The animal began in the wild.That animal hasn't been identified. It would be known if it was in a lab.
There are animals in the Wuhan lab.
I am looking at facts only.
The animal began in the wild.That animal hasn't been identified. It would be known if it was in a lab.
The animal began in the wild.
There are animals in the Wuhan lab.
I am looking at facts only.
Yes from an animal gathered from the wild. There was sufficient fear that a virus might infect humans from this animal it was experimented upon.
The experiment proved the hazard.
Then, to see if the new chimeras could infect people, they were tested against human airway cells and “humanized” mice — mice bred to have human ACE-2 receptors on their organs.
Recall that SARS infected 3 different labs even after it was under control, and 3 separate times just at one high level BS-4 lab in Beijing.
That animal hasn't been identified. It would be known if it was in a lab.
This may be a cultural point here. I don't know about China, except from the bit that I just quoted, but here in Japan it is also the same that people may just drop in at a hospital for relatively minor illnesses. When I first came here, I would sometimes be surprised when people said they had been to hospital "Oh my God! Are you okay?" - "Yeah, I just had a cold/headache etc..."
I can find no record that China has a BSL-4 lab in Beijing. There are quite a few references to the Wuhan lab being China's first BSL-4 lab when it was completed in 2015.
The Chinese government putting out a report the virus emerged in a wild animal farm and was shipped to various wet markets is a CT. Daszak pushing his various theories, directing the WHO team to look elsewhere is a CT.The virus itself would be know if it were in a lab unless there is a conspiracy to hide the fact that it was known in a lab. All "Escape from a lab theories" require such a conspiracy and are, by definition, conspiracy theories. All with all persistent conspiracy theories, no evidence of any actual conspiracy has been presented, and any expert in a position to actually debunk the conspiracy theory is discounted as being "compromised".
The virus itself would be know if it were in a lab unless there is a conspiracy to hide the fact that it was known in a lab. All "Escape from a lab theories" require such a conspiracy and are, by definition, conspiracy theories. All with all persistent conspiracy theories, no evidence of any actual conspiracy has been presented, and any expert in a position to actually debunk the conspiracy theory is discounted as being "compromised".
Cuomo's report was one of several I posted. What I posted Cuomo's for was his flashback to an interview with Daszak a year ago and then Cuomo discussed how that opinion which he initially held, had now changed.I've highlighted the bit that makes it unwatchable for me.![]()
It was noted that the 3 WIV employees may or may not have had a serious infection. The fact anyone at the lab was ill during late 2019 is also relevant because the head of the lab denied anyone at all at the lab had been ill during that time period.But indeed, I agree we need more information from the WIV.
As a counterpoint, in the WSJ article that was linked before was one of the members of the WHO investigators:
This may be a cultural point here. I don't know about China, except from the bit that I just quoted, but here in Japan it is also the same that people may just drop in at a hospital for relatively minor illnesses. When I first came here, I would sometimes be surprised when people said they had been to hospital "Oh my God! Are you okay?" - "Yeah, I just had a cold/headache etc..."
On the 12th Sep 2019, the main database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline. Eventually every single of the 16 virus databases managed by the WIV was taken offline. Here we show how these databases may provide essential clues at to the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and review the circumstances in which they were taken offline.
After a lot of trial and error, the Seeker stumbled upon exactly what he was looking for: a master's thesis written by a Chinese doctor. The document contained an account of six cases of "severe pneumonia caused by unknown viruses" in workers who had been cleaning an abandoned copper mine in Yunnan, China, in 2012. The patients' symptoms seemed eerily similar to those of COVID-19. Three of the patients, it said, died from the mystery illness.
The Yunnan mine and its resident bats, the Seeker knew, had been sampled by researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. He'd uncovered a missing puzzle piece: an association between the closest known relative of the coronavirus and research conducted at the institute in Wuhan, China.
"Finding it, at that moment, felt big," the Seeker, says, "like a homicide detective solving a cold case."
Minutes after reading the abstract, he posted his find to Twitter, in a long tweet thread tagging members of a loosely defined group known as Drastic, a "Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19." The master's thesis had the potential to rewrite the origin story of the pandemic.
OK then, I misunderstood this:Nobody said anything about a final word except you. The tentative conclusion is that it came, as diseases often do, from an animal source. Do you or do you not have evidence that it didn't?
I accept that's not what you meantBelz said:Oh, look! There's evidence that it jumped from bats to us. Gee, who'd have thought, eh?
The thread is full of this evidence.Ok, what are you waiting for, then?
I accept that's not what you meant
The thread is full of this evidence.
The closest virus has been found in bats in Yunnan and it was capable of infecting people directly with no intermediary species step. And samples of that virus were collected by researchers at the WIV.
So when you say there is evidence it jumped from bats to people it is a viable hypothesis.
So what is missing to say the lab was definitely the source?
Yeah, as in there's evidence to support it. That doesn't mean that it's the only possible explanation. But THAT doesn't mean that we can wildly speculate.
I think it's reasonable here to speculate that you jumped into this thread without reading it.
There is a lot of info that may give you some insight into where the conversation is at this point after hundreds of posts with a lot of facts and research.
There's a CT thread if you want to discuss the origin in terms other than evidence based. Please use it.
I'm not buying that "associated with different wildlife markets" without the detailed evidence. (Apparently it is in the WHO report.)In Lab Leak scenarios diversification of SARS-CoV-2 to its two separate early lineages A and B would have had to occur in the laboratory setting. Lab Leak scenarios must also account for the fact that the majority of early cases were associated with different wildlife markets in Wuhan.
I'll need to look at the WHO Report (next post).Theories on SARS-CoV-2 must also account for the fact that two distinct lineages of SARS-CoV-2 were distributed at different Wuhan wildlife markets.
So in that scenario ready to go viruses (ie matched to human cells) circulated in some wildlife species prior to said animals being shipped to Wuhan markets. And yet the virus did not emerge sporadically all over China, but only in Wuhan. And twice in Wuhan at about the same time no less.It also provides simple explanations for the fact that two different lineages of SARS-CoV-2 were linked to markets. In one possible scenario divergence of SARS-CoV-2 to lineages A and B occurred prior to the transport of infected animals to Wuhan and the infected animals were subsequently distributed to different wildlife markets.
Yes but, the super-spreader event at the Wuhan market also explains all those findings.A temporal analysis of the early human cases at the Huanan market confirms the pattern of spread from the areas of the market where wildlife products were sold to other parts of the market.
WHO, 2021. “WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS- CoV-2: China part”; www.who.int/publications/i/item/who-convened-global-study-of-origins-of-sars-cov-2-china-part.
The report of the international team on their Wuhan field visit, from 14 January -10 February 2021, was published today as WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus called for further studies. ...
The Chinese government putting out a report the virus emerged in a wild animal farm and was shipped to various wet markets is a CT. Daszak pushing his various theories, directing the WHO team to look elsewhere is a CT.
See how that works?
There's a CT thread if you want to discuss the origin in terms other than evidence based. Please use it.
No details.Many of the early cases were associated with the Huanan market, but a similar number of cases were
associated with other markets and some were not associated with any markets. Transmission within the
wider community in December could account for cases not associated with the Huanan market which,
together with the presence of early cases not associated with that market, could suggest that the Huanan
market was not the original source of the outbreak. Other milder cases that were not identified, however,
could provide the link between the Huanan market and early cases without an apparent link to the
market. No firm conclusion therefore about the role of the Huanan market in the origin of the outbreak,
or how the infection was introduced into the market, can currently be drawn
I believe this was serological evidence, not verified PCR samples. We discussed that upthread.Finally, the team reviewed data from published studies from different countries suggesting early
circulation of SARS-CoV-2. The findings suggest that circulation of SARS-CoV-2 preceded the initial
detection of cases by several weeks. Some of the suspected positive samples were detected even earlier ....
However, the presence of SARS-CoV-2 has not been detected
through sampling and testing of bats or of wildlife across China. More than 80 000 wildlife, livestock
and poultry samples were collected from 31 provinces in China and no positive result was identified for
SARS-CoV-2 antibody or nucleic acid before and after the SARS-CoV-2 outbreak in China. Through
extensive testing of animal products in the Huanan market, no evidence of animal infections was found. ...
Preliminary sampling and testing of other markets in
Wuhan and upstream suppliers to the Huanan market taken during 2020 did not reveal evidence of
SARS-CoV-2 circulating in animals...
The joint team’s assessment of likelihood of each possible pathway was as follows:
• direct zoonotic spillover is considered to be a possible-to-likely pathway;
• introduction through an intermediate host is considered to be a likely to very likely pathway;
• introduction through cold/ food chain products is considered a possible pathway;
• introduction through a laboratory incident was considered to be an extremely unlikely pathway.
It also directly infects endothelial cells lining the
blood vessels, unusually for a human respiratory virus.
Definitely not consistent with wide distribution via infected animals shipped all over China.Conclusions
Based on the sentinel surveillance data for ILI, and the associated laboratory-confirmed influenza
activity, in Wuhan as well as Hubei and six surrounding provinces, there was a marked increase in ILI
in both children and adults at the end of 2019 in Wuhan, but no evidence to suggest substantial SARSCoV-2 transmission in the months preceding the outbreak in December was observed. The increase in
ILI is mirrored in the remainder of Hubei Province and in neighbouring provinces and municipalities.
While this increase may be explained by a contemporary increase in laboratory-confirmed influenza
activity, further time series analyses were recommended and are underway to ensure that no other
signals are present. ...
Conclusions
Review of retrospective testing of respiratory tract swabs collected within the ILI and SARI surveillance
system, and the adult sentinel surveillance data for ILI from one hospital in Wuhan and SARI
surveillance data from a provincial hospital in Hubei Province revealed no clear indication of substantial
unrecognized circulation of SARS-CoV-2 in Wuhan during the latter part of 2019. Further time series
analyses are underway.
Conclusions
Analysis of four months of aggregated retail pharmacy purchases for antipyretics, cold and cough
medications over a period of four years was unlikely to provide a useful indicator of early SARS-CoV2 activity in the community.
Given the time lag from onset of disease to COVID-19-associated death of a median of 17 days (12-22
days) in Wuhan, the documented rapid increase in all-cause mortality in week 3 of 2020 and pneumoniaspecific deaths in week 3 of 2020 suggests that virus transmission was widespread among the population
of Wuhan by the first week (1-7 January) of 2020. The steep incline in mortality rate occurred with 1-
2 weeks’ delay among the population in the Hubei Province outside Wuhan, supporting the previously
reported (16) notion that the epidemic in Wuhan predated the spread in the rest of Hubei Province.