Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
a position of neutrality

I was not implying anything financial. One definition of the phrase "to hedge one's bets" is "avoid committing oneself when faced with a difficult choice." My interpretation is that he has moved from a position which leaned against a lab leak to a neutral stance.
 
Huh? What is Fauci reconsidering and what "bets" would he be hedging?


ETA: He doesn't appear to be reconsidering. He hasn't contradicted anything he's said earlier and he never expressed any final conclusion that would even make reconsidering possible. This appears to be blown up for sensationalism purposes.

The conspiracy theorists are somehow convinced that the Wuhan lab origin is proven now. Apparently Trump was right all along, as he, of course, always is.
 
I was not implying anything financial. One definition of the phrase "to hedge one's bets" is "avoid committing oneself when faced with a difficult choice." My interpretation is that he has moved from a position which leaned against a lab leak to a neutral stance.
I didn't think you meant financial. But I don't see a real change of position in those words. He has said in the past the evidence is strongly in favor of natural origin and is now saying that he's not convinced of natural origin. I hold both those positions myself simultaneously right now. And he's always been in favor of more investigations in to the origin without conditions about what possibilities should be excluded.
 
Last edited:
The conspiracy theorists are somehow convinced that the Wuhan lab origin is proven now. Apparently Trump was right all along, as he, of course, always is.

Does this apply equally to the people who are convinced the lab origin has been proven false? :cool:
 
No. How could it? When did Trump ever say it was it was false?
So it only applies to CTs Dump pushed? :confused:

And since he pushed the lab origin CT (no argument there) it must mean the opposite is true?


Bottom line, everyone would be wise to keep an open mind until the actual source is tracked down. Calling the lab origin a CT even when you couch it with 'proved' does not move this discussion forward.
 
Depends if there's any evidence either way. Oh, look! There's evidence that it jumped from bats to us. Gee, who'd have thought, eh?
First, I noted well back in the thread that Dump's BS made things worse because he made some valid evidence suspect.

Second, that evidence you sarcastically imply is some kind of proof, isn't.

There is evidence supporting a number of hypotheses, none of which includes anything conclusive. There is evidence (until resolved) which makes any conclusion problematic as well.
 
Last edited:
Second, that evidence you sarcastically imply is some kind of proof, isn't.

I didn't sarcastically imply that it was proof. I plainly stated it. The sarcasm was directed at you, not it.

There is evidence supporting a number of hypotheses, none of which includes anything conclusive. There is evidence (until resolved) which makes any conclusion problematic as well.

Excuse me, where is there evidence that it came from a lab?
 
So it only applies to CTs Dump pushed? :confused:
Yes, statements about CT's Dump pushed apply to CT's Dump pushed.

And since he pushed the lab origin CT (no argument there) it must mean the opposite is true?
Who said that? Of course not. Although with Trump maybe "Of course not" should be reconsidered.

Bottom line, everyone would be wise to keep an open mind until the actual source is tracked down.
Of course.

Calling the lab origin a CT even when you couch it with 'proved' does not move this discussion forward.
But there are lab origin CT's. "lab origin" is not one idea.
 
I didn't sarcastically imply that it was proof. I plainly stated it. The sarcasm was directed at you, not it.



Excuse me, where is there evidence that it came from a lab?

Well then you aren't paying attention because what you think is the final word on the origin of COVID 19 is only one of several hypotheses and it is one like the rest that has problems.

And yes, there is evidence it came from the lab, and that also has some as yet unsolved issues.

Neither explanation is yet resolved.
 
Last edited:
Yes, statements about CT's Dump pushed apply to CT's Dump pushed.


Who said that? Of course not. Although with Trump maybe "Of course not" should be reconsidered.


Of course.


But there are lab origin CT's. "lab origin" is not one idea.

Re that last bit, the one lab origin that it was manufactured and/or has some military aspect has pretty much been ruled out by the genetics. It wasn't created by inserting gene segments.

As for who said what, Belz' post sounded like he believes the bat to human transmission was proven. It hasn't been, though other coronaviruses have directly infected humans from horseshoe bats in the Yunnan Province. They were miners.
 
NBC: U.S. intel report identified 3 Wuhan lab researchers who fell ill in November 2019
The new details, first reported by the Wall Street Journal, add to the body of circumstantial evidence that supports a hypothesis that the Covid-19 virus may have spread to humans after it escaped from a Chinese research lab in Wuhan. But the evidence is far from conclusive.
Indeed, we don't have a conclusive answer yet.

Toward the above couple of posts in this thread:
The other theory is that the virus was transmitted to humans through an animal host. After a year and half of looking, no such host has been identified.


Reuters: Wuhan lab staff sought hospital care before COVID-19 outbreak disclosed - WSJ
The newspaper said the previously undisclosed report - which provides fresh details on the number of researchers affected, the timing of their illnesses, and their hospital visits - may add weight to calls for a broader investigation into whether the COVID-19 virus could have escaped from the laboratory. ...

China's foreign ministry spokesman, Zhao Lijian, said on Monday that it was "completely untrue" that three members of staff at WIV had fallen ill.

"The United States continues to hype up the lab leak theory," he said. "Does it care about traceability or is it just trying to distract attention?"
Of course there are official denials. There was also that eye doctor who was told to shut up that then later died of the infection.

And while Daszak has been trying to steer the WHO investigation away from the lab:
Asked about the report, WHO spokesman Tarik Jasarevic said via email that the organisation's technical teams were now deciding on the next steps. He said further study was needed into the role of animal markets as well as the lab leak hypothesis.


And then we have this: Dr. Fauci 'not convinced' coronavirus developed naturally
WASHINGTON — Dr. Anthony Fauci, the top immunologist who lead the COVID-19 response in the United States, said he's "not convinced" that the deadly virus was naturally developed and encouraged further investigation into its origins. ...

Fauci said this earlier:
This is a change from his earlier viewpoints. During an interview with National Geographic in May of 2020, a year ago, Fauci believed the virus likely came from animals and transmitted to humans.

"If you look at the evolution of the virus in bats, and what's out there now is very, very strongly leaning toward this [virus] could not have been artificially or deliberately manipulated—the way the mutations have naturally evolved," he said during the interview on May 4, 2020. "A number of very qualified evolutionary biologists have said that everything about the stepwise evolution over time strongly indicates that it evolved in nature and then jumped species."

This is the same distraction Daszak has been promoting, saying what we do know, it wasn't hobbled together in a lab, while claiming that ruled the lab accident out. But being created by inserting gene segments together is not the only way it could have developed in the lab. No one in this thread has yet suggested 'created purposefully in the lab' is still a viable option. It's pretty safe to say the genetics rules that out.

But there is still evidence it did develop in the lab and an accident let it out. Is that conclusive? No. Neither is a direct infection from bats in Yunnan and neither is it conclusive it spread from the wild animal markets via an intermediary animal species.
 
More of the current news stream, CNN, Chris Cuomo touches on the issues with a pretty decent 'we don't yet know' POV, start at ~ minute 17:29, skip all that Chris Christie stuff and stop at ~ minute 28 which is where the Belarus issue starts:

 
That's an excellent summary of the scientific community's evolution of thinking here from early 2020 to now.

I now agree with Nick’s central conclusion: We still do not know the source of this awful pandemic. We may never know. But the argument that it could have leaked out of the Wuhan Institute of Virology or a sister lab in Wuhan has become considerably stronger than it was a year ago, when the screaming was so loud that it drowned out serious discussion. ...

Also worrying: the hunt for the spillover theory’s smoking gun — a very closely related natural virus in a human or an animal — has gone on for over a year. Success would mean big prizes for the discoverer — especially from the Chinese government, which could say “See??”

And yet — zip. That doesn’t mean it won’t be found. But by now we might have expected at least some smoking shell casings. ...

As soon as it was clear that the threat was a dangerous new coronavirus, the local health commission and then the national one ordered diagnostic and genetics labs to destroy their samples or surrender them to high-level biosecurity labs. Most labs chose incineration — another crime scene wrecked. ...

The paper’s first author, Kristian G. Andersen of the Scripps Research Translational Institute, is still vigorously defending the paper’s basic premise — that an animal origin is by far the most likely.

But other eminent virologists, including at least one of his co-authors, are wavering.

During the uproar that ensued after the institute revealed that the RaTG13 strain was in its freezers, Dr. Daszak argued that merely having a virus in a frozen fecal pellet meant little. Infections take place only when viruses are warmed up and growing in cell cultures or animals. ...

Doubts have been raised about that, including the question: since Covid-19 was racing through Wuhan in early 2020, how likely would it be that no one in her lab tested antibody-positive? Wouldn’t some have gotten infected outside?
Ultimately, much of the debate comes down to this: Is Dr. Shi telling the whole truth? And even if she is, are all her similarly skilled colleagues in Wuhan? Are they being allowed to do so by their government — which has a history of silencing scientists? ...

Nick Wade quoted David Baltimore, who won the 1975 Nobel Prize for his work with viruses, as saying the specific amino acid sequences in the cleavage site made “a powerful challenge to the idea of a natural origin.” (This has prompted a complex debate among evolutionary geneticists over which specific rungs on the RNA-DNA ladder are statistically most likely to appear in a bat virus.) ...

But later he learned of studies with Dr. Shi’s name on them showing that work he considers dangerous had been done in level BSL-2 labs, which he considers highly porous to leaks, not just in 2016, but in 2020.
“That’s screwed up,” he said. “It shouldn’t have happened. People should not be looking at bat viruses in BSL-2 labs. My view has changed.”
That is still not, as he pointed out, direct evidence of a lab leak. There is no proof of a leak. ...

So there we are. All we have so far is speculation, and all the explanations are unsatisfactory.
The whole thing may just be a cold case, and stay that way forever. But there are more embers left to sift. The whole world, China included, needs a hard answer, whoever is to blame — so we can prevent this from happening again.
 
Last edited:
More of the current news stream, CNN, Chris Cuomo touches on the issues with a pretty decent 'we don't yet know' POV, start at ~ minute 17:29, skip all that Chris Christie stuff and stop at ~ minute 28 which is where the Belarus issue starts:


I've highlighted the bit that makes it unwatchable for me. :D

But indeed, I agree we need more information from the WIV.

As a counterpoint, in the WSJ article that was linked before was one of the members of the WHO investigators:

Marion Koopmans, a Dutch virologist on that team told NBC News in March that some WIV staff did fall sick in the autumn of 2019, but she attributed that to regular, seasonal sickness.

“There were occasional illnesses because that’s normal. There was nothing that stood out,” she said. “Maybe one or two. It’s certainly not a big, big thing.”

It isn’t unusual for people in China to go straight to the hospital when they fall sick, either because they get better care there or lack access to a general practitioner. Covid-19 and the flu, while very different illnesses, share some of the same symptoms, such as fever, aches and a cough. Still, it could be significant if members of the same team working with coronaviruses went to hospital with similar symptoms shortly before the pandemic was first identified.

This may be a cultural point here. I don't know about China, except from the bit that I just quoted, but here in Japan it is also the same that people may just drop in at a hospital for relatively minor illnesses. When I first came here, I would sometimes be surprised when people said they had been to hospital "Oh my God! Are you okay?" - "Yeah, I just had a cold/headache etc..."
 
Well then you aren't paying attention because what you think is the final word on the origin of COVID 19 is only one of several hypotheses and it is one like the rest that has problems.

Nobody said anything about a final word except you. The tentative conclusion is that it came, as diseases often do, from an animal source. Do you or do you not have evidence that it didn't?

And yes, there is evidence it came from the lab, and that also has some as yet unsolved issues.

Ok, what are you waiting for, then?
 
Nobody said anything about a final word except you. The tentative conclusion is that it came, as diseases often do, from an animal source. Do you or do you not have evidence that it didn't?



Ok, what are you waiting for, then?
Yes from an animal gathered from the wild. There was sufficient fear that a virus might infect humans from this animal it was experimented upon.
The experiment proved the hazard.
 
Yes from an animal gathered from the wild. There was sufficient fear that a virus might infect humans from this animal it was experimented upon.
The experiment proved the hazard.

That animal hasn't been identified. It would be known if it was in a lab.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom