Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The animal began in the wild.

There are animals in the Wuhan lab.

I am looking at facts only.

You are talking about wild animals in the lab? Which wild animals are we talking about?

I don't know if this is correct or not, so I would be interested in what you mean by this, and how it fits in.

Are you talking about live bats, taken from Yunnan Province, for example?
 
I am not aware that there were any wild animals kept at the WIV labs.

There were apparently "humanized mice" that were used as animal models.

Then, to see if the new chimeras could infect people, they were tested against human airway cells and “humanized” mice — mice bred to have human ACE-2 receptors on their organs.
 
Recall that SARS infected 3 different labs even after it was under control, and 3 separate times just at one high level BS-4 lab in Beijing.

I can find no record that China has a BSL-4 lab in Beijing. There are quite a few references to the Wuhan lab being China's first BSL-4 lab when it was completed in 2015.
 
That animal hasn't been identified. It would be known if it was in a lab.

The virus itself would be know if it were in a lab unless there is a conspiracy to hide the fact that it was known in a lab. All "Escape from a lab theories" require such a conspiracy and are, by definition, conspiracy theories. All with all persistent conspiracy theories, no evidence of any actual conspiracy has been presented, and any expert in a position to actually debunk the conspiracy theory is discounted as being "compromised".
 
Last edited:
This may be a cultural point here. I don't know about China, except from the bit that I just quoted, but here in Japan it is also the same that people may just drop in at a hospital for relatively minor illnesses. When I first came here, I would sometimes be surprised when people said they had been to hospital "Oh my God! Are you okay?" - "Yeah, I just had a cold/headache etc..."

Are the hospitals also more likely to admit patients as well? 'Went to the hospital' vs 'was hospitalized' seems an important distinction.
 
I can find no record that China has a BSL-4 lab in Beijing. There are quite a few references to the Wuhan lab being China's first BSL-4 lab when it was completed in 2015.

You are right!!
The exact quote in Nature (2017 -when the Wuhan BS-4 was accredited)
"The Sars virus has escaped from high level containment facilities in Beijing multiple times" and it goes on to discuss safety in Bs-4 levels, and how "the next ones are expected to be in Beijing and Kunming".

The BS-4 safety labs arent really involved. (That was surprising to me!)
SARS and the bat corona viruses did not require that level, and, to my knowledge, they did not use it. BS-2 and BS-3 were used.
 
The virus itself would be know if it were in a lab unless there is a conspiracy to hide the fact that it was known in a lab. All "Escape from a lab theories" require such a conspiracy and are, by definition, conspiracy theories. All with all persistent conspiracy theories, no evidence of any actual conspiracy has been presented, and any expert in a position to actually debunk the conspiracy theory is discounted as being "compromised".
The Chinese government putting out a report the virus emerged in a wild animal farm and was shipped to various wet markets is a CT. Daszak pushing his various theories, directing the WHO team to look elsewhere is a CT.

See how that works?

There's a CT thread if you want to discuss the origin in terms other than evidence based. Please use it.
 
The virus itself would be know if it were in a lab unless there is a conspiracy to hide the fact that it was known in a lab. All "Escape from a lab theories" require such a conspiracy and are, by definition, conspiracy theories. All with all persistent conspiracy theories, no evidence of any actual conspiracy has been presented, and any expert in a position to actually debunk the conspiracy theory is discounted as being "compromised".

I think you are missing several possibilities. A virus can enter the lab or be created in a lab without the researchers ever knowing it. A few pages back I described this exact scenario of a novel recombinant Hanta virus popping up between 2 rodent species and infecting 2 of Shi's students.

There were also many viruses that were never sequenced. And with live bats, they mutate very fast and can hold several viruses at once and create recombinant ones.
There is also a possibility of it coming in from field research in Yunnan- from a virus that was not even collected.
Unlike the Hanta example, Sars-CoV-2 could have slowly circulated a while with the young staffers and their experiments already 'disposed' of without anything left to test.
There are many possibilities more likely than "some unknown source" of bat-derived virus that happens to pop up next to the lab that studied them.

Simply put: We know corona viruses that can infect humans were at the Wuhan lab and used in 'human function' experiments. We know the outbreak began in Wuhan near that lab. We know that no pre-cursor virus closer than one that was in the lab has been found in any other animals, or through the markets, or wildlife farms.

The "Conspiracy theorist" accusations are getting old. I think they will die out soon. The tide of expert (and public) opinion is turning.
 
I've highlighted the bit that makes it unwatchable for me. :D
Cuomo's report was one of several I posted. What I posted Cuomo's for was his flashback to an interview with Daszak a year ago and then Cuomo discussed how that opinion which he initially held, had now changed.

Bob's link contains a thorough discussion of all the aspects of the evolving evidence and opinions from more than a year ago until now.

But indeed, I agree we need more information from the WIV.

As a counterpoint, in the WSJ article that was linked before was one of the members of the WHO investigators:

This may be a cultural point here. I don't know about China, except from the bit that I just quoted, but here in Japan it is also the same that people may just drop in at a hospital for relatively minor illnesses. When I first came here, I would sometimes be surprised when people said they had been to hospital "Oh my God! Are you okay?" - "Yeah, I just had a cold/headache etc..."
It was noted that the 3 WIV employees may or may not have had a serious infection. The fact anyone at the lab was ill during late 2019 is also relevant because the head of the lab denied anyone at all at the lab had been ill during that time period.

Earlier in this thread the fact people in the lab had been ill was noted. We also noted evidence of the claim was lacking. There were images of a full parking lot at one of the hospitals in Wuhan. I don't remember the details without going back to the beginning of the thread except that it was also considered questionable evidence.


What has changed here is the report on the employee illnesses has been released. Again, we don't know how serious their illnesses were. And again, it is evidence the claim no one at the lab had been ill was likely false. It impeaches the rest of the claims by the same person that no viruses the lab was studying matched COVID 19.


I believe I posted this earlier but this is a good time to repost it: An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline
On the 12th Sep 2019, the main database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline. Eventually every single of the 16 virus databases managed by the WIV was taken offline. Here we show how these databases may provide essential clues at to the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and review the circumstances in which they were taken offline.


The DRASIC website, and a bit more about the group: How the coronavirus origin story is being rewritten by a guerrilla Twitter group
After a lot of trial and error, the Seeker stumbled upon exactly what he was looking for: a master's thesis written by a Chinese doctor. The document contained an account of six cases of "severe pneumonia caused by unknown viruses" in workers who had been cleaning an abandoned copper mine in Yunnan, China, in 2012. The patients' symptoms seemed eerily similar to those of COVID-19. Three of the patients, it said, died from the mystery illness.

The Yunnan mine and its resident bats, the Seeker knew, had been sampled by researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
He'd uncovered a missing puzzle piece: an association between the closest known relative of the coronavirus and research conducted at the institute in Wuhan, China.
"Finding it, at that moment, felt big," the Seeker, says, "like a homicide detective solving a cold case."

Minutes after reading the abstract, he posted his find to Twitter, in a long tweet thread tagging members of a loosely defined group known as Drastic, a "Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19." The master's thesis had the potential to rewrite the origin story of the pandemic.
 
Nobody said anything about a final word except you. The tentative conclusion is that it came, as diseases often do, from an animal source. Do you or do you not have evidence that it didn't?
OK then, I misunderstood this:
Belz said:
Oh, look! There's evidence that it jumped from bats to us. Gee, who'd have thought, eh?
I accept that's not what you meant

Ok, what are you waiting for, then?
The thread is full of this evidence.

At this point none of the hypotheses have conclusive smoking guns. At least one has been ruled out, that of an artificially created virus. The hypothesis the pangolin was the intermediary species has become highly unlikely for several reasons.

As was noted in a link in my post: After more than a year no intermediary species has been found.

The closest virus has been found in bats in Yunnan and it was capable of infecting people directly with no intermediary species step. And samples of that virus were collected by researchers at the WIV.

So when you say there is evidence it jumped from bats to people it is a viable hypothesis.

Posted upthread is evidence the lab was working with live cultures. I won't review the evidence for that here.


So what is missing to say the lab was definitely the source?

When the first cases occurred probably goes back to Sept 2019 when the Chinese took a lot of WIV research offline.

One researcher, Andersen, did calculate, using a biological clock, back to Sept. 2019. At that point he found two distinct lineages. And that is where it's being argued that is evidence it didn't start in Wuhan.

However, what is lacking is any trail from elsewhere to Wuhan. From my understanding of Andersen's work, the specimens he analyzed were evidence of where the lineages are found, but it wasn't evidence the lineages went from elsewhere in the world to Wuhan.


Wuhan remains an incredibly unlikely place the pandemic began except for the location of the WIV. And to have 2 distinct lineages coincidentally turn up in Wuhan is even less probable.
It would seem to be a well supported hypotheses that there were 2 lineages in Wuhan in Sept. But if the pandemic began in Wuhan, 2 lineages is also a difficult bit to resolve. IOW it must have started elsewhere.

Take your pick of unresolved puzzle bits.
 
I accept that's not what you meant

I meant exactly what I typed.

The thread is full of this evidence.

Some people from the lab got sick. Ok, got sick with what?

The closest virus has been found in bats in Yunnan and it was capable of infecting people directly with no intermediary species step. And samples of that virus were collected by researchers at the WIV.

So when you say there is evidence it jumped from bats to people it is a viable hypothesis.

Yeah, as in there's evidence to support it. That doesn't mean that it's the only possible explanation. But THAT doesn't mean that we can wildly speculate.

So what is missing to say the lab was definitely the source?

Quite a lot, actually.
 
Yeah, as in there's evidence to support it. That doesn't mean that it's the only possible explanation. But THAT doesn't mean that we can wildly speculate.

I think it's reasonable here to speculate that you jumped into this thread without reading it.

There is a lot of info that may give you some insight into where the conversation is at this point after hundreds of posts with a lot of facts and research.
 
I think it's reasonable here to speculate that you jumped into this thread without reading it.

There is a lot of info that may give you some insight into where the conversation is at this point after hundreds of posts with a lot of facts and research.

Let's assume for a second that you're right. What would be the most important bit of information that points in that direction?
 
There's a CT thread if you want to discuss the origin in terms other than evidence based. Please use it.

Yes and any escape from a lab"discussion belongs there because ALL such theories necessarily involve a conspiracy to cover up the fact Covid-19 was "already being studied in a lab". If it was in a lab in 2019 then the only reason not to have identified it already would be a conspiracy to cover up it's existence.
 
Getting back to the earlier links, this one favors the hypothesis of a natural spillover. Cutting to the chase:
In Lab Leak scenarios diversification of SARS-CoV-2 to its two separate early lineages A and B would have had to occur in the laboratory setting. Lab Leak scenarios must also account for the fact that the majority of early cases were associated with different wildlife markets in Wuhan.
I'm not buying that "associated with different wildlife markets" without the detailed evidence. (Apparently it is in the WHO report.)

Two reasons, the initial wildlife market cases were consistent with a super-spreader event, not a common animal source. And connections to other markets has been dubious. For example one patient never went to any wildlife market, only her son had and he had no serological evidence of an infection.

Where specifically is this evidence?
Theories on SARS-CoV-2 must also account for the fact that two distinct lineages of SARS-CoV-2 were distributed at different Wuhan wildlife markets.
I'll need to look at the WHO Report (next post).


It also provides simple explanations for the fact that two different lineages of SARS-CoV-2 were linked to markets. In one possible scenario divergence of SARS-CoV-2 to lineages A and B occurred prior to the transport of infected animals to Wuhan and the infected animals were subsequently distributed to different wildlife markets.
So in that scenario ready to go viruses (ie matched to human cells) circulated in some wildlife species prior to said animals being shipped to Wuhan markets. And yet the virus did not emerge sporadically all over China, but only in Wuhan. And twice in Wuhan at about the same time no less.

To fit this to a spillover event explaining the two lineages as coming from wildlife markets one needs the evidence all the cases were linked to wildlife markets. It should be very easy to find the source intermediary animal species. And yet after a year and a half, no such species has been found. These authors suggest that is the most likely scenario explaining the 2 lineages. With such a huge clue one would think it only needed a routine search to find that species.


A temporal analysis of the early human cases at the Huanan market confirms the pattern of spread from the areas of the market where wildlife products were sold to other parts of the market.
Yes but, the super-spreader event at the Wuhan market also explains all those findings.


The data for the above animal market hypothesis is here:
WHO, 2021. “WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS- CoV-2: China part”; www.who.int/publications/i/item/who-convened-global-study-of-origins-of-sars-cov-2-china-part.
 
Well this is most telling about all that market sources evidence in the WHO report and it was posted before:

After the report cited above: WHO calls for further studies, data on origin of SARS-CoV-2 virus, reiterates that all hypotheses remain open
The report of the international team on their Wuhan field visit, from 14 January -10 February 2021, was published today as WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus called for further studies. ...

The report is a couple hundred pages long and it'll take a bit of time to see what the animal markets (plural) evidence is.
 
The Chinese government putting out a report the virus emerged in a wild animal farm and was shipped to various wet markets is a CT. Daszak pushing his various theories, directing the WHO team to look elsewhere is a CT.

See how that works?

There's a CT thread if you want to discuss the origin in terms other than evidence based. Please use it.

Huh? The idea that wild animal farms led to the outbreak is not a CT. It’s only a CT if you assume it was a lab leak in which case your idea that they put out this report to throw people off the lab leak trail is a CT - the CT that YOU are a proponent of. lomiller is correct that any lab leak scenario is a CT. Spillover is NOT a CT.
 
From the WHO report (the pdf file can be downloaded from the link):
Many of the early cases were associated with the Huanan market, but a similar number of cases were
associated with other markets and some were not associated with any markets. Transmission within the
wider community in December could account for cases not associated with the Huanan market which,
together with the presence of early cases not associated with that market, could suggest that the Huanan
market was not the original source of the outbreak. Other milder cases that were not identified, however,
could provide the link between the Huanan market and early cases without an apparent link to the
market. No firm conclusion therefore about the role of the Huanan market in the origin of the outbreak,
or how the infection was introduced into the market, can currently be drawn
No details.


Finally, the team reviewed data from published studies from different countries suggesting early
circulation of SARS-CoV-2. The findings suggest that circulation of SARS-CoV-2 preceded the initial
detection of cases by several weeks. Some of the suspected positive samples were detected even earlier ....
I believe this was serological evidence, not verified PCR samples. We discussed that upthread.

Aaand what we already know:
However, the presence of SARS-CoV-2 has not been detected
through sampling and testing of bats or of wildlife across China. More than 80 000 wildlife, livestock
and poultry samples were collected from 31 provinces in China and no positive result was identified for
SARS-CoV-2 antibody or nucleic acid before and after the SARS-CoV-2 outbreak in China. Through
extensive testing of animal products in the Huanan market, no evidence of animal infections was found. ...

Preliminary sampling and testing of other markets in
Wuhan and upstream suppliers to the Huanan market taken during 2020 did not reveal evidence of
SARS-CoV-2 circulating in animals...


Aaannnd we are back to this PC BS:
The joint team’s assessment of likelihood of each possible pathway was as follows:
• direct zoonotic spillover is considered to be a possible-to-likely pathway;
• introduction through an intermediate host is considered to be a likely to very likely pathway;
• introduction through cold/ food chain products is considered a possible pathway;
• introduction through a laboratory incident was considered to be an extremely unlikely pathway.


A clue I'm setting aside for later:
It also directly infects endothelial cells lining the
blood vessels, unusually for a human respiratory virus.


Evidence COVID was not circulating in other parts of China and wasn't circulating before the end of 2019:
Conclusions
Based on the sentinel surveillance data for ILI, and the associated laboratory-confirmed influenza
activity, in Wuhan as well as Hubei and six surrounding provinces, there was a marked increase in ILI
in both children and adults at the end of 2019 in Wuhan, but no evidence to suggest substantial SARSCoV-2 transmission in the months preceding the outbreak in December was observed. The increase in
ILI is mirrored in the remainder of Hubei Province and in neighbouring provinces and municipalities.
While this increase may be explained by a contemporary increase in laboratory-confirmed influenza
activity, further time series analyses were recommended and are underway to ensure that no other
signals are present. ...

Conclusions
Review of retrospective testing of respiratory tract swabs collected within the ILI and SARI surveillance
system, and the adult sentinel surveillance data for ILI from one hospital in Wuhan and SARI
surveillance data from a provincial hospital in Hubei Province revealed no clear indication of substantial
unrecognized circulation of SARS-CoV-2 in Wuhan during the latter part of 2019. Further time series
analyses are underway.
Definitely not consistent with wide distribution via infected animals shipped all over China.


Further evidence it started in late 2019 in Wuhan:
Conclusions
Analysis of four months of aggregated retail pharmacy purchases for antipyretics, cold and cough
medications over a period of four years was unlikely to provide a useful indicator of early SARS-CoV2 activity in the community.


More evidence it started in Wuhan:
Given the time lag from onset of disease to COVID-19-associated death of a median of 17 days (12-22
days) in Wuhan, the documented rapid increase in all-cause mortality in week 3 of 2020 and pneumoniaspecific deaths in week 3 of 2020 suggests that virus transmission was widespread among the population
of Wuhan by the first week (1-7 January) of 2020. The steep incline in mortality rate occurred with 1-
2 weeks’ delay among the population in the Hubei Province outside Wuhan, supporting the previously
reported (16) notion that the epidemic in Wuhan predated the spread in the rest of Hubei Province.


It's tiring to do this report justice all in one go. More to follow.....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom