... but I'll read it again. :eye-poppi
 
Last edited:
Just to be clear, I'm pretty sure that is the paper behind the first line of the page 80 WHO report you've quoted recently. Do you agree?

I'm not sure but does it matter?


We were posting right along when I found the evidence Chinese officials had removed a whole bunch of research data that had been available online.

An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline
On the 12th Sep 2019, the main database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline. Eventually every single of the 16 virus databases managed by the WIV was taken offline. Here we show how these databases may provide essential clues at to the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and review the circumstances in which they were taken offline.

The removal date in Sept, 2019, naturally begged the question: if it were related to the pandemic virus, how did they know before the pandemic was discovered?

I recalled reading the Sept date for the first cases. I recall it was in a paper by Andersen but regardless, I did read about that potential date of the first cases.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom